Author Archives: SHG

6th Amendment Fire Sale

Two independent posts, one from Grits for Breakfast and another from Sentencing Law and Policy, contribute pieces to a glaring problem, exacerbated by an economy that has caused us to rethink just about everything. 

Scott Henson wrote about how the cost of a public defender system, representing indigent defendants, was substantially less than the cost of having private lawyers provide indigent defense, and how a bunch of “rookie judges” in Dallas started assigning cases away from the PD because they were less inclined to be the “plea mill” the judges were seeking.

This paragraph in Scott’s post stood out:


In 2005 according to these data, the attorney cost per felony case at the public defender office was $303.04 per case, compared with $544.62 per case for private attorneys handling indigent clients. For misdemeanors, the average cost per case at the PD office was a paltry $65.86 in 2005 compared with $118.94 for private counsel.

Scott was looking at the numbers for the purpose of comparison; obviously, the cost of using the PD to represent indigent defendants is lower, and as pointed out elsewhere in his post, “PD lawyers in recent years have more frequently taken cases to trial and spent more time securing services and shepherding mentally ill clients through the system, the Dallas News reported.”  Better and less expensive is a very good combination.

Doug Berman posts:


From ABC News come this interesting article, headlined “Facing ‘Crisis,’ Public Defenders May Refuse Cases — Constitutional Dilemma: ‘Severe’ Budget Cuts Could Force Public Defenders to Turn Away Thousands of Poor Defendants.”  Here is how the article starts:



Faced with what they call severe budget shortfalls, several public defender offices across the country say they may soon begin turning away thousands of poor criminal defendants.


The combination of declining economy (meaning, a lot more people without the funds to defend themselves), a public defender system that is being crushed under the weight of needy defendants for lack of budget and staffing, and a per case fee structure that is insufficient to buy a Vente Mocha Latte at Starbucks.

Ladies and gentlemen, we have a 6th Amendment disaster on our hands. 

Whereas Scott notes that the PD can defend for less than private indigent defenders, just take a look at the numbers:  At the top, $544.62 per felony.  Let me not mince words.  That does not pay for much lawyering, even if we were to assume the lawyers to be competent, interested and dedicated.  Think about it this way, exactly how much lawyer time does this amount of money buy?  At fire sale rates of, say $100 an hour, it gets you nearly 5 1/2 hours.  If it were your life on the line, would you be satisfied?

And I take no issue with Scott’s premise that the PD can do better for less; I’ve seen it, much as my brethren in the New York 18b bar will argue that they do a wonderful job for as long as anyone cares to listen.  In my view, private indigent defense is a spotty proposition at best.  Extremely spotty.

Even at a cost that suggests the barest of minimal attention, it was not sufficient to fulfill the obligation to provide a criminal defense to the many poor who need it and, per Gideon, have a right to it.  If this was bad before, it’s about to explode given our current economic circumstances. 

While bad defense lawyering leaves judges and criminal defense lawyers shaking their heads in disgust, the line is drawn at no defense lawyering.  Defendants unable to retain counsel must be provided a lawyer.  Without one, cases cannot be prosecuted.  They will sit in judicial limbo, whether it means leaving violent criminals out on the street for lack of the ability to bring a prosecution to fruition, or leaving innocent defendants in jail awaiting the availability of a lawyer to stand up for them.  Either way, it’s a disaster.

But with the crushing costs of gasoline and food pressing down on the social consciousness of good citizens everywhere, combined with unemployment and ever-increasing tax burdens to pay for critically important things like war in Iraq to prevent the imminent threat of weapons of mass destruction depose a tyrant bring freedom to Iraqi’s who will welcome us as saviors enable us to leave Iraq as winners, who can afford the additional burden of financing the prosecution of such heinous criminals as prostitute solicitors and drivers failing to yield.

While the Supremes are busy deciding cases that will mean nothing for anyone wearing an orange jumpsuit in the heat of a Cuban summer, we have some mundane but pressing issues to deal with down in the trenches.  I wonder if the court on high can see that far below them to realize that the 6th Amendment is about to go on sale.  Do they know who will pay the Bill of Rights?  I do.

What If Someone Threw a Celebrity Trial and No One Came?

The news came in late yesterday afternoon, “R.Kelly Not Guilty!”  It prompted the universal reaction, “huh?”  The verdict was far more widely reported than the trial, because it was far more of a rarity.

The trial happened Chicago.  If it was mentioned at all in New York, it was buried somewhere between the ads for free gas giveaways and age-spot cures.  The first question asked was, “who is R. Kelly?”  He is a 41 year old R & B star whose signature song is “I believe I can fly,” a ballad known by every second grader because of its inspirational nature.  But, as was invariably noted on American Bandstand, you couldn’t dance to it.

