Author Archives: SHG

Snapple-osophy: Mind Your Own Business

Upon opening my bottle of Snapple Iced Tea, my son snatched the cap from my hand and read the “real fact:”


The first penny had the motto “mind your own business.”

Not that I’m distrustful, but I checked out the accuracy of this Snapple revelation.  Here it states :

In 1787 the Continental Congress of the Confederation commissioned the first penny. Designed by Ben Franklin, the front featured the sun rising over a sun dial. The word “Fugio,” Latin for “I fly,” sat next to the sundial, reminding everyone that tempus fugit. But most importantly, at least as far as this article is concerned, was the motto under the sundial, which admonished everyone to “Mind Your Business.”


If we had to condense the Bill of Rights, boil all ten of them them down into a single right, the demi-glasse of the constitution would be “The People have A Right To Be Left Alone.”






Where are the originalists now?

Dishonor in the NBA

Tim Donahgy is betting again, this time that Eastern District of New York Judge Carol Amon will believe him.  The disgraced former NBA referee has opened a Pandora’s box by alleging that one of the major sports leagues is internally corrupt.  According to the New York Times:

According to Donaghy, N.B.A. executives directed referees “to manipulate games” in order to “boost ticket sales and television ratings,” and he cited several examples. Although the team names were withheld, Donaghy pointed to Game 6 of the 2002 Western Conference finals as one such instance.

According to Lauro’s letter: “Tim learned from Referee A that Referees A and F wanted to extend the series to seven games. Tim knew Referees A and F to be ‘company men,’ always acting in the interest of the N.B.A., and that night, it was in the N.B.A.’s interest to add another game to the series.” The game was refereed by three tenured veterans, Dick Bavetta, Ted Bernhardt and Bob Delaney.

This is a sports fan’s worst nightmare.  It’s bad enough when your favorite team loses.  It’s worse when they lose because of a bad call.  But if it’s true, and the call wasn’t bad, but deliberate, then there’s no hope left.

Baseball has steroids.  Basketball is corrupt.  And the New York Giants won the Superbowl.

At least football is still an honorable sport. 

The Disinhibition of Debt

There was time when Americans would be ashamed of the fact that they couldn’t pay their bills.  No more.  David Brooks’ column in the New York Times discusses the emergence of a culture of debt over the last 30 years that has undermined our traditional disdain for flagrant self-indulgence.

The United States has been an affluent nation since its founding. But the country was, by and large, not corrupted by wealth. For centuries, it remained industrious, ambitious and frugal.

Over the past 30 years, much of that has been shredded. The social norms and institutions that encouraged frugality and spending what you earn have been undermined. The institutions that encourage debt and living for the moment have been strengthened. The country’s moral guardians are forever looking for decadence out of Hollywood and reality TV. But the most rampant decadence today is financial decadence, the trampling of decent norms about how to use and harness money.

As we are bombarded by the daily news of home foreclosures compounded by the impact of rising gasoline prices, food and healthcare, one can’t help but wonder how we turned away from respect for thrift and frugality to become a bastion of flash, bling and shiny things. 

As our presidential candidates offer gimmicks and meaningless answers to pressing problems, never once suggesting that part of the solution is to tighten our belts, stop spending money we don’t have and put some away for a rainy day, it becomes clear that our economic condition will not change until some extraneous event bails us out.

We have run up a national debt the likes of which are unfathomable in the history of man.  We have run up personal debt that has jeopardized the welfare of millions of Americans.  In both instances, there is blame to be levied so that we learn from these egregious errors.  But there aren’t many people brave enough to tell these many debtors that they were wrong.  It would make them angry. It would make them feel badly.  We wouldn’t want people to feel badly, especially if we want their vote.

Brooks explains the role the government has played in the destruction of our nation’s financial mores:


The agents of destruction are many. State governments have played a role. They aggressively hawk their lottery products, which some people call a tax on stupidity. Twenty percent of Americans are frequent players, spending about $60 billion a year. The spending is starkly regressive. A household with income under $13,000 spends, on average, $645 a year on lottery tickets, about 9 percent of all income. Aside from the financial toll, the moral toll is comprehensive. Here is the government, the guardian of order, telling people that they don’t have to work to build for the future. They can strike it rich for nothing.

