Author Archives: SHG

Does Incarceration Reduce Public Safety?

Massachusetts Federal District Court Judge Nancy Gertner’s sentencing opinion in U.S. v. Haynes is the sort of thing that culture wars are made of.  From Doug Berman over at Sentencing Law and Policy, consider:

At the time of sentencing, Haynes had already served approximately thirteen months in pretrial detention, longer than the sentence he served for the 1998 conviction.  The recommended sentence under the United States Sentencing Guidelines Manual, 33-41 months, was driven exclusively by the quantity of drugs for which he was responsible (on those two occasions in May 2006), the location of the sales, and his criminal history (Criminal History Category II). The government argued that the lower end of the Guidelines, 33 months, was entirely appropriate, not just because the Guidelines recommended it, but because “public safety,” one of the factors in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a), demanded it.

I found otherwise. While public safety certainly calls for the incapacitation of some, there is another side to the equation, which, after United States v. Booker, 543 U.S. 220 (2005), may finally be given the serious consideration it deserves.  The facts presented by Haynes’ case force the Court to confront the inescapable fact that disadvantaged communities like Bromley-Heath are injured both by crime and by the subsequent mass incarceration of their young men.  See Donald Braman, Criminal Law and the Pursuit of Equality, 84 Tex. L. Rev. 2097, 2114-17 (2006). Compare Randall Kennedy, Race, Crime, and the Law 373-76 (1997), with Todd R. Clear, Imprisoning Communities: How Mass Incarceration Makes Disadvantaged Neighborhoods Worse (2007).  Courts may no longer ignore the possibility that the mass incarceration of nonviolent drug offenders has disrupted families and communities and undermined their ability to self-regulate, without necessarily deterring the next generation of young men from committing the same crimes.

Haynes is an individual for whom continued incarceration beyond thirteen months makes no sense. Indeed, here, public safety seems to require the opposite of the government’s request; it requires that Haynes be permitted to return to his children so that they do not repeat his errors. Thus, I sentenced Haynes to time served: the thirteen months he had already served in pretrial detention plus a carefully considered supervised release program.

Ah, when those crazy justices in Washington opened the door to judges ignoring the belovedly harsh and inflexible guidelines, this is exactly what the “spare the prison, spoil the criminal” crowd feared.  Here comes those “activists” judges, coming up with their liberal schemes to let all the criminals out of jail to return to our their community to rape our wimmens.

Judge Gertner’s opinion is tantamount to heresy; If prison is good, more prison is better.  That’s how “justice” works in these United States.

Of course, as many commenters here and elsewhere have already made clear, “disadvantaged neighborhoods” aren’t made that way because of our many laws imposing extreme incarceratory punishments, lack of education, racial prejudice, lack of opportunity, but because their residents are just a bunch a darn criminals who make the choice to rape our wimmens.

Just to be clear, they shouldn’t commit crimes.  But without more, they’re likely to continue to pursue a lifestyle that others prefer they wouldn’t.  One of the things that must happen, in tandem with the primary need of better education, is to maintain a family culture that provides support for education and work ethic, positive role models and a belief that there is a way out of the cycle of poverty and crime.

It’s hard to do when a significant percentage of the males of the community aren’t coming home for 121 months. leaving children fatherless.  The solution to changing this culture isn’t easy, but it isn’t necessarily helped by locking up all the men for as long as we can. 

Judge Gertner’s opinion deals with a non-violent drug felony, not some psycho who has gone around and raped our wimmens.  She can’t force state and local governments to dedicate the funds needed to provide their children with a decent education, or shift the culture to one that supports positive vision of the future and vests them in a law-abiding life.  But she is doing what she can to change things.

Why?  Because the continuation of doing what we have been doing is both inordinately expensive and hasn’t worked.  If the definition of insanity is to continue to do something over and over, that has failed in the past (about 2.3 million times at the moment), expecting the outcome to be different, then this decision is at least an attempt to change our cycle of failure.

