Author Archives: SHG

Investment Tip: Taser International

As the stories of police using tasers in lieu of thinking become legion, there can be only one smart move:  invest.  Jonathon Turley posts about the latest taser target:



In Dayton, Ohio, citizens are upset over an incident where a blind woman, Denise Harris, 49, suffering from cancer was tasered by police — apparently while she was on the floor. The police insist that they needed to taser her “to control her hand movement.”



Family and neighbors insist that they told police that she was sick and was afraid. The initial police statements indicate that she was hit with the taser to facilitate cuffing — a very problematic rationale.


The police were reportedly trying to arrest Harris’ son on suspicion of robbery when things got ugly. In fairness, police often face hostile relatives in arrest situations, but it remains unclear why a taser was needed to be used for cuffing a blind cancer-victim (who is also suffering from diabetes).


But that’s just the start of Turley’s post.  Below the fold, he recounts some other pleasantries.


The story will add to the controversial use of tasers as a routine matter by officers, including recent incidents of such use on a disabled man and pregnant mother and an 82-year-old woman and routine ticket violator. This is not to mention the case where the police entered the wrong apartment and then tasered a deaf man who was in his bathtub, here.

The tales of the taser just get weirder and weirder.  The worst fears about tasers are no longer matters of prediction, but history.  It’s just so much easier for a cop to taser someone than reason, calm or behave with some modicum of humanity.  After all, tasers don’t actually do any harm (right?) and they make quick work of subduing those annoying people who just won’t do what they’re told.

This gives rise to two independent thoughts:  First, there are just too many stories of taser abuse to get all worked up about them anymore.  Maybe if they tasered an infant it would raise some interest, but the absurdly inappropriate use of tasers has already become rampant.  It’s gone from dog bites man to who cares. 

Second, any company that can continue to expand its customer base in the face of near-constant bad publicity is a great investment.  Put aside taser international’s problematic hype about how the claims of death by taser are lies spread by criminal-loving lefties bent on destroying the very fabric of American society.  The media has done its very best to bring out tales of police resort to taser when the word “please” would have sufficed.  No senscient being can be unaware that the taser has become the first line of defense against a smart-alecky geriatric.  And it hasn’t made a dent in business.  Not a dent.

Sure, it’s true that a taser does less harm than the slug from a Glock.  But then, most cops would be more reluctant to pull their weapon when a stopped motorist merely asks the question, “why”, than they would to taser the speedy miscreant.  “Why?  I’ll give you why…”  Zap. 

As long as no one is going to be saved, you might as well invest.  At least some good will come from tasers.

The “Science” of Plea Bargaining

Plea bargaining is a ubiquitous feature of criminal law, but hardly something that speaks well of the criminal justice system.  So when I read Doug Berman’s introduction of a new blog about plea bargaining, I cringed. 

The blog is called, quite simply, The Plea Bargaining Blog, giving it points for title clarity.  The subtitle, on the other hand, goes on at far greater length:

The Plea Bargaining Blog is dedicated to scholarship, articles and news regarding plea bargaining in criminal cases in the United States and around the world.  On average, 95% of all criminal cases are resolved through plea bargains.  As such, it is an integral part of the criminal justice system worthy of continuous examination and discussion.  The purpose of this blog is to further our understanding of the plea bargaining machine and its role in the criminal justice system.

While I have severe reservations that this is a subject worthy of too much scholarship, it’s certainly true that it is an integral part of the system.  But does that make it “worthy of continuous examination and discussion?”  That strikes me as a non sequitur.  So I went to the blog to see what sort of examination there was to be had.

The blog is authored by Lucian E. Dervan, an associate with a Florida law firm with which I was unfamiliar.  But from the sidebar, both noting his prior articles and links to lawprof blogs, it seemed that Lucian had one eye looking toward the academy.  Perhaps this was going to be the focus of his scholarship on the road to professorship.  The lawprofs all talk about how one has to stake a claim to scholarship if you want to get an office in the Ivory Tower.

The newest post discusses a “rocket docket” in Brevard County, Florida, apparently intended to expedite mass pleas to clear out real estate.  Dervan comments:


So is this a good idea, and should courts around the country utilize such swift justice to clear the dockets and the jail cells? I believe it depends on the reasons for the use of such a system and the safeguards employed to ensure justice is served. In the misdemeanor context, defendants who cannot afford bail often remain in jail awaiting trial longer than the length of a reasonable sentence should they be found guilty. It is hard to argue, therefore, that these defendants should not be given the chance to plead guilty and go home as fast as possible.

