Author Archives: SHG

Things to do While Waiting For a Verdict in Texas

I received an email from Austin criminal defense attorney Jamie Spencer demanding an apology for my “frequent blaspheming” of the Sovereign Nation of Texas.  Attach to the demand was a link to his post about the DWI trial of Casey Price, from the Houston Chronicle.

It was a normal enough trial (for Texas) when, during jury deliberations,

Then the judge decided she wanted Price to immediately take a drug screen urine test and ordered the bailiff to contact the Pretrial Services facility in the courthouse to arrange it.

The judge also said if Price tested positive, the results would be given to the jury, says [defense lawyer Paul] LaValle.

So what if the defendant was in the middle of trial.  So what if the judge was ordering the potential creation of evidence on her own to inculpate the defendant.  We’ve got a defendant and a jury, and no reason to waste the money of the good taxpayers of Texas waiting on a verdict.

The funny part is that this isn’t the bad part of the story.  The bad part has yet to come.


Before the drug test could be arranged, the jury returned with its verdict.

Not guilty.

Price wasn’t surprised. She said she felt the video clearly demonstrated that she wasn’t drunk. Still, she was relieved. She was free.

Or so she thought. But Judge Johnson had different ideas. Having ordered the drug test, she instructed the bailiff to take Price away for the drug test.

So Price was led to another floor of the courthouse, where she was questioned (strangely, she thought) on the details of her financial condition — her income and what she pays for rent, auto, utilities, clothes, etc. — and then made to urinate into a cup in front of a female staffer.

The results were negative.

Then they told her she had to pay $11.

Now I’m aware that many people in Texas feel that Yankees are a bit slavish about the whole concept of sequencing, like verdict before sentencing, but apparently this offended even Texan sensibilities.  Especially the part about paying $11, would have covered the post-verdict mocha frappocinos in New York.

Right now, you’re probably asking yourself (as did I), what was the prosecutor doing while the judge decided to move things forward with undue alacrity.


Eva Flores is a rookie who has been with the DA’s office only since May. She remained silent.

The veteran prosecutor who had supervised Flores during the trial, Gary Miller, had returned to his office when the trial ended, said LaValle. He said he’s confident Miller would have advised the judge against ordering the drug test.

A spokeswoman for the DA’s office, veteran prosecutor Donna Hawkins, said the DA’s office has “no responsibility to be part of anything” after a not-guilty verdict is announced.

Not surprisingly, they resorted to the motto of the Sovereign Nation of Texas, “not my job.”  My favorite is the senior prosecutor, Miller, who says he’s “confident”.  That’s comforting.

And what of the fine judge who came up with a bunch of great ideas to tweak the system a bit for maximum effectiveness?


LaValle noted that Judge Carolyn Marks Johnson was a visiting judge, a former district judge who had presided over civil trials, not criminal proceedings.

Johnson says she can’t comment “on a case that is still before me.”

[Reporter Rick Casey] asked if the case wasn’t over.

“There may be motions filed on it,” she said.

Judge Johnson has a point.  After all, if she’s going to sentence before verdict, you never know when the defense is going to make post-acquittal motions.  Maybe they plan to move for double-acquittal?

Too often, we don’t appreciate a judge who thinks outside the box, even if she’s trying to put the defendant into one.  Here, we have a jurist who has broken free of the chains of mundane procedure, slavish adherence to the laundry list approach to trials and an exceptionally firm view of justice.  Doesn’t she deserve our appreciation?

And the prosecutor, who we so often challenge for over-reaching, showed remarkable self-restraint by standing mute and rejecting the urge to become embroiled in self-serving grand-standing.  Where’s the kudos for this young, but obviously talented prosecutor?

Thus, I bow to Jamie Spencer’s demand.  I apologize for all the bad things I’ve said about Texas justice, and concede that there is no law like Texas law.

New Yorker: Only for Really Cool People (Update)

Ann Althouse had a picture of the cover of The New Yorker.  And I can’t tell you how proud I am to be a really groovy New Yorker too.



Ann’s question is what should Obama do about this cover, laugh it off or get “surly”.  She appears to come out on the laugh it off side.  But for many of us, myself included, I had some trouble figuring out what message this cover was intended to send.



The [Obama] campaign adds:



The New Yorker may think, as one of their staff explained to us, that their cover is a satirical lampoon of the caricature Senator Obama’s right-wing critics have tried to create. But most readers will see it as tasteless and offensive. And we agree.


Apparently, I’m not the only one trying to get the point.  But remember, this is The New Yorker, and it is only read by ultra-hip, uber-cool, chi-chi-oozing people.  So that means that no one except that group of 12 (possibly 13 if Norm Pattis is in town) will understand the point in any event.