Someone over at Doug’s blawg commented,


This is a bit much. I suppose the next step is for district judges to argue that incarceration itself reduces public safety because it costs money that could be better spent on other social programs, and on that basis sentence everyone to the statutory minimum (or no sentence at all if there’s no minimum).

Sarcastic extreme notwithstanding, what if it worked?  What if spending all the money we now flush down the prison toilet to change the culture of the ghetto served to change the lives of many, maybe even most, and ended the cycle of crime?  Would it break your heart, and give you no one to dump on?

But since we have never made a real commitment to try to change the factors that breed failure and crime, and since it all sounds like a neo-con’s nightmare of coddling the criminals, the poor, the downtrodden, stealing their money to give it away to welfare queens driving Cadillacs, we just keep trying the same old failed “solution” of mass incarceration.  It doesn’t work.  In never worked.  But at least it makes the taxpayers feel like their money isn’t wasted. 

What Smells About the DC Checkpoint Scheme

Orin Kerr, back from his debauchery in New Jersey, has started to dissect the DC Checkpoint plan.  This plan is ‘for a ‘military style checkpoint’ to stop gun violence” by having cops stop every car entering a cordoned off neighborhood, delightfully called a “Neighborhood Safety Zone” (because “Loss of Constitutional Rights Zone” doesn’t sounds nearly as appetizing).

According to the Washington Post :


The checkpoint will stop vehicles approaching the 1400 block of Montello Avenue NE, a section of the Trinidad neighborhood that has been plagued with homicides and other violence. Police will search cars if they suspect the presence of guns or drugs, and will arrest people who do not cooperate, under a charge of failure to obey a police officer, officials said.

Orin concludes that under existing precedent, this scheme is unconstitutional.  But since I’m less of a slave to precedent (and don’t believe that judges are nearly as careful in parsing precedent as Orin does), I’ve got a different beef.

Since when does anyone have to explain to a cop why he wants to drive his car into any neighborhood in America?  We are endowed with the right to travel freely throughout these beautiful United States.  We need not obtain the permission of the police to take scenic drives through bucolic downtown Washington, D.C.  And most importantly, we do not need to answer the questions posed by police officers when there is no basis to believe that we, specifically and individually, have done anything wrong.

Orin’s second post on the plan expands his view of what’s wrong with this hair-brained scheme.  Clearly, the hangover is abating.


Can a police officer order you to move along — that is, to leave the area — without any suspicion that you’ve committed a crime?

Also,


What are the Due Process limits on criminalizing failure to obey an officer? In particular, is there a constitutional requirement that the person understands that failure to obey is a crime? Citizens generally have no idea when they have to do what an officer tells them to do, and I would think there is some sort of Due Process requirement of fair notice that the order has to be obeyed before an arrest can be made.

Now we’re getting somewhere.

Just because some cop somewhere decides that whatever pops into his head at any moment becomes good cause for arresting otherwise law-abiding citizens does not give rise to a legitimate arrest.  The power to arrest is huge.  The power to take away our freedom is huge.  But this goes even farther.  Let’s say some poor fool disagrees with an officer’s decision that his explanation (as if he owed the cop an explanation) for being somewhere is inadequate.  The cops decides that he’s going to arrest this person who has done nothing more than refuse to surrender his citizenship to this cop.  The cop in turn decides that this fine motorist needs a little tuning up. 

The story ends with citizen beaten, arrested and imprisoned, all because he took umbrage with being told that he is not entitled to drive down a road built with taxpayer funds unless he OBEYS a police officer, is dutifully obsequious and satisfies this cop with his explanation.  Mind you, this isn’t happening in Moscow or Beijing, but in the cradle of freedom, Washington, D.C.

I’m sure that Orin will see, as soon as he removes that silly-looking orange and black beanie cap with the propeller on top that’s covering his blood-shot eyes, that this isn’t merely wrong because it nips around the edges of some precedent or raises questions of adequate notice.  This is a fundamental wrong, flying smack in the face of basic freedoms. 

