Author Archives: SHG

Ambulance Chasing, Criminal Law Edition

Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett has given new meaning to the old phrase, the meter’s running.


There’s a criminal attorney in Houston (I’ll call him “Ollie”) who is a really busy guy. Ollie reportedly has a cab driver who waits outside the jail in the wee hours of the morning when people are released on bond and refers them to Ollie for representation. Ollie charges a nominal fee ($500 or so to start); he will even fill out the clients’ retainer checks for them.

This is a new one on me.  I’ve heard of plenty of schemes to get clients, but having a cab sitting out front to whisk potential clients to your office is good one.  I’m not sure if it would work in Manhattan.  There are just too many cabs floating around to make it productive.  But now that Mark’s put it on the radar, I wouldn’t be surprised if we get our own Ollie by the end of the week.

There are any number of fine, upstanding lawyers in the Big Apple who will do anything short of pro bono to get their hands on the quick case (with its inherent quick plea).  But one story comes foremost to mind.

A former prosecutor in the Bronx walked up to me outside 100 Centre Street one day to say hello and inform me that he was now available for referrals.  I had a rather large conspiracy case with him when he was a tough guy on the Grand Concourse, under the tutelage of Eddy Friedenthal and Nester “the Molester” Ferraro, the head of narcotics for the Bronx.  (D.A., not the other side).  As a prosecutor, this kid was one obnoxious little jerk.  Not effective, mind you, but smarmy and smug, one of those grinning untrustworthy fools whose voice was squeak and crack as he tried to come up with some reason why it was okay for him to break the law when it wasn’t for my clients.

Standing there, stunned by the fact that this dweeb whom I found repulsive was now trying to stick his entire head up my butt to make a dime, he asked me if he could pray upon my experience and ask a question.  “What?”  “Is it a good idea to pay the hotdog guy in front of the courthouse $100 for every case sends me?”

I nearly fell on the sidewalk.  This little, prematurely bald, pompous weenie was absolutely serious.  It took me a few minutes to stop laughing and catch my breath.

“Is that how you thought criminal defense lawyers found their clients?”

“Uh.  Well…Yeah.  I guess.”

“Well, you can always do that, but you’re only gonna get the crap cases since I know another guy who’s giving him $250 per case.”  I feel terrible about admitting that I told him this, but it was just too funny to pass up.

There are some rather insidious schemes around to “get” clients.  There are the “MCC vultures” who troll the attorney visiting area at the federal lock-up to find prisoners feeling neglected with offers to get them out within the week.  There is even one lawyer, quite well known around the New York courthouses, who tells post-sentence narcotics prisoners that for a half million dollars, he can “arrange” for their freedom.  How this fellow manages to stay alive is beyond me.

Let’s face facts.  Lawyers need clients.  Clients don’t have a clue who is good and who is lying to them through their teeth.  At the very best, the client knows results, which often have little to do with the quality of lawyering they receive.  Get a good result on a garbage case and you’re a genius.  Get a great result on a very difficult case and the client is disappointed because he didn’t get an apology from the cops.  That’s the nature of the work.

But it’s rife with opportunity for the unscrupulous and dishonest.  I’ve often told myself that I could be rich if only I wasn’t so darn honest.  When I see a great case go to a lawyer who I know to be a buffoon, it breaks my heart.  But that too is the nature of the business.  Now, I’m going to wonder whether the client had to pay his own cab fare?

Risky Business: Chinese Lawyers Fighting for Rights

In the broader scheme of things, American lawyers risk little by taking bold stands on issue of civil rights.  Singapore is riskier, but only if you call a judge a prostitute.  But as this New York Times article shows, Chinese lawyers have it tough.


BEIJING — Two prominent human rights lawyers have lost their licenses after volunteering to defend Tibetans charged in the violent anti-China protests that erupted in March. The decision comes as Chinese authorities are tightening scrutiny over dissidents in advance of the Olympics in August.

The two lawyers, Teng Biao and Jiang Tianyong, are known for taking on politically contentious cases, including those alleging official abuses of human rights. Reached on Tuesday night, Mr. Teng said he learned last week that judicial authorities had renewed the license of every lawyer in his firm, except his own.

