Author Archives: SHG

My Problem With the Innocence Project is… (Update)

Thanks to our Hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, for this Youtube video of Republican Senator Dale Volker of the 59th Senate District (better known as Cheektowaga County, the world-renown center for critical thought): 

“I believe they don’t want to find innocent people innocent, they want to find guilty people innocent.”

“We have a problem that’s developing with DNA, and we know it.”

We know, for instance, that some of the people found innocent in Illinois because of DNA, were guilty. They actually committed the crimes. We know that.

In fact, I argue that the Innocence Project did a good job finding some guilty people innocent, because that’s clear.  We know that.  They confessed.

But because of the way evidence works, some of those people were found innocent.

I am happy to work on finding people innocent who are certainly not guilty.  But I have to tell you, there have been very, very, very few in this state.

That’s there job, is to find people innocent; That’s fine, if they’re truly innocent, because most of the crimes in this state, unfortunately, are not solved.  We know that for a fact.

I’m glad the New York City Bar, or New York State Bar, whichever it is, it doesn’t matter because they’re both the same, that they’re doing this, but they better watch themselves, because there’s a lot more coming out about DNA cases in the future, I’ll tell you right now, that’s gonna make a lot of people wonder about the total accuray of it, and that’s why we want more study…and I’m fine with using DNA to find people innocent it they’re truly innocent, I just want you to know that.

You can’t make this stuff up.

Now Senator Volker is a very influential, long-term senator in New York.  When he speaks, others listen.  He carries significant weight.  I suspect it’s because he “knows” stuff.  He knows who’s guilty and innocent.  He knows about the future of DNA, that’s inaccurate unless used to convict.  And he knows what evil lurks in the hearts of Barry Scheck and Russ Neufeld. 

If you wonder how thoughtful, intelligent and caring lawmakers end up doing such a poor job of things, don’t blame Dale Volker.  He knows better.



Update:  Mike at Crime & Federalism shows another video proving that Henry Waxman (D-CA) shows the stupidity owns no side of the aisle.


Doctors’ Orders

It doesn’t surprise me that Norm Pattis has a thing about doctors.  After all, at his age, the snap of a latex glove behind your back can’t help but cause a visceral reaction.  Still, calling a visit by federal marshals on a recalcitrant doctor “a thing of beauty” might be viewed as a bit uncaring. 

A doctor was issued a subpoena to bring medical records to court. He refused to come unless and until his patient signed a release to turn over the medical records. When it was explained to him that a subpoena is a court order that he must obey, he said he did “not understand it that way.”

So a federal judge was asked to intervene. U.S. Marshals made a call to the doctor, explaining, politely, I presume, that he had two choices: Either get in the car and come to court with the requested records, or wait for the marshals to come and get him. Those were his only two options.

There is undoubtedly a degree of satisfaction about making some smug doctor, too busy and important to take a phone call and too far above reproach to heed an admonition, comply.  But I’m reluctant to tar them all with the same brush.

In the course of their practice, physicians frequently touch upon aspect of law.  Being a generally bright group, this creates a belief that they know enough to make assess their legal responsibilities and intelligent choices.  Some are generally helpful and cooperative.  Some admit that they really aren’t all that clear on when they should be cooperative and when they ought to refuse to disclose. The HIPAA packet explains a lot, but it’s much too long for anybody to read.  And then there are those who believe that they are a law unto themselves.  They are brilliant, and the law is beneath them.  If they decide that they don’t have to do something, then they don’t.

This can be rather infuriating to lawyers, who suspect that all physicians look down on us.  They do, of course, but still need us, much as we all need plumbers when our pipes leak.  They have an entirely different attitude when they are the target of the prosecution, or the defendant in a med-mal action (which is also a reason why they look down at lawyers, manufacturing malpractice when all they did was maim a patient by accident). 

Is this antagonism between professionals healthy?  It may well be, as I can imagine that unduly compliant physicians would reduce confidentiality to something akin to giving your personal information to the government.  In a sense, I admire physicians who refuse to disclose information about a patient, even if inappropriately.  At least it’s better than the party that vomits whatever privileged communication they have as soon as they smell a lawyer letter in their mailbox.  Or worse yet, total disclosure when a cop tells them, “then I’m going to have to get a court order if you don’t want to cooperate.”  As if their non-cooperation puts them on the “evil doctor” list.

