Author Archives: SHG

2d Circuit Affirms in Doninger Appeal: Student Speech Crushed

Avery Doninger is the student that many wish their own kids would be, smart, involved and caring.  Now, here name will by synonymous with something different, a crushing blow against free speech by a student on the internet, now that the 2d Circuit has rejected her arguments for a preliminary injunction on appeal. Here, here and here are past posts on this case, and the mother-lode can be found at Cool Justice.

According to the Hartford Courant,


Ruling in a case that addresses broad questions of the boundaries of free speech in the Internet age, a federal appeals court on Thursday effectively ended a Burlington student’s effort to serve as a class officer and speak at graduation.

[T]he court’s ruling weighed in on a hotly contested and evolving area of the law, freedom of expression on the Internet. The three-judge panel stopped short of declaring how far schools can go in regulating offensive Internet speech made off campus, but stated that the school did not violate the Constitution in disciplining Doninger because her blog post “created a foreseeable risk of substantial disruption” at the school.

The mantra of old was that students don’t “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gates.”  Tinker v. Des Moines Indep. Sch. Dist., 393 U.S. 503 (1969).  But that was before the internet existed.  Apparently, everything has changed.

While the earlier rule held that students maintained a constitutional right to speech, even within the school yard, the Circuit’s vision is that they not only forfeit speech going into school, but do so again on the way out.  Avery’s challenge to school officials’ hegemony was made in a blog post, well beyond the proverbial schoolhouse gates of the past.  But there are no longer any gates, literally or figuratively, when it comes to student speech.

The test applied by the Circuit is extremely curious, holding that the district was appropriate in disciplining Avery because her blog post “created a foreseeable risk of substantial disruption.”  Almost as a matter of historic definition, weeding out acceptable exercise of Freedom of Speech because it had the potential to create thought and ideas that might be disruptive fundamentally undermines the right.  What point is there to speech that evokes no thought or ideas?  It’s disruptive speech that the 1st Amendment protects. 


The disruption the blog post caused, the court wrote, included students getting riled and administrators receiving phone calls and e-mails that made them miss or come late to school-related activities.

Even so, the ruling said, the relevant issue was not whether disruption occurred but whether school officials “might reasonably portend disruption.”

While this might be mistakenly viewed as a recognition that disruptive speech is protected, don’t be fooled.  This aspect serves only to relieve school officials of the duty to prove harm first, allowing them to foreclose speech for their own mere anticipation.  It further reduces the test to one of theoretical disruption, providing even greater deference to school officials to discipline students despite no adverse consequences.

If protected speech is limited to a chat about who’s taking whom to the prom, or what the popular girls were wearing to the dance, no protection would be needed.  The irony of the Circuit’s decision is striking: What better speech to protect than that which challenges government officials?

But the irony doesn’t end there. 


The court also emphasized that Doninger’s discipline barred her from an extracurricular activity, and that the blog post was inconsistent with the school’s policy that student government representatives have a record of good citizenship.

Citizenship has always been one of those phrases that has been subject to facile misconstruction.  Is citizenship blind obedience to the will of the government?  Were Jefferson, Washington and Madison bad citizens?  No, Avery’s deed doesn’t place her in the pantheon of American heroes, but her right to express them is the natural child of their efforts and ideals.  Avery Doninger challenge to heavy hand, the knee-jerk reaction of government officials is the epitome of good citizenship, except when the determination is being made by the very people criticized.  Only then does good citizenship get redefined as “obedience to governmental authority.”

This decision not only has dire significance for student speech, one of the “tail wagging the dog” areas of law that invariably ends with courts digging deep to find a way to defer to school officials, whose love of students stops abruptly when their might and wisdom is question.  But it also has significant implications for online speech, a realm where courts remains particularly out of touch.