There’s the answer.  We can all play the lottery and win ourselves out of the mess.  Well, maybe there’s something wrong with that solution. 


Congress and the White House have played a role. The nation’s leaders have always had an incentive to shove costs for current promises onto the backs of future generations. It’s only now become respectable to do so.

Respectable doesn’t even begin to express it.  We demand services now with the price tag left for the future.  Somehow, we’ve steeled ourselves to the reality that we are living on borrowed cash, and walled off our reason from recognizing that it’s going to collapse someday.  We can live with it happening to our children, as long as it doesn’t happen to us.  We’re free-riding, and we like it.


Wall Street has played a role. Bill Gates built a socially useful product to make his fortune. But what message do the compensation packages that hedge fund managers get send across the country?

Aren’t we all entitled to $6000 shower curtains?  Isn’t that what makes us important and worthwhile?  Certainly, it’s worth our while to go into debt to watch Oprah on a 60″ flat screen hi-def TV.  Andy Warhol predicted that everyone would enjoy 15 minutes of fame.  Shouldn’t we all enjoy 15 minutes of life like a hedge fund manager, right before we lose our home?

It’s not that I’m an advocate for the Puritan ethic.  We need not live in painful frugality, buying day old bread and scraping the bottom of the peanut butter jar until we wear through the plastic.  But that’s a long way from spending money you don’t have, knowing that you are unlikely to ever have the ability to pay it off.  The pride can now be found in driving the fancy car, if only you could afford the gas.  There is no longer any shame attached.

So what do you call a presidential candidate who speaks the truth, tells the American public that we’ve been playing Russian Roulette with our future and have finally caught the bullet? 

The loser.

Hospital Indictment Is Not a Cure

What do Farrah Fawcett, Tom Cruise and Paula Abdul have in common?  According to this report, their medical information was sold by nurses and orderlies of UCLA Medical Center to The National Enquirer.  Rush & Molloy , gossip columnists for the New York Daily News, report:

Former UCLA Medical Center staffer Lawanda Jackson was indicted on April 9 after allegedly leaking private info about Fawcett, Maria Shriver and 60 other patients. Now vets at the ‘bloids are wondering how long it will be before other health professionals and reporters are drawn into the investigation.

Staffers at L.A. hospitals favored by celebs have been on the payroll of the supermarket weeklies for years, based on transcripts we’ve obtained of taped conversations among dirt-diggers at Globe magazine.

Privacy is a pervasive issue in the law.  HIPAA was supposed to protect medial privacy.  It doesn’t.  It’s another grocery clerk solution, a form to be checked that is substantively ignored. 

Want proof?  Go to the hospital emergency room and wait for your name to be called on the loudspeaker.  What business do they have disclosing the fact that you are there, seeking medical attention, to a roomful of strangers?  Want more proof?  Ask Farrah.

We are asked to give up personal information to such a wide variety of entities, from medical to banking to pharmaceutical to the newspaper delivery person.  They give us a form and we dutifully fill it out, providing a wealth of personal information, much of which has absolutely no bearing on the purpose of engagement, but will come in quite handy if they want to collect their fees later.  Our entire life is floating around in files under the control of other people.

Most businesses have a “privacy statement” assuring us that they won’t disclose our personal information.  Officially, that’s largely accurate, except when a cop asks in which case they collapse on the floor and hand over everything they’ve got. 

In the meantime, consider who has access to all this information.  You may well trust your physician, but do you trust his nurse?  His receptionist?  The teenagers who work in the medical suite after school? 

The indictment of Lawanda Jackson is arguably a start in the stream of deterrence that might keep others in check.  But the story is that this had been going on for years, with plenty of sources happy to provide titillating personal information.  One person has been indicted.  Are the others shaking in their scrubs?  Not likely.

The fact that private information is readily accessible to anyone at UCLA Medical Center who bothered to look reduces HIPAA and proclamations of privacy to a joke.  Once Farrah’s personal information is revealed, there’s no way to unreveal it.  No indictment will restore her privacy.

And what of the National Enquirer, whether it seduced hospital employees to provide the information or merely accepted it on a silver platter? 


A spokesman for American Media Inc., which bought The Globe in 2000, said the legality of the dealings before then “are not our responsibility.” The rep declined to comment on the current Enquirer case.