Why do we keep thinking that cops get to make us do anything they want, and we must obey?  We really have to resist this very dangerous notion that they are the rulers and we are the ruled.

Barry Kamins Heads NY Task Force on Wrongful Convictions

Barry Kamins may be a name partner in a large law firm, but he’s a real criminal defense lawyer.  That’s the good news.  According to the New York Lawyer, Barry has been tapped to lead the New York State Bar Association’s Task Force on Wrongful Convictions. 

The bad news is that this is a New York State Bar Association task force.

The panel is the first initiative of Bernice K. Leber, the new state bar president, who said it is incumbent upon the group to take a leadership role in ensuring that no innocent people in New York are punished for crimes they did not commit.

It’s hard to blame Leber for wanting to take a “leadership role,” but incumbent?  Hardly.  This isn’t their issue, and they have no clout to affect change. 

This Task Force should have been formed by Chief Judge Judy Kaye, and received the imprimatur of government concern for putting innocent people in prison.  Granted, it’s not like the Legislature or Governor care a great deal about what comes out of the third branch of government, as they routinely ignore the judiciary, but it’s the only branch that might potentially care about convicting innocent people.  The others are more likely to shrug it off as a casualty of re-election.

And where would the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers be on this task force?  Silent, as usual, trying to secretly clean up one mess after another to make sure their internal dirty laundry doesn stink up their dues increases.  It doesn’t even rise to the level of irrelevance.

So what’s wrong with the NYSBA taking charge of the issue?


Ms. Leber announced yesterday that 21 members have agreed to serve on the task force with Mr. Kamins, including former Court of Appeals Judges Howard Levine and George Bundy Smith and District Attorneys Charles J. Hynes of Brooklyn and Janet DeFiore of Westchester.

There you go.  How do you “fix” the system?  Put two former judges and two of the biggest self-promoting District Attorneys in New York on the Task Force.  The very people responsible for the problem, or at least perpetuating the problem, and these are the “big names” who are going to ensure that innocent people don’t get convicted.

At the very least, these are the people who are “vested” in maintaining the system, for whom changes and the admission that the system has failed to protect the innocent prove that they have failed to honor their duty.  This is typical of the NYSBA, incapable of comprehending why you don’t ask foxes to guard the henhouse.  The State Bar adores big names in public office.  They are SO important, and the NYSBA loves important people.

I wish Barry the best of luck.  His job may be one step harder than heading a Gitmo tribunal on the integrity scale.  But at least Barry is a real lawyer. 

KSM Wins at Gitmo Tribunal

Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, the admitted mastermind of the 9/11 attacks, has won.  This is no surprise, of course, as it was clear from the outset that he would beat the system, but he’s now getting the chance to enjoy it a little before he meets his virgins.

As widely reported, KSM (as he’s called) is a happy man.


GUANTANAMO BAY, CUBA — When a visibly aged Khalid Shaikh Mohammed and four alleged accomplices were reunited in a sterile military courtroom here Thursday, they laughed and chatted like old school chums and apparently rekindled their common cause: to defy their American enemies or die trying.

Strident and unremorseful over the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks they allegedly plotted, four of the men declared their eagerness to be executed.

Asked by the tribunal’s chief judge, Marine Col. Ralph H. Kohlmann, if he recognized that he could be put to death if convicted, Mohammed said: “This is what I wish. I’m looking to be a martyr for a long time.”

The foundation of our system is predicated upon a few underlying assumptions:  That the defendant does not want to be convicted, that the defendant will resist conviction and that the defendant does not want to be punished.  The system is not going to work here.

KSM doesn’t want his lawyers.  KSM doesn’t dispute his “crime”.  If anything, he’s quite proud of his actions and would much prefer to use this opportunity to tell the world as much about his purposes as he can.  Our system allows to defendants to defend.  This is his “defense”. 

Ultimately, any chance that we’re going to find some level of satisfaction here is gone.  The tribunal’s chief judge, Marine Col. Ralph H. Kohlmann, is going to have a big problem on his hands, trying to maintain some semblence of dignity and integrity in these proceedings.


