Author Archives: SHG

Will the Sky Fall Today on New York Justice?

When the New York Times runs an editorial with the headline, Repairing New York’s Justice System, my pulse quickens and breath grows short.  Could this be the one that finally deals with the wholesale absence of discovery, the use of flawed identifications to convict the innocent?  Maybe they will finally nail testilying cops to the wall?  Is it the death knell of the Rockefeller drug laws, putting mules in prison forever for a couple ounces of dope?

Then comes the opening line:

New York’s justice system has fallen into crisis. Yet Albany is not dealing with three big problems dragging the system down — missing judicial pay raises, glaring deficiencies in indigent defense services and the swelling workload overwhelming Family Court.

Sigh.  I know it’s been a slow couple of weeks in the criminal law field.  No hot new murders.  No major new issues before the Supremes.  But this is just pathetic.

In the broadest sense, New York’s justice system has fallen into crisis, though it’s been happening for as long as I’ve been practicing law and will likely be the same on the day I die.  It’s a perpetual battle and it always will be.  We will never achieve a perfect system.

But crisis?  The Times raises two issues that have been on the burner for years, and are not significantly different today than they were yesterday.  Or last year.  Of all the many things that are wrong with the Justice system, these hardly rise to the level of crisis. 

The Times isn’t wrong about the first and second, though the thirds reflect something of a misunderstanding of the problem.  There are underutilized Supreme Court judges around the state, given the drop in crime.  Personnel can be shifted to cover the gaps, and systems can be better organized to make things move more effectively.  Also, add 39 more judges and you need 39 more courtrooms and staff. 

My issue here is that there are problems with the system of justice, and there is always going to be plenty of need for improvement as we strive to figure out how to deliver more perfect justice, a goal that will never be achieved.  But to make every burp and pothole in the system into another claim that the sky is falling is needlessly and unhelpfully hysterical. 

Judges salaries don’t rise to the level of consequence as convicting the innocent.  A statewide indigent defense system, which is primarily a cost-saving plan, is important but will still take years to implement, and will have its own problems along the way.  And 39 more judges in a juvenile justice system that is rife with internal systemic error is hardly as important as participants who take personal interest in the children they exist to help rather than the rote application of rules.

The system is not in crisis today any more than it was in crisis yesterday.  It just has problem that can, and should, be dealt with.  But let’s save the chicken little act for when it counts. 

Fascination with Crime and Criminals

The second question a criminal defense lawyers is asked at a cocktail party is, “Do you have any big cases?”  They want to know whether we represent somebody who made headlines, some criminal they’ve heard about.  The question is really a two-part inquiry, as they are asking us whether we are sufficiently high profile that they would “know” us, and whether we touch notoriety through our clients.

While we live in a celebrity culture, a significant oddity is that criminals have joined the ranks of the famous.  Unlike Paris Hilton, whose celebrity comes from nowhere, criminals hold a fascination for people who seem not to recognize that they may not be fascinating at all. 

This piece in the ABA Journal Magazine announces the National Museum of Crime and Punish­ment in Washington, D.C.  It seems a natural step down the road of glorifying criminal culture.  Not glorifying crime as much as our fascination with crime.  While I can’t imagine why anyone would want to go to it, I’m sure that there will be plenty of visitors.

While there are some criminals whose allure has held firm over the years, like John Dillinger or Bonnie & Clyde, and certainly Al Capone,  there is little about them that would drive me to see artifacts of their crimes.  Similarly, I can’t imagine standing in line to view an exhibit about “constitutional rights and notable U.S. Supreme Court rul­ings, including Miranda v. Ari­zona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966).”  Sounds awfully sexy, doesn’t it?

This culture of celebrity has resulted in some peculiar problems for criminal defense lawyers, particularly the younger ones who have their first opportunity to take on a high-profile case.  The legal issues are usually nothing out of the ordinary.  When a crime lands on the front page of the New York Post, the criminal suddenly has leverage.  Family members will try to use that leverage to get a lawyer to take on the case at a greatly reduced fee, or possibly for free, in order to get the publicity that comes along with the profile.

On a few occasions, this pofile has served to take a run-of-the-mill lawyer and turn him into a star of sorts.  I vividly remember the Bernie Goetz case, making Barry Slotnick into a household name.  At least for a while, long enough to get paying clients into his office so that he could cover the cost of the Goetz trial. 