Perhaps the scholarship aspect is over my head, being the simple country lawyer that I am, but the depth of understanding of this scheme seems a little lacking.  This is a plea bargaining “fire sale,” offering deals too good to pass up by releasing defendants immediately for taking the deal.  It’s good to clear out beds.  It’s bad if innocents are induced to take the deal just to get home, as is surely its purpose.  Dervan continues:


And this negative aspect of the “plea rocket docket” brings up yet another problem, this type of system creates an immense incentive for defendants to plead guilty even if they are not guilty of the charged offense. It almost defies reason to believe that anyone would volunteer to remain in jail awaiting some future opportunity to present his or her case to a judge when freedom is a simple guilty plea away.

Well, yes.  Obviously.  And this is the hallmark of plea bargaining.  An inducement to accept/acquiesce for the benefit of a known result, sacrificing factual guilt and constitutional rights in the process.

The discussion made me wonder what Lucian Dervan’s background is, so that I could understand why he’s chosen to stake a claim to being a plea bargaining scholar.  His Avvo profile states that he was admitted to the Georgia bar in 2002, worked in Biglaw for four years before getting an 11th Circuit clerkship.  He then went to work for a Florida firm, and I would guess that he’s awaiting admission to the Florida bar.  The profile states that his practice is 90% employment/labor law, 10% white collar crime law.  The picture was coming into focus.

I read some more posts until I came to one involving the Souther District of New York, my neck of the woods.   The post was about Ronald Peteka, who has conspired with a Morgan Stanley employees to glom some proprietary information.  Peteka has taken a plea, which apparently made him an appropriate subject of discussion.


The requirement that Peteka plead to a statute containing a maximum sentence of 10 years, rather than one of the numerous statutes with a 5 year maximum, indicates that this plea agreement was late in the process and Peteka may have secured a better deal had he acted more quickly. Of particular note here is the fact that the co-defendant pleaded guilty eighteen months ago, indicating Peteka was somewhat of a hold-out.

Say what?  I hate to be disagreeable, but this is hardly what I take from the negligible information available.  Without knowing who the defense lawyers were, this smells of the co-defendant flipping early, leaving Peteka holding the bag.  There is nothing to suggest that Peteka could have secured a better deal by pleading earlier.  Maybe by ratting out his mother, but it’s unlikely she brought much to the table. 

As for pleading to the 10 year count, they Southern District almost always requires its pleas to be to the highest count, and then softens the blow in the plea agreement.  After all, the maximum sentence means little without knowing the agreed-upon guidelines calculations.  Maybe Peteka had a great defense and a great lawyer, and maybe they gave him a sweetheart plea because they didn’t want to try him.  Nothing can be gleaned from the worthless U.S Attorney’s  press release.

But the analysis offered in Dervan’s post is precisely what concerned me from the outset.  To the unaware, the commentary suggests that pleading early and often is the way to go.  If a reader was to assume that Dervan, by dint of having a blog dedicated to plea bargaining, had vast knowledge and experience, and was a voice to heed in the handling of criminal charges, the reader might well be inclined to believe that there’s no point in fighting criminal charges as almost everyone, guilty or innocent, ultimately pleads guilty anyway.  And the best course to take is plead as quickly as possible, since that’s when the best deals are to be cut.

This “message” is absolute garbage, and reflects a fundamental lack of knowledge and understanding about the nature of criminal prosecutions in general, and plea bargaining in particular.  It is grossly simplistic and totally wrong.  This is the sort of advice one gets from a shill for the prosecution.

I don’t begrudge anyone starting up a blog on any subject they select.  All it takes is a dollar and a dream.  But I do question whether a blog that purports to specialize in a non-existent specialty might serve to be dangerously simplistic and misleading to those readers who are scared to death, looking for “expert” advice and subject to accepting misinformation as reality. 

There have been individual posts from some of the lawprofs from time to time that relate to the propriety of plea bargaining and its mechanics, though I can’t recall any that reflect any real comprehension of the dynamics of plea bargaining in the real world.  But there’s nothing at The Plea Bargaining Blog that adds anything meaningful to the discussion, and it may well prove dangerous should any defendant happen to stumble upon it or any new lawyer think that this is how “everyone does it.” 

I doubt that there’s any place for a blog dedicated to plea bargaining.  But even if there is, I’m sorry to say that there’s no place for this blog.

Slackoisie: Boomers Screwed the Pooch

Former 1970s disco superstar turned trial lawyer/blawger, Dan Hull, got a keyboard-lashing from a reader for his vituperative challenge to Gen-Y sensibilities:



The boomer’s [sic] have systematically destroyed all that once made life bearable: marriage, traditional faith, the hope of financial security. In place of what used to be the societal superstructure, our generation has been force fed the consumer culture. We still feel empty. The money you pay is not worth it. When I pay off my loans (twenty years from now) you can kiss my ass.


