Author Archives: SHG

SJ to WSJ: Stop Stealing My Stuff!

Today, the Wall Street Journal law blog has a big story:


Forfeiture and the Sixth Amendment: From Drug to White-Collar Cases?



When White Powder Law Meets White Collar


Now I can understand the pressure on Dan Slater to produce good quality work for his gig at the WSJ.  I know how hard it is, day after day, to find something interesting to write about.  I appreciate the drudgery when your paycheck is on the line, when thousands of readers are counting on you to produce, when the kids need to get fed again today.

But Dan, as much as I realize that you’re working with a gun to your head, you’ve got to stop coming over here to glom my pieces.  Sure, link to me and riff off my stuff all you want.  I get it.  I’m just some blawging knucklehead (a name I’ve come to admire) and you work for the Wall Street Journal.  It’s not like Rupert takes hostages, right?

Even so, it’s just not nice.  Hey, send me an email saying, “Yo, Scott, mind if I take one of yours from the weekend?  I’m stuck and Murdoch’s all over me like flies on the New York Post.”  I cool with that.  I let people borrow pretty liberally.  I’ve got a heart.

Or buy me a beer some time.  And Turk too, because we drink together (we’re like a team).  That way, when we pass out in a stupor after the first beer, there’s someone we can fall on and not hurt ourselves. 

Look Dan, you’re welcome here whenever you want.  While we have yet to bond, I consider us brothers in arms, so to speak, so I’m here for you.  Just give me the heads up next time.  And if you want, I’ll even write a couple of extra posts just for you and you can have them whole, lock, stock and barrel.  No need to thank me.  That’s the kind of blawger I am.

Do Baby Governments Need Their Own Sarbanes-Oxley?

Hot on the heels of the Long Island/New York school district attorney/superintendent scandal, which has and will continue to expand as long and as far as anybody who wishes to scratch the surface will take it, comes this curious solution from the opinionistas at Newsday.  What if there was a Sarbanes-Oxley-type law holding elected officials both responsible, and criminally liable, for the competent exercise of independent judgment?


One school superintendent said that his contract prohibits the school board from meeting unless he is present in the room, according to Nassau County Comptroller Howard Weitzman, who told the story at a hearing on Thursday. Weitzman’s point was that the contract provision greatly reduced any chance that independent auditors could alert school board members about financial problems.


“I was told this was a common practice,” Weitzman said of the contract provision. “This is a cultural issue that needs to be looked at and discussed openly.”


He said the schools need a culture change, to which hearing convener Attorney General Andrew Cuomo responded, “Prosecute the violations of law, and then you’ll see the culture change.”


This scene could have played out in the private sector in the days before Sarbanes-Oxley reform.


The Sarbanes-Oxley Act was passed in 2002 in the wake of major corporate and accounting scandals at Enron, Tyco International, Adelphia and WorldCom. Sen. Paul Sarbanes (D-Md.) and Rep. Michael Oxley (R-Ohio) recognized that the boards of directors at these companies did not have enough information or professional acumen to see the impending doom. Board members were supposed to be in charge of the company, but instead they were under the thumb of the chief executive and other senior managers.


Sarbanes-Oxley, among other things, established new standards for boards of public companies — including criminal penalties for not living up to the duties. The act stressed that outside auditors must be free to express their concerns to the board, without the company’s managers present.


If the directors of private corporations are liable for their failure to live up to their duties, should we expect less from public elected officials?  After all, the shareholders of corporations made an active decision to invest; Taxpayers have no such choice. 

Having spent some time around a variety of local government units, what I like to call baby governments, there are two overarching things that smack you hard in the face.  First, the majority of people involved, though largely well intended, lack the competencies to perform the job.  They can’t read a budget.  They don’t have a clue about the law, or even the basic civics involved.  They are incapable of critical analysis. 