The pervasiveness of online communication, its breadth and reach, scares the daylights out of courts.  They can order a person to be silent; indeed, they can imprison a person to stop her from speaking her mind.  But the courts have no control over the internet, where ideas flow instantaneously around the world, beyond the reach of even the mighty Circuit judge, and remain forever no matter how forceful an order he issues.

So, some petty school officials smacked a student who posted a negative and vulgar comment about them.  The Circuit had a chance to enforce the Constitution, and instead chose to hide behind deference to these petty officials, lest they lose their ironclad control over a bunch of kids.  The court elected to protect the petty officials from embarrassment, and instead embarrassed itself, the country and our self-proclaimed respect for freedom of speech. 

The relief no longer matters for Avery Doninger, who is now past the discipline these petty officials can level.  But it speaks to the farcical nature of our proclaimed love of freedom, as it’s denigrated by this far-reaching decision.  What a sad lesson about freedom and the Constitution was taught at Lewis S. Mills High School in Connecticut and the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan.

Teacher Du Jour: Wendy Portillo of Port St. Lucie, FL

In keeping with our  school appreciation theme, we offer the teaching stylings of Port St. Lucie, Florida kindergarten teacher of Wendy Portillo.  In her class was 5 year old Alex Barton, who has Asperger’s Syndrome.

Gosh darn those learning disabled kids are such a pain, right Wendy?  But being a real pro, Wendy knows just how to handle those annoying little pests:


After returning to Ms. Portillo’s classroom after a recent visit with the principal, his teacher decided to punish him with humiliation. She had Alex stand at the front of the class while his fellow students listed off what they didn’t like about him. After informing him that they found him “disgusting” and “annoying”, the class was instructed to vote on whether or not Alex should be allowed to stay in the class. By a 14 to 2 margin, they voted him out.

But lest you say to yourself as you read this, “finally, a teacher that I want for my kid,” you’re out of luck.  According to USA Today, she’s been “reassigned”.  Perhaps there are learning disabled students in high school, they fear they could make it to graduation without having been adequately abused?

One aside:  If this child has Asperger’s, what is he doing in the principal’s office because of his behavioral issues?  If he cannot be taught in a typical classroom because of problems engendered by his syndrome, and accommodations cannot be adequately made, then he must be provided with more a suitable situation.  You don’t punish a kid because he has autism.

The Silent Majority is Back

When Turley posted about some local Ford dealer’s  radio commercial directed to the “84%” of true believers in a Christian nation, it was worth a few chuckles.  After all, most people assume that they represent the norm, and there’s no reason to expect some wacky Ford dealer to be different.

But then comes the pathetic retraction, after the dealership, Kieffe, after it turns out that they may have offended slightly more than the 14% of heathens out there.  The claim is that while they reviewed the advertisement, they didn’t “closely review” it.  Well, that’s that, right?

Wrongo.  It seems that while Kieffe et fils may recognize that its franchise was on the line, the fellow who writes their advertising is less concerned about commerce than his client.  According to J.W. Horne, proclaimed author of the radio spot (note that I’ve broken up his statement into paragraphs because it was just too painful to read otherwise):


For those of you out there in never land or la la land or maybe underground and under the radar who are so called non believers, I am the man who wrote and recorded the Kieffe and sons spot. In fact I write and produce all of the Kieffe and Sons ford spots. I have had the pleasure of serving the advertising for the dealership for many years. I am a believer and I am pretty sure that most everyone at Kieffe and Sons ford are also believers. I wrote and produced the spot that so many of you “unbelievers” find offensive.

Frankly I don’t give a flip whether you are an athiest or just plain doubter. I wrote and recorded the truth. There is a great silent majority of Americans that are believers. The difference between them and you is this. Believers do not have to justify their existence. The only ones in this country that respond to an honest ad are the ones who seem to despise honesty. The truth is this. This country was founded on the belief in God. All you have to do is read the constitution and see for yourself. Now does that mean that everyone here must believe? NO absolutely not. The great thing about the constitution is that it allows for each American citizen to believe as the wish and speak and do what they want so long as it is within the law. I support that. I support everyones right to think and do and live as they wish. I do not condem any American that disagrees with me. You all can stand up and shout, burn flags, gather on a corner and cuss the government, males can marry males, females can marry females you can all buy one of those imports and send the money to Japan if you want, but you do not have the right to force your philosophy on to others.