And why was he on trial? 


the case was intended to be clear-cut: the “sweet, nice, lovely” victim was introduced to Mr. Kelly at the age of 12 by her aunt, a protégé of Mr. Kelly’s named Stephanie Edwards. But instead of making the girl a star, Mr. Kelly preyed on her, made her do “vile, disgusting” things and filmed them. Since Mr. Kelly knew she was under age, the state said, he was guilty of making child pornography.

This was certainly salacious enough to justify interest.  Even better, the main witness against Kelly was “Lisa Van Allen, who testified that she had a three-way sexual encounter with them.”  Better still.


Ms. Van Allen, who received state and federal immunity to testify, did not appear to be an unimpeachable witness. She told the court that she had first had sex with Mr. Kelly at age 17, immediately after being introduced to him on the set of one of his videos, and admitted that she stole a $20,000 Rolex from him. Her current boyfriend and a former boyfriend are both felons.

Dating felons?  Talk about guilt by association.  But enough for a defense lawyer, and a jury, to use to challenge her credibility.

But there was one thing the case lacked:  A victim.  The supposed 12 year old girl didn’t testify, and averred that it wasn’t her.  Fourteen others said it was.  She said it wasn’t.  There’s a lesson here about identification, and self-identification, thankfully, still carries more weight.

But why wasn’t this case a media sensation, raising troubling and difficult issues about whether “stars” receive special treatment, or whether sexual exploitation of children is destroying the fabric of America?  The New York Times takes a stab at it:


In some ways, this case did not resemble the Simpson case. R. Kelly is a Chicago success story and still makes his home here, yet as a public spectacle the trial was something of a bust.

The courthouse is in an inconveniently located neighborhood, the charges were old, and allegations of the singer’s interest in under-age women are older still. On most days there was more courtroom security than spectators.

Like the Times, I don’t have a clue either.  This trial might have caught my eye, but it never did.  I knew it was happening, but was never interested enough to pay attention.  Frankly, now that I’ve taken a few minutes to learn a little bit about it, it strikes me as one lousy prosecution. 

Was this about taking a bad case and running with it because it involved a celebrity and the prosecution thought it could make some noise and get some attention for going after R.Kelly?  If so, it appears that their scheme failed and never achieved widespread interest in the prosecution itself.  Instead, the only thing that will be remembered is that the prosecution lost.

An Unpleasant But Necessary Lesson in Legal Economics

Susan Cartier Liebel at  Build a Solo Practice has been kind enough to do the math for us:

                               2001                                      2008

Home Heating Oil $ 1,000                                   $ 4,790

Gas                      $ 2,600                                   $ 5,200 

Food                    $ 6,240                                  $ 10,400

Electric                $    600                                  $  1,080

RE Taxes            $  4,200                                  $  6,600

TOTAL                $14,640                                  $ 28,010 

Notice anything?  The net result is almost a doubling of costs to survive, yet it is reasonably safe to say that the difference is not being used to make sure that lawyers are able to timely pay their bills.  Where is it going?  Iraq and Saudi Arabia, perhaps (albeit for different reasons)?  Maybe China and India?  It doesn’t matter for the purpose of this post.  What does matter is that it’s not going to lawyers.

Susan asks the hard question.

The reason I bring this up is to show you while you may be squeezed as a solo practitioner, raising your prices is not necessarily going to be the answer to covering your bills.  Your clients, if you deal with individuals, are going to be looking at their non-negotiable expenses, too, and deeply distressed.  Their discretionary income is evaporating as well.

This begs the question:  How will you be coping with your potential clients loss of discretionary income and their increasing inability to pay you for your services?

While her question is directed at new and fairly new solo practitioners, escaping from the oppression of Biglaw and finding bliss in their control over their own destinies, it applies with equal, if not greater relevance to private criminal defense lawyers. 

While this bodes poorly for public defenders, who will be expected to pick up the flotsam and jetsam of debt and poverty as the police haul them in, but will enjoy no commensurate benefit with the increase of their caseload, it bodes even worse for the private bar.  Without a paycheck every other Friday, we depend on our clients having a certain amount of disposable income.  Without it, our creditors begin to frown at us.

For anyone thinking that I have an easy answer to this question, you’re going to be disappointed.  There is no easy solution for getting blood from a rock.  While we aren’t responsible for creating the situation that demands the payment of a legal fee, most of us feel quite badly when clients are forced into extreme situations to pay the tab.  Not necessarily bad enough to represent defendants for free, but we try very hard to not cause our clients needless pain.

Susan has put together a list of things to do to help our practices through these more difficult financial times. 

  • Analyze your overhead; and
  • Your (in)effective use of technology; and
  • delegation of less profitable tasks;
  • See if there is any opportunity to decrease your overhead while increasing your productivity; and
  • Look at your pricing structure to see if you can improve upon fees, payment terms and payment options.

To some extent, they require a bit of thinking outside the box, as so many criminal defense lawyers are resistant to change.  But these are practical, doable adjustments that will help us to maintain fiscal stability in a declining market.  Remember, a penny saved is a penny earned.  And you can’t earn a penny if you have no business.