Norm is right that a nice visit from the marshals serves to remind doctors that they too are required to comply with a court order.  The arrogance to think otherwise is the sort of thing that makes lawyers really angry.  There are other people who are too self-important to believe that they are obliged to honor an order of a court.  We meet them all the time.  We ask them, cajole them, try everything in our bag of tricks to persuade them, to follow the law.  They sometimes laugh in our face.  “Hahahaha.  I decide what I do, not you, you lawyer-scum, or your stinking judge too.” 

Sometimes, it’s nice to know that federal judges have marshals to do the persuasion for you.  Now that’s a thing of beauty.

Michigan Fails to Defend Its Poor

From Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious, a disheartening story of how indigent defense in Michigan fails to pass constitutional muster.  Apparently, it’s called “McJustice”, the derogatory reference suggesting that representation of the poor is to lawyering what Big Macs are to food. 

From the NALDA, the National Legal Aid & Defender Association:


A Race to the Bottom: Speed and Savings Over Due Process: A Constitutional Crisis” also found that residents are routinely tried in district courts without access to any legal counsel whatsoever, calling into question the reliability of Michigan’s criminal justice system.

The report found that counties across the state failed to meet the vast majority of the American Bar Association’s Ten Principles, which are considered the national standard for indigent defense. In particular, many residents facing district court trials never have the opportunity to meet with a public defender, and when they do, these meetings are often last-minute and non-confidential.

The Grand Rapids Press tells it this way:


In part, the year-long analysis identified problems such as judges handpicking defense attorneys, lawyers appointed to cases for which they are unqualified, defenders meeting clients on the eve of trial and holding non-confidential discussions in public courtroom corridors, and attorneys failing to identify obvious conflicts of interest. It also cited failure of defenders to properly prepare for trials of sentencings, attorneys violating their ethical requirement to zealously advocate for clients and inadequate compensation for those appointed to defend the accused.

When the system is ruled by grocery clerks, this is what happens.  I bet the defense lawyers believe that they have no choice, given the quantity, but to provide substandard (read worthless to near-worthless representation) legal defense.  The judges just want movement, like cows herded to slaughter.  At the end of the day, the only question is asked is how many cases were closed.

Is this happening where you practice?  Maybe the situation isn’t quite as extreme, but does any of it sound familiar?  It does to me.  And I’ve heard all the excuses.  And I do not accept any of them.

The NALDA press release argues that the answer is funding.  While funding plays a huge role in the ability to have sufficient lawyers to provide the time needed to meet, discuss, investigate, think and defend, it’s not just the funding.  What lawyer knowingly and intentionally becomes a willing cog in the wheels of McJustice?

Without criminal defense lawyers greasing the wheel, happily becoming the enablers of an unacceptable system, the wheels of McJustice would grind to a halt.  This isn’t a monopolistic call to arms, but a call to ethics.  Each lawyer should individually and independently arrive at the conclusion that he or she will not violate the constitution by providing a shoddy (which may be an overstatement) defense to the poor.

And don’t come back and argue that if they refuse to enable, the poor people in the system will go down without any legal representation at all.  Who are you kidding?  Do you really think that your agreeing to wholesale plea deals is making any difference in their lives?  They will give them the same lousy deals with you or without you. You add no value to the mix, by standing nearby as they railroad these indigent defendants and clear the calender.  Don’t give yourself too much credit.

But if you don’t mean to be the person slamming the jail door shut on the poor, then stop doing it.  Afraid to miss your paycheck?  Then we’ve established what you are, and more money in your pocket will just make you more expensive, not better.

When we become attorneys, we make a choice.  We can either practice law or facilitate a system that provides tries to provide the appearance of justice without rendering any.  Your choice. 

John Yoo Ain’t Afraid

Torture?  Turn to Yoo, the former Department of Justice lawyer who penned the memo enlightening our President that American torture is a-okay.  After taking the first air force transport out of Washington, he parachuted into a lawprof job (proof that the Ivory Tower may not be as pure as some might think) at the University of California, Berkeley.  He’s also called a “visiting scholar” at the American Enterprise Institute.  Hey Ted, does he have an office near yours?  Despite calls to cleanse the old Boalt Hall of Yoo, he held firm.