Having done some cross-border work involving lawyers in China, most aren’t held in high esteem by the good people who need them over there.  They are viewed as tools of the government, worthless from the perspective of how lawyers are viewed here. 

But these two lawyers, Teng and Jiang, have engaged in some risky business by fighting for the rights of Tibetans.  China has not been kind to Tibetans, and no doubt will not be kind to Chinese who aid and abet any people they’ve chosen to oppress.  How many American lawyers would be willing to take this sort of risk?


Lawyers are increasingly at the cutting edge of efforts to push systemic change in China. Self-styled “rights defenders” regard the law as a tool to expand and protect the rights of individuals in an authoritarian political system. But the ruling Communist Party is often wary of lawyers who try to challenge what it regards as the unassailable pre-eminence of the party in society.

I can think of no analogy to what we do in the United States.  While we may challenge the government’s abuse of constitutional rights at every turn, we rarely fear that we won’t be able to walk out of court at the end of the day and return the next day to do it again. 

There is one surprising aspect to this situation.  While defending Tibetans may raise the Chinese government’s ire, and result in suspension of the license to practice law, at least they didn’t suddenly disappear in the middle of the night.  Bear in mind, this is the country where the managers of factories that used lead paint on children’s toys exported to America committed suicide within hours of the news breaking. 

The fact that Teng and Jiang weren’t rounded up for re-education may itself tell us that Mao’s Great Leap Forward has been replaced with Wal-Mart’s Lower Prices Everyday, certainly a far less risky proposition than a bit of torture followed by a sale on body parts.  Still, one has to admire lawyers in the fading days of a totalitarian regime taking the risk of defending enemies of the State.  It takes huge guts to do the right thing in the face of severe consequences, and they deserve our admiration.

H/T to the Turk for his vigilance in Olympic Coverage.

Hahvahd Ain’t What She Used to Be

When Phil Telfeyan’s Note in the Harvard Law Review hit the news stands, it caused a stir amongst those who hold things like law review, or Harvard, in high esteem.  For the most part, it aroused some passion amongst the lawprofs (who by their nature care about law reviews) and bemused disinterest amongst real lawyers who think this is the academy’s way of showing that they take this stuff way too seriously.

But this wasn’t the end of it for Phil or HLR.  Yesterday, I received a blast email from a fellow named John Jay McKelvey IV.  I don’t personally know anybody by that name.  I may have met him at the synagogue, but I can’t be sure.  No matter. 

JJ (as his close friends call him) has a blog called the Harvard Law Review Review.  I think it’s a very funny name, but I’m not entirely sure it was intended to be funny.  It seems that JJ is the lineal ancestor of the founder of the Harvard Law Review, and considers it his duty to preserve and protect this national treasure.


My name is John Jay McKelvey IV. More than 120 years ago, my great-great grandfather, John Jay McKelvey, while attending Harvard Law School came up with the idea for the Harvard Law Review. As Time magazine recounted in a 1937 article marking the Review’s th anniversary (here), he was one of the “Harvard Four” who launched the Review. With my great-great grandfather serving as the first editor-in-chief (a title changed to “president” in 1902), the first issue of the Review was published in April, 1887.

What a horrible burden to carry through life, one step above maintaining the Cincinnati Dust Bunny Museum.

Anyway, JJ wrote an open letter to Robert Allen, the President of the Harvard Law Review (who to my mind should be called Grand Poobah or something more Hasty Puddingish).  JJ wanted to make sure that this letter was spread far and wide, to ensure outrage at the HLR and its loss of any standards of literary and intellectual decency. 

JJ’s letter is quite long, intricately detailed and fully footnoted and cite checked.  I’m just going to cherry pick the really important parts.


Almost as soon as the May, 2008, issue of the Law Review was posted online, legal bloggers and commentators began generating what by now total something like 1000 posts attacking various flaws in an unsigned student note which appears on pages 1886 through 1907.