Gun Control Gives Up and Shifts Gears

The Supreme Court will issue its decision in D.C. v. Heller any day now.  I can’t wait to see the explosion across the blogosphere when it comes.  We will, without a doubt, be in our glory.  But the forces fighting a fundamental right to keep and bear arms are already preparing for the worst.

In this ABC interview, Paul Helmke, campaign president of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, talks about preparations for the next phase of gun control.

“We’ve lost the battle on what the Second Amendment means,” campaign president Paul Helmke told ABC News. “Seventy-five percent of the public thinks it’s an individual right. Why are we arguing a theory anymore? We are concerned about what we can do practically.”

If the Supreme Court strikes down the D.C. gun ban, the Brady Campaign is hoping that it will reorient gun control groups around more limited measures that will be harder to cast as infringements of the Second Amendment.

“The NRA [National Rifle Association] won’t have this fear factor,” Helmke said.

Helmke raises an interesting point.  While the Brady group and the NRA have been in opposite corners of the fight up to now, they may well find that they have far more in common than they thought once the “fear” of losing the 2d Amendment battle is over.


Brady Campaign Attorney Dennis Henigan said there are multiple gun control measures that would not run afoul of a Supreme Court decision striking down the D.C. gun ban.

“Universal background checks don’t affect the right of self-defense in the home. Banning a super dangerous class of weapons, like assault weapons, also would not adversely affect the right of self-defense in the home,” said Henigan. “Curbing large volume sales doesn’t affect self-defense in the home.”

While the details of control will no doubt differ, and likely differ significantly, the NRA has always been strong on the position that gun ownership entails education, limits on ownership by felons and the mentally ill and responsible possession.  They aren’t promoting the notion that everybody and anybody should be allowed to grab a gun and wave it around on the street.

On the other hand, this decision may well turn out to be a “be careful what you wish for” situation, with a fundamental right going much farther than anybody had in mind.  The “good for me but not for thee” approach may fly in the face of a holding that finds it difficult to recognize and rationalize limits on a fundamental right to keep guns out of the hands of those “unsavory” characters.  After all, even unsavory people get the benefit of the Constitution.  In fact, one might argue that protection of their rights lie at the heart of the Constitution, since the rights of the “good guys” tend not to be as readily infringed.

Whether Heller results in a seismic shift in the proliferation of guns across the nation, or whether the decision is far more limited in its breadth, has yet to be seen.  Smart money says that the Supreme (Nino excepted) will find some way to allow the government to keep its fingers around the neck of the gun-toting population while paying lip service to the 2d Amendment being a fundamental right, mostly because it is inconceivable that they would void all restrictions overnight and throw the nation into chaos.

But how they do so, and how far they go or don’t go, may well make for some unlikely bedfellows.

What Can Boumediene Do For You?

When the Supremes decide a case, lawyers go to work.  We parse, analyze, dissect and question.  Sometimes, lawyers can see so much and still be unbearably blind.

All the usual suspects have offered thoughts and analyses of the Boumediene v. Bush decision.  Gideon has even been gracious enough to cherry pick some of the best quotes from the decision, thus saving many from the tedium of reading it.  Like so many Supreme Court opinions, it sports broad, grand language of the sort that makes lawyers swell with pride just thinking about the majesty of the law.

But for all these great minds considering the decision, only Dahlia Lithwick noticed that it doesn’t do a thing for the flesh and blood people hiding behind all those fine words.


This is, after all, the third stinging setback and blistering rebuke the court has handed the Bush administration with respect to prisoner rights at Guantanamo. Yet you may have noticed that all of these setbacks and rebukes have mostly meant more hot days in orange jumpsuits, more solitary confinement, and ever more plus ça change for the detainees there. At his pretrial hearing in April, one of the detainees “lucky” enough to actually face a trial, Salim Hamdan, pointed out to the presiding judge that winning his own appeal at the Supreme Court in 2006 got him precisely nothing.

How is it possible that lawyers, giddy with their “win”, neglect to notice that not one human beings has as yet benefited from these huge victories?  What point is there for the litigant to win if, in the end, it changes nothing?

Even the justices have failed to recognize that the impact of their decision is nonexistent:


This is pretty legal and technical, and the concrete ramifications are still baffling to just about everyone. Judging by the tone of Justice Antonin Scalia’s dissent, however, you’d think that Justice Anthony Kennedy and his colleagues in the majority not only released Hamdan and his buddies from their imprisonment at Guantanamo, but also armed them with a rocket launcher and paid their collective train fare to Philadelphia. “The game of bait-and-switch that today’s opinion plays upon the Nation’s Commander in Chief will make the war harder on us. It will almost certainly cause more Americans to be killed,” Scalia wrote. He concluded his dissent with this warning: “The Nation will live to regret what the Court has done today.”