The oddity is that, as explained by the magazine staff, its intent is to lampoon right-wing critics.  Did anybody at The New Yorker consider that maybe, just maybe, the rest of us non-groovy folks will see it differently, and that there could even be a whole bunch of people, in such really uncool places as Nebraska and Ohio, who will view this as confirmation of their concern that he doesn’t have the middle name “Hussein” for nothing?

Really cool New Yorkers tend not to care much for Republicans, because they are not awesome or ginchy.  But sometimes, really cool New Yorkers outsmart themselves, putting out something so brilliant, so intriguing, so deep, that nobody gets it.  And sometimes, when nobody get it, they get something out of it that isn’t intended at all, and actually cuts the other way.  Methinks this may be just such a time.

I bet the New Yorker’s reaction to this suggestion is that if those anti-hip people can’t figure out who they are satirizing, then they are just too stupid to be worthy of their very cool attention.  I agree completely, except for one problem:  There are just so darn many of them, and they vote.

Update:  Apparently, Walt Handelsman has his issues too.  Maybe I’m not crazy?

New-Yorker71608

Sheriff Gets a Pass on Stupid Cop Tricks

This story comes from the circuitous route of Mississippi’s Sun Herald, to Agitator Balko, to TV Star Lammers, and finally reaches the bottom of the food chain.

GULFPORT —  The seizure of 500 plants that looked like marijuana in Harrison County in 2003 did not violate the land-user’s civil rights, the 5th Court of Appeals has ruled.

The crop was kenaf planted as deer food on land leased by the Boarhog Hunting Club. Waltman planted the crop based on research at Mississippi State University. The research concluded that kenaf, used to make paper, could also attract deer and provide larger hunting trophies.


Waltman was watching a TV news show Sept. 8, 2003, when he saw an inmate work crew chopping down plants as high as 15 feet. He heard Payne say they were suspected of being marijuana. Area narcotics officials later said it was the first time they had heard of kenaf.

The raid came after a narcotics agent received a tip that marijuana was growing off Herman Ladner Road in an open field between power lines. 

Sheriff’s officials circled the area by helicopter and a sample from one plant was tested. It tested negative for THC, the illegal compound in marijuana. Agents said a sample from a fresh-cut plant could show a false result, so Payne decided to seize the plants and allow samples to dry for more  reliable tests.

Payne later said he had received reports children had been going into the field to pick the plants. Payne said he was concerned the helicopter’s presence and media coverage could encourage them to return and help themselves.

Now here’s the rub (aside from the “inmate work crew,” who likely could have told them they had the wrong plant).  Had it been marijuana, Payne would have been a hero and a genius, protecting all from demon reefer.  Had Waltman been a “bad guy,” it would have been at the top of the story and sucked the wind out of the claim.  But Waltman did nothing wrong.  It wasn’t pot. And Waltman had no history worthy of overt smear.  Waltman just got screwed.

This is all about tension.  The tension between protecting law enforcement, when it does the job we ask of it, versus the right of innocent people to not suffer harm because the sheriff made a mistake.  But this case is a good one to test the issue, since we have a nice, clear, bright line between the “good guy” plaintiff and the bone-head sheriff.

Why bonehead?  Because the sheriff, having done the right thing at first by testing the plant before razing the entire crop, came up negative.  This would lead a normal human being to question whether the knee-jerk assumption that the crop is marijuana. 

The sheriff said that it could be a false negative.  Yes it could.  So what would a reasonably thoughtful person do?  Test it again.  Test it better.  Test it.  But not this sheriff.  The test came back negative, and his solution was to destroy the entire crop.  Logical disconnects are usually the sort of stuff that judges should be able to detect. 

But the decision here was that the sheriff failed to show “deliberate indifference” when he decided the run down the bonehead path with his eyes wide shut.  Boneheaded?  Yup.  Stupid.  You betcha.  But deliberate?  Not according to the Circuit.

The sheriff did not cut it down callously, but with the best of intentions.  He was just wrong.  He just failed to employ any of a variety of intelligent options that would have avoided the damage and loss.  He decided to take the route of “better safe than sorry,” and now the 5th Circuit says that he doesn’t have to be sorry.

When foolish damage befalls a person, the initial course of action for the police is to find whatever they can to smear the victim and thus deflect their stupidity and responsibility.  And the courts, recognizing that we could face disaster should police be held accountable to harm to the public based upon stupidity, have enabled and encouraged police to do whatever they have to, with the Courts to do their part when needed.

Note that this is in federal court for violation of civil rights, rather than a state court action for damages to property.  While some might find this an inconsequential distinction, it strikes me as making the rule particularly grievous.  The big picture for society is not about one individuals loss of kenaf, but about law enforcement that is not accountable for its stupidity and the harm it does to the very people it exists to protect and serve.

