Author Archives: SHG

When It Happens To a Cop

Hat tip to Slate’s Convictions for this D.C. Circuit decision in Johnson v. D.C..  As it happens, Johnson (first name Juan) is a cop.  Out of uniform, however, he’s just good old Juan.  That’s a dangerous thing to be in any city, especially the District of Columbia.

And so the decision begins with this illuminating paragraph:


Juan Johnson is a police officer whose off-duty act of kindness to a stranger in distress landed him in the middle of a drug bust in which he was repeatedly kicked in the groin by a police officer who mistook him for a criminal.

That can happen when your name is Juan.  A narcotics officer, Jeffrey Bruce, told the story this way:


Bruce testified at his deposition that Johnson tried to escape by lunging into the apartment and trying to crawl away, keeping his hands close to his body. Bruce claimed he then ran into the apartment after Johnson, holstered his weapon, and reached for Johnson’s arms, at which point Johnson produced his police badge and Bruce let him go. Bruce denied ever having kicked or stomped Johnson.

Officer Bruce, by his version, was every bit the consummate professional.  Juan told a different story:


Johnson, who was standing just outside his apartment, immediately complied and tried to signal to Bruce that he was a fellow police officer. When his signals failed, Johnson realized that he could not easily resolve this case of mistaken identity and feared that Bruce might shoot him in the face or chest. With his hands still raised, Johnson turned away from the gun and fell through the open doorway of his apartment, landing face-down on the floor. While Johnson was prone on the floor with his arms and legs spread, Bruce repeatedly kicked and stomped his groin and buttocks. Johnson protested, “What are you kicking me for? I’m the police. I’m the police. Why are you kicking me, why are you stomping me?” When the MPD identification badge around Johnson’s neck finally came into view, Bruce stopped kicking him.

The rest of the decision is about §1983 issues, having nothing to do with my purpose in posting this.  The rest of this post is directed toward my friends in the judiciary.

My dear judges, the facts as related by Police Officer Juan Johnson, who learned to his dismay what it means to be accidentally close to a perp when not in uniform, are essentially the same as the stories I and my brethren in the criminal defense bar have been telling you for as long as I’ve been practicing law. 

As we tell the story, your eyes glaze over.  As we recount the pointlessness of mindless, knee-jerk police violence, your head turns away.  When my Juan doesn’t have a police shield like this Juan, you “find” the police officer credible, despite the horrific physical injury that makes the cop’s story impossible. 

Bear in mind that Officer Jeffrey Bruce, who was likely very angry because he was forced to run after a perp who sold drugs to an undercover (and we all know that making a cop chase you down is an invitation to a good tuning up) was never threatened.  This was a garden variety buy and bust.  This was not hardcore violent crime, unless Bruce’s gun went off as he was running after the perp with his weapon drawn so he would be ready to shoot him.

Why does Officer Bruce feel so entitled?  Is it acceptable, as long as it doesn’t happen in your neighborhood?  Can you continue to pretend that these things never happen and reflexively side with the cop in the face of all evidence to the contrary?

I understand it’s hard to sift through the facts, but it’s worth the effort.  These things happen. They happen regularly.  They will continue to happen as long as you give the cop a free pass on beating citizens and lying to you about it.  You can stop it.  If you want to.
Juan Johnson learned what it means to be a citizen.  What did you learn?

Obama on Telecom Immunity

From the Daily Kos, Democratic candidate for President of the United States of America, Barak Obama:



“Given the grave threats that we face, our national security agencies must have the capability to gather intelligence and track down terrorists before they strike, while respecting the rule of law and the privacy and civil liberties of the American people. There is also little doubt that the Bush Administration, with the cooperation of major telecommunications companies, has abused that authority and undermined the Constitution by intercepting the communications of innocent Americans without their knowledge or the required court orders.


“That is why last year I opposed the so-called Protect America Act, which expanded the surveillance powers of the government without sufficient independent oversight to protect the privacy and civil liberties of innocent Americans. I have also opposed the granting of retroactive immunity to those who were allegedly complicit in acts of illegal spying in the past.


“After months of negotiation, the House today passed a compromise that, while far from perfect, is a marked improvement over last year’s Protect America Act.


