Author Archives: SHG

Ask Mr. Simple Justice, Gun Edition

As anticipated, a flurry of questions from the groundlings have followed the media’s reporting of the Supreme Court’s decision in Heller.  And I am nothing if not helpful.


Why do citizens of New York City need a PERMIT or PERMISSION to exercise a right now reaffirmed to be guaranteed under the US constitution?

Because Justice Scalia said so.


Does NYC require a permit to exercise the Rights of Free Speech, the Right to Privacy, etc? Does a citizen have to PAY TO [EXERCISE]THOSE RIGHTS?

Duh.  Haven’t you ever been to the Gay Pride Parade? 


Just as poll taxes were used in the South to deny African-Americans the right to vote, NYC’s blatantly high fees and arbitrary permitting process deny New Yorkers their newly re-affirmed right to own a gun.

This isn’t a question, but I’ll help you out anyway.  Comparing poll taxes to gun rights requires a knowledge of American history that few people possess, and reveals you to be an egg-head and thus unqualified to possess a weapon, thus making the permitting process denying you your right anything but arbitrary.


To file a permit to own a firearm for target or hunting use, applicants are required to file a $300 fee. For what?  And they then force you to purchase the gun from a selected list of stores.

Running the United States is not an inexpensive proposition.  Do you have any idea what a cruise missle costs?  If you aren’t willing to do your part, then you have no business demanding constitutional rights.  As for the approved gun stores, maybe you would like to have just anybody selling guns in New York, comrade?


Why isn’t the Federal firearms background check sufficient in applying for this permit?
NYC has decided that the Federal background check performed and accepted across the United States when purchasing a firearm is NOT sufficient.

Because acceptance of the federal firearms background check would preclude NYC from charging a fee to do its own, and thus impede its ability to capitalize on Justice Scalia’s pronouncement that nothing in Heller should be read as to preclude any existing revenue raising measures from remaining in full force and effect.


Who are the unelected City and NYPD bureaucrats who routinely deny New Yorkers their rights?

Why, that would be your friendly neighborhood police brass.  The same ones who turn on the sirens on their police cruisers so that they can make it to Dunkin Donuts at the precise time when the fresh donuts come out of the back room.


My wife caught a felony when she was picking up a package with half a key for me from my buddy, but I only have a misdemeanor when I plead down my assault for beating up this [expletive deleted] who I should have killed when he cut me off.  Can I still keep my gun?

Absolutely, but you will have to get rid of your wife.  She’s a felon.

Steven Hatfill is still a Person of Interest

Reports abound over the deal cut for Dr. Steven J. Hatfill, perpetual person of interest in the seven year old Anthrax scare following 9/11.  While the Hatfill saga seems like ancient history to most of us, where the former Army scientist became the focus of the FBI’s investigation into letters containing Anthrax virus sent to members of Congress and the media, it’s daily reality to Dr. Hatfill.

But Hatfill, aside from his public denials of having anything whatsoever to do with these letters, sued the government in 2003.  Now they’ve settled.  Here’s the deal :


The settlement calls for an immediate $2.82-million payment to Hatfill. Beginning in 2009, the government will pay Hatfill an annuity of $150,000 a year for 20 years, according to court papers.

Of course, the lawyers take their cut up front.  It was initially reported that Hatfill’s attorney, Mark Grannis, was putting the entire check in his pocket, but reports have backed off that piece, so it’s possible that Hatfill will get enough out of the big check to fill up the tank of his pick-up truck.

But settlement notwithstanding, the wheels of law enforcement continue to grind. 


“The government remains resolute in its investigation into the anthrax attacks, which killed five individuals and sickened others after lethal anthrax powder was sent through the United States mail,” Mr. Roehrkasse said. 

An F.B.I. spokesman, Jason Pack, said the anthrax investigation “is one of the largest and most complex investigations ever conducted by law enforcement” and is currently being pursued by more than 20 agents of the F.B.I. and the Postal Inspection Service. 

“Solving this case is a top priority for the F.B.I. and for the family members of the victims who were killed,” Mr. Pack said.

Twenty FBI and postal agents remain on the case?  Doing what?  Investigating (whatever that means) Hatfill.  You see, he was the only “person of interest” they have, and he remains the only “person of interest” they have. 

However, [Hatfill] was never arrested or charged and a federal judge presiding over his lawsuit said recently that there “is not a scintilla of evidence” linking him to the mailings.

