Author Archives: SHG

Cops, Coffee and Crime

When I read about this yesterday, it was deja vu all over again.  From Turley and Mike at C&F, the “funny” story of Major Garvin, a Daytona Police Lieutenant.  From the Orlando Local 6 News,



An internal police investigation found that Daytona Lt. Major Garvin received free coffee for about two years from a city Starbucks coffee store.



However, when recently denied free coffee from new management, Garvin allegedly told managers that he could change the police department’s response time if they refuse to give him complimentary drinks.



Garvin is accused of saying, “If something happens, either we can respond really fast or we could respond really slow. I’ve been coming here for years and I’ve been getting whatever I want. I’m the difference between you getting a two-minute response time, if you needed a little help, or a 15 minutes response time.”


While this may sound like a funny story, prompting a pun from a commenter at Turley’s that was so cute that he changed the title of his post to include it (“Don’t Tazerberry Me, Bro”), I’m having a hard time finding a chuckle in all this. 

Does anybody remember Serpico?  Does anybody remember the Knapp Commission?  New York City cops had developed a culture of extortion and shakedowns, walking from store to store to take whatever “freebie” the owner was giving that day to make sure that bad things didn’t happen to him.  It was the mob with shields, and it was so much a part of cop culture that Frank Serpico’s life was worthless when he decided to reveal it. 

Since then, there has been one rule of thumb that is no longer in question in the NYPD.  You don’t take a freebie.  Not a free cup of joe.  Not a free hot dog.  Nothing.  This of course doesn’t apply to large sums of cash or narcotics, which falls under a different set of rules altogether.

It’s certainly a sign of the times that Lt. Garvin’s beverage of choice was the mocha frappucino, which he scarfed up around 6 time a day.  There’s always something funny about Starbucks beverages, because they have those crazy names and seem so effete.  But there’s nothing funny about street cops returning to the ways of commonplace, low-level extortion.

And while one might contend that the fact that Garvin was caught shows that the culture of the old days is gone, bear in mind that he got away with it for 2 years before anyone found out, and the only reason this came to light is because a new manager refused to go along with the grande extortion.  Had the new management been sufficiently intimidated by Lt. Garvin, it would have never come to light.

Things tend to go around in circles, with old ways finding new audiences.  This is one blast from the past that I hope to never hear about again.  I just don’t find anything humorous about it.

What the Constitution Ought to Say

A debate is raging between Orin Kerr and Sasha Volokh over the distinction of “is” versus “ought” in constitutional law.  The debate itself is one that only a lawprof could love, culminating in such gems as Kantian ethics and Hectorism.  Sexy stuff.  They should make a movie about it.

But it does raise some issues that apply to trench lawyers, constantly called upon by our clients to tell them “what the law is,” which almost invariably precedes our clients telling us “what the law ought to be.”  Orin takes the view that there is an “is” when it comes to the Constitution, while Sasha argues that the “is” only “is”
until it isn’t.

I’ve struggled with this problem for year when counseling clients.  People want a definitive answer as to what they can and can’t do, and what the government can and can’t do.  They say, “you’re the lawyer; you tell me what the law is.”  It’s a fair question, and it makes me feel ashamed of the fact that I have never found a way to express with clarity the line where “known” law meets variable law.  Indeed, this just got a whole lot worse with this terms Supreme Court decisions, where “known” law has increasingly become variable, and in cases like Heller, shockingly variable.

A lawyer’s typical description starts with black letter law, the stuff that is written in stone and we all know to be the case.  But when given facts that seek to finesse the line of black letter law, we stumble because we know, at least if we are being honest with ourselves and our clients, that the law is uncertain and subject to the interpretation of judges.  We can’t trust the law, and we certainly can’t provide any guarantees about what a judge will think.

When it comes to the Constitution, a document that has been parsed more than any other, one would think that lawyers have a firm grasp on what it means.  Of course, ten years ago, there would not be a lawyer in the United States who would have advised a client that the 2d Amendment protected an individual right to keep and bear arms.  We all knew, with absolute certainty, what the 2d Amendment means.  But we were wrong.  Today, we have no idea what it means, and may well have no idea for the next 20 years.  Try explaining this to a client.

