Author Archives: SHG

Ode to Cornell University, Ivy and All

Carolyn Elefant went home again over the weekend to her alma mater, Cornell Law School.  Her law school chums were passing out buttons to express their spirit of “no pettifoggers,” Andrew Dickson White’s dream.  Carolyn was unimpressed.

Like most other law schools, Cornell has stepped up its marketing efforts, branding itself with the tag line “lawyers in the best sense.”  The quote comes from Andrew Dickson White, one of the school’s founders, who envisioned the law school as a place to educate  “not swarms of hastily prepared  pettifoggers but a fair number of well-trained, large-minded, morally-based lawyers in the best sense…” Indeed, a bunch of alumni are even circulating buttons with a picture of a pettifogger and a big red X through it.

My initial reaction was that this slogan is just so typically, quintessentially Cornell – removed from present times, stuck in the past and such.   At a time when lawyers out here in the blogosphere, on the cutting edge of the law, are talking about social networking and building relationships and 21st century practices, here’s my alma mater, concerned about stamping out pettifoggers.

I was a Cornell undergrad, lacking the basic qualification to attain entry to the old guard Ivy’s (the ability to pay the tuition and the knowledge of which bread plate was mine).  Cornell had a couple of land grant schools through the largess of the State of New York, which enabled the riff raff with decent SAT scores to get a room at Mary Donlon Hall in the North Campus.

Carolyn changed her mind about the “no pettifoggers” button after further consideration.

And then I realized that’s why the brand works.  Because for better or worse, the tag line is genuine representation of Cornell Law School’s authentic self.  With it’s tag line, borrowed from its past, Cornell isn’t trying to be anything other than it is:  a solid, monastic place somewhat isolated from the real world where students can focus on their training.  Some may want this type of education, and others might not, but those who come to Cornell will get what’s been put out there.  No false advertising here.

There’s no shame in a school being true to itself.  If indeed that’s the case.  It begs the question of why Cornell University law school needs a tag line to attract students.  Has it so badly fallen from grace that it picks up the dregs of the applicant pool?  That would be terrible, but I don’t believe it to be true.

My sense is that this is all part of the U.S. News and World Reports Syndrome.  The tierism that has blinded the academy from its purpose and seized the hearts and minds of professorial class.  Or maybe the need for an extra 1,000 applications from students who will never gain admittance will pay for new leaded glass in the windows of Myron Taylor Hall.

I don’t believe any law school has as yet adopted the slogan, Pettifoggers-r-Us, leaving it up for grabs.  Of course, most potential law students won’t know (or care) what a pettifogger is, making the slogan relatively unhelpful in any event.  The ad campaign to enlighten law school applicants probably isn’t worth the potential draw of pettifogger wannabes.  I could be wrong about this.

I received a superb education at Cornell University.  I didn’t appreciate how good it was until much later, when the amorphous stuff that was stored away in the far reaches of my brain turned out to be useful.  Had I realized it at the time, I would have paid much closer attention.  I blame this on Roger Keeran, my adviser, who tried unsuccessfully to turn me into a wobbly.  I’ve just googled Roger and found no evidence that he ever existed.

So Cornell wants to produce “lawyers in the best sense.”  Me too.  I would suggest that they lead by example and be a “law school in the best sense” by concentrating on their students and rejecting any urge to slavishly succumb to tierism.  Then they won’t need to pass out silly “no pettifoggers” buttons to the alumni and can focus their reunion efforts on the more important things, like explaining what happened to “the stump.”

The Stump

The Stump

 

Welcome Home, Willie Horton

For those who are too young to remember the Willie Horton ad that crushed Michael Dukakis’ campaign for the presidency in 1988, let me say that it was devastating.  Not just to Dukakis.  Not just to the Democrats.  It was a blow to civil rights and individual freedom that was more effective than anything before it.

And it’s back.

According to the Huffington Post,

On a website he calls ExposeObama.com, Floyd G. Brown, the producer of the Willie Horton ad that helped defeat Michael S. Dukakis in 1988, is preparing an encore.

Brown is raising money for a series of ads that he says will show Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) to be out of touch on an issue of fundamental concern to voters: violent crime. One spot already making the rounds on the Internet attacks the presumptive Democratic nominee for opposing a bill while he was a state legislator that would have extended the death penalty to gang-related murders.

“When the time came to get tough, Obama chose to be weak. . . . Can a man so weak in the war on gangs be trusted in the war on terror?” the ad asks.

