
H/T Legalantics, where there’s a ton of very funny stuff. Go check it out.


H/T Legalantics, where there’s a ton of very funny stuff. Go check it out.
When it comes to the “court of public opinion,” no one fares worse than a judge. While the media can parse the judge’s life story, each reversal and decision, the judge is constrained to sit there and take it on the chin, denied the opportunity to fight back and tell the media where to shove it.
But Judicial Reports posts about the American Bar Association’s panel presentation, “Judges Under Fire.”
“We can’t really depend on the media to do all of the job for us. The media has an interest in doing sound-bytes,” said Cook County Circuit Judge E. Kenneth Wright, Jr., reportedly the first sitting judge to helm the Chicago Bar Association.
“Many times, they want to spin it the way they spin it,” he later concluded.
Wright joined two other jurists, a former New York State Bar President, and a journalist on a panel sponsored by the American Bar Association to explore “Judges Under Fire.”
Overall, the judges agreed that members of the bench should be insulated from the press during active cases, toying with different kinds of groups that could maintain that separation: public relations specialists, bar association teams, or some other independent organization.
The problem has become pervasive, but worse, has created a downward spiral of public misunderstanding of the law that feeds upon itself.
[The] discussion began with footage of Fox News pundit Bill O’Reilly’s 2006 campaign against Vermont District Court Judge Edward Cashman. O’Reilly’s inflammatory editorial attacked the judge for a lenient sentence in a child molestation case.
The panelists agreed that the video had misinterpreted the case, ignoring the fact that the judge had actually approved a plea agreement, rather than having issued the decision on his own. “This is a plea bargain. The prosecutor agreed to it,” explained Acting Supreme Court Justice Patricia Anne Williams, who was appointed to the Bronx Criminal Court in 1986, and has been an Acting Justice since 1989.
For anyone who has had the momentary pleasure of watching Bill O’Reilly knows, he isn’t always the most reliable source of information. In fact, some might contend that little stands in his way of making his point, with truth being the first casualty.
This has both micro and macro effects. Under the “judges are people too” heading, no one wants to be wrongly smeared in the media, whether by deceptive reporting or sheer ignorance. As the public appetite for stories about criminal prosecutions grows unabated, the media is forced to make judicial decisions sound more interesting or controversial than they often are in order to interest their viewers. This comes at the expense of the judge, whose absolutely proper and sound decision is contorted to appear outrageous.
At the same time, the public grows increasingly disgusted with a judiciary perceived to be out of touch or out of control, an impression largely fostered by the neocon pundits like Reilly who need scapegoats to whip up outrage in their fans. Not only has this resulted in fostering a growing belief that the judiciary is part of the problem, but has made judges the target of particularized hatred and even violence.
The fact is that judges are easy targets. As public officials, they are subject to criticism. As judges, they can do little to respond. No matter how badly the media mangles their decision, there is little to be done. After all, it’s hard to explain complex issues of law in 60 second sound bites, and it’s so much easier to reduce the law to an absurd abstraction with a few colorful adjectives suitable for angry viewers.
And even when the system attempts to defend the judges, it does an awfully poor job of it.
“The media is not the enemy. You have to take advantage of these teaching moments,” said Kathryn Grant Madigan, the former president of the New York State Bar Association and a partner at Levene Gouldin & Thompson.
The legal leader urged all bar associations to create “rapid response” teams to speak on behalf of judges and help jurists deal with controversial cases. To that end, the American Bar Association offered copies of a pamphlet entitled “Rapid Response to Unfair and Unjust Criticism of Judges” to all attendees.
This is so lawyerly; Some pundit wrongfully skewers a judge, and lawyers put out a pamphlet. Lawyers can find ways to bore people like nobody’s business, and there is nothing more ineffective than the collective wisdom of a bar association.
But the problem is becoming increasingly real. Over the past week, Southern District Judge Louis Stanton has become the object of scorn over at Youtube because of his ruling in the Viacom case, to the point where people have posted videos threatening Judge Stanton for his ruling. As an aside, I’ve tried a case before Judge Stanton, and found him to be one of the most gracious and thoughtful judges on the bench. He used to walk around Foley Square on his own during the luncheon recess. My guess is that he now has reason to fear for his safety, with the potential of some psycho, juiced up by their “outrage”, doing him harm.