This has long been a problem for criminal defense lawyers, particularly with the 4th Amendment warrant clause.  Read it.  It seems clear enough.  Yet explain why there are about 743 exceptions that cover almost any circumstance that’s likely to arise and serves to undermine any reliance on the plain language of the Constitution.  Our efforts are constantly directed toward arguing why a search and seizure doesn’t fall within an exception, though there’s no mention of any exceptions at all in the 4th Amendment.  Explain this.

And it goes further, as Crawford now commands that our right to confront witnesses who make testimonial statements must be honored, whereas before we were swallowed up in a tidal wave of hearsay exceptions.  So can we prepare for trial in reliance on keeping harmful hearsay statements out for lack of a living witness, or will they be called non-testimonial to circumvent the newest variation on an old rule?  This could mean the difference between a winner and loser at trial, but we may well have no clue which way the court will rule on our objection.

So while Orin may argue that there is a “is” when it comes to constitutional law, and that people who confuse “is” with “ought” are just sloppy, wishful thinkers, I find myself struggling with the idea that there really “is” a law and those of us who are paid to give advice should be able to tell it like it “is”.  While we can convince ourselves that we know that the law “is”, and from time to time may find that a proposition is sufficiently well-settled that even the dopiest judge can be counted on to rule correctly, we are almost invariably left to hope that our understanding of what the law allows or prohibits will remain in place long enough to make it through verdict and that we end up with a judge who finds the state of the law sufficiently clear that we can count on an anticipated ruling.

At least that’s how it ought to be.

If Physicians Dislike Malpractice, They Will Really Hate This

The WSJ Law Blog reports that there’s a new problem on the horizon for doctors who have bad results.  No longer can they limit their whining to the trauma of facing a potential medical malpractice suit.  Now they have something even worse to worry about.


Michael O’Keefe, the D.A. for Cape Cod, is apparently pushing the criminal envelope in this area that’s typically left to tort law. O’Keefe has filed an indictment charging Dr. Rapin Osathanondh, a research associate at the Harvard School of Public Health, with manslaughter charge after an abortion he performed last year ended in the death of Laura Hope Smith, a 22-year-old woman.

It raises a very interesting question.  When does the level of professional neglect reach the point of criminal conduct?  As crimes have expanded well beyond intentional acts to reach conduct that is reckless, sometimes even negligent, why should this be limited to some people and not others, such as physicians?


O’Keefe, the D.A., told the Globe that the indictment came after an investigation by local and state police, and the Massachusetts Board of Registration in Medicine found Osathanondh’s conduct to be “willful, wanton, and reckless.” Osathanondh, 65, resigned his medical license in February.

“Suffice it to say, there was an inattention to the kinds of procedures of a lifesaving nature that one would expect in a place where an operation with anesthesia is being performed,” O’Keefe said. “There was nobody monitoring her, long enough to result in her death. There were a number of other shortcomings that make up the willful, wanton, and reckless conduct.”

Other than characterizing the neglect with particularly harsh words, there’s nothing particularly notable about what happened here that couldn’t be said about many other instance of medical malpractice, perhaps even all such instances.  After all, nobody would remove the wrong leg, or leave a clamp in someone’s chest, if they were paying the level of attention we expect and demand from doctors. 

So where is the line between criminal neglect and civil neglect?  Simply repeating the words “willful, wanton and reckless” means nothing.  This wasn’t an intentional act.  It was a screw-up that resulted in death.  Isn’t the same true of a drunk driver who ends up causing a fatal accident? 

I’m certainly not advocating that physicians should bear criminal liability for negligence in the operating room, but I am having a relatively hard time understanding why a drunk’s negligence should conceptually differ from a physician’s negligence.  If anything, the physician appreciates, whereas a drunk lacks the ability to do so, that his actions could easily result in the death or maiming of a human being should he not perform his function in a meticulous fashion.  If the physician fails to do so, having every opportunity to appreciate the consequences of his failure, and harm to a person results, is it less criminal than the negligence of a non-physician?

While one can distinguish the physician’s purpose for engaging in the conduct, to treat a patient, from the drunk’s purpose, to have a good time, is having far greater social utility, the doc’s purpose would seem to go hand in hand with a higher level of care as well. 

This trend could wreak havoc in the medical world should it gain traction, and then we could really be in trouble.  But if we are to have an equal application of law, and our criminal laws have been expanded to cover negligence by regular folk who mean no harm but end up doing it anyway, then it remains a strong possibility that doctors will face criminal consequences for their bad outcomes should they shortcut in the operating room, something that happens far more regularly than anyone wants to admit.