It is titled, Never Again Should a People Starve in a World of Plenty. Both its title and its inspiration are taken from a statue located about 100 feet from the Review’s offices (Gannett House), across the street in Cambridge Common.

Harvard takes its statues very seriously.  But apparently, JJ takes the comments of legal bloggers even more seriously.  Legal bloggers are very influential at Harvard.


Some of the most extensive coverage of the controversy can be found on Volokh Conspiracy (David Bernstein) (here), Above the Law (David Lat) (here, here, and here), Concurring Opinions (Dave Hoffman) (here), CrimLaw (Ken Lammers) (here), and Prettier Than Napolean (Amber Taylor) (here and here). See here for a fuller listing of blog coverage.

Note that I’ve been dissed twice in one day, especially galling since Ken’s post came out of mine.  But I was worthy of the blast email to promote your cause, eh JJ?


Perhaps the principal criticism of the note which risks adverse impact on the preeminent status of the Review as a top-quality scholarly institution involves certain undeniable factual mistakes in the note’s description of the statue on which the note is based. These are unambiguous mistakes for which the Review to date has not apologized.

Preeminent status is strong stuff.  I bet the guys over at Yale Law Review Journal (whatever) are fuming.

After providing a litany of faults and flaws with the Note, JJ asks:


[I]f the Review is publishing this sort of thing, shouldn’t it inform readers of its new, sharply lowered, publishing standards?

Finally, we get to the point.  I’m with JJ on this one.  And in my role as blawgosphere maker of general announcements, here goes.


The Harvard Law Review would like to inform the legal world that, in its efforts to maintain its preeminent status as a top-quality scholarly institution, it has new, sharply lowered, publishing standards.

I bet JJ feels like the weight of the world has been lifted from his shoulders.  Now that Harvard Law Review will no longer be saddled with 121 years of finding perpetually stuffy, yet boring, articles with which to fill its pages, it will be free to publish things that someone might potentially care to read.  Hallelujah!


And, with reference to the controversy over the other note which has existed for the past couple of weeks, which has yet to be addressed by the Review (would you please do so, sir?), may I ask: what has the Review come to in deciding to publish, in the same issue (not just the same year) two notes as unoriginal and flawed as the “ministerial exception” note and the “Do the Right Thing at Every Moment” note which appear in the May, 2008, issue?

I’m glad you asked, JJ.  In a further (and heretofore unannounced special treat), HLR will be offering a centerfold, featuring Nancy Gertner as its inaugural pin-up babe (she’s hot!). 

And please keep me on the email list for new developments from the Harvard Law Review Review, because I care so deeply.

The Blawgosphere Loves a List

The website “Criminal Justice Degree Guide,” under ordinary circumstances, would not get the time of day from the blawgosphere.  It appears to be a site to find schools for those who hope to work in the “criminal justice” field some day. You plug in your zip code and schools pop out.  Not exactly what most of us are interested in.

But this Website was the toast of the blawgosphere yesterday, when it came out with its list of “The Top 100 Criminal Justice Blogs.”  The blawgosphere loves a list, and loves it even more if your blog is on it.

Simple Justice didn’t make the cut.  But then, neither did Volokh or CrimLaw.  I’m just going to have to work harder at being better. 

But many of me neighbors in the blawgosphere did make the list, so anything that lets more people in on the secret of the blawgosphere and sends more readers their way is good by me.   Grits was to make the cut, as was Anne at court-o-rama, though she felt a little weird about it later.  A quick plug for Anne, by the way.  I’ve never seen any blog slide into the middle of the blawgosphere as if it was always there, an integral, funny and useful member of the gang, like court-o-rama.  Overnight, she’s on everybody’s feed because she’s that good.  No need to give Grits a plug, as Scott has been a staple of the blawgosphere long before I got here, and remains a primary destination.

Houston criminal defense lawyer and force of nature Mark Bennett was a little suspect of this list.  He thinks “There’s more to this list than meets the eye.”  I think he meant less, but that’s just a matter of semantics.