Nothing will change until this idea is firmly planted in everybody’s head.  The cops are not a separate species, unrelated to the rest of society.  As tough a job as it is, it still requires some modest degree of thought.

Compelling Disclosure of Anonymous Posters (Update)

A decision by Westchester County Court Judge Rory J. Bellantoni has quietly established New York’s first test for compelling the disclosure of online anonymous commenters who defame others in their post.   It didn’t help that the couple defamed, in this case, included Richard Ottinger, former congressman and dean of Pace University Law School.

While not precedent, this is important as it’s the way rules get started, and then become “the rule” adopted by courts struggling to find some way to address difficult situations in the future.

In this law.com article, courtesy of Bashman, Noeleen Walker writes:


The allegedly defamatory posts, which appeared on the “LoHud” site maintained by the Journal News, centered around an effort by Ottinger and his wife, June, to renovate their Mamaroneck home.

In September 2007, a post under the name “SAVE10543” accused the couple of presenting a fraudulent deed “in order to claim they own land under water,” and “lying to the State” and other officials to secure permits for their home’s construction. Subsequently, a post under the name “hadenough” maintained that the Ottingers were part of an “illegal scam.” A third post by “aoxomoxoa” later chimed in that the mayor of Mamaroneck “took the juice from Richard and June Ottinger to the tune of $25,000 so they could build their starter Taj Mahal on a substandard lot.”

The Ottingers did not think this funny, and decided to do something about it.  But to whom?

The action, begun as a “John Doe” defamation action and then converted to an action for pre-trial discovery, sought the identities of the anonymous poster(s).  The judge first ordered a notice to be placed on the website to notify the poster(s) that they could intervene anonymously.  When no one came forward, he addressed the merits of disclosure.


Judge Bellantoni then turned to the four-step test set forth by the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, in Dendrite International v. Doe, 775 A.2d 756 (2001), to guide his inquiry.

In Dendrite, the court held that a plaintiff who wants an Internet service provider to disclose the identity of anonymous posters must first “undertake efforts” to inform the writers that “they are the subject of a subpoena or application for an order of disclosure.”

A plaintiff must also identify the “exact” alleged defamatory statements and “produce sufficient evidence supporting each element of its cause of action, on a prima facie basis.”

Finally, a court “must balance the defendant’s First Amendment right of anonymous free speech against the strength” of the plaintiff’s case.

Whether the information contained on the Journal News “LoHud” website will be sufficient to identify the poster is another matter.  For those who don’t know, even anonymous posters leave behind a footprint including their IP address, if not more.  But this information isn’t always enough to identify who wrote the offending words.

The quadripartite test is interesting in that the plaintiffs are required to make a prima facie showing that the comments are defamatory, which should be sufficient in itself to remove the cloak of First Amendment Protection.  While it may be easy to prove the allegations are false, it’s hard to imagine how they can prove them to be malicious when one doesn’t know who published the words.  Falsehood alone does not make speech defamatory.

While balancing tests tend to go over well with most people, it is a purely subjective measure and provides no rule or guidance for its application by a court.  This leaves the judge to superimpose her own sensibilities over the relative weight of the competing interests.  Sometimes, there is no better option.  But if New York is going to develop a test for the future, I would hope that we can do so by removing a purely subjective prong and provide greater clarity for all involved.

Since the third prong of the test requires a prima facie showing, it would seem that overcoming that hurdle would be sufficient.  Once the showing is made, it really shouldn’t be left to a judge to determine that a viable cause of action is sufficiently weighty at the opening stage of litigation. 

From the standpoint of a potential target of such an action, and a blawger who is less than enamored with anonymous posters, my strong pro-free-speech sensibilities give way to disclosure when someone is defamed.  Anon posters are emboldened to post some truly bad stuff about others, hiding behind their nifty screen names to deliberately hurt their “enemies” with lies.  There’s nothing about doing this that makes me feel compelled to protect them.

Note that this is about people who deliberately publish lies about others, not about those who publish an uncomfortable truth.  We have the right, indeed the duty, to disclose impropriety that public officials would prefer remain unknown.  But the depth of political extremism and hatred these days tends to drive some people to go to any length to hurt their political enemies.  When they cross the line from truth to lies, they lose my sympathy and they do grave harm to political discourse.

And, of course, the ability to publish anonymously at will on a website is an invitation to problems.  If online content is to have meaning, there must be a way to stop liars from having their way.

Update:  On August 27, 2009, Justice Richard Liebowitz dismissed the Ottingers’ cause of action for defamation as a SLAPP suit again named defendant Stuart Teikert (note the comment below).  Justice Liebowitz refused to award damages, both actual and punitive, to Teikert despite the holding, and further refused, in the exercise of discretion, to award attorneys fees and costs.  It sounds like a “pox on both their houses” decision.