And after you are dead, which unfortunately will take a while and cripple our generation financially, we can correct the gervious [sic] injuries that your generation inflicted on humanity. If the present election is any indication, boomer’s [sic] are incompetent leaders who’s [sic] malignant narcissism is only exceeded, at times, by their myopia. Take your second trophy wives, McMansions, and blinding self love with you when you shuffle off this mortal coil.


So much for the “better educated” claim, but what of the criticism of baby boomers?  Did we really screw the pooch?  Dan’s musical response (thankfully not the Bee Gees) may sail over the heads of Gen-Y, most of whom are still listening to music from boomer days since there hasn’t been any good music made in over 40 years.  As I have before, so too will I step into the breech to help again.


Dear Slacky,

You are correct that baby boomers have made mistakes.  Many of them, in fact, though I hesitate to take responsibility for George W. Bush, who was elected to office by everyone except the baby boomers.  As for trophy wives, McMansions and “blinding self love,” I’m only guilty of the last, but try to keep it private.  Were you peaking into your parents’ bedroom again?

On the other hand, we had a goal when we were younger, and full of that great energy that’s denied us when we finally know what to do with it.  We may have been misguided in our denial of human nature, refusing to see it as ugly and brutish, but at least we tried to improve the human condition.

Getting a tattoo and a pierced nipple doesn’t qualify as improving the human condition.  So you lose.


Sincerely,

Greenfield


But Dan isn’t the only one to be challenged lately.  I received an attempted smack as well, in reaction to my old post about The Lawyer Look.  More than a year after that piece was posted, I still get the occasional slacker trying to justify his foolish choices.  This one came in yesterday from Justin (with his rant sliced into paragraphs to compensate for his apparent lack of having a “return” “enter” key on his computer):

While I understand that everyone is entitled to their opinion, I must say that assuming that someone is dumb or foolish based on a tattoo or piercing is stereotypical and just what I would hope we would all be working against.

That being said, I have my bottom lip pierced and one earring in each ear. I also plan on getting “3/4 sleeve” tattoos. The only thing that is unsightly or unprofessional looking in professional dress is the lip rings which will come out upon graduation. I think the main thing to remember when talking about piercings and tattoos is that lumping everyone with them together is a little ridiculous. Having tattoos that are covered in the courtroom, or any professional place for that matter, is not indicative of someone being dumb. If anything, it is a mark of someone that took the responsible and sensible route in finding the proper balance between personal wants and professional goals.

I must say though, there are those out there who seem to beg for a life of minimum wage and constant scrutiny. It is a price they pay and if they are happy with the choice then you are foolish to waste your time judging them. I somehow doubt that the person you choose to display a picture of (which is by far the extreme end of the spectrum and a horrible misrepresentation of the average person with a tattoo or piercing) wishes to be a lawyer or in any professional career.

Perhaps you should use a more fitting example of the people you seem to despise so much or maybe you are just a bit jealous of the carefree life that their culture lives. While you say that them defending their decisions is just to cover up their regret for the poor decision they have seemingly made, one could point the same finger at you for spending your life as a lawyer. It is all a matter of perspective and therefor you should respect what others do with their lives and bodies as much as they should respect yours.

Justin confuses tolerance with respect.  It’s not his fault.  His parents likely tried to teach him to be tolerant of others, and he got confused.  It happens when children are small.  But if Justin is old enough to have his lip pierced (ewww), then he’s old enough to learn the difference.

We are tolerant, Justin.  We don’t hunt people who chose to mutilate themselves down to improve the species.  We just don’t respect you.  We hear your rationalization of childish vanity, and shake our heads because we’ve heard such foolishness before.  Even God isn’t buying.

Are we “just a bit jealous of the carefree life?”  You bet we are.  We had the best time during the summer of love, Woodstock and (in Dan Hull’s case) Studio 54.  But if we didn’t get down to work, little Justin would go hungry.  As boomers learned, children like to eat.  Every single day.  Sometimes multiple times a day.  And we need to go out and earn a living to pay for the food they eat.  That’s how you managed to grow up big and strong so that you could put a ring in your lip some day. 

Dan’s commenter castigates us for dubious taste in housing and spouses.  Good taste seems to defy generations.  Have you ever seen a split level or a leisure suit?  But there’s nothing that boomers have constructed that can’t be de-constructed.  Make a mistake?  Fix it.

Humankind has always made mistakes.  But the Slackeoisie will have an awfully hard time explaining theirs to their grandchildren when their cool, carefree tats sag down to their knees.  Our dubious choices were made with the best of intentions.  Yours?  Childish vanity.  You lose.  Now get a job.

Things That Won’t Survive, Part 1 (Update)

I received an email that cuts are happening at the New York Times.  Reporters are being quietly told that they should look for new jobs now, because they won’t have jobs come next spring.  At the same time, cost-cutting at all levels has become the rule, with delivery to more distant places discontinued.  After all, who needs to deliver a newspaper when there’s nothing left in it but an editorial and some supermarket advertisements.