Ali Abdul Aziz Ali told Kohlmann he shared the views of the three before him who praised martyrdom and replied nonchalantly to Kohlmann’s question as to whether he knew the ultimate penalty could be levied against him: “Naturally. I know.”

Ali, who insisted to the court that his real name was Ammar al Baluchi, spoke in fluent English, mocking the judge’s earnest assurances of his rights to legal assistance.

A nephew of Mohammed and a college-trained computer engineer, Ali said it was late for his U.S. jailers to be offering him a lawyer.

“Everything that has happened here is unfair and unjust. Since the first time I was arrested, I might have appreciated that,” he said of the offer of free legal representation.

“The government is talking about lawyers free of charge. The government also tortured me free of charge all these years,” he said.

Kohlmann told him he considered it unwise for the defendants to insist on representing themselves, to which Ali retorted, “For me, this proceeding in its entirety is unwise.”

They’re good.  No wild-eyed screaming and ranting.  These are not ignorant men.  Kohlmann has his hands full.

Worse yet, every issue that is raised by our government’s handling of these matters, from torture to denial of counsel from the outset, is coming back to smack the tribunal.  It’s hard to maintain legitimacy in the face of how this has been handled.  We haven’t been true to ourselves, though it wouldn’t have changed the defendants’ stance.  But we gave them the ammunition to belittle our claims of fairness and wisdom, to ridicule our process with the country and world listening.

And this is just the beginning.  What threat do we hold over these 5 terrorists?  I can’t call them accused, since they have happily admitted their roles, and are proud of what they have done.  Will we make them martyrs?  They already are, and there’s nothing we can do about it. 

When a defendant announces at the beginning of his trial that his hope is to be put to death, all leverage is gone.  The United States has played its hand poorly.  We will now go through the motions, as KSM picks his shots and lands blow after blow.  The outcome is utterly irrelevant, as is already clear. 

Khalid Shaikh Mohammed has won.  The only thing left to see is how much more harm he can do to us.

No Money Laundering, But They’re Keeping the Cash

Justice Thomas, writing for a unanimous Supreme Court in Cuellar v. U.S., held that merely concealing currency in a secret compartment of a car was not tantamount to money laundering.

The capsule of the decision, courtesy of SCOTUSBlog :

The federal money laundering statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1956, prohibits international transportation of the proceeds of unlawful activity.  The statute requires the defendant to know that such transportation is “designed in whole or in part . . . to conceal or disguise the nature, the location, the source, the ownership, or the control of the proceeds of specified unlawful activity.”  In Cuellar v. United States, No. 06-1456, the Court considered whether that part of the statute requires the government to prove (1) that the defendant attempted to make illegal funds appear legitimate or (2) merely that the defendant hid the money during transportation. 

The answer:  neither.  On Monday, June 2, 2008, the Court held that although the government does not need to show that the defendant attempted to make illegal funds appear legitimate, it is required to show that the defendant did more than merely hide the funds during transport.  To sustain a conviction, the government must prove that the defendant knew that a purpose of the transportation was to conceal or disguise a listed attribute of the illicit funds.

This is another long-overdue decision, distinguishing the mere concealment of currency from the intent to disguise criminal proceeds. 

Scott at Grits for Breakfast has posted about Cuellar, both in praise of Justice Thomas (who’da thunk!) and to take this decision a few steps further. 


In case after case, courts have deemed simply finding large amounts of hidden, unexplained cash sufficient to justify state seizure, often when no associated crime is prosecuted. That should change, though, after the US Supreme Court just ruled in a Texas case this week that more investigation is required to justify asset seizures.

While Cuellar’s implications for a money laundering conviction are significant, I doubt this decision will have any impact whatsoever on asset seizures.  They are two completely different animals in almost every respect.  Asset seizures are in rem proceedings against the cash, rather than in personam proceedings against the person.  The elements are entirely different, as well as the burden of proof, contrasting beyond a reasonable doubt with probable cause. 

