Author Archives: SHG

The Apple Didn’t Fall Far From Rudy’s Tree

My memories of Andrew Guiliani were of a pudgy little kid being a bit over-rambunctious at Donna Hanover’s feet during Rudy’s first inauguration as Mayor of New York.  The media tried to play it as little Andrew being cute.  I saw it as ironic, that Rudy tried to be the toughest hombre in New York but couldn’t control his own kid.

Year have passed since those playful days.  Donna’s been tossed aside for a newer model.  Rudy found out that he may have been “America’s Mayor” for his fifteen minutes after 9/11, but not even the Republicans want him to be America’s President.  And Andrew has become a young man.  Apparently an unpleasant young man.

When Newsday broke the story that Andrew had filed suit in federal court in North Carolina against Duke University for “canceling his eligibility” to play on the golf team, I felt badly for the kid.  It’s bad enough for a college kid to get thrown off the team, but to have everybody know about it is devastating.  But the details behind the Duke coach’s decision raised some old questions.


The lawsuit asserts Vincent said Guiliani, son of former New York City Mayor Rudolph Guiliani, tossed an apple at a teammate, hitting the side of his face, and that in a football game with golf teammates he “played harder than some of the other boys wanted to play.”

Included in the lawsuit is an e-mail to Guiliani from five teammates saying they no longer wanted him on the team.

“After careful consideration we have come to the unanimous decision that we wish that your involvement with the Duke Golf Team is terminated,” the e-mail says.

Too aggressive.  Violent tendencies.  Inappropriate behavior.  Doesn’t get along with others.  I wonder what caused young Andrew to behave this way?

An old saw is that if you want to know what a young woman will look like in 20 years, look at her mother.  It is similarly true for a young man, except as to his attitude and behavior.  Andrew Guiliani grew up cursed by a father whose success came by his overly-aggressive, usually inappropriate behavior.  It’s not that he is forced to suffer the consequences of his father’s mistakes, but that he has learned how to behave by emulating Rudy.  That’s usually the case for young men.  But unlike Rudy, who managed to situate himself in a place where his inappropriate behavior was hidden behind a prosecutor’s mantle, Andrew’s was exposed on the fairway. 

And like his famous father, Andrew appears to have taken no responsibility for his behavior.  A sincere apology and promise to behave more thoughtfully would have likely been sufficient to avoid being thrown off the golf team.  Instead, he sued:


“I just want to make sure this doesn’t happen to anyone else,” Guiliani said.

Not much of a reason, since Rudy doesn’t have any other children.

The questions raised by Andrew’s ouster from the Duke golf team really aren’t about Andrew at all.  Granted, at 22, he’s old enough to recognize that he needs to get along with others, even in golf, if he wants to be accepted as part of a team.  But the lessons he learned in how to do so were at the knee of Rudy many years before. 

What we see is the real Rudy, the inside as shown through the prism of Andrew, without the handlers and PR shills covering up Rudy’s ugly persona, sans comb-over, to make him more appealing to voters.  Rudy’s son has grown up just like him, which reminds me of a song.

Judge John Gleeson’s Moral Compass

Criminal defense lawyers don’t always have kind words for prosecutors.  But United States District Court Judge John Gleeson of the Eastern District of New York could make me eat my words.  Judge Gleeson, who went from Southern District superstar mob prosecutor straight to the bench, has proven to one the finest and most thoughtful judges around. 

His decision this week in McKithen v. Brown (via Volokh) demonstrates Judge Gleeson’s commitment to the integrity of the criminal justice system rather than slavish adherence to procedural rules that would leave innocent people imprisoned.  As Eugene Volokh notes (including his parenthetical), this is the bottom line:

The Petition Clause … secures a right of meaningful access to whatever avenues remain [after normal appeals have been exhausted, avenues that include a clemency petition -EV], and the Due Process Clause confers a procedural right of access to evidence for DNA testing, if the testing can be accomplished at little cost and exculpatory results would undermine confidence in the outcome of the trial.

Big deal, you say?  Why should I be fawning over a decision that allows a convicted defendant, years later and following exhaustion of the normal processes, access to physical evidence to perform DNA testing?  Because this decision stares down those habeas decisions that would deny an innocent person the opportunity to prove his innocence because of judicial inconvenience.  There are a long line of judicial excuses/explanations to justify depriving a defendant who claims actual innocence the ability to prove it, and even the ability to get before a judge to make the pitch. 

The courts have elevated their procedural niceties over the actual innocence of human beings to keep the cases flowing smoothly.  While this is how one keeps the trains running on time, it does little to fulfill the promise of justice that permeates our legal platitudes. 

John Gleeson has a moral compass.  He has shown it many times  before and now he shows it again.  Like the judge whose seat he filled, Jack Weinstein, he has shown no fear when it comes to fulfilling our highest expectations of the judiciary. 