There are many great blawgs on this “top 100,” and it certainly put this website on the map overnight.  While I was a little suspicious when I saw Tony Collelouri’s blog on the list, since he hasn’t posted since March of ’07, I don’t begrudge any of the fine blawgs receiving a little extra press.  And for those who noticed my absence, I thank you for your kind thoughts.  But enjoy the fame and glory.  You’ve all got great stuff and deserve to be on anybody’s “Top 100” list, mine included.

The Federal Numbers Game Debunked

Before 1987, the “value” of a crime in federal court was a matter of argument between counsel.  The government would try to stuff in every penny it could find, while the defense would minimize the damage.  It was but one of the points raised at a sentence, and not nearly as significant as the nature of the defendant’s conduct, the “maliciousness” of his act.

With the acceptance of the federal sentencing guidelines, the entire world turned around.  Suddenly, numbers meant everything.  Whether drugs or financial crime, the severity of the sentence was based on a number attributed to the crime by the government, which tied the judge’s hands as to sentencing range.  What was meant by those numbers quickly became clear:  The numbers bore little connection to any rational view of the crime, but rather to some fictional construct that served to make sure that a $10 theft looked like a million dollars.  The defendant was sentenced accordingly.

Twenty years later, with the heat turned down to a mere simmer, the Supreme Court is finally fleshing out some of the harshest, most bizarre applications.  In an odd 4-1-4 decision, the Supremes decided   United States v. Santos, which held (kinda) that proceeds, at least in the context of gambling crimes, to mean “profit”.  In this case, the crime itself involved the laundering of “proceeds”, and the issue arose in the context of a numbers runner delivering winnings.

While the lawprofs and Supreme Court watchers are fascinated with the breakdown of the vote, noting that Justices Scalia, Thomas, Souter and Ginsburg make up the bulk of the majority, with Justice Stevens providing the tie breaker, this is of less concern for me since I dwell in the trenches.

My hope is that this will bring reason back to the loss calculations of the sentencing guidelines.

Consider the implications: Santos involved “numbers” (called a “lottery” by the Supremes and gambling by others).  The  idea is that they take in money from people betting on the number, and pay out money on people who hit the number.  The amount of money between what’s taken in and what’s paid out is the profit.  To use hypothetical amounts, let’s say a numbers guy gets $100,000 worth of bets.  Mind you, the bettors don’t pay the money until later, so they are just placed.  One guy hits the number, and wins $50,000.  He gets paid and the numbers guy collects from the losers, so he grosses a profit of $50,000.  He has to pay his runners, rent, collection people, 3M Corp., BIC pens, Verizon, etc.  Net profit ends up being $25,000, and that would be the amount used to calculate the guidelines.

So, under the government’s view, proceeds included all revenues, meaning the $100,000.  Under Santos, proceeds is now interpreted per the rule of lenity, to mean profits, revenues less the cost of doing business.  Moreover, the movement of funds that are not “profits” will no longer be criminal proceeds, and therefore not constitute money laundering or other related crimes.  This is a significant change in itself, with ramifications for a variety of crimes.

The difference between the gang of four and Justice Stevens is in the latter’s opinion that while this interpretation can apply to gambling, it is not unreasonable to believe that Congress meant a different interpretation to exist with regard to narcotics and organized crime.  Justice Scalia, writing for his group, contends that proceeds should be interpreted consistently throughout, and that you can’t pick and choose interpretations based on the particular crime involved. 

In federal cases, the amounts of money involved in crimes are viewed as astronomical, divorced from any actual “gain” from the commission of a crime.  A crime that actually nets a defendant $10,000 will be attributed a value of $100,000, for example, because “proceeds” has included any amount of money allegedly involved, no matter how it was involved, and that sum was never reduced by the costs of committing a crime.

For those who would argue (and understandably so) that criminals shouldn’t benefit from their own cost of doing business, this misses the point of attributing a value to a crime.  It’s not about coddling criminals or diminishing the significance of their crime.  It’s about trying to squeeze crime into a loss table and figuring out what the actual numbers should be.  A person who gains $10,000 from crime should not be sentenced as if his gain was $100,000 or a million.  Small-time criminals should not be converted to kingpins because the government likes to play with the numbers. 