You might think that John Yoo would be a bit gun shy after all the drama, but no real 110% American can keep his pen sheathed when there’s a nation to defend, and so an editorial appeared yesterday in the Wall Street Journal on how our liberal activist Supreme Court has gone to war against our country in Boumediene v. Bush .


Boumediene should finally put to rest the popular myth that right-wing conservatives dominate the Supreme Court.

I know it burst my bubble.  To borrow from America’s Mayor, Richard Daley, a good judge is one who gets bought and stays bought.  I think America deserves a refund.


First out the window went precedent. Under the writ of habeas corpus, Americans (and aliens on our territory) can challenge the legality of their detentions before a federal judge. Until Boumediene, the Supreme Court had never allowed an alien who was captured fighting against the U.S. to use our courts to challenge his detention.

And so what if they weren’t actually “captured fighting” but rather rounded up afterward because somebody pointed the finger at them.  Hey, it’s not like defendants in a narcotics conspiracy are actually required to have anything to do with drugs.  Semantics don’t win wars, you know.


The Boumediene five also ignored the Constitution’s structure, which grants all war decisions to the president and Congress. In 2004 and 2006, the Court tried to extend its reach to al Qaeda terrorists held at Guantanamo Bay. It was overruled twice by Congress, which has the power to define the jurisdiction of the federal courts. Congress established its own procedures for the appeal of detentions.

While I haven’t read it in a while, I’m pretty sure that Article III limits the Supreme Court to getting together for the ceremonial group photo once a year, and otherwise making sure that the really important branches of government get to do whatever pops into their minds as a good idea.


Incredibly, these five Justices have now defied the considered judgment of the president and Congress for a third time, all to grant captured al Qaeda terrorists the exact same rights as American citizens to a day in civilian court.

It just makes you want to cry out in anguish.  Habeas Shmabeas.  Don’t these activists realize what side they’re on?


Judicial micromanagement will now intrude into the conduct of war. Federal courts will jury-rig a process whose every rule second-guesses our soldiers and intelligence agents in the field. A judge’s view on how much “proof” is needed to find that a “suspect” is a terrorist will become the standard applied on the battlefield. Soldiers will have to gather “evidence,” which will have to be safeguarded until a court hearing, take statements from “witnesses,” and probably provide some kind of Miranda-style warning upon capture. No doubt lawyers will swarm to provide representation for new prisoners.

Do they get paid extra for micromanagement?  But Yoo has completely missed the boat by suggesting that lawyers will “swarm” to provide representation.  Accused terrorists are terrible payers, and it’s almost impossible to collect.

Okay, enough sarcasm.  Yoo is nuts, plain and simple.  Rarely does one see such sycophantic rant from someone who is allowed anywhere near young people.  It was one thing when he was on the DOJ payroll, providing the administration with the rationale to do as it pleased for political ends, but either Yoo actually believes this utter crap or he’s found himself a niche and plans to milk it for all it’s worth.

Yoo concludes his diatribe with a call to elect McCain.  So what’s his angle, attorney general or Ginsburg’s seat on the Court? 

While I am in the camp that Yoo should not be tossed out on his ear as a lawprof because he holds extremist views, the fact that his argument against the Boumediene decision is so irrational and unfounded leads me to think that he should be tossed out for legal incompetence, politics notwithstanding. 

If nothing else, John Yoo should have the good sense to lay low for a while.

AP to Blawgosphere: Drop Dead (Update)

From Dan Solove at Co-Op, this bit of tawdry news from the New York Times that the Associated Press has had enough of us bloggers glomming up all their “creative content.”



The Associated Press, one of the nation’s largest news organizations, said that it will, for the first time, attempt to define clear standards as to how much of its articles and broadcasts bloggers and Web sites can excerpt without infringing on The A.P.’s copyright.


The A.P.’s effort to impose some guidelines on the free-wheeling blogosphere, where extensive quoting and even copying of entire news articles is common, may offer a prominent definition of the important but vague doctrine of “fair use.”