Maybe this will give legislators pause to rethink expanding the criminalization of negligent conduct because of bad outcomes?  Of course, in order to rethink, one must have thought in the first place.

Oral Argument on NY Judicial Salary Case

It was pure kismet that Eric Turkewitz of New York Personal Injury Law had a case before Judge Edward H. Lehner yesterday, and happened to still be in the courtroom as the lawyers squared off to argue one of the most unique actions to find its way into a courtroom, Chief Judge Judy Kaye’s suit against the rest of the New York State government over judicial pay raises.

So Turk, having nothing better to do, hung around and listened, giving him the opportunity to provide a great report on the argument.


The Chief Judge has created a thicket of issues by suing the Assembly, Senate and Governor, with the case being heard by the judiciary. Justice Lehner noted at the outset that he stands to benefit from a raise if he were to order it.

With about a dozen lawyers and assistants involved in the well of the courtroom or sitting in the gallery, it was at the outset hard to tell the lawyers without a scorecard. Numbers and names on the back of suits would have helped.

Peering out over his reading glasses from his dark wood paneled courtroom at 60 Centre Street — and using the same demeanor he used to discuss whether a fall on wire on a floor was a slip or a trip, at issue on the case preceding this — Justice Lehner delved into the legal morass of what he called “the most novel case of my court career.” (Complaint)

Turk provides a terrific synopsis of the issues and arguments, and if you are interested in this ongoing train wreck, it’s definitely a worthwhile read. 

From Turk’s description, Judge Lehner handled the argument with grace and intelligence, noting a variety of very unusual and sticky issues, and ultimately cutting through the chafe to get to the wheat.

The argument was also covered at Judicial Reports, which opens its post by recounting Judge Lehner’s using a little joke to break the tension:


Supreme Court Justice Edward H. Lehner cracked a joke while listening to oral arguments Thursday in a suit that could raise judicial salaries around the State.

“My daughter worked as a summer associate,” said Lehner. “She’s trying to get me a job there. I’d make more money.”

Ouch.

When the First National Bank of Criminal Law Closed Its Doors

Back in the old days, there was a bank just for criminal law.  It was used by prosecutors, defense lawyers and judges.  We did favors (called “contracts”) for one another from time to time, and the favors went into the bank.  

Some may remember a novel by Tom Wolfe, Bonfire of the Vanities, which talked about the bank and how contracts worked.  Tom learned about it from his good buddy Eddie Hayes, who was a criminal defense lawyer and former Bronx ADA.  Eddie and I were in the same office at the time, and Tom Wolfe would come around dressed all in white. 

Last night was the 40th birthday party for my former protégé’s wife, on a roof garden atop a Fifth Avenue penthouse in midtown.  The party was spectacular, the birthday girl looked fabulous.  I bring this up because the party was lousy with lawyers in general and criminal defense lawyers in particular.  Many were former Bronx ADAs, as was my young friend shortly before we started working together. 

Sitting there, enjoying the beautiful evening and magnificent views of the Empire State Building (and looking down into the windows of neighboring apartments to see if anything interesting was happening), we got to talking about how criminal law has changed over time.  Younger criminal defense lawyers cannot remember a time when the Supreme Court expanded rights, when judges didn’t universally find cops credible no matter how crazy their testimony, and when defendant were given a fair shot.

But not one of them knew what a contract was, or how you banked one or how you made a withdrawal.  The idea was totally foreign.  This was a shame.

When I started doing this, one of the first things you learned was the sanctity of a contract.  When you sought a favor, you owed it back.  If you didn’t pay on demand, your name was mud and no one would ever do you a favor again.  In fact, people would go out of their way to burn you.  It was a matter of internal honor.

I did a lot of favors for people back in those days.  I banked them.  I rarely had much need for favors in return, being a well-organized and somewhat compulsive type of lawyer, so that my account at the favor bank was pretty healthy.  One day this would come in handy.

Sometime back then, the bank quietly closed its doors.  It wasn’t FDIC insured.  It just disappeared.  And with it, my account.  I can’t quite tell when it happened.  I didn’t receive anything in the mail.  No phone call.  Just one day, no one seemed to know anything about it.  No longer did anyone talk about contracts.  They never even heard of them.  Talk about it and you got a blank stare in return.