These problems are exacerbated by the fact that taxypayers are generally clueless as to how their baby governments function, holding some strange belief that there are a bunch of gnomes in a backroom somewhere doing the legwork necessary to provide all the services they think they’re receiving.  They believe that this is happening because they want to believe.  The alternative, that a bunch of taxpayer money is flushed down the broken and dirty toilet of their baby government, is too unpalatable.  At best, it’s deeply depressing.  At worst, it would compel action, and people don’t want to get involved.  They pay taxes so other people can get involved and do it for them.

The negative to such a plan is that a SOX type responsibility would likely prove quite costly to baby governments, both in terms of redundant safeguards as well as the availability of competent elected officials.  There are not enough people interested in running for office for volunteer jobs that suck up a substantial amount of time (if done properly) and offer little by way of prestige, except to those with the lowest self-esteem.  Competent people are busy, and busy people don’t care to spend their time on such parochial matters.

A secondary problem is that people assume greater self-competency than they deserve.  This is a pervasive problem, as very few people can apply the level of self-criticism needed to recognize that they lack the knowledge, experience or integrity needed for public service.  The Dunning-Kruger Effect is in full force, and the greater the desire to achieve prominence, the lesser the ability to realize their incompetence.

That said, there is essentially nothing available at present to hold a baby government elected official responsible for their actions, and hence no motivator to constrain them to be responsible.   Reliance on the “professionals”, the very people who lead them down the path to perdition, is pervasive.  Most think that this is the way it’s supposed to be, with elected officials doing little more than smiling as they rubber stamp.  It’s a very easy job when no thought is required, and no thought it required when there is no liability for malfeasance.

While SOX is subject to well-deserved criticism for being unduly onerous on small corporations, and frequently creating very costly processes when there is no clear need to make everything more complex, that doesn’t mean the threat of criminal prosecution doesn’t serve a purpose.  Without consequences, the only force that drives people to do the right thing is their internal sense of integrity.  History teaches that integrity isn’t always sufficient.

This is an avenue that is definitely worthy of greater exploration.

A Prosecutor Discovers the Joys of “Clients”

Fifteen minutes or so after I hit the play button on Ken Lammer’s CLTV #27 (the one where he’s wearing a lavender shirt at the beginning, and swills a beer by the end), I took a look at a young prosecutor’s blawg that Ken favors.  This particular blawg is often mentioned by the Star and Host of CLTV, but I hesitate to look because it presents one huge problem, it has no actual name. 

The latest title appears to be Ubjeckshin, Home of Speezy Story Time.  I guess prosecutors feel no need for branding, which is understandable.

Ken raised my consciousness to Speezy’s latest post about why he hates prosecuting assault cases.  Aside from some issues he has with what constitutes an “assault”, which I leave alone since I don’t know the laws in his jurisdiction, his rant is directed toward the true bane of a prosecutor’s existence:  The Victim.


The first category of victims follows a very predictable pattern.  Defendant gets angry with Victim, and then Victim gets scared.  Victim calls 911.  Cops show up, and Victim suddenly changes their mind.  Defendant gets arrested anyway, gets thrown in jail, gets charged, and becomes my problem.  Victim comes to me and says they do not want to press charges, because Defendant is a good person and they just overreacted (or some other lame excuse).

There you go.  Angry = crime.  Not so angry = waste of perfectly good prosecutorial time.  Hello?  Don’t you victims know that he’s got better things to do than listen to you change your mind?  He’s got criminals to put in jail who commit real crimes, and here you are sucking up valuable resources that could be better spent nailing loiterers to the wall.  At least with loiterers, there’s no flipping victim to get all wiggly on him.

But this isn’t the victim that really galls him.  This one is:


The other set of victims usually start frothing at the mouth the moment you initiate prosecution of their case.  They hound you constantly, trying to interject “important information” every step of the way.  And the moment you tell them that their “information” is either crap, or otherwise unusable (which it almost always is), they get pissed at you.  Of course, it is obviously my fault that the rules of evidence and criminal procedure are the way that they are, and shame on me for not changing them specifically for this case…due process be damned!  What is even better, though, is that they insist on trial no matter what…alternative resolutions simply are not acceptable, and some even consider them a violation of their “victims’ rights.” 