Asset seizures of cash in excess of $10,000 are presumed to be criminal proceeds, having the effect of shifting the burden to the claimant to prove that the funds are lawful.  The proceedings are civil in nature, meaning that the discovery mechanisms are available to the government to demand where the assets came from and how they ended up in a secret compartment.  Lie under oath in discovery about the cash and end up sharing a cell with Martha Stewart. 

I wholly agree with Grits that asset forfeiture is one of the most notorious and outrageous scams that the government has in its arsenal, and like Scott I wish that some degree of fairness and due process was brought to bear on these actions.  I just can’t see how the Cuellar decision can be extended to reach it. 

So when the cops stop and search, find the cache of cash, there’s a good chance that they will smile and wave as they let you drive away.  But the reason they’re smiling is that they’ve got your money, and there’s no basis to believe that it’s going to change any time soon.

Restaino Gets The Boot

Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen Casey, reports that Niagara Falls City Court Judge Robert Restaino lost his bid to retain his robes in a decision issued by the Court of Appeals yesterday.  Prior coverage of Restaino’s antics are here, here, here and here.

Up to now, we’ve been working with relatively spartan information about what exactly happened on March 11, 2005, the day that a cellphone rang in Restaino’s domestic violence courtroom.  The decision provides the details, and the scenario is uglier than previously understood.

One defendant, for example, exhorted petitioner to rethink his approach to an otherwise legitimate courtroom concern that could be handled differently, stating: “I think the more people you send to jail, [the] less likely [the] culprit is to come forward,” to which petitioner responded: “he’ll go right to jail with everybody else.” In other instances, one defendant pleaded that he had a doctor’s appointment he would miss if jailed; others pleaded that they would lose their new jobs, that they did not have the resources to post bail. Others pleaded for simple fairness, exclaiming that “this ain’t right,” to which petitioner acknowledged: “You’re right, it ain’t right. Ain’t right at all.” Another had a scheduled appointment for counseling pursuant to an imposed condition, while another had his mother “in surgery [that] morning.” Finally, another pleaded that he had a bi-weekly scheduled visit with his “little girl” that he would miss if jailed. These pleas fell on deaf ears.

Restaino called every defendant on the calendar and, one by one, imposed or raised their bail, eschewing their arguments and pleas.  He then called the defendants whose cases had been called before the cellphone rang and raised their bails as well, assuring that every defendant in that courtroom would be returned to custody that day. 

Restaino had a policy that defendants were required to remain in the courtroom after their case was called until he had completed the calendar for the day.  This is quite unusual, in my experience.  I’ve never heard of a judge who keeps defendants captive for the day after their case has been heard.  Had they been allowed to leave, the 11 defendants whose cases were recalled would have been long gone.  Instead, they were still present and subject to their bail being increased to hold them.

One by one, Restaino individually jailed defendants, despite their explanations of how this would impact their lives.  He had 46 chances to rethink his bizarrely improper abuse of power.  He refused to relent 46 times.

We often talk about how a judge is like a god in his courtroom.  Restaino was an angry, irrational god, swollen with his power.  Over the perceived disrespect and breach of decorum, this demi-god jailed 46 people, one by one. [Edit: This is the money quote of the opinion, and genius that I am, I left it out]


[B]y indiscriminately committing into custody 46 defendants, petitioner deprived them of their liberty without due process, exhibited insensitivity, indifference and a callousness so reproachable that his continued presence on the Bench cannot be tolerated.

A commenter, Peter Calabrese, (who I believe to be a Priest) posted following the Court of Appeals decision but apparently unaware that the decision had issued, stated:


So you are in favor of the death penalty for him in the end. All your talk is in the end gibberish. Actually his record had now been blemished regardless of what sanction or lack thereof is applied. He has been publicly humiliated because someone failed to be honest.  He probably would be a better judge then he already was for the ordeal he has been through.