One point requires additional commentary:  This is why a prima facie showing, rather than a summary judgment showing, is inadequate to protect first amendment rights when outing an anonymous poster.   The Ottingers got their name, but couldn’t make their case?  That it was held to be a SLAPP suit, without any defamation, should make the point as clearly as possible.  Prima facie is an insufficient test to compel disclosure of an anonymous speaker.

The Non-Aggression Pact on Judicial Nominations Expands: Lawyers Now Included?

Following my post about Rick Hills’ proposal of a non-aggression pact and amongst lawprofs nominated for federal judgeships, regardless of ideologoy,  Rick has responded :


I should have seen it coming: Scott Greenfield, over at Simple Justice, takes my proposed pact on judicial nominations to be a slight on trial lawyers with experience in the trenches. This is what comes of treading near to the edge of the Culture War between Academia and the Bar: One risks being misunderstood.

Just for the record: I’d presumptively prefer a street-smart, experienced trial lawyer over a law prof as a judge any day. This is especially true for the trial courts, but my preference holds also for the appellate bench as well. In general, the trial lawyers that I know have been wiser, quicker, and more intellectually open-minded than my law prof friends.

That’s very kind of Rick, though I didn’t exactly take his omission of trial lawyers from the universe of potential judicial nominees as a slight.  Rick made no mention of trial lawyers, and I simply corrected that omission. 

Now that he’s acknowledged that experienced trial lawyers (though this term bothers me, as it is generally used to refer to civil litigators rather than criminal defense lawyers) bring something to the bench that others cannot, we’ve removed that albatross from the discussion.  I hope.

But Rick goes then further:


But I am happy to accept a friendly amendment from — or a joint cartel with — the trial lawyers: We profs will agree to support any nominee for the lower federal courts who is an “ace trial lawyer” (definition to be negotiated — but I’d say, anyone with roughly 15 years of experience litigating cases and with a great reputation with the ACTL and analogous organizations) if you trial lawyers agree to support analogous law profs.

The absolutely essential aspect of this pact is that neither group should give a whit what any nominee thinks about actual doctrine: On the lower courts, the stakes of such ideological disputes are low enough that we can pocket our preferences about Roe, etc.

Is it a deal?

I have some questions/issues/problems.   But I told Rick that I would check in with the brethren and get back to him.  Anyone think this is a good idea?  Anyone care to note any questions/issues/problems you see with this proposal?

Reader Mailbag No. 4

And it’s time again for my reader mailbag, always enlightening if somewhat less than thrilling.


Greenfield:

I leave comments for you all the time.  Almost every day.  And you never respond.  No “good idea.”  No “I never thought of that.”  Not even “thanks for the comment.”  Nothing.  Zero, zippo, nada.  You respond to other people, even those who call you names and tell you that you are the devil incarnate.  Why not me?

Sigh.  This is a tough one, and one that has bothered me for a long time.  The reason it bothers me is that your comments show that your heart is in the right place.  The problem is that your head is somewhere else, likely a dark, moist location with an unpleasant odor. 

Comments that repeat what’s already said, state the obvious as if it’s an epiphany or just totally miss the point, often wandering off to some strange place where there’s no intelligent life, present a problem.  You see, I don’t want to attack a commenter for vapidity when they’ve done nothing to deserve attack.  But on the other hand, I can’t agree with a comment that’s vapid either.  I’m in a quandary.

I enjoy comments.  I really do appreciate the challenge of different ideas, and believe that discussion and disagreement test our thoughts.  But your comments bring absolutely nothing to discussion.  They add nothing.  They detract nothing.  They reflect the absence of thought.  I can’t figure out why you bother, since they say nothing.  And yet there you are, regularly posting a comment.

I’m frequently left with the impression that you didn’t bother to read the post, or you just don’t have a clue what the post was about.  But then, why bother to comment?  Perhaps your purpose is to promote yourself, to obtain what little recognition one can from commenting on a blawg.  Perhaps you do it here and elsewhere as well, spreading your words across the blawgosphere.  I don’t know.

But my failure to respond to your comments makes me feel badly as well.  I see them.  I know you’re there.  I just can’t figure out what to say in response to comments that say nothing.


Greenfield:

I’m smarter than you.  Ha!  I can toy with you at will, writing my little comments that highlight your idiocy and knowing with certainty that you will fall into my trap by trying in your pathetic little way to keep up with me.  And I am better looking than you too.

An interesting phenomenon happens when you have a blawg.  People read it.  If it sucks, people stop reading it.  It’s one of the great beauties of the blawgosphere: It’s ultimately the writing and ideas that make it worthy of some other person’s time and attention.  So if someone stops by Simple Justice, it’s not because I, personally, carry such great weight, but that there’s something that I’ve written that makes another person decide to spend a few minutes of their time.