Don’t blame them for being at the bottom of the journalistic barrel.  They make no pretense otherwise, and plenty of people buy these tabloids at the checkout counter.  But bear in mind that the Enquirer never promised to vouchsafe anyone’s privacy.  They may be sick, disgusting scum, but at least they are true to their purpose. 

For all the trees that have died so that hospitals can pass out their HIPAA policies to patients, nothing has been done internally to safeguard patient privacy.  And that’s hospitals, one of the few places where you can identify the source of illegal disclosures. 

Consider the hundreds of other entities that have our personal information in their computers, multiplied by the number of individuals who can access that information at will.  Do you trust them?  It’s time to take personal privacy seriously, both in our giving out unnecessary personal information and their assuring our privacy. 

Newspapers: 44% Say No Bloggers Allowed

Motivated by the sacking of Chez Pazienza, former news producer at CNN and Deus Ex Malcontent blogger (discussed here), Simon Owens decided to find out whether newspaper editors and publishers would be okay with their people blogging.

At Bloggasm, Simon’s research began:

To complete the survey, I sent emails to editors and publishers of 250 newspapers — five for each state — containing this question:


Question: Would you allow your staff writers, without prior approval, to blog during their free time after work as long as they don’t write about the beats they cover for your newspaper?

To provide clarity, I added this example:


EXAMPLE: A staff writer for your newspaper covers the local courts and cops beat and then goes home and writes in his personal blog about the national presidential election. He does this without asking for your permission. Would you be fine with this?

The only issue I might take (and this may well be quibbling at best) is whether they would allow (meaning the bloggers sought advance permission) or fire (meaning they did what they wanted and were subsequently found out).  It often harder to get permission than to apologize.  Chez didn’t ask, and was fired as a result.  That’s an extreme reaction.

Simon’s heard back from 39 of the 250 surveys:

Twenty-two — 56% — said they wouldn’t mind if writers blogged on non-beat issues without obtaining permission. The remaining 17 — 44% — either required disclosure of the blog, issued caveats over what subjects couldn’t be covered, or had outright bans on having personal blogs at all.

Some of the comments Simon got back are enlightening.  This one in particular:

“Blogs are really a Pandora’s Box for reporters,” [Bill Doak, editor of the East Hartford Gazette] wrote. “On the one hand you have a reporter who, like anyone else, wants to be free to run home and say whatever he or she wants to say to friends, family, other reporters or on a blog. But the reporter risks his or her credibility and objectivity in so doing. Of course there is a place at every newspaper for those with opinions. But a reporter also squanders their objectivity by blogging, and that blog might also jeopardize the objectivity of the newspaper. So, to a degree the blogging reporter risks much more than he or she gains, not the least of which includes employment.”

What’s striking is that the “risk” of expressing opinions, consisting largely of an open and semi-permanent record of one’s views, is an exposure of perspective and analytical skills.  Whether this constitutes “squandering objectivity” or revealing vapidity is another matter.

The pretense that journalists lack any personal thought is a silly fiction that mainstream media holds in the name of neutrality.  They believe that disclosure of thought would subject them to claims of bias, while concealment of thought protects them from such claims.  I doubt it’s a belief that the public is incapable of understanding that reporters have thoughts, but that they are defensive against those who would attack their stories based upon their reporters’ personal beliefs.

The ability to write a relatively even-handed article is the skill a journalist brings to work; he or she need not be devoid of belief to be a good journalist.  Just as lawyers represent clients even though we don’t approve of their conduct, their job is to present news stories fairly.

But the fact that 56% of newspaper editors have no issue with reporters blogging tells a bigger story.  While there’s a nagging question of whether they would maintain the same laissez faire attitude if one of their reporters wrote something particularly outrageous, or offensive, or just plain stupid, is another matter.  The defenders of free speech still wouldn’t want their reporters outed as inchoate Klansmen or admirers of Jessica Simpson’s intellect.

All in all, I’d say that Simon’s survey reveals a grudging respect for the blogosphere in particular and free speech in general.  It’s understandable that editors wouldn’t want their reporters making fools of themselves online, or opening the door to attack of their mainstream work.  Newspapers are a business, and the value of the business has to be upheld or there’s no cash to buy the newsprint.  Still, the fact that the majority of respondents took no issue with blogging journalists is a positive sign for the blogosphere.