I only pray that those passing their judgment on him, no matter how professional that judgment may allege to be, will never meet the same harsh judgment that is being prepared for him. Those that condemn him had better never even have a wisp of impropriety about them.

You miss the point.  We don’t show mercy by returning those who abuse their power to office.  He was denied a privilege, to sit in judgment of others.  He was not sent to prison.  He was not compelled to suffer the same consequences he levied on others who had nothing wrong.  Restaino showed no mercy whatsoever, but he also showed an unfathomable level of callousness toward others.  You don’t get to jail 46 people and expect to be allowed back on the bench.

The cellphone person is not to blame for Restaino’s psychotic behavior.  Nor is Restaino’s behavior legitimized by anyone else’s impropriety.  This man was a judge.  This man’s actions were abhorrent.  So now he’s publicly humiliated?  What a shame.  Where is your sympathy for the 46 defendants he jailed?

In light of the detailed information provided in the Court of Appeals decision, Restaino’s conduct was so utterly over the top that there could be no other reasonable penalty.   Restaino had to go.



The Indigent Defendant’s Right to a Jury Consultant

From Overlawyered comes this rather curious issue of whether an indigent defendant in a high-profile murder case can retain a jury consultant on the public teet.  Before you rush to laugh at the notion, consider the totality of the circumstances as revealed in this post from The Jury Box Blog, providing a much fuller picture.

The case involves Neil Entwistle and the allegation of the sordid murder of his wife and child.  It’s received huge media attention in Massachusetts and elsewhere.  It’s not your run-of-the-mill trial.


It is rather standard by now for the defendant in a case of this magnitude to use a trial consultant to help identify potential biased jurors. The primary concern is the saturation of the jury pool with pretrial publicity, especially that which is prejudicial to the defendant.

Massachusetts has one of the most liberal statutes with respect to the availability of public funds with which indigent defendants can hire experts. The language of the statute reflects the basic premise that if a paying defendant would reasonably hire such an expert, the indigent defendant should be able to, as well. Unfortunately, the statute is rarely interpreted as liberally as it appears on its face. So far as I know, no defendant has ever been awarded public funds to hire a jury consultant.

To some extent, it may well be argued that the fact that defendants possessed of sufficient wealth may indulge their fears by spending money wastefully does not compel the state to waste its funds in a similar manner.  But then, I’m not a big fan of jury consultants, regardless of whether my clients want to flush their money down the toilet or not.  Others disagree with me.

Aside from my view that this is voodoo, a sham science that’s primarily used to generate revenues for psychologists and mind-readers who have difficulty maintaining a stable patient base, there is a very real question about the allocation of very scarce resources, funds for indigent defense. 

I can think of no state in this nation where indigent defenders are complaining of an embarrassment of riches.  They are horribly overworked, and constantly struggling to find adequate resources to perform the basic function of representing the poor accused of crime.  The monies spent on very expensive, and highly suspect, services comes straight out of the funds needed for the thousands of others requiring representation.  Does one high profile defendant have the right to be an inordinate drain on a strained system at the expense of a hundred other, equally deserving, defendants?

But the judge in Massachusetts won’t let this rest here.


Judge Diane Kottmyer flatly refused requests by Entwistle’s attorneys for money to pay for a trial consultant in this case. Her rationale was that it had never been done before, so she didn’t have to do it now. She never addressed the actual merits of affording Entwistle this procedural protection in a case so prominent in the public eye. Judge Kottmyer assured counsel that she could handle the issue of pretrial publicity by issuing the jury proper instructions to disregard anything they might have heard, read or seen about the case in advance. Alas, the judge’s assertion here is simply ignorant. Every single study that has ever been published about the effects of pretrial publicity has concluded that such limiting instructions are completely useless.

Judge Kottmyer similarly refused motions for attorney conducted voir dire, sequestered voir dire, a change of venue and even an extensive supplemental juror questionnaire. After allowing the lawyers to submit some questions for a questionnaire, the judge decided that she would write her own, allowing no input from either counsel.