Don’t you just HATE THAT!  People getting all angry and demanding and irrational.  They are SOOOO annoying!
They call you every ten minutes with some new whine or complaint, or just to revisit whatever angst they shared the day before, relishing the moment as they roll it over again and again in their mind.

Share the hatred.  Join in the anger.  Something has to be different, and you have to make it different.  You are the problem because you are supposed to be the solution.  AAaaarrrggghhh (not the pirate aarrgghh, but the frustrated prosecutor one). 

Welcome to the law.  We all agree that the practice of law would be so much more fun but for the clients.  So the victim isn’t really your client, but they don’t know that.  They think you work for them.  I mean really, just because they pay your salary (of course, most don’t actually pay taxes, so they really don’t, but they think they do and they say it anyway). 

Dealing with the human side of the law frustrates everyone.  Some clients are wonderful.  Cooperative and appreciative, they work with us to maximize our ability to serve them and fulfill their goals.  Most don’t.  Some are insane.  Some cannot get a grip on their emotions, and while they don’t mean to drive us nuts or take up every waking moment of our time to the preclusion of actually performing the legal work we’re supposed to be doing, they do.  Some we can manage to handle; Others can’t be controlled.

When you are first starting out in the law, your ability and willingness to tolerate the vicissitudes of human beings is limited.  You are impatient, easily frustrated and intolerant.  It gets worse from there.  If you can’t deal with it as a prosecutor, where your livelihood doesn’t depend upon the love and admiration of these terrible victims, you’re really going to hate it if you ever leave the dark side and become a criminal defense lawyer.

For better or worse, these are THE PEOPLE that the Constitution speaks about.  And they aren’t going to change.

Harvard Law Review Activist Ripped to Shreds

While most criminal defense lawyers studiously avoid anything bearing the name “Harvard” as a matter of personal choice, I found it impossible to ignore this post by David Bernstein over at Volokh about a student note in the (hushed tone) Harvard Law Review entitled Never Again Should a People Starve in a World of Plenty.

Described as “bizarre”, Bernstein notes that “[i]f there is any traditional legal analysis in this Note, it’s not obvious (though I admit that I didn’t read the entire thing).”  The note, by HLS student Phil Telfeyan, is a passion play on morality versus justice set within the wealthiest University in the world.

If Bernstein’s damnation of this note seems harsh, it’s nothing.  The comments to the post rip the author to shreds.  The readers are offended, outraged and predict the fall of Harvard Law School as a direct result of the publication of this screed for the poor.  Who is this sanctimonious punk to litter HLR with this pap?  How dare he besmirch the history and tradition of HLR with his political rant? 

Granted, Harvard Law Review is generally considered a source for thoughtful legal analysis, and this polemic does not quite fill that niche.  Also granted, Phil is an “angry young man” who has yet to realize that his morality versus justice views are not exactly novel. 

But the depth of anger and outrage against this law student was shocking.  If the commenters sought to express their disgust toward this young man and HLR for having published his Note, the harshness of their attack and lack of any interest in what purpose or benefit could be derived from it was worse.

One of the most disturbing things raised with some regularity about young people today is their lack of social conscience.  This third MTV generation is lazy, self-absorbed and grossly materialistic, we often note.  Well, here’s one young man who is not.  Yes, he is sanctimonious, but aren’t all angry young men?  Would they have felt better if his Note was about vicarious liability of Ferrari ownership instead of sacrificing a Ferrari to save the life of a little girl?

Here was a young man with a strong belief, and an opportunity to express his strong belief in a national platform of some recognition.  Harvard Law Review!  For Telfeyan, how much better could the soapbox get?  Can anyone blame him for using this opportunity to express his strongly held belief that our resort to justice at the expense of morality was an inexcusable disgrace? 

And so, the alleged grown-ups were outraged.  The alleged grown-ups are always outraged when some punk kid tells us what we already know, even if we don’t adhere to a moral path with much regularity.  There could have been a swelling of chests, a pride in the fact that some kid took a wild-eyed chance to promote a social agenda that helps others.  Even libertarians aren’t inherently against morality, though giving up the Ferrari (which model, some asked themselves) might have caused a true dilemma.