Could Justice Scalia’s fears be just a little overwrought here?  This is law detached from reality, as not a single person has walked free as a result of any ruling of a court.


Scalia points to the 30 detainees released from Guantanamo—by an order of the Bush administration, not a court, it should be noted—who have allegedly “returned to the battlefield.” One detonated a suicide bomb in Iraq in May. Scalia notes that this “return to the kill” happened even after “the military had concluded they were not enemy combatants” (italics his). So you see, even those who were deemed innocent at Guantanamo are actually guilty in Scalia’s mind. And whether or not they ever get to go home, the mere act of providing them with civilian court oversight will surely endanger yet more American lives.

Of course, this case comes too late and offers too little to be of much use to any person who might actually be involved.  But the Supremes are always looking toward the future, keenly aware of how today’s decision will affect tomorrow’s nation.


The dissenters here are unwilling to bear the risk that any of the 270 men at Guantanamo—among them people who were grabbed as teens and others who claim actual innocence—go free. And, indeed, reasonable people can disagree about whether that risk is too much to bear. But Scalia and his dissenting friends today made clear that this is not the risk to which they most object. What they cannot accept is the risk that their brothers and sisters on the federal bench—with decades of judicial experience and the Constitution to light their way—might now do what they are trained to do: hear cases.

Frankly, I understand Nino’s fear.  It’s similar to mine, albeit the opposite.  I’ve lived through too many “stinging defeats” and “blistering rebukes” that never actually did a thing to help the person whose name the decision bears to take this too seriously. 

The point of our courts is to not merely engage in an academic exercise, but to address a controversy and provide relief to a person whose freedom depends on its outcome.  We forget this part far too often.  Perhaps one day a district court judge will cite to Boumediene as the precedent she is constrained to follow, and allow some purported enemy combatant his day in court.  After which, he will be shipped back to the gulag to spend his hours trying to appreciate the majesty of American justice.  Should we pat ourselves on the back for being such fine lawyers?

So Just How Many Innocents For One Guilty Man?

It had to be something special for Eugene Volokh to stoop to flagrant nepotism.  After all, puffing a 1997 Pennsylvania Law Review article is, well, not exactly cutting edge blogging.  But what really caught my eye was that its author, some kid named Alexander, had not yet gone to law school when he wrote it.

The article, n Guilty Men,  146 U. Penn. L. Rev. 173, by Alexander Volokh, is one of the best law review articles I’ve ever read.  It is incredibly funny, done in the most serious tone and wonderfully satirical. 

The article deals with the roots and permutations of the old maxim (even the issue of whether it’s a maxim, adage or “an item of food, specifically a ‘chestnut’,” gets skewered in this article), how many innocent people should go free lest an innocent person be convicted.

The “n” is the mathematic variable, which Volokh follows through the ages to the present, then going around the world, state to state, and ultimately offering advice to criminals as to which state offers them their best shot.


 According to some researchers, though, the maxim is considerably older.  At least three commentators — one Hebrew prophet, one Founding Father and one appellate judge — have dated it back to the beginning of time.  Moses’ precept, from the book of Exodus, was supposedly handed down from Someone who was around “in the beginning.” 46  Benjamin Franklin claims that the maxim, with n = 100 and for suffering, “has been long and generally approved; never, that I know, controverted.” 47  According to Ninth Circuit Judge Alex Kozinski, the “popular notion” 48 that n = 10 (for conviction) is just something “we have always said.” 49  A then-future U.S. president, John Adams, was more modest and merely dated the saying (with n = “many” and for suffering) back to the beginning of laws, saying that “there never was a system of laws in the world, in which this rule did not prevail.” 50

Note the timely reference to Judge Kozinski, a Volokh family favorite.  Moreover, Volokh addresses the looming sexism question:


Whoever the innocent man is, he can also naturally be an innocent woman.  The literature, in a less self-conscious time, usually said “man,” but today usually says “person” or “defendant.”  In the early modern period, many commentators wrote of guilty and innocent “perfons,” warning that “prefumptive evidences fhould be warily preffed.” 77  What exactly a perfon is may be a fruitful fubject for further refearch.

Though, reaching the outer edge, Volokh finally informs us where the line is drawn.


Objects, such as computers 85 and states, 86 and certain categories of people, such as saints, 87 are typically not entitled to the presumption of innocence.

