Author Archives: SHG

Before You Hit the Send Button

I happened upon a very popular, though non-legal, blog this morning called Seth Godin’s Blog.  The name may not be particularly catchy, but it certainly has the attention of a very large segment of the blogosphere so it must be doing something right. 

In any event, Seth has prepared a list of things to consider before sending that email.  It’s a generic list, and is not entirely relevant to the emails sent by lawyers.  Still, it covers a lot of ground and is worth reading and perhaps sending to others who need a loving reminder that they are annoying the heck out of you.  So,  courtesy of Seth Godin, read on…


Email checklist



Before you hit send on that next email, perhaps you should run down this list, just to be sure:




  1. Is it going to just one person? (If yes, jump to #10)
  2. Since it’s going to a group, have I thought about who is on my list?
  3. Are they blind copied?
  4. Did every person on the list really and truly opt in? Not like sort of, but really ask for it?
  5. So that means that if I didn’t send it to them, they’d complain about not getting it?
  6. See #5. If they wouldn’t complain, take them off!
  7. That means, for example, that sending bulk email to a list of bloggers just cause they have blogs is not okay.
  8. Aside: the definition of permission marketing: Anticipated, personal and relevant messages delivered to people who actually want to get them. Nowhere does it say anything about you and your needs as a sender. Probably none of my business, but I’m just letting you know how I feel. (And how your prospects feel).
  9. Is the email from a real person? If it is, will hitting reply get a note back to that person? (if not, change it please).
  10. Have I corresponded with this person before?
  11. Really? They’ve written back? (if no, reconsider email).
  12. If it is a cold-call email, and I’m sure it’s welcome, and I’m sure it’s not spam, then don’t apologize. If I need to apologize, then yes, it’s spam, and I’ll get the brand-hurt I deserve.
  13. Am I angry? (If so, save as draft and come back to the note in one hour).
  14. Could I do this note better with a phone call?
  15. Am I blind-ccing my boss? If so, what will happen if the recipient finds out?
  16. Is there anything in this email I don’t want the attorney general, the media or my boss seeing? (If so, hit delete).
  17. Is any portion of the email in all caps? (If so, consider changing it.)
  18. Is it in black type at a normal size?
  19. Do I have my contact info at the bottom? (If not, consider adding it).
  20. Have I included the line, “Please save the planet. Don’t print this email”? (If so, please delete the line and consider a job as a forest ranger or flight attendant).
  21. Could this email be shorter?
  22. Is there anyone copied on this email who could be left off the list?
  23. Have I attached any files that are very big? (If so, google something like ‘send big files’ and consider your options.)
  24. Have I attached any files that would work better in PDF format?
  25. Are there any or other emoticons involved? (If so, reconsider).
  26. Am I forwarding someone else’s mail? (If so, will they be happy when they find out?)
  27. Am I forwarding something about religion (mine or someone else’s)? (If so, delete).
  28. Am I forwarding something about a virus or worldwide charity effort or other potential hoax? (If so, visit snopes and check to see if it’s ‘actually true).
  29. Did I hit ‘reply all’? If so, am I glad I did? Does every person on the list need to see it?
  30. Am I quoting back the original text in a helpful way? (Sending an email that says, in its entirety, “yes,” is not helpful).
  31. If this email is to someone like Seth, did I check to make sure I know the difference between its and it’s? Just wondering.
  32. If this is a press release, am I really sure that the recipient is going to be delighted to get it? Or am I taking advantage of the asymmetrical nature of email–free to send, expensive investment of time to read or delete?
  33. Are there any little animated creatures in the footer of this email? Adorable kittens? Endangered species of any kind?
  34. Bonus: Is there a long legal disclaimer at the bottom of my email? Why?
  35. Bonus: Does the subject line make it easy to understand what’s to come and likely it will get filed properly?
  36. If I had to pay 42 cents to send this email, would I?

A parting thought.  Once you send an email, the thoughts expressed no longer exist only inside your head.  Can you afford to lose them?

Indigent Defense Attacked At ACS

The American Constitution Society held it’s 6th Annual Convention this weekend.  I didn’t go as I wasn’t invited, though many others from the blawgosphere were.  One such participant was part of a panel discussion about the right to counsel in civil cases, and this participant posted about it yesterday.