I was telling stories about contracts to this groups of lawyers, sitting atop this tall building on a beautiful summer evening, and they couldn’t believe that there was a time when those of us who worked in criminal law were actually able to cooperate with each other.  They couldn’t fathom the existence of an unwritten honor code where we trusted each other to return the favor.  They couldn’t conceive of a virtual bank where our contracts were held, awaiting the day we needed a favor in return.

Much has been lost in this business over the years. 

An Early Morning Knock on the Door

One of the things that people find most shocking is how disrespectful police seem when they arrive to execute a search warrant.  It offends the dignity of the target.  It also protects the police from getting killed.  It’s left to a judge somewhere to decide where, along the spectrum of dignity and death, any particular entry should be.

When a judge signs a search warrant, it includes a line that either allows or forbids entry without notice.  A “no-knock” warrant permits the cops to break down the door with nary a howdy-do, and is supposed to be based upon a factual showing that the residents may present a risk of harm or destruction of evidence if they are given any heads-up at all, such as a knock on the door requesting that they open up and allow the police entry.

On the other side, absent a “no-knock” authorization, police must first give the residents notice of their presence and purpose, and thereby allow the residents the opportunity to open the door.  The police then show the warrant to the residents, who then stand aside and allow the cops an opportunity to do their job.

No-knock warrants became all the rage in the mid-1980s, as drugs became the focus of law enforcement.  The argument was that drug dealers were inherently violent, commonly possessed weapons and were invariably inclined to use the opportunity between the time of the first knock to the moment the door was broken open to dispose of narcotics in the toilet. 

Prior to this, no-knock warrants were considered quite extreme and contrary to appropriate police conduct.  But given the scourge of drugs, at least as perceived by the courts, every search warrant for drugs included the allegations, and most judges routinely permitted no-knock warrants based on such generalized allegations.  Almost all home warrants were executed at 6:30 a.m., the perfect witching hour when the occupants were still fast asleep and would be too groggy to think clearly when the boom on the door was heard.

Which brings us to Mike Cernovich’s post at Crime and Federalism about the 9th Circuits approval of the five second rule in Howell v. Polk .  In 2000, the same court held that 5 second was not long enough to allow the residents to wake up, open the door and permit the police entry to execute the warrant.  Not this time.

In Howell, the issue was put to a jury, as the issue arose in a 1983 action.  The jury found that the five seconds between the first knock and the police beginning to break down the door (as the door was a steel security door, it apparently took about 20-30 seconds before they were able to break it open) was sufficient.  Despite the fact that this was a determination by a jury, decisions like this return to haunt criminal suppression motions because they create a “rule” to be easily applied to other circumstances.

The per curiam opinion, with Chief Judge Alex Kozinski sitting in the big chair, is a curious exercise in sophistry.  Not because Judge Alex knows that it can take longer than five seconds to download a decent picture of naked women painted like cows when the server is busy, but because they engage in a post hoc balancing test of the reasonableness of the 5 second delay.

Judge Alex knows better.  He knows the process for determining and issuing a search warrant.  He knows that the warrant application includes (or not) a no-knock provision and is supposed to provide allegations of fact in support.  He knows the 4th Amendment requires that a neutral magistrate decide whether, and to what extent, to grant a search warrant.  He knows how it works.  And then he completely ignored it, circumvented it and undermined it in Howell.  You can’t play dumb when you’re a smart judge.

Each of the arguments proffered in Howell in support of waiting a mere 5 second, clearly not long enough to allow the occupants of a home to arouse from sleep, recognize that there is someone knocking on the door, put on appropriate attire, travel to the door and open it, are the same stuff that routinely (though wrongly) were used to rubber stamp the no-knock warrants of the old days. 

The Howell warrant was a knock and announce warrant.  Whether the cops sought a no-knock and it was refused, is unknown.  But a knock and announce was what they had in hand, and that was as far as their authority went.  If they wanted to crash through the door, they needed the approval of the issuing judge.  They didn’t have it.  This is not an “easier to ask for forgiveness than permission” opportunity.

The arguments made in favor of not waiting may well have been deemed entirely valid.  But that’s not the point.  These were arguments to be made to the issuing judge, not to some judges afterward.  The exercise of a search warrant is to obtain prior approval to enter someone’s home.  The time to make your pitch is before you break through the door, not after. 