But rarely does the high profile case serve to help the budding lawyer.  First, there is a never ending stream of them, and today’s front page case is tomorrow’s yawner.  The neophyte lawyer is still stuck on the free case, but his image has already been forgotten.  To the media, the lawyers aren’t the main event.  As I read coverage of high profile cases, I immediately look to see who the lawyer is.  Most of the time, the story doesn’t even include the lawyer’s name.  He’s an afterthought at best.

Having had the pleasure of representing some high-profile defendants, I can unequivocally tell you that they are no more fascinating than anyone else.  They are, however, far more time-consuming and demanding.  They buy into their publicity, believing that they are indeed quite important.  In fact, to some extent, our fascination with crime drives some of it, with people who are particularly uninteresting finding their moment in the limelight, their 15 minutes of fame, through crime.  Sick but true.

Some defendants actually court the attention.  They love it.  They want to talk to the media, to be courted by reporters.  When the offers roll in to be on some newsmagazine, they drool at the opportunity.  When I explain that this is not in their best interest, that they will not come off as a star, but rather as a creep at best, they get angry.  Who is this lawyer to steal their moment of fame?  They believe that they can convince the world of their importance, it not their innocence, not realizing that this is all about editing for entertainment. 

Some lawyers are right on board with their clients, thrilled at the prospect of sitting next to their very own famous criminal.  Who cares if the defendant is eviscerated on camera, as long as they look good.  That chance to be the hit of the cocktail party is hard to pass up.

But don’t let the glare of the camera lights blind you from reality.  Very few cases are museum worthy.  Very few defendants are interesting.  Most are painfully pedestrian.  They are real people with very real problems, exacerbated by the attention, but hardly the types of people who will ever walk down a red carpet. 

So when I’m asked the cocktail party question, I answer the same.  Yes, I have big cases.  Every person I represent is a big case to me.  But not one of them is someone who deserves celebrity.  They just aren’t very fascinating.  And they certainly have no place in a museum.

Bad Boys, Bad Boys, Whatcha gonna do…

When I tackled the issue raised by Eugene Volokh’s praise of a gun-toting good samaritan, I expected some of the RKBA crowd to come out from under the rock.  They didn’t disappoint.

These are the ones who cried man-tears when they heard the news of Charlton Heston’s death.  These are the ones who raised every example of fallacious reasoning in furtherance of their agenda, that the select few who are worthy have a constitutional right to keep and bear arms.  They are a pugnacious crowed, edging for a fight and trying to see who they can sucker in to their well-honed, but logically insipid, traps. 

It was good for a laugh, but more importantly, these guys are as self-serving in their position as any other single-issue interest group.  There position is clear:  the right to own and carry a concealed weapon is constitutionally protected, as long as you are one of the good guys.  They, of course, get to define who are the good guys. 

In support of their position, they have a plethora of blogs and websites dedicated to stories about other good guy gun toters who shoot and kill bad guy criminals.  Each story proves their point, about how a good guy having a gun kills a bad guy, thus saving themselves, others and humanity from the criminals. 

They challenge their opponents to prove otherwise.  The fallacy is that it’s their single-issue agenda, leaving those who don’t maintain a constant vigil for the opposing viewpoint, that good people with guns sometimes get shot, that children in homes with guns sometimes shoot themselves or their friends, that the outcome is not always a heart-warming story. 

There may be legitimate studies somewhere that show the harm to benefit ratio of arming citizens, but I am not aware of them.  I have some doubts that citizens armed with concealed weapons shooting people is such a wonderful thing.  One story, even a thousand stories, without a balanced study of the full picture, will not persuade me otherwise.

But this is still playing in their sandbox.  They can demand that some knucklehead like me prove them wrong, but I don’t have to.  I don’t go to their home and challenge them, and when they come here they don’t get the right to make demands of anybody.  If they don’t like it, they can go away.  I won’t mind.

The problem, that they have yet to grasp, is what happens when their dream comes true.  Should DC v. Heller produce the anticipated result of proclaiming the 2d Amendment to state a fundamental individual right to keep and bear arms, they better build a bigger clubhouse.  Arguing for years that this was what our forefathers intended, they have dedicated their lives to their guns, secure in the belief that they would finally be proven the true Americans they always knew they were.

And what of all the others?  “What others,” they ask?  Well, there’s going to be some new kids at the gun shop.  Let’s consider the basic universe of new gun owners, shall we?

First, there are the “good guys” (your definition) who will eventually reach their boiling point, pull out the Glock to teach a driving lesson to that fellow in the sports car who just cut them off.  He’s now a bad guy, but he was a good guy when he bought the gun.