An overriding concern for innocence is a central preoccupation of our constitutional tradition. See, e.g., Winship, 397 U.S. at 363 (“The standard [of proof beyond a reasonable doubt] provides concrete substance for the presumption of innocence — that bedrock axiomatic and elementary principle whose enforcement lies at the foundation of the administration of our criminal law.” (internal quotation marks omitted)); id. at 372 (Harlan, J., concurring) (“[I]t is far worse to convict an innocent man than to let a guilty man go free.”); McKithen VII, 481 F.3d at 91-92 (“‘[O]ur procedure has been always haunted by the ghost of the innocent man convicted . . . .’” (quoting United States v. Garson, 291 F. 646, 649 (S.D.N.Y. 1923) (Hand, J.))). Furthermore, “‘[f]reedom from bodily restraint has always been at the core of the liberty protected by the Due Process Clause from arbitrary governmental action.’” Foucha v. Louisiana, 504 U.S. 71, 80 (1992) (quoting Youngberg, 457 U.S. at 316). It might then seem natural that inmates retain a liberty interest in being released from custody, conditioned on their innocence.

For many, it will come as a bit of a surprise that a judge is constrained to explain why actual innocence matters.  To you, I say welcome to criminal law, especially in the federal courts.  Not only does John Gleeson write that innocence matters, but he backs it up with his ruling.  That doesn’t happen often.

By way of explanation as to why this particular decision matters, since it addresses 11th hour efforts to prove innocence and hence comes at the very back end of the system that most people believe already provides a defendant with huge (even excessive) opportunity to prevail, here’s why.  The assemblage of rules and rights that constitute the myth of criminal law simply don’t happen the way most people think.  While all the right words are uttered, rarely does the process happen in a way that fulfills the rhetoric. 

The result is that we continually find, many years later, that our beloved system made a mistake and that an innocent person spent the better (worse?) part of their life in prison for a crime they did not commit.  Judge John Gleeson ruled that due process trumps the grocery clerk’s list of rules.  And that’s why this decision matters.

Lori Drew Dismissal Motion: Is It Enough?

The death of teenager Megan Meier at the prodding of adult Lori Drew is a sad allegory for our time.  There can be no one who isn’t deeply saddened by what happened, though it’s questionable whether anyone has yet learned a lesson from Lori Drew’s conduct.

But once Missouri mom Lori Drew was indicted in California for violating the  Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 USC §1030, we left the realm of techno-morality and entered a twisted world of criminalizing  behaviors so common as to make almost all computer users criminals.  No one. of course, plans to arrest people as they type happily away on their keyboards, but should the indictment against Lori Drew stand, the government will have the ability to do so should someone be disturbed by the product of people’s computer.

Lori Drew’s lawyer, Dean Steward, has moved to dismiss the indictment, per the Wall Street Journal Law Blog and the Washington Post.  Orin Kerr had a pro bono finger in the motion as well.  The WSJ includes pdf links to the moving papers:

Here are the three motions to dismiss for: failure to state an offense, vagueness and unconstitutional delegation of prosecutorial power.

Rather than a single motion, the attack consists of three independent sets of papers attacking the indictment.  According to Steward, the most significant motion is the attack for vagueness:


In its 22-year history, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act has never before been used to criminally punish the violation of a website Terms of Service. The government’s novel theory is that the statute prohibits the violation of essentially all Terms of Service [hereinafter TOS] that apply to essentially all computers connected to the Internet.

As a matter of statutory construction, the government’s farreaching argument is either right or wrong. In either case, however, the indictment must be dismissed. If the government’s statutory construction is wrong, the statute did not reach Lori Drew’s conduct and the indictment must be dismissed because the crime has not been committed. If the government’s statutory construction is correct and the statute criminalizes violating a website TOS, then the statute is void for vagueness because it fails to provide warning of what is prohibited and ensures discriminatory enforcement under City of Chicago v. Morales 527 U.S. 41, 56 (1999).

The gist of the government’s theory is that Drew, by creating and using a false persona on MySpace, violated the MySpace terms of service.  The elements of the violation are:


♦ intentionally accessing a computer
♦ without authorization or exceeds authorization
♦ and obtains information
♦ from a protected computer
♦ involving interstate or foreign commerce

Because her use of MySpace violated the TOS, she is alleged to have intentionally accessed the MySpace server without authorization.


Nowhere in the statute is the term “unauthorized” defined. The government claims that a violation of the TOS makes access unauthorized, and therefore criminal. Surely the government will concede that, standing alone, a violation of a TOS is not a criminal act. The government’s theory in the indictment fails to set out how the next step, from TOS violation to §1030 criminal law violation, occurs.