While one could argue that this should have been a no-knock warrant for the reasons upheld by the Circuit, the fact remains that it wasn’t.  It was a knock and announce warrant, and a five second delay between knock and start breaking down the door is a sham.  And Judge Alex knows it, and voted to approve it anyway.

Scalia’s Emanations and Penumbras

Does Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia secretly read Justice William O. Douglas for inspiration late at night in the privacy of his bedroom?  It just may be, if David Kopel at VC is correct when he writes:

District of Columbia v. Heller clearly establishes self-defense (not just gun ownership for self-defense) as a constitutional right.

“Clearly establishes” is some strong language, and if true, opens some huge doors to criminal defense lawyers.  The more rights, the merrier as I always say.

Now I’ve read the Constitution, as well as the Bill of Rights, and I can’t remember anything mentioned about a right of self-defense.  But then, David’s not crazy.  There are no less than 86 references in the entire Heller opinion (including syllabus) to the “right to self-defense.”  Those words seem fairly clear, no?

Orin Kerr picked up immediately on David’s “clearly establishes” claim, and disagreed.  But after commenters referenced the pervasive use of the “right to self-defense” throughout the opinion, Orin found himself in a dilemma.   In a comment, he wrote:


I suppose that’s a possible reading, but doesn’t it seem unlikely that Justice Scalia would believe in a general constitutional right to self-defense founded in the emanations and penumbras of various textual constitutional provisions?  It seems like a rather un-Scalia-like reading of the opinion.

Note this comment, for it’s the first use of a significant rule of interpretation, the “un-Scalia-like reading” rule.  This will no doubt find its way into a footnote next term.

Eugene Volokh, ever the peacemaker, then jumped into the fray.  With a lengthy explanation, Eugene found himself on David Kopel’s side, constrained to accept the position that a right to self-defense has reared its ugly head historically and, given its flaunting by Scalia throughout Heller, seems destined to make its way into a full-fledged constitutional right.

So is there an unenumerated constitutional right to self-defense hiding beneath the Heller bedsheets?  And has Scalia secretly adopted the “emanations and penumbras” approach to constitutional interpretation when it serves some evil purpose?  Not likely.

Missing from the debate is any reference to natural law, which I find surprising for such an erudite group.  While I’m not a proponent of natural law in most instances, largely because it’s been stolen by people who want to replace it with their personal morality, there are some cases in which it holds great merit.  This is one of them.

There is no “law” more basic to the existence of humanity than survival.  It is a reflex, fight or flight.  We each do what we must to survive, and the notion that any human being would stand there and allow himself to be killed rather than do what is necessary to protect himself is so fundamental to our nature that any law or rule that would require otherwise violates our humanity. 

Sure, we have laws that suggest the contrary, like efforts to protect oneself from a good beating by the cops when lying on the ground cuffed and trying to get away from the flailing batons, the stomping boots, the clenched fists that follow “department policy” to subdue perps.  That’s called “aggressive behavior” by the perps, who are supposed to lay there and enjoy a good “tuning up” without attempting to block the crashing flashlight to the head lest the post hoc rationale for the beating enjoy some validity.  But I digress.

The Heller decision clearly invokes the right of self-defense, but it’s a right that all people inherently believe and accept to be their birthright, not something that any government can give or take away.  What is significant about its elusive head popping up in Heller is that it becomes available for use in court, rather than merely some unacknowledged though universally accepted, right in reality. 

Eugene properly notes that this right, when put to the test, has rational parameters.


Thus, a rule that one can only use deadly force to defend oneself against threats of death, serious bodily injury, rape, kidnapping, and a few other very serious threats would likely be constitutional (even though many states also allow use of deadly force to defend against robbery and in some situations burglary). Likewise, the “duty to retreat,” which is to say the principle that deadly force can only be used in self-defense if it’s genuinely necessary, in that no safe avenue of retreat is available, is likely to be constitutional, too, because it has long been recognized in at least a substantial minority of states. There may be other examples as well. My point is that a federal constitutional right to self-defense likely exists, especially in the wake of Heller; but it is not unlimited, and is likely to be strongest precisely where there’s a broad and deep common-law and statutory tradition of recognizing such a right.

While the edges of the right remain somewhat fuzzy, and people will argue about whether there is a duty to retreat, or how in the midst of a threat they are to have the ability to sit back, reflect and limit their natural self-defensive reaction so that it meets the expectation of some judge making sanitary decisions in the safety of a courtroom, the fact that it exists, it must exist and should be available as an assertion of right should a person’s self-defensive actions result in his ending up court some day adds an important enunciation of rights to our arsenal.