Former federal prosecutors knowledgeable about the investigation said the government payout to Hatfill signified that, in all likelihood, he would never be charged.

Frankly, given the fact that Hatfill will likely be subject to our government’s scrutiny for as long as he lives, precluding him from practicing medicine, working as a government scientists or having anything resembling a normal life, the $150,000 a year payout strikes me as minuscule. 

It seems like somebody at Justice has it stuck in his head that he’s going to get Hatfill, even if it takes forever.  This isn’t just another fine use of our tax dollars, but an example of the disconnect between federal law enforcement focus and reality.  It 24/7 scrutiny over 7 years has failed to reveal a “scintilla of evidence,” maybe he’s, oh, completely and totally innocent of all allegations?

But I can’t leave this discussion of Steven Hatfill before mentioning my favorite snippet of information:

In May 2003, an F.B.I. surveillance car ran over Dr. Hatfill’s foot in Georgetown as he approached the car to take the driver’s picture. He was given a ticket for “walking to create a hazard” and was fined $5.

And that, in a nutshell, sums it all up for me.  Another “proud to be an American” moment.

But What Would Justice Jackson Say About Heller?

My old friend and St. John’s Lawprof, John Quincy* Barrett, has a thing for Robert H. Jackson, who inched his way from Nuremberg Prosecutor to Solicitor General to Attorney General to Supreme Court Justice.  And because of his enthusiasm, I’ve become quite the admirer of Jackson as well, and often ask myself, “but what would Justice Jackson think about this?”

Since finding his way from the Department of Justice to the classroom, John Q. has focused his scholarly attention on Jackson, and has given me (and others on his Jackson List) a fine appreciation of Justice Jackson’s contributions.  And lest you think he’s jaded by his government service, he clerked for Third Circuit Judge A. Leon Higginbotham, Jr. in his formative years, so John Q. can’t be all bad.

But aside from Jackson being a pretty cool guy, why should we care what he would have thought about Heller?  Jackson argued Miller v. U.S. in 1939, the Supreme Court’s last word on the Second Amendment until Heller.  What makes this particularly fascinating is how the government’s position in Miller, serving interests that at the time might be viewed quite favorably from a conservative perspective, have flipped on its head today. 

While most in the academy think us blawgers in the Practical Blawgosphere have neither knowledge nor appreciation of history and precedent, and are only concerned with how a decision impacts our clients in the trenches, this will show how far off base you are.  We care a great deal about scholarly concerns.  We just don’t want you lawprofs to know and get swelled heads.

So here’s John Q.’s take:



During his country boyhood in western Pennsylvania and western New York State, Robert Jackson was very familiar with guns—his later recollection was that every house had one.  His uncle, Dan Houghwot, a careful man, took young Robert hunting and taught him to handle guns safely.  As a high school boy in Frewsburg, New York, Robert often went hiking on his own, usually carrying sandwiches fixed by his mother and sometimes carrying a not-too-heavy “kid’s rifle.”  His pleasure was the hiking, but if he saw something to shoot at—usually woodchucks or groundhogs—he did.  Jackson continued to be a real outdoorsman, a gun owner and occasionally a hunter throughout his life.  One of his pistols is now a museum holding in his adult hometown of Jamestown, New York.



Jackson also was familiar with guns as a constitutional litigator in the Supreme Court of the United States and as a federal law enforcement officer.  In 1939, when Jackson was Solicitor General of the United States, his name was on the top of the government’s brief (click here for a retyped version that is, as far as I know, accurate), and Jackson probably was present in the Supreme Court when his colleague and close friend Gordon Dean argued and won a unanimous decision, Miller v. United States, upholding the constitutionality of a federal prosecution under the National Firearms Act (1934) for transporting an unregistered, unauthorized sawed-off shotgun across state lines.  The Miller Court, adopting Jackson’s written arguments and (I assume) Dean’s oral arguments on behalf of the United States, noted the absence of evidence that possession of such a shotgun was reasonably related “to the preservation or efficiency of a well regulated militia” and, on that basis, the Court declined to “say that the Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear such an instrument.”



A year later, Jackson was Attorney General of the United States.  That spring, he officially transmitted to the Congress draft legislation that would have, in the interests of both international security and national law enforcement, required the registration of all firearms in the United States.  Attorney General Jackson transmitted the proposed bill to the Speaker of the House, Rep. William B. Bankhead (D.-AL), beneath this May 29, 1940, transmittal letter:


My Dear Mr. Speaker:



I desire to recommend legislation to require registration of all firearms in the United States and a record of their transfers, accompanied by the imposition of a nominal tax on each transfer.