“Under this compromise legislation, an important tool in the fight against terrorism will continue, but the President’s illegal program of warrantless surveillance will be over. It restores FISA and existing criminal wiretap statutes as the exclusive means to conduct surveillance – making it clear that the President cannot circumvent the law and disregard the civil liberties of the American people. It also firmly re-establishes basic judicial oversight over all domestic surveillance in the future. It does, however, grant retroactive immunity, and I will work in the Senate to remove this provision so that we can seek full accountability for past offenses. But this compromise guarantees a thorough review by the Inspectors General of our national security agencies to determine what took place in the past, and ensures that there will be accountability going forward. By demanding oversight and accountability, a grassroots movement of Americans has helped yield a bill that is far better than the Protect America Act.


“It is not all that I would want. But given the legitimate threats we face, providing effective intelligence collection tools with appropriate safeguards is too important to delay. So I support the compromise, but do so with a firm pledge that as President, I will carefully monitor the program, review the report by the Inspectors General, and work with the Congress to take any additional steps I deem necessary to protect the lives – and the liberty – of the American people.”


An awful lot of words to say nothing.

Harry Reid says, “Probably we can’t take that out of the bill, but I’m going to try.”

I have an idea.  As long as telecom immunity is in the bill, just say no.  If FISA is so vital to national security, then pass the bill without telecom immunity attached.  Separate the two and vote.  As I recall, the Dems have a little something to say about things.

Telecoms Get Immunity; The Nation is Safe

A deal has been cut.  In order to enable the government to engage in secret wiretapping, Congress has agreed to give the telecoms immunity for breaking the law.   It was so important to the Bush administration that the telecoms get a pass that they were willing to put our nation at risk of terrorist attack.  Whew.  That was close.  I know I’m sure glad that the risk is over.

The deal, expanding the government’s powers to spy on terrorism suspects in some major respects, would strengthen the ability of intelligence officials to eavesdrop on foreign targets. It would also allow them to conduct emergency wiretaps without court orders on American targets for a week if it is determined that important national security information would otherwise be lost. If approved, as appears likely, the agreement would be the most significant revision of surveillance law in 30 years.

And sometimes, they even catch a good old American criminal in their nets.  How great is that!


The agreement would settle one of the thorniest issues in dispute by providing immunity to the phone companies in the Sept. 11 program as long as a federal district court determined that they received legitimate requests from the government directing their participation in the program of wiretapping without warrants.

Of course, because it would all be a secret, the lawyers for the other side would never know about it, have a chance to argue against it, present evidence that it was a big old sham or take any action to prevent it.  In fact, the court couldn’t even explain why it was dismissing the case, since that would be a breach of secrecy as well.

And if you have a problem with this, why not just invite your local al Qaeda cell over for tea and crumpets, you terrorist lover.  It’s good to know that Congress is watching our back.

There’s Competency and There’s Competency

The Supremes issued a 7-2 decision in Indiana v. Edwards, the case where the State of Indiana sought to restrict the right of a criminal defendant to represent himself where he “cannot communicate coherently with the court or a jury.”  In other words, the defendant was sufficiently competent to stand trial, but not sufficiently competent to go pro se. 

The opinion by Justice Breyer is one of those that begs for the another case, since the Supreme Court held that there are, as a matter of constitutional right, now two levels of competency.  But the Court expressly rejected Indiana’s test for the right to represent oneself, and in its place substituted . . . nothing. 

In some respects, the opinion demonstrates a degree of awareness of the problem of mental illness that is rarely seen in court decisions.

Mental illness itself is not a unitary concept. It varies in degree. It can vary over time. It interferes with an individual’s functioning at different times in different ways. 

The American Psychiatric Association (APA) tells us (without dispute) in its amicus brief filed in support of neither party that “[d]is organized thinking, deficits in sustaining attention and concentration, impaired expressive abilities, anxiety, and other common symptoms of severe mental illnesses can impair the defendant’s ability to play the significantly expanded role required for self representation even if he can play the lesser role of represented defendant.”

This nascent recognition that competency is not as simplistic as the law has held for so very long is significant.  The old view, that a defendant is either incompetent or not, failed to address the most basic medical understanding of mental illness, and made it enormously difficult to address a defendant’s psychological issues with a recalcitrant judge.

But then, the Court dropped the ball.  Having made clear that the right to self-representation remained intact, but not absolute, and having concluded that this right could be stripped from a defendant if he was incompetent, but not so incompetent that he couldn’t stand trial, they skidded to a deal halt at that crucial moment when one critical question remained unanswered.


We are sufficiently uncertain, however, as to how that particular standard would work in practice to refrain from endorsing it as a federal constitutional standard here. We need not now, and we do not, adopt it.