I think that it is time for you to understand this very simple little fact. You are in the minority and as loud as you yell and protest, you will always be in the minority. If you don’t like the radio spot then don’t listen to it, but if you were careful enough to listen to the entire spot you would have heard me say that to the good people at Kieffe and Sons ford “everyone one is welcome at the dealership whether you are a believer or not, you are still welcome. You would also have heard me say that you may get God taken out of the class room and the pledge and even off our money, but you will not get God out of this dealership. We do business according to the rules of the good book.. if you are offended by that, then you are offended by the truth. So each of you who find some offense to the radio ad and you want to be up in arms over it, you have the right to think what you wish but you do not have the right to take my copyrighted material and destort it for your personal gain. If you are offended, well like I said in the commercial.. thats tough.

You da man. Horney.  But I’m not exactly clear where you come up with the statement that the “great silent majority of Americans” are “believers”. 

Here’s my problem.  Like you, J.Dubya, I ascribed believerhood based upon what type of car people drive.  It’s not that people who drive Toyotas (or, God forbid, Saabs!) think to themselves, “well there’s a blow to the church,” but you and me both get it; Drive a foreign and you might as well kiss the devil (who, by the way, is a man, making it a double sin, if not more).

But, J.Dubya, everyone with half a brain (and you certainly qualify) knows that American vehicles aren’t doing too well.  Heck, Ford just announced that it can’t sell its pickups anymore, no doubt the product of some Arab plot to shift jobs to Mexico where all those illegals are coming over the border to kill believers.  So if Americans are busy buying up Datsuns, and Ford’s dying a slow and painful death, the silent majority may have gone over to the side of Beelzebub.  That silent majority may not be too majority anymore.  I know, makes your eyes tear, don’t it?

Now I’m not telling you not to keep the faith, Brother J. Dubya, and use the skills that God gave you to advertise your American heart out in the na,e of believers everywhere, whenever possible, no matter how many people think you’re totally insane.  But if you end up being driven out of business because you offended every SUV loving soccer mom in Mojave, well…that’s tough.


Gun Anecdote Proves Nothing

Glen Reynolds, the Instapundit, provides fodder for Volokh to proclaim a gun toting hero in Winnemucca, Nevada.  After Ernesto Fuentes Villagomez walked into the Players Bar & Grill and shot and killed two individuals,


[a 48-year-old Reno man] produced a concealed handgun and proceeded to fire upon Villagomez who succumbed to his wounds. The Reno resident was in possession of a valid Concealed Carry Permit issued through the Washoe County Sheriff’s Office.

That this armed bystander stopped a shooter from killing others is undisputedly a good outcome.  And given that we are all awaiting the Supreme Court’s decision on whether the 2nd Amendment states a fundamental individual right to bear arms, stories about how legally armed individuals protected others provides justification to such an interpretation.

But does this story prove the point?  Gene writes:


My hat is off to the anonymous man who likely could have blended into the crowd and escaped, but who put himself at considerable risk to protect the lives of others.

We can all appreciate the actions of a person to protect others at personal risk.  Certainly, the shooter could have turned his weapon on the good samaritan, and the choice to pull out his concealed handgun was one of putting the safety of others before his own.

Query:  Had this good samaritan tackled the shooter, would he be less of a hero?  Had he struck the shooter over the head with a beer bottle, would he be less of a hero?  There are plenty of other examples, but the point is the same.

And what if the anonymous good samaritan lacked a valid permit for the concealed weapon? How would that change the equation?