Such a step would be of great importance in the interests of national defense, as it would hamper the possible accumulation of firearms on the part of subversive groups.  It is also of outstanding importance in the enforcement of the criminal law.

It is only too well known to require detailed depicting that Federal, state and local law enforcement officers have frequently been killed by desperate criminals who equip themselves with firearms and have no hesitancy to use them in an endeavor to escape apprehension.


On a number of occasions in recent years members of the personnel of the Federal Bureau of Investigation met their death in this manner while unflinchingly performing their hazardous duties.


It is to be particularly noted that the legislation, the enactment of which I recommend, would in no wise improperly limit the freedom of action of peaceful, law-abiding persons.


The contemplated legislation would not hamper or hinder any person from purchasing or possessing a firearm.    It would merely require him to register the firearm and to record any transfer of the weapon.


It would interfere with personal liberty no more than is the case with the requirement that is imposed in every state in respect to registration of automobiles.


It is equally important that death dealing weapons be registered so that a record of the traffic in them may be maintained for purposes of national defense and for enforcement of the criminal law.


A proposed bill drafted in this department embodying the foregoing recommendations is enclosed herewith.  I recommend its enactment and hope that favorable action can be taken in respect to it at this session of the Congress.


This proposal for mandatory federal gun registration did not pass.  Indeed, an October 1941 law that granted President Roosevelt legal authority to requisition private property for defense of the United States specifically disclaimed any interpretation that it conferred such authority and said the requisition authority should not be construed “to impair or infringe in any manner the right of any individual to keep or bear arms….”


Did Jackson interpret the Second Amendment to confer such an individual right?  The evidence I know of is inconclusive.  His own gun use and gun ownership were instances of behavior, not constitutional exegesis … but in many people the former does inform and evidence the latter.  Jackson’s constitutional argument in the government’s Miller brief was nuanced, not categorical—it did not argue that the Second Amendment protects guns only in the context of militia service and does not also encompass individual rights.  And the 1940 Jackson proposal seeking national gun registration legislation sought only that; he did not seek a law banning gun possession.


All of this is relevant, of course, to yesterday’s Supreme Court decision, District of Columbia v. Heller (click here), which recognized in the Second Amendment an individual right to possess a firearm unconnected with militia service, and to use that weapon for lawful purposes such as self-defense within the home.



Heller itself recognizes limits on individual gun rights under the Second Amendment and displays some sensitivity to the practical concerns that surround guns.  It can be hoped, going forward, that this jurisprudence and future explications of this individual right will remember and embody the distinction between gun savvy and gun crazy.  Robert Jackson’s personal behavior with guns and his legal work on gun control issues did that.  His Uncle Dan raised him that way.


Having enjoyed John Q.’s “Jackson List” emails for years, I commend his work to everyone and urge you to sign up at the Jackson List Archives, where you can also check out John Q.’s prior posts on Jackson.  And in case you ever make it onto “Jeopardy!”, Robert Jackson happens to be the last Supreme Court Justice who didn’t graduate law school.  Which could explain why he has so much to offer.

* John Q.’s real middle name is Quin, but my buddy Kenny and I started calling him John Quincy, later shortened to John Q., because of the remarkably similar demeanor and mode of attire to our 6th President, and I can see no reason to resort to slavish accuracy now.

John Quincy Adams

See what I mean?

NYT: Oil Speculators are our Friends

While one generally views the New York Times as a bastion of limousine liberalism, that isn’t necessarily true in the business section.  When it comes to protecting money interests, they can out-conservative the Wall Street Journal any day.  So Joe Nocera’s defense of oil speculators should come as no surprise.

What does come as a surprise is just how flagrantly Nocera sells the speculator line.  Without any shame at all, Nocera opens his article thus:


So now we know: it’s all the fault of those damnable speculators. They’re the ones to blame as the price of oil tops $140 a barrel.

It’s not our government’s fault for failing to come up with a credible energy policy — that can’t be it. Nor is the problem the weak dollar, or the voracious energy appetite of the Chinese, or those pesky rebels in Nigeria who are trying to blow up their country’s oil pipelines. And it’s certainly not the fault of you and me for driving gas-guzzling S.U.V.’s. It has to be those speculators. They are the only villains in sight.