So the Court was certain enough to reject the standard proposed by Indiana, but not so certain as to provide a standard to be used?  Well that’s a little less than helpful.  And thus, the Indiana v. Edwards decision manages to provide enough of a holding to gum up the works, but not enough to actually serve any meaningful purpose.  I think the justices owe me a refund for this one.

And a couple of interesting asides coming out of the decision.  First, a debate broke out at Grits for Breakfast over how there could be two independent standards for competency.  Scott Henson disagreed with me that there could be a difference the two, and we bantered back and forth in the comments section.


And if they’re competent to stand trial, historically that assumed they’re competent to make the decision to self-defend. I guess I see plenty gray area in the issue on a case by case basis, but not in the decisions made by the court. Those MUST be black-white, yes-no answers, by definition.

While I would agree with Scott that the standard for competency to stand trial is so far outmoded as to be nothing more than one of our beloved historic relics, and that if one is competent to stand trial, then one should be equally competent to exercise all rights given to defendants, it was clear that the Supreme were not going to raise the bar on the low end (particularly since it wasn’t at issue in the case) and that a different, more legally and medically realistic bar needed to be set on the upper end of the incompetency spectrum.  And so it goes.

Secondly, the Supremes, at oral argument and in the majority decision (at page 16), cited to Erica Hashimoto’s law review article.  This, according to Breyer, provided the empirical support that pro se defendants didn’t fare so poorly representing themselves as the Court feared.  In fact, according to Hashimoto’s survey, they actually did better on their own then they did with an indigent defender.

This was the subject of some controversy, as Hashimoto (a former AUSA) posted at Concurring Opinions her assumption of the reason for this outcome:


This raises (at least) two concerns in the minds of many defendants: first, many of the lawyers are paid very little, so the quality of state-appointed counsel can be pretty abysmal; and second, the lawyer is being paid by the government, and the lawyer therefore may feel some allegiance to the same government that is prosecuting the defendant. There is a lot of evidence that there is validity to both of these concerns. Stories of ineptness by court-appointed lawyers fill the federal reporters, and there also are many stories of lawyers who attempt to curry favor with prosecutors and judges by ensuring that their clients plead guilty so that they can continue to be appointed in other cases.

Importantly, while the Supreme accepted Hashimoto’s empirical evidence to support the proposition that pro se representation was a viable alternative in its reaffirmance of the right to represent oneself in Faretta v. California, the Court made absolutely no mention of Hashimoto’s theory that it’s due to the incompetence of indigent defenders.  Clearly, Erica’s empirical efforts provided a degree of usefulness that her baseless assumptions and overt bias did not, leaving her with a bright future as a bean counter.

And finally, Anne at Court-o-Rama, the least dangerous blog, adds her 2 cents to the mix:


Maybe the better question is who is competent to self-represent? The lawyerly reflex: nobody. You’d have to be crazy to try it.

And so they are.
 

The Missing Defendant

A criminal prosecution is often a game of hurry up and wait.  After the shock of the arrest wears off, inexperienced defendants are often surprised at how uneventful a prosecution seems to be, with court appearances where nothing happens and lengthy delays from court date to court date. 

In complex federal cases, defendants out on a PRB (personal recognizance bond) are often excused from appearing, and it may seem like they no longer have much of anything to do with the case.  Given the significance of a criminal prosecution to their lives, this disconnect causes the experience to seem surreal.

In beginning, the defendant may call regularly to ask what’s going on, what are you doing, what will happen next.  Naturally, the perpetual question gets asked:  What’s going to happen.  And after the 27 time explaining that the ball is in the prosecution’s court, whether to provide discovery, respond to motions, whatever, and that there is nothing more to tell except that you are there, ready, willing and able to fight, there is nothing much to do for the time being.  Eventually, even the most ardent and involved defendant will take a deep breath.

Then one day, out of the blue, a shoe drops.  Whether it’s the delivery of 187 boxes of documents, videotapes in flagranti delicto or a plea agreement with an expiration date, the time has come when you need to meet with the client.  Now.

So you dial the telephone number.  Ring.  Ring.  Ring.  Nothing.  You call the cellphone.  No answer and the mailbox is full.  Send an email.  Not even read, no less returned.  For all you know, your client has been practicing his penmanship so the cops will know he wrote “suicide is painless.”

Having tried every means available to you, you find it impossible to get hold of your client.  It’s conceivable that he has flown the coop, but you never thought that would happen.  He could be dead.  That can happen too.  Or something else.  The problem is that you don’t know how to reach him, but you do know that you need him now.