Then there nervous people, reading too much into the front page stories of rapes, assaults, killings, whatever.  They put that sweet little thing into their purse just in case.  They don’t want to be a statistic, now do they?  But they aren’t quite clear when they should pull it out, and on any given day, feeling a tad jumpy in the face of last night’s news story, blow a hole in the face of the fellow asking for directions to the nearest Wal-Mart. 

Or the off-shoot, when they pull out the pee-shooter but can’t bear to pull the trigger, and have it turned back on them.

And then there’s still the problem of dopey children playing with the found gun at home.  The Constitution doesn’t mention a requirement for a gun-safe anywhere.  And kids will be kids.  And parents will be knuckleheads.  “I only left it on the dresser for 2 minutes when I went out to see if the mail came,” the weeping mother said.

Notice that I’m not even coming close to the really hard issues, such as why Martha Stewart, convicted felon, doesn’t have a need, or a right, to protect herself.  I hear that Martha’s got a vicious temper.  Would you want to work for an armed Martha?

It’s not that I disagree with the anticipated Heller ruling, but that all the well-trained, competent gun afficionados are going to have one heck of a time explaining how this isn’t a potential problem.  As it stands, the license to carry a concealed weapon can be limited to those individuals who are competent to do so. at least in theory.  But once that limitation can no longer stand in the face of a fundamental constitutional right, the universe of potential concealed weapon carriers expands exponentially. 

I can’t imagine that we’ll be watching daily gunfights at the OK Corral, except where they would happen anyway.  But we will be reading about a lot more shooting stories because there will be a lot more guns on the street.  Even if they are only in the hands of good people (until taken away or good people become bad people), to have a gun is to potentially use a gun.  Will these same people be arguing to restrict gun ownership?  Their arguments now portend poorly should their wish be granted.

What you packing, grandma? 

Toying With Children’s Emotions About Death

When I first read this post by Dallas criminal defense lawyer Robert Guest, it evoked a huge shrug.  Since I’m not a DWI lawyer, the word MADD alone doesn’t cause me to have convulsions.  But the heart of the matter, as explained in Radley Balko’s Agitator post, struck me as not being such a terrible idea.

Many juniors and seniors were driven to tears – a few to near hysterics – May 26 when a uniformed police officer arrived in several classrooms to notify them that a fellow student had been killed in a drunken-driving accident.

The officer read a brief eulogy, placed a rose on the deceased student’s seat, then left the class members to process their thoughts and emotions for the next hour.

The program, titled “Every 15 Minutes,” was designed by Mothers Against Drunk Driving. Its title refers to the frequency in which a person somewhere in the country dies in an alcohol-related traffic accident.

This described a dramatization, as no one was in fact killed, crafted to make a point, that in a moment of stupidity, a young life could be lost.  I know the “every 15 minutes” claim to be utterly false, but being the parent of an 18 year old, I also know their sense of invulnerability and obliviousness to threat until after the unthinkable happens.  Teenagers live in a cocoon that bad things will never happen to them, no matter what risks they take.  As a parent, it scares me.

But after reading further, after thinking further, I realized my error.  My first reaction, that there was no downside to teaching a critical lesson.  Would I encourage, even accept, teenage drinking and driving?  Certainly not.  So what’s wrong with smacking a kid with an understanding of tragedy to make sure the point is clear?

This was a well orchestrated charade.  It was intended to have the impact of making half a high school believe a friend had died, and it did.  Teenagers have a fragile understanding of life and death to begin with.  That’s part of the problem in trying to teach kids about serious consequences.  But this was planned for maximum impact.  And it served its purpose.

This MADD plan brought teenagers to the brink of hysteria and emotional despair, and then pushed them over the edge.  It went too far.  The police, who executed the scheme, traumatized these students in the name of safety.  In the name of protecting them from harm, they caused harm. 


Though the deception left some teens temporarily confused and angry, if it makes even one student think twice before getting behind the wheel of a car while intoxicated, it is worth the price, said California Highway Patrol Officer Eric Newbury, who orchestrates the program at local high schools.

Too simplistic.  I don’t fault the officer for wanting to save a student from making a tragic mistake.  But to cause them immediate, intentional emotional trauma is not worth the price.  Moreover, who made it this police officer’s call to decide what price should be paid by another parent’s child?

