Author Archives: SHG

Can You Tell if Someone is Lying?

Grits for Breakfast has an important post about lies and deception, and the fact that we have yet to figure out a way to tell.  While most people believe that they can tell, claiming it’s in the eyes, or the nose or some other bodily orifice, the fact is that people aren’t very good at figuring out if another person is telling the truth.  Grits points out that this is true of cops as well, though they, more than others, believe they know.


The problem is just as Anderson identified: The error rate is high, risking the same mistake committed by Othello when he falsely accused Desdemona. According to the (highly recommended) recent book by Richard Leo, Police Interrogations and American Justice (pp. 98-99):

Numerous controlled studies have shown that people are not good intuitive judges of truth and deception, typically performing at no better than chance levels of accuracy. Controlled studies have also shown that even investigators and other supposed experts who routinely evaluate deceptive behavior are highly prone to error. Moreover, Kassin and Fong have shown that police interrogators and others specifically trained in the [Behavioral Analysis Interview technique taught by John Reid and Associates] not only fail to discriminate accurately between true and false statements much of th time, but also that behavior analysis training actually lowers the ability of police interrogators to discriminate accurately between true and false denials. Further, such training inflates their confidence in their judgments. (citations omitted)

Assuming police can accurately judge lie detection leads directly to false accusations and confessions.

Taking this a step farther, the same is true of jurors and judges, neither of whom is endowed with the gift of being able to tell whether a witness is being truthful or lying.  Yet this is one of the tasks we demand of them, perhaps their most important and difficult task.  So then, why do we do so if the fact is clear that they are no more capable than anyone else?  Because we have no better way.

Trial by jury is one of the basic tenets of our legal system.  We rest enormous faith in it, even to the extent of putting people’s lives at risk based upon the decision of twelve ordinary people.  We hold this methodology to be so sacred, so worthy of our trust, that we are willing to kill people if those twelve people tell us to do so.

But if it turns out that the twelve can’t tell a lie from the truth, as well as suffer from some other infirmities that happen when you put a group together and ask it to make a decision, have we created a sham solution?  By pretending that the jury system is far better, far more accurate, than it really is, we take the responsibility off of our own shoulders to find a better answer and fall back on facile maxims, like “it may not be perfect, but it’s the best system there is.”  Is it?

While the defense often goes to trial without witnesses, since the burden of proof is on the prosecution, we are often told by jurors afterward that the absence of any human being (particularly the defendant) taking the witness stand and telling the jury that he didn’t commit the crime is a glaring omission.  Yes, the jury is instructed that the defendant has no obligation to testify, and that they cannot infer anything from his failure to testify.  As if an instruction from a judge undoes the basic human expectation that an innocent person would deny his guilt.

There are two reasons why defendants don’t testify.  The first is thrust upon the defense, as the defendant’s prior criminal history will be brought into the case and thus inform the jury that he’s prone to commit crimes.  Propensity, of course, is not a permissible reason to raise a defendant’s prior criminal history, so we’ve come up with a bunch of other excuses to let it in, thereby making sure that the jury knows about the defendant’s propensity while pretending that they would never let that affect their decision.

The second reason is that defendants often don’t come off well as witnesses.  They are in unfamiliar surroundings, with rules of engagement that are abnormal.  They aren’t schooled or sufficiently practiced the manner of appearing truthful and deflecting difficult questions.  When they don’t understand a question, or fear that it’s a trick, their eyes may dart toward their lawyer and give the appearance that they are being shifty.  They may hesitate before answering, giving the appearance that they are constructing a lie.  They may appear cocky and unlikeable.  They may not be very good at expressing themselves verbally.  They may get angry, and say things they don’t mean.  There’s a long list of things that defendants may appear to be as witnesses, and few are good for them

But none of these things necessarily has anything to do with whether they are lying or telling the truth.  They relate to our understanding of how jurors perceive people to be lying or telling the truth.  We advise defendants not to testify because we believe that jurors will believe them to be liars, even though they may be 100% truthful. 

I’ve written many times about the arm-squeeze moment, during the cops testimony when the defendant grabs your arm and whispers in your ear, “he’s lying.”  And maybe he is, but the sky doesn’t all and no red lights flash or sirens sound.  Cops lie well.  They are trained to provide persuasive testimony, and to artfully deflect questions that present problems.  They keep their cool and have convenient lapses in memory.  They look demure, dressed nicely in their going-to-court clothing, with their sincere faces turned ever so slightly toward the jury. 

I have no answer to the question of how we are to construct a legal system that can accurately distinguish a lie from the truth.  But I know that we aren’t paying much attention to the problem, and rely instead on our old, trusty jury system, even though we know that jurors are no better than cops, or anyone else, at telling one from the other.  But after all, the system “may not be perfect, but it’s the best there is.”  And isn’t that good enough?

