Author Archives: SHG

Creating a Master List of the Practical Criminal Law Blawgosphere

I asked Austin criminal defense lawyer (who should always be referred to that way, incidentally) to do me a favor.  Being a dinosaur, I have some trouble keeping track of the ever-changing world of the blawgosphere, particularly the criminal law blogs that come and go.  I keep finding new ones that I’ve missed, and it makes me wonder what else I’ve missed out there.

Jamie, being far more experienced in such things than anyone else I know, except possibly Gideon, who already has his hands full keeping up with that tiny slice (40+) of public defender blawgs, picked up the gauntlet and is ready to run.

Please help Jamie. 

This should enable the criminal law blawgosphere to identify new blawgs more quickly and benefit from the thoughts and ideas that they bring to the conversation.  New blawgs often fly under the radar for a while, and some great content is lost because we just don’t know they’re there.  Bear in mind, just because a blawg is new doesn’t mean the writer isn’t brilliant and doesn’t have great things to offer.

Following up on Jamie’s post, I would like to see every real criminal law blog listed, and a way for new blogs to be added as they enter the blawgosphere, whether because the new blogger knows enough to do so or a reader or long-time blawger sends Jamie the URL.  They can then be organized into groups, like Prosecutor Blawgs, Public Defender Blawgs, Lawprof Blawgs, Texas Blawgs (for obvious reasons, Texas gets its own group).  It would be great to have a brief description of each (self-written perhaps?) to know what its focus is.

I would also like to see blogs that appear to be criminal law, but exist only for self-promotion, identified as such to save everyone the time of looking.  I don’t care for these, and frankly find it disturbing that they exist at all, tend to have the most pretentious names and, in my humble opinion, bring disrepute to the blawgosphere.  So, there should be a blacklist of faux blogs. 

Perhaps the biggest problem with doing a list like this is that it’s never a static event.  This is an unstable world, with blawgs coming and going without fanfare.  How can we make new blawgs aware of its existence?  How can we keep the changes on everyone’s radar?  I don’t know.  But I, for one, would like to have a far better way to keep abreast (no giggling, children) of the criminal blawgosphere. 

If you think this would be a good thing, give Jamie a hand.  And add in your own ideas of how to make this work best.  The practical blawgosphere (name invented by the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett) is one of the most vibrant places on the internet.  Let’s keep it that way.  Are you with me?

Rothgery Gets a Lawyer

The Supremes have decided Rothgery v. Gillespie County, that dopey Texas case where they decided that a “magistration hearing” is a good time to put people in jail but a bad time to provide them with counsel.  Past discussions can be found here and here.

But aside from this, the decision doesn’t provide much by way of guidance.  The holding appears to be:

[A] criminal defendant’s initial appearance before a judicial officer, where he learns the charge against him and his liberty is subject to restriction, marks the start of adversary judicial proceedings that trigger attachment of the Sixth Amendment right to counsel.

Does that create a new tripartite test, requiring (1) initial appearance before a judicial officer, (2) he learned of the charges, and (3) his liberty is subject to restriction.  If one of these things is missing, does that mean the right to counsel doesn’t attach?  Isn’t it really all about the “liberty subject to restriction,” and the others factors are just the norm, but not critical?

And then, the question remains whether the defendant must have counsel present at the proceeding, or whether he has to request it, or whether he gets counsel afterward. 

Lots of questions.  The Court has now gotten away from the semantic problem, what the proceeding is called, and into the substantive problem of what happens at the proceeding, regardless of what it’s called.  It also rejected Gillespie County’s argument that it has to do with the availability or presence of a prosecutor.

In the end, we know that what Gillespie County did was wrong.  We just don’t know what is right.  I guess we’ll just have to wait for the next decision on the issue to bring us a little closer to understanding when these out-of-the-way jurisdictions are going to start affording counsel to defendants before they lock them up.

Bernstein at Volokh: I’m One of the Little People!