In the world of effective political marketing, Brown’s Willie Horton ad is a legend.  It was perhaps the most powerful political ad since Lyndon Johnson’s 1964 “daisy girl” ad.  While the purpose of the ad was to smear Dukakis and thereby help Bush 41 win the election, it galvanized Americans to believe that violent crime was consuming and destroying the country, and that no law or penalty was too harsh or severe.  The mindset that it was time to give up freedom for safety was embedded in the American psyche.

So Floyd Brown wants to beat Obama.  Fair enough.  He’s allowed to favor any candidate he chooses.  But the attacks need to be grounded in reality, not deception.  Brown isn’t all that interested in truth.  He’s much more concerned with impact.  From the LA Times :


Obama’s campaign, and some independent observers, say Brown’s work is misleading at best. FactCheck.org, a political watchdog, has called the death penalty ad — which suggests that Obama’s vote made him responsible for the gang-related deaths of three youths — “reprehensible misrepresentation.”

The legislation was largely symbolic, because many gang killers were already eligible for death under state law. It also was running up against concern over the administration of the state death penalty law. That concern ultimately led to a statewide moratorium on executions. The Republican governor at the time, George Ryan, eventually vetoed the legislation.

There are little prizes and big prizes.  The presidency is a big one, worth pulling out all the stops to some people.  But the collateral damage of such efforts may be even more important than winning any particular election.  Brown isn’t concerned about collateral damage.  He will sacrifice people, truth and the fabric of society to smear Obama. 

Do my complaints sound extreme? Perhaps, but we aren’t without experience in these matters.  Presidential campaigns, while intended to put one individual into the White House, set a ball in motion that impacted the thinking of the majority of Americans who lack the ability, desire or information to think for themselves.  Mind you, no one believes they’re part of this group, each individually believing that they know all they need to know and that their opinions are formulated through sheer personal brilliance.  Each lemming sees himself as an independent thinker.

Marketing is all about finding something that “resonates”.  Playing the fear card is not only easy, but effective.  It’s a base instinct.  It’s a no-risk proposition, since it’s always the other guy who is evil and will have to pay.  We enjoy the safety and the miscreants should all disappear.  Then our lives will be better. 

That the ad campaign that Brown plans to employ is deceptive, it has a good chance of finding resonance.  The reasons why it’s false are too complicated for our independent-minded lemmings.  And the more fear of crime that’s raised, the greater the reaction of the majority to demand a solution.  So what if there isn’t really a problem.  A problem is what people perceive it to be, and if they see a series of ads telling them about a handful of horrific crimes or rejection of tough-on-crime laws, they will believe.

And we will be back to the days of Willie Horton. While most people are beginning to realize the costs and problems this has wreaked on society, this realization is fragile and easily susceptible to manipulation.  Will Floyd Brown be able to do it to us again?

Now That Fieger’s Acquitted, Was He Wrong?

In all the coverage in the blawgosphere of the trials and tribulations (but mostly trials) of Geoffrey Fieger, which largely stemmed from the fact that it brought Gerry Spence out of hiding, one question went undiscussed.  Just how wrong was Fieger’s conduct?

Many people have read about the case, mostly to keep a keen eye on how the master would try it, handle the cross-examination and then sum it all up in such a way as to make the jury believe that a conviction of Fieger would signal the end of civilization as we know it.  But they can’t remember exactly why Fieger was being tried.  It’s time to take a look.

Walter Olson at Overlawyered brings us the post-mortem from the Detroit Free Press :

…There is no doubt that Southfield attorney Geoffrey Fieger completely subverted [the aims of campaign law] when he essentially laundered through employees of his law firm hefty contributions to the 2004 presidential campaign of John Edwards.

But can you make a federal case out of it? A U.S. District Court jury didn’t think so, refusing Monday to convict Fieger and law partner Vernon (Ven) Johnson of doing anything illegal. So congratulations to Fieger for gaming the system and then beating it.

But that doesn’t make what he did right. …

Fieger played McCain-Feingold by having his staff make campaign contributions in their own name, defeating the limits imposed on individuals, and then reimbursing them for the contributions (including paying them enough additional money to cover the tax consequences of the contribution).

Campaign finance is a controversial issue.  There’s a tension between the use of cash to subvert the democratic process, essentially buying a bigger voice and greater influence and thereby undermining the one person-one vote influence that each American is supposed to have. 