And this, obviously, brings you.  You may indeed be smarter than me.  You are likely better looking than me (like that’s a big deal).  But you’ve come to Simple Justice.  I didn’t come to you.  Neither did any other reader here. 

I respond to most comments left at SJ (with the notable exception above).  You really didn’t quite trap me into taking the bait.  I take the bait willingly, because this is my blawg.  It’s not just about pontificating, but about taking it to the next step, discussion.  I’ll discuss things with pretty much anybody (with the notable exception above).  Even you. 

But if you sincerely believe that you are scoring points, you’re probably wasting your time.  I don’t consider the size of my genitalia to be at stake, and I happily concede that I am not ultimate arbiter of anything.  You can be smarter than me anytime you want.  But you have to do it through ideas.

On the other hand, if you really want to test how much others admire your genius, why not start your own blawg rather than waste your time messing with me.  If you are as brilliant as you think, then others (including me) will flock to your blawg and devour your every word. 

But if you’re going to waste your time coming to my blawg, then bear in mind that it’s mine.  Feel free to show your brilliance whenever you would like, but trying to “one-up” me is silly waste of bandwidth (which I control here, by the way).  Rather than brilliant, it comes off as obnoxious and childish, and tends to give rise to complaints from other readers about why I allow rude and annoying comments. 

I try to let people, even obnoxious people (and you aren’t the first and won’t be the last) have an opportunity to get it out in the hope that they will calm down and become contributing readers rather than trolls.  Most have. Some haven’t.  And it’s up to me to decide who stays and who goes.  You know why?  Because it’s my blawg.

Proposed “Non-Aggression Pact” on Federal Judicial Appointments of Law Profs

I didn’t see this coming.  And if you don’t slum at the lawprof blawgs, chances are you didn’t either.

Rick Hill over PrawfsBlawg proposes that his fellow lawprofs enter into an agreement, one that would have some fascinating implications for lawyers in the trenches:


Here are the terms of the pact: Law profs agree to support any academic appointment to the federal district or appellate bench, full stop. Left law profs will endorse, say, Professor Doug Kmiec for the Ninth Circuit when a Republican occupies the White House; Right law profs will endorse, for instance, Dean Elena Kagan for the D.C. Circuit when a Democrat occupies the White House.

Well, this could really put a crimp in lawprof mud wrestling.  Why would they do such a thing?


The reason for the pact? Law profs — literally any law prof — is likely to be as good as, or even a better than, the typical nominee to a lower court, whose qualifications typically amount to being a Senator’s friend or staffer. Yet law profs face an enormous headwind in securing a nomination, because they have paper trails on controversial issues. It does not help that law profs testify against their own when a professorial nominee has particular positions that the profs oppose. But eliminating profs in this manner actually is self-defeating in every sense of the word: It is not as if the professorial nominees are replaced with nominees that are ideologically simpatico.

An interesting point.  One the one hand, we have lawprofs, right or left, and on the other, some Senator’s friend or staffer.  Oddly, that had never been my idea of the entire universe of potential federal court judges.  But then, the “Senator friend” may sound more derogatory than it really is.  More about this later.

The initial reaction came from Jonathon Adler at VC, who was ready to play.


I’m ready to sign on (even though — or perhaps because — I’m quite sure I’d never be a direct beneficiary. But I’d also go Rick one better, and suggest that law professors begin urging an overall de-escalation of judicial nomination fights. In particular, it would be nice if law professors stopped providing intellectual ammunition to Senators and activist groups who wish to dress up their ideological attacks on qualified judicial nominees. In my opinion, the purpose of Senate confirmation for judges (as for ambassadors and many other positions) is to prevent against cronyism, not second-guess the President’s ideological preferences.

I’m not entirely sure, but I believe that the Constitution limits cronyism to the executive branch.  But the point about de-escalation is interesting.  Do the lawprofs go after each other tooth and nail, ripping their brethren to shreds in Senate hearings, exposing their law review articles as intellectual frauds with Senate testimony, dripping with sarcasm, as one condemns the other as having “scholarship that fails to meet academic rigor.”  Ouch.  Nasty stuff.  I can see Arlen Specter grimace.

Next came fellow PrawfsBlawger Paul Horwitz’s reaction, who questions why a non-aggression pact would be necessary or good.


It is possible that law professors are less likely to be “corrupt” than these other lawyers, depending on how you define the term, if for no other reason than that they are less likely to be worldly, or at least successfully worldly. But there are all kinds of ways for judges to be corrupt. One of those, and the most important, is to lack impartiality; and I see no reason for assuming that law professors will be impartial than any other lawyer, particularly once you factor in partiality based on political ideology.

Horwitz, traitor to the cause, makes some excellent points.  So do the others, really, but Horwitz comes out and says some ugly truths: 

1.  Lawprofs lack the “worldliness” that practicing lawyers expect and need from judges.
2.  Lawprofs can be as ideologically “corrupt” as anyone else.