There are certain assumptions under which we all labor.  One is that when we dial a telephone number, there will be someone on the other end who is available to answer.  Normally, this is the case.  Occasionally, it’s not.  Don’t try to explain this to the judge, however, as he has a surefire way to make sure you know how to find your client whenever you need him.  The client will not be happy with the judge’s solution.

The reason this has come up is that a case that I’ve been handling for more than a year, with little happening as a result of governmental inertia and a court’s reluctance to pressure the government to actually do anything, popped on me last week.  My client, one of the most pleasant defendants I’ve had the pleasure of representing, had been interested, involved and available for the first few months of the case.  But as it dragged on, going nowhere fast, he grew bored with it and, following my advice, went about his life.

Last week’s appearance, unlike numerous prior court appearances, held a surprise.  The judge decided that this case was sitting on his calender far too long, and therefore shifted the momentum from the prosecution (who had been entirely responsible for all delay up to that point) to the defense, demanding that we suddenly take immediate action to give the appearance that the Speedy Trial Act was honored.  Suddenly, I needed my client.

Calls were made.  Emails were sent.  Messages were left.  And nothing.

As it turns out, my client heeded the call of the eastern end of Long Island, where New Yorkers go in the warmer months to relax and contemplate life.  Plenty of sandy beaches.  Few cell towers.

Even though I had instructed the defendant to let me know if he went anywhere that might prevent me from reaching him on a moment’s notice, he had lapsed into such a dulled state that he saw no harm in taking a few days away without informing me.  He didn’t think it would be a problem.

The moral of the story is that no matter how a case appears to drag on pointlessly, lawyers must keep abreast of their clients’ whereabouts, and clients must keep their lawyer aware of their trips to happier locales.  If I can’t reach you, I will assume you’re dead.  And I really, really hate it when that happens.

Bear Stearns Pair Walk the Walk

Ralph Cioffi and Matthew Tannin, the managers of Bear Stearns’ hedge fund  High-Grade Structured Credit Strategies Fund which trafficked in subprime mortgages, were arrested yesterday in the Eastern District of New York.  The indictment disclosed Tannin’s ill-conceived email comment, “the entire subprime market is toast.”

This case is custom made for the WSJ Law Blog, so if you want to learn all the gritty details, check out the many posts with more to come, no doubt.  Slater’s got it covered like flies on a hedge fund. 

What was curious about yesterday’s “arrest” was that the feds chose not to allow Cioffi and Tannin to surrender, as they would have surely been happy to do, but instead decided to put on a show.  The pair were forced to do the dreaded “perp walk.”  Like common criminals.  



Tannin_art_200v_20080619131927.jpg


(Credit: Associated Press)

The AP photo at left shows Matthew Tannin cuffed and held firmly by two unnamed federal agents.  Were they grasping him so tightly to prevent his sudden escape, ripping his arms away from their manly hold and Tannin pulling a “Cool Hand Luke” with the secret cache of pepper stored in the inside pocket of his custom-made suit? 

Don’t be silly.  Tannin was suitably dressed to appear before the court for arraignment on his indictment.  Since he’s out of a job, he had no other good reason to put on a tie.  Normally, he would just be padding around the house in his $4,700 monogrammed robe, like anyone else.  He dressed for success in anticipation of an arraignment, and would have been just as happy (happier even?) to have shown the marshals the way.

The WSJ provides the explanation for this needless phenomenon:


“For a little insight, we checked in with William “Mitch” Mitchelson, a former AUSA and current white-collar defense lawyer at Alston & Bird in Atlanta. Mitchelson, back in March of 2006, helped write this comprehensive piece in the National Law Journal on the perp walk.

“In high profile cases, it lets the public know that law enforcement is taking action against a problem,” says Mitchelson. “It also encourages people with evidence to come forward.”

Which brings us to the point of this post:  When you do white collar defense, preparing the client for the first 24 hours of his new life of misery is critical. 

Tannin (who is represented by Susan Brune) shows some indication of a well-prepared defendant.  He’s appropriately dressed, suited yet conservative, for the cameras.  But the pic shows two problems.  First, the scowl on his face suggests that he’s an angry man.  It makes him look evil, clearly an image he would be better off avoiding.  This photo will appear over and over, and will be the image that people hold of him as this case progresses.  The facial expression should be benign. This requires a studied awareness and plenty of practice, since he’s not a happy camper in the photo and may well be in a bit of discomfort.  Cuffs will do that. 

Think of Tom DeLay’s mugshot as he was booked by the Harris County Sheriff.  This is possibly the finest example of a defendant using a bad situation to his advantage.  He should have asked for copies to distribute for his next election campaign, it was that good.  When you look at it later, there is absolutely no way you would think that this is a mugshot, denying Texas authorities their effort at humiliating him.  It was brilliant.