On the other hand, free political speech suggests that we are allowed to shout as loud as we want, or more importantly, as loud as we can, to support the candidate of our choice.  Campaign contributions are a tool used in the exercise of free political speech.  Our Constitution prohibits muzzling those who choose to spend their own money to further the candidacy of someone they prefer and thereby reducing their voice in the political process.

Both arguments have merit, but as with most things, a choice has to be made.  The choice, at least for the moment, favors limits on contributions.  One can disagree, but doesn’t change the law. 

Fieger is not the poster boy of free speech.  He didn’t proclaim his civil disobedience, his rejection of limits as a matter of principle.  He made a secret end-run around the law.  It was a pretty good effort at gaming the system, as it worked and he’s walking around free. 

But had it not been Geoffrey Fieger, shoveling cash as fast as he could to John Edwards, might we look at it differently?  What if it was some right-wing religious cult doing the same for their candidate?  Would it have smelled any worse?

The propriety of the conduct doesn’t change because Fieger backed the wrong horse, or a horse that doesn’t offend too many people at the moment.  And Fieger may well be correct when he claims that the extreme effort of the government was a political prosecution, going after Fieger because of who he is and who he backed while leaving others to subvert the law with impunity.

But many wrongs do not make a right.  They may properly make for an acquittal, but they don’t make gaming the system right.  In the scheme of politics, cash is indeed king.  Every elected official I know (and I count a few friends amongst the group) starts humping for dollars the day after the election victory.  The cost of running for office is shocking, and they have no choice but to beg for money or risk being targeted for defeat.  It’s a disgraceful system and disgusting problem, that our votes have to be bought in a media-driven marketplace.

Individual citizens rarely can compete with special interests, particularly corporate interests that financially dwarf us.  We are, effectively, muzzled because our nickels and dimes are inadequate to buy us a seat at the table.  We pay our taxes, obey the laws and are roundly ignored by all involved, except for the empty rhetoric that characterizes politics since they figured out that we’re too stupid to realize when they are blowing smoke up our butt.

It’s not a good thing when the cash comes from the banking industry, or the teachers union.  It’s no better when it comes from Fieger.

Legal Funnies: A Potential Human Being

In anticipation of Melvyn Weiss’ sentencing, more than 275 letters were solicited attesting to his good character.  Some of the letters were written by luminaries of the bench, bar and financial world.  Some were written by regular people whose lives were enriched by Mel Weiss.  Some letters were moving.  Some said nothing and just provided bulk.

As I’m a big fan of pre-sentence memoranda, together with letters from friends, family, colleagues and acquaintances, and strongly advocate lawyers preparing them for their clients (meaning [a] doing them, and [b] doing them yourselves, not hiring some outside biz to do a useless cookie-cutter memo), I’ve seen some truly fascinating letters come back to me for submission to the judge.

As noted in the Weiss post, where a few of the letters were construed as “damning with faint praise” when the raised such significant acts of charity as helping a Merrill Lynch general counsel find a new watch or buying new boots for the wife of an art dealer, vetting letters for content is a critical aspect in the construction of a sentencing package. 

Some might complain that by doing so, the lawyer undermines the integrity of the letters offered in support of the defendant.  This is utter nonsense.  As we solicit support, we similarly oversee that it fulfills the purpose for which it was sought.  The purpose is to humanize the defendant, to show the judge a side of a human being that doesn’t appear in the indictment or trial testimony.  While prosecution witnesses will say many mean things about our client, no one will expect them to testify on direct about his charitable works.  It’s our job to bring this forth, and not to dirty the waters in some misguided sense of fairness.

More importantly, the people from whom we seek letters of support are unlikely to be very proficient in preparing such a letter.  It’s not like they (hopefully) do it all the time. 

My practice is to provide the defendant or his family with a one page “cheat sheet” that explains both the mechanics of preparing a letter as well as directions as to what content will be helpful.  As to the former, I explain that the letters are addressed to the judge, but returned to me.  Every letter much be signed and state the name and address of the writer.  Letters should be typed, or at minimum very legible.  Letters from friends and acquaintances should be no more than 2 pages.  Close family letters can be longer.  Letter should be written in English, or a translation must be provided as well. 

These “rules” all seem obvious.  You would not believe how many people would do otherwise if they were not given the “rules”.  Indeed, anticipate plenty of telephone calls and letters that fail to meet these basic criteria, usually with fascinating explanations of why it’s just not possible to comply. 