Oops.  Did I quote too much.  Is Adam Liptak preparing the takedown letter even as I type?

[Edit: Just so we’re clear, I am not arguing that reposting an AP article in its entirety is or should be acceptable.  We’re talking quotations, people, quotations!]

Dan provides the root of this stupidity (note my word choice, should you have any doubt as to my thoughts on the subject):


This statement comes on the heels of the AP’s sending a letter to the Drudge Retort to remove quotations from AP stories that ranged from about 40 to 80 words. These weren’t very big excerpts. The AP later backtracked a bit, claiming that its letter was “heavy handed,” but it has not withdrawn the takedown letters to Drudge. According to the NY Times article: “The Associated Press believes that in some cases, the essence of an article can be encapsulated in very few words.”

Generally speaking, we quote only as much as is needed to make the point.  Whether it’s 5 words or 100.  I respect ownership of content likely far more than most, and it annoys me greatly when other steal my posts wholesale and publish them on their own blogs, often without any attribution.  But I have one saving grace: They can steal one post, but I can create more.  This they cannot do.

For the AP to whine about the length of quotes is just plain silly.  They thrive off recognition of their content.  It gives the AP credibility and relevance.  What if nobody cared what the AP had to say?  Hey Sam Maull (AP reporter for New York courts), need a job?


If anything, discussion of articles in the blogosphere enhances the attention a news organization will receive, as well as encourages more people to read the article. The AP says that it doesn’t want to stop people from quoting its articles very briefly and linking to them; it wants to limit how much bloggers quote. The difficulty here is that AP stories quickly disappear from the Internet, so links to full articles go dead after a week or two. The New York Times has a much more enlightened policy, encouraging bloggers to use and link to its articles by offering a permalink that will never go dead.

Absolutely.  So quit yer whining and forget about giving ultimatums.  The day nobody quotes from an AP story is the day you should start to worry.  In the meantime, you ought to send out little thank you notes to show your appreciation for the fact that anybody even cares enough to recognize your existence.  Sheesh.

Update:  Orin Kerr at Volokh spreads a bit of irony on the AP:


Glenn Reynolds, Michelle Malkin, and Patterico have noted the apparent irony that the Associated Press quoted 154 words from one of Patterico’s blog posts soon after threatening bloggers for quoting fewer words than that from Associated Press stories.

Anybody still want to argue the point?  This does not involve wholesale lifting of content, but fair use quoting. 

Who’s at Fault For the Kozinski Kerfluffle?

Just when you thought it was safe to go back to the 9th Circuit, there’s a new explosion of interest in Chief Judge Alex Kozinski.  His wife, lawyer Marcy Tiffany, has come to her husband’s defense, writing an email that was posted on Patterico’s Pontifications.


[T]he LA Times story, authored by Scott Glover, is riddled with half-truths, gross mischaracterizations and outright lies. One significant mischaracterization is that Alex was maintaining some kind of “website” to which he posted pornographic material.

She makes a good case, and proceeds to rip into the source of the story:


I think that there is another very important piece of this story that has not received the attention it deserves, and that is the role of Cyrus Sanai.

Cyrus Sanai, a disgruntled attorney/litigant, has widely claimed credit for engineering this smear campaign. In a 2005 decision, District Judge Zilly USDC Western District Seattle, describes Sanai’s conduct in a case before him as “an indescribable abuse of the legal process, unlike anything this Judge has experienced in more than 17 years on the bench and 26 years in private practice: outrageous, disrespectful, and in bad faith.”

This part of her argument, all too familiar to criminal defense lawyers when a client is accidentally shot by cops and then smeared by a prior criminal record as if to suggest that killing him was no big deal anyway.  So what if Cyrus Sanai is an unsavory lawyer; That doesn’t have anything to do with Judge Kozinki’s conduct.

But for a judge who clearly wanted to get this behind him, Tiffany’s email served to open a new chapter to the story, and give it longer legs than it had before.  It may not have been her purpose, but it was certainly the effect.

According to the WSJ Law Blog, Larry Lessig has taken the offensive by attacking the media, including the blawgosphere, for smearing Judge Kozinski.