The cost of paper has skyrocketed.  Energy costs are through the roof.  And the people who go out and investigate and report on the news still need to get paid.  If you keep them on.  If you don’t, then there’s a huge savings.  It just means that there won’t be any news in the newspaper.

This is bad.  Technology combined with spiraling costs spells huge changes for the “dead trees” media.  If the FCC would let it happen, television news would be replaced with Survivor #47 in a flash.  While readers view the press as a right, media owners have to remember that they’re a business, and they have to make enough money to pay the bills. 

Already, changes in newspapers are happening, though slow enough to escape notice of most people.  Not those who work there, who are painfully aware that the Woodward/Bernstein days are mere nostalgia, but those of us who read their product.  Fewer articles amidst the pages of advertising.  And the advertisers know it too, as they realize they can target their audience much easier on the internet, and at far lower cost. 

This is bad.  While readers (like me) enjoy the ready availability of free access to news across the spectrum on demand, there’s no business model that makes it work for the producers of news.  I read at will, and there’s nothing in it for them.  These media websites have ads, but at far less benefit then a quarter page in the paper, and they compete with ads on everyone else’s websites, making newspapers’ websites one of many competing for advertisers’ dollars.

The problem is that we need these guys to do their job.  We need newspapers and TV news to stay in business.  We need them to thrive.  Their reporters are the ones who go out on the street and collect the news.  Their camera people take the pictures that we look at so intently.  Blogs may do a decent job of explaining or editorializing on events, but we need to know about the events themselves or we have nothing to explain. 

We can’t force the Sulzbergers, Zuckermans, Murdochs to keep publishing.  No matter how important information is to society, to democracy, they need a viable business model to keep revenues flowing and pay the paper bills, the reporters’ salaries, even the kid on the bicycle who tosses the paper on your front porch.  There was a time when every home received a newspaper delivery.  Of course, there was a time when every home had a telephone land line.  Things change.

Newspapers are too smart to print a story about their plight on the front page, above the fold.  Announcements of impending demise tend to turn people off.  Especially advertising people.  But it is most assuredly happening right before our noses. 

We need the media, whether we like them or not.  They may annoy and disappoint us.  They may fall short of fulfilling our expectations on a regular basis.  But consider life in America without them.  Worse yet, consider life in America where the only access to information available is USA Today, with the depth of a sheet of copy paper and the breadth of a media mogul’s greasy fingertips. 

This is bad.

Update:  As pointed out by my ever-prescient hinterlands correspondent, it’s not like this state of affairs comes as a surprise to newspapers.  It’s been coming for years, since the 80s actually, as smaller papers were purchased, consolidated or folded.  They began to realize back then that the model was getting old, and lack of competition made them fat and lazy, even though change was inevitable.

So what did newspapers do about it?  Nothing.  No adaptation.  Smug in their necessity and self-importance, they stood there, editors with their arms folded across their chest, and did absolutely nothing.  No accomodation for changing circumstances.  No preparation for the coming storm.  They believed (and still do) that there can be no world without newspapers, and they would hold their breath and wait for the reading public to come running back with open arms and show them the love and respect they deserved.

Also a little addendum to my latest note about our younger, oft-times tattooed, friends. They don’t read the newspaper.  They don’t subscribe to the newspaper.  That’s for old fogies.  They get the news off their iPhones.  

DNA, What are the Odds?

It’s hard to argue identification when an expert states with certainty that the odds of a misidentification are 1 in 100 billion.  There’s always deterioration, or cross-contamination, but those arguments are hard to make comprehensible and not always available.  After all, it’s 1 in 100 billion, right?

Well, maybe not.  Maybe not even close.  In a lengthy article in the Los Angeles Times, it seems that law enforcement’s statistical showing may fall far short of their courtroom claims.  And the FBI is going to war to try to keep this information under wraps.


State crime lab analyst Kathryn Troyer was running tests on Arizona’s DNA database when she stumbled across two felons with remarkably similar genetic profiles.

The men matched at nine of the 13 locations on chromosomes, or loci, commonly used to distinguish people.

The FBI estimated the odds of unrelated people sharing those genetic markers to be as remote as 1 in 113 billion. But the mug shots of the two felons suggested that they were not related: One was black, the other white.

In the years after her 2001 discovery, Troyer found dozens of similar matches — each seeming to defy impossible odds.

Kathryn Troyer opened a big can of worms.  The Arizona DNA database contained only 65,000 samples, yet found matches within the database that defied the statistics.  Thomas Callaghan, head of the FBI’s CODIS unit was not amused.