But what of the vaunted Harvard Law Review’s decision to publish this rant?   It wasn’t legal analysis, the outraged grown-ups screamed.  How dare they sully this sanctum sanctorum of intellectual integrity.  They could have used the pages to deconstruct truly important legal questions, like whether Indiana Jones’ rights were violated during his interview with F.B.I. agents.

Whether Phil Telfeyan stood on a soap box in Harvard Yard, or published in Harvard Law Review, isn’t nearly as important as the fact that we need the next generation of people who care about something other than themselves, their Biglaw job and their eventual Ferrari.  It warms my heart to know that there is a Phil Telfeyan waiting in the wings to fill the shoes of social activists who came before him. 

And the commenters to Bernstein’s post, from former HLR editors to Biglaw pretenders, your castigation of this Note and personal attacks on its author reveal only how shallow and myopic you are.  There is a disgrace to be found here, and it is your intolerance of anything that would defile your Bible, the Harvard Law Review.  What a terrible shame that all that intellectual effort was put into beating up on this punk kid instead of doing something to help someone.

Has a College Education Reached Oversaturation?

Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, enjoys a breath and scope of interests that never ceases to amaze.  In her travels, she’s come up with this poignant tale of “Professor X” in the Atlantic, In the Basement of the Ivory Tower.

Parents tell their children that if they work hard, they can grow up to be president.  It helps if your father was president, of course, but still it’s possible.  Unless you suffer from one problem.  You aren’t very smart.  Okay, maybe not.  But let’s not let politics get in the way of an important point, shall we?


My students take English 101 and English 102 not because they want to but because they must. Both colleges I teach at require that all students, no matter what their majors or career objectives, pass these two courses. For many of my students, this is difficult. Some of the young guys, the police-officers-to-be, have wonderfully open faces across which play their every passing emotion, and when we start reading “Araby” or “Barn Burning,” their boredom quickly becomes apparent. They fidget; they prop their heads on their arms; they yawn and sometimes appear to grimace in pain, as though they had been tasered. Their eyes implore: How could you do this to me?

The rule of thumb is that everyone should have a college degree.  We take for granted that education makes us better at what we do, expands our horizons and allows us to understand and appreciate our world more fully.  But there’s a secret problem with this rule.  Not everybody is cut out for a college education.


The bursting of our collective bubble comes quickly. A few weeks into the semester, the students must start actually writing papers, and I must start grading them. Despite my enthusiasm, despite their thoughtful nods of agreement and what I have interpreted as moments of clarity, it turns out that in many cases it has all come to naught.

Remarkably few of my students can do well in these classes. Students routinely fail; some fail multiple times, and some will never pass, because they cannot write a coherent sentence.

Whether it’s because students lack the requisite skills, intelligence or motivation to do well is no longer relevant.  Whether it’s because the teacher can’t communicate effectively to impart the information needed to succeed is irrelevant.  The idea that everyone in America should be a college graduate may simply be a pipe dream.  At some point, each of us takes responsibility for our own lives, and if we can’t manage the degree of effort required to produce work and thought at a college level, then we have no one to blame but ourselves.  And maybe that’s okay.


The colleges and the students and I are bobbing up and down in a great wave of societal forces—social optimism on a large scale, the sense of college as both a universal right and a need, financial necessity on the part of the colleges and the students alike, the desire to maintain high academic standards while admitting marginal students—that have coalesced into a mini-tsunami of difficulty. No one has drawn up the flowchart and seen that, although more-widespread college admission is a bonanza for the colleges and nice for the students and makes the entire United States of America feel rather pleased with itself, there is one point of irreconcilable conflict in the system, and that is the moment when the adjunct instructor, who by the nature of his job teaches the worst students, must ink the F on that first writing assignment.

There can be no success without failure.  A college degree means little if everyone has one.  And the American Utopian dream of everyone receiving a fine education may have finally hit the wall.