To Serve the Elderly

No, it’s not a cookbook.  But as our society ages, lawyers should be aware of what’s happening in other areas with older Americans as well as those that impact us professionally and personally, such as DWE.

The New York Times has an article this morning about the Senate Republican’s cut of 10.6% in Medicare reimbursement rates.  The American Medical Association has launched a series of ads to fight this cut, but it remains to be seen whether this effort will have any impact.  President Bush (you remember him, he’s the guy that John McCain never talks about) says he will veto legislation restoring the cuts.

The rationale is to “rein in the rising cost of health care.”  Certainly a worthy cause, in a vacuum.  But like most overarching ideals, the devil is in the details.  On whose back will costs be controlled.  The Big Insurance Companies?  No.  Pharmaceutical Companies?  No.  The physician?  Yes. 

Consider Medicare the health care equivalent of indigent defense.  Doctors who take Medicare patients are required to accept the reimbursement rates set by Medicare, rates that have been unilaterally reduced for years.  The rates bear no relationship to the costs of a medical practice.  They just are. 

The rates paid for treatment of military and veterans are tied to Medicare, so what’s said about one applies equally to the other.

When Medicare reduces payments to doctors, fees under the military program are also reduced, and it becomes more difficult for military families to find doctors.

Congress is “playing chicken with your health care,” the Military Officers Association of America told its members in a bulletin last week.

Irony stems from the pretense that the Republicans love our military.  They wear lapel flag pins to prove it.  They give speeches about supporting the military.  Then they cut the reimbursement rate for their doctors?  They may love them, but they don’t want to pay for them.  Do active duty soldiers know about this? 

To put it bluntly, the reimbursement rates before the cut were incredibly low.  Low, as in barely meeting the cost of doing business, without being able to make a profit.  You see, health care professionals have costs too.  They have staff and rent.  They have equipment to perform tests, and it’s not only expensive, but needs constant love to keep it functioning properly.  Even the basic stuff they use in their offices, like those tongue depressors, get tossed after each use and have to be replaced.  It all costs money.  And after it’s all paid for, the docs would like to earn a little for themselves.
As the maneuvering goes on in Washington, doctors around the country have begun to reassess their participation in Medicare.

Dr. David D. Richardson, 40, an ophthalmologist in Los Angeles County, closed his practice last week to all but emergency patients and those needing surgery.

“I love practicing medicine,” Dr. Richardson said, “but I would lose more money by keeping my office open than by pulling it back to a skeleton crew. Just like a physician in the emergency room, I try to reduce the hemorrhaging.”
Did I mention caps?  Have a stroke?  You may need physical therapy and speech therapy, but they are both lumped together with a cap of $1,800.  You can walk or you can talk, but you can’t get enough treatment to do both. 

We must rein in health care costs.   Many in health care will not turn away a Medicare patient, just because it seems wrong to do so.  These are our older Americans, our mothers and fathers, grandparents, who need treatment.  We want them to feel well and enjoy life.  They worked hard, raised us, sacrificed for us and we owe them for all they have done. 

But this is true of Republican Senators as well.  Some of them had parents.  Where’s their sense of debt for their elders?  Well, given the constitution of the Senate, combined with a spectacular health plan that far surpasses anything mere mortals (other than cops and teachers) would receive, they are the elders and they’re doing just fine.

So each physician, each allied health care provider, must make a personal decision of whether to treat an older person under Medicare, and accept whatever amount Medicare decides to pay that day, even though the reimbursement rate is lower than the actual cost of treatment.  They are no longer giving only of their time, but they are now going to suffer an actual financial loss to treat the elderly.  The health care provider is paying part of the bill when the old folks receive treatment.  And old folks tend to need more treatment than most.

So be nice to the doc who treats grandma.  Chances are that she’s covering part of the bill because Medicare won’t.  And if she decided that she will no longer pay part of that bill, who’s going to serve the elderly?

This Year’s Loser Job

Some might say that getting any job this year is a coup.  After all, jobs aren’t easy to find this year.  Even for kids with newly minted law degrees.  But this year, as always, there are the cool jobs and the loser jobs.  They are the same jobs that have always existed, but the cool/loser denomination changes with the tide. 

Last September, there was a depressing report that law students didn’t want to go into criminal defense anymore.  The report came from Skelly, who keeps his finger on the pulse of the public defender world.  It’s a weak pulse, Skelly informs, and he would know.

Today marks the first day on the job of another new public defender, according to Skelly’s post at Arbitrary & Capricious.  This former law student, now budding PD, captures his enthusiasm for his foray into the trenches at a blog entitled, I Immediately Regret This Decision.