This is of no consequence to the use of DNA to exclude identification, by showing that a person’s DNA did not match DNA found at a crime scene.  This is valid science.  But the claims that DNA provides positive identification, to the tune of 1 in a billion, “the FBI’s best estimates,” just got a kick in the teeth.

And what does the FBI have to say about the validity of their courtroom claims?


Several scientists and legal experts as well want to test the accuracy of official statistics using the nearly 6 million profiles in CODIS, the national system that includes most state and local databases.

FBI officials argue that, under their interpretation of federal law, use of CODIS is limited to criminal justice agencies. In their view, defense attorneys are allowed access to information about their specific cases, not the databases in general.

[Thomas Callaghan] urged authorities in several states to object to Arizona-style searches, advising them to tell courts that the probes could violate the privacy of convicted offenders, tie up crucial databases and even lead the FBI to expel offending states from CODIS — a penalty that could cripple states’ ability to solve crimes.

In other words, they refuse to allow their numbers to be scientifically tested.  While defense lawyers can test the database for their individual client, they can’t test the database for validity in general.  The problem with this approach is that the database remains significantly limited.  They don’t have one billion samples to compare your client’s DNA against, and if you can’t find a 9 point match in the existing database, then you’re out of luck.

Complaints about the way Troyer unearthed her matches seek to blunt the impact of her discovery.  They claim that it skews the result, since she compared each of the 65,000 DNA samples in the Arizona database against each other to see how many loci would match up.  In normal testing, one known sample would be compared with the 65,000, giving rise to a completely different result.  As soon as one marker did not match, the test sample would be excluded.

The problem is that the testimonial claims of uniqueness, and the number of matching loci, are all statistically based.  Like most scientific wonders, the basis for these claims go untested and assumed until they become part of the myth. 


In the 1990s, FBI scientists estimated the rarity of each genetic marker by extrapolating from sample populations of a few hundred people from various ethnic or racial groups. The estimates for each marker are multiplied across all 13 loci to come up with a rarity estimate for the entire profile.

These estimates make assumptions about how populations mate and whether genetic markers are independent of each other. They also don’t account for relatives.

Bruce Weir, a statistician at the University of Washington who has studied the issue, said these assumptions should be tested empirically in the national database system.

“Instead of saying we predict there will be a match, let’s open it up and look,” Weir said.

Some experts predict that given the rapid growth of CODIS, such a search would produce one or more examples of unrelated people who are identical at all 13 loci.

Such a discovery was once unimaginable.

It may well turn out that there is a number of loci that are sufficient to make that identification that the FBI would have us believe is beyond dispute.  But we’re not there yet.  In the meantime, judges (not always the best arbiters of good versus junk science because they don’t know squat about science which is why they became lawyers) stick the “tried and true” testimony despite evidence that it may not be accurate.

The article goes on to discuss various attacks on the database around the country, the FBI’s efforts to thwart the attempts to ascertain the validity of their claims and how various judges, some bold and some not so, have dealt with it. 

This article is a great starting point for learning about DNA fallacies, so even if you haven’t had a DNA case yet, eventually you will and this is stuff you need to know.

The Re-Education of Adam Liptak

Taking extreme liberty with spatial, temporal and stark reality, I post about my chat yesterday with New York Times’ Legal Smeagle Adam Liptak.  I’ve had my issues with Adam in the past, and since he’s slated to be the voice of the Supreme Court for a fairly credible newspaper, I couldn’t ignore it any longer.  Not after Adam wrote this article. 

After brief pleasantries, we settled down to our drink.  I voted for a beer, but Adam insisted on green tea due to its herbal healing qualities and the possibility that it would induce the growth of hair.

Adam, there are way too many people reading your articles for you to play so fast and loose with the truth…

         What!  I don’t do that.  I would never do that.

Adam, you wrote


The United States is the only country to take the position that some police misconduct must automatically result in the suppression of physical evidence. The rule applies whether the misconduct is slight or serious, and without regard to the gravity of the crime or the power of the evidence.

What were you thinking?

         But that’s true.  It’s true, true, true.

Not only is it not true, but it’s completely misleading.  First, the exclusionary rule doesn’t come into play because of “police misconduct,” but because the police have violated a defendant’s rights under the 4th Amendment.  

         It’s the same thing.

Not even close.  Misconduct encompasses a huge variety of wrongs, from a good beating to lying under oath.  You remember “testilying”, don’t you?

         I never believe it happened, by the way.  It’s just another liberal plot.

Sigh.  Let’s save that one for another day and focus for the moment on this one article.  Are we clear that it’s not about “police misconduct?”

         I suppose, maybe.

Now let’s talk about the word “some”.  You stuck that in there to suggest that no matter how trivial the “misconduct”, the criminal would beat the case, right?

         I was just trying to be accurate.  Is it my fault that suppression sucks?