As a relatively educated person, I have great respect for higher education.  I also have great respect for someone who can field-strip the SU carbs on my Healey.  Whether he can quote Shelley while doing so doesn’t concern me greatly. 

As a parent, I hope that my children will have better and easier lives than I did, or my parents did.  But most of all, I hope they find a place where they will be happy.  I expect that it will require higher education, but I could be wrong.  It would likely disappoint me at first, and I would anticipate fighting it because I, like most parents, think I know better about what would make my kids happy.  But ultimately, I would do everything possible to support their dreams.  It’s not like my choices have always panned out so well.

It must be terribly painful for the anonymous author to have reached the realization that despite all his/her efforts and desires to help, most of his/her students would still fail.  But even the ivory tower has a basement, and even the basement has a floor.  It doesn’t necessarily mean that those students who can’t manage to stand on the floor of the basement are unworthy, but just that they are in the wrong building.

Criminal Lawyers Market with Class

Leave it to Ted Frank at Overlawyered to find the best of the worst.  Play the message to get the full experience.


If you got a ticket or were arrested you gotta call
1-888-9-NOT-GUILTY

Talk to an Attorney immediately free of charge

It’s a Free call…you have nothing to lose but the points on your license


How did I ever miss the boat, busy learning the law and honing my skills, when all I really needed to do was get some woman to pose suggestively wearing a police cap. 

Oddly, I would like to tell you where this firm is located, or who this Shugar person might be, but nowhere does that information appear.  But it’s a free call, so what the heck.

The Start of a Hamptons Summer

Memorial Day weekend is the official start of summer in the Hamptons, Long Island’s playground for the rich and famous (together with about a zillion tourists from New Jersey who want to pretend to be New Yorkers).  Time to pull out the linen suits, and switch over to the Murakami version of the Louis handbags.

Proof that summer is now official in the Hamptons came this weekend with the massive police raid on the Vered Gallery in East Hampton.  Of course, crime in the Hamptons isn’t exactly like crime elsewhere.  According to Newsday :


About 200 art aficionados were sipping Veuve Clicquot Champagne and chilled white wine at an East Hampton gallery this weekend when the police arrived.

It was a soiree like many others for Vered Gallery, which twice a month invites guests to drink, nibble cheese and view its latest show.  But this time, gallery owner Ruth Vered was led away in handcuffs.

East Hampton Village police declined to comment Sunday except to confirm in a written statement that the gallery owner, who is widely known as Vered, was charged with selling alcohol without a liquor license.

“Free Vered,” rang out through the crowd, as police let her away in handcuffs.   It’s likely been decades since many have had a halfway decent chance to protest. 







Still, it was unclear why the police choose to target Vered to make their point.  She was having an opening on Saturday night, and served the required Veuve Clicquot (non-vintage) to her guests. 

She doesn’t charge for the champagne.  That would be gauche.  Vered would never be gauche. 

I’ve enjoyed Vered Gallery for years.  They specialize in overpriced Picassos and the occasional Braque, with the typical bunch of Caldors and Chagalls for those with more money than taste.  There are a lot of people like that in East Hampton.  Vered is quite the eccentric character, dressed like Johnny Cash on a designer budget.  She is the quintessential Hamptons art purveyor.

The gallery is officially listed as being on Park Place.  If you haven’t had the pleasure of spending time in East Hampton, Park Place is a pretentious name for an alley way between the main street and the public parking lot. 

There used to be a nice little ice cream parlor on the corner, that’s been morphed into a Starbucks.  It’s just a stone’s throw from where the original Barefoot Contessa’s place used to be, before she became a Food TV star and left East Hampton without any place to buy a decent prepackaged dinner.

At Hamptons.com, the arrest was big news.


The highly visible display of “Nine police cars and Vered being hauled away in cuffs was clearly police harassment,” partner Lehr asserted in a phone interview Sunday morning. With the crowd of on-lookers chanting “Free Vered,” Lehr took the opportunity to point out that “the show is sexy, and the gallery was filled with fashionistas.”