Basing a lack of authorization on a violation of TOS presents multiple problems. Are all TOS violations enough to render the accessing unauthorized, or only material breaches? Must the terms of the TOS be reasonable? What if these terms are racist, illegal themselves or call for violence? Does the violation of such TOS’s still render access unauthorized? These questions render the term “unauthorized” hopelessly vague.

The government’s employment of a website’s TOS as the basis for a federal crime implicates some very big picture issues.  The motion to dismiss, unfortunately, addresses them more as minor technicalities than fundamental flaws, rather nit-picky than conceptually vapid.  Given the novel nature of this prosecution, combined with the vast implications of making a substantial chunk of the population susceptible to criminal prosecution, I would have hoped for a far broader approach.

The questions posed to suggest that the term “unauthorized” is “hopelessly vague” are a reach.  The first two questions need not be answered in this case, and show why facial challenges usually fail.  The next two questions are purely hypothetical and unripe for adjudication.  By posing their attack in this fashion, I fear that they have given the judge an easy out to leave these questions for another day and another case, where these issues actually arise.  Judges are appropriately reluctant to rule on theoretical issues.

But what troubles me is that the argument, that the intentional violation of the TOS renders access unauthorized, and unauthorized access falls within the ambit of §1030, is barely addressed in the motion.  Steward’s argument is that “[s]urely the government will concede that, standing alone, a violation of a TOS is not a criminal act.”  But of course, this didn’t stand alone, but was used to intentionally cause harm to another, resulting in death.  The defense has opened the door to being slam-dunked on the point.

The fundamental flaw in the government’s theory is indeed what constitutes lack of authorization, and the flaw is that user terms of service cannot constitute the basis for lack of authorization under the statute.  By analogy, the distinction is between someone being invited to a party and behaving poorly, as opposed to someone crashing the party.  The terms of service are precatory; sufficient to ask someone to leave the party but insufficient to deem their presence criminal.  To reach the level of criminal, there must be an independent wrong committed, regardless of that fact that they were invited into the party, that would be wrong whether there were terms of service or not. 

The motion to dismiss for failure to state an offense includes one prong that is very significant: That there is no allegation of fact that Drew (or her co-conspirators) read or knew of the terms of service.  While ignorance of the law is not excuse, ignorance of the TOS may well be.  The government has addressed this by alleging that the TOS were readily available for Drew to read.  So is the Library of Britain, but that doesn’t mean we are all responsible for knowing its contents.  This element has far-reaching implications for all computer users as well, since few (if any) of us actually read any website’s TOS, and the potential that we be held criminally liable for our failure to write “please” before any request is absurd.

While many will quietly hope that Lori Drew gets nailed for what happened to Megan Meier, the idea that almost every computer user is turned into a criminal in the process is at stake in this indictment.  As horrible as Lori Drew may be, this indictment is not the cure. 

It’s simply unclear from my reading of the motions to dismiss whether Steward has mounted an argument that will prevail.  For the sake of all of us, I hope he does.  But I fear that his motion falls short. 

Safer or Sicker: A Peek into your Neighbor’s Lives

A reader sent me a head’s up the other day about a new website that purports to allow you to learn about a person’s criminal history or just search your neighborhood to see who’s been busted for what.  Appropriately named criminalsearches.com, I held off posting about it until I checked it out to see if it was real.  There have been some spoof sites that claimed the same, and I’m dumb enough to fall for them.

Well, this is the real McCoy.

It begs some questions.  Is this reliable?  Does it smear the innocent along with the guilty?  My understanding is that the content is derived from governmental sources, and we all know how reliable that can be.  The government is never wrong.  Except when it’s wrong.  And what about showing arrests that resulted in acquittals or dismissals?  Experience with government databanks is that bad news goes in, but good news rarely comes out.  It’s just not worth the government’s effort to clean up the mess.

With the foregoing in mind, what does this information provide to the public?  The depth of the information is, as would be expected, negligible.  Some numbers and the name of the offense, in the lingo of the charging authority, but nothing about the underlying crime.  In the absence of information, most people are inclined th fear the worst.  This could impact block parties.

As people check out their neighbors and their kids, their children’s dates and their parents, the teachers at school and the classmates, will it be voyeurism or security?  Will word spread like wildfire about the sex offender and the thief, so people can point and whisper as they walk into the room?  What about the speeder, or the DUI?  How evil are they really?

As I maneuvered around the website, I found myself checking out my neighborhood, and a few particular people I know, just for fun.  And that’s when I realized, that checking criminal histories of people you know “for fun” was a sick thing to do.  These are real people, and here I’ve objectified them, not as sex objects but crime objects.  It adds nothing to my knowledge of who to deal with, but was titillating knowing who had a record and kinda for what.  It’s different when you know who the people are.  I was not pleased with myself.