It could well be argued that, lacking a concealed weapon, the chances are substantially less that anyone would have challenged the shooter by brute force, a beer bottle or any other way.  It could also be argued that if guns weren’t so pervasive, the shooter wouldn’t have had one and would have engaged in fisticuffs with his enemies rather than murdering them.  This is all speculation, so there’s no point in arguing which is accurate.

The question of whether the Second Amendment will ultimately result in rampant shootings across America, or responsible gun culture that will serve better to protect than to harm, has nothing to do with whether there is a right to bear arms.  It’s just a way of blunting the claims of potential disaster, and making the anticipated interpretation more palatable.  See, a gun saved lives.  Take that, you liberals.

My preference is to see that a man saved lives.  The same motivation to do something to stop harm to others existed regardless of whether the fellow carried a concealed weapon.  The gun doesn’t make the hero.  The hero makes the hero.  The fact that this person was willing to risk his own welfare to help other people sounds decidedly “liberal”.  Maybe only liberals should have guns?

On the other hand, this happened at the lovely Players Bar and Grill.  Maybe if we prohibited alcohol?

An anonymous person stopped a man from killing people by shooting him with a concealed weapon.  It proves nothing more than on this occasion, one good man stopped one bad man from doing harm.  I too applaud the anonymous man, but this doesn’t prove that all good people should carry guns.

The Same-Sex Marriage Fight is Over; Sanity Wins

With mind-numbing speed, and against the predictions of critics, the confluence of two events will change the landscape for gays and Lesbians forever and end the legal fight over the right to same-sex marriage.

First, the decision by the California Supreme Court that denial of marriage to same-sex couples was unconstitutional has resulted in California announcing that marriage licenses will be issued as of June 17th.

New York will now close the loop, with Gov. David Paterson directing state agencies to revise their regulations to acknowledge same-sex marriages performed in other jurisdictions, as posted by Gideon from this New York Times article.

That’s the end of the game.  Now that the bookends will either perform the marriage or recognize it as such, resistance in the middle is meaningless.  It’s untenable to have a country where marriage is available and recognized by some states and not others.  With resistance futile, it no longer matters what legislators in hick states think.  It’s a done deal.  The only thing left to be proven is which states are so ridiculously out of touch that they will continue to fight the tide and reduce themselves to America’s latest joke.

Now that this chapter in history has come to an end, let’s realize its significance.  First, gay and Lesbian couples will no longer be able to hide behind discrimination to absolve themselves of responsibility for their actions and inactions.  Either get married or not, but if you do not chose to marry, then don’t expect a separate set of rights from everyone else to compensate.  If you marry, it will encompass the full panoply of rights and responsibilities.  If you don’t, then don’t expect special treatment.

This point was made by a post by Eugene Volokh challenging his readers to consider the conflict between two conservative positions.  On the one hand, conservatives favor marriage as means of providing stability to the family unit.  On the other, conservatives are against same-sex marriage because . . . they just are.  Gene asks, “who wins?” 

Mike at Crime & Federalism, who apparently is a closet Volokh Conspiracy fan, posts a screed against the overtly bigoted views of many who responded to Gene’s question.  Mike points to this comment, ripping the bigots for their true feelings, that they lack any rational basis to challenge gay marriage.  They just hate gays.  Some do so in the name of Jesus, blanketing their hatred (of the act, not the person, they say) in the warmth of religion.  But it’s just good old American irrational prejudice.

There will no doubt be debates in the future, as there has in the past, about the impact of same-sex couples on raising children.  Of course, all heterosexual couples do a great job of it, and single parents are having a ball dealing with the tribulations of kids.  There will be the ordinary challenges of love and subsequent unlove, with divorce rates being scrutinized to prove some point.  And so there should be, just as there should be of

The question to those antagonistic heterosexuals (or those fearing latent homosexual tendencies) as to why they should treat gays and Lesbians with respect is of little consequence.  Who cares what you think about the sexual preferences of others?  They’re queer.  They’re here.  They’re going to get married.  Get over it.