Rick Hill’s beef had much to do with the fact that lawprofs, unlike most other appointees, have a clear track record of their thinking, available in law review articles (and now blawgs as well), that puts them at particular risk of having their head ripped off at confirmation hearings. 

By Hill’s reasoning, the alternative is “blanks”, people as ideologically committed but without any history to provide fodder to the opposition.  This leaves lawprofs exposed and “blanks” protected.  His non-aggression pact would seek to limit the bloodshed over lawprofs’ scholarly efforts.  Implicit in his lawprofs versus “blanks” point is that lawprofs, at least, are a better (smarter?) choice than “blanks”.

One thing they all seemed to agree upon, that the fighting over confirmation is over the top and requires “de-escalation”.  To the extent a rationale appears for this, it’s that the Senate is paralyzed by the fighting and not enough appointees are being confirmed, leaving courtrooms without judges.

It’s curious that Hill doesn’t consider the fact that appointments have become ideologically extreme, thus raising the level of attack and rhetoric.  Maybe the solution to the paralysis, which is the safeguard that the Constitution deliberately includes for that “check and balance” thing, is ideological de-escalation rather than some subversive non-aggression pact. 

Not going to happen?  Perhaps, but as the right goes to extremes, so too must the left to seek balance.  It’s a lousy balance, since we’re not talking about appointees who are impartial, open-minded and qualified.  If one side tries to stack the deck its way, the other side is (a) obliged to try to stop it, and (b) obliged to stack the deck the other way.  After all, if lefty Senators believe their views are correct, how can they acquiesce in righty ideological choices just to keep the peace and move things along?

There is an entire side of the issue that Hill failed to recognize, though Horwitz picked up on it right away.  Who says lawprofs make good judges in the first place?  Sure, they may be smart.  Some even brilliant.  Smart is good, but brilliance is over-rated, and is often a handicap.  But what about having experience in the trenches?

This is where many federal judges fall flat.  They lack real world experience.  They lack breadth of experience.  How many have tried a case to verdict before a jury?  Of those, how many did so without either having the backup of the United States Attorney’s office or Biglaw behind them?  Why does this matter?

Federal judges, contrary to the expectations of lawprofs and ideologues, deal with real people with real disputes.  One recurring issue, based on my time in the trenches, is that too many judges have never actually sat down and spoken to a criminal defendant.  Too many have never comprehended the relative conflict between defendant and federal agent.  Too many have no clue that everyone doesn’t fit neatly into the little round and square openings that they will ultimately put them into. 

They sit on big wooden benches and believe they understand the world, but they don’t.  Their lives have been cloistered, and their world is black and white.  Call it ideological or just painfully naive.  All too often, they just don’t “get” reality, and this leads them to make facile decisions.  They don’t think so, but they do. 

Then, there’s the suffering of trench lawyers at the hands of the federal bench.  Such as, “counselor, prepare a memo on that issue for tomorrow morning” when you make an application at trial, just received 298 pages of Rule 3500 material for cross in the morning and are a sole practitioner, and you know the judge is going to deny it anyway.  Or the judge who leaves you sitting in the courtroom for 5 hours, awaiting her appearance, without thinking that you’ve got other clients and other judges who might appreciate your presence as well.  Or the judge who demands that you and your client appear in their courtroom in an hour, assuming that you do nothing except sit in your office awaiting a command performance. 

Judges make bizarre, unrealistic and incredibly onerous demands on lawyers all the time.  They do this because they have never experienced what life is like for a practicing lawyer.  Even if they do, their experience is usually in Biglaw (that’s how they get to know their Senators, when they hand over the campaign contribution check), and think everybody has 12 associates asking “how high” when they say jump.  Lawyers are fungible to them.

I can’t tell you how many times I explained to a judge when a case was adjourned to a date where I was already booked that it was a problem.  The response was, “so have another lawyer appear,” to which I would feign looking in my pockets and reply, “Sorry, but I don’t seem to have any other lawyers in there.”  They would be completely befuddled by the concept that lawyers have other cases, other clients, other obligations.

And if the disconnect is bad at the trial level, the appellate level can be totally disconnected from reality.  It’s like explaining the flavor of food you’ve never tasted. 

So while Rick Hill’s dreaded “blanks” may not have a paper trail of law review articles with which to attack their ideological bent, lawprofs may lack the breadth of experience in the trenches to understand how their service impacts on real people and real lawyers.  Given Paul Horwitz’s second point, that lawprofs are no less ideologically “corrupt” than anyone else, I think I would prefer a judge who has some clue about life in the real world over some lawprof whose theoretical perspective is ideologically simpatico with today’s occupant of the oval office. 