I’m being somewhat obtuse in my reference because, while the post came across my feed, the blogger subsequently decided to remove the post in its entirety.  While the bell once run cannot be unrung (meaning that I have a complete copy of the post), I will respect the poster’s desire that his/her identify not be revealed and the post not be attributed to him/her.  Given the content of the post, one of the most bizarrely misguided diatribes I’ve ever seen, I can completely understand the poster’s shame and desire that the words never see the light of day. 

Of course, should the poster chose to out him/herself, then the gloves are off.

The post was a screed against providing access to free legal counsel to indigent civil litigants upon the fundamental basis that if they had any merit at all, they would be worthy of the limited resources of the Legal Services Corporation or garner the help of some Biglaw pro bono program.  Thus, by definition, the fact that they can’t find free legal counsel demonstrates the meritlessness of their cause and they don’t deserve more.

But buried in the post, which was the prepared text of a presentation at the ACS panel, was this little nugget explaining the wastefulness of criminal indigent defense:


Criminal Gideon shows why a civil version will have problems. Let’s give credit to the public defenders’ office for the often thankless task they do, but let’s also agree that the record of court-appointed defense counsel has been one of triage at best. And that is triage often executed for political ends rather than the good of their clients. Take the case of the Atlanta public defenders, where the public defenders have blown a fifth of their budget on a single case, that of the plainly guilty Brian Nichols, who murdered a judge and a court reporter and two others. Why? Political maneuvering against the democratically-created death penalty. On the civil side, Legal Services Corporation taxpayer funding has gone for first-class airfare and limousine service and $14 cookies. GAO and inspector general reports have found a lot of waste. Before Congress stepped in the 1990s, LSC would focus its budget on political causes and regulation through litigation rather than providing legal services to the poor.

Triage at best.  The allocation of scarce resources dictated by political ends.  Taxpayer funding for first-class airfare, limousine services and $14 cookies.  Note that the use of triage is not to suggest that they lack the funding to fulfill their mandate, but rather that they allocate funding to further a radical political agenda at the expense of the poor.  In other words, indigent defenders are the enemy of the poor, using Gideon as a political weapon while standing on the writhing bodies of indigent defendants.

This is from the prepared text, meaning that the author had the opportunity to deliberate, consider, edit and modify its content.  Assuming that their is ny physiological reason why the synapses weren’t firing properly at the time, this paragraph reveals the author’s true feelings on the subject and finest intellectual approach.

Apparently, the talk didn’t go over very well, since in the post-panel post, the writer includes this footnote:


1) The talk was mistakenly interpreted as an attack on criminal Gideon itself. I agree that Gideon was correctly decided (the Supreme Court’s previous test was unworkable) but the constitutional and normative concerns motivating Gideon–better n guilty men go free than one innocent man go to jail–are not applicable.

This brief exculpatory claim belies the poster’s shocking misapprehension of his/her intent.  Apparently, the author is of the view that the reaction was because of wrongfully perceived challenge to the concept of Gideon, rather than his manufactured contention that indigent defenders are evil, abusing the poor and taxpayer alike in their quest to further their politics and fly first class.

The rest of the post, arguing why the poor are undeserving of a civil right to counsel and how such a right would be abused to foment an explosion of frivolous litigation, is equally offensive (perhaps even more so).  But to reveal it would likely give the astute reader an inkling as to the identity of its author, and subject him/her to widespread hatred and ridicule. 

As the author has apparently come to realize, purportedly upon the advice of counsel, that public disclosure of such views, would not be one of his/her brightest ideas, I will honor his/her decision.  Though honor is hardly a word that should be used in connection with the author’s post.

But make no mistake about it.  This post reflects the personal views of one well-known but self-loathing member of the blawgosphere.  And this poster has plenty of followers.

How to Spoil a Good Day

Many in the blawgosphere have had their fun ridiculing the actions of the Rock Hill, South Carolina school district for having seven people arrested for the crime of cheering at a high school graduation.  At first blush, it was just one of those mindlessly stupid overreactions that petty school tyrants enjoy so much. 

Now I’m one of those guys who finds it personally annoying when people demonstrate that they have no manners at all and engage in inappropriate behavior.  From my early musician days, I hate it when people clap after a musical solo but before the end of a piece. 

And yes, the clapping and hooting and hollering for one kid during a graduation ceremony may mean that the family of the next kid doesn’t get to hear their child’s name announced.  Plus, I’ve heard people from the Cacalaccas hoot and holler, and they sound like idiots, diminishing the significance of a ceremony by the jarring realization that even children from this background are allowed to participate.