Cut the crap, Adam.  There’s no “some” involved.  Either the cops made an unlawful search or they didn’t.  That’s the question, and the only question.  Your “little bit pregnant” allusion is designed to feed into the wackos who love to call constitutional violations “technicalities”.  Admit it.

         But some of them are my best friends…

Yeah, like you have friends.  Anyway, let’s get to my favorite word choice in this polemic, “automatically”.  You want to explain that one?

         Well, they have to suppress if the cops did something wrong.  The judge has no choice!

Slow it down there, buckaroo.  Do you know how many exceptions to the rule of the 4th Amendment now exist?  According to my good buddy, Norm, it’s up to 479 as of today, except in the State of Washington where it’s 478.  Any judge who can’t find an exception to allow an unconstitutional search is a disgrace to the robe.

         But all those activist judges and their revolving door justice?

You have got to stop reading George Will.  Just take a look at the cases, man.  Maybe one in a hundred ends in suppression.  Maybe less.  It’s almost as rare as hen’s teeth.  Why are you trying to make it seem like it happens all the time?

         Because if I didn’t, then my whole story would be a load of garbage and they 
        would make me go back to work in the legal department in a little cubicle.

But your story was about how other countries don’t have the exclusionary rule.  How Cardozo ridiculed it, and how the Supremes may get their chance to play with Mapp v. Ohio when they decide Herring v. US next term.  You could have told the truth and still written an interesting article.

        Yeah, but do you know how hard it was to find anybody, even a law professor, who
        thought the exclusionary rule was a bad idea and should get tossed?  Even my old stand-by,
        Orin Kerr, thought it was justified by historical experience.  I mean, I had to find
        some Yale guy, Akhil Reed Amar, who wrote a 1994 Harvard Lampoon, I mean Law Review,
        article to get a negative.  Yale, for Pete’s sake!


So do you think there might be a reason why all these people think that the exclusionary rule is needed to stop the cops from playing with the 4th Amendment?  Now drink up your green tea.  I think I see something sprouting up top.

Note to Self:  Remind readers at some point that this conversation never happened, that Adam Liptak won’t take your calls and even though he reads Simple Justice religiously, pretends that he doesn’t know you at parties.

H/T Mike at C&F

What’s the Rusch to Search a Law Office?

Why a Texas judge, of course.  From Grits for Breakfast, yet more of the fascinating world of Texas judicial follies. 


“Judge Mark Rusch of the 401st District Court in Collin County apparently issued a search warrant at the request of the DA’s office for defense attorney files in a murder case before his court.” KRLD Radio reported the search warrant “may be a first in Texas.”

The background of the story from the Collin County Observer :


The suspect, Mark Bell, wrote letters to his wife detailing “suicide and escape plans”, and one describing an orange shoe box that “could be crucial to the prosecution’s case”. Police learned of the letters which the suspect’s wife had delivered to Keith Gore, who is Bell’s defense attorney.

Four days before a hearing to determine if the police could see those items, the police instead executed a search warrant on the defense attorney and seized the letters and shoe box.

So many issues raised by one little warrant execution.  Now one might be inclined to go after the prosecutor for seeking a search warrant when the hearing to determine production was only four days off, but that would only implicate the prosecutor for playing hard ball.  You see, prosecutors can ask, but they need a judge to approve.  So the onus falls on another truly special Texas judge, Mark Rusch.

Had the prosecutor somehow obtained evidence that the defense lawyer was about to destroy evidence in his possession that would inculpate his client, then there might be a reason to take such drastic action as approve a search warrant.  Of course, it’s hard to imagine a scenario where a prosecutor would have such evidence, unless the defendant lawyer, Keith Gore, was screaming it down the courthouse hallway.

Beyond that, there can be no explanation for the issuance of a warrant.  If the evidence existed (as it apparently did), it was the defense lawyer’s duty to preserve it pending order of the court.  If he was inclined to behave unlawfully, it would likely already by destroyed.  An order from the court directing him to preserve the evidence would not have been inappropriate.  But other than that, they had a hearing scheduled to determine the issue.  There was no cause to raid the law office.

Side Note: Grits has an update from NBC 5 stating that Keith Gore has hired his own attorney, who “calls the search ‘illegal’ and ‘unconscionable’ and a violation of attorney client privilege.”  While there is a complex privilege issue involved, including spousal privilege since the evidence seized included letters between the defendant and his wife, it does not violate attorney client privilege to seek evidence of a crime that is held by the attorney.  Physical evidence of the crime itself is never privileged, regardless of who holds it. 

Letters written by the defendant to his wife, essentially confessing to the crime, however, are not physical evidence of the crime.  But included with the letters given to Gore by the wife was a shoe box containing a Wal-Mart receipt for something (perhaps the murder weapon?), and this receipt, unlike the letters, is not privileged and does not become privileged because it came into the lawyer’s hands.