Parsing “the Kozinski mess”: Lessig says the real Kozinski mess is “the total inability of the media — including we, the media, bloggers — to get the basic facts right, and keep the reality in perspective.” Lessig writes: “The real story here is how easily we let such a baseless smear travel – and our need is for a better developed immunity (in the sense of immunity from a virus) from this sort of garbage.”

Well, hold on a minutes.  Does Lessig suggest that we should ignore an article in the LA Times because we don’t have personal knowledge of all underlying facts and haven’t personally and individually verified each and every one? 

Does Lessig argue that this “baseless smear” is wrong, but takes no issue when the “baseless smear” affects someone who isn’t as near and dear as Judge Kozinski?

This is yet another twist of interest to the Kozinski story.  While some commentators, like Eugene Volokh, have been up front about their connection to, and relationship with, Judge Kozinski, to the point of openly admitting that his ideas should “properly be discounted because of my bias,” others have not been as open.  Still others have been downright disingenuous, making argument in support of Kozinski that fly in the face of their actions as to everyone else.

David Lat, who has feasted on unsubstantiated gossip at Above the Law as well as his blog dedicated to sifting the salacious from the judicious, Underneath Their Robes (where he blogged anonymously as Article III Groupie, or A3G as he came to be known), joins the chorus.  But does the former AUSA explain his sudden conversion?  Isn’t this the guy who is first on line (and online) to publish a smear of any lawyer or judge?  In fairness, Lat’s connection to Kozinski is well-known to his long-time followers, but the new reader would be left out in the cold.

Jon Katz, posting at Underdog about whether Judge Kozinski’s recusal and mistrial order implicates double jeopardy for Ira Isaacs, whose trial was scuttled as a result of all this, addresses whether this “scandal” constitutes manifest necessity for a mistrial.  Jon writes:


As much as I dislike self-censorship, I suggest that a mess of the current magnitude should have been reasonably foreseeable by Judge Kozinski over his uploading sexually explicit images to the Internet. Of all trials to take as a supplement to his appellate judging, it is surprising that Judge Kozinski would have taken this one.

Regardless of whether one loves, hates or doesn’t feel much either way about Judge Kozinski, the fact remains that he’s a judge.  As such, he was in a position that exposes his professional life, and anything arguably wrong or sordid in his personal life, to scrutiny.  He knew that.  We know that.  The question of whether it truly matters, or whether it would have gone public had some disgruntled lawyer not gone after him, is another matter.  Judge Kozinski was flying too close to the sun, and he is clearly smart enough to have known better.

So while I do not believe that the many attacks on Kozinki were entirely justified, and I do not agree that recusal was the necessary and inevitable outcome of the disclosure and ensuing “scandal”, I similarly reject Judge Kozinki’s defenders effort to shift the blame to the media, or the blawgosphere, for creating what Lessig calls the baseless smear.  That’s life on the big bench, and Judge Alex should have been smart enough, and tough enough, to handle it. 

And as long as we’re talking about internet integrity, I hope that Larry Lessig and David Lat maintain their overt concern for truth and accuracy in the media when the person smeared isn’t a personal friend.  I have a few clients who would benefit from their position as well, and I trust that they will do the same for my clients as they’ve done for Judge Kozinski.  But I won’t hold my breath.

Is She “Yer Honor” When She Leaves the Bench?

Historically, there was little question of how a former judge should refer to herself.  When a judge’s career on the bench was over, it was due to one of three causes:  Retirement, death or disgrace.  One joined the judiciary as the crowning glory of a distinguished career in the law.  Ah, but that was way back when. 

Today, as kid prosecutors become judges as part of their career path, something that I’ve taken issue with in the past, and as judicial salaries fail to cover college tuition bills, something is happening today that was never part of the deal before:  Judges are leaving the bench to return to private practice as (ahem) ordinary lawyers.

According to the New York Lawyer, this has created an identification issue:

In canvassing a number of former judges across Pennsylvania, it seems the scales are balanced in terms of those who still use the title in their Web biographies or phone messages and those who do not.