We are an information society, expecting to find anything about anyone at anytime.  Yet it adds so little to our understanding.  Like Oscar Wilde’s cynic, we know the price of everything and value of nothing.

This is a bad website.  But it’s real, and it’s here, and that’s that.  There is no way to get the genie back in the bottle.

Promises of Privacy Give Way to the Cops (Update)

The story of former Cravath Swain attorney, James Colliton, isn’t going to generate enormous sympathy.  After all, the 44 year old Colliton, married and father of 5, was nailed for bedding a pair of underage girls.  If it makes anyone feel better, he received 3 concurrent one year sentences after a plea, and was released almost immediately as he already had 19 months inside.

But as is so often the case, out of ugly cases comes issues that have far broader significance, and this is true for Colliton who has sued American Express.  Not surprisingly, the New York Post headline sums up the simpleton’s view of the lawsuit: NERVY PERV SUES AMEX.  For the Post, “nervy pervs” get a different set of rights than their vision of good people.


Using your American Express card to go on the lam? Priceless. Getting turned in by American Express? That’ll be $4.9 million.

You’ve got to admit, it’s cute.  But the nature of his suit is far more serious than the headline suggests.  It seems that Colliton was caught in Canada by police who tracked him down through his use of his Am Ex card, an endeavor in which American Express happily cooperated.  Remember all that “we respect your privacy” crap and “we will keep your personal information private?”  All true, unless a cop asks.  Then Am Ex will tell them anything about you they want to know.  Some privacy, huh?

Walter Olson at Overlawyered  Michael Krauss at Point of Law, via Walter Olson, questions whether the Am Ex agreement stands in the way of the charge card company being a laboring oar in the enforcement of law and the capture of fugitives.


We haven’t seen his contract with Amex, but doubt that it obliges the company to resist requests from law enforcement.”

It’s curious that Walter Michael Krauss asks the question that way.  Obliged to resist?  It presumes the default position to be “happily provide the confidential information of its customers to law enforcement upon request.”  I can’t see the next great Am Ex commercial telling us, “Hey, use Am Ex and we’ll spill our guts to any cop who wants to know about you!”  Not a compelling pitch.

For the common person (the very, very common person), the idea that when a cop asks, you answer doesn’t strike them as an inappropriate proposition.  Submission to the shield is a pervasive theme.  Cops know it and depend upon it.  It helps them to do their job, and one can hardly blame cops for taking advantage. 

But the flip side is that most of us would like some modicum of privacy in our personal lives.  We want to believe all these corporate come-ons that they really do respect our privacy and really will keep our personal information confidential.  We need to trust them. 

I can hear Walter Michael Krauss whispering in my ear, “Oh yeah?  So what are they supposed to do to find this mutt who likes little girls?”  The answer is simple.  Get a warrant.  Show a neutral magistrate that there is sufficient cause to believe that the target has committed a crime and that the confidential information is really needed and its disclosure is appropriate.

What is not good enough is that an entity who has assured us of our confidentiality will immediately bend to the will of the cops for the mere asking.  Sure they are tough with us when we want to dispute a charge, but they are jelly in the hands of anyone who says his title is Detective.  And don’t think this is just about Am Ex.  Do you think Visa or Mastercard are any different?  Or any of the other businesses that collect your personal information?  They all fawn when law enforcement calls. 

Since this action is brought by Colliton, the nervy perv, it will be subject to ridicule and derision.  Few will stand up for the rights of a man who likes little girls.  But while we may care nothing for James Colliton personally, the action is about everyone else’s rights as well, the good, the bad and the ugly.  And it’s usually the ugly that does the dirty work to protect our rights.  Never forget that.

Update:  When I referenced Walter Olson’s post at Overlawyered, I failed to note that almost the entire post was taken from a Michael Krauss post at Point of Law, so all references to Walter should have been to Michael.  While I apologized to Walter for the mis-attribution (though the mistake would have been avoided had the quote been blocked, but that doesn’t change my fault), it seems that Ted Frank, also of Overlawyered, is deeply troubled by my failure to change the body.  I have no idea if this bothered Walter, but it was disturbing enough to Ted that he stopped reading the National Enquirer or bashing lawyers to come over here and give me a piece of his mind (see comment below).

So now I’ve done so, special for Ted.  Ted is very special here, and we do everything we can to keep Ted from being sad.

Bad Court Thingy Explains the Screwed Pooch Thingy

A few days ago, I took issue with some comments around the blawgosphere from Gen Y (“Y” for whiners).  I’ve been accused of harping on the subject, as some don’t like to hear anything beyond how special they are, and perhaps the subject has been beaten to death around here.  But a post at Bad Court Thingy, responding to my geriatric vitriol, was just so good that it warranted one more post.