Unfortunately, the panel discussion proved one overarching point: Judges are incapable of comprehending the problem, no less dealing with it.
“Maybe we have to explain ourselves, not just orally in court, but in a written opinion that can go up on the [court] website, so responsible reporters can go to the written opinion,” said Friedman, offering that as the most appropriate means for judges to explain themselves to the public.
Right, because the public really wants to spend its time reading judicial opinions, and the media would much rather spend 10 minutes of a 30 minute program explaining in painful detail the legal nuances that produced the controversial ruling.
And what of the media? Will they take responsibility for doing a better job of reporting judicial decisions?
Dale Van Atta, the only journalist on the panel, stayed quiet during the media debate. The reporter compiles the yearly “America’s Worst Judges” list for Readers’ Digest magazine — bestowing the “Broken Gavel Award” on hapless jurists.
When asked whom judges could trust in the media, he had a simple response. “It’s difficult to trust a young reporter. It is safer not to [go on the record]. I’m moving towards the ABA’s side,” he concluded…
Of course, this comes from a fellow who writes for that extremist rag, Readers Digest. No word as yet from more thoughtful and moderate Sean Hannity.
When Bill Keller, executive editor of the New York Times, was buzzed by his secretary that Robert S. Mueller III was on the line, I bet he was nervous. A call from the FBI is everybody’s second least favorite call. No need to mention the first.
But according to this Times story, Mueller called to apologize. He informed Keller that his people made a bit of a “boo boo” four years ago:
The Federal Bureau of Investigation said Friday that it had improperly obtained the phone records of reporters for The New York Times and The Washington Post in the newspapers’ Indonesia bureaus in 2004.
F.B.I. officials said the incident came to light as part of the continuing review by the Justice Department inspector general’s office into the bureau’s improper collection of telephone records through “emergency” records demands issued to phone providers.
The records were apparently sought as part of a terrorism investigation, but the F.B.I. did not explain what was being investigated or why the reporters’ phone records were considered relevant.
Just to avoid any lack of clarity, this is the sort of mistake that the FBI and Department of Justice explained very carefully, very slowly and with the utmost of sincerity, could never happen if only they had the power to “protect Americans from terrorism” by doing anything they pleased without having to ask anyone’s permission. “Trust us,” they said. “We’re from the government.”
You have to admit, the fact that Mueller not only admitted that it happened, but apologized for it, is a step in the right direction. But only a baby step. The fact remains that it happened. The fact remains that they did what they did, and had it not come out through a review by the Inspector General, no one would have ever known.
To the FBI, the obtention of reporters’ telephone records was “improper”. Had it been you or I, a different word would have been used by the FBI: criminal. An American citizen would go to jail for doing this, while the FBI director gets to say “I’m sorry.” I have plenty of clients who would be happy to say “I’m sorry” if we could just call the whole thing off. Let bygones be bygones. Water under the bridge. It will never happen again. I swear.
“The F.B.I. is committed to protecting the news media consistent with the First Amendment and Department of Justice policies, and we very much regret that this situation occurred,” Valerie Caproni, general counsel for the bureau, wrote in a letter to Mr. Keller faxed Friday.
If only warm and fuzzy words like “committed” meant something beyond the double entendre. They keep promising their sincerity, and they keep making “boo boos.” Some will say that mistakes will happen. As criminal defense lawyers, we can vouch for that. But mistakes have consequences, for everyone except our government.
The problem is that there will always be that zealous lot in our law enforcement agencies who believe the rules don’t apply to them, or their purpose is higher and more important than a bunch of stinking laws or that thing called the Constitution. They do what they have to do, and can always apologize later.
Over time, in the name of whatever war on (fill in the blank) we’re fighting today, our elected officials give the government more authority to save us from demons, real or pretend, based upon the proposition that government would never abuse its power. But they do, and we never seem to learn from it, so we rationalize it. As soon as we have forgotten the last “boo boo,” we extend the government’s authority even farther.
We just can’t seem to learn any lesson. And the government just can’t seem to keep its promises.
David Tarrell at In the Moment, and 2007 Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year, has posted two stories about his experiences on the road that are not only vivid and moving, but provide a palpable reminder of how people see the world around them through their own limited experience which may not be shared by the person driving the car in front or behind.
In his first post, Proximity to Tragedy, David and his daughter watched as a motorcyclist crossing his path appeared to lose control of his bike as he crested a hill.