Now that I’ve offended a large portion of the southeast corner of the United States, school administrators and parents of musicians who inadvertently clapped for junior, the time has come to address satirical post by that pointy-headed wag,  Orin Kerr. 

Proving that the academy demands a higher order of ridicule than the rest of us, Orin has managed the reverse slippery slope slam to note that this story of human frailty has failed to make the rounds of the lawprofs.


I think this is a classic slippery slope problem. Imagine you let people cheer at graduation. It seems innocuous at first. People get used to it; it feels good. But the next thing you know, they’ll start cheering at sporting events. Then they’ll add in concerts. Then they’ll cheer on their favorite contestants when watching American Idol. Before you know it, people will start expressing great joy all the time. Let’s face it: Graduations are the gateway cheering event. I’m glad the cops are taking this seriously.

Sure, notice how he brings American Idol into this, gratuitously denigrating another American institution.  But there is a real issue here that no amount of Ivory Tower sanctimoniousness can ignore. 

These bastions of American education have long been the birthplace of critical thought and intellectual freedom.  Without the bold moves of educators, recognizing a real problem while others play games and have their fun at the expense propriety, the next generation of our society could be our last. 

While rudely cheering the fact that little billy managed to get through high school, itself a feat that many families in South Carolina never thought would come, coming despite an announcement by the handful of people charged with bringing gravity and propriety to an event that signifies reaching the apex of achievement for so many, parents and family friends would rend the fabric of society.

Do you think it was easy for these educators to take such a bold stance, Orin?  Is that why you beltway liberals show your disdain for propriety by undermining your lesser brethren on the front line of decorum?

And what of the police officers charged with enforcing a school officials unpopular edict?  What if some harried grandmother pulled her concealed weapon out to challenge the cops efforts to make the school’s rules stick?  Would you be laughing then, with an officer down and four young children watching their pappy’s life drain out of him to the strains of Pomp and Circumstance?  No, not a pretty picture, is it?

We know that lawprofs, sitting in their oak-paneled offices and sipping Chardonnay from stemmed glassware with their pinky held high in the air, will be only too happy to laugh at the efforts of school administrators to stem the tide of rude behaviors, even if it means breaking a few eggs.  But if someone doesn’t take the initiative to do something, who will teach these young people, our future, our hope, right from wrong?  Do you think making a joke about it is going to help?

So while it’s fine for the worker-bees in the trenches like me to conclusively prove our intellectual frailty by ridiculing the efforts of school officials in Rock Hill, South Carolina, we expect far greater respect for the law, the police and the rigorous demands of high school propriety from someone like you.

And if I can’t hear when my daughter’s name is called at her upcoming high school graduation because of some miscreant’s inappropriate hooting and hollering, thus ruining the culmination of 12 years of blood, sweat and tears, I know who I have to blame.  Are you proud of yourself now?

And you can clap and yell all you want as you watch American Idol.  From your jail cell.

Sponsorship Opportunity

A nasty email arrived from my webhost yesterday.  It seems I’m using up way too much bandwidth, running out of my monthly allotment early in the month.  I’m not entirely clear what this means or how I did it, but it could have something to do with the more than 8600 reads that Simple Justice had yesterday (a Saturday, which is usually the slowest day of the week).  Not too shabby, but getting expensive since these humps hosts demand that I purchase ever-increasing bandwidth to accommodate the demand. 

Isn’t it enough that I type my fingers to the bone?  Now I have to pay more for the privilege of posting stuff for other people to read at their leisure (and then leave comments making fun of me)?  The blawgosphere can be a very tough place.  But the people who do come and read do so because they’re an interested, involved group, which makes them different from most couch-potatoes who sit there and wait to be spoon fed drivel.

So it occurs to me that while I have eschewed advertising in the past, there may be an opening here for one sponsor, appropriate to Simple Justice and its readers, to have their advertisement (or offering, or frankly whatever they want provided its tasteful) prominently displayed on my sidebar.

If there’s anybody out there, a legal publisher perhaps, or website, that offers goods or services to the criminal defense bar or our clients, this might be a good fit.  Even a specialty bar association, like the NACDL, might find an appropriate home here.  Hey, I’m open-minded.

Send me an email if you’re interested.  And no, there is no argument that I will entertain to suggest that either lawyers in general, or criminal defense lawyers in particular, are in special need of either Viagra or Cialis.