As of 8:30 AM on Monday I will be officially employed. I’m working for a local public defender but I don’t know whether to be excited or bummed. It will be nice to have a little more structure in my life and a feeling that I am accomplishing something, but it was REALLY nice to do the things I wanted on my own terms. I had a great little schedule worked out and I was doing the things that I wanted to do. Now recess is over. After my stint with the New Orleans public defender, I have a vague idea of what to expect, lots of motions to exclude and habeas corpus petitions. That’s fine with me, I don’t hate that kind of writing and research. But, again, part of me is a little uneasy with defending people (not ALL, obviously) who have committed crimes. I suppose it really comes down to the fact that EVERYONE gets a fair trial, whether they have money or not.

I get an image of this person staring in the bathroom mirror, trying very hard to convince themself to put on a tie for the first day of work, and fighting the feeling that he should just go back to bed.  Why?


What’s funny about all this is that I hope to be a prosecutor once I graduate.

It’s that simple.  This isn’t the dream job.  This is the default job.  The loser job. 

It’s hard to imagine that he went into the job interview and said out loud that he really doesn’t want to be a PD, but couldn’t get the good job at the DA’s office, so he’s here instead.  But that may well have happened, if the applicants to the PD jobs are largely prosecutor rejects.  Maybe the PD doesn’t have a lot of choice, and is happy to pick from the best of the losers to staff the office.

The transition from school to work is fraught with disappointments for most people.  Sure, there are always those who get everything they ever wanted and dreamed about, but these are the ones who end up miserable in 7 figure jobs or, worse yet, as lawprofs, forever trying to persuade others that their novel theory is valid.  The rest try to get into dream college, dream law school and ultimately the dream job.  Sometimes they come close.  More often, they settle.

Being a public defender was once a cool job.  You did good for others (a cool thing).  You had cool people in your office with you, and you got to hang out with them after work (also cool).  You didn’t have to put on “airs” and pretend that your father forced you to take that Biglaw job, when you really wanted to be a PD.  And best of all, when you met an attractive person of the opposite sex in a bar and told them what you do, they would respond, “that must be SOOOOO exciting.”  Nobody every says that to a transactional lawyer.  

Nobody would even admit, back in my day, that they were a prosecutor.  A prosecutor was one of those evil people who worked for “the Man” keeping the people down.  Of course, the prosecutor was no more evil than the PD was the saint, but that was the perception.  It was a product of the times.

Skelly, who seeks out these young people with their negative attitude, has a hard time dealing with this too.  He writes:


… to keep my middle-aged p.d. head from shaking, I’m thinking of all the cool young lawyers who, rather than fall into indigent defense work, strive for it heartily and dive into it enthusiastically. I know they exist – I’ve worked with many, and hired a few myself. Others I know from reading their blogs.

But Skelly surely sees that it’s different.  It’s no longer cool to be a public defender.  There are excellent reasons to be one, and the system could not function without them.  They still perform a vital function, which society should and must appreciate.  But when young people are compelled to rationalize why they should go to work on their first day as a PD, it’s painful.  What went so wrong that being a public defender is perceived to be the loser job?



Meeting the Neighbors

As regular readers know, I’ve been trying to push my local newspaper, Newsday, to improve its content, particularly its editorial content, through constructive criticism.  Since Newday’s subscribership has floundered, perhaps they would consider my friendly suggestions.

In the course of this effort, I’ve paid closer attention to the comments section to their editorials, and have offered some contributions that would, perhaps, challenge the editorial board to consider more pointed and fully conceived positions.  Because I do this very early in the morning, and was not stopping back later to see what developed, it seems that I missed out on a very important development, the comments of my fellow residents of Long Island.  When I did, I was surprised, to put it mildly.

For those who hail from elsewhere, Long Island is largely a mature, bedroom suburb of New York City, having been developed after World War II.  Before that, it was the country home of the old guard (read The Great Gatsby) and clamdiggers.  As a suburb of the Big Apple, one might suspect that it shares a certain educational, cosmopolitan culture, together with its liberal leanings.  One might suspect that.  One might be wrong.

I took a look back at two recent editorials that caught my interest, the first, Policing the Police, and the second, True Patriots Ask Questions.  Neither editorial, from my perspective, was particularly controversial.  Indeed, both were relatively pointless, stating the obvious and offering nothing constructive or novel.  These were what I would call “safe” editorials, designed to offend no one.

But that didn’t mean that they didn’t generate some interesting comments from readers.  At least, I supposed they are readers, giving them the benefit of the doubt that they can read.  The first thing that struck me is the pervasiveness of anonymity by commenters, emboldening them to post things that they would never say if we knew who they were.  There were venomous comments, replete with racism and anti-semitism.  In my mind’s eye, I saw bumper stickers on all their cars.   The bumper stickers have angry slogans on them. 