At first I thought he was having fun, scaring his friend, but he kept it up too long, shaking back and forth too far, just as he went over down the hill and out of my sight. I didn’t think, I just yelled what came to mind, “Oh God, No, he’s going down!” I saw the friend turn and look ahead, where I couldn’t see, seemingly alarmed too. My daughter screamed back at me, asking what I saw, unused to having to look at other cars as we rode. I screamed, “No! No! No!, shocked, thinking that I’d just seen a kid turn from having fun to becoming a road stain in seconds. I thought that down that hill lay a rolled bike, a skinny kid wearing a sleeveless tee and shorts become at least a severe road rash victim on his way to the hospital. Perhaps worse.
As he sat there, stunned and trying to figure out whether to turn and see if this young man was alive, reality kicked him in the face in the form of a white Corolla.
The woman in the white corolla right behind me, shaking her hands at my face in the rearview mirror, telling me to get my ass in gear. I pointed to place the kid had gone, thinking somehow that she’d figure out, perhaps from the reactions of the cars going down there, what I’d just seen and why I wasn’t moving fast.
But she screamed even more, her hands flying up at her windshield, yelling at me for holding her up for those few seconds, those few car lengths of time.
In his second post, Road Rage 2: “Electric Bugaloo”, David recounts the everyday experience of picking up his kid from school, gone wrong.
Last year, riding with my wife on the way to pick up my kids after middle school, a mini van pulls behind us. I can tell the driver is upset as she drives close behind me. But she goes further than a typical tailgater, weaving back and forth. When I don’t react, and just keep driving, the speed limit mind you, she starts waving her hands at me. I turn a few times, driving through a neighborhood by the school, and she stays right behind me. When I make the last turn, moving down the driveway in front of the school, she’s still there, still waving her hands at me, acting crazy.
As luck would have it, the “crazy woman” is picking up her kid from school too, ending up standing right next to David and his wife as they waited for their children to come out.
I want to yell at her, to embarrass her if that’s what it takes, to teach her a lesson about not driving crazy around my kids.
I avoid the temptation to ask her who the hell she thinks she is and instead hear myself ask her, “you doin’ o.k.?”
“No,” is all she says, almost whining, her body language telling me she’s desperate but not yet ready to talk about it.
Then the lady looks at us, stressed and embarrassed, and says, “I’m sorry.” “It’s just… there’s been, um, there’s been a…. we lost someone in our family and we really have to get home.”
Both stories are compelling and carry a moral that we could all stand to remember. Like it or not, we all think to some extent that we are the center of the universe, and that what exists in our head is the only thing that matters. As David reminds us, it’s just not so.
The indictment of Ben Kuehne sent shockwaves through the Miami bar which could be felt around the country. This was the guy who everyone agreed was as straight as an arrow, as trustworthy as they come, and yet here he was, the target of a federal indictment for having been retained to vet the payment of legal fees for Roy Black from accused Medellin drug lord, Fabio Ochoa Vasquez. The feds claimed that Ben gave the fee a clean bill of health in exchange for $200,000, and that he knew the money was dirty.
Well, that was then. This is now. Having impugned Ben Kuehne, not to mention having cost him no doubt a small king’s ransom to defend, the feds are whistling a different tune. According to the New York Lawyer,
In a surprising turnabout, federal prosecutors who indicted prominent Miami attorney Ben Kuehne on money laundering charges now say they plan to offer no trial evidence directly linking him to drug profits.
Instead, the government will offer testimony to show that millions of dollars used to pay Colombian druglord Fabio Ochoa’s high-powered defense team was tainted by the family’s legendary cocaine smuggling network.
This was revealed in the government’s response to an order to provide a bill of particulars. For those of you who don’t do federal defense, this won’t mean a great deal, but let me explain. In federal court, a bill of particulars is like the holy grail of discovery. Ordered rarely, it compels the government to actually provide substantive information to flesh out its vague rhetorical claims, almost invariably insufficient to allow defense counsel to prepare adequately to defend. But while there’s a rule allowing it, the government fights it tooth and nail. And the courts, invariably reluctant to force the government to disclose its hand, looks seriously askance at demands for the government to put its allegations of fact in writing.
The gist of the government’s opposition is that it will “unduly prejudice” them to disclose the facts it alleges that constitute the crime. In plain English, this means they won’t be able to sandbag the defense by surprising it at trial with allegations that come out of the blue. That would make it a fair fight, and the government hates a fair fight. It could lose.
