Author Archives: SHG

An Unholy Alliance

Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett posts that our neighbors in the Sovereign Nation of Texas have come up with a brilliant idea to stop drunk driving this holiday weekend.

A no-refusal weekend is a weekend in which local law enforcement, prosecutors, and (paragons of impartiality) judges team up to ensure that anyone who is arrested for DUI (actually “DWI” in Texas, but I’m surrendering to the usage more common nationwide) who refuses to blow in the breathalyzer (as drivers are entitled to and generally should refuse, despite the legal fiction of “implied consent”) is subjected to a coerced blood draw under a search warrant.

Many, if not most, will applaud this effort because they want to eliminate the “scourge” of drunk driving.  Except for sex offenses, drunk driving is one of the pre-eminent bogeymen of our time.  One has to give enormous credit to the marketing efforts of Mothers Against Drunk Driving for convincing the majority of Americans to over-criminalize an activity that they indulge in.

From the announcement of this no-refusal weekend, it is clear that there is no shame attached to the teamwork of police, prosecutors and judges in effectuating this scheme.  There should be, but there isn’t.  Each arm of this team has a separate function from the others, and they should never be laboring oars in the same boat.

While one can more easily forgive prosecutors for ignoring their duty to parse the efforts of police, since our expectations of prosecutorial independence and ethics are so low, the same cannot be said for judges.  Judges exist to exercise judgment (hence the name) over the unilateral fiat of law enforcement, to prevent them from riding roughshod over the rights of people.  When judges join police and prosecutors for a purpose, then they have abdicated their responsibility and abandoned citizens to the whims of the police.

Many, who believe that they are immune from the abuse of police powers and maintain blind faith in the propriety of law enforcement, have no problem when the various arms of government coalesce into a single-minded machine designed to achieve an end with which they agree.  These are the people who see a very simple solution to such problems:  Just don’t do it and, if you are stopped, just do what the cop says. 

Criminal defense lawyers know that a liberal is a conservative who has been arrested.  While we don’t wish this on anyone, there is a certain tacit humor in the irony, as they learn that their entire vision of justice and law enforcement might be slightly misguided.  It’s not that we haven’t told them, but that they just won’t believe it until it’s their time.

It’s possible that the captive judges of Harris County, Texas, a place where the best defense to murder is “he needed killing,” will make themselves available to the police and prosecutors, but refuse to become their rubber stamp and still demand probable cause before scribbling something on blood warrants.  It is possible, but it doesn’t seem likely, since the push to punish precludes a thorough review and consideration of the validity of the warrants.  Indeed, one can imagine a form warrant already in the computer where only the name needs to be changed.  No individualized allegations of fact required. 

At least this is happening in Harris County, Texas, and not in the good ol’ U. S. of A., where we would never tolerate an unholy alliance like this.

Our 232nd* Year and It Doesn’t Look Promising

Last July 4th, I was optimistic about the future of America.  Sure, we had to maintain the struggle to keep the promise of our forefathers, but it was worth the effort.


Today is the Fourth of July.  Independence Day.  It’s a good day to think about the promise of America in the minds and hearts of great men.  And to question how we, ordinary people, have dealt with that promise.   Many will be saddened that 231 years have passed and we have not yet accomplished the dream.  Others will be heartened by the fact that some of us, indeed many of us, are still trying.  Don’t give up.  It’s a dream worth fighting for.

This year, I’m less sanguine.  Not because the value of our Constitution is diminished, or because the struggle is less worthy, but because of my macro-view of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs.  Today, our nation is faced with very basic problems that will consume our energies and focus.  Our economy is in shambles.  Wars continue, even raging worse now than before.  Food and fuel have become a crushing burden, and the jobs that remain fail to maintain real wages even as unemployment.  Foreclosure has left many in fear of losing their homes, whether they deserve them or not.  All of these issues address basic human needs.

The 232nd* year should be one of great promise.  We have a presidential campaign in full force, and yet neither party’s candidate has answers.  Indeed, the campaign rhetoric, which is becoming increasingly clear as mere rhetoric to even the least aware Americans, has homogenized to the point that our one bright spot, the fact that a major political party will have a black American candidate for President, fails to inspire. 