The Bully Pulpit

While the New York Times was quick to make a major story out of the bullying of Fayetteville, Arkansas student  Billy Wolfe, there was no mention whatsoever of some Long Island kid named Patrick Kohlmann.  Maybe they aren’t inclined to admit that Long Island school administrators, despite their near-CEO range paychecks, are no better at protecting students then school officials elsewhere.

Fortunately, Newsday didn’t ignore the West Islip teen’s plight.


Patrick Kohlmann was scared. For more than a year at Udall Road Middle School in West Islip, the soft-spoken 13-year-old had been taunted and shoved, chased through the halls and slammed into lockers.

Then one day last month, Patrick says, one of his regular tormentors said: “I’m going to kill you tomorrow.”

The next morning, Patrick’s mother said, she warned the school’s vice principal about the threat. That afternoon, Patrick said, the bully struck him on the head with a rock.

He suffered a concussion.

It seems impossible not to notice a glaring hole in this narrative.  The bullying had been going on for a long time, but nobody at school either noticed or thought to address it.  Then, on the day that Patrick was to be “killed”, the vice-principal was forewarned and did . . . nothing to stop a 13 year old from having his head bashed with a rock.

Nice job.  If we paid you more, school administrators, would you consider safeguarding children in your care?

So what does West Islip school district spokeswoman Nancy Lenz have to say about this?


“I know we’re being accused of not caring and nothing could be further from the truth,” she said. “We take this very seriously. We’re aware of it, we’re on top of it, we’re addressing it, we’re saddened by it.”

You’re saddened?  Not nearly as much as this kid who had his head bashed by the rock.  Unbelievable how the School District’s idea of a worthy reaction is to emote after the fact.  It’s almost as good as actually doing something.  Well, no, it’s not anywhere near as good as actually doing something.  Actually, it’s a disgraceful response.

Patrick, on the other hand, has chosen not to await his school’s recognition that perhaps doing something before another kid’s head meets a rock.  He has created a video about what happened to him to help himself and others kids who have been ignored and neglected by the adults who are supposed to protect him from violence.





Once again, I wonder why these school administrators who allow violence and harm to come to students in their care should not be held criminally accountable for their failures. 

Who Do You Want to Represent?

What about Clients Paris? doesn’t pull punches, whether discussing its fundamental philosophy of putting the client first or the penumbras of this theme.  It makes its point by straight talk, even if the talk may be painful to those inclined to take the easy path.

Dan Hull, whose basketball skills are a frequent subject of debate, tells a painful truth when he advises lawyers to lose their small or unsophisticated business clients.  With small variation, his message is true for criminal defense lawyers too.

Most young criminal defense lawyers want to convert their practice from doing DWIs and misdemeanors to high-profile, front page-type clients.  When you hang out your shingle, you seldom have the option of picking and choosing who walks in the door.  But over time, as you dedicate yourself to proving that you have the skills, the work ethic and the dedication to handle heavy weight defense, things will change.

But here’s the problem.  If you establish yourself as a lawyer who handles small-time cases, then that’s what you will be.  Big cases will shun you.  Clients charged with heavy crimes will see you as lacking the experience to handle their case.  You can wait until the cows come home for the phone to ring for that triple homicide, or CEO with backdating issues, but the phone will not ring.

Unlike Dan’s civil admonition, the “size” of our clients are in their cases.  Often, unsophisticated clients get charged with major crimes.  Some will call the first name in the yellow pages, while others will seek advice and find their way to the lawyer whose reputation is that he handles “big time” cases.  Which one do you want to be?

It doesn’t happen overnight, especially since every lawyer with a misdemeanor practice needs to keep the lights on while slaving away on his trial prep.  But if you don’t seize control of where you want your practice to be, and start putting in the effort to show that you can handle more serious crimes, you will be a misdemeanor lawyer forever.

One way to push yourself toward building a reputation of being the “go-to” lawyer for heavier cases is to align yourself with the lawyers who are doing that work now.  Make friends and let them know that you’re looking to expand your practice.  Tell them that they’re your hero, and you want to work with them.  Ask them to send you a secondary defendant in a multi-defendant case, and let them know that you will back them and make them proud.  And make them look smart for giving you the break.

Don’t try to be too greedy right out of the box.  You don’t get the monster fees until you’ve proven than you deserve them.  When you get those early referrals, show fee-deference to your rabbi.  Take on as much of the heavy lifting as possible, as this will give you the chance to prove your mettle.  No one needs a second-banana who’s lazy, too busy to do his job or is unappreciative.  There are many other lawyers handling DWIs who would love to get a shot to show his chops in a major federal conspiracy case.