Speaking of cuffs, it is particularly difficult to wear them well.  Despite plenty of opportunity, handcuff makers have put shockingly little effort into increasing their comfort over the years.  When hands are cuffed behind the back, it tends to force a person’s shoulders to stiffen and cause a person to force them backward in order to relieve the pressure on the wrists.  This, in turn, causes the defendant to thrust his chest forward, making him look defiant and aggressive.  Again, not the look we’re going for.

While the discomfort of being cuffed is real, it’s far better to suffer a little wrist stress for the few minutes it takes to walk from the agents’ car to the courthouse door than to appear a hunted man, straining to break free.  There is little a defendant can do to control his image during the perp walk.  It’s designed that way, so the government can show the public what they’re getting for their law enforcement tax dollars.

Of course, there is also the wealth of details every defendant needs to know about being unceremoniously seized to be put on public display.  Prepare them for what to say, and what not to say, as they are interviewed.  Prepare him for the questions from the press, and how to smile and say nothing as the cameras click away and the screams of ugly words come flying.  Explain how he must keep his cool no matter what, and how only by happily relinquishing physical control over his person for 10 minutes can he maintain true control over his life.

Given the opportunity, defense counsel should always try to arrange for a voluntary surrender, both to expedite processing and to avoid the perp walk circus.  But it’s not in our control, and we frequently get burned even when a prosecutor promises to let us walk our client in with dignity.  So regardless of whether you believe that you’ve got it covered, prepare your client for what might come and save him from the shock and humiliation that will haunt him for a long time after the perp walk is over.

Bear in mind that regardless of whether the case results in a win, lose or draw, the image of the perp walk and mug shot are usually the ones that others remember, and the taint from bad images will linger long after the case is over.  You have one chance to get it right.

And for those of you who may not quite understand what this whole subprime mess is all about, here’s a reprise of the official explanation.

Help Wanted: Chief Judge, No Experience Necessary

It’s finally happened.  Chief Judge Judy Kaye has announced her retirement after 15 years as the gal in the middle of the Court of Appeals, according to the New York Sun.  Unlike her predecessor, Sol Wachtler,  whose “retirement” was a bit more abrupt (thought he was a spectacular Chief Judge), the Governor can leisurely consider the available candidates this time around.

Appointments to the state’s top court, the Court of Appeals, are ultimately made by the governor, who is limited to choosing from seven candidates put forward by a state commission. To be considered by the commission, a candidate must apply.

With a current salary of $156,000, the job of presiding over the state judiciary would bring a drastic pay cut for many would-be applicants who are partners at major law firms. But a raise may be forthcoming, after a state judge last week ordered the Legislature to up judicial pay.

Of course, the wage issue doesn’t arise with many potential candidates, who can’t afford to leave their first year associates job at Biglaw and take such a massive pay cut.  So who are the “leading candidates” for the big chair?


Many of those who have applied for past Court of Appeals vacancies are already judges of the lower courts. Repeat candidates include Judge James Yates, who, in the span of a month earlier this year, both accepted and subsequently turned down the job of counsel to the governor, as well as Judge Richard Andrias, who sits on a mid-level appellate court in Manhattan. 

Another likely candidate, courthouse sources say, is Judge Jonathan Lippman, who previously served as Chief Judge Kaye’s top administrator.

I’ve posted about both Justice Yates and Justice Lippman before.  Justice Andrias, now sitting on the Appellate Division, First Department, has been on the short list for a while, notably during the Pataki administration where he and the guv were old college roomies. 

Justice Rick Andrias is another good guy, who showed serious concern with constitutional rights when he was a trial judge in Manhattan.  He’s become a bit more conservative on the appellate bench, but hopefully would steer a clear course should he wind up in Albany.

Applications are due by September 8, and don’t be put off by these other judges being the “leading candidates.”  When it comes to the Court of Appeals, you never know who is going to get the nod.

How To Wiretap, or Not

Caution:  The legalities of wiretapping vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.  Before you do anything, know your law.

Ever wonder what other people have to say about you?  Well, now you can find out by having fun with wiretapping!  Ever wonder what others know about your private life?  Well, now you can keep your peccadilloes to yourself by having fun with beating wiretaps!  Great for parties, too!

Seriously, wiretapping, or electronic eavesdropping, is a tool and a weapon, according to whose hands its in.  There are legitimate uses for covertly recording conversations, or protecting against others who would record yours.  That said, here’s a primer from IT Security on how to, and how to fight back, wiretapping. 