Sarcasm is always a good way to deflect attention, but it’s a poor way to construct a credible defense against accusations of wrong doing.  Sure, there’s blame to be leveled at others, but that doesn’t mean you didn’t pull the trigger.

Nocera then tries to shoot down the arguments.  First up, the straw man:


More than once this week, legislators used that same word their constituents were using: “manipulation.”

So let’s take a closer look at what the speculators’ critics are saying. First, despite the loose use of the word “manipulation,” that is really not what is being alleged here, at least not in the classic sense. Remember how the Hunts tried to corner the silver market? They bought up silver and took it off the market, thereby creating an artificial shortage. I suppose OPEC could do something like that — one could even argue that OPEC does that already — but no mere speculator could.

But Joe, that isn’t the market they are manipulating.  They are playing with the commodities futures market.  Do you have anything to say about that, Joe?  I didn’t think so.


Instead, the critics’ thesis is that speculators are creating an energy bubble the same way investors created the Internet bubble. As speculative bets on energy have grown drastically in recent years, the sheer amount of money being thrown at energy futures is making those bets a self-fulfilling prophecy. All that money, in other words, pushes prices higher than they would go if the market simply consisted of the actual buyers and sellers of oil.

There are so many holes in this argument I scarcely know where to start. The C.F.T.C. says that some $5 trillion worth of futures and options transaction trades take place every day; can an influx of $240 billion, spread over five years, really propel prices upward to the extent that he and others claim? Then there’s the fact that the commodities markets don’t work like equity markets, where a small amount of trading can lift every share of a company’s stock. In commodities trading, every contract has a buyer and a seller, meaning that for every bet that prices are going up, somebody else is betting they are going down. Why doesn’t that short interest depress prices?

Fact alert: The $5 trillion covers the spectrum of commodities, and the $240 billion is only the increase in the amount in commodity funds, as known to one trader.  And no one said it was spread over five years.  And you left out that it was all “long-money”, meaning that there is $240 billion today buying up options.  Could that cause the price of oil to sky-rocket?  You bet.  Has it?  I’d say there are $140 reasons to conclude it has.

So let’s cut to the chase, and gain a little appreciation of why New York Times business reporter Joe Nocera thinks that speculation in oil futures is good for America.


Even if you eliminated speculation entirely, the price of oil wouldn’t fall. Thankfully, no one is proposing to go that far (though Senator Lieberman was toying with the idea), because even members of Congress understand that futures markets serve a crucial purpose. They help companies hedge their oil prices, and they help energy companies manage their risk, for starters.

As I was filling up the tank the other day, I asked myself, “Isn’t it only right that oil prices go through the roof so that oil companies can hedge their prices and manage their risk?”  After all, you never know when someone will invent some inexpensive, inexhaustible source of energy that will fuel the world and turn shares of Exxon Mobil into colorful wallpaper.  Now that would be a tragedy.

Aitzaz Ahsan to Speak at New York City Bar

I just received news that Aitzaz Ahsan, the leader of the Pakistani lawyer movement, will be speaking at the Association of the Bar of the New York City Bar on Tuesday, July 1st.  This is a huge opportunity to meet and hear a lawyer has put his life on the line for the principles we espouse from the safety of our computer keyboards.  If you’re anywhere near NYC, don’t miss this opportunity.  Here’s the press release:  


AITZAZ AHSAN, LEADER OF PAKISTAN’S “LAWYERS’ MOVEMENT,”


SPEAK AT NEW YORK CITY BAR



New York, NY, June 27, 2008 — Aitzaz Ahsan, President of the Supreme Court Bar Association of Pakistan and the leader of the “Lawyers’ Movement” in that country, will speak at the New York City Bar on Tuesday, July 1st, 2008, at 9:00 a.m. Mr. Ahsan will discuss the latest developments regarding the legal system and judicial independence in Pakistan.


Last November, members of the New York City Bar, along with the New York State Bar, the New York County Lawyers’ Association and other organizations, rallied in support of the lawyers and judges affected by the imposition of emergency rule in Pakistan and the deposing of Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry. Mr. Ahsan will provide an update on efforts to achieve, as he phrased it in a recent article in Newsweek, “Justice for our Justice,” and the reinstatement of other members of the judiciary.


“We have been very supportive of the efforts of Pakistan’s legal community to promote judicial independence and the rule of law, and are delighted that Mr. Ahsan is here to inform the New York City Bar of the progress on those fronts,” said Patricia M. Hynes, President of the New York City Bar.