There is a civil cause of action called “intentional infliction of emotional distress.”  The reason why this exists is because it is deemed wrong to do this, to deliberately cause psychological harm to another person.  This scheme deliberately harmed children, and it was meant to do so in the name of a greater good.  But the choice of whether a child should be harmed in the name of a good deemed sufficiently greater does not belong to the cops or to a groups of mothers with a dedicated agenda that places their issue above everyone else’s.

The lesson from Robert is how overly dedicated single-interest groups such as MADD, superficially doing something that we can all agree upon, become so myopic as to ignore the harm they cause in furtherance of their agenda.  I appreciate being taught that lesson. 

The lesson about the police and the officials of a public school, all employees of our government, forcing children to be unwilling participants in this scheme, is different.  Both are endowed with substantial power, particularly over children, under the belief that they will exercise this power with sound discretion and in the best interest of the children. 

It is becoming increasingly apparent that one of the gravest threats to the welfare of children are the cops and school officials themselves, whether by usurping the right of a parent to determine how far to go in providing guidance to their child, and manipulating young minds to adhere to their vision of morality upon pain of death.

No doubt the police officers, the school administrators, the mothers of MADD, all believe their choice to be correct and worthy.  I don’t care what they believe.  Raising my child is not a democracy, and they don’t get a vote.  I will not defer to the lowest common denominator when it comes to making decisions about my child.

An American in Paris

Every weekend, Dan Hull changes the title of his blawg, What about Clients?, to What about Paris?.  Dan is very international.  I want to be international too.

When I read about some Biglaw firm opening an office in some exotic locale, I become depressed.  I want to practice law on the continent.  I love Paris.  I love London.  Madrid, not so much, though Fuengirola is fun.  But I’m stuck here.  Criminal defense doesn’t seem to translate well into romance languages.  Go figure.

I’ve mused with the notion of opening up an office in Paris, either atop or next door to a patisserie.  No, I don’t speak French, but then I don’t speak Spanish well either, and it hasn’t hurt me with my clients from the south.  This would prevent me from appearing at the Palais de Justice, conveniently located on the Île de la Cité in central Paris.  It’s where French justice is bought and sold.

But what of all those Parisians who come to the United States and find themselves inadvertently engaged in the American legal system?  Don’t they deserve representation?  I would be there for them, to guide them through the Byzantine system that has brought down so many of the unwary. 

While corporate work flourishes across the pond, criminal defense has yet to make much headway (aside from Joe Tacopina’s Milan office, conveniently located in his grandmother’s basement).  I don’t know of any criminal defense lawyer who has found a home in Europe.  Sure, there’s the Hague and the International Criminal Court, which pays slightly less than a court appointed attorney in Mississippi New York and isn’t recognized by the Bush White House.  In case you haven’t notice, the Euro keeps going up, and I would still have to pay for my eclair.

Why should corporate law wonks get to have all the fun?  And you wonder why the French hate Americans.

But as I’ve served my time in New York, and harbor the secret dream of retiring to Aix-en-Provence someday, I’m ready to pack my bags.  So if anybody needs a New York criminal defense lawyer to fill that glaring legal gap in their Paris office, give me a call. 

Practical Blawgosphere: More Ebb Than Flow?

Granted, there hasn’t been a lot of criminal law news around lately, save the Fieger trial that Norm Pattis has been following (in a Gerry Spence-obsessive sort of way).  But three days of no verdict is hard to post about.

The academics keep writing, though they steer clear of the practical blawgosphere as much as possible.  As one lawprof recently told me when I asked him why he neglected the practical blawgosphere in discussing a particular issue,


Generally, I try to avoid polluting my pure ivory tower head with practitioner thoughts, lest I come up with something of use to the world.

He’s a very funny guy.  But there’s been a definite ebb around the practical blawgosphere lately.  Mark Bennett,  Texas Tornado, has been pretty quiet.  Gideon’s had very little to say, other than to let me know when he thinks I’m making a big deal out of nothing.  And one of the best blawgers around, Anne Reed, is almost awol since the new year.  It breaks my heart.

What gives?   

I suspect that there’s a wave of burnout happening amongst the trench people.  Without any big news, something to grab their attention and make them want to write, they’re getting tired of sitting at the computer.  It’s not like the spirit of Kevin O’Keefe resides in each of us.  Some need extra motivation to get their mojo working.

With that in mind, I pose a challenge to my brethren in the practical blawgosphere.  Unless you want to see the lawprofs and nutjobs (note that they are two separate groups in my mind) seize control, fight.  No, you don’t have to post as much as I do.  I just like to write.  It’s my therapy, but it doesn’t have to be yours.  Just don’t let inertia take hold.  Once you walk away from the computer, it’s hard to get back into the flow.