David Bernstein, Volokh conspirator and lawprof at George Mason Law School in Arlington, Virginny, is a regular guy.  No Chardonnay for him, I gather, from his scathing criticism of a reference in a  New York Times article on green homes, a favorite subject lately since green became the new black.

To prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that he’s a shot and beer guy, Bernstein gives the Times a smack:

I often get a kick out of the subtle signals the Times sends that its target demographic is a Manhattanite with a family income of at least 500K a year. For example, in an article on green homes today: “The checklist for certification can be more daunting than a private-school application.” Note the assumption that (a) readers are familiar with private school applications; and (b) that the private schools that people send their kids to are extremely competitive and hard to get into, which I suspect account for a very small fraction of private schools nationwide and even New York City generally, but a large fraction of schools to which upper-income Manhattanites send their children.

Nice going Dave.  So if you ever get the job at NYU Law, your kid’s chances of getting into Horace Mann just went from slim to none.

The handful of private schools that they’re talking about aren’t your run-of-the-mill parochials, or omnipresent Busy Bee Nursery School.  We’re talking top of the line, the sort of school that you apply for at least 6 months before your child is born if you want any chance of getting junior into Harvard some day.  If you can’t grasp the difference, then it doesn’t matter because you don’t have a chance of getting a seat anyway.

The problem for Manhattanites is too many people with too much money and too few academic choices.  It’s a standing joke, but not a joke at all in New York City.  Of course, the Times reference was to the joke aspect, since we all make fun of the competitive nature of these schools, and how young parents live and die when the admissions letter arrives, their child’s entire life dependent on the contents.

Of course this isn’t representative of private schools nationwide.  It isn’t supposed to be.  This is Manhattan, not Topeka.  And trust me, Manhattan doesn’t want to be Topeka.  Not even on its worst day.  Stupid as this may be to the people who live happily in Topeka, it’s reality.  Elitist?  If they could put elitism in a can, there would be a store selling it on Madison Avenue in the 50s.

There are “the” schools to be in, and there are the rest.  No one cares about the rest.  That’s where loser children go, the ones who either didn’t cut it at the interview or whose parents are preparing their children for a life of misery. 

Those of us who escaped from the City have a good laugh at new émigrés, who rush to the best private schools within hours of closing on their house to sign the kiddies up.  They bring their city fears of missing the Yale Train, when our blue blook private schools aren’t quite as competitive.  Just as costly, mind you, but seats are still available.  It’s just the Manhattan mentality, the kill or be killed attitude of self-preservation. 

But David is dead wrong about the half mil crowd being the intended target of such references.  Parents will eat tuna for dinner daily if they have to in order to pay the freight of one of the “in” schools.  It’s what people in Manhattan do.  It’s like Carrie whats-her-name from Sex in the City buying Manolo Blahnik shoes.  There are some things that are worth the sacrifice.

So Bernstein wants to ridicule the New York Times to the frugal and struggling?  Who cares?  New York City doesn’t aspire to be frugal.  It aspires to be FABULOUS!  And it’s fine it that’s not your thing, which is why there are places around like Arlington, Virginny.  Or, frankly, anywhere other than Manhattan.

The Public Defender Blawgosphere; It’s Huge!

Gideon, of A Public Defender fame, moonlights as the blogmeister of Public Defender Stuff, “Indigent defense news, delivered fresh daily.”  And you wonder why he always looks tired.

Probably in response to my complaining yesterday about having too many blawgs to read, Gid reminded me that I’m a piker compared to him.  To this end, he urged me to take a look at what’s going on in the Public Defender blawgosphere and I have to tell you, it’s quite remarkable. 