And he further notes that not everyone accepts the concept of “n”:


Jeremy Bentham, founder of utilitarianism, warned against the warm fuzzy feeling that comes from large values of n:


We must be on guard against those sentimental exaggerations which tend to give crime impunity, under the pretext of insuring the safety of innocence.  Public applause has been, so to speak, set up to auction.  At first it was said to be better to save several guilty men, than to condemn a single innocent man; others, to make the maxim more striking, fix the number ten; a third made this ten a hundred, and a fourth made it a thousand.  All these candidates for the prize of humanity have been outstripped by I know not how many writers, who hold, that, in no case, ought an accused person to be condemned, unless evidence amount to mathematical or absolute certainty.  According to this maxim, nobody ought to be punished, lest an innocent man be punished. 128

For you Lost fans, there’s one less reference to ponder.  And, as with any article challenging our blind reliance on platitudes, Volokh concludes with a final thought to ponder:


The story is told of a Chinese law professor, who was listening to a British lawyer explain that Britons were so enlightened, they believed it was better that ninety-nine guilty men go free than that one innocent man be executed.  The Chinese professor thought for a second and asked, “Better for whom?” 238  

The article is relatively short, but absolutely hysterical.  For those of you, like me, who bristle at how the law blindly accepts and adopts old maxims without giving them another thought, and how these maxims frame our thinking without the benefit of critical analysis, you will absolutely love this article.  Finally, a law review article where trees didn’t die in vain.

The Ties That Bind

The day I finally cracked and gave up my law library was one of the most painful in my career.  A law library was a badge of honor.  Clients would ask me if I had read “all those books.”  In response, I would just smile.  They would be suitably impressed, never having read a book in their lives.  It was a perk of having a library.

The law library was great as a backdrop for interviews and press conferences.  It made me look, well, lawyerly. 

There was great comfort in laying books out on the table, stacked as high as they could before they tipped and fell.  Referring back and forth between cases was the rule.  Having a bunch exposed to my scrutiny, all at the same time, was the norm.  That was how we researched, before we plopped ourselves down at the typewriter with carbon paper between our sheets of Esquire Bond.

The law library cost a small fortune.  A new book came for each set every month, each with a number so we knew where it went on the shelf.  By the end, the books costs more than $50 apiece, a princely sum.  But the whole set reflected many thousands of dollars commitment to the law.

Even the real estate for the library came at a dear price.  As sets of books grew, they commanded more space.  There were tricks, placing every fifth book behind the others, to get more available shelf space.  But that ran out quickly.  The law library was like Audrey II in Little Shop of Horrors, screaming “feed me.”   And we did.

Then one day, when West and Lexis had passed through their CD stage and entered the internet phrase of research, and the book prices were increased yet again, I could no longer hide my head in the sand.  The days of the law library were over.  It was a pleasant anachronism, but too expensive to continue just for old time’s sake.

You couldn’t get rid of the library.  No one would buy it, and law schools were overwhelmed with donations and no longer wanted anything that could be held in one’s hands.  Books were pariahs, to be avoided at all costs.

I finally figured out a way to let go of my beloved books without being utterly wasteful.  I offered them in sets of 10 on eBay as “Designer Law Books,” great for designers to use to fill those empty shelves in customer’s homes where they wanted to give the impression of being well-read without ever having to actually read a word.  All the books sold.  It made a few shekel’s, but more importantly didn’t require room at a landfill.  I was thrilled.

Carolyn Elefant inquired the other day in her Legal Blog Watch post whether ties will go the way of the law library.

First, it was typewriters, then law libraries and bike couriers.  Now, it seems that neckties are destined for this growing heap of law firm and business accoutrements rendered obsolete by 21st century trends.

As the Denver Post reports, sales of neckties are declining, down from a $1.3 billion peak in 1995, to less than $678 million during the 12 months ending March 31.  And according to a Gallup Poll in 2007, only six percent of men wore ties to work daily. 

Let me first say that I don’t wear a tie to work daily.  I may be a dinosaur, but I’m not stupid.  My days of wearing a white shirt and tie to match my blue or gray suit ended long ago.  But when I go to court, I will wear a necktie.  Not an ascot or bow tie.  No open collar.  A necktie.  And I will do so as long as I stride into a courtroom as an attorney.

I realize full well that many have nothing but disdain for the “uniform” of dinosaurs, like the yoke of slavery around the neck of the oppressed.  It’s hot.  It’s tight.  It’s uncomfortable.  It’s uncool. 

The “issues” that the casual have with the uniform are all true.  But I will not give it up.  I do not want to give it up.  It is part of the mantle of office of a member of the bar, an officer of the court, a professional.  Even the suffering is important to me.  It reminds me that the privilege of being an attorney does not come without some suffering, some small degree of discomfort.  If I can’t tolerate this minor discomfort, how could I possible withstand the pressure of my duty. 

The plain truth is that I like wearing a necktie.  I like the way I look and feel in a suit and tie.  If American barristers wore robes and wigs, which I understand to be remarkably unpleasant and itchy, I would probably like it too.  These trappings of office may be laughable to a generation that views propriety as a burden, and sees no reason to suffer anything that they can possibly avoid, but they are the uniform of choice to me.

I’m sure that I seem downright irrational to the Slackoisie, who still can’t fathom why flip-flops shouldn’t be de rigor in Biglaw.  Well, my dear children, I can live with your ridicule and derision.  I refuse to live in a world where everyone dresses like they are prepared to dig ditches or go to the beach.  Whether you should ever feel this way or not, I will continue to wear a necktie, and will do so proudly.