But mechanics aside, content is king.  And this is where you really have some fun.  A few important points must be noted up front.  Defendants invariably think that letters from “important” people who don’t have a clue who they are will be persuasive to the judge.  Important people carry more weight, right?  Except when they have nothing to say. 

Second, defendants love letters from their clergy, as if their pastor would write a bad letter for a parishioner.  There’s nothing wrong with a letter from the family’s religious guide, but judges know that many defendants are very religious in their spare time when they aren’t murdering people.  They don’t tend to sway a judge very far.

Third, defendants tend to be very concerned with quantity over quality, and will ask people on the street corner to write a letter for fear that they can’t find enough people who have anything nice to say about them.  This can cause some interesting problems, as it becomes clear that the defendant has no supporters or has done nothing commendable in his life.  Rarely will someone on the street corner have anything worthwhile to add.

The content of the letters would seem fairly straightforward.  First, explain the relationship between the writer and the defendant, including how long and in what capacity they know each other.  Second, provide a story about the defendant that exemplifies the reason for your support.  Use specific information rather than generalities, and telling writers to include an anecdote helps greatly to focus them on providing details.

The conclusion should ask the court to consider the information provided in formulating a sentence.  It can ask for mercy.  It can explain the negative consequences of punishment on others.  What it should not do is assert that the defendant is innocent and the cops lied through their teeth.  If the sentence is post-verdict, and the defendant maintains his innocence, the letter shouldn’t concede guilt, but it shouldn’t argue innocence either. 

Bear in mind that judges have limited time to read rambling, pointless letters, and after a few, will put their time to better use (like checking the guidelines grid again).  Structure your letters so that the closest family is up front, and the letter that are worthwhile but lack punch are buried in the middle.  Close with a strong letter, as some will read the first few and the last one to get a feel for the submission.  The middle is often just there for weight.

Despite this basic approach, there is one thing that must remain on the attorney’s radar.  People don’t write very well.  They mean well, but just can’t express themselves.  Also, some people who the defendant thinks are his friends may be, well, less than admiring.

Consider a letter I received from a “friend” in a case in the Southern District of New York:


Dear Judge:

I can’t believe this lying rat-bastard has managed to avoid prison this long. 

Sincerely,

This letter didn’t make the cut.  But still, even the letters from friends express some interesting concepts.  Consider this one, received from a friend just the other day:

Dear Judge:

Ms. S**** deserves serious consideration as a potential Human being, and I recommend her highly.

Sincerely,

For some people, this is the best they’re going to get. 

Just Do What The Cop Says

I posted about the DC Checkpoint Plan a couple of days ago, and went back to check the comments left here.  Spartan would be an overstatement.  I am constrained to assume that readers of Simple Justice don’t really care much about the issue.  Fortunately, the NAACP and ACLU think it’s worth keeping an eye on.

But over at the Volokh Conspiracy, readers held stronger feelings on the subject and were less recalcitrant to express them.  One theme emerged that was quite troubling, not just because of its application to this specific law enforcement initiative, but as a general reaction to authority.


If a cop tells you to do something, just do it.

For most of us, this is assuredly the path of least resistance.  Why fight it when it doesn’t count?  As one commenter put it, unless you have a corpse in the trunk, when a cop asks to look in your trunk, show him. 

Ironic that a bunch of folks who like to fashion themselves as libertarians find the path of least resistance the wise choice.  It is, without a doubt, the easier choice.  Lets face it, let the cop have his way and we save ourselves a whole bunch of problems.  For the most part, compliance with a police officer’s direction is no skin off our nose.  We’ve got nothing to hide.  We’ve done nothing wrong.  We didn’t wake up this morning muttering to ourselves, “hey, let’s pick a fight with a cop over nothing.” 

There is, of course, one small problem with this attitude.  It has bred a society of police appeasement, which in turn has empowered police to use their authority at will, and similarly removed the basic constraints over the exercise of police power.  In other words, cops believe they can tell citizens to jump and the only proper response is “how high?”

It comes as no surprise that some people hold this attitude.  In the constant tension between law and order, many come down on the order side of the equation, believing that its necessary to give up some freedom to enjoy safety.

What is a surprise, however, is how pervasive this attitude has become, and how militant its adherents are in promoting order over law.  There is little tolerance of those who are not inclined to give up their right to be left alone, their right to assert their freedom even in the face of a police officer ordering them to do otherwise.  To these folks, the answer is simple and beyond dispute.  Just do what the cop tells you.