There’s nothing wrong with having a DWI/misdemeanor practice for your entire legal career, if that’s what you want to do.  Somebody has to represent these defendants, and they are as entitled to competent representation as anyone else.  But if you want to grow and get into the major leagues, then heed Dan’s advice and go after the clientèle you really want.  They are out there, and they need lawyers.  Make yourself the lawyer they will want to call.


South Carolina Gets Its Voice in the Blawgosphere

South Carolina criminal defense lawyer Bobby G. Frederick has hit the ground running with his new criminal law blawg.  He’s been posting up a storm, and shows no fear about expressing an opinion. 

Bobby’s posts show a well-developed use of sources from many of the top blawgs around, putting together sound sources to provide good coverage of events and launch into his own views on the subjects.  While he has yet to take the initiative of coming up with his own posts, borrowing mostly from current events, I would expect that Bobby will soon start providing more personal insight.  And, I might add, he looks to be an excellent writer.

A few nits to pick, in the hope that Bobby breaks free of the yoke of his Justia-prepared blog.  First, there is no “about me” link, so we really don’t know much of anything about Bobby.  Even on his website, little information is given about him, leaving one to wonder why he doesn’t include how long he’s been practicing law, a glaring omission.

The blawg itself needs a few tweaks to eliminate the typical Justia.com smell of self-promotion which is belied by Bobby’s excellent posts.  Particularly, clean out the blogroll to remove all the garbage, links to purely promotional blogs that bring nothing to the table or blogs that he doesn’t personally care to promote.  It taints the purpose of the blawg, and Bobby’s content deserves better. 

For me, the blogroll is a quick way to assess the sort of things that the author finds important, and Bobby’s blogroll, which I assume to be prepackaged with other Justia blogs, screams self-promotion rather than content and expertise.  While most new bloggers have yet to find their way around the blawgosphere, Bobby’s liberal use of links to great blawgs tells me that he knows who to read.

Bobby Frederick’s blawg is one of the best new entries in the criminal law blawgosphere in a while.  I hope he keeps it going and finds his own voice.  I look forward to learning more about who he is and what he’s got to say.  Welcome to the neighborhood, Bobby.

Tiger Woods Plays Golf

Today is Father’s Day, and in honor of all father’s out there who take comfort in knowing that they are not only appreciated by their children, but can look forward, as they grow older, to a sport which allows one to ride around in a motorized vehicle, only to occasional alight to swing a club at a small ball, I recap the end of last night’s U.S. Open.

Tiger is behind by five strokes to Rocco Mediate with 6 holes left to play.  The last three holes, eagle, birdie, eagle, was some of the most exciting golf ever seen.  It was just Tiger doing what he does.  From the New York Times :

With a dramatic 30-foot eagle putt at the 18th, Woods finished a round of 70 for a 54-hole total of three-under-par 210, giving him a one-stroke lead over Westwood and a two-shot advantage over Mediate.

“Just another boring round of golf, huh,” Woods joked. “Really, I was lucky on a couple of shots. The shot I hit on 17, that has no business going in the hole. I hit it too hard. It came out hot. One hop and it’s in the hole.”

Woods had driven wildly to the right on the 17th, finding the deep rough. His 7-iron shot from there flew into the deep rough next to the green. What happened next would be dismissed as fiction had it not been witnessed by thousands in person and millions on television. Had it not hit the pin, it might have gone 8 to 10 feet past the hole. 

Even before that shot, he had electrified the massive galleries by eagling the 13th hole after an equally wild drive into the right rough. He somehow found a good lie, hit a perfect 5-iron just through the green and, implausibly, made a 66-foot downhill putt with 6 ½ feet of break to get back into red numbers.

No, compadres, you will never finish a round this way.  You are not Tiger.  I am not Tiger.  Only Tiger is Tiger.  This is what it looked like.



The game of golf in played in one’s head.  Few have the ability to make one’s body work like Tiger’s.  Even Tiger looks like his body is getting old, and the rotation he gets is something that only teenagers can mindlessly enjoy.  It’s a thing of beauty that will never again happen to the rest of us.  Few things have the ability to make us as frustrated as a bad shot.  Don’t blame the body.  Blame the mind.