There are so many problems our society has to deal with that are of true meaning and consequence.  Recognition of same-sex marriage is now off the table.  If you need to find something to hate to make yourself feel special, focus on injustice.  It’s not going away anytime soon.

As for those who will avail themselves of same-sex marriage, congratulations and welcome to the ordinary world of fun and games, pain and aggravation.  Your wish has come true.  Be careful. 

For those readers who prefer to read my posts in their original French, please see Du mariage homosexuel en Amérique at Rubin Sfadj.  I sound so much better in French.

Litigator Whines, Fly Me! (Update)

Once again, shame rains down on trial lawyers because some overly-sensitive litigator can’t understand the word “NO”.  According to the AP report:

Attorney Richard Roth says not only did he and his family arrive in Buenos Aires, Argentina, almost three days late, he had to spend unplanned thousands of dollars on food, hotels and transportation, and buy tickets for another airline.

And because Delta misplaced his luggage, Roth’s lawsuit says, he had to buy new clothes for himself and family members after arriving in Buenos Aires.

Though he was promised Delta would bring his luggage, Roth says he had to drive to the airport in Buenos Aires to look for and retrieve his bags himself.

So here’s another he-man trial lawyer who thinks he can muscle the airlines with a lawsuit just because he had the patience of a gnat.  His bags were misplace.  Like it never happened to anyone else. 

But what really pushed his buttons was that some gatekeeper, responsible for hundred of other people, wouldn’t bend over backwards at his command.


In Atlanta, say court papers filed Friday in Manhattan’s state Supreme Court, a gate agent refused to let Roth and his family onto the jet for the connecting flight, although the plane was sitting at the gate with the door open.

Roth says his cousin, already on the plane, told him by cellphone there were several empty seats. When Roth asked the agent to speak to the pilot, he replied, “The pilot is not in charge here. I am. All the pilot does is fly the plane.”

How dare anyone defy the litigator.  Don’t they know how important he is?  Don’t they realize they should cower when he speaks?  If he says he wants to speak to the pilot, then the gate agent ought to jump.  Instead, just a little sass brought a lawsuit down on Delta’s head.  And what’s a little sass worth these days?


Roth said Tuesday he wants $21,000 for out-of-pocket expenses and another $275,000 in compensatory damages for emotional distress. He said he also wants punitive damages that would be at least three times the compensatory amount.

Kinda makes you want to take vacations for a living, doesn’t it?  Just to see how much you can milk out of an airline on the shoulders of all the other passengers who just want to fly without all the drama. 

Of course, if a guy like Richard Roth didn’t step up to the plate to do something about the fact that the airline left him high and dry in Atlanta on December 20, in the midst of his family’s trip to Argentina to celebrate his mother’s 80th birthday, telling him he was screwed and they couldn’t get him down there until January 8th, even though he had return tickets on December 28, next time it could be you. 

So to all you lawyer-haters out there, who do you think is going to do the heavy lifting to keep the airlines honest, so you don’t end up getting screwed like Richard Roth?  That could never happen to you, right?

Update:  It appears that my effort at sarcasm has left some wondering whether I am castigating Ross.  While I would have thought the final two paragraphs would clear it up, let me eliminate any confusion.  The airline industry has long viewed itself as having no responsibility to fulfill its agreements to consumers, and has been one of the worst, most callous abusers of its custmers in America.  I applaud Richard Roth for taking action against Delta and think Delta’s conduct is horrendous and fully deserving of punitive damages.  Not just because of what it did to Roth and his family.  My use of sarcasm in this post was to note how often people deride trial lawyers for taking actions that protect the rest of us. 


Shame First, Convict Later

Nassau County Executive Tom Suozzi has come up with a great way to prove how he’s doing something about drunk driving.  After a county cop was seriously hurt after being struck by a drunk driver as he was stopped to ticket a drunk driver, the expected public outcry was that “somebody has to do something.”  The cops swore to nail a bunch, and they got 109 over the holiday weekend.