Of course, journalists (again, like lawyers) ought to consider their credibility whenever they write, regardless of the venue.  The surest way to undermine one’s credibility is to write something foolish for all to see.

Technorati Free Fall (Update: Loop Closure x 2)

High tech gurus like Gideon and Ken Lammers probably have a better way, but I check Technorati to find out if anybody has linked to Simple Justice.  Technorati isn’t exactly the most reliable method, as it’s fairly hit or miss as to whether it picks up everything going on in the blawgosphere, and has constant updating problems.  It’s not unusual to see something a day or two after it was posted, if at all.  But then, the price is right.

One of the other things that Technorati does is attribute “authority” to a blog.  By that, it notes the number of different blogs that link to you in the past 6 months, and quantifies your place in the blogosphere based upon that number.  This is pure vanity, having absolutely nothing to do with anything substantive about blogging at all.

And I’m miffed.

A couple of days ago, my authority was 303, and there were a couple of new blog links that had yet to be reflected in the number (Technorati takes its time doing that as well).  Then yesterday, my authority fell to 280.  What the?  So I checked to see what came off the back end, since authority only runs for 180 days and then goes away.  I couldn’t find anything to explain a 23 point drop.

This morning, it’s down to 273.  By the weekend, I should be hovering around 6.  This is really beginning to bug me.

I posted on the Technorati discussion board, and while the admin responded to questions before and after me, I was left high and dry.  I sent Technorati an email about the problem, and received an acknowledgment informing me that they were very busy over at support and I could expect a response sometime before the end of my natural life.

No, it doesn’t change anything about Simple Justice if my authority is 6 instead of 303.  But it isn’t doing a darn thing for my self-esteem.   So if anyone reading this has a cousin who works in Technorati support, would you ask them why their trying to crush my spirit.  I’m only human.

Update:  I finally received a response from technorati support:


My apologies for the delay. Your authority looks up-to-date for the number of blogs in our system linking to your in the past 180 days. It does look like a large number of links fell out of the 180 day window recently which would explain the drop.

So, given the non-responsive response, I decided to manually go back 180 days and see what fell off the back end.  It appears that there was a flurry of blogs within the Lexblog sphere of Kevin O’Keefe that had added Simple Justice to their blogroll.  But if I’m in the blogroll, it shouldn’t fall off the back end unless the blogs were never indexed again. 

It doesn’t make sense to me, but apparently, the Technorati answer is “it is what it is.”  And Kevin, have you grown tired of SJ?

Update 2:  New piece of the puzzle just came in from Technorati.  I’m informed that when they scan a blog for links, a blog on the blogroll is only counted the first time it’s seen.  After that, it’s not counted again, so it falls off the back of Authority after 180 days even though it’s still there.

To those of you on my blogroll to whom I thought I was showing a little authority-love, I apologize.  I didn’t know it worked this way.  I don’t think it should, since the blogs that remain on a blogroll are there for a reason every day.  And yet, Technorati thinks differently.

Maintaining Minimum Standards (Update)

While the slightly libertarian bent at the Volokh Conspiracy may give some people reason to question the writers’ conclusions, one can rarely question the intellectual integrity of the regulars, Eugene, Orin and others.  Not that they would hang out with a trench lawyer like me, but I admire their thoughts just the same.

But the lawprofs have this thing about bringing in guest bloggers. And so James Q. Wilson enters the blawgosphere, where he posts:

We are frequently told that America should be ashamed of having sent so many people to prison. We are compared unfavorably to most of Europe. But these complaints rarely ask what benefits flow from prison.

The best scholars have estimated that between 25 and 30 percent of the recent decline in crime rates is the result of imprisonment. A comparison with England is helpful. At one time it imprisoned a higher fraction of offenders than did the US, but in the 1980s it changed by imprisoning fewer people. As a result (I think), the British crime rate soared while ours fell.

Between 1980 and 1985 the American prison population increased by more than half and between 1985 and 1990 it again increased by half. But from 1987 to 1992, the British prison population dropped by about five thousand inmates despite a sharp rise in the crime rate.