I’m a pretty social fellow, and know my neighbors.  We’re friendly.  We talk.  We enjoy dinners together, as well as the occasional cocktail.  We talk some more.  Never in all these conversations did any of my neighbors express the thoughts that appear in these comments.  Here are the comments to Policing the Police.  Here are the comments to True Patriots Ask Questions.  Who are these people?

It is clear that these Newsday forums have become a clearinghouse for the worst of Long Island, where anonymous posters can express their deepest hatred and prejudice toward others.  It is clear that these are mostly uneducated people.  It is clear, at least in the comments to the police editorial, that many of the most offensive comments come from police officers, providing us insight to their true thoughts.  They truly do believe that they are a completely insular group, defensive of their foibles and antagonistic to everyone outside their sphere.

I am deeply disturbed to learn that these are my neighbors.  I like my neighbors, but I don’t like these people.  I am shocked to learn how they really feel.  I am saddened to think that this could be the person next door, to whom I wave good morning and share a barbecued burger. 

I get some strange and stupid comments here from time to time, but they aren’t even close to the types of comments left at Newsday in terms of hatred and offensiveness.  When someone leaves an offensive comment here, I remove it.  I subscribe to the “broken windows” theory, that offensive comments will breed even more offensive comments.  It’s not my purpose to become a warehouse for prejudice, hatred and stupidity. 

This is not about comments from people with whom I agree or disagree.  Intelligent argument makes for better decisions.  But this was a slew of attacks, with no cognizable thought involved.  I knew there were a lot of angry people around, but never before was I so painfully clear on who they blamed for their misery.

In reading the Newsday comments, I wondered why any intelligent person would want to express an opinion there, only to be subjected to being slammed by the ignorant.  When this is allowed, it becomes a magnet for the angry, an outlet for hatred and resource for the stupid who want to know that they are not alone in their stupidity.  Just like misery, stupid loves company.

Now that I’ve had the pleasure of following the comments on these two editorials, I can’t think of any reason to venture back for more.  There was not a single comment that was illuminating or thought-provoking, other than the thought that these were horrible comments.  These are definitely not the same people as read the New York Times.

Newsday is sending a message, at least to me, by way of these comments.  It is telling me that they are the newspaper of the angry, the prejudiced, the ignorant.  They could oversee and control their comment section to rid themselves of this crowd, and promote a far higher level of discussion to show that there is a place where thoughtful and concerned people can share ideas and challenge each other’s notions of right and wrong.  They could, but they don’t.

Perhaps this is some misguided devotion to free speech, where someone believes that it would be wrong to censor the voices of their readers, no matter what those voices are saying.  But this failure to prevent their comments from spiraling out of control disenfranchises more thoughtful voices, who are left with no place but the gutter should they desire to speak.  Limiting commentary to respectful expressions is not censorship, but an expansion of freedom.  The screaming of the mob will always drown out the softer voices. 

Or maybe Newsday knows something that I don’t; that these are my real neighbors, without the friendly faces they wear when the wave back at me, and that it doesn’t get any better than this.  If so, it’s time to move.

Better to Be Lucky

Reading a post over at Grits, about the false confession prosecution of Frank Esposito, got me thinking.  Scott Henson’s point was about videotaping confessions, a concept about which I am ambivalent because I’ve seen otherwise fine ideas undermined by the perpetual tension between the need to convict at any cost and honesty, but this isn’t about videotaping.  It’s about luck.

Frank Esposito was represented at trial by Nicholas A. Gravante Jr., of Boies, Schiller & Flexner.  His family mortgaged their home to pay the $150,000 legal fee.  When that ran out, as it was nearly certain to do with the Boies firm unless it was a quickie plea, the Esposito family caught a break.  When Gravante informed David Boies that the cellphone records proved the confession to be false, Boies told him to run with the case even though the defendant couldn’t pay.  The legal bill ended up in the half million neighborhood.  Esposito was acquitted.

On its surface, this sounds like a success story.  After all, defendant wins and justice is done, right?  But on deeper scrutiny, Esposito’s acquittal is due to a series of fortunate events, strung together to produce the result.  I don’t want to negate the efforts of Gravante, as good lawyering creates good fortune and capitalizes on it, and he did everything he could use luck in the defendant’s favor.

But even the fact that Esposito had Gravante in his corner was a matter of good luck.  He had a family willing and capable of paying a $150,000 retainer to the Boies firm.  The law firm was willing to eat 70% of the legal fee and expenses.  And ultimately, the cellphone company’s records remained intact until they were obtained by the defense. 

One of the most disturbing aspects of this job of criminal defense lawyering is watching luck run out.  The story of Esposito and Gravante is instructive because of the commitment to defending against false charges from the outset.  There are always things that will happen outside of our control, but the greatest opportunity to capitalize on good fortune exists at the beginning.  The opportunity dwindles appreciatively as time goes by. 