Anybody wonder why Nancy Gertner is so appreciated? 

But For Video, Volume 29

Grab your popcorn.  It’s time for some more fun videos, this time courtesy of South Carolina criminal defense lawyer Bobby Fredericks.

First, up, we have this great piece from beautiful Yonkers, New York, showing how a real man treats a woman:

Sweet, isn’t he. Notice how he gently hugged the young woman before body slamming her to the ground like a rag doll. And aren’t we proud of all those other fine officers standing around watching. I bet they all went home and hugged their wives just the same way that day.

Next up, we have this great video of how the Harrisburg Police “process” their prisoners.  As a special added bonus, we have a judge who, after further deliberation, noticed that something was “wrong” when this fellow with dried, matted blood all over his face came before him.  Listen carefully for the judge’s deep abiding concern.




Now here’s a quiz:

Was the Judge:

1.  Thoughtful and concerned?
2.  Remarkably observant?
3.  Fair-minded and neutral?
4.  Trying as hard as he could to minimize what should have smacked him in the face the second he observed a defendant appear before him who had been beaten by police while awaiting arraignment?

The winner gets an all-expense paid trip to Harrisburg.  The loser gets two trips.

And, as always, an ode to the fine men and women who protects us from criminals, with apologies to Jon Katz.  Caution:  Do NOT watch this video if you have indigestion, high blood pressure or erectile dysfunction.


Some Will Die This Winter

Chances are strong that you are feeling the pinch at the pumps these days.  Maybe death grip around your throat is a better way to put it.  But that’s because it’s a beautiful summer day, and you want to jump in the car and take a ride out to the beach and enjoy the sun and surf.

Six months from now, it will be cold outside.  Putting a tiger in your tank will not be your only concern.  You and your family will sit inside your home, and expect there to be enough heat to keep your warm.  I hope you will have that heat.  I know some will not.  Some people will die this winter for lack of heat.

Bob Herbert’s column today talks about the problem in light of former Senator Phil Gramm’s economic solution.


“We’re the only nation in the world,” Mr. Gramm once said, “where all our poor people are fat.”

“They are 80-year-olds,” howled Mr. Gramm. “Most people don’t have the luxury of living to be 80 years old, so it’s hard for me to feel sorry for them.”

“You’ve heard of mental depression; this is a mental recession.”

In other words, if they freeze to death, they deserve it.  Very helpful, in a Herbert Hooverish sort of way.

And what does the junior Senator from Illinois have to say?

“You know, America already has one Dr. Phil,” said Mr. Obama. “When it comes to the economy, we don’t need another.”

Now that’s very humorous.  Very humorous indeed.  But seriously, Mr. Obama, how do you propose to keep people alive this winter?


[silence]

This is what we are looking at.  I’ve been called unduly pessimistic by some because I find it difficult to take comfort in the expectation that America will pull another rabbit out of a hat.  But to date, no one has suggested any possible way to deal with the problems we are facing. 

This is a combination of two great American strengths.  The ability to ignore reality in a flourish of American positivism, because we are the greatest civilization on the face of the earth and therefore will overcome this challenge.  The ability to take one day at a time, and thereby refuse to confront more complex situations that require us to look down the road and see what will come in the future.  Add to this the “rugged individualism” that appeals to so many Americans, at least as long as they aren’t personally suffering, and there is no problem we can’t overcome.

I don’t subscribe to this theory.  I believe that while we hope for the best, we prepare for the worst.  But then, I’m not running for President of the United States of America.  What do I know?

The cost of home heating oil will be beyond the means of many people this winter, especially when combined with unemployment, declining wages, health care costs, food prices and that old tank of gas issue.  But falling back, as I tend to do, on Abraham Maslow, the fulfillment of basic survival needs must come first.  If you’re a CEO with a decent golden parachute, and your company isn’t bankrupt yet, you’ll probably make it through the winter.  Others will struggle.  Some will fail.  Some will die.

We have no answers.  Plenty of talk, some of it very cute and humorous, but nothing that will actually help.  Worse yet, there is no sense of urgency and no demand by the public to have something more meaningful to say than cutesy responses. 

Neither politics nor business wants to touch serious problems.  They are so darn negative, and people want to hear good, happy, positive things.  It makes them feel better about themselves, no matter how badly things are going or how dire the situation.  That the rhetoric from Obama and McCain is meaningless happy drivel is no surprise.  Their polls tell them that no one will vote for them if they don’t say happy things.  And even pundits are told to tone it down by their editors, since harsh negative prognostications will make people depressed and not want to read their newspapers, which means they won’t get advertising revenue.

Cold weather is only 6 months away.  Maybe less.  Once it comes, people will die.  You heard it here first.  I’m not selling anything, so I can tell you the truth.  The bill for America has come due, and we will pay for it in blood.  Sorry to be such a downer, but it’s time somebody told the truth. 