Increase Ordered for New York Judges

From Judicial Reports, Supreme Court Justice Edward H. Lehner has ordered the Legislative and Executive branches of the State of New York to increase judicial salaries, “to reflect the increase in the cost of living since such pay was last adjusted in 1998,” within 90 days.

The decision in Larabee v. Governor (not to mention everybody else) of the State of New York, issued yesterday, is based upon the “linkage”, the tying of a judicial salary increase to a salary increase for legislators as well.  While the Attorney General conceded that everyone agrees that an increase in judicial salaries is appropriate, the stumbling block has been disagreement over legislative salary increases. 

The reason for this linkage is obvious:  No citizen of New York would support an increase in legislative compensation without a gun to his head.  By linking it to judicial compensation, the legislature hopes to have a handy-dandy gun.  Unfortunately, their weapon only shoots blanks.

Judge Lehner then lept from linkage to separation of powers, stating:



[W]hile the Senate and Assembly may perhaps now disagree as to whether it is appropriate for them under the current political situation to enact a legislative pay raise, the legal issue before me comes down to whether the refusalof the legislature for almost a decade to provide the supposedly co-equal third branch of government with a pay adjustment due to the aforesaid linkage to legislative pay demonstrates an abuse of power and an unconstitutional interference with the independence of the judiciary.Clearly, a conclusion that the aforesaid practice of linkage may be wrong as a matter of governmental policy does not mandate a finding that it is unconstitutional.

Yet, the court later holds:


In order to insure the public’s right to a competent and independent judiciary, this Commonwealth must maintain its ability to attract and retain the most qualified people.Due to inflation, increased tax obligations and other economic factors, it can only do so by lessening the difference in compensation between judges and lawyers with equal experience and training in the private sector.Otherwise, judicial service will not longer be viewed as a viable alternative to the private sector.Traditionally, government service offers pay scales to some extent lower than private industry for comparable positions requiring equivalent training, experience, responsibility and expertise.This disparity is deemed to be offset by the opportunity to render public service and to participate directly in the governmental process.However, this laudable motive cannot be reasonable expected to overcome the stark realities of the market place.Compensation of appreciably lower than the expected value of those services will inevitably result in the inability to obtain the quality of performance required

While the argument that separation of powers demands that disengagement of the linkage between the compensation for the judiciary and the legislature, a position that enjoys strong support as far back as Federalist No. 78, the connection between the rationale and the ruling is awfully tenuous.

Had Judge Lehner stopped at with separation of powers, and issued an order directing the Legislature to consider the compensation of the judicial branch of government without regard to the compensation of any other branch of government, his decision would have been on firm ground with a very fundamental foundation.  But he didn’t.

The holding appears to be based upon the contention that the judiciary’s independence will be undermined because qualified candidates “cannot be reasonably expected to overcome the stark realities of the market place.”  Now we’re back on shaky ground.

Is the judge saying that the crop of candidates and appointees in the past year aren’t qualified?  I don’t think so.  Is he saying that there aren’t a half dozen applicants or candidates for every opening?  Nope.  Then what is he saying?  He’s saying judges “deserve” it.

This is a mistake.  Whether or not judges deserve to be compensated with some degree of equivalence to, oh say, first year Biglaw associates is a political question, not judicial.  Worth is relative, a subjective value suited for those who can be voted out of office for their spendthrift ways.  This is even more true when the decision-maker has a horse in the race. 

If competent candidates could not be found, and Judge Lehner made such a finding, we would have a different situation.  But he didn’t, and he can’t.  The judiciary has a politics of its own, you know, and he can’t call his brethren incompetent.  It would be poor form.  Moreover, I don’t think that’s the case or the judge believes that to be the case.

Rather, it smells more like some public marketing to make the decision more palatable to the public by protecting our right to a “competent and independent” judiciary.  Unfortunately, the public doesn’t seem to be on board with the concept as whole, both from the standpoint of feeling that the judges are currently unduly burdened or that their “competence and independence” is at risk.  Indeed, some would argue that the ship on competence and independence sailed a long time ago, given some vocal challenges to the judiciary over the past decade.

The New York Times article on the ruling includes the Governor’s reaction:


“While the governor has long supported salary increases for judges, today’s opinion flies in the face of the State Constitution, which makes clear that only the Legislature has the power to set judicial salaries.”

It appears that it will be a long appeal process before there’s a surprise in our judge’s paychecks.

Judge Alex Kozinski: “I Didn’t Know it was Public” (With Photo Update!)