Whether it’s locating witnesses, or evidence, or preventing an indictment before the presentment, the earlier one deals with it the better.  But this requires defendants and their families to see it that way as well.  Too often, they don’t.  What we do see is denial and misguided optimism.

A friend told me yesterday that I am a pessimist.  I responded that I’m a believer in hoping for the best, but preparing for the worst.  If that’s pessimism, than I’m guilty.  But unprepared people lose, and I don’t want to lose.  Still, if the choice is not in my hands, there’s little I can do.

Recently, I met with a potential client who was unbelievably lucky.  He knew, well in advance, that he was going to be arrested and prosecuted for a white-collar crime.  In the interim, he made statements to everyone in sight, both orally and in writing.  He was very smart and well educated, but, by his own admission, an “idiot savant” when it came to the law.  Fair enough. 

Since we were at the pre-arrest stage, the options available were plentiful and opportunities were about as good as they were going to be to prepare for the prosecution before law enforcement shut down our ability to collect evidence and witnesses for the defense.  There was also the matter of preparing the defendant for his day in the sun, which would be ruinous for his career if not properly managed.  This was a huge opportunity, and he was enormously lucky to have it.

But he blew it.  Rather than see what could be done and how it would impact his future, he was unsure of whether all this effort would be necessary.  He wanted to first be certain that “this was serous” before committing himself.  It was purely a financial decision, driven by the “penny wise, pound foolish” motive. 

I’ve seen this thousands of times over my career, defendants concerned but not enough to commit.  They hear stories about some people who somehow escaped prosecution by some quirk of fate, and they can’t help but hope that they too will enjoy such fantastic fortune.  This does happen, on occasion, but rarely.  And when it does, the defendants believe themselves to be brilliant for having made the right choice.  They aren’t brilliant.  They are lucky.

In the vast majority of cases, the defendants aren’t so lucky.  By the time they realize that this is serious, they have squandered most of their luck.  Opportunity is lost.  They come back to me, if they aren’t embarrassed by their poor decision, asking if I would take them back.  They want to know if we can go back to the beginning, do all the things we talked about way back when.  They apologize.  They are sorry they didn’t take it seriously in the first place.

There’s no reason to be embarrassed or to apologize.  I’m not judgmental about this.  Their choices, though foolish, are common.  And the job of a criminal defense lawyer is to take defendants as they come to you, for better or worse.  But no, we can’t go back to the beginning, and we can’t do all the things we talked about way back when.  That window of opportunity slammed shut. 

More often than not, a new facet of representation is required as a result of their choices.  Rather than attack the prosecution in a pro-active fashion, the first line of defense is to undo all the half-baked work that had been done by the cheapo lawyer up to that point.  Waivers of rights, bad (really bad) motion practice, concessions to the prosecutor in private conversations that create his frame of reference and approach.  The list is long.  The damage is severe.  The defendant neither knows nor understands the degree of harm done to his defense.

Rather than dedicate efforts toward winning the case, time is directed at undoing damage to the extent possible and then cutting losses.  Ironically, the defendant ends up at best in a neutral position as a result of his attempt to cheap out in the early days, but more likely in a hole where he is futilely struggling to claw his way out.  Even more ironic is that it ends up costing more to undo damage than it would to achieve success.  He outsmarted himself.

It’s easy to understand why defendants are reluctant to seize the opportunity up front.  Retaining a good criminal defense lawyer is dead money.  There’s no return on your investment in the sense of interest and dividends, a quantifiable benefit that you can put in your pocket when the case is over.  There’s no guarantee of success, a perpetual problem for honest lawyers and a great source of revenue for dishonest ones.  And the general perception that lawyers, as a profession, are untrustworthy, greedy, lying, self-serving, incompetent and abusive (this is the short list). 

But when you hear about cases like Frank Esposito, or Marty Tankleff, or the handful of others that are so unusual that they are newsworthy and make their way from the courtroom to the living room, consider all the stars that had to align in order for success to be achieved.  This is pure luck.  But at the same time, there was a criminal defense lawyer laboring in the background to seize upon the good fortune and make it work in the defendant’s favor.  Without that lawyer, no one would notice these lucky opportunities, take advantage of them and turn that defendant’s good fortune
into a success. 

It’s better to be lucky.  But the likelihood of being lucky depends on having a good lawyer standing beside you.

DWE

The ever-thoughtful and provocative Frank Pasquale at Concurring Opinions raised the difficult issue of Driving While Elderly.  Our aging population makes this issue increasingly consequential, but similarly difficult to address, both on a personal as well as systemic level.  As one commenter to Frank’s post noted, “For young drivers driving is privilege. For elderly drivers it’s a sanctioned right.”  Very true.