The practical blawgosphere is one of the best things that’s happened to the discussion of criminal law.  We’ve sparred with one another, agreed with one another, but expanded the understanding and debate far beyond anything that existed in the old days.  New lawyers can come online and learn from the mistakes that old lawyers made.  My personal depth of understanding has increased enormously thanks to the insights of others.

Don’t let this fade away.

I’ve watched as some have silently disappeared from the scene, finding the burden of post too much.  Others have learned that the payback for blawging can’t be counted in cash as easily as they hoped.  Still others are so devoid of anything worth reading as to be unworthy of being called a blawg (I received an email yesterday from some twinkie who is the “editor” of one that I criticized for this reason, informing me that she was removing Simple Justice from their blogroll. Nuts.)  What will be left?

I know that you people care about the world, about the law and about people.  Everyday brings new thoughts and ideas worth pursuing.  Remember what Dan Quayle said, “what a waste it is to lose one’s mind or not to have a mind is being very wasteful. How true that is.”

Don’t be wasteful.

10 Commandments Redux in Ohio

The good news is that this he didn’t put up a Farrah Fawcett cheesecake poster in his courtroom.  The bad news is that he might have been smarter if he had.

According to this AP report via New York Lawyer,

MANSFIELD, Ohio (AP) – The American Civil Liberties Union says an Ohio judge has again posted the Ten Commandments in his courtroom, defying rulings that he not display them.

The group on Thursday asked a federal court to hold Richland County Common Pleas Judge James DeWeese in contempt.

In 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a lower court’s decision that a framed poster of the commandments in DeWeese’s court violated the Constitution.

DeWeese denies he’s displaying the Ten Commandments now and accuses the ACLU of attempting to silence speech.

While there is currently a poster in his courtroom that includes the commandments, DeWeese says it illustrates a debate about philosophies that affect the handling of criminal cases.
What is it with this guy?  Is it not sufficient that he’s a judge, wears a robe, gets to pass judgment on other people? 

Before any fanatics decide this is a perfect opportunity to explain how the United States is a Christian country, or how the 10 Commandments form the foundation of all laws, or how we would all be better off if we were to honor God’s laws, there is one point to make.  This fellow is a judge, and his day job is to apply and interpret the laws of the State of Ohio.  He can believe as deeply in his religion as he wants, and it’s up to the good residents of Richmond County to decide whether they trust him to serve. 

If he wants to drive him in a car with the 10 Commandments emblazoned across his hood, that’s his business.  If he wants to paint them across the front of his house, whatever.  But he can’t post them in the courtroom.  It’s not his choice, and this attempt to circumvent the law is just plain crazy.

Keeping religion out of government, and particularly out of the courtroom, should never be this difficult. 

As I’m occasionally told that I tend to be critical without offering any constructive alternative, I submit this as a better choice for Judge DeWeese as proof of God’s existence.

Farrah Fawcett

Talk about showing my age. 

Mel Weiss to WSJ: Unfair and Demeaning

A lawyer for Mel Weiss is miffed, perhaps rightfully so.  And if he’s miffed, I’m miffed. 

I posted about the more than 275 letters (the number varies with each account, so I’m sticking with the original 275 number) submitted in support of Mel’s efforts to humanize himself to California District Court Judge John Walter.  My post was based on Dan Slater’s  WSJ post.  Now, Slater is under attack by Kenneth White, one of Mel’s lawyers, who saw Slater’s post the same way I did, as damning Mel Weiss with faint praise.


But your selective description of the letters seems calculated to belittle Mr. Weiss’s supporters and to sensationalize his position and their support, not to describe that support fairly. By choosing to highlight two isolated references to minor instances of kindness – one related to a watch, another to a pair of boots – you clearly seek to portray the testimonials as a whole as banal or comical. A fair reading of the letters would not permit that interpretation.

Banal is the perfect description.  I wish I had thought of it first.  White wrote to Slater to challenge his post that belittled the support shown Mel and, he argued, intentionally subjected the defense to ridicule:


Your emphasis on the boots and the watch appears calculated to encourage ridicule instead – precisely the sort of ridicule you drew in comments to your posts. I note that your posts have also drawn hostility and even overt prejudice — such as the commenter who describes Mr. Weiss as a “Holocaust industry shyster.” That is the foreseeable result of your chosen spin.