Who: Aitzaz Ahsan, President of Pakistan’s Supreme Court Bar Association  and “Lawyers’ Movement” leader


When: Tuesday, July 1st, 2008 at 9:00 a.m.


Where: New York City Bar Association, 42 West 44th Street 


About the New York City Bar:


The New York City Bar Association was founded in 1870, and since then has been dedicated to maintaining the high ethical standards of the profession, promoting reform of the law, and providing service to the profession and the public. The Association continues to work for political, legal and social reform, while implementing innovative means to help the disadvantaged. Protecting the public’s welfare remains one of the Association’s highest priorities.

Silence from the Grave

While the frenzy of gun rights diverted attention away from everything else in the world, the Supreme Court decided the California case of Giles v. California, the case where Dwayne Giles was convicted of murdering Brenda Avie based upon statements she made to police a few weeks in advance of her death, that Giles had assaulted her and threatened her with a knife. Thankfully, Howard Bashman was paying careful attention while I was blinded by shinier decisions.  Gideon was watching too, but he has yet to speak his mind.

In a 6-3 decision, the United States Supreme Court reversed the California Supreme Court.  Justice Scalia (whom I have maligned unmercifully of late, though he doesn’t seem to notice) wrote the majority opinion.  As described by the Washington Post :

“Domestic violence is an intolerable offense that legislatures may choose to combat through many means,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority. “But for that serious crime, as for others, abridging the constitutional rights of criminal defendants is not in the State’s arsenal.”

Scalia added that the lower courts were free to consider whether in shooting Avie, Giles may have intended to dissuade her from notifying authorities about the abuse, a factor that should be considered as part of the Sixth Amendment analysis.

The decision is a return to the basic rule that a defendant who intentionally causes the unavailability of a witness against him forfeits his 6th Amendment right of confrontation.  The California court, proving that the slope can be slippery at times, sought to contract the right to confrontation by eliminating the intent requirement.

The dissent, and partial dissenters, apparently bowed to the current trend of treating domestic violence different from all other crimes by throwing the rules out the window.


In a toughly worded dissent, Justice Stephen G. Breyer, said the majority was overanalyzing the thin historical record and overcomplicating the analysis.

“The defendant here knew that murdering his ex-girlfriend would keep her from testifying; and that knowledge is sufficient to show the intent that law ordinarily demands,” Breyer wrote. He was joined by Justice John Paul Stevens and Anthony M. Kennedy.

Refusing to join in a portion of the Scalia opinion, Justices Souter and Ginsburg gave confrontation half a loaf:


Justice David H. Souter, joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, agreed with Scalia’s historical analysis but said prosecutors could introduce evidence that defendants had engaged in a pattern of domestic violence as a substitute for their intent, perhaps opening the door to a finding that the alleged abuser had forfeited his right to confront a missing witness.

In other words, concession to the “psychology of abuse” popularized by domestic abuse advocates who are less concerned that guilt be proven than they are of creating an independent jurisprudence applicable solely to cases where women are harmed in claims of domestic violence, has gotten traction from the justices who would otherwise be expected to demonstrate some concern for the rights of the accused.

Having had the pleasure of trying cases where this nouveau version of evidence, considered wholly unreliable otherwise but somehow transformed into perfectly accepting and overwhelming damning evidence when applied to claims of domestic violence, it is a painful reminder of how transitory whims as to popular victims undermine reasoned jurisprudence. 


Activists who decry more than 1,500 deaths and 2 million injuries each year stemming from domestic violence expressed disappointment in the opinion. Officials at the Family Violence Prevention Fund warned the decision could make it less likely that victims will reach out to authorities for help. In many such cases, they said, the victim is the lone witness to a crime.

It’s not the wrongfulness of the crime, but the proof of the commission, that’s at issue.  Yet again, Justice Scalia turns out to be the hero of the defense, demanding that the constitutional right of confrontation be respected even when the underlying crime is a flavor of the month.

Praise the Lord and Pass the Ammunition

Here we are, Heller +1, with a chance to breath a little more deeply and consider whether initial reactions, coming mere seconds after the opinion was issued and read, taste any different after a suitable digestion period.

Part of the process is considering what others have to say, whether they see something we missed, or whether they offer a clarity of thought when our own was compromised and cloudy.  Not surprisingly, newspaper editorials abound.  From my neck of the woods (since this is a New York blog, after all), the New York Times :

In a radical break from 70 years of Supreme Court precedent, Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the majority, declared that the Second Amendment guarantees individuals the right to bear arms for nonmilitary uses, even though the amendment clearly links the right to service in a “militia.” The ruling will give gun-rights advocates a powerful new legal tool to try to strike down gun-control laws across the nation.