There has been much discussion around the practical blawgosphere about DWI, and whether it should be a crime, and if not, how then to deal with it.  One hard truth to the DWI discussion is that drunk driving is not the only thing that happens behind the wheel of a car that has a high propensity to cause harm.  But drunk driving is volitional, whereas aging is not.  Drunk driving has few proponents, whereas aging has many, and they are powerful and wealthy.  Drunk driving has little inherent justification, whereas the need of elderly people to drive in a mobile society means independent survival.

But, the person dead at the hand of an elderly driver is just as dead as the person run down by the drunk.

It’s not a crime to grow old.  Indeed, most of us hope to do so.  Some of us are closer to accomplishing this hope than others.  And some of us are confronting the problems incumbent with aging even as we write.  It is an unbelievably difficult problem.  Some of us pray for the day that the ravages of age become so clear and overwhelming that we can grab the keys away from our aging charges without hesitation and with a clear conscience.  But aging doesn’t happen overnight.

Day by day, month by month, small changes happen.  We usually can’t see them until the small changes add up to big ones, like dementia or loss of vision or hearing.  But even then, we see things along the way that leads us to believe that DWE presents an unwarranted risk, both to our loved ones as well as people we will never know. 

Still, the changes don’t come in a clean and clear fashion.  One day, the fingers can’t grip a steering wheel.  The next, they seem to hold on just fine.  One day, they can spot an red-tailed hawk a mile away, and the next they can’t see the car to their left.  Just when we think the day has come, they make us eat our words and prove that they are still alive, still capable of being “alive”.

Frank raised and shoots down the economic model, promoted by Richard Posner, of dealing with the problem.  Poster contends that insurance costs for the elderly will drive those who cannot handle the wheel anymore out of the market.  Pasquale responds that it will drive the poor away, but leave the wealthy elderly free to run down as many people as they can afford.  Financial incentives apply unevenly. 

We look to external solutions because we have such terrible difficulty dealing with the problem on a personal level.  Try telling your mother, who carried you for nine months, who stays up with you at night when you were sick, who bandaged your wounds, that she’s too old to drive anymore.  Just wait until you look into her eyes, hear her quivering voice, pleading with you not to end her life.

The chance of a political solution is slim, given the clout of the AARP and the general sympathy toward our elders.  And they are as firm in their resolve as the NRA, if not more so.

And yet, the victim of an elderly person driving incompetently is just as dead as the victim of a drunk driver.  It’s a very serious dilemma, and it will become an increasingly significant problem, as Frank correctly points out, as time goes on.  Will there be a group called MADE advocating elderly checkpoints? 

Wanna Fight with Snow White?

Taking arguments to their logical extreme is a tool used to test validity.  But taking a gun to Disney World is barely a hop, skip and jump down the road. 

Via Turley, it seems that Florida has yet again emerged as the pre-eminent testing ground for all things bizarre.  This time, Florida has passed a gun law that doesn’t even begin to touch on the scope of rights that may (or may not) be covered by the 2d Amendment, and yet raises problems.  According to WESH in Orlando :



Several major theme park companies are challenging a new Florida law that allows people to keep guns in their cars.



The new law went into effect Tuesday and allows employees to bring their guns to work as long as they have a concealed weapons permit and keep the weapon in their car. 


Neither Disney nor Universal Studios is amused.  It seems that they don’t want guns on their property.  It strikes me that their parking lots will become a version of “guns-r-us” if they allow people to bring them, then force them to leave the weapons in cars.  Anybody want to venture back to the parking lot, unarmed, after a wild day at Universal to find out who’s been looking in your car?

The arguments flesh out like this:

“No guns on property. It’s a family facility. I don’t think there should be any firearms at all,” Disney employee Lee Morgan said.


“It’s typical of Disney. They have no regard for the safety of their customers or their employees,” Marion Hammer of the National Rifle Association said.

While I don’t think the NRA nailed this one, it’s just the beginning of an effort to change the face of society at the point of a gun. 

While the 2d Amendment applies only to the government’s (and for the moment only the federal government’s) efforts to limit the fundamental freedom of Americans to keep and bear arms, and does not have any bearing on the rights of private parties to prohibit weapons on their property, we must anticipate these situations arising on a regular basis from now on.  Consider, if people have guns (even though the 2d Amendment for the moment only provides a right to keep them within your home) on their person, they will still have guns when the enter stores, malls, entertainment venues and your home.

While the Supreme Court no longer seems to suffer the constraints of rational decision-making, as evidenced by pages 57-58 of the slip opinion in Heller, it may fall to other courts, legislatures and executives to explain how a right now enunciated can be subject to ad hoc application and denial.  In other words, now that the barn doors are open, it should come as no surprise that the horses are going to run out.

This will produce some wild and crazy results, and perhaps even some really good arguments by the NRA.  Stay tuned.