Barak Obama uses the word “change” as an empty mantra, while courting disaster by trying desperately not offend anyone by promoting anything resembling ideas.  Political pundits tell us that he cannot win by ideological purity, and must abandon clarity of thought to make himself more appealing to the masses.  John McCain, on the other hand, has shed his statesman-like independence to pull together the conservative base that gave rise to our current circumstances, but refuses to take responsibility for the disastrous consequences we now face.  And the mass of Americans will not accept any political candidate who demands the one thing of them that they adamantly refuse to give:  Thought.

Americans will not be deeply concerned about freedom in our 232nd year.  They will be concerned about eating, jobs, gas and keeping a roof over their children’s heads.  Abraham Maslow explains why higher order concerns take a back seat to basic needs.  For most of its history, America did a superb job of feeding and housing its citizens.  But in this flat world, where our dreams are counted by the price of a barrel of oil, we may have run out of American miracles.

Like every American, I have to hope that we have a few miracles left, because to do otherwise is to give up.  Americans don’t give up.  But my tolerance for the greedy, the vapid, the smug, the selfish and the angry has grown very short.  And it wasn’t much to begin with.

It is politically expedient to appeal to the “common wisdom” of middle America, massaging the ego of the masses into believing that they are indeed “right” in their thinking.  History informs otherwise, but that’s why George Santayana never won an election. 

“Common wisdom” is an oxymoron.  an Orwellian phrase designed to appease the masses into believing that they will overcome adversity based on simplistic assumptions and need not strain themselves to achieve success in accomplishing their goals.  As times get tougher, resort to simplistic assumptions (and those who promote them) will flourish.  Unfortunately, this is when we need to think harder and make more difficult choices to overcome adversity, first to fulfill our base needs and then to address our higher order concerns.  If the former cannot be accomplished, we will not reach the latter.

So our 232nd year isn’t looking very promising.   And I end with one of my favorite quotations:


There is no expedient to which a man will not resort to avoid the real labour of thinking.

-Sir Joshua Reynolds

* Mr. Bennett, of the Houston Bennetts, correctly notes that we have completed our 232nd year, and are entering our 233rd, thus making my calculations suspect.  I bow to his conclusion and beg your forgiveness.

Is This What They Think of Criminal Defense Lawyers?

So I’m reading Doug Berman, as usual, and come to a quote by some lawprof named Dan Filler from The Faculty Lounge, and come to a screeching halt.  What the heck is he talking about?

The subject is Heller, a case that will fascinate and provide fodder for lawprofs for years to come, and the discussion is about what it means to practicing criminal defense lawyers.  Naturally, the lawprofs discuss it amongst themselves, as they certainly wouldn’t want to consider what actual, real, practicing trench lawyers think about it.  That would be demeaning.

So I put on my rattiest tweed jacket with the leather patches over the worn elbows, clench a Meerschaum pipe between my teeth and sneak into the Faculty Lounge.  Standing with his elbow on the mantle of the roaring fire (in 90 degree heat in the midst of summer, but without any beads of sweat on his brow at all), holding a petite glass of Chambourd mixed with just a touch of cheap champagne, is Dan Filler, pontificating in a stentorian voice to the rapt audience:

I agree that criminal defense lawyers will work hard to use Heller.  At the end of the day, however, I suspect  that most legal havoc will come via facial challenges to broad gun regulation.    As criminal defense attorneys have long known, it’s very difficult to protect constitutional rights when the constitutional defender is a bad apple.  Yes, the courts have issued various defendant-protective criminal procedure rules over the years.  But notwithstanding these decisions, the facts never seem to quite come out right for the defendant.  Police and prosecutors learn the rules and shape testimony (and, though I’m skeptical, perhaps behavior as well) to meet those rules.  And elected judges have perfected the art of strategic fact-finding – which trumps “the law” almost every time. 

Defense lawyers may have fun with Heller for a while but I suspect that they’ll soon discover little to play with, and they’ll return to the bread and butter.  Dramatic closings; perilous cross-examination; and of course plea bargain after plea bargain after plea bargain.

Resisting the urge to leap forward and pop him one in the kisser, but only because it would blow my cover, I slowly wheeled around and slinked out of the room.  “Is that it,” I asked?  “Is that what they think of us?”

Who is this guy to assume that we’re all flash and no substance?  Probably some Biglaw wannabe who hitched his wagon to the prosecution before dedicating his life to the denigration of criminal defense lawyers.  So I checked him out.