This is a decision that will cost innocent lives, cause immeasurable pain and suffering and turn America into a more dangerous country. It will also diminish our standing in the world, sending yet another message that the United States values gun rights over human life.

Whew.  That was close.  I was afraid the Times might be a bit hyperbolic.  It’s understandable that an editorial board dedicated to causes would jump to the end of the decision to check out the bottom line, then extrapolate from its own result-oriented viewpoint what the end of the world is upon us.  This, after all, the New York Times. 

On the other hand, Adam Liptak’s analysis is far more sober.


Most state and city gun restrictions appear to be allowed under the ruling, including licensing laws, limits on the commercial sale of guns, restrictions on guns in places like schools and government buildings and prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill. “Dangerous and unusual” weapons can also be banned, although that phrase was not fully defined.

Adam apparently read the whole decision, and arrived at the conclusion that “[t]he legal battlegrounds will be cities with ordinances similar to Washington’s essentially complete ban, most notably Chicago.” 

Newsday’s editorial view, in contrast, was that this was as big a win for gun control advocates as they could have reasonably hoped for.


But the 5 to 4 decision, written by Justice Antonin Scalia, expressly rejected the notion that the right to keep and bear arms is unlimited. It spelled out examples of acceptable existing restrictions, such as prohibitions on gun possession by felons and the mentally ill, restrictions on the commercial sale of firearms, and laws barring guns in places such as schools and government buildings.

That’s some good news for control advocates. 

Now that the court has spoken, the power of gun proponents’ slippery-slope argument has been drained away.

If I had to give a grade, Newsday would get a “C+” for reading comprehension.  They got the obvious, but missed the more subtle language that wound its way through the many pages of dubiously decipherable rhetoric.  Like the Times, they focused on end-result, but came up with a different spin. 

In the Viewsday post on the decision by Michelle Chen, reference was made to a number of commentators, both partisan and neutral, discussing aspects of the decision that left gaping holes.  While this was the closest either paper came to appreciating the wealth of unanswered questions in the decision, it fell short of showing any organic understanding of the issues/questions/problems.  It’s always troubling how sound-bites from commentators are designed for the unaware, and how often the unaware fall into the trap of repeating meaningless drivel because it fits neatly into a slot.

The most fascinating part of the Viewsday post were the comments left by the few, the proud, the fundamentally ignorant.  While each of the comments raised Darwinism issues, this one caught my eye:


I find it difficult to believe that a fourth grade student can explain what the Second Amendment means and four out of nine Supreme Court Justices failed to get it correct. Just how morally corrupt are they and what are they trying to do to my beloved nation?

I’m personally amazed that he can find the floor when he gets out of bed in the morning.  To a person, there is no doubt whatsoever that they have no clue what the decision says, but that wasn’t going to stop them from having their say, likely under the First Amendment’s promise of free speech.

And at Simple Justice, we are fortunate to have one of the most astute and well-informed commenters around, Joel Rosenberg, proprietor of Twin-Cities Carry.  Joel has offered numerous thoughts on the decision, but can be summed up by noting his appreciation of the Scalia’s finally opening the door and letting gun advocates stick more than a toe into the crack. 


I’m still thrilled. I think there’s a lot of issues to still be decided, but, as I wrote (and said) at length before today, even the best possible decision (which this isn’t; although it is, IMHO, pretty close) will still result in years and years of litigation to give it teeth.

Joel is clearly an optimist, but at least he can see clearly through his rose-colored glasses, recognizing that while Heller may have given very little away, “judicial conservatism impels the Court to at least try (although, in this case, I think that they’re trying a little too hard) stay away from deciding issues that aren’t before it, and haven’t been argued.”  He also has a penchant for understatement.

Similarly, commenter Mike Hansbury, from whom the title of this post is stolen, sees a half-full glass as overflowing.


What was the question before the court?

Whether the following provisions — D.C. Code secs. 7-2502.02(a)(4), 22-4504(a), and 7-2507.02 — violate the Second Amendment rights of individuals who are not affiliated with any state-regulated militia, but who wish to keep handguns and other firearms for private use in their homes?”

The answer is YES.

All true, but so what?  They invalidated a federal ban on handguns in the home for self-defense by certain people, leaving the likelihood that states can regulate the crap out of arms otherwise, exactly as they do now. 