Rarely, if ever, will one see so bald an assertion.  Forget the mix of percentage against a meaningless raw number, but raise an argument without any foundation whatsoever is shocking.  This is the sort of argument made at loony neo-con blogs, where they don’t need no stinkin’ facts to make their point.

So who is James Q. Wilson?  According to Wikipedia (yes, he’s listed in Wikipedia):


James Q. Wilson (born May 27, 1931) in Denver, Colorado is the Ronald Reagan professor of public policy at the Pepperdine School of Public Policy in California, and a professor emeritus at UCLA. From 1961 to 1987 he was a professor of government at Harvard University. He has a Ph.D. (1959) and masters degree (1957) from the University of Chicago and an undergraduate degree from the University of Redlands (1952) where he was the national collegiate debate champion in 1951 and 1952.

Not an unimpressive vita.  And there’s more:


He is a former Chairman of the White House Task Force on Crime (1966), of the National Advisor Commission on Drug Abuse Prevention (1972–73) and a member of the Attorney General’s Task Force on Violent Crime (1981), the President’s Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board (1985–90), and the President’s Council on Bioethics. He is a former president of the American Political Science Association. He has served on the board of directors for the New England Electric System, Protection One, RAND, and State Farm Mutual Insurance.

He is the chairman of the Council of Academic Advisors of the American Enterprise Institute. Wilson is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the American Philosophical Society, and a member of the International Council of the New York-based Human Rights Foundation.

Plus, he received “the Presidential Medal of Freedom by President George W. Bush in 2003.”  This fellow is not a slouch.

But what happened to intellectual rigor?  Is it acceptable for a person, even someone with very substantial academic and professional credentials, to made bald-faced, facile assertions and then base his argument on them? 

Lawprofs are generally intolerant of normal lawyers (like me) who argue a position without having first substantiated the factual basis upon which we rely.  Good lawyers don’t do this, though we generally try to frame our points in common language, eschewing the jargon of paternalistic pedagogy so beloved by lawprofs to distinguish their fine clarity of thought from our more mundane efforts.

Why then, I’m constrained to ask, is this sort of strawman garbage foundation acceptable from James Q. Wilson at the Volokh Conspiracy?

Perhaps, I thought to myself, it’s an accident.  A one-time error that slipped past Wilson in a moment of weakness.  But then came Wilson’s next post at Volokh :


It is true that the proportion of inmates described as drug offenders has gone up dramatically, but as Jonathan Caulkins and Mark Kleiman point in their essay in Understanding America, very few are in prison because of drug possession. Many are either major dealers or plead down to a drug possession charge in order to avoid being convicted of a more serious offense. There are more than one million arrests every year for drug possession, but very of them result in prison or jail time.

So much for the accident theory.  Perhaps he’s so attuned to drug culture because he’s done a bit too much field research?  Nah, I’m not going there.

The best guess I can make is that Professor James Q. Wilson sees the academic blawgosphere as the wild west, unworthy of the intellectual rigor that one would demand of a first semester undergrad, where otherwise distinguished thinkers can vent their spleen to the chorus without fear of scrutiny.  Perhaps he feels that he’s been through the ringer enough that he no longer needs to base his wild and woolly politics on facts, seeing himself as the font of truth and thus feeling it sufficient that if he says something is so, it is so.

This is the sort of stuff that undermines the fabric of the blawgosphere, where one can anticipate that a post on the Volokh Conspiracy can pass intellectual muster, whether you agree with its conclusions or not.  Some day, someone will link to Wilson’s guest-blogging posts and affirm that it must be true because it’s posted at the Volokh Conspiracy.  

These posts fail to pass minimum standards of intellectual rigor.  I am deeply disappointed that Eugene has allowed these posts on his blog. 

Update:  Responding to criticism of his blogging style, Wilson posts this :


A lot of readers have suggested that I am not a helpful blogger because I refer people to other studies for data to support my arguments. These critics are probably right. Were I devoted to blogging full time, I would quote all the data and summarize all of the studies, thereby getting nothing else done. I had assumed when I started my blog messages that people would pause, think, and look up facts. A few have, but most seem to have opinions they like to express quickly. There is nothing wrong with this, except that it doesn’t advance knowledge.

It’s hard to imagine a more ironic and disingenuous  mea culpa.  To help Prof. Wilson understand better, he’s not the teacher and we’re not the students.  If you want to express an opinion based on fact, source your fact.  It’s not our job to do your legwork.  Too difficult for you?  Then go back the classroom. 