But in Ben Kuehne’s case, it was much worse than a mere fair fight. It was an indictment with nothing behind it.
“With respect to the remaining wire transactions, the government represents that it does not currently intend to introduce evidence directly tracing narcotic sales to specific assets that resulted in wire transfers to defendant Kuehne’s attorney trust account,” the bill of particulars said.
Even here, the government is disingenuous, saying “it does not currently intend,” as if it was doing Ben a favor and has great proof, but just doesn’t feel like using it. For now.
It now appears that while the government has evidence to show that Ochoa’s “millions” (ah, to be Roy Black) was, in fact, laundered drug proceeds, there is no evidence to show that Ben Kuehne knew that to be the case and thus, by giving his seal of approval to Black, intended to launder the funds himself. In other words, the government now claims that Kuehne was simply mistaken. Oops.
Ironically, the government’s evidence that the money was dirty comes from its own operations, pumping traceable money into drug and laundering scheme and watching where it came out. Just in case you’re wondering where the government got the cash to do this, check your pockets.
The funds funneled from our own government through the Ochoa family that wound its way back to Ben Kuehne and ultimately Roy Black were well masked to show that they came from the family’s legitimate businesses, including the sale of Paso Fino horses. The government knew better, but Ben Kuehne didn’t.
“You can be wrong giving an opinion, even tragically wrong,” Coffey said. The attorney said it is ironic that the clearest traceable illegal funds are the government’s own money from the drug stings. He said it’s not illegal to be fooled by your own government.
Having now disclosed that the government has no evidence of criminal conduct by Ben Kuehne, it begs one question: Why are they still proceeding to trial? Since there’s no pre-trial motion to dismiss under the federal rules, there’s nothing further for Kuehne’s defense team to do until their first chance for a trial order of dismissal. But given the bill of particulars, it appears that they have no case against Kuehne.
You may wonder whether they plan to dismiss the case next week, or next month, before trial. Perhaps, though the normal, and smarter, course would have been to dismiss rather than provide the bill of particulars.
The only thought that comes to mind is that this prosecution is being continued to make clear the burden that the government intends to place on the back of lawyers, even lawyers with the most impeccable credentials for honesty and integrity, who undertake to help criminal defense lawyers and their clients.
The message: Don’t think you’re going to help notorious defendants and get away clean.
I hope that no lawyer of integrity is going to let the government scare them off.
The first indictment in a federal prosecution is rarely the last indictment. Often, it charges a count that permits a lesser sentence so that the government can cut a plea and use the threat of a superseding indictment as the big stick to beat the defendant into submission. But sometimes, the original indictment isn’t undercharged on purpose, but because an AUSA blew it. What happens then?
That’s the ball game, according to Judge Alex Kozinski, writing for a unanimous panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in Garcia-Aguilar v. U.S., on a writ of mandamus.
These consolidated cases show again why the ten most terrifying words in the English language may be, “I’m from the government and I’m here to help you.” Defendants pled guilty to re-entering the country illegally after having been previously removed, in violation of 8 U.S.C. § 1326. Their guilty pleas were taken by magistrate judges, who conducted the plea colloquies required by Rule 11(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, and who thereafter recommended that the district court accept the pleas.
When the cases came before the district court for acceptance of the pleas, the U.S. Attorney objected on the ground that the magistrate judges had erred in conducting the Rule 11(b) colloquies. The district judges agreed and refused to accept any of the defendants’ guilty pleas.
Well that’s not supposed to happen. The difference, you see, is 18 years, as the original indictment omitted a charge that the defendant had been previously removed from the country for conviction of a prior felony. the maximum sentence without this detail was two years versus 20.
The issue with the Magistrate Judge’s Rule 11(b) colloquy was that they told the defendants that, under the statute, they faced a maximum punishment of imprisonment for 20 years. The government argues that they should have said 2 years, which would have alerted the drowsy AUSA of his screw-up. But Rule 11(b) doesn’t exist for the benefit of the government. It’s there for the defendant.
Rule 11(b) is there for the defendant’s benefit, so it seems quite noble at first for the U.S. Attorney to stick up for defendants’ rights. But this generosity comes at a steep price: The U.S. Attorney has already arraigned defendants on superseding indictments that specifically charge a violation of 8 U.S.C. § 1326(b)(2), which is punishable by twenty years in prison. This is eighteen years more than the two-year maximum sentence available under defendants’ original indictments, which did not charge any conduct that could increase the maximum penalty above two years.