Four years as a Philly public defender, and then a year as a staff attorney for Bronx Defenders!  

Sure, he did some time at Debevoise, but nothing that a year in the Bronx couldn’t fix.  How did he go so wrong?

So I asked my buddy Danny, the co-founder of Bronx Defenders, about this Filler character.  “Who?” he responded.  “Filler, Dan Filler. What did you do to this guy to make him hate criminal defense lawyers so much?”  I couldn’t get a rise out of him, likely a result of that fall on his head while rock-climbing on the Grand Concourse.


Dramatic closings; perilous cross-examination; and of course plea bargain after plea bargain after plea bargain.

Now I can understand where the plea bargain after plea bargain stuff comes from, though it doesn’t commend him as one of the more skilled public defenders, but has he lost all touch with reality in his decade in the Academy?  Or is this what they actually think comprises the breadth and scope of being a criminal defense lawyer?

No wonder they pay no attention to what trench lawyers think.  As I left the oak paneled walls of the Faculty Lounge, draining the remnants of the Pinot Grigio from my stemmed glass, I muttered to myself, “well, he can eat my . . .”

Update:  Doug Berman has posted the question at Sentencing Law and Policy whether the divide between lawprofs and the practical blawgosphere is as big as I suggest.  This could well be a matter of my being too close to the situation to recognize that we are far closer than I believe.  As Dave Hoffman of Co-Op suggested the other day, I may just be a whiner.  Or perhaps we are closer than, say, non-blawging professors and practicing lawyers, but not as close as we could/should be within the blawgosphere.

I look forward to seeing the responses to Doug’s question.

Stop Thinking — Like a Lawyer

She may seem nice enough, but Anne Reed is an evil sociopath determined to pursue her diabolical agenda of giving trial lawyers intellectual wedgies.  This time, however, she’s gone too far.


“Stop Thinking Like A Lawyer!”



Law books 85752623_4f15c9fb74_m

“Most of your most cherished beliefs about juries are wrong.”


So begins jury consultant Patricia Steele of Varinsky Associates in her article “To Deal Better With Juries, Stop Thinking Like A Lawyer!”  She should know about lawyers’ mistaken assumptions, she explains, because she was a lawyer.  “[A]fter hundreds of hours debriefing actual jurors and watching mock juries deliberate,” she says, “I now know that a great deal of [lawyers’] accepted wisdom about jury psychology is completely baseless.”


Great.  All that money and three years of life down the tubes.  Just the picture of those books, at $50 a pop, in the snow is enough to break a lawyer’s heart.

Anne, what are you doing?  You’re killing me.  I feel so . . . worthless.

Learn to think like a lawyer, that’s what they kept telling me in law school.  Nightmare images of Prof. Kingsfield (we all had one) socraticizing us into submission.  Beating, beating, beating logic into our dumb, thick heads.

Ms. Smarty-Pants Reed, after gently informing us post after post of how voir dire should be performed, now tells us that it doesn’t matter because, no matter what we ask or what they say, we won’t get it because we’re (gasp) lawyers. 


“For generations lawyers have told each other that the jury’s opinion of the lawyer is important to their decision in the case. Trial lawyers think that what they wear and how charming they are influences jurors. They think they can dazzle juries with their eloquence. This is a huge misconception.”

And now she’s making fun of my suits?  Is there nothing sacred to this Reed person?


“In addition, lawyers typically have little in common, either socially or economically, with the average juror.”

Now that hurts.  Just because we don’t earn as much as plumbers is no reason to publicly humiliate us.  And the fact that no one wants to hang out with lawyers socially is just rubbing salt in the wound.  Do you think we’re happy sitting all alone, night after night, when even our spouses tell us how annoying we can be?  My God, Reed, is there no end to your cruelty?

If you have a strong stomach, or are one of those self-loathing lawyer-types, go read Anne’s post, designed to destroy the very fabric of the lawyer belief system and reduce us to sniveling piles of much.  I would write more, but I now have to go into the corner, ball myself up in a fetal position and cry.

Aitzaz Ahsan: U.S. Silent About Ousted Judge in Pakistan

At the request of the New York City Bar, I announced the relatively impromptu talk by Aitzaz Ahsan, leader of the Pakistani lawyers revolt stemming from the ouster of the Chief Justice of their Supreme Court.  I figure the least I could do is close the loop.