Messages Sent, Messages Received

One of our favorite lawyer expressions is “sending a message,” used to explain why something that is otherwise inexplicable happened.  It is beloved by prosecutors and judges, who “send messages” about how people shouldn’t commit crimes by seeking or imposing incredible sentences.  Defense lawyers like to use it as well, but we don’t get nearly as many opportunities.

It is axiomatic that communication is comprised of two parts, sending and receiving.  Lawyers focus on the sending piece, where we send messages to “society” that some conduct won’t be tolerated.  What we fail to consider is the messages received, the ones that real people pick up on as a consequence of our legal system. 

Message sent are almost invariably announced as such.  When a judge imposes a sentence of more than 236 years in prison (without possibility of parole), she wants everyone to know that she does so to send a message, and expressly says as much, lest anyone think she’s merely bad at math or unfamiliar with the normal lifespan of human beings.  The message is, do the crime and you will be locked away for the rest of your life.  The intent of the message is general deterrence.

The reason for the “message sent” strategy is that those who indulge in it figure that people need a stark reminder that criminal conduct is wrong, and that they shouldn’t do it.  But, of course, the fact that certain conduct is criminal in the first place is intended to send that message.  It would be one thing if the consequence for certain conduct, say murder, was a “slap on the wrist,” a reference to a punishment that is inadequate to deter a person from committing the crime.  By balancing the desire to commit the crime with the punishment imposed (if one gets caught, a separate and more important factor, but not one to be discussed today), rational people inclined to engage in criminal conduct might willingly take the punishment in exchange for committing the crime.

But is the potential “ordinary” punishment for a murder, say a maximum of 25 years to life in prison in New York, insufficient to deter someone from doing it?  Many would answer yes, since murders keep happening.  But if 25 to life is inadequate to deter a murder, would 236 years change the potential murderer’s mind?  The obvious answer is no.  The length of punishment becomes just more of the same.  If life won’t do it, will a two lives in prison?  Or 5 lives?  It’s just silly.

Now to the point of this post.  Criminal defense lawyers learn from our clients the messages that they receive from our legal system and government.  I also receive a surprising number of emails as a result of this blawg from people who want to express their understanding of the law and the system.  It’s not a pretty picture.

To the extent that “messages sent” become “messages received,” the message is that the system is harsh and irrational.  Impose a sentence of 236 years, which even the dumbest criminal recognizes to extend beyond a human life, and they find it laughable.  While the judge believes she is being “tough”, the message is that she’s a nitwit.  Nobody lives that long, they realize.  “Doesn’t the stupid judge know this?” 

This, of course, is not the message intended, but it’s the message received.  Rather than strike fear in the hearts of potential perpetrators, it reduces the sentence to a farce. 

But the “message received” side of the equation gets worse.  More often, the “message received” comes when no message is sent, but when the legal system simply does what it normally does.  For example, in the case of Marty Tankleff, who spend 17 years in prison and was subsequently released after an appellate court determined that there was sufficient evidence to show that his conviction for the murder of his parents was based upon unreliable and inadequate evidence, the message received was loud and clear:  The system is unfair, unreliable and unacceptable.  If an appellate court does not believe the conclusions of a jury, and 17 years later, a trial judge, when how can the public trust a judge to properly and adequately do his job?

For lawyers, we look at the release and dismissal of charges against Tankleff as a success of the legal system.  Marty won.  He got out.  The indictment was dismissed.  Aren’t we wonderful!  But this is an example of thinking like a lawyer, which Anne Reed warns us not to do, and David Giacalone reminds us does not require us to think like an ass.

To the non-lawyer world, Tankleff stands for the failure of the legal system.  They see 17 years in prison for an unproven crime.  They see a one-in-a-million chance at reversal almost two decades later.  They see the wrong person convicted, the system trying desperately to defend the conviction despite the fact that it flies in the face of all the fine rhetoric that we use to promote the system, and proof that the system failed at every point along the way, until this one lucky kid finally got a fair shake.

A more subtle, but far more pervasive, message received comes from the our system’s inability to discern truth from lies.  We pretend that a trial provides a magic way to ferret out lies and reveal the truth.  But we are only kidding ourselves.  A situation occurs on the street.  Present are a couple of cops and a person, later to be called the perpetrator and then the defendant.  No one, other than these three people, know what actually happened on the street.  But these three people do know, and their reality will not be altered by any fact-finding later in a courtroom, no matter how well our systematic protections are applied.

Initially, the two cops provide a written description of the person’s (now called the “perp”) conduct.  It falls somewhere along the spectrum of truthfulness and expediency, assuming that the perp in fact committed a crime and the cops’ purpose is to get him prosecuted for it.  But the details are changed, whether to eliminate some impropriety along the way, or to embellish the wrongdoing to assure a conviction or enhance leverage.  Assuming it’s not entirely false, it’s not entirely true either.