And indeed, Slater’s post did seem calculated to encourage ridicule.  White demanded a correction:


Though your emphasis has been unfair and demeaning, it is not too late to remedy that injustice. Please consider a supplemental post highlighting some of the other letters that more fairly represent Mr. Weiss’s support. 

Jamie Heller (notably not Dan Slater) posted White’s letter in full at the WSJ law blog.  That’s not an insignificant concession on the part of the Wall Street Journal.  Of course, it’s not a retraction either.  But this is what happens when money butts heads with money. 

In the introduction to the publication of Ken White’s letter, Mel is described as a “plaintiffs lawyer.”  Those two words are the WSJ equivalent to calling him the scum of the earth.  There is no more demeaning epithet amongst the WSJ crowd than to represent plaintiffs.

But their Murdoch perspective aside, the handling of Mel Weiss’ sentencing letters left the door open for ridicule, and this comes as quite a surprise given how well Ben Branfman did on the plea negotiation. 

Lesson 1 in media relations for lawyers is that you have no control over what the media will say about your client.  Ever.  Mel’s lawyers should have known, must have known, that the letters submitted on Mel’s behalf would be subject to scrutiny by a less than adoring media.  With this in mind, the handling of support letters, straddling the useful and the unhelpful, the important and the inconsequential, is critical. 

It’s hard to write a helpful letter in support of a defendant at sentence.  It’s not the sort of thing one does every day, so most people have not perfected their technique.  Not only must the lawyers provide guidance as to how to craft the letter, and direct writers to focus on information that conveys the sort of things that will help their cause, but they must scrutinize the letters written before they are provided the Court to make sure that they aid the cause. 

This sounds highly manipulative, and indeed it is.  But it’s not that the content of the letters aren’t true and accurate.  Just that the letters, like everything else involved in defending someone, are sought to further a purpose.  The government’s purpose is to inform the court about the crime.  The defense’s purpose is to inform the court about the human being and the good things he’s done.  The defense has no obligation to submit letters showing the defendant to be a creep.

So the proffer of letters showing Mel to be banal (see, I got to use the word too!) isn’t Dan Slater’s fault, and the fact that the door to ridicule was opened by offering such examples of good deeds as buying watches or womens boots falls on the shoulder of the defense lawyers.  They should have known better.

It’s possible that Ken White had no control over the submission of these letter, and that they were sent by supporters directly to Judge Walter on Mel’s behalf.  If so, then Mel deserves a refund of his legal fee.  No competent defense lawyer has letter writers submit directly to the court.  While letters should be addressed to the judge, they are sent to the lawyers, who then vet the letters for content. 

Submitting letters directly to the judge is facial malpractice, and courting unbelievable disaster.  I’ve seen people who defendants believe to be their beloved friends write scathing letters of hatred about them.  I’ve seen letters from people who include lines like, “for a jew, he’s a good Christian.”  You never know what people are going to write until you see the letters.  Suffice it to say, some letters never see the light of day.  Based upon the letter links in Slater’s post, it appears that the letters went through the attorneys, as they should have.

Given the fact that Weiss had more than 275 letters of support, many from very prominent individuals (which is another common mistake, where people think that prominence, rather than substantive information, is more helpful in humanizing a defendant), was it necessary to include two letters that made Mel appear particularly banal?  Would the judge have said to himself, “Hey, he’s only got 273 letters, so I guess he doesn’t have enough friends?”

Mel Weiss carved out a very significant niche for himself in the law, gathering some powerful friends as well as some very powerful enemies.  It’s brought him substantial wealth, but it came at a price.  Mel is not some old-guard, gin-drinking white shoe lawyer.  He was a street fighter, and he apparently wasn’t above buying his way into the cases he wanted to control. 

We can only hope that Mel did some good with the cash he took off the top of class actions, since the unnamed class of plaintiffs rarely got enough to buy themselves a beer to celebrate their victory.  I’m not denigrating the purpose of class action suits, but there is a stink to the fees they generate when contrasted to the damages spread amongst the great unwashed class. 

Locally, Mel Weiss has done little to help others.  He’s never seen at local charity events, nor is his name listed amongst the donors of worthy local charities.  Since he’s my neighbor, I know.  But that doesn’t mean that Mel doesn’t give to others, to those he deems more worthy.  That’s a personal choice, and while Mel could do a little something for those close to home, I don’t begrudge anyone their personal choice in where to spread their love. 

While I haven’t read through all the letters submitted (though I have read the initial crop, which should reflect the best letters available), they don’t impress.  They speak to Mel’s “commitment” to represent the poor and downtrodden in class actions.  Of course, Mel was very well paid for that commitment, reducing its significance to less than nothing.  Indeed, this “commitment” was the root of his indictment.  Didn’t anyone think of that?