Justice Scalia’s opinion doesn’t make it new.  But it does make it real.  And it reminds us that there are some rights that exist even beyond the four corners of the Constitution.

Danger Jim Robinson — Making the Terror List

It’s always fun to learn that what goes around comes around.  This time, former Assistant Attorney General Jim Robinson, the top criminal prosecutor in the Clinton Department of Justice, learned that karma sucks.

From the New York Lawyer :

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department’s former top criminal prosecutor says the government’s terror watch list likely has caused thousands of innocent Americans to be questioned, searched or otherwise hassled. 

Former Assistant Attorney General Jim Robinson would know: he’s one of them.

Robinson joined another mistaken-identity American and the American Civil Liberties Union on Monday to urge fixing the list that’s supposed to identify suspected terrorists.

Isn’t it amazing how they only get religion after they leave DOJ?  Of course, with a name like Jim Robinson, it was only a matter of time before he was confused with some potential terrorist. 

While Robinson’s problems with the terrorist list didn’t start until long after he left Justice, thus putting him in the position of being personally affected by governmental over-reaching and abuse of basic civil rights, it’s not like similar challenges weren’t around in the 90s and routinely laughed away.  But now that it’s happening to Robinson, he’s become a voice of reform.

“It’s a pain in the neck, and significantly interferes with my travel arrangements,” said Robinson, the head of the Justice Department’s criminal division during the Clinton administration. He believes his name matches that of someone who was put on the list in early 2005, and is routinely delayed while flying — despite having his own government top-secret security clearances renewed last year.


Now Jim Robinson didn’t rise to the head of criminal prosecutions in Washington by being a dope.  He’s a smart guy.  He must have had some inkling that the sort of stuff they were doing in the name of law enforcement was “a pain in the neck” to innocent Americans back when he had his finger on the trigger. 

The difference, of course, was that when he was a government official making decisions about how much of a burden to place on the civil rights of Americans, he was more than happy to sacrifice our civil rights on his alter of law enforcement.  My, how the worm turns when even former DOJ bigwigs learn what life is like for real people.


“I suppose if I were convinced that America is a safer place because I get hassled at the airport, I might put up with it,” Robinson said. “But I doubt it.”

What?  No talking points to justify how it may not be perfect, but?


The government calls its watch list one of the most effective tools in its fight against terrorism. It was created after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks to consolidate 12 existing lists and make sure no terrorists slipped through the cracks — whether when entering the country or if otherwise stopped for questioning. Last year, congressional investigators found “general agreement that the watch list has helped to combat terrorism.”

Chad Kolton, a spokesman for the FBI’s Terrorist Screening Center that maintains the list, said the government is working to fix the gaps.

“We strive to have the watch list contain all appropriately suspected terrorists who represent a threat to the U.S., but only appropriately suspected terrorists,” Kolton said.

As long as our government is striving, aren’t you satisfied, Jim?  Or perhaps you’re beginning to realize how empty promises and vague press statements really don’t match up well with being the wrongfully named guy on a government list.

And for all our good friends in the Bush administration’s DOJ, your turn is coming very soon.  And if you think Jim Robinson got some karmic payback, I have two words for you:  water boarding.

Convictions Suspended Indefinitely

No, not the type that wrongfully put innocent people in prison.  Not even the type that put guilty people in prison.  This is about the  Convictions that made such a huge splash, with an all-star cast of writers, at Slate a mere four months ago.  It’s come and gone.


Convictions on Sabbatical


Over the past four months, Convictions has reached hundreds of thousands of readers and contributed a great deal to America’s legal conversation.  However, we have decided to take a sabbatical. Instead of running Convictions as a continuous blog, we’ll call on our excellent roster of contributors when news breaks, and run their exchanges as a multi-part conversation, as we do Dahlia Lithwick and Walter Dellinger’s Supreme Court conversation at the end of term. 


When Slate announced Convictions, it was an attempt to bring together the “biggest names” in the blawgosphere.  It was an interesting concept in an ever-evolving world.  But “interesting” doesn’t pay the bills.

When Slate was first announced to other blawgers by emails, I posted about it.  I went over there and read it.  I was bored and stopped reading it.