While lawyers around the country protested for a day after Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf put an end to the rule of law in our ally, most of us went back to work afterward and didn’t give it a second thought.  After all, it’s so much more interesting to talk about going to war for “freedom” than getting one’s hands dirty in the actual nitty-gritty of  it, especially when it’s our own ally who’s taking it away, America’s silence.

This was Ahsan’s point, as related in this New York Lawyer article.


In a breakfast talk yesterday at the New York City Bar Association, Aitzaz Ahsan, the president of the Supreme Court Bar Association of Pakistan, criticized the White House for not speaking “a word, a syllable” to protest the five-month house arrest of Pakistan’s chief justice, Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry.

Mr. Ahsan said the administration had been silent because it “does not want to embarrass” Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf. Mr. Ahsan added that the silence is “noticed in Pakistan” and is “a tragedy in the larger context and canvas of Pakistan’s place in the world.”

Without the reinstatement of the ousted judges and the return of the rule of law, Mr. Ahsan said, the “broad masses” in Pakistan are without “enforceable rights.”

In that environment, he asserted, “extremists will encroach upon the middle ground,” leaving as vulnerable a front-line state in the war against terror.

Kinda makes you feel all warm and fuzzy about the loss of American lives so far away for the cause of freedom.

Ahsan said that the lawyers of Pakistan recognized the protests by American lawyers and appreciated their efforts. 


To keep up the pressure to reinstate the judges, Mr. Ahsan told the 120 lawyers who attended yesterday’s 70-minute session that lawyer groups in Pakistan are calling for an international convention in September.

He said he hoped “distinguished attorneys” from around the world and the “elected representatives” of bar associations would attend to hear first-hand accounts of Chief Justice Chaudhry and other ousted judges.

This is the flat world of the law, and while we espouse civil rights and freedoms for ourselves, will we care as much when it’s about it in Pakistan?  Bear in mind, there may come a day when we need the favor returned.

And More Videos of “One Bad Apple(s)”

A spate of cool videos is making the rounds of news lately, bringing us wonderful entertainment.

From the  LA Times, we have the video showing that the cops testimony, that he saw the defendant toss a black object containing cocaine, proven to be a lie.

From ABC News, we have the video of the cop choking a hand-cuffed suspect to find non-existent marijuana in his mouth, until he passed out.  (Note that you have to watch a commercial before seeing this video, since ABC/Disney couldn’t possibly pass up the opportunity to cash in on your interest in exchange for providing you a mediocre news story).  In Tennessee, the reports don’t call it choking, but “vascular restraint.”  It sounds so much more technical, doesn’t it?

But today’s winner is:



The part I love the best is that, without videos, these things never happened.  Tell a judge that your client was beaten by the cops for fun, and it never happened.  Tell the jury that the cops are lying, and it never happened.  But show a video, and it’s real.  It’s a miracle!

There is a little known but scientifically verified release of neuro-toxins, affecting the blood/brain barrier, that happens inside courtrooms which precludes jurors from appreciating that the same things that are caught on video, and hence real, also happen when there is no video available, and therefore never happened.

Simple Justice is currently conducting an unauthorized by highly regarded experiment to determine whether higher concentrations of these toxins are released by the combination of wood-paneling, black polyester and the imported wool found in Paul Stewart suits.  We are having some difficulty accounting for the supple leather used in Gucci loafers, which presents a variable given the rich Corinthian leather used in knock-off Nike sneakers.

Notably, the same toxins affect the potential exoneration of wrongfully convicted defendants with regard to DNA.  When DNA is available, innocent defendants are exonerated.  When there is no DNA involved, no innocent defendant has ever been convicted.  Thus, it’s all the DNAs fault, which we hypothesize must also be connected to the creation of the dreaded courtroom toxin.  Fortunately, this experiment will not require living human subjects.

The results of this experiment will be reported in the New England Journal of Medicine or here, whichever is most convenient.

Seriously, how many times can people listen to the “one bad apple” excuse without figuring out that there are too many bad apples?

Which brings us to another video of a heinous crime against humanity.

There’s a Disruption in the Force Contest

Simple Justice is running a contest!  Woo Hoo!  The winner gets bragging rights across the entire practical blawgosphere and the chance to be mentioned on CLTV if I can convince the host and star, Ken Lammers, to go along.