The wealth of posts, information and insight available from the PDs is amazing.  Compared to the handful of decent criminal law blawgs by private lawyers, the PD blawgosphere is bursting at the seams.  Consider Gid’s list:


a public defender
A Public Defender’s Life in Alaska
Abolish the Death Penalty
Arbitrary and Capricious
Between A Laugh And A Tear
Cook County Public Defenders Blog
Demonstrative Evidence
Doubtslinger
the Dream Antilles
Fifth Circuit Blog
Fourth Circuit Blog
Go West Young Tex
Indefensible
Indignant Indigent
Infinity Ranch
Ipse Dixit
Jay
Kansas Defenders
Kansas Federal Defender
Knit and the City
La Peine Forte et Dure
lawbabeak
MissTyrios dot com
Ninth Circuit Blog
Petition for Review
Preaching to the Choir
Rabid Sanity
Second Circuit Blog
Scoplaw
Sixth Circuit Blog
Swan Lake Samba Girl
Tales of a Public Defender Investigator
Tenth Circuit Blog
The Rural Bus Route
The Saucy Vixen on Life
The Underblawg
Third Circuit Blog
Woman in Black

While I can’t say that I read all of these blawgs, I do read some religiously and scan others regularly.  If you’re interested in criminal law topics, this is a mother-lode of good reading.  Before people jump down the throats of public defenders, take a good look and appreciate some of the best and most concerned lawyers around.

And lest I forget, thanks to Gideon for putting this all together in one place for the rest of us.

Former ADA Admits Throwing the Palladium Murder Case

In 1990, the Palladium murder case against Olmeda Hidalgo and David Lemus was big news.  Outside the Palladium nightclub, known for drugs and hard-partying, they were accused of gunning down the bouncer.  It looked open and shut at the time.

But in 2003, evidence suggested that the defendants were innocent, and the matter made it to a hearing in 2005.  ADA Daniel Bibb, one of the most senior trial lawyers in Manhattan DA Robert Morgenthau’s office, was put in charge of the investigation.

From the New York Times :

Mr. Bibb said he shared his growing doubts with his superiors. And at a meeting in early 2005, he recalled, after defense lawyers won court approval for a hearing into the new evidence, he urged that the convictions be set aside. “I made what I considered to be my strongest pitch,” he said.

Instead, he said, he was ordered to go to the hearing, present the government’s case and let a judge decide — a strategy that violated his sense of a prosecutor’s duty.

But Dan Bibb, who looks much more like a cop than a lawyer, had been in the office for too long, and had enough.

[Dan Bibb] threw the case. Unwilling to do what his bosses ordered, he said, he deliberately helped the other side win.

He tracked down hard-to-find or reluctant witnesses who pointed to other suspects and prepared them to testify for the defense. He talked strategy with defense lawyers. And when they veered from his coaching, he cornered them in the hallway and corrected them.

“I did the best I could,” he said. “To lose.”

I know Dan pretty well, and I find it almost impossible to believe.  Not that he did the right thing; He was a stand-up guy.  But he was a company man.  He was a lifer.  That he would actively work to undermine the prosecution is incredible.

Shortly after this case, Dan left the DAs office in disgust.  I found out when I saw him sitting in his regular seat at the bar at Forlini’s and we talked.  He was trying his hand at doing some defense work for a small firm, and was having a hard time of it.  It wasn’t really in his blood, though he had an epiphany that defending people wasn’t evil.

And what of the ethics of a prosecutor not merely throwing a case that he doesn’t believe in, but actively helping the defense?  First, the Torquemada of the legal profession:

Stephen Gillers, a legal ethics professor at the New York University School of Law, said he believed that Mr. Bibb had violated his obligation to his client, and could conceivably face action by a disciplinary panel. “He’s entitled to his conscience, but his conscience does not entitle him to subvert his client’s case,” Mr. Gillers said. “It entitles him to withdraw from the case, or quit if he can’t.”

Even Torquemada can be right every once in a while.  And what does the defense lawyer think?

But Mr. Mehler, the defense lawyer, said Mr. Bibb acted honorably. While lawyers on both sides must advocate for their clients, he said, “a prosecutor has an additional duty to search out the truth.

“I say that he lived up to that.”

And finally, what does Dan Bibb think of what he did?

Today, Mr. Bibb says he does not believe he crossed any line.  “I didn’t work for the other side,” he said. “I worked for what I thought was the right thing.”