While my application of Santos, which is not a guidelines decision, may have to await another decision of the Supremes before circuits and district courts decide that Justice Scalia’s view, that consistency of interpretation across the board is required, should prevail, this decision should hopefully bring a little sanity back to the sentencing guidelines calculations.   Of course, there’s nothing to stop the Sentencing Guidelines Commission, should it so desire, from undoing the impact of this decision by revising the tables to increase the guidelines to make a $1 profit a level 34.  But at least it’s a step in the right direction.

Gerry Spence, Superstar

Criminal defense lawyers tend to be characters.  Unlike our brothers in Biglaw, who dress alike, talk alike and try their best to behave appropriately, we relish in our larger than life personas.  But none alive today can compare to one man who hails from Wyoming and, with long white hair and a fringed jacket. 

Gerry Spence says he has tried his last case.  He says that he has never lost a criminal case.  Yesterday, he got an acquittal in the Geoffrey Fieger case.  If there was truth to his claim, then he going out with his reputation intact. 

I never drank the Spence cool-aid.  I never attended the Trial Lawyers College he runs at his Jackson ranch.  I saw Gerry Spence as another lawyer with an ego as big as the Wyoming sky, immodest beyond words.  My comments about him have been derogatory for this reason.  He was neither my friend nor mentor.  I was not inclined to pray at the alter of Gerry Spence.

But for all his ego, his immodest comments, his flagrantly self-aggrandizing persona, there is one thing that cannot be denied.  He may well go down in lawyer history as the best criminal defense lawyer since Clarence Darrow.  We may well have just watched the last trial of a legal Superstar.



It’s hard to step back and view current events from a historical perspective.  People who, when the history books are written, become legends were usually viewed as normal people by their contemporaries.  It’s only later that their contributions, skills, genius, are appreciated.  Will this be true for Gerry Spence?

Following the Fieger acquittal, the Detroit News published this:


“I knew this jury would never convict,” Spence said after the verdict. “They were a good, solid American jury and the evidence wasn’t there.” 

Spence, who has written several books on criminal defense, defended former Philippine First Lady Imelda Marcos, Idaho separatist Randy Weaver in the Ruby Ridge case, and the family of corporate whistle-blower Karen Silkwood.

Spence boasts he has never lost a criminal case and it appears he will now retire with his record intact.

If these words came from the mouth of anyone else, they would sound ridiculous.  But I can hear Spence’s sonorous tone and imagine him looking into the eyes of the jurors with utter sincerity, while speaking words of great justice, the type that later end up in some inspirational platitude to convince children that America is the greatest country ever conceived.  Spence can do these things, when they would be laughable from almost anyone else, and make it work.

There are many other great criminal defense lawyers today.  I’m sure the same was true during Darrow’s time, but not another name comes to mind now.  When criminal defense lawyers look back on this era in the law, whose name will immediately come to mind as being a legend? 

Maybe it would have been less distasteful had Gerry Spence not been quite so immodest about his considerable skills.  Perhaps his flashy Americana persona was too incongruent for someone like me.  Maybe I am just inordinately jealous of the fact that I’m no Gerry Spence.  But he has accomplished what he set out to accomplish, and he will end his career with proof that his claims are true. 

Whether Gerry Spence will prove to be the legend of our time will only be known when we are all long gone.  But for now, there is no denying one thing.  Gerry Spence is a superstar.

Breaking News

Fieger acquitted.  H/T Bennett.

Mel Weiss gets 30 months.

Quite a day for heavyweights of the plaintiffs’ bar.  While I have sinned against Gerry Spence in the past by accusing him of immodesty for his claim to have never lost a criminal case, I must atone for my sins.  By tomorrow, perhaps the local papers will have interviewed the jurors and learned that this was another Imelda story (though I doubt it, based on Norm’s running coverage.  But regardless, Spence beat the case. 

Gerry Spence said this would be his last case.  He’s 80.  He’s tired. It’s understandable.  And it’s one heck of a way to close out a career.  Gerry Spence, for all his bluff and swagger, may truly be the Darrow of our time.