The first dozen letter contain conclusory assertions of Mel’s generous and charitable nature, but fail to note a single instance in support of the conclusion.  This is a problem.  Plenty of hyperbole, but essentially no substance whatsoever.  Way in the back, there are letters that provide detail of Mel’s acts of charity, including one from Beau Dietl (who has a way of being gratuitously self-aggrandizing even as he tries his darndest to say something nice about someone else).  But letters stuck way in the back tend to add mere weight, not substance, to the submission.

Notably, Ken White’s letter to the Wall Street Journal really doesn’t help matters, as it makes the point as clearly as Dan Slater’s post.


By choosing to highlight two isolated references to minor instances of kindness – one related to a watch, another to a pair of boots – you clearly seek to portray the testimonials as a whole as banal or comical. A fair reading of the letters would not permit that interpretation. You could have chosen to emphasize Harvard Law School professor Arthur Miller’s comments about how Mr. Weiss’s efforts improved access to justice for the poor, or Judge Stanley Sporkin’s comments about how Mr. Weiss’s efforts were an essential supplement to inadequate SEC regulatory activities.

It’s hard to say for sure what Mel Weiss has done for others with the wealth he accumulated from his class action suits.  He’s helped personal friends, and it appears that he’s been a supporter of some charities despite the scarcity of detail.  Beyond that, who knows.

Lesson number 2 in media relations for lawyers.  Never send a letter you don’t want to see in print.  Whether Ken White has helped Mel’s cause in stirring this up again is hard to say.  Personally, I wouldn’t have done it.

The Late Night Email

Norm Pattis, known around the Connecticut courts as Mr. Communication (as well as a few other choice names), raises a timely question about how much of good thing will drive a lawyer nuts.

I’ve noticed a tendency among clients to send emails at all hours of the day and night. I regularly get two or three emails sent between midnight and two a.m. from one client. Another sends them shortly after 6 a.m. The emails ask question upon question about things sometimes only marginally related to the litigation I am handling. Sometimes they want to know what I did the day before and when I plan to do a number of other things on their behalf.

The emails are often a sword through my heart, slaying any sense of professionalism.

I’ve notice the same thing.  Recently, I wake up in the morning to find a half dozen emails from the same client in my mailbox.  Questions, comments or sheer emotive angst smack me in the face, sometimes showing a full circle between the first and last email of a sleepless night.

The problem is not that they use email as a means of communication, but that email is so easily used to express every momentary tinge of pain, fear and concern.  Tossing off an email to revisit an hour long discussion of strategy, asking, “can you explain it to me again,” is problematic.  Not because we can’t ignore the panoply of emotions, but because we’re not the type of lawyer who ignores clients.  I think Norm feels as I do, that we owe our clients communication about their lives.  But where does it stop?

The telephone used to be the lawyer’s nightmare, when clients would call a dozen times a day to express every thought that pops into their head.  I would explain that if I spend all day on the phone with each client (or family member of the client) who calls, then no work would ever get done and their quest for justice would come to a screeching halt.  They didn’t want that, right?

Then came email, a way for them to express themselves without necessarily precluding my ability to perform actual work.  It held so much promise.  So very much.  Until clients realized that they could type a dozen emails an hour.  All things in moderation is a great rule of thumb, but moderation is relative to the perceived critical importance of any particular email. 

Norm asks for suggestions in how to handle the deluge of late night emails he receives.  It’s painful for the communicative lawyer to not respond, but it’s even more painful to address each and every one.  My practice is to now respond once to the bunched groups of emails to the extent responses are truly called for.  When the emails reflect ongoing angst, then I try to respond calmly and focus them back on the issue at hand.  When the emails ask for detailed responses to issues in their case that have no been discussed, then I respond that we can and should sit down for a discussion and make an appointment. 

When the emails seek to repeat discussion already had, once if not thrice, then I tell them that nothing has changed since our last discussion, and we need to spend our energy working toward results, not revisiting every decision to the point of paralysis.  These are really comfort emails, assuaging their midnight fears of pending disaster.  It’s perfectly understandable, given what I do, that my clients feel this way.  Yet their fear doesn’t make the problem go away, or further my efforts to help them.  If these calls for calm are viewed as cathartic exercises, and the client accepts the idea that we really are doing our job while they stay up late and obsess, we can survive together.