From the sublime to the ridiculous.  It’s one thing to refuse the request for a jury consultant, but another entirely to reduce jury selection to a farce.  No doubt Judge Kottmyer thinks very highly of her skills as a judge and her impartiality.  Or maybe she just figures that she’ll get a fast jury and be ready for sentence by lunch time.  Either way, her mangling of jury selection in a trial under this level of scrutiny shows horribly poor judgment.

Focusing on one of the worst foundational fictions in the law, the judge is going to “handle” the problem of pre-trial publicity by “issuing the jury proper instructions.”  This is one of those magic moments that judges (including appellate judges) love, because with the sweep of their hand, reality disappears and their absolute authority to control the hearts and minds of jurors makes all things right.  There can be no prejudice, because the judge says so.

Edward Schwartz of the Jury Box Blog calls this “simply ignorant.”  He’s being kind.  It’s absurd.  It’s outrageous.  And it’s done all the time.  Instructions from the judge to “disregard” make defense lawyers cringe.  The bell once rung cannot be unrung.  We all know it, but to actually undo the damage would, in the minds of courthouse grocery clerks, place to onerous a burden on the system.  We can’t have a system that strains to do justice when it’s far easier to pretend that judges can make all evils disappear.

What’s even more unfortunate about the Entwistle trial is that there will be no way to objectively ascertain the impact of these rulings.  While the judge proclaims her own capacity to seat 12 good people in the box to provide Entwistle with a perfectly acceptable verdict, how can we quantify the magnitude of her arrogance? 

As Schwartz notes, few will be sympathetic to Entwistle, whose conviction is widely anticipated.  And so the fact that he gets only the pretense of voir dire, no frills attached, does no harm in the minds of many.  Or we can note as clearly as possible that, while the ability to retain a jury consultant may not attach, the ability of defense counsel to participate in the selection of a fair jury in a case given vast media attention has been fatally undermined. 

Simply ignorant indeed.

Kuby Flying on Air America

My old friend Ron Kuby, one-time protégé of Bill Kunstler, was given the boot from his duet with one-time Guardian Angel Curtis Sliwa when Imus returned to the air following his notorious “nappy-headed ho’s” comment.  Kuby, who goes to the same hair-stylist as Norm Pattis, was crushed.

But you can’t keep a good lefty down.  It’s taken a while, but Ron’s coming home on the Air America shuttle, the Al Franken version of Fair and Balanced Fox.

According to the New York Lawyer, Ron has found lefty love with Air America and will start his new gig next Monday morning. 

NEW YORK (AP) – Ron Kuby, who lost his previous radio job to Don Imus, will return to the air Monday on the Air America Radio network. Kuby will be on Air America from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern time, the network said Tuesday.

In a statement, the former WABC-AM morning host said he will have “a few things that listeners haven’t thought of yet, or don’t want to think about.”

WABC dumped Kuby for Imus, who returned to radio last December. CBS Radio fired Imus in April 2007 for making offensive on-air remarks about the Rutgers women’s basketball team. At WABC, the left-leaning Kuby had sparred with Guardian Angels founder Curtis Sliwa since May 2000.
I’m happy for Ronny.  His abrupt removal, coupled with the fact that Sliwa was kept on board, must have hurt.

But Air America?  I hate to say it, but never have I listened to sound emanating from the speaker of my Prius hybrid radio that had less to offer.  The sounds of shrill voices, restating the obvious from two year old news, having yet to notice that George W. Bush is a lame duck or widely reviled by people of all persuasions, is painful to my ears.

While Rush Limbaugh’s oxycontin delusions are always a fine source of humor and fascination (“where did he come up with that nonsense?”), there is no similar humor to be found on Air America.  Preaching to the choir of leftyism is a pointless endeavor, even if it was conceived as an offset to the challenge of neo-con fantasies.  Fringe elements of the right and left are not comparable; Heck, lefty’s don’t put truck-vaginas on their pickup to contrast with trucknutz, do they?