Mel Weiss, on the other hand, probably isn’t feeling that good today.  He hoped for 18 months, and did substantiall worse.  Given the treatment of his partner and protege, Bill Lerach, it’s not exactly a surprise.  But then, Mel was a master of the universe, and they don’t lose.

Mel got a great plea deal out of Ben Branfman.  Sentencing didn’t go nearly as well, but that’s a matter of relative expectations.  With 18 months in sight, 30 months seems like a very long time.  If he remembered that he had 161 months in sight before, 30 doesn’t sound nearly as bad.  It will go quickly, and Mel will find a few fellows to hang with in a very nice prison camp somewhere.  If someone asked a young Mel Weiss if he would give up 30 months of his life to gain the wealth and lifestyle he’s enjoyed, I bet he would happily agree. 

Quite a day for the plaintiffs’ bar indeed.

Serious Blawgers

An interesting schism came about in the past few days over the Avery Doninger decision in the 2d Circuit.  I’ve written fairly extensively about the case, because it involves issues dear to my heart, free speech and education.  That doesn’t mean that anybody who hasn’t written about it doesn’t care about either, but just wasn’t propelled forward.

On the flip side, and no doubt to some small extent as a result of my interest in the case, some of my brethren in the practical blawgosphere felt compelled to post about the case.  Not because they wanted to alert their readers to my posting brilliance.  Not even close.  Their purpose was to point out that they felt that the case was trivial and that my focus (not to mention dire predictions about its impact on student speech) were, ahem, overblown.

I don’t mind.  Not merely because I’m right and they’re wrong.  Not because I don’t respect their opinion (I do).  Not because I’m more highly attuned to these issues and can appreciate the nuanced impact of issues that are only tangentially related to criminal law.  Not even because I am far better looking.

I don’t mind because there is room in the covenant of good people to disagree.  Reasonable minds may differ.  It not only happens, but happens regularly.  Even people who tend to agree with each other 99% of the time will have their odd moments of conflict.  Perhaps this is not only unavoidable, but necessary.  It reminds us that we aren’t just the choir, but actually give some thought to each individual issue, each specific case, independent of what anyone else is thinking, and then arrive at the same conclusion.  Almost always.

It’s not entirely clear why, on the other hand, my brethren felt this case unworthy of being taken seriously, but were serious enough to post about a trivial case to make sure that their readers knew it was inconsequential, at least to them.  Did they need to distinguish themselves from me?  I would be flattered it that were so, but I doubt it.  

I believe that it had to do with the fact that this was a Connecticut district court case, and they are Connecticut lawyers.  Having some New York cosmopolitan erudite suave lawyer and part-time busy-body butting into the Muffy-world of Connecticut was too much for them to stand.  Their choices were limited:  Either jump in the fray to lay claim to one of the very small issues of interest deriving from the small yet bucolic state of Connecticut, or let the New York dude lay claim.  They couldn’t let that happen. 

So rather than post to distinguish themselves from me, they posted to give me a little smack and remind me who owns Connecticut.  Gideon will deny this and claim that he just wants to set the record straight, but he’s full of it.  He’s just a passive aggressive in public defenders’ clothing, laughing out loud at the aggravation he can cause with a few keystrokes. 

Norm, on the other hand, will do anything he can to avoid making a humorous response, for fear that it will further his public image as the latter day Oscar Wilde.

A commenter posted that I was wrong about this decision too.  Under the pseudonym, TheReadJustice (intended to be “The Real Justice,” but spelled wrong), he wrote :


This blog entry clearly shows that even a lawyer like you didn’t even read the ruling and facts of the case, rather just responded to other bloggers rants of “facts”. YOu are a disgrace to the profession.

Ironically, it was a comment to an essay written by Avery Doninger, not me.  The Read (Real) Justice was clearly very serious, even more so than my brethren, not to mention quite incensed.  Not only did he accuse me not reading the “ruling and facts,” but to responding to “other bloggers rants.”  Despite a certain lack of clarity, Read Justice is seriously serious about this.