It’s hard, if not impossible, to balance the client’s therapeutic needs with his legal needs.  But I’m a lawyer, not a therapist.  Nor does the client share responsibility with me for being the lawyer, as if my every move requires the client’s understanding and approval.  I try to keep my clients abreast of everything they need to know, and most are appreciative and more than satisfied with my communication.  But there will always be some who will sit awake at night shooting off emails.

Did that help any Norm?  Probably not.  It’s the same old story with a new delivery mechanism.  You know as well as I do that it’s just part of the job.

A Civics Lesson From a Young Woman

Avery Doninger has had quite a ride through the courts.  We learn from what she has learned.  The following is an essay she wrote and has used for her college applications, explaining what this has meant to her:


Scales of Justice
By Avery Doninger


This year I have come to understand why liberty and justice are symbolized with scales. There is much to be balanced and decisions can weigh heavy. Since May 2007, a series of good and bad decisions, made not only by me, but also by others, has led me on a journey filled with risk and rich in learning opportunities.


The first decision that I made reflected positively on my character. I invested myself fully in student government and worked diligently in my elected positions. Frustrated over scheduling snags and short-notice cancellation of a school event (Jamfest), I went home and posted a blog on an obscure Live Journal page. In the blog I encouraged people to petition our administration – a good decision; it was political speech. The bad decision was the opening line, “Jamfest is cancelled due to the douchebags in central office.” Not my finest moment.


Along with other student leaders I rallied community support for Jamfest and the event was rescheduled. However, my decision to use an unsavory term was still sitting out there on the scales of justice, waiting to be weighed. A month after the scheduling was resolved, an administrator stumbled across my blog. Consequently, the principal punished me. She said I had to apologize to the superintendent, tell my mother, step down from all leadership positions, and withdraw my candidacy for secretary of the Class of 2008 (I had been secretary for three years). This was when the lessons from my civics class became increasingly relevant to my life. I agreed to the principal’s first two requirements, but I refused the third.


The school administrator’s had their own scales of justice – my opinion did not tip the balance, and the punishment was final. Efforts to negotiate with the administrators were refused. A write-in campaign by my peers (I won a plurality of votes) was ignored; and “Team Avery, Support LSM Freedom of Speech” t-shirts were confiscated (illegal according to Tinker). As I researched civil rights and school law, my scale tipped, and I filed a lawsuit. This was a hard decision; I’ve never been in trouble: I am an engaged student, yet I did use an unsavory word. My mother also put my word choice on her scale of justice. She found my comment rude, sophomoric, and below the standards she has set. My mother’s verdict, as one commentator put it, “Avery, you’re grounded and we’re going to the Supreme Court” (Colin McEnroe, October 2, 2007, WTIC am 1080).


At age 16 I became a citizen fully engaged in the democratic process. I filed for injunctive relief: not suing for money but for justice. I testified for four hours in federal court; I have done tons of print and broadcast interviews; I have spoken to large audiences about my story and the First Amendment rights; and I was the poster child for Poets and Writers for Free Speech. I have learned the big cases decided by the Supreme Court as well as how my case is distinguished. Most important, however, are the lessons that have become apart of me.


I believe in democracy. I believe in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. I believe that each citizen is responsible for participating in the maintenance of democracy by challenging government officials when they overreach. The principal accused me of a failing to be a good citizen. I disagree. Apathy and passivity are poor citizenship. Rallying students and the community to petition the government is good citizenship. I failed at vocabulary, not citizenship. However, the First Amendment does not limit protection to those with sophisticated vocabularies (though I will not make the error of rudeness again).


Democracy is a gift that Americans have inherited, but it requires maintenance and vigilance. Democracy needs to be retained at the lowest levels if we are to have a democracy at the highest levels. If as citizens we refuse to defend liberty in our own backyards, how do we expect to bring democracy to Iraq or Korea or any place suffering under tyranny? Civil liberties are eroded slowly when citizens don’t bother to insist on challenging unconstitutional practices. Citizens, particularly students who are the next generation of leaders, must be willing to take on the responsibility of maintaining and protecting democracy while enjoying the rights democracy affords.


Eventually, the scales of justice will determine whether students have speech rights off campus in the age of the Internet and whether there is a difference between shouldn’t have said and didn’t have the right to say. No matter the outcome in court, I am proud that I was willing to engage in the democratic and judicial processes. I will continue to defend civil rights, to think critically, and to consider the ramifications of my word choices. While I don’t plan to live my life according to bumper stickers, I am going to think globally and act locally.