And, admittedly, it is a confusing issue with no clear rule that refers to former judges and titles. The Code of Judicial Conduct is worded for sitting judges, and the state’s Rules of Professional Conduct generally point to attorneys without referencing judges specifically.

While others may refer to former judges by using a courtesy title, the question of whether the former judges may hold themselves out as “Judge Jones” to clients is another matter.  Some use “judge” all over the place, on their voicemail, in their pleadings, on their letterhead and in the faux wood-grain nameplate on their desk.

I’ve always referred to ex-judges by using their title as a matter of courtesy, unless they are personal friends in which case I may not be very formal at all.  But for the former judges to promote themselves as if they are entitled to quit the job and enjoy the perks forever is another matter.

Once you’ve stepped off the bench and into the well, you’re not “judge” anymore.  You’re one of us again, trench lawyers fighting for a client like anybody else.  How pretentious, how pompous, how wrong, to refer to yourself as “judge” when you’re not.  It’s a flagrant commercialization of the position, using it as a lawyer to suggest having an “inside track” which you know to be nonsense, and trying to sell the title to promote yourself.  Aren’t you embarrassed by doing this?

Unfortunately, there are no real rules about this.


Joseph A. Massa Jr. is chief counsel of the Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board. Speaking only for himself, Massa said he would point to Canon 2(b) of the Code of Judicial Conduct as to the rule governing the issue of former judges retaining titles. The rule states that judges “should not lend the prestige of their office to advance the private interests of others; nor should they convey or knowingly permit others to convey the impression that they are in a special position to influence the judge.”

So that suggests that former judges, who should be expected to conduct themselves with some small recognition of right and wrong, will act accordingly?


Even if the rules were interpreted to mean former judges should refrain from using the title, the judicial and attorney disciplinary boards haven’t gone after anyone for the infraction and some say that wouldn’t be a priority compared to other potential egregious acts.

While this isn’t the most pressing concern of the bench and bar, it wouldn’t take much to clarify the rules and end this clearly inappropriate usage.  Given the trend toward judges returning to private practice, it’s likely to be a growing problem.  Let’s nip this one in the bud.

Jersey Goes Way Wrong on Bail

Thankfully, trends never start in New Jersey.  That’s where they go to die.  But that doesn’t mean that an outrageous and conceptually dangerous new bail law won’t manage to wreak terrible harm across the river from civilization. 

Thanks to a tip from a reader, this New Jersey Law Journal op-ed ($$) exposes how Jersey has turned its already unwieldly bail system on its head:


The new law, N.J.S.A. 2A:162-13 and 14, applies to certain crimes, such as murder, manslaughter, sexual assault, drug offenses and eluding the police. It requires the accused to provide a statement under oath about the source of the bail money. That statement must include the accused’s employment history, the names and addresses of the people who contributed to the bail, the amount, the nature and timing of the contribution, and the relationship between the accused to the people providing the funds. Bail cannot be approved until the form is completed. This puts an enormous burden on the accused.

The starting point is the NJ uses bail bondsmen to post bail with 10% collateral.  This is good for bondsmen, since they make a fee based upon the State’s forced love, but already puts defendants and their families into paying for the privilege of not becoming a guest of the State.

But the State has now shifted another burden, proof of the source of funds, onto the defendant and his family, even in the absence of any evidence to suggest that there is any issue at all. 

There is an understandable, and somewhat reasonable, argument to be made the defendants should not be allowed to use criminal proceeds to free themselves on bail.  From one angle it makes sense, since ill-gotten gains shouldn’t inure to a criminal’s benefit.  The problem, of course, is that the defendant is not yet a criminal, having been convicted of nothing, and his funds cannot yet be deemed criminal proceeds for the same reason. 

In some states, such as New York, prosecutors can make a showing that there is a likelihood that the funds used for bail are tainted, and if the judge is convinced (or just too prosecutorial-minded to question), the burden then shifts to the defendant to show that his bail money is clean.  While the burden on the state is far too low, and shifts far too easily and indeed presumptively when the crime charged involves drugs, the problem is with lax judges and not terribly bad law (just moderately bad law).