Before getting to the beef, there’s one thing about Bad Court Thingy that demands note:  The name.  Where did this seemingly bizarre name for a blog come from, asks the silly old man.  The explanation:



The Simpsons were a big and probably unhealthy influence to me growing up. There’s a good chance that explains what’s wrong with my generation. Lionel Hutz, the sleazy attorney was always one of my favorite secondary characters on the show. The title of my blog comes from an exchange between Hutz and Judge Synder, from the Marge In Chains episode.


Hutz: And so, ladies and gentleman of the jury I rest my case.
Judge: Hmmm. Mr. Hutz, do you know that you’re not wearing any pants?
Hutz: DAAAA!! I move for a bad court thingy.
Judge: You mean a mistrial?
Hutz: Right!! That’s why you’re the judge and I’m the law-talking guy.
Judge: You mean the lawyer?
Hutz: Right.


The Simpsons.  Could it get any more Gen Y than that?

So BCT, painting me as Mr. Wilson (do they know who Mr. Wilson is?), so prune-like and cantankerous as to delight in  “telling the neighborhood kids they can’t have their Frisbee back” while listening to my Victrola (did they ever play Stairway to Heaven on a turntable?), explains the world.


First up, we’re [the] product of feel-good, Boomer parents. We’ve been raised by children of the sixties and Sesame Street and Mr. Rogers Neighborhood to believe that our happiness is the most important thing in the whole wide world, and if something doesn’t make you happy, it’s not worth doing. We’ve been told how special and unique each one of us is, and we can do anything we want.

Guilty.  When you were very little, and afraid that you couldn’t kick the ball as far or as hard as little Jimmy, we didn’t want you to cry and run away.  We wanted to encourage you to keep trying, to be the best Little Bad Court Thingy you could be. 

But we never told you that if it didn’t make you happy, it wasn’t worth doing.  We wanted you to keep trying, not give up.  You got the message wrong.  But this was our fault, since so many of you got the same message.  So it is our fault for sending the wrong message.  But you were only six years old then.  We thought you would grow up eventually.


Then, throw in our consumer culture. I have no idea if our society has always placed such a high value on material goods, probably not to the extent it does now. From shows like MTV Cribs and My Sweet 16 and fashion magazines, our media is sending the message that unless you have the best house/car/clothes/gadgets/party, you’re worthless.

Guilty.  We didn’t have “things” like this when we were young.  They didn’t exist.  Or if they did, our parents, products of the war and perhaps even the depression, were too frugal to buy us trinkets.  We saw things as they were invented that we thought were cool, and swore that someday, when we had kids, we would give them the things that our parents denied us.  So we did.  And it gave rise to the consumer culture that now permeates society, and is causing us such distress as people sacrifice their financial security to buy stuff for themselves, their kids, and, mostly, proof of their existence. 

The irony of the consumer economy is that the 60s was a time of anti-materialism.  We rejected our parents desperate need to show their financial stability through a shiny new car and the house in the suburbs.  But as we grew up, and had children who demanded meal after meal, and who only seemed to smile when we bought them a new toy (and we so dearly wanted our children to smile), we fell right back into the parent trap.


Real life, however, does not care if what you’re supposed to do makes you happy. Real life doesn’t care if your billable hours are making you depressed. And therein lies the first problem, we’ve been told if it doesn’t make us happy, its not worth doing. But if not having the latest iPhone (which I really want) means you’re not the cool kid on the block, then what do you do?

The simple answer is, you suck it up and play the game. 

Exactly.  That’s the point.  No, neither Little Jimmy nor Little Bad Court Thingy are going to be TV stars or the president or get to sit in front of a Wii and have BMWs magically appear outside their door.  Our day will be over soon.  We’re getting older and you are coming into your own.  We may not like the idea of handing over the reins, but it’s going to happen no matter what.

We thought you would watch us and understand that there’s a lot of life that sucks.  It always has, and success is understanding that it will be a struggle, that there will be accomplishments and setbacks, but that you still have to keep pushing through.  Ten percent inspiration and 90% perspiration. 

What we never expected was that you would take Mr. Rogers seriously.  It was a kids show, a young kids show at that.  We thought it was fine for the age, but that you would grow out of it. 


So why isn’t Generation Y convinced that partnership is next to godliness, why isn’t there any loyalty to the firms that gave these young attorneys a job? Because we’ve watched what has happened to our parents generation. Jobs have been cut, downsized, rightsized, outsourced, and every other euphemism for being fired. Maybe this is just me because I grew up in the Rust Belt, but I’ve seen it way too often. People getting fired who did everything they were supposed to do. Go to college, get a useful degree, be a loyal company man or woman; and then get told we’re paying you too much, we can hire 3 people right out of college for what we pay you. Assuming they’re not shipping your job to India.