But this has bred widespread misunderstanding of the relative roles of police and citizens.  A non-lawyer spelled out his understanding quite well:


Maybe I’m just unusual in this regard but I was raised with the notion that one ALWAYS does what an officer tells one to do unless the officer tells one to jump under a bus or something. Maybe I’m just a sheep — I’m obviously not a lawyer since this issue would never have occurred to me to inquire into.

For me, it’s simple. He’s the police. He’s got the badge. He’s one of the good guys, presumptively anyway, until he proves that he’s not. If an officer asks me to move along or for information, I assume there’s good reason for it aside from a general desire on the officer’s part to be a bully. I think officers have a tough and dangerous job that shouldn’t require them to justify their every action to any and every citizen with which they come into contact.

Furthermore, s/he has authority to arrest people. As a general rule, I do not want to be arrested merely for refusing an officer’s request/order or for demanding that the officer justify the request/order…unless, and I stress this, I feel that I am exercising some important right: peacefully protesting at an abortion clinic, standing the required distance from the clinic, not blocking traffic or pedestrians, not hassling clients or personnel entering or exiting the clinic. Under some such situations, I tell the officer that I have the first amendment right to be there doing what I am doing and the only way he/she will get me to move is by arresting me and bodily carrying me away. But if it’s just a matter of me hanging out somewhere that is not my personal property, if an officer tells me to move along, I move. I might say, “Yes, of course officer. May I know why?” or “Sure! What’s going on?” but I’m just not that into civil disobedience for the sake of making the point that unless the officer of the law goes through chapter and verse of the relevant penal code, I have a right to do pretty much whatever I please.

So am I undermining the Constitution or something by this “Yes officer” attitude?

Undermining the Constitution might be a bit strong.  You are not, but you are enabling the officer to do so.  Walking down a public street in any city in America is not an act of civil disobedience, and the idea that it becomes so because an officer directs you to “move on” demonstrates an underestimation of your rights. 

There are a handful of offenses that involve a person’s disobedience to authority.  Failure to obey a lawful order of the police is a crime in many jurisdictions.  So is resisting arrest.  Protesting innocence didn’t do much for Martha Stewart, but that was a bit different.  The question remains, what do courts perceive as lawful behavior on the part of the police?  The answer, unfortunately, is that judges typically defer to the cops.

In the hierarchy of players in the legal game of life, cops are definitely a few rungs higher than mere citizens.  Whether it’s because they have a difficult job to do, or because citizens are presumed to deserve it should they find themselves in the dock, the word of a police officer carries are more weight than yours. 

Is this the goal James Madison hoped to achieve when he persuaded others to sign on to the Constitution?  Our forefather had a very healthy fear of authority, and would have found deference to arbitrary orders anathema.  They understood that policing was a critical component to survival of a society, but the line stopped at the point where a specific harm was involved and police were just flexing their muscles.  The latter was not acceptable, and they fought to hard to throw off the yoke of one tyrant to happily wear the yoke of another.

We should, in a perfect society, obey the directions of police, under the assumption that they would not issue directions but for a legitimate, legally cognizable reason, whether under police power or public safety.  We should be able to trust our police to know where the line of their authority is drawn, and to be as strict in enforcing the limits of their own conduct as they are in limiting ours.

The DC Checkpoint Scheme is an example of why we don’t live in this perfect society.  When law enforcement, whether as a matter of broad public policy or a matter of a lone cop’s exertion of power beyond his authority, fails to adhere to its limits, we facilitate lawlessness by acquiescing in obedience.  In the long run, the path of least resistance will turn into the road to perdition.

Alberto Gonzalez Finds Gainful Employment

Former AG Alberto Gonzales has not been the busiest guy around, except for that really cool gig doing the commencement address at Free Will Baptist High (All six members of the graduating class thought he did a great job, I might add).  While most attorneys general land on their feet, AG landed on his butt.  But not for long.

According to Bloomberg via The Muckraker, AG has started a new career as peacemaker (no prior torture experience required).



Former U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, who was forced from his job amid a controversy over the firings of federal prosecutors, has been hired to provide assistance to a special master on a patent case.


Gonzales will help former U.S. District Judge Layn R. Phillips oversee settlement talks in the case of a Texas company which claims banks such as Wells Fargo & Co., Citigroup Inc.’s Citibank and Bank of America Corp. are violating its patents for taking and transmitting digital images of checks.