So what’s the big deal?  Well, first we have cops and prosecution seizing evidence prior to the determination that they have any authority to obtain it from the defense lawyer, essentially circumventing the court to grab what it may not be entitled to possess.  This is a sentence first, convict later type situation. 

But more significantly, at least to my mind, is the police rifling through Gore’s files, his privileged and confidential information about his criminal defendant clients, to search for evidence in satisfaction of the warrant.  File by file, page by page, the police thoroughly and diligently search.  And now every case, every client represented by Keith Gore has been compromised.  The wrong done to these other, unrelated clients, is inestimable.  The sanctity of the privacy of a criminal defense lawyer’s files has been violated.

There’s got to be more to this story, such as what compelled Texas judge Mark Rusch to sign a warrant under these circumstances.  The Texas and National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers has sent a strike force to Collins County to go after this perversion of justice, seeking to ameliorate the damage to the extent possible and force Rusch’s recusal from the case. 

Hopefully, Grits will keep abreast of this case and we’ll get to take a peak at the search warrant application to see what was alleged to justify a search of Keith Gore’s office.  This ought to be interesting.

Can’t You Smell That Smell

The odor of burning marijuana has long been a telltale sign of . . . burning marijuana.  It reminds some of rock concerts.  Others are reminded of youthful indiscretions of political candidates.  But to Washington State Trooper Brent Hanger, it was the smell of . . . arrest.

Via Arbitrary & Capricious, and later the WSJ Law Blog (stealing Skelly’s Cheech & Chong theme without any attribution at all), the Supreme Court of Washington did something that I haven’t seen in quite a while in State v. Grande.  The Court held that the rights afforded under the state Constitution were more protective of individual freedom from arrest than under the United States Constitution. 

Trooper Hanger pulled over a car with an unhappy Lacee Hurley driving and Jeremy Grande in the passenger seat.  Hanger “detected the ‘moderate’ smell of marijuana coming from the car.”  After taking several deep breaths to make absolutely sure (this isn’t in the decision, but a figment of my vivid imagination), he arrested both driver and passenger.  This was where he went wrong.

Subsequent to arrest, he searched Grande and found a pipe with remnants of pot, as well as the burnt end of a joint in the car.  But this came after the arrest, and there’s the rub.


The police officer’s arrest of Grande was not predicated on safety concerns, but on the odor of marijuana  emanating from the vehicle. As a result, the question is whether the police officer had an objective rationale that it was Grande committing a crime and consequently, probable cause for his arrest. 

Our state constitution protects our individual privacy, meaning that we are free from unnecessary police intrusion into our private affairs unless a police officer can clearly associate the crime with the individual. We cannot wait until the people we are associating with “alleviate[e] the suspicion” from us. Unless there is specific evidence pinpointing the crime on a person, that person has a right to their own privacy and constitutional protection against police searches and seizures.

This does not mean, however, that a law enforcement officer must simply walk away from a vehicle from which the odor of marijuana emanates and in which more than one occupant is present if the officer cannot determine which occupant possessed or used the illegal drug. In this case, because the officer had training and experience to identify the odor of marijuana and smelled this odor emanating from the vehicle, he had probable cause to search the vehicle.

Cheech and Chong aside, this was a bit of a strange scenario.  Had Hanger not arrested first and search later, it seems that all would have been well with the bust.  He would have found the “roach”, then had probable cause to arrest and perform a search incident, then found the pipe and remaining pot.  Apparently, Trooper Hanger missed “how to sequence your search/arrest” class in trooper school, not to mention the “how to tailor your testimony” seminar.

So the real lesson of this decision is to search first and arrest later, not that passengers can’t be arrested for the smell of pot.  Which, incidentally, raises another question:  What was Hanger arresting the pair for?  It’s the possession of marijuana, not the use of marijuana, that’s a crime.  As the trooper arrested Hurley and Grande before he found any pot in the car, were they arrested for smelling like Eau du Cannabis?

What stands out about this decision is that Supreme Court of Washington used the opportunity to make a statements about its view of the Supreme Court trend to enhance certain constitutional rights while denigrating others.


Our cases have strongly and rightfully protected our constitution’s protection of individual privacy. The protections of article I, section 7 do not fade away or disappear within the confines of an automobile. Parker, 139 Wn.2d at 505. We have always been careful to balance an individual’s privacy concerns with the safety concerns and law enforcement duties of police officers. Within this balance, we have carefully safeguarded constitutional privacy rights by adherence to the requirement of an individualized determination before those rights can be infringed.