The blawgosphere is abuzz, awash, atwitter, about the Los Angeles Times revelation that 9th Circuit Chief Judge Alex Kozinski has a kinky side, revealed by “sexually explicit” images on his personal website.  That he was currently presiding over an obscenity trial of Ira Isaacs, described by the WSJ Law Blog as “accused of distributing criminally obscene sexual-fetish videos depicting bestiality and defecation. (For background on the Isaacs case, click here for an AP story.)“

Some have seized upon this delicious opportunity to challenge Judge Alex’s ethics and called for his recusal from the case.  Others have questioned whether the images are “crude and misogynistic — pictures of naked women as cows; pictures of womens genitalia with the caption, “Bush for President”; implied bestiality as humor.” And Howard Bashman asks whether this is newsworthy at all.  After all, would we be writing about this if Judge Alex was spotted at the newstand buying Playboy?

But when it comes to the salacious and titillating, or when it comes to anything about judicial hottie self-applicant Alex Kozinski, there’s only one place in the blogosphere to go:  David Lat’s Above the Law.  Naturally, upon learning of the scandalous allegations, Lat went straight to the cow’s horse’s mouth to get the scoop.  This is what the judge had to say:


David: I can’t comment on the trial.

As for the other matter, the server was maintained by my son, Yale, for the entire family. Pictures, documents, music, audio and other items of personal and family interest are stored there so various family members can reach them from wherever they happen to be. Everyone in the family stores stuff there, and I had no idea what some of the stuff is or was — I was surprised that it was there. I assumed I must have put it there by accident, but when the story broke, Yale called and said he’s pretty sure he uploaded a bunch of it. I had no idea, but that sounds right, because I sure don’t remember putting some of that stuff there.

I consider the server a private storage device, not meant for public access. I’d have been more careful about its contents if I had known that others could access it.


This response is unbelievably remarkable for one reason:  Judge Kozinski sounds just like every criminal defendant who gets caught.  I don’t remember it.  I don’t think I did, but I’m not sure.  I thought it was private.  I thought no one else would see it.  If I had known that I would get caught, I would have been more careful.

The line between lawful and unlawful has grown so very thin, almost to the point of being imperceptible these days as the slightest tweak in conduct raises some malum prohibitum brainstorm of criminalizing nearly ordinary behavior. 

I’m not suggesting that Judge Alex was engaged in some porn crime, but in the same vein, he wasn’t all that far away from others who like their images hot or humorous, however they wish to characterize it.  Acceptability is largely in the eyes of the beholder.  I’m not one for explicit images personally, but that’s my sensibility.  Others feel differently, and I won’t castigate them for their choices.

But this tempest raises the same response from a judge who could well be packing his bags to move to Washington in the near future.  If Judge Alex can say that he really can’t remember much about how these images found their way onto his “personal” computer, why does judge after judge reject and ridicule ordinary people who can’t offer a judicially satisfactory explanation of how stuff made its way onto their hard drives? 

Unless the rest of the federal judiciary is prepared to call Judge Alex a liar and a disgrace, why a different set of rules for him than for the rest of us?

Compare as well the reaction of the Stephen Gillers, the Torquemada of the bench and bar.

Stephen Gillers, a New York University law professor who specializes in legal ethics and has known Kozinski for years, called him “a treasure of the federal judiciary.” Gillers said he took the judge at his word that he did not know the site was publicly available. But he said Kozinski was “seriously negligent” in allowing it to be discovered.

“The phrase ‘sober as a judge’ resonates with the American public,” Gillers said. “We don’t want them to reveal their private selves publicly. This is going to upset a lot of people.”

Gillers said the disclosure would be humiliating for Kozinski and would “harm his reputation in many quarters” but that the controversy should die there.

He added, however, that if the public concludes the website was intended for the sharing of pornographic material, “that’s a transgression of another order.

“It would be very hard for him to come back from that,” he said.

Gillers has never before found a transgression that didn’t mandate the death penalty.  What difference does it make that it was intended to be private?  Does that save the defendant from charges of possession of simulated kiddie porn, intended for private viewing?  Since when do people have to intend their indiscretions be public before they’re wrong?

What I take from all of this is that Judge Alex Kozinski may well be the best qualified jurist on the federal bench to sit in judgment of others.  He’s demonstrated that he’s human, something that most judges would avoid at any cost.  So he enjoys the occasional image of a naked woman.  So what?  So he finds humor in odd places.  So what?  So his personal quirkiness went public.  So what?

Do we remain so naive, so Puritanical in our hearts, that we believe that judges should still be so buttoned-up in starched white collars that they have no attachment to what’s happening in the rest of society.  Must they be so pure, so as not to offend even the prissiest member of society, to be deemed sufficiently trustworthy to pursue justice?

Yes, Judge Alex’s reaction was to offer the same old excuse, “I didn’t know,” that has been offered and rejected a million times by defendants throughout our country.  Let’s make this the discussion, that real people don’t always remember what or why they did something stupid, but didn’t intend to do harm or wrong.  Not every itty bitty act is part of a scheme of greater significance demonstrating an evil heart. 