You’ve got to admit, Judge Kozinski is a hoot. If all circuit decisions were this much fun, lawyers might actually read them.
Criminal defense lawyers have a tendency to think that AUSAs never make mistakes, and if there’s something beneficial staring us in the face, we suspect there’s some trick attached that we haven’t caught onto. Yet. But try to enjoy the benefit and the government will smack you so hard it will make your head spin. Often, this is the case. But as this case shows, mistakes not only happen, but can happen in a big way.
What is surprising is that the 9th Circuit did not react as so many of us would expect, finding some loophole to let the government back into the game. We see small errors constantly, but experience shows that any effort to capitalize on it is a dangerous game. Most courts just ignore minor gaps and improprieties by the government as if they didn’t exist, and look askance at the defendant’s argument that he is entitled to rely on the law. That’s when they toss out the old “hypertechnical” lingo to show us that we won’t get away easy.
Indeed, here the District Judge did exactly that, rejecting the Magistrate Judge’s plea and letting the prosecution off the hook. Had it ended there, it meant an 18 year difference for the defendants. But they took it to the Circuit, and the Circuit put its foot down:
But whatever legal significance may attach to a guilty plea taken by a magistrate judge, the plea also carries significant real-world consequences. A defendant’s guilty plea is a confession, freely and publicly made, that he is a criminal. This has immediate and enduring effects on the defendant’s standing in the community, and for that reason and many others is often an excruciating experience.
The defendants took the plea, and the government’s chance to up the ante was over. This quote from the decision is of particular interest. A guilty plea isn’t merely some technical mechanism, used to shift the proceedings from start to finish. It’s a confession to the world that the defendant is a criminal. Once said, it can never (in real-world terms) be unsaid.
Having extracted that confession from the defendant, the integrity of the law demands that the deal is done and the government doesn’t get a mulligan.
“HAZEL PARK, MI—In a statement made to reporters earlier this afternoon, local idiot Brandon Mylenek, 26, announced that at approximately 2:30 a.m. tonight, he plans to post an idiotic comment beneath a video on an Internet website.

“Later this evening, I intend to watch the video in question, click the ‘reply’ link above the box reserved for user comments, and draft a response, being careful to put as little thought into it as possible, while making sure to use all capital letters and incorrect punctuation,” Mylenek said. “Although I do not yet know exactly what my comment will entail, I can say with a great degree of certainty that it will be incredibly stupid.”
Mylenek, who rarely in his life has been capable of formulating an idea or opinion worth the amount of oxygen required to express it, went on to guarantee that the text of his comment would be misspelled to the point of incomprehension, that it would defy the laws of both logic and grammar, and that it would allege that several elements of the video are homosexual in nature.
“The result will be an astonishing combination of ignorance, offensiveness, and sheer idiocy,” Mylenek said.”
This breaking news from The Onion could not have come at a better time. Simple Justice is a blawg on the internet. It is not “the truth,” but just one person’s view. It may refer to actual news, or real court decisions, or even living human beings, but it is nothing more than the ramblings of a criminal defense lawyer who tends to be a bit prickly, skeptical and occasionally snarky. Unlike some of your heroes, I’m no demi-god and don’t possess the solution, just some thoughts that, from time to time, strike me as worth writing down.
To the extent that anything written here strikes a chord, enjoy it. If it’s at all helpful, use it. If you disagree with it, ignore it. Don’t look to the internet to find words of wisdom or gurus to follow. Don’t let yourselves get all bent out of shape over some comment that suggests you’re a blithering idiot. It means nothing.
There are relatively few of you who I know outside of the internet. For others, blawgers and commenters alike, I’ve grown to respect you based solely on what you say, not who you are or what you have to offer. Your credibility is earned. I find some comments (and their authors) to be very persuasive. Others not so much. Some not at all.
It’s not that I agree with you all the time, or that you agree with me. Lots of people disagree with me, so don’t get a swelled head. But aside from people who post spam comments (and I get a ton of this, but delete it as quickly as I can) and pointlessly offensive comments (and there’s plenty of these as well, by people who think a few curses makes their totally unreasoned position much more convincing), most comments are left relatively alone. It’s not that I think they add much to the conversation, but even stupid comments reflect what people are thinking, for better or worse.