What has been extremely disappointing is the lack of thoughtful commentary, or indeed recognition, by the mainstream media (including our New York Times analyst, Liptak), of the total absence of any explanation of how the Supreme Court majority could recognize a fundamental individual right under the Second Amendment, and then leave untouched all regulation of this purported fundamental right that contravenes their holding.

The gun advocates take comfort by shrugging and saying that this will be dealt with in the next case, or the one after that.  The gun control advocates will smile shyly, happy that they get to keep almost every restriction they’ve ever wanted, and the gun advocates don’t seem to notice or care.

As a lawyer, I remain deeply troubled by a decision of constitutional magnitude that is all rubric and no rationale.  It’s one thing for the trial judge to say “motion denied” without explanation.  It’s another for the Supreme Court to state dicta of shocking breadth without making any attempt to provide a reason. 

Is this the new constitutional jurisprudence?  Will the Supreme no longer bother to answer the “why” question when the making sweeping pronouncements? 

Randy Barnett at Volokh tries to sneak in his kid’s law review article as if he gets ESP signals from Scalia to provide a rational framework for further scrutiny of the myriad of laws restricting guns.  If my son wrote on the subject, I would do the same thing.  After all, it makes just as much sense to grab a little promotion for his kid on Scalia’s coattails as anything else.  He may be shameless, but what father wouldn’t seize the chance to help his child when there isn’t any better explanation in town?

Then there’s the “judicial modesty” question, that a Court’s holding go no farther than is needed to decide the specific question before the court in one particular case.  While this notion doesn’t satisfactorily explain the Heller decision, since Scalia chose not to state the level of scrutiny to be applied, while noting that it was something higher than rational basis, it remains a responsibility of the Court, both historic and pragmatic, to fill the gap that it has just created rather than to leave us and the other courts of this nation to fall into a deep, dark hole with no observable bottom. 

Judicial modesty may work fine when the Supreme Court is deciding small cases.  But big issues, where societal upheaval is at stake, require more.  Much more.  Hiding behind such conservatism is a cop out.  Heller opened a door just a crack, but Joel Rosenberg is entitled to know whether he’s about to be invited in or his leg is going to get cut off at the knee if he doesn’t pull it out quickly.

If a client came to a lawyer to ask the question of what rights he had under the Second Amendment, and the lawyer told the client the holding of Heller, the client would walk out muttering the lawyer was an incompetent idiot.  How could he not even know what the Second Amendment means?  Today, we are all Second Amendment idiots.  Some just don’t realize it yet.


Another Thought on Heller

Reading the comments of Linda Singer, the former District of Columbia’s Attorney General, “[w]hile the majority spent much time on British and colonial history, they talked almost not at all of the real world, right now, life and death consequences to the Court’s ruling,” another thought crossed my mind.


A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Can any of you textualists out there point out where in the Second Amendment the words “self defense” (or defence, as they preferred to spell it back then) appears?

While defense of one’s home is certainly a significant reason why the right to keep and bear arms should exist, nowhere does the text of the amendment provide a limitation of its purpose to self-defense (as opposed, for example, to the defense of democracy from a tyrant). 

And where does it mention a home, apartment, abode, living space, castle or any other particular location?  So how do we end up with a right, but only inside our home? 

As noted in my earlier post, Scalia went on at length to explain that the right to “bear Arms” refers to the right to carry arms around with you.  Yet this aspect of the right disappears during his discussion of what the court is permitting.  Is it a magic trick?  Is it a miracle?  Is it a concession to that reality that Linda Singer was talking about?

This is not an argument over whether it’s a good or bad idea, but whether it’s rational and internally and externally consistent.  What was that thing about judicial philosophy again, Justice Scalia?

And don’t get too hot and sweaty over which of your state laws are going to fall first.  After all, it’s not like Scalia said that the right was incorporated and applies to the states.  Even that will be left for another day and a million dollars later.

The Heller Decision: A Massive Disappointment For All

I’ve just finished reading the 68 page Scalia majority opinion in the 5-4 split decision in D.C. v. Heller.  For anyone, like me, who believes that our United States Supreme Court poorly serves its function of providing comprehensive and meaningful guidance to the People of the United States of America, you will not be disappointed.  Heller is a massive disappointment.

To cut to the chase, the sum total of Heller is that states cannot have a blanket prohibition on the possession of a handgun within the home for purposes of self-defense by individuals who are not otherwise prohibited, such as felons and the insane.  That’s all she wrote.