To appreciate how Bibb must have felt about being put in the position of prosecuting two men he believed to be innocent, consider this:

A close friend, Robert Mooney, a New York City police detective, said that if not for the Palladium case, Mr. Bibb “would have spent his entire professional life at the prosecutor’s office.

“He’s brokenhearted that he’s not doing this anymore.”

If I had to bet on anyone being a lifer for the prosecution, it would have been Dan Bibb.

George Carlin, 71, Dead of Heart Failure

One of the most significant comic social commentators since Lenny Bruce, George Carlin died yesterday.  He was prominent during the late 1960s and 70s, when he used his popularity to make anti-establishment points through his comedy.

But from the outset there were indications of an anti-establishment edge to his comedy. Initially, it surfaced in the witty patter of a host of offbeat characters like the wacky sportscaster Biff Barf and the hippy-dippy weatherman Al Sleet. “The weather was dominated by a large Canadian low, which is not to be confused with a Mexican high. Tonight’s forecast . . . dark, continued mostly dark tonight turning to widely scattered light in the morning.”

But that was tame compared to what was coming.


Among the more controversial cuts was a routine euphemistically entitled “Shoot,” in which Mr. Carlin explored the etymology and common usage of the popular idiom for excrement. The bit was part of the comic’s longer routine “Seven Words You Can Never Say on Television,” which appeared on his third album “Class Clown,” also released in 1972.

It might seem tame today, but at the time was quite shocking.  It opened the eyes of many.

Do Real Lawyers Use LexMonitor?

Kevin O’Keefe of Real Lawyers Have Blogs has started a “new thing” called LexMonitor.  As it’s become more popular, and more necessary, to use blawg aggregators to keep track of the ever expanding universe of the blawgosphere, Kevin is (as usual) trying to get in as early as possible.  Kevin, like me, is a cutting edge kind of guy.

So Kevin put Rob LaGatta on the job.


It’s Friday, and so far I’ve been spending most of the morning reading through hundreds of law blog posts and tagging them with relevant keywords or phrases. The experience has been interesting: not only have I been able to size up the 1600+ blogs in LexMonitor to determine their quality, focus and author’s voice, I’ve also been able to get a better grasp on what legal issues are being discussed and why.

So who are these 1600+ blogs in LexMonitor and how has Rob tagged them to make this service work?  I decided to check it out.

On the front page, there are a total of three blog posts:


Law held hostage in essay on presidential politics

The CJR series “Turning Point” on press coverage of the presidential election turns to coverage — or lack of it — of likely Supreme Court appointments. Writer Zachary Roth, former media editor at the New York Observer and writer at Washington Monthly, has the politics and media smarts to weigh in…

Looking at Trial Preparation and Office Management With a Mac

– I just read the article posted on the 16th, from well-known Mac user Kern Lewis. Mr. Lewis goes through his set of reasons to switch to a Mac and, like any great trial lawyer, makes a very cogent case. The title of the article is Trial Preparation Made Easy With Macs and you can read it here. I jus…

SOS FOR IOWA LAWYERS

I turn the mic over to Tom O’Connor, and his TechnoGumbo blog: Ernie Svenson has a post on his blog today with pointers to the Linn County Bar Association which includes Cedar Rapids, a city hard hit by the recent flooding and location of the Linn County District Court. Despite the flooding, the…

The second of the three posts on the front page is from a blog called Criminal Defense Law With An Apple.  Granted, I could be missing something, but is there really a demand for this?

I decided to try the tag for New York to see what came up. Aha!  There were four posts, two from personal favorites blawgs, Randazza at the Legal Satyricon and Dan Hull from What About Clients?  There were also posts from Adam Smith, Esq. and Norovirus Lawyer.  So here’s my question:  What does this have to do with New York?  I know that neither Randazza nor Hull are New York lawyers, or post about New York topics.

A while back, I had expressed concern that Kevin’s LexBlog was a bit insular.  To Kevin’s credit, he’s made great strides in making LexBlog a part of the Blawgosphere rather than isolating his stable of blogs from the rest of the universe.  It was smart for the business and good for the blawgosphere.