We may never finish a round like Tiger did yesterday, but we can get one shot per round, sometimes, that is similar to what Tiger makes happen time after time.  At that’s enough to keep us coming back.

Happy Father’s Day.  If you can’t play today, watch Tiger. 

Kozinski Bails: Now It’s a Problem

When the LA Times disclosed that Chief Judge Alex Kozinski had some “explicit images” on his personal website, it created a huge stir, opinions ranging from “so what” to “off with his head” from the Queen of Hearts.  But the question of whether it was a “kerfluffle” or a “judge gone wild” is a sideshow.  Judge Kozinski turned it into the main event by declaring a mistrial in the Ira Isaacs trial and recusing himself.

The problem is that handling cases is the job of a judge.  Declaring a mistrial, under the rule of manifest necessity, is a measure of last resort.  Both defendant and prosecution have an extremely keen interest in avoid mistrial once a trial has commenced, having selected a jury and allowed words to spill from their mouths.  They are now committed, and prepared to take what is on the table and move it to completion.  There are rulings at stake, language and allegations put before the jury, and a commitment to dealing with the heavily scrutinized tactics of the opposition.  Try a case and you can appreciate how much goes into every word, glance, tilt of the head, point of the finger in a courtroom.

Certainly, this has caused Judge Kozinski and his family embarrassment.  No one wants their personal peccadilloes displayed for all the world to see.  Not that we all don’t have them, but we put on the serious face when we wear our serious clothes, and others would just as well pretend that there’s nothing more to us than that.  While we may know that there’s a person underneath the robe, we’re just as happy not to look (except, of course, for David Lat, but that’s another story).

But now Judge Alex has allowed his personal embarrassment to scuttle a trial.  He’s upped the ante by deciding that he cannot do his job as a judge.  On the one hand, some may think that his decision is exemplary, by removing any possible taint of impropriety from the mix.  But that suggests that there is a taint of impropriety; Not necessarily wrongdoing, but the appearance of wrongdoing which is enough to taint a judge.

As one commenter asked, had Kozinski been caught buying a Playboy, would we have this mess?  I think the answer is clearly no.  No one (well, maybe one person) would have cared at all.  So he likes to look at naked women.  BFD.

By allowing this tempest to affect the trial of Ira Isaacs, however, turns it from a silly personal matter to one of legal significance.  Is he saying that he cannot be fair?  Is he saying that his enjoyment of erotica, whether because of his sense of humor or personal predilections, precludes him from doing his job as judge?  And if this is true of Judge Kozinski, is it not true of all judges?

Then we must now go on a witch hunt throughout the judiciary to find out whether any other judges suffer from a similar taint.  Do you now or have you ever looked at a picture of a naked person?  Will this be another disqualifying factor for the judiciary?  For some of us, failure to do so (regardless of sexual preference) would be a far more troubling concern.

And while the focus has been on dirty pictures, another issue has cropped up at the ABA Journal.  It seems that Judge Alex not only had the suspect images on his website, but some MP3s as well:

A tour of his website last month by the ABA Journal, on a tip from the same Los Angeles lawyer who gave the story to the LA Times, yielded, for example, more than a dozen mp3 music files, most of them songs by the parodist Weird Al Yankovic.

This raises the ugly specter of the RIAA swooping down on the 9th Circuit for their violation of copyright and sending threatening letters demanding $17,000,000 in penalties.

But the bigger question likely concerns access to those files for downloading rather than uploading. The ABA Journal searched in Google for “alex.kozinski.com” and “mp3” several weeks ago and found file-sharing websites with links to music on Kozinski’s website.

A lawyer who works for the recording industry, and who would not speak for attribution criticizing a federal appellate judge in a matter likes this, says that it doesn’t matter how difficult the route to the files, as long as they are accessible by the public for sharing it is problematic legally.

I suspected that the powers conferred on the RIAA to privately police these copyrights would eventually reach people in high places, though I suspect it to be more likely to reach George Bush then Alex Kozinski.

Yet, the bigger problem remains.  If these few pictures (and possibly a few Weird Al songs) are sufficient to scuttle a federal trial and reduce the Chief Judge of the 9th Circuit to a quasi-pornographer copyright thief who is no longer qualified to sit as judge, then we are left with only a handful of geriatric jurists who can pass muster anymore.  And frankly, I would really hope that our judiciary is staffed by people with a little more contemporary understanding of our world than that.