But Jersey had to be different.  By law, the burden is on the defendant to prove, without any hint whatsoever, the source of bail funds.  This goes way too far.  These are presumptively innocent people, while the law presumes them guilty by forcing them to prove where there money comes from in the first instance.  Then, it creates a whole new pile of hazards for the defendant, swearing to the truth of matters which a defendant can’t possibly know, and risking perjury in the process, or sitting in jail.

This smells of using bail as an investigative tool to ferret out untaxed income as well as criminal proceeds.  This isn’t the purpose of bail, which is limited to securing the defendant’s attendance at future court proceedings, and uses defendants as pawns in a law enforcement game.  

This new law will prove a very expensive gambit to Jersey, when the taxpayers have to cough up the money to house and feed all those defendants who can’t meet the new rules, not for nefarious reasons but because their friends aren’t inclined to get involves in this new bail process, and defendants, such as children or the mentally ill, can’t lawfully swear to the source of other people’s money.  Even the timing required to obtain the information will mean that defendants who have the legitimate resources to pay bail and complete the affidavit languish in jail until the paperwork can be completed. 

One would have hoped that Jon Corzine, Democratic seat belt criminal and near death survivor, would have been more thoughtful before signing a law like this.   This law is wrong on every level, and for a governor trying to reduce the tax burden on his citizens, this is a fool’s errand.

Breaking News: Tiger Wins in Sudden Death

After an 18 hole playoff left Tiger Woods and Rocco Mediate tied at even par, Tiger took the win in sudden death with a birdie.  This is Tiger’s third U.S. Open Victory and 12th (or 14th according to who you’re listening to) Major.

Rocco Mediate was a star through this U.S. Open, playing spectacularly and always with a smile on his face.  His world ranking rose 111 spots, and admiration for his effort and demeanor cannot be counted. 

What a great U.S. Open.  Thanks Tiger and Rocco.

Bullying: Editors Murder a Tree

When I noted that Newsday took the lead on the Patrick Kohlmann bullying story, while the NY Times was too busy questioning what color was the “new black,” it was to praise the schizophrenic tabloid for addressing ugliness close to home and in the face of institutional school district resistance.  That feeling didn’t last too long.

Today, Newsday prints an editorial on the Patrick Kohlmann article and the topic of bullying.  I mourn the loss of trees.

Let’s cut to the beef of the editorial:



A West Islip school district spokeswoman says she cannot discuss Patrick’s case. Fair enough. But when contacted Friday, the school did not take the opportunity to describe its anti-bullying program either, or even to confirm if it has one.


Effective programs have been available to schools for a decade. Not only does anti-bullying education teach kids about standing up for themselves, it puts tormentors on warning. The programs send a message, schoolwide, that bullying won’t be tolerated. Every school should know where to find such resources when they’re needed.


A kids gets his head bashed by a rock.  The vice-principal is informed in advance and does nothing.  And Newsday, in a palpable display of anger and frustration, calls for schools to have an anti-bullying program?  Talk about going out on a limb.

This is what I call the “let’s put on a play” form of editorializing, skirting controversy at all costs by pretending to address a subject while saying essentially nothing.  Come on.  Take a chance.  Get wild.  Get crazy.  Demand that schools actually protect their students from getting their heads bashed in. 

What could possibly have gone through the collective minds of the committee that came up with the “let’s put on a play” solution to a problem that is not only real, not only inexcusable, but can cause actual human blood to mess up that nicely shined linoleum floor in the high school hallway? 

This problem goes back to my challenge, issued less than a week ago, for Newsday to tough it out by either taking a position or offering some meaningful critical dialogue, or go cut bait and use its paper to wrap the dead fish.  At least then, the murder of so many trees wouldn’t be a total waste.

Newsday editors, this is not an attack but the extension of one reader’s hand in moving this paper off the dime.  Either you stand for something, or you stand for nothing.  I know you to be a very smart, very engaged group of people, ready to challenge each other and just dying to air it all out.  Are you afraid to offend?  Are you afraid to save the life of some kid somewhere whose head may be bashed more effectively than young Mr. Kohlmann, who had the good fortune to survive?  I know you care.  What is stopping you from showing it?

If you won’t do it for me; if you won’t do it for all the Patrick Kohlmann’s who are depending on you, then at least do it for the trees.