Again, true.  But this was part of the lesson that life was difficult and unfair.  Do everything “right” and there’s still no guarantee that you get the gold watch at the end.  We wanted to teach you that if the going gets tough, the tough get going.  Instead, you learned to quit and whine about it.  So our message didn’t get across very well.


My take on it all is this. Very few people are truly happy at their jobs. I’m actually a little suspicious of any lawyer who says they love what they do. But at some point, you make a decision. You either find take a job that keeps you financially comfortable and hope your soul doesn’t rot away. Or, take the chance and do something you really want to do. My generation needs to realize that the Boomers are still running the show, and ultimately they’re the ones setting the rules, for now. Yeah, not getting the BMW right away might suck (I’d rather have a Cadillac myself). Wearing a suit isn’t always fun. But those are the rules as they stand right now.

Not everyone is treated like garbage.  Somebody gets to sit in the corner office.  We wanted to make you strong and independent, capable of being the one to grab that golden ring.  We wanted you to want the BMW, but expected that it would be the incentive for you to work hard, achieve and earn it for yourself.  We thought you would have a wonderful childhood, but that eventually you would grow up and come to terms with reality.

For too many, they have rejected reality and thrown a temper tantrum.  We’re not going to play. Waahhh.  It’s too hard.  Waaahhhh.  It’s not fair.  Waaahhhh.  But you are correct, the message we hoped to teach was not communicated properly, and you received the wrong one.  That’s our fault.

But now you are grown up.  To the extent the boomers failed to deliver, get over it.  Who do you plan to whine to when we’re gone?  We won’t be there to wipe your noses or your bottoms, so you better be able to wipe them yourselves.



But Boomers, be nice to us. We’ll be picking out your nursing homes.


We may have been too nice to you.  And you will have the opportunity to pay us back one day.  Our biggest fear isn’t that you will put us in some disgusting nursing home, but that there won’t be anyone operating nursing homes because you will all be sitting in your childhood bedrooms playing computer games, waiting for mom to bring you an afternoon snack.

Boomers wanted their kids to succeed, to be more brilliant, more successful, happier than we were.  We did something very wrong, but now it’s up to our children to overcome our indulgent child-rearing and figure out how to accomplish goals for themselves.  Whining, complaining, demanding, tattooing, piercing, quitting isn’t going to do it.  You have the tools to succeed.  Use them.  Despite us.

Blawg Review from the Trenches (Update)

It occurred to me yesterday that the anonymous Ed. of Blawg Review fame pressed me into service in a moment of weakness to host Blawg Review #170.  Uh oh.  This places me in the difficult, if not untenable, position of coming up with something thoughtful and or witty.

There have been masterful Blawg Reviews from the past, with Anne Reed at Deliberations and Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law standing out in my mind, as well as fellow criminal defense lawyers Jamie Spencer and Gideon.  Colin Samuels is the epitome of a Blawg Reviewdom, having followed Dante’s trilogy of the Inferno, the Purgatorio and the Divine Comedy.  As proof of Colin’s exceptionally good taste, Simple Justice wasn’t mentioned in any of his Reviews.

So now, I beg the aid of others.  Certainly nothing I produce will compare favorably with the great Blawg Reviews that came before, but I’m desperately hopeful not to embarrass myself with the singularly most pathetic Blawg Review ever.  Unlike the genius (not to mention far better read) Colin, I have absolutely no clue how I will approach this endeavor.  The anonymous Ed. is nowhere to be found.  Turk has offered some very useful advice, though it involves my getting arrested immediately so that I can live-blog my way through processing.

Please don’t let me crash and burn.  Submit your favorite posts to Blawg Review or send me an email.  And I’m sure that whatever theme I come up with at the last moment, I’ll come up with a better idea the next day.  Thanks to all in advance for your help.

Update:  This from Colin Samuels at Infamy or Praise :


Next week’s Blawg Review will be hosted by another rapidly-rising brand, Scott Greenfield’s Simple Justice blog. Greenfield’s commentary is consistently amongst the most intelligent and engaging in the legal blogosphere. I know that I’m not alone in my eager anticipation for next week’s edition of the carnival of legal blogging.

I am so dead.

What Happens When You’re Run Down by Former DA Pirro?

It seems that former Westchester County District Attorney Jeanine Pirro has a nasty habit of getting herself into awkward situations.  It’s not easy being a shrill “tough on crime” voice when you get involved in wiretapping with Bernie Kerik while running for Senate, or just hanging out at home with your felon, cheating husband.  So who can blame her when she runs some poor fellow down and the cops doctor the police reports to make her involvement disappear?

Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Blog has done a journalistic mitzvah reporting the story of Harley-owner Scott Lieberman, who just had the pleasure of cashing a check for $200,000 to cover the injuries when he was sideswiped by Pirro’s SUV.  Now there’s nothing terrible about having an accident, but as with everything else Pirro, a simple accident turned awkward.