How weird that two of my favorite things end up together, when there was absolutely no connection between the two previously?

I’ve posted quite a bit about DataTreasury, the Plano, Texas company that owns tha patents that our close friends in the banking industry want desperately to use without paying for.  The banking industry has gone on full scale attack to smear the principals of the company and buy the senate’s love to avoid the price tag.  It seems that it’s worth a few million in political donations and lobbying fees to save $20 billion.  So what if it requires undermining law and democracy in the process.  This could run into real money.

But why Gonzales?  That’s a mystery.


Phillips, in an order signed yesterday, said he needed Gonzales’s help because of the number of parties in the case and the “overall complexity of this litigation.”

That explains why help is needed, but not why Gonzales is the right man for the job.  Is this a set-up?  AG doesn’t come with either a wealth of trust in his dedication to doing the right thing, or any particular experience in dealing with complex banking or patent issues.  True, he was available, and probably wouldn’t quibble with the pay.  But there were probably a number of others with actual qualifications for the job who were equally available.  Special master in a dispute is a job for an honest broker, two words that have never been associated with Al Gonzales.

So why Gonzales?  I can’t explain it.  But I’ll keep an eye on it just to make sure he hasn’t been brought in to be the “banker’s friend” in this deal.  There is one thing that can’t be denied about AG.  He knows how to be loyal and to whom he owes fealty.  After all, there might be a good job as a bank security guard available to him some day, if he plays his cards right.

Riots in the Street

Oil up $10 a barrel.  Cost filters through the system, raising food prices while those who still have jobs struggle to pay for healthcare.

Other than general complaining, people have yet to recognize the pervasiveness of the problems they will be facing next winter, when they can’t afford to heat their homes, eat, drive to work and recover from illness at the same time.  When they crash, the rugged individualists will whine like the rest of ’em for big brother to “do something.”  What something?  Snap their fingers and make an inspirational speech?  Have a professor expound on a theory? 

We hear news stories about individual problems, whatever is the flavor of the day.  These problems are interconnected, however, and will have a negative synergy that will make our heads spin.  It’s not just one bad thing happening, but a bunch, each making the next worse in a vicious circle.

Politicians offer answers to placate the stupidest voter in the country.  In a presidential election year, they will not offend oil companies or hedge fund managers, lest they decide not to exercise their free speech right to contribute money.

By the time the stupidest voter gets hit square between the eyes, the chances of addressing the problem will be gone.  Will there be riots in the street?  Will there be incalculable and unresolvable pain, with Bushville’s springing up in dusty fields?  They’ll probably called Obamavilles in the history books.  It doesn’t really matter when your children are hungry.

There are very real problems heading for us at great speed, and we prefer to pretend that some miracle is coming to fix it before we have to admit that we are in severe trouble.  It’s what we do best.  Act dumb and wait for something to save us.

Like I said, one day the miracles will be over.  When that happens, riots won’t help.  The time to tighten the belt, address the structural problem and deal with harsh reality is now.  It was really 8 years ago, but it’s too late to start that feud back up. 

Does anyone else remember that we have a lot of soldiers in Iraq at the moment? 

This is a very bad situation.  It’s not going to get better by itself.  Start thinking about it, please.

Welcome to Peking Law School

As if China hasn’t done well enough riding out lead-painted coattails.  The ABA will been asked to grant accreditation to a new law school.  No, not the one planned for beautiful downtown Rochester as an urban renewal project.  Oh no.  This is going to change everything.


A new law school in China has announced its intent to seek accreditation from the American Bar Association, so graduates could potentially practice law in the U.S. (States commonly require a degree from an ABA-accredited law school as a prerequisite for taking the bar exam.)

Peking University School of Transnational Law, the first 55-student class of which will start this fall, will teach classes on American law in English, reports the National Law Journal. The law school’s dean is Jeffrey Lehman, a former dean of the University of Michigan Law School, who plans to use the Socratic method. The school says it will award juris doctor degrees after three years of successful study.
Maybe I’m feeling a little protectionist.  Maybe I’m of the view that we have too many lawyers already for our own good.  Maybe I’m just afraid that this is the worst idea for any hope of maintaining professionalism in the law I’ve ever heard.  But I think this is absolutely horrible.