The first 54 pages of the majority opinion go through a painful explanation of how the Second Amendment provides an individual right to have weapons and carry them, provided they are weapons commonly used by regular people, as opposed to weapons used by the military.  Nothing surprising, though Scalia spends a lot of time shooting at the dissent.

As part of his explanation (and this will be relevant in a bit), Scalia writes:

From our review of founding-era sources, we conclude that this natural meaning was also the meaning that “bear arms” had in the 18th century. In numerous instances, “bear arms” was unambiguously used to refer to the carrying of weapons outside of an organized militia.

Slip Op. at 11 (used to distinguish J. Stevens argument that “bear arms” referred to use by militia).

Scalia, at section III of the opinion, then states “what’s allowed”:

For example, the majority of the 19th-century courts to consider the question held that prohibitions on carrying concealed weapons were lawful under the Second Amendment or state analogues. See, e.g., State v. Chandler, 5 La. Ann., at 489–490; Nunn v. State, 1 Ga., at 251; see generally 2 Kent *340, n. 2; The American Students’ Blackstone 84, n. 11 (G. Chase ed. 1884). Although we do not undertake an exhaustive historical analysis today of the full scope of the Second Amendment, nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms. We also recognize another important limitation on the right to keep and carry arms. Miller said, as we have explained, that the sorts of weapons protected were those “in common use at the time.” 307 U. S., at 179. We think that limitation is fairly supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of “dangerous and unusual weapons.”

This is where the opinion spirals downward into the toilet.  This portion of the decision, which purports to provide the actual answer to the actual question, does nothing.  Consisting of a grand total of 2 pages, at 57-8, it provides absolutely no rationale for the imposition of obviously goal-oriented limitations that fly directly in the face of his first 54 pages of verbiage.

During the arguments preceding Heller, I asked everyone, particularly the lawprofs, to provide any explanation of how one concludes that the Second Amendment provides a fundamental individual right, and still avoids all the implications of such a right.  We now have an answer, straight from the pen of Justice Antonin Scalia:

There is absolutely no rationale to support such a conclusion, so Scalia simply announced that all the limitations that he wants to apply continue to do so and provides no explanation or rationale at all.  It’s a total punt.

But if you thought this would be the only smack in the face Justice Scalia had to offer today, you would be wrong.  Ultimately, the holding is this:

Respondent conceded at oral argument that he does not “have a problem with . . . licensing” and that the District’s law is permissible so long as it is “not enforced in an arbitrary and capricious manner.” Tr. of Oral Arg. 74–75. We therefore assume that petitioners’ issuance of a license will satisfy respondent’s prayer for relief and do not address the licensing requirement.

Slip Op. at 59.  Remember Scalia’s whole discussion of what “bear arms” means?  It doesn’t matter, because he never reaches, never discussed, never even mentions, whether the right extends to carrying a weapon.  Because Dick Heller only wants to keep a gun at home, that’s as far as Scalia goes.  Because Mr. Heller, a D.C. special police officer, would otherwise be entitled to a permit, that’s as far as the decision goes.  Because Mr. Heller only asks for D.C. to grant him a permit, that’s as far as the decision goes.

So, now that Justice Scalia spent 54 pages to argue the existence of an individual right under the Second Amendment, we know nothing more than that Dick Heller can get a permit to keep a handgun in his home for self-defense.

The Supreme Court of the United States has utterly failed to fulfill its purpose of providing guidance to the American public.  They have opened the door to huge, fundamental questions, and slammed it shut without answering any but the tiniest of them, and did so without bothering to offer any explanation or rationale for its decision, leaving the legitimacy of its holding in the toilet.  What a disgrace.

D.C. v. Heller Decision: Individual Right, Maybe, Sorta

This just in from SCOTUSBlog :

Answering a 127-year old constitutional question, the Supreme Court ruled on Thursday that the Second Amendment protects an individual right to have a gun, at least in one’s home. The Court, splitting 5-4, struck down a District of Columbia ban on handgun possession.

Justice Antonin Scalia’s opinion for the majority stressed that the Court was not casting doubt on long-standing bans on gun possession by felons or the mentally retarded, or laws barring guns from schools or government buildings, or laws putting conditions on gun sales.

The decision isn’t up yet, so expect this to be replaced with more substantive info shortly.  But from the blurb, this should prove to be one of the worst-reasoned, result-oriented decisions ever.