How to Wiretap

Did you think wiretapping was just for the FBI and mobsters? It’s actually so easy that we can show you how to install and manage different wiretapping systems yourself.



  • Tap in using your own phone: Listen to other people’s calls through your own basic telephone by hooking up your phone to a part of the original line that runs outside the house of your target. By cutting one of the plugs so that the red and green wires are exposed, you can figure out which part to plug into your phone and complete the connection.
  • Disable the microphone: Remember to disable the microphone on your phone or tapping device so you don’t have to worry about making any breathing noises which will give you away.
  • Use a recording device: Voice-activated recorders are easy to install if you only want to hear short conversations, because the tape inside the recorder will eventually run out. These recorders can be hooked up to the original telephone and hidden under a bed or even inside the bed frame or under the mattress.
  • Install a bug: One of the most popular wiretapping devices depicted in movies and TV shows is the bug. By installing a bug into the receiver of a telephone, you can route the electrical current which airs the phone conversation to a radio transmitter.
  • FM wiretapping: This system relies on an FM frequency to send a phone call to your transmitter or listening station.
  • Record a call from your phone: If your wiretapping mission involves recording a conversation between you and your target, you can simply record the call. All you have to do is dial an 800 number, such as the one provided by RecordMyCalls.com, and the number of the person or company with whom you want to record a conversation. The service is marketed toward businesses, salesmen and attorneys, but you can technically (but illegally) use it however you want.
  • Upload software onto a cell phone: Cell phone surveillance is a higher tech form of wiretapping, and it’s even easier to do. Whenever you’re around the person you want to spy on, take advantage of bathroom trips or any other circumstance that causes him or her to leave the room without his or her cell phone. You can quickly install a monitoring software program onto the phone which will record calls and text messages. If you’re really devious, set up an alert so that you know when that person is on the line with a number you’re curious about.
  • Use a cell phone as a bug: The Web site GeeksAreSexy.net discusses the “advanced eavesdropping” technique of using a cell phone as a bug. The service FlexiSPY allows you to dial the cell phone number of the person you want to spy on, and you’ll be able to hear all that’s going on in the room. The best part is that the cell phone never rings or vibrates, so no one knows you’re listening.
  • Track someone’s whereabouts with their cell phone: Without needing to break into someone’s house or steal their cell phone for a few minutes, you can use World-Tracker to find out a person’s whereabouts. The service currently only works for phones registered with U.K. phone companies, but is easy to use. Just type in the target’s number, and World-Tracker finds the phone for you on a map.
  • Wiretapping VoIP: Though it’s much more difficult to listen in on a call made over the Internet, it can be done. VoIP operates by digitizing your voice into bits that are transmitted over the Internet and are reconfigured, but are never actually turned back into sound waves. VoIP also runs on your ISP, which is more open than regular phone lines. A product called Cain & Abel was designed to record VoIP calls by decoding the bits and turning them into WAV files. Cain & Abel is available here.
  • Buy a kit from Toys “R” Us: If you’re too lazy to come up with any of these constructions on your own, you can always buy this wiretapping kit from Toys “R” Us, which helps you build a dime-size wiretapping device that can “fit into most telephone handsets.”

Fighting Back

Defend yourself against wiretappers and spies by following these tips. You’ll be able to determine if someone is eavesdropping on your home phone, cell phone or VoIP calls.