There have been numerous comments criticizing what I post, not so much for being right or wrong (which certainly happens as well), but for not being what people want to read from me. Of course, my critics are often diametrically opposed as far as what I should be writing about. If my purpose was to please others, I would fail miserably.
Then there are a handful of people who want to use this blawg, because it’s established itself over time, as a launching pad for themselves by trying to show me up. Sometimes I let this go for a while, but if it doesn’t calm down, I cut it off. This is my blawg, not yours. You want to be a jerk, get your own blawg. It’s that simple. I don’t owe you a place to post. There are moments when I can be more gracious towards a jerk, and moments when I just get annoyed. It happens. I admit it, I’m not always the most tolerant fellow around.
So it boils down to this: I write what I write, and you have the choice of reading it or not. I may be dead wrong, whether in my analysis, concerns, viewpoints or critiques. So what? It’s just the internet, folks.
With this in mind, allow me to take note of my favorite quote of the week, this from Paul Horwitz at PrawfsBlawg :
On the critical side, although Steve Bainbridge has been very active on this issue and makes some excellent points, I find his open letter to the AALS far too fervid. First, the line, “What you may not realize is that [the boycott] is the subject of widespread and, in many cases, highly critical debate in the law school blog community” demonstrates . . . what? With all due respect to myself and my co-law-bloggers, that’s not reason enough to cross the street, let alone to pay serious attention; I mean, we also have vicious debates about the law and economics of the Sith Wars.
It’s just the internet, folks. Real life is out there somewhere.
H/T Orin Kerr
It was impossible to be surprised that Salim Hamdan, driver to Osama bin Laden, would not be convicted by a military tribunal that was ordered to convict him. Orders are orders. But when he was sentenced to 66 months imprisonment, that was a surprise.
The prosecution sought 30 years. Hamdan was credited with time served, and has 5 months left. Someone isn’t getting another star on their uniform.
My old friend Andy McCarthy wasn’t pleased at all. As he wrote in the National Review :
In an astounding finale to the first military-commission trial, Salim Hamdan, Osama bin Laden’s personal aide, has been sentenced by a military commission to five-and-a-half years in prison — five-and-a-half years — upon conviction for the war crime of providing material support to al-Qaeda.
It gets worse. The military judge, Naval Captain Keith Allred, has decided that Hamdan should be credited with the five years he has already spent in custody.
In effect, the jury’s shameful 66-month sentence is thus reduced to a shocking six months — for key assistance to a terror network that has killed thousands of Americans and continues plotting to kill more.
This guy must be one heck of a driver, to make Andy all apoplectic. But while the hard right spews venom at this attack on American justice (where they probably wouldn’t have been happy unless he had gotten two death penalties, and had both carried out), there is a silver lining behind the gray cloud of justice.
According to CNN (via Turley),
Pentagon spokesman Bryan Whitman said after the verdict Wednesday that Hamdan was now a “convicted war criminal” and that he was “no longer considered an enemy combatant.”
But on Thursday, Whitman said Hamdan’s status would revert to “enemy combatant” when his sentence is completed.
As an enemy combatant, Hamdan can be held indefinitely by the United States.
Safe at last. See Andy, you got yourself all worked up over nothing. Here in America, we sentence you, you serve your sentence, then we just hold you until we’ve had enough of you. It’s unclear what happens then, as he is likely to find himself ineligible for a hack license in New York City despite his conceded driving skills.
But Andy isn’t happy yet. First, some “liberal” judges (who somehow infiltrated our military and rose to high rank) made a mockery of America:
In Hamdan’s case, we thus have a double problem. First, the jury of military officers somehow decided that material support to our enemies, by a guy who actually protected bin Laden and transported weapons for al-Qaeda, was worth only five-and-a-half years in jail. Second, the judge then made matters incalculably worse by effectively giving Hamdan what everyone (including the judge) must know will be taken as a get-out-of-jail card: i.e., full credit for the five years Hamdan has already been in custody as an enemy combatant. That turns the 66 months into six months.
But worse, America has cowed to the pressures of treating “war criminals” as if they were people!
Understand: there is no requirement to try captured enemy combatants for war crimes. As the laws of war have long provided, and as the Supreme Court has recently reaffirmed, wartime enemy combatants may be held without trial for the duration of hostilities. War crimes charges are an additional measure against combatants who commit egregious law-of-war violations.