Here’s the contest.  Something is missing today in the practical blawgosphere.  It’s bold.  It’s occasionally offensive.  It’s almost always right.  It’s happened before and now it’s happened again.

What could it be?

Test your skills.  Test your knowledge.  Win big!

Many will enter but only one will win.  Will it be you? 

Consent to Search — Writing Required?

I’m a little embarrassed to say that I learned about this Newsday article from Grits for Breakfast, since it’s my local paper, but I obviously missed it and Grits gets the hat tip.  The article states that the New York Police Department has a new initiative to obtain “consent to search” in writing.


The New York City Police Department wants suspects to sign a consent form before searching their homes or cars, a move that eliminates the need for a warrant and is meant to provide police a layer of legal protection, Newsday has learned.

The initiative was put in place because consent searches are often challenged at trial – and jurors too often believe the suspect’s claim that police never got permission to conduct the search, police sources said.

There was an initiative in Texas that died in 2005 when Governor Rick Perry vetoed a bill requiring that consent to search be in writing. 

But before anybody gets too excited, and aside from the extremely cursory information in the Newsday article, this appears to be nothing more than another police procedure, or “best practices” type of rule, that is of absolutely no legal force and effect.  In other words, while the police brass may want their cops to do it, that doesn’t mean that failure to obtain consent in writing undermines the claim of consent in the courtroom. 

There are three typical scenarios where consent to search, an exception to the 4th Amendment warrant clause, comes into play:

Scenario 1: 

Officer:  Do I have your permission to search your trunk?
Human Being:  No.
Officer:  I heard you say yes, and thank you very much for your cooperation.  Now spread ’em.

Scenario 2:

Officer:  If you have nothing to hide, then you will let me search your trunk. Do you have something to hide?
Human Being:  I have nothing to hide.
Officer:  Fine, then I’ll just have a look-see since you have given me permission.

Scenario 3:

Officer:  If you don’t consent to my looking in your trunk, I’ll just have to take you to the precinct, hold you there for 24 to 36 hours until I get a search warrant, and then take a look.  I get overtime.
Human Being:  But, but, but…
Officer:  Glad you see it my way.  Now let’s see what we’ve got here.

There are, of course, plenty of variations on these themes, but the picture is clear.   The first scenario can be fixed by a written consent to search form.  The other two cannot.  Submission to the shield is a perpetual problem, which undermines the concept of a knowing, voluntary act.  The cops are trained to use this psychological control to get people to do what they want.  It’s unbearably easy to make people succumb.  And it makes a writing troubling.

The problem, as clearly expressed in the article, is that juries believe a writing:


Robert Thetford, a retired FBI agent who works closely with state troopers on constitutional law issues, says a signed consent form is typically the difference between a jury believing an officer or believing a suspect.

“The bottom line is juries believe what they see in writing,” he said.

By using consent to search forms, the difficulty in challenging a bad consent is significantly worse, though the validity of the consent may be no better than before.  It’s not that obtaining consent to search is necessarily a bad thing, but that it falls into that group of simple solutions to complex problems that often brings to the fore as many problems as it cures.  Always be suspect of magic bullets, which tend to be the ones that strike you in the butt.

When the “Castle Doctrine” Goes Nuts

The tale of Joe Horn’s “no bill” (what we call “no true bill” in New York) didn’t catch my eye initially.  So a guy doesn’t get indicted?  That’s as interesting as dog bites man, right?  But this was a Texas case, and as usual, it’s about a state of law in the Sovereign Nation of Texas that will make a New Yorker’s head explode.  It did just that to Connecticut public defender, Gideon.

The “Castle Doctrine,” as it exists in civilized society, is that a homeowner can shoot to kill a person who unlawfully enters his home at night, but only if he cannot safely retreat.  For many, this was a brutal twist of the law, since there was no requirement that the shooter’s (or anyone else’s) life be imminently threatened before the taking of another’s life.  Instead, it was a “per se” rule, allowing the defense of a home, “a man’s castle,” by deadly force, subject only to the most limited of conditions.  Killing was a last resort, rather than the front line of home defense.