While I appreciate the concept as well as the next guy, I have no plans to add Air America to my AM dial.  Besides, it’s dangerous to drive when there is such a strong likelihood of falling asleep.

90 Days Rejected for Female Teacher’s Student Obsession

Given the harsh treatment of sex offenders, often viewed as inadequate by the multitudes who would rather they all be put to death immediately if not sooner, it’s difficult to explain why a female teacher from Staten Island would receive a recommendation of 90 days for her attempt to seduce an 11th grader.

According to this WABC account,


An arbitrator had recommended the [90 day unpaid suspension] penalty for 39-year-old Colleen McGraham, a tenured teacher at Staten Island’s New Dorp High School, who wondered in her blog in June 2005, “Will I ever get over this? Do I want to? I just love him so much.”

There was no physical relationship between McGraham and the student. Prosecutors said McGraham, who was 36 during the encounters in 2005, sent the 11th grader e-mails, called him and spoke to him in an attempt to seduce him. But the student instead reported McGraham to another teacher, who then told education officials.

Most of us have a really hard time comprehending how things like this happen, such obsessions being so far outside the realm of normalcy.  Had the teacher been male and the student female, there would be outrage.  But when the tables are turned, we don’t get the same sense of disgust, but more a matter of confusion.  At best, our refusal to accept the parity of the situation is latent sexism.  At worst, it’s denial that a woman can be a sexual predator.

In any event, the recommendation of a 90 day suspension never made it past the judge.


State Supreme Court Justice Sheila Abdus-Salaam said the arbitrator’s recommendation of a 90-day unpaid suspension was “irrational” and “violates a strong public policy” to protect children.

Abdus-Salaam said the arbitrator seemed motivated by the fact that there was never a physical relationship between the McGraham and the student, and the boy had gone to college and “moved on with his life.”

But the fact a relationship didn’t develop, despite the feelings McGraham expressed in her e-mails and blog entries, “may say more about the student’s maturity that the teacher’s ability to conduct herself appropriately,” the judge said.

It’s not that I have particular feelings about the punishment to be imposed on McGraham.  I’m just astounded by the shocking difference in treatment given her when compared to any man who would engage in the same conduct. 

I can’t wait to hear what the Feminist Law Professors have to say about this.  After all, I’m sure that they will be horribly offended that she was treated so daintily.

Spiderman, Spiderman, Climbing for the Environment

In a couple of hours, a man will climb a building somewhere in the City of New York.  Why?



Please join me at 9 am (LOCATION TO BE ANNOUNCED LATER TODAY.)  I will be there and happy to answer questions about my work and we’ll take it from there!  I am climbing with my bare hands, as a PEACEFUL way to create support for far greater and urgent action from world leaders on  global warming. Greenhouse gas emissions are still climbing. So am  I!!!


 But The Solution Is Simple:

 1 – Stop Cutting Down Trees. Plant More Trees.

 2 – Make Everything Energy Efficient.

 3 – Only Make Clean Energy.
All issues of grave concern.  But will climbing tall buildings bring attention to the cause, or bring cuffs to the wrist?  Or both? 

There’s two ways to look at stunts like this.  Some think it’s just awfully cool to watch someone scale the outside of a building (like a spider, perhaps?), while others believe that this is one individual engaging in behavior that’s risky to him and to anyone with the misfortune of standing below him.  Not to mention that public resources are used in stunts like this (think of all the cops standing around to keep people away), an allocation of resources that no daredevil is entitled to make.

I’m all for the cause, being the tree-hugger that I am.  And I am generally supportive of people acting to raise the consciousness of others about the need to protect the environment.  I just have a difficult time connecting up this act with the environment.  It’s a guy who like to climb up buildings announcing a purpose to justify the fact that he likes to climb up building.

I hope he doesn’t fall.  And I hope that there is some social benefit to this climb.  But I don’t really see it.  Expect to see him in handcuffs around 11:30 this morning, smiling.  Arraignment within 24 hours. Bail set at $1000? 

One tree lost for all the paperwork.