It’s plagued our universe of people who can meet the expectations of our purist, most self-righteous when it comes to elected office, where candidates who “smoked dope” were automatically excluded from the group of “appropriate” people.  Until we realized that there was no one left to run except a handful of circus geeks and religious zealots who enjoyed personal conversations with their deity (where their god actually responded).

And now the Red Scare hits the courthouse.

Part of the blame falls on our criminalization of everything under the sun, making everyone a criminal for 15 minutes.  Part of it comes from the fact that real people have failings, or more accurately, flaws.  If we want judges to be real people, we have to acknowledge the fact that they too will have flaws.

One’s humanity is proven by the existence of flaws.  Lest we forget our humanity, that’s why there are spouses.

Let Judge Alex Kozinski suffer the effects of his personal quirks at home.  At the courthouse, let him be a judge.  But now that’s brought his personal problems to work, he’s open hunting season on judges.  He shouldn’t have done that.

Taking Stock of the Supremes

While I’ve never demonstrated a deep concern for the personal wealth of members of the federal judiciary, saving it all for the personal wealth of the private criminal defense bar, the harsh reality is that becoming a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States should not require an oath of poverty.  Picture Nino and Thomas singing “I believe I can fly” in two-part harmony on the courthouse steps for tips during the lunch break.  It’s not a pretty picture.

In this New York Times editorial, the Justices are taken to task for having stock portfolios that preclude them from sitting on cases involving corporations in which they have a putative interest.


So it is dismaying to find that some sitting justices continue to own stocks. Financial disclosure forms released this month show that the worst offender is Justice Stephen Breyer, who retains shares in more than three dozen companies. Chief Justice John Roberts holds stocks in 16, and Justice Samuel Alito owns stocks in 5.

While the problem exists for all federal judges, it’s more problematic for Supreme Court justices.


It would be best if all judges ordered their investments to avoid conflicts. But the issue is most acute for Supreme Court justices, who cannot be replaced by another jurist. When Supreme Court justices recuse themselves, they risk altering important decisions and blocking the court from doing its job.

The editorial goes on to provide a number of recent examples where stock ownership by justices has impacted the court’s ability to reach a majority, and even to hear a case.  This is a problem.  When the highest court in the nation, consisting of 9 justices, can’t consider a case or reach a decision, the system fails.  This shouldn’t happen.

But what’s the solution?  This is what the Times has to offer:


Two years ago, Congress changed financial rules to allow federal judges to defer paying capital gains taxes on securities they sell to avoid conflicts of interest. That should make it easier for them to do the right thing: sell off their individual stocks in favor of mutual funds, government securities or certificates of deposit. To do the nation’s business, the Supreme Court needs a full complement of justices, fully focused on the law, and not their own bottom lines.

That’s unfair.  Like everyone else, they have mouths to feed and bills to pay.  Climbing the ladder of accomplishment in the law is an act of fiscal suicide.  Considering the level of achievement required to sit on that bench, the pay is paltry.  With your run of the mill hedge-fund manager making in the mid 7 figures, and non-rainmaking partners at Biglaw doing almost as well, our Supreme Court Justices can barely afford a new bowtie, a lacy collar or stripes on their robes.  Seriously, they have earned the right to have a fair degree of financial comfort.

Assuming that our justices have saved a few dollars over the years, it has to be placed somewhere.  Does the Times suggest that they keep it under the mattress, or perhaps a nice 6 month CD (oops, that would leave them conflicted when a bank case came before them, so that won’t work).  There aren’t many places to turn.  A blind trust might work, but considering that it isn’t for 4 or 8 years, but perhaps 30 or more, it’s not entirely reasonable to expect them to have no clue about their personal financial situation.  How does one decide whether to redo the downstairs bathroom when you have no idea whether you can afford it?

Yes, they are Supreme Court Justices.  But yes, they are still people.  I enjoy the fruits of my labors, and I know what those fruits can buy me.  They are entitled to enjoy and know as well.  So if society demands that they shed all earthly investments and thus free themselves of all inchoate conflicts, then society owes them a darn better living then they now receive. 

I suggest that we index the wage for a Supreme Court Justice at 50% of the median income of an equity partner at law firms with 1000 or more lawyers.  That will account for the public service aspect of the job, not to mention the intangible benefit of being one of nine who gets to decide big issues, while providing for a pretty comfortable lifestyle at a multiple of 10 times their current salary.  Then, let them shed their investments, whether to a blind trust or altogether.  Pay them well, and they can afford it.