As the blawgosphere grows in various directions, it has become increasingly difficult to keep up with both good posts, particularly from blawgs that don’t post on a daily basis, as well as new blawgs that come on the scene.  While I use RSS feeds to keep track of a fairly broad group of blawgs, even this is becoming overwhelming, and it doesn’t help me to find new ones.  So the idea of LexMonitor, much like AllTop, offers something that should help.

Unfortunately, LexMonitor isn’t cutting it.  If this is what Rob La Gatta thinks are the top posts in the blawgosphere, then he needs to get out more.  Moreover, if this is how LexMonitor is planning to tag blawgs, then he needs to either take less (or more) sips of his martini before going to work because as of now, it’s so far off base as to be useless, bordering on the absurd.

While I can understand why there may be an inclination toward promoting LexBlog blawgs, and I can’t criticize Kevin for trying to gain some organic synergy from his various products, it has got to have a wee bit of credibility if it’s going to be of any use or interest to anyone else.  At the moment, I’m not seeing any, which is a shame. [Edit: After further thought, I think this paragraph is unfair to Kevin and Rob, so I retract it. In fact, as I read it now, I have no idea what my message was.  Forgive me. It happens]

And this seems like a decent opportunity to raise another issue, one that probably troubles Kevin a bit as well, though it would be inopportune to mention it.  The roll of blawgs that are supposedly covered by LexMonitor contains many that have nothing to do with LexBlog and represent some of the best work in the blawgosphere.  Others, created via LexBlog, are there as well. 

Some of these, and I’m not naming names because they didn’t ask for it and they don’t deserve a gratuitous slam, carry terribly pretentious names.  But they stink.  They are just plain awful.  Whether because they are flagrant self-promotional blawgs, or they post once every month or two, or they just plain suck.  I bet Kevin wishes he could take back some of the more pompous names so that he could use them for blawgs that would reflect a whole lot better on LexBlog, but it’s too late for that.

The credibility of LexMonitor isn’t going to bring down the credibility of the blawgosphere itself.  It’s just not yet worthy of that degree of weight.  But it isn’t going to help anybody, and just provides more flotsam and jetsam in a blawgosphere that has become increasing difficult to navigate with all the junk floating about. 

It’s not that I’m against new entrants into the blawgosphere.  In fact, I frequently welcome them.  But I have a problem with the pipeline getting clogged with crap that will make people turn away from the blawgosphere because it appears to offer nothing useful and serves only self-promotion.  This will harm businesses such as Kevin’s as well, and it’s in his interest to get his customers on track as well as produce content that serves a purpose.  LexMonitor has the potential to do so, but doesn’t. 

Why Lawyers Letters are Scary, But Shouldn’t Be

When word broke of the new stance of the Associated Press with regard to the overuse of quotes from its “creative content,” my take on it was substantive.  I thought it was silly of the AP to try to count words across the blawgosphere lest someone step a few syllables over the line.

But the point was different to others.  This wasn’t only about word counts, but another post about using lawyers to attack the poor and downtrodden.  How I missed this point I don’t know.

Patterico saw it very differently.  This was the AP’s assault on the “little guy.”  Quoted with approval was Jeff Jarvis, who wrote:

What the AP and The New York Times’ Hansell don’t seem to realize is how hostile an act it is to send lawyer letters to individuals. They have armies of attorneys. We bloggers don’t. The mere act of sending us a letter can cost us money out of our own pockets. Sending a lawyer letter is an assault.

Orin Kerr reacted that this is all a bit overwrought:

Patterico, I realize that you can get very excited in your blogging and can be a bit over-the-top (such as describing the sending of a notice and takedown letter as using an “army” to “terrorize” people — kind of waters down the terms, I would think).

Patterico replied that Orin didn’t, and Jarvis did, “get it.”  It’s like they’re all speaking in tongues.