But that wasn’t good enough.  Per this Newsday article, Suozzi created his “Wall of Shame,” showing photographs and identifying the people arrested.  No doubt his constituents will love him dearly for his “doing something,” as they demanded.


And in what county officials called an unapologetic effort to shame those charged, the names and addresses of the suspects were itemized and distributed to the media; the mug shots of the 81 people charged with driving while intoxicated were to be posted on the county government’s Web site.

But, does anybody consider that this public shaming puts the cart before the horse?  Let’s see what the lawprofs have to say.


“Is it ethical to shame a person before they have been deemed guilty?” asked Hofstra University ethicist Professor Arthur Dobrin. “Whatever can be done should be in this fight [against drunken driving], provided it is both legal and ethical. Here it may very well cross the line of the latter.”

Thanks for the forceful view, Arthur.  Anyone else?


But Hofstra Law School professor Robin Charlow said in a recent interview that Suozzi was on the right track constitutionally.  “We want to use the criminal law to deter others from committing crimes. Shaming individuals — which Suozzi is attempting — serves the same function,” she said.

Robin Charlow, just so you know, teaches con law and crim law. 

Fortunately, someone has the guts to cut to the chase, popular opinion notwithstanding:


The outrage here is that the government is going out of its way to embarrass citizens who may or may not be guilty,” said Tara Keenan-Thomson, executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union’s Nassau County chapter. She said Suozzi’s policy of “naming and shaming” may run afoul of a United States Supreme Court decision barring governments from disgracing people before their guilt has been proved, on the grounds that such actions violate due process.

To their credit, there’s one more piece to the puzzle.  Not a single newspaper was willing to go along with Suozzi’s “naming and shaming” approach. 

Humanizing Mel Weiss

Slater at WSJ Law Blog posts about the pre-sentence submissions for Mel Weiss, whose plea deal was nothing short of spectacular.  I was going to steal Slater’s title just to get back at him, but it sucked so I’m giving him a pass on this one.

The deal was cut, but the work isn’t done.  Now the government and defense need to hash out the actual numbers.


Weiss, the former head of the law firm now known as Milberg LLP, pleaded guilty last month to racketeering conspiracy in connection with the firm’s alleged improper payments of kickbacks to class-action clients. He is slated to be sentenced on Monday. Prosecutors are seeking a 33-month sentence while Mr. Weiss would like the judge to impose a term on the lowest end of the range in his plea agreement – 18 months, with at least half of that period either in community service and/or home confinement.

This is where the pre-sentence memorandum and letters come into play.  Up to now, Mel is just a defendant who committed a crime.  Now exactly the image that we try to instill in the judge’s head as we argue for bottom of the guidelines or less.  This is when the judge needs to see a three-dimensional human being.  He already knows the defendant did wrong; now it’s time to show that he’s done right in his life as well, that he’s helped others, meant something to people, served humanity in some way that mitigates the harm that brought him there.

Team Weiss has submitted 275 letters on Mel’s behalf.  That’s a lot of letters.  Whether it’s too many, or just the right amount (not a chance in the world that it’s too few) is a matter of content and context.  Slater has read through the letters, and this is what he found worthy of mention:


Collectively, the letters speak to the traits of kindness, integrity, as well as remorse. Several mention work on behalf of Holocaust victims, while others mention specific acts of generosity. Donald Kempf, the former chief legal officer at Morgan Stanley says that after an unexpected on-the-street encounter, Weiss offered to help Kempf find a certain kind of watch. “And he did.”

According to a letter submitted by a friend and art dealer in Sun Valley, Idaho, in a “spontaneous” gesture while in Vienna, Weiss bought the art dealer’s wife an expensive pair of boots. Weiss also submitted a letter, in which he asks to be allowed the chance to “use the skills I have developed to help others and hopefully help undo the damage I have caused.”