This vision of seven billion Chinese lawyers swarming the hallways of American courthouses is just too much to take.  Will they offer a joint program with the University of Bombay next, because I’m sure that there are many hard-working Indians who would be happy to seek a fine American legal education?  The Chinese, Indians and others are smart, hard-working and fully prepared to sacrifice for a better future. 

Kinda sounds like the way Americans used to be before we decided we’re too good to work hard anymore. 

The flat world isn’t helping the United States very much.  We produce nothing and churn our revenues in a circle of services until the money finally finds its way to our ports and the next boat out.   If anything, we should close down half the law schools in the United States.  All those would-be lawyers can then spend their days building something of actual use of society.

But Peking Law School?  What a nightmare.

Liberals Want Their Constitution Back

It’s been a long time since the word “liberal” was stolen from the vernacular and turned into a curse.  In the interim, we’ve managed to squander a budget surplus, get into a losing, and never-ending, war, watch our economy tank, then tank some more, and then really tank. 

Our prisons are filled with more than 2.3 million people, who can’t leave because they can’t afford the gasoline to drive them home, but it doesn’t matter too much because their home was foreclosed.  All in all, it has not been the halcyon days that Newt Gingrich expected.

This may be about to change.  Not only have we seen some interesting changes in American politics, but the re-emergence of the word “liberal” could signal a shift in political thought that would open avenues of thought that had been rejected by most Americans.  We’re a curious bunch, we are.  We learn from our mistakes.  Eventually.

Tony Mauro at Legal Times, repeated at the New York Lawyer, announces the formation of the liberal law firm, dedicated to a liberal textual reading of the Constitution, together with the American Constitution Society, the flip side of the Federalist Society.



The United States Constitution: It’s not just for conservatives anymore.


With that thesis in mind, a new liberal think tank and public interest law firm launched in D.C. on Tuesday, hoping to catch a progressive wave in both election politics and scholarly research on the meaning of the nation’s founding document.


To spread the word and take it into court, Kendall has assembled liberal stalwarts — and liberal money — to back his effort and support his view that, unlike unsuccessful liberal efforts in the past, his approach of embracing the Constitution’s text has the best shot of recapturing the constitutional high ground from conservatives. Yale Law School’s Akhil Amar and Jack Balkin and Duke’s Walter Dellinger are advisers, and George Soros’ Open Society Institute is a major funder. Ron Klain, former chief of staff to Al Gore and now an investment adviser for progressives, is also on board. Startup money totals nearly $2 million.


It’s about time.  Kendall is absolutely right that a liberal’s had given away the Constitution from a text-based analysis, only to find that my very dear, personal friend, Nino Scalia (dinner this Sunday at 6 again, pal?) has resurrected their hopes.


Ever since the start of the Reagan legal revolution in 1980, Kendall says, conservative judges and thinkers have laid claim to the Constitution’s language, basing their legal arguments — genuinely or not — in “originalism” or “textualism,” while painting liberal positions as rootless judicial activism. Liberals responded, Kendall says, by distancing themselves from the words of the Constitution, fearing that it produced bad results.

Kendall wants to debunk that view and supply the research and support that will enable liberals to seek progressive results by using arguments based on constitutional text and history. (Kendall avoids the word “originalism,” a term with no fixed meaning, in his view.)

Having watched as the arguments devolved into simplistic absolutes, it has become increasingly clear that Scalia, based upon his unvarnished textual reading of the Constitution, has done more the salvage basic rights than anyone since Earl Warren.  Yes, he’s been less than perfect, but who else gave us Crawford?  Think about it.  No emanations or penumbras, just a clear vision of the right to cross-examine witnesses. 

Contrary to the assumptions that the general bias against all things liberal, not to mention the conversion of a philosophy to an epithet that Democratic candidates for office avoid like the plague, it’s only dead if progressive thinkers allow it to be.  No side owns the Constitution unless you let them.

Kendall’s efforts signal a resurgence in the belief that there is no shame in liberal beliefs.  Hey, why give up the high ground to the great mass of thinkers who find a third grade civics exam an impossible challenge?  I applaud this effort and hope that Kendall will give me a call if he could use a hand. 

The Slackoisie Fight Back

A couple of weeks ago, Dan Hull at What About Paris? questioned the work ethicof the incoming class of lawyers, suggesting that it might not be entirely up to snuff.  It was a fairly tame piece of work, Dan recognizing that these budding geniuses would be too busy playing Super Mario Smash Brothers and Grand Theft Auto 36 to bother to notice that he was making fun of them.