The message received is that the government, the cops, the system, promotes lying to achieve it’s societally beneficial goals.  The message received is that lying, conduct that is malum in se, is an accepted and acceptable weapon in the conflict between cops and other persons.  When the perps turn into defendants, they tell their lawyers about this.  Our response is, “this is how it happens.”

This is a terrible response.  It’s true, but worthless to the defendant.  While words like “truth” and “justice” are uttered ad naseum, the message received is that the best liar prevails, and that the government’s lies are happily accepted by the judge as truth, even though the defendant knows them to be lies.  This is the problematic part:  No matter how deeply the judge believes the cops to be telling the truth, the defendant still knows that the cops are lying.  The system cannot change this. 

And eventually the cause comes on for trial.  Witnesses swear to God, then lie.  The judge and jury nod their head knowingly, as one cop tells a  story and the other backs him up.  It sounds so normal, so factual.  The prosecutor argues that the cops have no reason to lie, to frame an innocent man.  The arguments are compelling.  Even the defendant, listening to the testimony, recognizes that it sounds completely plausible.&
nbsp; Except that it’s untrue, whether in whole or part.

The message received, by the defendant, by his family, by his friends, is that it is a system built on lies, deception and ignorance.  As the judge and jury decide with certainty, beyond a reasonable doubt, that a lie is true, the message received is that there is no such thing as justice, and that obedience to the law is sham.  If there was any value to obedience to the law, then cops would not swear to God and then lie.  If there was any integrity to the system of law, then judges wouldn’t blindly accept the cops’ word as truth.

Defendants have asked me, far more times than I can recall, “how can the cops lie?”  I’ve struggled for years to come up with an answer that will both explain the phenomenon as well as instill a belief that our system is not inherently rotten and that it is worthwhile to be honest and obey the law.  But the message received is that the system is an unfair game, and that the winner of the game is the one who can lie and deceive better than the other side. 

This has never been the message intended to be sent, but this is the message received.

Sitting in the Dock of the ‘Bay

One of the problems with doing something kinda witty is that stupid people won’t get it.  That isn’t a problem from the perspective of their getting the point, but it can be troubling if the stupid people have the power to arrest and prosecute you.

And so it happened to 19 year old University of Minnesota student, Max P. Sanders.  From this CNN report, via Turley, after putting his vote up for auction on eBay, with a minimum bid of $10, Sanders was arrested and charged “with one count of bribery, treating and soliciting under an 1893 state law that makes it a crime to offer to buy or sell a vote” in Hennepin County District Court.  It was a witty little protest, except to the Hennepin County Attorney.

“We take it very seriously. Fundamentally, we believe it is wrong to sell your vote,” said John Aiken, a spokesman for the office. “There are people that have died for this country for our right to vote, and to take something that lightly, to say, ‘I can be bought.’

“It’s a real shame,” he said. “I can imagine the conversations being held in American Legion Clubs and VFWs about whether this is a joke or not.”

Really?  I can imagine those old geezers, who watched as their friends gave their lives for this country, wondering aloud whether the Hennepin County Attorney is a moron.  People who fought and died in wars did so for serious reasons.  And they could tell the difference between a joke and a crime.


The charge carries up to five years’ imprisonment and a $10,000 fine.

Do they take paypal?

Are You a Justice Maker?

Everyone loves a contest, so why not a contest for Justice?


GENEVA, June 24 – A competition for innovations that end torture, arbitrary detainment and abuse is being announced by International Bridges to Justice (IBJ). Called JusticeMakers, the initiative launches on June 26th, the United Nations International Day in Support of Victims of Torture. The competition will award $5,000 to the eight best proposals for concrete, achievable action. JusticeMakers is open to anyone with an idea and a familiarity with his or her country’s criminal justice system.

Cash.  Justice.  What’s not to like?

This contest is run by an organization called International Bridges to Justice.


International Bridges to Justice: we are a US-registered (501 (c) (3) non-profit organization dedicated to the promotion of criminal justice in developing and transitional countries with a particular emphasis on criminal defense. Our founder and CEO is Karen I. Tse, a former Public Defender who was recently named by the US News and World Report as one of America’s Best Leaders and is going to be granted the American Bar Association Award on August 8 for her work through International Bridges to Justice.

While I am unfamiliar with this group, and can’t vouch for any winner getting paid or, for that matter, investigated by any of our fine alphabet investigative agencies for becoming involved with IBJ, bear in mind that anyone who has had the temerity to visit Simple Justice is likely to already have a folder in the J. Edgar Hoover Building, and so you might as well try your hand at Justice and win, win, win!

Anyone wishing to apply, or just check out what these guys are up to, should visit the Justice Makers website.  The contest runs through August 14, 2008.  After that, you will just have to come up with great ideas for justice for free.