Convictions developed into a conversation between their various writers (or which there were many) debating issues of internal interest.  When I read a post, it made the post to which it responded seem fascinating and controversial.  When I read the original post, it just wasn’t. 

Unlike other blogs, Convictions kept its focus internal, not linking to outside blawgs or posts and debating internal issues until they were beaten beyond any recognition.  There’s a lesson there for all of us.  Beat a horse enough and no one will care anymore.

Orin Kerr, not merely a Volokh Conspirator but one of the Convictions all-starts, asked a few weeks later why no one reads Convictions.  This was my answer:


I took a look around Convictions today, just for kicks.  Man, those lawprofs are going after each other in that collegial way that only lawprofs can.  They’re smacking each other around like crazy.  Name calling, b-slapping, jello wrestling, you name it.

I’m serious.  Check this out,  Marty Lederman’s smackdown at Eric Posner :


With all respect, I think that post really is beyond the pale.

And that’s just the first line!  It’s like wild animal at the zoo day over there.

So what did Posner do to deserve this vicious attack?

Few pleasures are more intense than that of contemplating one’s ideological opponents being punished for their errors, an activity that we law professors have so far been able to indulge only in our fantasies. 

Indulge in their FANTASIES!!!!!  Gag me.  This is what gets lawprofs all hot and bothered?  Ewwww.

Check it out.  But remember, it doesn’t get any grittier than this.


If you ask me, we’ve all learned some lessons from this experiment.  First, even all-stars can be a bore if left to their own devices.  Second, I don’t think there can be any viable existence in the blawgosphere that doesn’t include a broad spectrum of voices in the conversation, at will, at random, sticking in the low-brow with the high-brow, and coming out with a sausage that may be ugly to watch being made but at least has some flavor. 

Convictions was tasteful and tasteless.  Its demise reminds me how much I appreciate the input of readers to keep the conversation alive.  And if anyone decides to try something like this again, they might want to include some real lawyers in the mix, even though we may be neither “aces” nor all-stars.  At least we tend to be interesting.

Bronx DA Subpoena Tries a Scam and Gets Caught

Some genius in Bronx District Attorney Rob Johnson’s office decided to try to play the subpoena game.  No, not the dreaded “office subpoena” this time, but a subpoena for the identity of an anonymous blogger who was posting about the close and loving relationship between the Bronx Republican and Democratic parties.  Who knew there was a Bronx Republican Party?  That must be one lonely office.

The subpoena was served on New York political blog Room Eight, and  the subpoena had a little twist.  It contained the statement

Subpoena from Robert Johnson

The only problem is that they can’t do that.  There is no law that allows the DA to order anyone to conceal the existence of such a subpoena.  And it certainly sounds like an order.   The DA’s spokesman, Steven Reed, also claimed “not uncommon for subpoenas to include nondisclosure language in order to protect an investigation.”  Nowhere do the words “pretty please” appear.  So he’s saying they break the law regularly?

To its enormous credit, Room Eight fought the subpoena and, as reported in the New York Times, Johnson’s office decided to “withdraw” it, which is code for ran away with its tail between its legs after it got caught abusing its power.  Again.

The New York Times reports this evening that a spokesman for the District Attorney – over whose name the original subpoena, dated last October, went out – says Johnson was “not aware that a subpoena was sent nor was he aware of the content of the comments, until after the subpoena was sent. The district attorney reviewed the matter, determined that a subpoena was not necessary at this time, and directed that it be withdrawn.”

So, let’s add up the issues.  Rob Johnson’s office abused its power.  Issued a subpoena with an unlawful command.  Rob Johnson knew nothing about it.  And rather than admit his error, claimed that it was “not necessary,” suggesting that his office issues unnecessary subpoenas.

All in all, it really doesn’t make the Bronx District Attorney’s office look particularly professional.

And, just to provide some contextual background to the situation, Room Eight graciously thanks its pro bono counsel, “talented, dynamic lawyer at the Public Citizen Litigation Group, Paul Alan Levy, a national expert on online free speech” and “our smart, thorough, generous, and knowledgeable local counsel — Charlie Spada and Deepa Rajan.”  But as noted, “not every blogger will be lucky enough to find pro bono counsel like ours, and few can afford to pay for lawyers.” 

Any chance these factors may have emboldened the Bronx DA to try to play fast and loose here?  Nah, they would never do that.  After all, the District Attorney is the good guy.

H/T Orin Kerr at VC