So it comes as no surprise that Texas has a similar rule, but one that takes it a few steps further down the road of reason until it reaches that most Texas-like of all defenses, “he needed killin’.”   Gideon explains the hornbook Texas Rule:

A person can use deadly force (as in this case) if he believes it is immediately necessary to terminate the trespass/burglary/robbery AND the property being taken cannot be recovered by any other means AND he has a reasonable belief that the third person asked him to protect the property. Actually, upon further reading of the statute, it seems that this last one is not a requirement. So, in Texas, you can kill someone you believe is robbing your neighbor without having the neighbor’s permission to protect his house. Don’t we all feel like men now

Ignore that last sentence.  It isn’t part of the rule.  This is Mark Bennett’s shorthand version of the Texas Rule:

In a Texas murder case, though, the focus is often not on the accused and his “legal right” to shoot the decedent, but instead on the decedent and whether he needed killing. Then the only question is whether the decedent was the right guy to do it.

You see, Horn’s house wasn’t being burglarized, but his neighbor’s.  The cops were on the way. Horn called it in and was on the phone with them when the idea to kill the burglars popped into his head, and he went out and shot the two burglars in the back as they were leaving.  Horn’s fear wasn’t that they were going to harm anyone, as the burglary was already over, but the two burglars (who, as Gideon notes, were hispanic) might get away.  We can’t have that.  Not in Texas.

So  Bennett patiently explains to Gideon why the Yankee just doesn’t get it:

But was Joe Horn right under the law? I don’t know. He apparently didn’t know that the cops were right there, and so he might reasonably have believed that the only way to protect his neighbor’s property without exposing himself to a substantial risk of death or serious bodily injury was to use deadly force. Even if he was wrong, though, there’s enough there for a grand jury to hang its hat on that it could justify a no-bill based on its answer to The Real Harris County Self-Defense Special Issues.

Did the complainant need killing?
Was the defendant the right guy to do it?

Don’t try this in New York.  Don’t try this in Connecticut.  And more importantly, don’t kill a person, no matter how much you think he needed killing, to protect property, yours or anyone else’s.  Even Mario Procaccino wouldn’t have gone that far.  It’s just plain sick.

Driving with Cellphones, The Anti View

When I posted a while back about the Texas foray into its unbearably inconsequential limitations on hand-held cellphone use while driving through a school zone, you would have thought I had advocated the castration of all males of child-bearing age. 

In contrast, David Giacalone at f/k/a shares my New York sensibility.  Thanks, David.  I was beginning to think that maybe I was nuts (Don’t say it). 


Sometimes, it’s really hard to avoid cynicism over phony politicians, greedy special interest groups, and — let’s be frank — the spoiled, self-absorbed American public. Case in point: the so-called safety law that goes into effect in California tomorrow.

What were these guys thinking (or trying to achieve or avoid), when they decided to permit the continued use of hands-free devices while driving? They had to know what study after study has demonstrated: hands-free car phoning is just as dangerous as the hand-held variety, because the problem is mainly one of distraction (and “inattention blindness“), and not the number of hands on the wheel. DWP — driving while phoning — leaves the driver as incapacitated as does DUI, with slower reaction times, longer stopping distances, and poorer judgment.

While heresy elsewhere, not to mention the road to tyranny if Texans are to be believed, I (like David) fail to see any necessity in using a cellphone while driving that justifies any increased risk to any other human being under any circumstances.  Want to call?  Pull over.  It’s that simple.

Almost all the arguments made against my view (and death threats are not considered valid arguments around these parts) are based on the slippery slope.  Ban cellphones and the next thing is government will be housing soldiers in your bed.  The argument, of course, is a renown logical fallacy, but remarkably meaningful to true believers.  They’ll have to pry my cellphone from my cold dead fingers.

David’s post not only debunks the argument that cellphone use is harmless, but castigates the cheap political trick of banning hand-held cellphones while permitting hands-free, noting that it’s not the unavailability of a hand that causes the problem, but the unavailability of the mind.  A mind is a terrible thing to waste, particularly when it’s needed for operating a vehicle.

The flaw of the slippery slope is not only that it provides for a limitless extension of a position to all possible permutations, regardless of how tortured, but that most people are unaware of the conceptual ledge, that place on the slope where the argument naturally and legitimately stops its slide. 

My hat is off to David, both for the boldness and thoroughness of his post, as well as the exceedingly good sense to recognize just how ridiculous it is to fall in love with cellphones.  At least in New York.