Arbitration versus Captive Arbitration (Updated)

Ted Frank at Overlawyered, has long been a strenuous advocate for arbitration.  He’s right, of course.  Conceptually, arbitration offers an expeditious and cost-effective method of resolving disputes.  This is a good thing, right?  Well, not exactly.  As Ted notes, opponents of mandatory arbitration claim that it denies people their “day in court.”  Well there’s a loss.

For the vast majority of ordinary disputes, the court system is a nightmare, taking forever and burdening everyone with expense the often dwarfs the amount in dispute.  The need for a better way to address disputes has long been clear.  So why, then, has arbitration become a dirty word?  Ted writes:



Unfortunately, there are thirteen separate bills before Congress proposing to abolish a consumer’s right to pre-commit to arbitration and extract the resulting savings from the businesses with which they contract. As a coalition of business groups note :



If successful, these legislative efforts would retroactively declare unenforceable potentially millions of provisions for the orderly and economical resolution of disputes. Opponents of pre-dispute arbitration have neglected to realize that, if enacted, these provisions will actually limit the realistic opportunity for an average consumer, employee, and investor to obtain a remedy if a dispute arises.


Note the proponent, the United States Chamber of Commerce.  This is where things turn ugly, where consumers have tarred the very concept of arbitration as a business trap to deny them a fair hearing.  In short, the harder business interests try to persuade regular people that arbitration is good, the harder consumers fight arbitration. 


The problem is not arbitration.  The problem is captive arbitration.  Essentially, people believe that businesses that employ mandatory binding arbitration in their contracts “own” the process.  The arbitrators are in their pocket.  The private businesses operating arbitration need to maintain their loving relationship with business to keep those fees rolling in.  After all, it’s the businesses that feed their coffers, not individual consumers.  Please the business and the arbitration enterprise enjoys revenues.  Anger them and arbitrators will be out on the street looking for random disputes to resolve.

There are studies that suggest that consumers fare poorly with the major arbitration services, the ones most likely to be used by big business.  These studies are disputes, and may not in fact reflect any bias, but rather that businesses aren’t wrong nearly as much as consumers.  Or, they side with their patrons. 

Arbitration is an industry, like many others.  There are large enterprises engaged in it, and individual arbitrators who handle cases.  No doubt some are better than others.  Perhaps some pretend to be neutral, but really serve their masters.  If so, then it isn’t arbitration.

If the arbitration industry doesn’t change the perception that it exists for the benefit of business, and that consumers won’t get a fair shot, it will be a terrible loss.  The fault isn’t with the concept of arbitration, but the perception and, if true, reality, that arbitration is bought and owned by business. 

But this perception is not going to change based upon the continued assertion of support by business interests, the very entities that give rise to the mistrust of arbitration, or the collateral attacks on lawyers as the self-serving opponents of arbitration.  Refusal of the business proponents of arbitration to recognize that their advocacy does more harm than good continues to drag the concept of arbitration into the gutter.  People don’t trust business, and they don’t trust a dispute mechanism that business favors.

Moreover, the compulsion to slam trial lawyers at any opportunity does no service to the cause of arbitration.  Even if we were to assume that it’s the evil trial lawyers, a fundamental tenet of Overlawyered, that have malevolently smeared to good, kind, benevolent business interests of America, it does nothing to instill faith in the neutrality of arbitration.  Ordinary people must believe that they will receive a fair shake in arbitration.  They don’t.  Slamming trial lawyers does nothing to change this. 

As a long-time advocate of alternate dispute resolution, it pains me to see this concept dragged into the mud by allowing itself to be perceived as the captive of business.  It not only has to be fair and impartial in fact, but maintain the perception of scrupulous integrity to gain the acceptance of the public. 

And believe me, a “day in court” isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

Update:  I forgot to mention this, which isn’t going to help the image of arbitration any.  From the WSJ Law Blog,


In its cover story this week, BusinessWeek offers up a lengthy critique of the National Arbitration Forum, one of the nation’s largest arbitration firms. The story focuses on credit-card collection arbitrations, citing internal NAF documents, case results, and interviews with NAF arbitrators for the proposition that NAF “operates a system in which it is exceedingly difficult for individuals to prevail.”