Whenever commenters take names like “Read (Real) Justice” to make clear that they represent truth, sanity and most importantly, common sense (there are about 540,000 people who lay claim to “common sense”), I find it hard not to giggle.  So many people who want so desperately to be taken seriously.  I see self-esteem dying right before my eyes.  It’s horrible.

And the Read (Real) Justice concludes that I am “a disgrace to the profession.”  Now that’s a very serious thing to say,  But it’s not exactly something I can dispute.  If Read finds me disgraceful, then disgraceful I am.  To him, at least. 

Fortunately for me, I can disagree with my brethren from time to time (except Doc Berman, who won’t take no for an answer) and still remain a step above becoming a disgrace to the profession.  At least, I think so.  Seriously.

The “Allen” Charge, Democracy and Dinner Reservations

As the Fieger trial goes into a new week of jury deliberations, with Gerry Spence not getting any younger and likely wondering how he’s going to hang up his spurs if he doesn’t pull an Imelda out of his 10 gallon hat, Norm Pattis raises the spectre lurking in the background:  The dreaded Allen Charge.


At some point this week, the jury may well report that it cannot reach a verdict. United States District Court Judge Paul Borman will then pull out his book of jury instructions and read the so-called Allen charge, in effect, inviting jurors to reconsider their views in light of the conscientiously held opinions of their peers. There will be no invitation to surrender to the majority, simply because the majority has more votes. Jurors will be told that each must be persuaded. But they should listen to one another.

I disagree with Norm.  I bet Judge Borman has his Allen Charge in hand at the ready, just waiting to pounce.  The Allen Charge doesn’t get pulled out until the jury sends back the deadlock note.  This is the one where they tell the judge that they have tried and tried and tried, but can’t agree on a verdict.  They are tired.  They are often angry with one or two of the jurors, who just don’t “get it.”  The majority of the jury believes with all their heart and soul that they have struggled to fulfill their duty.  It’s just not going to happen.  They have given up.

Then they get the charge.


“Members of the Jury:


I’m going to ask that you continue your deliberations in an effort to reach agreement upon a verdict and dispose of this case; and I would like for you to consider as you do so.


This is an important case. The trial has been expensive in time, effort, money and emotional strain to both the defense and the prosecution. If you should fail to agree upon a verdict, the case will be left open and may have to be tried again. Obviously, another trial would only serve to increase the cost to both sides, and there is no reason to believe that the case can be tried again by either side any better or more exhaustively than it has been tried before you.


Any future jury must be selected in the same manner and from the same source as you were chosen, and there is no reason to believe that the case could ever be submitted to twelve men and women more conscientious, more impartial, or more competent to decide it, or that more or clearer evidence could be produced.


If a substantial majority of your number are in favor of a conviction, those of you who disagree should reconsider whether your doubt is a reasonable one since it appears to make no effective impression upon the minds of the others. On the other hand, if a majority or even a lesser number of you are in favor of an acquittal, the rest of you should ask yourselves again, and most thoughtfully, whether you should accept the weight and sufficiency of evidence which fails to convince your fellow jurors beyond a reasonable doubt.


Remember at all times that no juror is expected to give up an honest belief he or she may have as to the weight or effect of the evidence; but, after full deliberation and consideration of the evidence in the case, it is your duty to agree upon a verdict if you can do so.


You must also remember that if the evidence in the case fails to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt the Defendant should have your unanimous verdict of Not Guilty.


You may be as leisurely in your deliberations as the occasion may require and should take all the time which you may feel is necessary.


I will ask now that you retire once again and continue your deliberations with these additional comments in mind to be applied, of course, in conjunction with all of the other instructions I have previously given to you.”



This charge plays to a jurors sense of democracy, that majority rules.  Its purpose is to force the holdouts to capitulate to save the government from the expense of trying the case again.  There is nothing more antithetical to the concept of a unanimous jury of twelve than to tell the one or two who don’t “get it” that they are losers, failures and screwing up the deal. 