What would Andy have done if somebody hadn’t come up with the title “enemy combatants?” After all, Hamdan doesn’t sound at all threatening if he called him “the guy who drove bin Laden around in a car.” When all is said and done, Andy asks a very important question:
But all that said, how does a serious person continue to defend the military system after Hamdan?
This is why I think so highly of Andy McCarthy. Despite our differences, we always find something to agree on.
Just in from Turley, this story from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette about the death of Andre Thomas.
One resident on that block said Andre Thomas had knocked on some doors, yelling that someone was trying to shoot him. Police have not confirmed that account.
Swissvale officers encountered Mr. Thomas, 37, in front of a residence in the 2200 block, county investigators said.
James Morton, assistant superintendent of county police, said today that Mr. Thomas refused to comply with the policemen’s orders to submit to them. An officer used a Taser to subdue him.
A neighbor said she saw Mr. Thomas standing with the prongs of the Taser still attached to him when four Swissvale officers forced him to the ground and handcuffed him.
“I saw them shove [Mr. Thomas] to the ground, and they handcuffed him,” the neighbor said. “They killed that man. They killed him. They killed him,” she added, her hands trembling. The woman said she saw one officer stomp on Mr. Thomas’s upper back, holding his foot there while the subject lay on the sidewalk with his head hanging over the curb. Another officer “reared back and punched him in the head with all his might,” she said.
>Mr. Thomas vomited. Then, for several minutes, he lay motionless, another nearby resident said, before an ambulance was called. The rescue truck stayed on the scene for several minutes more before Mr. Thomas was taken away, the witness said.
Andre Thomas was dead.
There really isn’t anything I can add to this story. I just felt that you should know.
A personal admission: I like to take a nap in the afternoon for an hour or so. I wake up refreshed and ready to go. I kept this to myself up to now out of concern that others would think me soft, but apparently I’m not crazy. Or alone.
The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, always a voracious reader, has posted about a book he just completed called Brain Rules by John Medina. The book appears to be a compilation of “rules” about how people work, not exactly new ideas but put together in one place.
Rule #7 caught Mark’s attention: “Sleep well, think well.”
[T]here is a period of time in the mid-afternoon when most people experience transient sleepiness. “It can be nearly impossible to get anything done during this time, and if you attempt to push through, which is what most of us do, you can spend much of your afternoon fighting a gnawing tiredness. It’s a fight because the brain really wants to take a nap and doesn’t care what its owner is doing.”
Yes! Yes! Vindication! Don’t fight the brain!
Had it only been Mark who recognized this basic human need, perhaps one might chalk it up to criminal defense lawyer pandering. But when David Giacalone, in a post completely independent from Mark’s, agrees, I know we’re onto something big.
A year ago, we argued that law firms have an ethical obligation to provide nap rooms for their aging members. A new survey done in the UK gives us a stellar “quality of life” or “professional civility” reason for more lawyer nap rooms. You see, a poor night’s sleep makes most people rather grumpy the next day at work. “Study highlights bad sleepers” (The Press Association, Aug. 3, 2008). And, a group of lawyers in their 50’s are apparently the most sleep deprived segment of British Society (via: Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch, Aug. 4, 2008). The f/k/a Gang believes that there’s nothing like a good nap to calm an old grump.
I love it. Not only is it a sound concept based upon the need for clarity of thought (at least for those of us who believe that thought is a helpful thing), but it’s an ethical obligation as well. You wouldn’t want to be unethical, would you?
The siesta is a time-honored tradition in many countries, though it has often been viewed as a sign of weakness, even laziness. Oh you fools, so blind in your desire to prove yourselves tougher and stronger than others. Fighting human nature is a losing proposition. And why would anyone be proud of being grumpy anyway? It’s time to face facts, sleepy people are indeed grumpy, and we have become a very grumpy nation. It doesn’t have to be this way.
Trials lawyers have known forever that the witness who testifies immediately after the luncheon recess is lost. We never put an important witness on the stand after lunch, and we always try to push the other side’s killer witness off until after the jury returns from lunch to give us the greatest chance of having the jury nod off during the testimony.
Now that I know that I’m not alone in my appreciation of an afternoon nap, perhaps we can openly recognize this as a basic human need. Long live the Siesta!