This is going to be a really tough one to blame on the trial lawyers.  Maybe they seized control of Business Week in the middle of the night?

Rehabilitating a Verdict

Anne Reed, who doesn’t post nearly enough anymore, has a fascinating post at Deliberations coming out of the California Court of Appeals opinion in People v. Carrasco.   Like New York, California requires a unanimous jury verdict in criminal cases.  After the verdict is returned and read aloud in the courtroom, the judge will ask whether the defense (if it’s a guilty verdict) would like the jury polled.  Each juror will be asked individually whether that is his or her verdict, and each must respond.

While jurors hate this, as it takes the onus off the group and places it on them personally, they stand and affirm that the verdict is indeed theirs.  Usually.  Almost all the time.  But not in Carrasco.



The Court:  “Juror No. 2, is this your verdict?”





Juror No. 2:  [no response]





The Court (maybe looking up sharply, perhaps a little louder):  “Juror No. 2, is this your verdict?”






Juror No. 2:  [after a pause] “Yes.”  And she starts to cry.


This doesn’t happen often.  It’s never happened to me.  But it’s one of the million things for which we must prepare.  Should it happen, there’s about a half second to be prepared to deal with it, and dealing with it properly could mean the difference between prison and freedom.

Anne provides the transcript of what happened next, and it’s worth your time to read Anne’s post.  The court engaged in cross-examination of the juror, in camera, in an effort to understand why she began to cry.  Eventually, this happened:


“THE COURT: Go ahead and explain to me that — nobody will know about, the other jurors won’t know about our discussion here — but I want to know what went on in the jury room that made you come up with a guilty verdict when you’re now indicating that was not really your desire or intent.





“JUROR NO. 2: I had reasonable doubt.


But the judge didn’t stop there.  Instead, he went on to question why, despite this reasonable doubt, she voted with the majority.  As Anne points out, had inquiry stopped the moment the juror stated she had a reasonable doubt, there would be no unanimous verdict.

After further inquiry, the judge ascertained that the juror was more concerned that the offense was a felony, and the juror didn’t realize that she was convicting the defendant of a felony.  Of course, the judge pushed the juror to reach this conclusion, just as the other jurors pushed the juror to agree to a verdict of guilty.  A malleable juror is even more malleable under the scrutiny of a judge.  And you wonder how people get pushed into false confessions.

This story opens the door to one of the most troubling aspects of the jury system and our expectation that a verdict of guilty will not be reached until a unanimous jury agrees that guilt is proven beyond a reasonable doubt. 

When the juror said that she had a reasonable doubt, that should have been sufficient to undermine the verdict.  That the judge was able to rehabilitate her comes as no surprise.  Judges carry a lot of weight in a courtroom.  But the means he used to do so is what raises hackles.  The judge sought a reason.  The judge was not willing to let go until juror no. 2 explained why she had reasonable doubt.

Explaining one’s belief is the gaping hole in the criminal jury system.  While the jury is instructed that proof beyond a reasonable doubt is not proof to a mathematical certainty, they are never told exactly what it is.  Indeed, no one has even, to my knowledge, figured out what exactly it means.

But it is clear that there is one thing it does not mean.  It does not mean that a juror who does not believe that the prosecution has met its burden has to provide an articulable explanation for that belief.  A reasonable doubt does not require the expression of a reason.  A juror who does not believe that a person should be found guilty does not have to explain themselves, either to the other jurors or to the judge.  Or to anyone else, for that matter. 

The California Court of Appeals affirmed Carrasco’s conviction in a 2-1 decision.

Carrasco’s lawyer hadn’t objected to the judicial cross-examination, and he didn’t argue on appeal that the verdict wasn’t unanimous.  Instead, the argument was that the judge should have granted defense counsel’s request to contact Juror No. 2.  The appellate court upheld the trial judge 2-1, saying there was “no showing” of juror misconduct, and that defense counsel should have “proposed an additional line of inquiry” to the trial judge, even though she’d been shut down when she asked to inquire herself.

Only in the dissent do you find the words you’re looking for here:  “I think that at this point the juror had made it adequately clear that she did not intend to find the defendant guilty.”  Defense counsel didn’t need to object, said the dissenting judge; although no California case has yet dealt with the issue, “there is every indication, in my opinion, that a less than unanimous verdict is reversible error per se.”