Should Judge Alex recuse himself from the Isaacs’ trial?  Absolutely not.  So what if he likes a little nudity once in a while.  Where is it written that judges must be antagonistic to defendants before they are competent to sit?  Has Judge Alex shown himself to be unsuitable for the Supreme Court of the United States of America?  To the contrary, he has shown himself to be exactly what we would hope for in a person who would sit on the court of last resort:  A brilliant judge and a real person, who has an appreciation and understanding of things that real people do. 

Having foibles is a consequence of being human, not an unacceptable transgression.  While I may disagree with some of Judge Alex’s conservative positions and his libertarian politics, I will sleep very well knowing that he has failed to meet some Victorian image of perfection.

Update:  Gideon (who posted at about the same time is me, so I hadn’t seen his when this was posted) argues that this is much ado about nothing.


These pictures are tasteless at worst, funny at best. They’re not meant to be sexually arousing or pornographic.  What’s the big deal? We gotta stop being fuddy-duddies.

Clearly, Gid is a far better connoisseur of sexually arousing photos than me, and I defer to his judgment.  From his link to Patterico, here are some of the images that were supposedly downloaded from Judge Alex’s website, and here is the image of the two naked woman painted as cows. 

Viewsday: Journalists Trying to Blog, But …

Newsday, my hometown newspaper, is trying to get into the blogging business.  It’s started a blog called Viewsday.  This wouldn’t be readily apparent from the Newsday website, where almost everything, news included, is a distant second to crass advertising.  In fact, you would be hard-pressed to find the blog since there’s no link to it on the front page at all. 

Aside from the fact that Newsday’s website is possibly the worst of any major newspaper, demonstrating a fundamental lack of understanding of how to use, or be used, the internet, the creation of Viewsday demonstrates a painful ambivalence to change and new media.  Somebody over there believes that online delivery of news and opinion may hold some key to future success, but they lack anything close to an institutional commitment to the concept. 

This may be a result of the pending management changeover, from Sam Zell who wanted to shed a revenue drain to the Dolan family, with more Cablevision cash than journalistic savvy.  But having made the start, why not do it right?  Better yet, having made the start, why serve up half a loaf (or less, maybe just the ends that nobody wants to eat) and prove that they aren’t ready for prime time?

I am a big supporter of the Viewsday concept.  Long Island needs a blog to provide a forum for conversation about local news and events.  We’ve got plenty of problems here worthy of discussion, and more than our share of drama.  What better place to air it out than the blog of our one daily newspaper.

But a blog needs to have something to say.  Save a couple of posts that hint at the potential for thoughtful commentary, Viewsday has thus far been a miserable dud.  I check it out every day in the hope that somebody over there woke up and said to themselves, “hey, let’s post something of consequence on the blog today!”  No such luck.

This morning, I saw a post by Bob Keeler, one of Newsday’s editorial guys and a regular columnist.  That’s a start, since this was supposed to be the editorial staff’s outlet for opinion.  Here’s his post :


       The costs of wrongful conviction



It’s hard for most of us to imagine what it might be like to spend more than a decade in prison for something we didn’t do, but it happens far too often in our state. The cost to the person wrongfully convicted is immense, but the cost to taxpayers is not trivial. Housing one innocent person for a decade costs about a quarter of a million dollars. Then there’s the cost of compensating that same person for the crushing injustice, loss of earning capacity and separation from family. Now the New York State Bar Association is trying to do something about it. Keep an eye on the editorial page in the newspaper itself.

Put aside for the moment that this is old news, something I posted about here last week.  The best I can make of Bob’s post is that somebody put a gun to his head and told him “post something on the blog or else,” and this is what he churned out.  It’s beyond lame and pathetic.  It’s simply pointless.

Michelle Chen has been charged with infusing some life into Viewpoints, and she strikes me as a dynamic and focused person.  But she’s laboring under two distinct disabilities.  First, Newsday’s editorial management doesn’t see Viewsday as a priority, worthy of allowing Michelle to give it her full attention.  Second, and more important, is that Newsday has never been anywhere near cutting edge, and appears to lack any real comprehension of what the blogosphere is, does or has to offer.

Up to now, Viewsday has been used as filler.  It’s a place to claim to have a blog, but hardly a blog in any sense.  The blog says nothing.  It has no voice, no stance, no controversy, no life.  In my effort to be helpful, particularly since Rita Ciolli, the editorial page honcho at Newsday, apparently recognizes that online existence may have a little something to do with Newsday continued viability as a going concern, I’m doing what little I can to push Newsday to stop counting pennies and start drawing in readers by offering them something worth reading.

Typical of mainstream media, they are scared to death to commit to the concept, and even more afraid that if they blogged for real, they might fall off their journalistic pedestal and be forced to wallow in the gutter with the rest of us.  I’m trying to give them a little shove and expedite the process.  It’s not so bad here in the gutter.  At least we can post about things that matter, express actual opinions, and bring something to the conversation.

Come on, Viewsday.  Give it a shot.