The starting point for the discussion is the issuance of a letter from a lawyer making a demand.  Oddly, the letter does no more than assert a right, meaning the right that they claim existed before the lawyer letter was not being fulfilled, and they seek to bring it to the recipient’s attention.  The implicit (or explicit) threat of the letter is that if the recipient continues to ignore the right, the other party’s recourse is to go to court and seek relief.

What’s the problem?  After all, if people disagree and are unable to work out their problems between themselves, courts are the places where disputes are resolved.  That’s why they build those big, fancy buildings, right?

But the threat of litigation itself is viewed as the penalty for failing to comply with the lawyer letter, not the order of a judge years from now.  Patterico reads the threat as being, “we have an army of lawyers and can ram our demand down your throat no matter what.  Comply or die.”

The very act of expressing the demand itself is an “assault,” according to Jarvis. What does that tell us about the views of non-lawyers toward the legal profession and the courts.  We have become “terrorists” in a nation of laws, not men.  Our threat to bring the matter to a judge for resolution is a akin to threatening an invasion of Poland.  This is troubling.

But what is a lawyer, or more specifically, the lawyer’s client, supposed to do?  A lawyer letter is the mechanism of expressing a position and alerting the other party that the client takes issue with some conduct being performed, or not performed.  How are lawyers to advise others of their clients’ position in a warm and fuzzy, non-threatening way, and make clear that the client takes the problem quite seriously?

The underlying issue appears to be the cost of litigation.  In Jarvis’ reaction, he complains of the cost of disagreeing with the lawyer letter from the AP, with its “armies of lawyers” (another reference to warfare, as if the threat of storm troopers in three-piece suits wielding briefcases instead of guns is a scary image) is more than a blogger can bear.

This makes sense, since the blogosphere is a shoe-string operation, producing little or no revenue with which to defend one’s actions and thus making the risk of a potentially expensive lawsuit a very real threat indeed.  But the cost of litigation, a non-productive cost in almost all instances (save plaintiffs’ suits for injuries), is a concern for everyone.  Sure, large corporations have litigation budgets, and don’t appear to mind throwing money down the lawyer hole, but regular people and small businesses tend not to want to squander their revenues on litigation which, at the end of the day, leaves them where they started if successful.

The lawyer-haters will see this as a reason to move toward a “loser pays” system, where the little guy who prevails gets his expenses back and thus ends up no worse for wear.  But little guys also know that there’s no guarantee that they will win, or collect, and hence will remain every bit as threatened by the cost as if they were putting it down at the craps table and about to roll the dice.  They still have to pay the money out in the first instance, and no systemic change is going to alter that problem.

What the recipient of the lawyer letter fails to recognize is that this is nothing more than an assertion of right.  Regardless of how silly the AP might have been in this instance, they decided that they were getting angry with bloggers taking too much of their content, the stuff they pay their people to produce,   It’s not that the AP is necessarily right, but they are allowed to believe this to be the case.  If it’s wrong of them to send a lawyer letter, what then are their options?

The answer is obvious.  Just commence the lawsuit.  No warning.  No demand.  No opportunity to discuss the issue or try to work it out.  Just drop the bomb.  Is this what Jarvis and Patterico want?  I don’t think so.

The lawyer letter is a shot across the bow, but it does no harm in itself.  It should be viewed as an opportunity rather than an assault.  It’s intended to make clear that the sender is serious about his concern and wants the recipient to take the concern seriously.  It does not, and cannot, force the recipient to comply.  It’s just words.  But it opens the door to a serious dialogue about the concern.  The recipient is free to disagree with the sender on whether rights have been infringed, or wrongs have been done.  He can ultimately decide to tell the sender to go fly a kite, if that’s his choice, and put the ball back in the sender’s court to do as he must.

But don’t hate the lawyer letter.  There has to be some way for a party to alert another party that there’s a problem, and we would be worse off with it.

Brutal Attack on Memphis Cop’s Fist By Transexual’s Face

You know how those darn transsexuals can be so violent, using their face to cause grievous injury to the fist of a police officer.  Thankfully, one Memphis cop’s fist was protected by his handcuffs, which saved him from permanent debilitating harm from this vicious she-male, Duana Johnson.