If It Makes No Sense in English, Then What About Spanish?

The New York Times told the story of Erik Camayd-Freixas, who is a federal court interpreter with 23 years experience, as well as a professor of Spanish at Florida International University.  Apparently, Professor Camayd-Freixas hit the wall after he was summoned to Waterloo, Iowa for help in a case involving 400 illegal immigrants, and decided to publish a 14 page essay about his experience.

In the essay and an interview, Professor Camayd-Freixas said he was taken aback by the rapid pace of the proceedings and the pressure prosecutors brought to bear on the defendants and their lawyers by pressing criminal charges instead of deporting the workers immediately for immigration violations.

He said defense lawyers had little time or privacy to meet with their court-assigned clients in the first hectic days after the raid. Most of the Guatemalans could not read or write, he said. Most did not understand that they were in criminal court.

I’m shocked.  Shocked!

I’ve written in the past about how English-speaking defendants have no clue what’s happening in court and how juries don’t understand instructions.  Lawyers and courts use both arcane terms as well as convenient short-hand for doing our job.  It works great for us.  It doesn’t work well at all for our clients. 

Superimpose over this scenario a defendant who doesn’t speak English.  Many of our lawyer-words don’t translate well into other languages under any circumstances, and are particularly problematic when dealing with uneducated defendants.  These are not easy words, and the underlying concepts are even more difficult to understand.  Many lawyers don’t get them.  Should non-lawyers be subject to higher expectations?

Then, it all comes under very difficult circumstances, in the enormous tension of a courtroom and at a pace so rapid that it precludes any attempt at explanation. 


“All defendants were provided with experienced criminal attorneys and interpreters before they made any decisions in their criminal cases,” Mr. Teig said.

“Once they made their choices, two independent judicial officers determined the defendants were making their choices freely and voluntarily, were satisfied with their attorney, and were, in fact, guilty.” Mr. Teig said the judges in the cases were satisfied with the guilty pleas.

“The judges had the right and duty to reject any guilty plea where a defendant was not guilty,” Mr. Teig said. “No plea was rejected.”

Another dirty little secret of the law exposed.  Before a plea can be accepted, the judge must inquire as to whether the defendant understands all the rights being waived and that there is a factual basis for the plea.  It consists of the judge talking in legal jargon and the defendant saying the word “si” numerous times.  Afterward, we all pretend that the defendant had a clue what the judge was saying and that we’ve done our duty.

As the interpreter knows, the defendant turns and looks at him after each question is asked by the judge, with sad, inquiring eyes, pleading with him to “tell me what I’m supposed to say?”  The defendant has no clue what the judge is saying.  The interpreter has no time to explain, in a way that might possibly be meaningful, what is happening. 

The plea allocution (it’s called other things in other places) is a mantra that we go through, but its utility is entirely dependent on understanding both the nature of rights as well as the language of rights.  Afterward, when a defendant has had a chance to calm down, recapture his composure and have the courtroom scene relayed for him (if he ever gets to see his lawyer again), he suddenly realizes that he had no idea what he was agreeing to, and wants to take it back.  Too late, the appellate courts tell us.  The rights were “fully explained” and he said “yes”.  End of story.  The legal fiction of comprehension prevails.

This is true of most defendants.  It is almost universal with non-English speaking defendants.  This is what made Professor Camayd-Freixas so upset.  He didn’t want to be a part of this sham perpetrated on 400 Guatemalans who couldn’t read or write, but worked in our agriprocessing industry in Iowa. 

These people thought they were in Immigration Court, and that they were agreeing to be deported. Nope.  They were being prosecuted for using false social security numbers. 

He suggested many of the immigrants could not have knowingly committed the crimes in their pleas. “Most of the clients we interviewed did not even know what a Social Security card was or what purpose it served,” he wrote.

He said many immigrants could not distinguish between a Social Security card and a residence visa, known as a green card. They said they had purchased fake documents from smugglers in Postville, or obtained them directly from supervisors at the Agriprocessors plant. Most did not know that the original cards could belong to Americans and legal immigrants, Mr. Camayd-Freixas said.

There are many people who will have no sympathy for these 400 illegals.  After all, they were illegal, so who cares what happens to them.  They are criminals and they get what they deserve.  While this attitude is ignorant, it’s also irrelevant.  The question isn’t whether they are illegals, or whether illegals are evil, but that our legal system does what it pretends to do. 

In all likelihood, the disposition of these 400 would not have been much different had they fully comprehended what they were doing.  But the problem of people in our court system making knowing, voluntary and intelligent decisions remains.  And it’s the same problem for well-educated, English-speaking defendants, just 100 times worse when language and cultural barriers make comprehension a joke.