As soon as courts look behind the reasoning of the jury, the burden of proof changes.  People may not be able to explain their beliefs adequately, and are likely to say the wrong thing to justify their feelings in a rational way.  It doesn’t matter why a juror believes that she has reasonable doubt, anymore than we can demand an explanation from jurors as to why they belief that the evidence proves guilt beyond it.  Once lawfully instructed, they can do as they please, including nullification should that be their decision.

Defense counsel in Carrasco was clearly (and admittedly) unprepared to handle what happened.  But she got to go home after the verdict, unlike Ernest Carrasco.

Counseling Crime

When a call (or email) comes in from a potential new client, the first question asked is what’s the case about.  Clients are often reluctant to say aloud what their problem is, whether because they fear the phone is tapped or they are just embarrassed to find themselves in need of legal services.  Sometimes there’s someone listening, like the cop who just printed them.  Other times there’s a family member, and the client would prefer not to shatter their hope.  It’s all part of the deal.

But every once in a while, someone requests a consultation with only a vague purpose.  “I need to discuss a very important matter with you.”  No detail as to the nature of the matter, criminal or civil.  No information about an arrest or prosecution.  Just “a matter.”

An email like this came in the other day.  It included the right words, recognizing that there would be a fee for the consultation.  But it didn’t provide any hint as to the subject matter of the consultation.  It was polite and appropriate in tone.  But it studiously avoided giving any hint of why a consultation was sought.  I turned it down.

This is a phenomenon that would happen to a civil lawyer.  A paying client is rarely turned away from a consultation.  There would be no reason to do so, since the hour of the lawyer’s life would be filled and the worst that could happen is that the lawyer informed the client that his legal needs were outside the lawyer’s realm of expertise.  And of course, there’s always the referral, a potential goldmine for rainmakers who take their third for sending clients to others.

In criminal defense, these requests hold a special risk.  Over time, criminal defense lawyers learn a bit about the mechanics of crime.  How successful criminal enterprises function; how unsuccessful criminal enterprises fail.  We may lack certain specifics about the manufacture of drugs, but we do learn a great deal about how people get caught with them.  This knowledge has value to certain people.

Vague requests for a consultation have occasionally sought my legal counsel on how to commit crime.  Some people will pay very well for the information I’ve gleaned over the years, and it will likely save them a great deal in legal fees and years in prison, not to mention opportunity costs.  If one was to think of a criminal enterprise as a business, this would be the function corporate lawyers serve.  Except the business of the business is illegal.

This is where the line is drawn.  Lawyers cannot do this.  We may have plenty to offer, but aiding someone in the commission of a crime is illegal and unethical.  This is the difference between a criminal lawyer and a criminal defense lawyer.  The former goes to jail.  The latter doesn’t do it.

But there is another problem lurking in the background.  If you seek advice on how to get away with a crime you plan to commit in the future, you’ve come to the wrong place.  Lawyers cannot do this.  We cannot tell you how to best commit crime, or how to get away with it. 

We are lawyers, not your co-conspirators.  We cannot help you to be better criminals.  This may strike you as a silly difference, and you may think we’re being too prissy about it, but this is an absolute line that can never be crossed.  We are criminal defense lawyers, not criminals.

A dear lawyer friend of mine, a good guy who wanted to serve his clients well, found himself straddling this line.  He knew where the line was drawn, but had a client who he had represented before and who he hoped to represent again, push against the line a few times.  The lawyer at first resisted, but he wanted desperately, too desperately, to keep the client.  And he finally toed, then crossed, the line. 

When the client was arrested, the first thing he did was rat out the lawyer.  It was a big fish for the government, and bought the client five years off the back end of a thirty year sentence.  The government was happy, though neither client nor former lawyer were feeling very good about their choices.

You want a consultation?  My pleasure.  Just provide me with the required level of detail to know that it’s for a lawful purpose and within my realm of expertise.  I couldn’t care less if you’re guilty or innocent.  It doesn’t matter if you want to keep it secret from your spouse or boss.  I won’t tell.  But please don’t expect me to engage in any conduct that is illegal or unethical.  That’s all I ask.