  • Listen for breathing: An amateur wiretapper may not have disabled the microphone on his or her device, so you’ll be able to notice odd breathing on the line, especially if the person you’re on the phone with is talking.
  • Listen for clicking: Hearing a clicking sound while you’re on the phone is one of the most well-known signs that you’re being wiretapped with a bug.
  • Determine if anyone has broken into your home: Look for broken locks, rearranged furniture and mussed up pillows or bedding (if your phone is on a night stand) to find out whether someone has been inside your home and messing with the phone.
  • Open up your phone’s receiver: Pop open the receiver to see if there are any bugs, recording devices or strange wires inside your phone.
  • Check for any suspicious wires running from your phone: Spybusters LLC, a company that performs eavesdropping-detection audits, explains on its Web site the different types of wires your phone should have and which ones indicate wiretapping.
  • Look for a permanent splice in your phone wires: If you trace the entire phone wire, you should be able to find this splice, which indicates that someone has wiretapped your phone.
  • Look for any evidence that a bug was ever in your home: If you’ve made it known that you suspect someone has been spying on you, the perpetrator may have been able to get to your phone and remove the wiretap. Look for damage done to the telephone cable or receiver which could indicate a hasty removal of a wiretap.
  • Don’t mess with the evidence: If you find a wiretap but are afraid of someone removing it before you have a chance to call the police, photograph the evidence.
  • Use an encryption VoIP service like Skype: Skype is an especially difficult service to tap, because of its encryption strategy. Slate reporter David Bennahum writes that “the company has built in such strong encryption that it’s all but mathematically impossible with today’s best computer technology to decode the scrambled bits into a conversation.” You’re more protected with this system.
  • Have your cell phone wiped clean: If you aren’t sure how to delete the hidden software on your phone, you can take the phone to your provider’s office, where they can wipe out any extra software.
  • Check to see if your phone lights up irregularly: If you aren’t using your phone when it lights up, someone may be trying to listen in.
  • Get a wiretap-detection device: You can get professional help by calling a company that evaluates your phone for wiretapping evidence, or you can use a wiretap-detection device that monitors your phones for bugs and eavesdropping tools.
  • Call the police: If you’re seriously afraid of someone infringing on your privacy rights, stealing confidential information or even threatening your well-being, call the police. Don’t disturb any evidence of the wiretaps so that the police can evaluate the surveillance.

One important caveat.  This isn’t going to help anyone who seeks to defeat wiretapping or a pen register by law enforcement, which is ordinarily done via the telecoms at a central station/wire room.  These taps are not detectable at your end of the phone, and they aren’t supposed to be.

Note that this post was republished at the invitation of IT Security, and you should check them out to learn more.

A Lesson in Real Law (or A Bad Day in Court)

Norm Pattis made the mistake of agreeing to have his case tried before a Magistrate Judge in the District of Connecticut.  It hasn’t turned out very well for him.

Norm describes how the federal rules of evidence are supposed to work, how objections are supposed to be made and how the court is supposed to be fair in its application of the rules to both sides.  He also describes how this isn’t happening.

Norm’s description provides a critical lesson for less experienced lawyers and non-lawyers alike.  One is often left with the impression from the various discussions in the blawgosphere, particularly from the lawprofs, that the law consists of highly thoughtful, intellectually sound and deeply nuanced application of rules.  But lawprofs spend their days discussing decisions of the United States Supreme Court, which sits at the top of the federal judiciary food chain.  Norm’s trial is happening at the bottom of the food chain.

This is what I call the trenches.  I might call it the gutter, but that would be derogatory, and lawyers are prohibited from denigrating the judiciary so I would never do so. 

Reality in the trenches is very, very different from the rarefied atmosphere of the Supreme Court.  No thousand eyes and ears parsing every word, every argument, every subtle nuance.  Just the participants engaged in a very rough approximation of the things discussed publicly in Washington.

By the time a case tried in the trenches makes its way onto anybody else’s radar, it’s been sanitized and gussied up to give it the appearance of what we have come to believe is a trial.  But like making sausages, watching it happen is ugly.  Should this trial ever make it to the Supreme, you wouldn’t recognize it.

Some judges give great trials.  Some trials just go smoothly.  And some go like Norm’s. 

So the lesson is that life in the trenches may bear no relationship to our nice discussions about the law.  In some trials, objections may be sustained or overruled in a fashion that seems so arbitrary and capricious as to make everything we learn, everything we discuss, seem like a cruel farce.

For young lawyers, when the day comes that you end up on trial before a judge who seems to be operating under a set of rules that is foreign to everything you know, realize that this is life in the trenches.  Norm does what most young lawyers are unprepared to do.  He stands his ground, risking the anger of the judge and the outside chance that he’s going to get pounded for his insolence.  Most young lawyers will collapse in the face of a heavy judicial hand, lacking the security of knowing that they are right in their position and fearing the power of the majestic robe.

When you are young, you tend to give judges a great deal of credence.  As you age a bit, you realize that judges may not be as brilliant, fair or knowledgeable as they appear.  You still show deference, but maybe not as much and with far less concern for what the judge will think of you. 

For any reader who has, or may have, a case that will go to trial, this reflects the variable that you will confront.  If you find yourself before a great judge, you may have a great trial.  But it’s quite possible that you will find yourself before a judge who shoots without aiming, who seems remarkably unfamiliar with all those silly evidentiary rules that lawyers use when devising their strategy and expect to have in their corner when executing it.  In other words, some trials feel like they’re being tried in the District of Wonderland.  Don’t ask your lawyer to explain it.  There’s no explanation.  It is life in the trenches.