While the officer on the scene first reported a collision between Pirro’s SUV and Scott Lieberman riding his Harley, that report was subsequently deep-sixed after the officer saw Jeanine Pirro in the back and saw that the SUV was owned by her husband. The second accident report didn’t have the Pirro vehicle in the accident. According to this New York Post story at the time:

Lieberman said that after talking to Horgan, cops stopped writing a two-vehicle accident report and started one saying he skidded off the road on his own. “Investigation reveals no other veh. involved in accident,” the final report reads.

According to an interview I conducted with Lieberman’s counsel, Harlan Wittenstein, a copy of the original police report indicating a collision was given to Lieberman’s ex-girlfriend who had been riding ahead and saw the accident in her rear-view mirror as she pulled up to a stop light. The original report clearly has Al Pirro’s name on it as the vehicle owner. The subsequent police report only claimed a motorcyclist down with no contact and no Pirro name. The two reports are here: Lieberman.pdf

After learning the Pirros were involved, the police accused Lieberman of being a fraud as he was writhing in agony. Lieberman, who was taken to the hospital and needed surgery to fix his broken ankle, didn’t take kindly to the accusation.

It’s like magic.  First Lieberman was run down by Pirro.  Then there was no Pirro involved at all.  Poof.  Naturally, the police officer who exercised discretion by omitting the Pirro involvement from the doctored report suffered no ill-effects.

One might ask, why should the Pirros be blamed when it was the cop who doctored the reports?  Because Jeanine Pirro, who never shied away from the limelight when accusing others of wrongdoing, was happy enough to stand by while the cop “fixed” the problem.  Had she stepped forward and admitted her role, then the fault would rest solely on the cop, if indeed the cop would have done anything wrong in the absence of a little encouragement.

But Jeanine, Ms. Law & Order, was happy to hide behind the fictitious report and conceal the fact that she was involved in running Lieberman down.  The Pirros have a funny thing about how right and wrong is only for the little people.

The SUV in which Jeanine was riding was owned by hubby Al, who has had some problems of his own:

Al Pirro — a disbarred real estate attorney who was convicted of 66 counts of tax fraud, whose license has been suspended (and reinstated), has been embroiled in head-line grabbing extramarital affairs, and generally been a burden to his wife’s ambitions — is no doubt happy to get at least one legal problem behind him.

The good news is that the People of New York somehow managed to avoid electing Jeanine to the position of senator or attorney general in the midst of this, and she’s been relegated to TV judge, a pale copy of Judge Judy.  Jeanine has always been good for entertainment, though rarely in the way she intends.

Are Lawyers Stealing From the (not so) Poor?

David Giacalone at f/k/a has deconstructed the practice of lawyers who sell their services to people who are financially drowning with the promise that they can save them “up to” 50% by negotiating down their debt.  We’ve all seen the TV commercials, noticeably more prominent in this time of recession economic downturn, holding out the promise of staving off bankruptcy and financial ruin.

While the smiling faces seem kind and sincere, and the possibility of avoiding disaster from profligate spending is certainly alluring, David has taken a hard look at the underbelly of this practice.  And it’s not a very pretty sight. 

David specifically looked at a for-profit entity called NetDebt:

I first heard of NetDebt on June 9th, when they tried to plant a link from f/k/a to their affiliated weblog, in order to increase NetDebt’s online profile. When the Comment showed up for “moderation,” my response was: “I just looked at your ‘NetDebt’ web site and have many questions about your services — especially the fees. Until I get a chance to review it more fully, I do not want a link from this weblog to yours, and have removed your URL.”

Having now looked more deeply into NetDebt, I want to present my continuing concerns about their fees — which are 15% of the amount of debt you bring to their program (regardless of results or the number of creditors it must deal with), plus a “small” monthly service fee of $50.

The fee structure has a few interesting features.  First, it’s a flat fee based upon a percentage of outstanding debt, so that it bears no relation to the scope or depth of services to be provided.  Whether the debt is owed to one lender or 50, the fee is the same. 

Second, it is not a contingency fee.  It’s 15% of the debt, win, lose or draw.  If they accomplish nothing, obtain no reduction and leave the client in precisely the same position as when then came in, they still get 15% of the amount of the debt.  Third, it’s front loaded, meaning that client has taken 15% that could have been used to pay off the debt and given it to the debt negotiation lawyer instead.  David runs through the fee issues at far greater length and detail.

Then comes the big question, what service is provided for this fee. 


Here’s how NetDebt describes its services in its FAQ :



“What does “debt settlement” mean? The term ‘debt settlement’ means negotiating with a creditor to reduce the amount of a delinquent debt down to a lower amount, that the debtor can then pay in order to fully satisfy (or pay off) the debt. The primary benefits of this strategy are to help you become debt free sooner, pay your debts on terms structured to your specific budget, avoid bankruptcy, and pay less than you would by making the minimum monthly payments.”