But after a while their Wii remote batteries needed recharging, so they skimmed the ‘net to see what their job prospects looked like since they’d run out of Doritos and needed a job to buy another bag.  Coming upon Dan’s comments, they were outraged.  How dare this Hull guy question their work ethic (pass the cheetos)?

Let’s see what our future has to say:

I love the implication that Baby Boomers were all work ethic back in the day. Look, I didn’t live through the ’60s, but I’ve seen the films. Don’t give me this “back in my day, we’d work for 300 hours a week, and our only pay was a nickle and swift kick in the pants, and we were glad to have that” crap. And if you want to start stereotyping generations, then you get to explain why, in your day, reasonable minds could differ on the moral propriety segregated schools, lunch counters, water fountains, and restrooms. (I mean really. There was a legitimate pro-segregation movement — with U.S. Senators on board. I’m not making this up.)

Many of us “Gen-Y-ers” work our butts off, and those who don’t, well, they won’t be around the office when those of us who do are running law firms and complaining about the young associates and their new-found sense of entitlement.

In sum, quit talking ’bout my g-g-generation. It’s not our fault some hack is trying to sell a worthless seminar.

What a whiny loser.  Try learning history from the books instead of movies.


This is a horrendous slander by greedy, entitled and narcissistic baby boomers. It’s also a scheme by which they make another easy and undeserved buck. “Hey, those Gen Y people are lazy but if you pay me $xxx I’ll help you work with them.”

As a Gen-Yer dealing with financial problems and a dearth of opportunity which you, you grotesque old cretins couldn’t have imagined coping with, all I have to say is two words.

F*&k YOU.

That’s right, bite the hand that fed you, you ingrate.  At least we had the balls to spell out our curses when we were young.  The only reason we can’t do it now is that we can’t remember stuff.  You want proof, read this:


Even as a Boomer, I feel it is short-sighted and egotistical to tell the Gen Y-ers that “it is your problem” and “your job to adjust to us.” Of course it is not. The world progresses, and the way business is done now is much different than the way it was done in the past. Who brought about these changes? New generations of workers who had new – not worse – ways of working. We can all learn from each other; in fact we have to, if we want continued success in our practices.

Business hasn’t changed.  You put your money on the table and you get something in return.  The only thing that’s missing on you, boomer wannabe, is genitalia.


I find it extremely interesting that the knee-jerk reaction to the above e-mail is to say “I’m older and I sign the checks, so why should I bother with keeping my employees engaged in my business?” The e-mail in question is offering a seminar to show how to manage Gen-Y employees in such a fashion that you keep them happy and productive.

Do employees have a right to be treated in a way that keeps them happy and productive by their employers?
No.

Does an employer have a duty to manage its workforce in a way that keeps employee morale high?
No.

Is it in a firm’s interest to retain particularly intelligent, competent, and productive employees?
Clearly.

Of this class of employees, who is more likely to remain with the firm – the employee who is happy, motivated, and feels that the firm’s culture parallels his or her own values; or the employee who feels unhappy, unappreciated, and has difficulty communicating these concerns to their superiors?

If you want to find and keep the best people, you have to make them feel like your office is the best place to work, and for the vast majority of people that goes beyond the size of their pay check, especially when other employers will match the salary.

Ah, we’ve reached the nadir.  How about this concept:  If you want to drive around in a BMW to show all your buddies how cool you are, get your butt to work and do your job. 

No, workplace revisionism does not depend on changing the “firm’s culture” to “parallel” the slacheoisies’ and make him feel “happy”.  If you were half as brilliant as you attribute to yourselves, you would understand that your happiness does not translate into a better workforce, just a happier overpaid workforce that doesn’t perform. 

Susan Cartier Leibel has already explained to me that you refuse to stay on the leash, having watched mommy and daddy suffer the indignity of a corporate culture that ate them up and spit them out.  So you’re not having any of it.  I got that part.

But your answer is that you want the benefits without the responsibilities.  You want to come and go as you please.  You want no consequences when you are non-productive, when you fail the client because it’s inconvenient to you.  You want a seat on the executive committee by the end of your first week.  Get a life.

We are a profession of effectiveness, not efficiency.  Clients don’t care if you feel good about yourself.  They care that you attend to their representation timely and effectively.  Clients come to lawyers to help with their problems, not yours.  That’s why they pay us. 

Does this make you sad and lower your self-esteem?  Bummer.