The degree of frustration that comes with bizarre rulings is overwhelming.   Lawyers cannot plan to apply rules that don’t exist or exist only for one side.  What do you do when you make a Crawford objection, and the judge responds, “Crawford, Schmawford.  Next question.”

There’s always an appeal, but the fact remains that trial provides the best chance of winning, and we want to win at trial.  I would venture to say that most judges give us good trials.  But there are a lot of judges, and that means that there are still a lot of judges who will make trial rulings like the ones Norm has gotten.  If you try enough cases, you’re going to end up with one of these judges eventually.  And that’s life in the trenches.

Just Say No to More Law Schools

To more law schools.  A combination of two stories at the New York Lawyer makes the point I’ve argued here:  We don’t need more law school and we don’t need to continue to promote the notion that a law school degree is the ticket to fame and fortune.

New York, the law school state, fearing that some potential rival for the title will creep up on it and surpass it quietly, isn’t satisfied resting on its laurels.  No, it wants to add more law schools to its arsenal.  Perhaps the goal is to provide a lawyer for every resident.  Perhaps it means to send them out across the control, like sleeper moles, to awake one day and seize New Yorkean control over courtrooms everywhere.  Why knows?

But not everyone (aside from me) favors the idea:

The Bar Association of Erie County opposes “any and all plans to develop new law schools in New York State at this time,” according to a recent resolution adopted by its board of directors.

The Buffalo bar group’s resolution came in response to controversial budget items adopted by the Legislature in early April – allocations totaling $50.5 million toward the possibility of as many as three new law campuses. New York now has 15 law schools accredited by the American Bar Association, two of which are public institutions.

One argument in favor of adding 3 new law schools, two annexed to the State Universities at Stony Brook (on Long Island) and Buffalo Binghamton, and a third as part of a private college in beautiful downtown Rochester, is that there are only 2 public law schools in New York out of the existing 15, and these would offer a less expensive law school education to New Yorkers.

Are legislators trying to break the stranglehold of private law schools, offering access to the law to those who can’t afford the high price of a legal education?  If that was true, it would at least offer a rational basis for adding more law schools to a grossly oversaturated market.  But the alternative is that this is empire building (in the Empire State, get it?) by legislators trying to steer public monies, projects, jobs and control to their districts.

But simultaneously, the New York Lawyer points out that:


To hear many students tell it, law school is a guaranteed ticket to a well-paying career. So a recent milestone must have sounded like good news.

The United States last week became the world’s first nation of 200 accredited law schools, as the American Bar Association gave provisional approval to two North Carolina institutions.

Connect the dots here.  Two Hundred law schools put out a lot of lawyers.  Every year.  Year after year.  And they all have to do something with that degree.


But many students don’t realize at first that the high-paying law firms recruit almost exclusively at institutions ranked in the top 15 or so. Overall, the median salary for new lawyers is $62,000. For public interest law jobs, new lawyers can expect about $40,000.

Meanwhile, the average amount students borrow to attend a private law school surged 25 percent between 2002 and 2007 to $87,906, ABA figures show. For public law schools, borrowing averages $57,170.

“I think we have this fundamental disconnect between images of lawyers in the popular media, in the courtroom dispensing justice, where everyone seems prosperous and well paid,” said William Henderson, an Indiana University-Bloomington law professor who studies the job market. “The reality is for a lot of people, law school is a route to trying to start your own private practice, and that’s a very crowded business right now.”

Given the law porn that has become the weapon of choice for law schools to deceive solicit young people to send in that deposit, the dubious use of statistics to support the belief that law school is the academic alternative to “Who Wants to be a Millionaire” and the pervasive cultural belief that being a lawyer is a guarantee to a life of comfort, happiness and fulfillment, the creation of yet more law schools is like offering heroin to an addictive society. 

Contrary to popular belief, there is a saturation point in education.  Every American cannot be a lawyer, or a doctor, or an Indian Native-American chief.  Aside from the harm this does to the young people who are being led down the garden path to lawyer-misery, the dilution of the quality of the bar (that horse may have long ago left the barn) and the drain of talent from disciplines that would provide more societally beneficial skills, the creation of too many lawyers results in a mass of social problems created by idle lawyer hands. 

If the public authorities feel compelled to add new public law schools, then they should close two for every new one opened.  Or mandate lower tuition with increased entrance requirements.  But stop ignoring the reality in the name of urban renewal, local pork or better access for the poor. 

We are producing too many lawyers.  This isn’t helping anyone.