Now this is a sentiment that brings back memories.  Kudos to the Court for refusing to let your Constitution be dragged into the gutter by other courts that have lost their concern and focus on the protection of individual privacy in their enabling the paramounts interest of order over law.

Gerry Spence, Blawger (Update)

There’s another new kid in the neighborhood.  Except he isn’t exactly new to anyone, and he’s certainly no kid.  Gerry Spence may have tried his last case, but he’s just starting out in the blawgosphere.  Welcome to Gerry Spence’s Blog.

Susan Cartier Leibel gave me the heads up, and we talked a little about what this means.  After all, this is Gerry Spence, a living legend in criminal defense.  What will he blog about?  Will he preach from on high, or will he join us in conversation?  How will the “simple country lawyer” thing play out online? 

I don’t know him personally, like Norm does, and I never went to the Trial Lawyers College at his ranch.  I never drank the cool-aid, so while I’m impressed, I’m not a sycophant.  Will this be a summary of college techniques, or closing statements, or rants against the machine?  I have no clue what to expect.

There are a bunch of questions running through my mind.  Will he do the blogging himself, or have someone else post under his name.  Will he only pontificate on grand constitutional points, or will he deal with nitty gritty daily stuff.  When he opines, will his view become the authoritative one?  If so, will it be because of the soundness of his argument or just because it came from Gerry Spence.  If nothing else, this will be fascinating to watch, to read and to follow. 

I welcome Gerry Spence to the blawgosphere, and I hope he will join in the conversation.  I hope he will do it personally, and not put some flunky to the task.  And I hope we will all welcome him as one of us, not a legend or prophet.   I truly look forward to hearing more from Gerry Spence.

Update:  A second post is up at GSB, rather typically existential and will play well to the chorus.  More interesting are the welcoming comments to his first post, ranging from predictions that he alone will change the blawgosphere to those hoping to implant their heads deeply up his rectum to the cool-aid drinkers.  On the other side, there are those telling him what to think and do. 

Also note the title image on GSB:  A profile picture of Gerry Spence.  Half a mug shot or his better side?  I don’t know what this means, but it signify that special sort of vanity that leads to effective satire.

Since comments are moderated, someone has given the Spence seal of approval on posting these comments.  Will those who pray at the alter of Spence cause Gerry’s head to swell to the size of Geeklawyer’s?  Will those who are positioning themselves to knock him off his pedestal make headway? 

To date, the best comment left at GSB belongs to the Texas Tornado himself, Mark Bennett.  It’s simply perfect.

Will Cuomo Dig Deep Enough?

Newsday reported this week that New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo has sent out 200 letters around the state seeking information on jobs and benefits provided private lawyers, and now other professionals as well, who have been living large on the public dime.


More than half of the 200 letters, which seek specific information about jobs and benefits such as pension credits, have been sent to lawyers. The rest – in a significant expansion of Cuomo’s investigation – have gone to civil engineers, accountants and doctors who have been employees of local governments and school districts. The names of the recipients of the letters on Long Island could not be learned.

“We have found waste, fraud and abuse in all corners of the state regarding public benefits improperly awarded to outside consultants. This is a significant step in the expansion of the investigation,” said Cuomo spokesman John Milgrim.

And they’ve barely scratched the surface. 

While the investigation is expanding (a good thing), it still remains limited to relatively obvious wrongs, such as private contractors to public entities being claimed as employees for the purpose of obtaining the sweet package of benefits that goes with public employment.  These are great perks for the beneficiaries, and nice little gifts for local politicos because they fly under the public’s radar.  Sure, the public pays for it, but you would have to look long and hard to see where the dollars are buried.

Unfortunately, I can’t imagine how Cuomo’s office could possibly have the time and manpower to dig deep enough to understand the depth and scope of the problems, going well beyond the obvious pension issues and into the daily decision-making that sustains waste and abuse.  Between the ignorance, deceit and arrogance of petty elected and appointed officials, and the culture of concealment and enabling by the handful of professionals who are theoretically supposed to keep the asylum under control, it’s a morass of fraud, waste and abuse.

Unlike those who are disaffected by the decisions, or those who merely complain because their taxes are “too high,” this is about what happens when you put a bunch of people who desperately want a little power and recognition to compensate for their lack of dinner invitations in charge of things.  While lawprofs ponder high ideals, and trench lawyers like me ponder lower ones, they ponder nothing.  Lacking any real ideology, or firm interest in public service, those inclined to run for lesser public office, in a not-so-silent cry for attention, become children in a candy store when they finally grab hold of a little power. 

This is where local government meets Lord of the Flies, and we pay for it, both in ineffective government as well as the hard costs of corruption and mismanagement.  I wish Andy Cuomo well, because he has his work cut out for him.  If he’s sincere in having an impact on the problem, however, he still has a long, long way to go before he gets to the heart of the problem.