An interesting juxtaposition is presented.  Helping Holocaust victims versus finding some rich guy a watch, or buying an art dealer’s wife a pair of boots?  The former is the sort of thing that shows the other side of the defendant, the one that the judge should be apprised of before lowering the boom for the crime.  But watches and boots for rich people not only fail to meet the test of fleshing out a person’s humanity, but smack of elitism, shameless waste and misdirected “kindness”.  How many homeless people were stepped on while Mel was shopping for that antique Rolex Daytona?

One of the problems with letters of support is “damning with faint praise.”  If defense counsel feels that the best that can be said of his client is that he bought an art dealer’s wife a pair of boots, then this guy is a creep.  It’s not that there aren’t good things to be said, but why contrast the good with such counterproductive letters?


Reading through all these, we were of two minds. One was that Mel Weiss really does sound like a pretty good guy. The other: Is this going to have a whit of difference on his sentence? It might, says Douglas Berman, the author of the Sentencing Law & Policy blog. “It’s like chicken soup,” says Berman. “You don’t know if it’ll help, but it probably can’t hurt.”

That’s not what I was thinking at all as I read Slater’s piece.  When a pre-sentence submission is done well, it has a significant impact on the judge’s view of the defendant.  It may not mean that he goes below the guidelines, but it provides a strong basis for obtaining the best possible sentence. 

The problem here is that given the very high number of letters, and given that some of them, at minimum, fail to serve the defendant’s best interest at sentence, the submission can backfire.  It can just as easily show that a defendant who has achieved as much financial success as Mel Weiss has done remarkably little to help society or humanity.  It portrays a greedy, self-serving human being, whose idea of helping others is throwing some cash at them, provided they are in his “league”.  Not exactly endearing.

So it’s not at all like chicken soup.  It most assuredly can help, and it similarly can hurt.  There is nothing that demonstrates how little a person has done, or cares, about anything but himself than a voluminous but weak show of support.  Sure, some letters come back devoid of any useless bit of information, but then you don’t include those letters in your submission.


That said, Berman says that defense lawyers still have to walk a fine line between giving a judge a complete picture of a person and, well, overdoing it. “You don’t want a judge asking whether he really wants to hear from all these people,” says Berman. “Lawyers have to ask how much they want to push the envelope.”

That’s the lawyer’s job, knowing what serves to help the client as opposed to what hurts, or undermines, his position.  The problem is quality versus quantity.  Not only can the submission become excessive and burdensome, though one should expect that judge to simply ignore the excess as requiring way too much time to be worth the bother, but a handful of truly helpful, meaningful, informative letters will do far more than a couple of hundred letters about finding some Morgan Stanley guy a watch.

It’s really not that fine a line when done properly.  If it wouldn’t make a difference to you, leave it out.  If it makes your client look greedy and self-serving, toss it.  If it’s more than even the defendant’s mother would bother to read, then it’s too much.  Pre-sentence submissions are just as strategic as any other part of a case, and it’s hardly in a defendant’s best interest to throw everything against a wall and hope something tastes like chicken soup.

Why We Think Like Mush

Following up on my ode to the slippery slope, Mike at Crime & Federalism has an important post about how we think, and why we do it wrong, that’s a must-read.  Mike reviews the book, “Don’t Believe Everything You Think: The 6 Basic Mistakes We Make in Thinking,” by Thomas Kida, and it is indeed enlightening.

Oddly, Mike only lists 5 “mistakes”, the book title notwithstanding.  The “mistakes” are:

The narrative fallacy
Confirmation bias
Mistaking coincidence for causation
Memory sucks
We are super simple Simons


Check out Mike’s post for an explanation of each of the “mistakes”, then come back when you’re done.  I’ll wait. . .

Okay, now let’s consider why they are crucial to criminal defense lawyers.  If our purpose is to persuade, it’s critical that we do so effectively or we’ve just sent our guy up the river.  The first step is not to allow our own thought processes to fall into these traps.