. . . “Once you enroll in the program, you will immediately stop paying your creditors, and instead start putting your monthly payments into a Trust Account the is established by the law firm. From that point on, the attorneys take over everything. Since your creditors will not be receiving monthly payments, your accounts will become past due, but in a controlled environment.”


. . . Once there is sufficient funds in your account, the lawyers will settle with the first creditor, and that process will continue until [you settle all accounts and your balance is zero].


There are only two major problems with this concept.  First, there is no guarantee that creditors will settle for anything less than the full amount, together with interest that accrues while the debtor isn’t paying them and the attorney is holding the money.  Second, there is nothing being done that a debtor couldn’t do on his own.  If the debtor is sued by the creditor, NetDebt doesn’t defend.  It’s a phone call.

I hadn’t given much thought to debt settlement practices since the days of Andrew Capoccia, a disgraced lawyer whose debt settlement practice gave rise to a huge scandal.

Capoccia charged what he called a “small part” of the savings (25 to 27%). His massive advertising campaign was aimed at people with significant unsecured debt, who wanted to avoid bankruptcy — and who had enough money to afford his fees. Capoccia took his fees upfront, before starting “negotiation” with creditors. Negotiation amounted to sending form letters and making phone calls requesting a large reduction in the client’s debt, while withholding payments and hinting at bankruptcy to increase leverage over creditors.

So what’s wrong with all this?  Debt settlement lawyers prey upon desperate people, charging fees that are grossly disproportionate to the negligible services provided, guaranteeing that they get paid up front while providing slick suggestions but no assurances that they will accomplish anything on behalf of the clients.  In the process, they destroy their clients credit by withholding payments, take monies that would otherwise be used to pay down the debt and provide a service that the client could accomplish on his own with a little guidance.

While this niche practice will no doubt bring a handful of lawyers a lot of money in this recession difficult economic time, it feeds into the public’s disgust for the profession.  And with good reason.  David’s done a great job of shedding light on this practice, and hopefully will save people with enough problems from one more.

An Originalist’s View of the Exclusionary Rule

Not being particularly adept at Originalist rationales, nor sufficiently versed in American constitutional history, the open wound left by Liptak’s ill-conceived article requires a far more scholarly analysis than I could provide.  So I thanked my lucky stars that Orin Kerr decided to step up to the plate and swing.

Over at Volokh, Orin has hit a home run with his analysis of the exclusionary rule, from a historical originalist context, and made a great argument in favor of the judge-made remedy being fully consistent with how the founding fathers would have addressed the issue.


 It is widely agreed that at common law, the primary way of enforcing search and seizure rules was through civil trespass suits. There were no professional police in those days, but agents of the King could get a warrant permitting them to lawfully search a home for a warrant. If an agent of the King broke into your house and searched it without a valid warrant, your remedy was to sue the agents for trespass into your home.

Critics of the exclusionary rule generally rely on this history to say that the U.S. Supreme Court invented the exclusionary rule out of thin air. The exclusionary remedy is not found or hinted at in the common law trespass cases, the argument runs, and it does not appear in the Constitution itself.

But early warrants permitted only the search and seizure of contraband, not evidence.  Thus, if evidence was seized, it was seen as “stolen” by the King’s agent and the remedy would be its return.  Upon its return, it would not be available as evidence against the person from whom it was “stolen” and, in that respect, suppressed.


Thats’ just what happened in Weeks v. United States, 232 U.S. 383 (1914), the case that is generally understood as having introduced the exclusionary rule. The police in Weeks broke into Weeks’s home without a warrant and took his papers away. Although the timing of events isn’t exactly clear, Weeks was charged with a crime based on the papers and he filed suit seeking return of the papers on the ground that the government had no right to possess them. That is, Weeks wasn’t seeking “suppression” of the evidence: He was seeking a return of his stuff that the government had unlawfully stolen from him. The trick was that by getting the property back, Weeks could keep it away from the government: The government needed to possess the property to move for its admission in court.

See?  The exclusionary rule isn’t just the only remedy with any potential to have an impact on the cops, but one that an originalist can love.

And as long as we’re on the subject, bear in mind that the rule protects the innocent as well as the guilty.  How many people are subject to unconstitutional searches where nothing is found and they are sent on their way?  These people never show up in anyone’s statistics, because “nothing happened” that doesn’t end up in a prosecution.  Without a hard incentive to comply with the Constitution, there is nothing to stop cops from searching and seizing at will, and sorting the evidence (if found) out later.

This is really all about protecting the innocent, you see.  Not those evil criminals and terrorists.  They just come along for the ride.