But there remains a nagging question that keeps coming up in these videos.  Aside from the question of whether anyone at the Memphis Police Department would care about this beating, if this video didn’t find its way onto a news report and thus get public exposure, one point recurs in almost every one of these beating videos that fails to receive any mention.

Why is it that this occurs in a police station (read a building full of sworn law enforcement officers) and yet not a soul does anything to stop it. 

Understand, we’re not talking about one cop breaking the blue wall of silence.  They don’t have to rat out a brother, something that just can’t happen.  We’re talking about a cop stopping another cop from the ongoing beating of a human being.  No snitching necessary.  Just stop the beating.  Nothing more.

While the individual cop, and his probationary holder (you have to learn how to be a real cop at some point), are certainly the focal points of blame for this outrage, am I the only one who wonders why there isn’t another cop anywhere in that stationhouse willing to say or do anything about it?

This is not, as is the general thrust of commentary, an isolated problem caused by “one bad apple.”  This is the product of one violent cop enabled by the failure to act of every other cop.

I harp on this whenever the name Abner Louima comes up.  I continue to do so now.  Do not forget that this beating happened in a stationhouse full of police officers sworn to protect. 

And the concern for the harm to the officer’s fist was quite endearing.  It’s nice to know that they have some humanity, if only for themselves.

H/T HuffPo via Turley

Who Does Al Sharpton Call?

I remember the Reverend Al Sharpton hanging around outside my first office building at 401 Broadway in the early 1980s.  He typically wore a bright blue running suit with a big, round gold medallion.  His pompadour hairdo glistened in the sun.  Even then, this was not in style.

He was there because his good buddy, C. Vernon Mason, had an office in the building too.  Mason was a very funny guy and an excellent trial lawyer.  When he was later disbarred, it was for neglect of cases.  Mason just had too many cases, and those that didn’t make the cut sat in a pile and stayed there.

Twenty years later, Al Sharpton wore a suit and ran for president.  Strangely, he was taken seriously.  How he managed to pull off this transformation is a testament to his imagination.  I give him a lot of credit for it, as he managed to get past Tawana Brawley and his blue running suit.  Neither was a small feat.

[AL+sharpton.jpg] 

His presidential campaign and his National Action Network finances are under scrutiny. Now the Reverend Al used to be tight with a lawyer named Alton Maddox.  But he’s been disbarred too.  So neither Mason nor Maddox can help him now.  Who does Al Sharpton turn to in his time of fiscal need?

The civil-rights activist told ABC News that he felt compelled to hire Zachary Carter, the former Brooklyn U.S. Attorney, three months ago because the veteran prosecutor is best equipped to understand the workings of his old office.
Zach Carter?  Yes.  Zachary Carter, of the Dorsey firm. 

Now I can well appreciate that the Reverend Al would seek the representation of a black lawyer, whether for political or philosophical purposes.  But there are excellent attorneys of color in New York, like Tony Ricco or Richard Jasper.  These are lawyers who are not only perfectly suited for a case like this, but are actually working in the trenches.  Zach Carter shifted out of the practice of law around 1980, when he went over to the administrative and judicial side. 

What Al is buying here is influence.  Former presidential candidates can’t be seen as antagonistic to the government, but as cooperative and statesman-like in dealing with their problems.  Of course, you still have to beat back the problems, which is why Al needs Zach to make a few phone calls to a few important people and make this problem go away.

It’s curious how Al takes to the streets when it’s about civil rights, using lawyers in the trenches for the poor and downtrodden to protect, defend and vindicate the rights of African Americans.  But when his cash is at risk, not to mention his carefully crafted reputation as the spokesman for blacks, he turns to a man wielding inside influence. 

I’m sure Zach Carter knows plenty about how the United States Attorney’s office works these investigations.  So do plenty of other former United States Attorneys, not to mention the AUSAs who actually do the work.  So why do so many march their clients to the fateful meeting that secures a stay at Club Fed?