Defendants come to us grasping at straws.  They are desperate to convince us that they can and should win by falling into the very thinking traps Kida notes, particularly with issues of memory (gestalt theory), coincidence (which I discuss often under the heading of inductive reasoning) and oversimplification.  Confirmation bias is simply telling them what they want to hear.

If we can recognize their flawed thinking, we can avoid heading blindly down a path to disaster.  It’s often difficult, it not impossible, to get clients to see why their heartfelt beliefs will crash and burn as a defense, and that’s unlikely to change even if the error of their thinking is pointed out.  Reason is overcome by desperation in the defendants’ mind, but we can’t afford to let that happen in our own mind.

After realizing that we, like everyone else, indulge ourselves in fuzzy thinking, we can recognize the error in our approach, eliminate the ineffective, indulgent arguments and develop a strategy that is directed toward winning over the only minds that matter, the jurors’.

But these errors come back into play again, this time as the mechanism to convince a gang of 12 who suffer from the same malady of fuzzy thinking.  Turn the tables and use these tricks as the tools of persuasion. 

Every lawyer knows how defendants offer incredibly complex excuses for their conduct, usually challenging fact after fact with long-winded, highly improbable explanations that make perfect sense to them but require a jury to adopt so many assumptions that the chances of their accepting the defendants excuses are nil.  Well, Kida tells us to simplify. and he’s right.

By cutting the lengthy tale of woe down to two or three sentences, we can sell an explanation that would never fly otherwise.  Frame it as a story and enjoy the benefits of the narrative fallacy.  Offer coincidence as if it were causation and they will accept it.

This is great stuff, not just for understanding ourselves and why our own thinking is so often less than perfect, but as weapons for the fight. 

I see that Gideon has also posted about this, and reminds us of Occam’s Razor and Bennett’s Chainsaw, discussed here as well.  If Gid felt compelled to point to Mike’s post, it’s got to be important.

Millennials: It’s Awesome to be Us

Coming on the heels of Dan Hull’s slightly negative reaction to the proposition that the world should change to suit the whims of our most youthful new members of the workforce, the original newsmagazine 60 Minutes, whose primary correspondents have a combined age of 497 years did a segment last Sunday on a group it calls the “Millennials”. 

Edit:  Hull has thrown me a bone by sharing a slice of the Hull McGuire vernacular:  Hereinafter, Millennials shall be known at Simple Justice as “The Slackoisie.”

Before cutting to the videotape of the segment, you should note that it was originally broadcast in November, 2007, and updated for May, 2008.  A few things have changed between those dates, and as I watched the segment, I wondered whether one critical assumption still held true.

The clout of the Millenials (what we previously called Gen Y,I believe) is in the claim that as they enter the workforce, there are far more jobs than Millenials to fill them.  In other words, they may be a bunch of narcissistic, self-absorbed babies, but we need them anyway.

Do we still need them?  One of my issues with 60 Minutes is that, while they court controversy well, they rarely challenge the self-serving statements of their interviewees directly.  As the video shows, the consultants who are busily earning some very good fees from companies by advising how to make Millennials “feel good” about their work, the only thing that seems to matter to the members of this group, attribute some wonderful qualities to them. 

Are Millennials really so wonderful?  Let’s see: They’re well educated, but inherently lazy.  They are techno-savvy, but don’t see themselves as serving anyone but themselves.  They are the most talented generation?  Says who?  Are they talented in treating your clients with respect?  Not that I can see.  And they have to be taught how to eat with a fork and knife?  They have to be cajoled into showing up for work every day?  This seems to be a significant gap.

Now it’s one thing if there aren’t any competent, non-whiny warm bodies left on the face of the earth to fill the open slots in business.  But at the moment, I suspect that there are more bodies available than before, and that employers will be more than happy to cut out the balloon parties on Friday and gently explain to their employees to either get to work or go find their perfect job.  Elsewhere.

Anyway, enjoy Morley Safer’s take on kids (talk about irony) and wonder, if this is our future, are we in worse trouble than we thought?