After the Allen Charge, the jury returns to their room to “continue their deliberations.”  For a normal person, who is holding ten or so others hostage, the pressure is unbearable.  They have lives waiting for them.  There are children who are hungry.  There’s a spouse to contend with. 

Two words have always summed up the Allen Charge to me:  dinner reservations.  Assuming a reasonable juror with no ax to grind, by the time the deadlock note comes in, they have tried.  The majority has explained, cajoled and pleaded with the holdout to change their mind.  They have gone through all twelve steps, invoking everything from Gandhi to God in their effort to convince, and come up empty.  The holdout stood firm.  The groups exhales as one, and the decision is made that they can no longer bear to face another minute in that room together.  The note is sent, believing that they have done their duty to the best of their ability, and but for the holdout, justice would be done.

Now, they’re back.  Scolded by the judge for having failed, read some infantile script about “honest beliefs” that should be reconsidered in light of the fact that a majority believes you’re a moron and sent to the corner like the schoolroom dunce, it feels as if it will never end.

Dinner reservations.  My belief is that this is the straw that will break the camel’s back.  The holdout need only have dinner reservations to change his vote and end the pain.  Before the Allen Charge, it was a matter of right and wrong.  The holdout did so for truth, justice and the American way.  Now it comes down to dinner reservations.  Should he stay in that room, fighting with this angry mob, or just give in to the will of the majority?  Should he make the other eleven sit there, angry and frustrated, when even the judge has told him that he’s supposed to listen to the majority?  It will take nothing more pressing than dinner reservations to change everything.  It’s not worth the fight.  Maybe they’re right.  If I don’t give in, we’ll be here forever.  Then I’ll miss my dinner reservations.  Is it worth it to me?

The difference between a verdict and a hung jury comes down to dinner reservations. 

Will the Sky Fall Today on New York Justice?

When the New York Times runs an editorial with the headline, Repairing New York’s Justice System, my pulse quickens and breath grows short.  Could this be the one that finally deals with the wholesale absence of discovery, the use of flawed identifications to convict the innocent?  Maybe they will finally nail testilying cops to the wall?  Is it the death knell of the Rockefeller drug laws, putting mules in prison forever for a couple ounces of dope?

Then comes the opening line:

New York’s justice system has fallen into crisis. Yet Albany is not dealing with three big problems dragging the system down — missing judicial pay raises, glaring deficiencies in indigent defense services and the swelling workload overwhelming Family Court.

Sigh.  I know it’s been a slow couple of weeks in the criminal law field.  No hot new murders.  No major new issues before the Supremes.  But this is just pathetic.

In the broadest sense, New York’s justice system has fallen into crisis, though it’s been happening for as long as I’ve been practicing law and will likely be the same on the day I die.  It’s a perpetual battle and it always will be.  We will never achieve a perfect system.

But crisis?  The Times raises two issues that have been on the burner for years, and are not significantly different today than they were yesterday.  Or last year.  Of all the many things that are wrong with the Justice system, these hardly rise to the level of crisis. 

The Times isn’t wrong about the first and second, though the thirds reflect something of a misunderstanding of the problem.  There are underutilized Supreme Court judges around the state, given the drop in crime.  Personnel can be shifted to cover the gaps, and systems can be better organized to make things move more effectively.  Also, add 39 more judges and you need 39 more courtrooms and staff. 

My issue here is that there are problems with the system of justice, and there is always going to be plenty of need for improvement as we strive to figure out how to deliver more perfect justice, a goal that will never be achieved.  But to make every burp and pothole in the system into another claim that the sky is falling is needlessly and unhelpfully hysterical. 

Judges salaries don’t rise to the level of consequence as convicting the innocent.  A statewide indigent defense system, which is primarily a cost-saving plan, is important but will still take years to implement, and will have its own problems along the way.  And 39 more judges in a juvenile justice system that is rife with internal systemic error is hardly as important as participants who take personal interest in the children they exist to help rather than the rote application of rules.

The system is not in crisis today any more than it was in crisis yesterday.  It just has problem that can, and should, be dealt with.  But let’s save the chicken little act for when it counts.