So while others debate and discuss our prisons filled with the poor and the injustices heaped upon society by a government hellbent on criminalizing every aspect of the human condition, it’s critically important that you know that the Hamptons have not escaped unscathed.

Welcome to summer.

Is the Death Penalty the Worst Punishment?

Scott Hanson at Grits for Breakfast, reacting to a local Texas prosecutor’s blawg inquiry at Harris County Criminal Justice Center, asks the question, which is worse, the death penalty or life without parole.  Scott tries to stir things up a bit by suggesting that death may not be worse, should there be an afterlife.  After all, Scott writes, “But death is also a sentence to which we’re all condemned – everyone’s entry card to the human condition bears an unknowable expiration date – which makes it at once as un-extraordinary as it is exceptional.”

Some commenters took Scott to task for stretching quite so far to find a rationale, but I suspect that Scott was trying to expand the inquiry far enough to get people to do something novel.  Think.  Playing devil’s advocates is a time-honored means of asking people to go beyond their knee-jerk reaction.  I think Scott’s effort here was well placed, even if his argument was a little fuzzy.  Most of us would answer this question on autopilot if no one pushed us any harder.

I would have been one of the mindless had I not had an experience a few years ago that tested my assumptions.  I’ve mentioned it in past posts, so regular readers will note its familiarity.  I was half of a contingent meeting with a judge from Mainland China. My bookend was Larry Goldman, former president of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and sophisticated New York bon vivant.

Eventually, discussion turned to China’s execution of prisoners, enough to make a Texan blush.  Bearing in mind that China (pre-quake) had far more people than it could handle, I anticipated that the judge would view life as a rather expendable commodity, and justify the imposition of the death penalty as being a fairly mundane sanction, where a billion fewer people would not be noticed.

The judge did not.  Not at all.  He was quite serious in explaining that he believed that death was a kinder outcome to the defendant than life in a Chinese prison without parole.  In fact, he was critical of our view that putting a human being in prison for the rest of his life like a caged animal was less cruel. 

The picture he painted (mind you, he was talking about Chinese prisons, not American) was of a slow, lingering death of 20 to 50 years, maybe even longer, making it sound like a means of horrible torture.  Death by a thousand days, rather than swift and painless not too painful.  He could not understand why we would think the suffering of life in prison was of a lesser quality than execution.

Larry immediately chimed in that he agreed, making a point of noting that I would no doubt disagree with him as well as the Chinese judge.  Larry stated that if faced with the choice of spending the rest of his life locked in a prison cell with no hope of ever walking free, he too would prefer death. 

Trying to be my normal, friendly, amendable self, I told Larry that his assumption about my views was misplaced.  If he was faced with the choice of death or life in prison, I would absolutely support his desire for immediate death.  I got him good. 

But the truth is that I realized that the agony of a life in prison without parole may be seen by some as more harsh than death.  Whether cultural, religious or pragmatic, the visceral reaction that death is always worse may not hold true for everyone. 

In an absolute sense, I still believe that death is the most severe punishment.  It is irrevocable.  There can be no change in the law that allows subsequent release.  There can be no change in treatment that enables a person once deemed incorrigible to be freed.  There can be no scientific breakthrough that proves a person innocent when once thought guilty.  Death is the end of the road, and there’s no going back.

And, as Scott contends, life leads to death for all of us, the only variable being time.  Some are fatalists, and decide that their time is up.  Some would find life in a cell too torturous to withstand.  Some would just be unable to live without hope, and find comfort in certainty.  I can see now, after the Chinese judge, that choices can reasonably differ, even if my choice would not.

Still, we need to decide as a society which punishment is most severe so that our hierarchy of punishments is clear.  The vast majority would view the death penalty as the worst we can do to one another, and it’s place as the ultimate sanction is secure. 

But it’s worth asking the question, and revisiting our answer every once in a while.  And it’s important to realize that there will comes times that a defendant would prefer death rather than life without parole.  It may not be the choice we would make, but it’s not outside the pale.  Just ask the Chinese judge.

Memorial Day 2008

Before considering what to write, or whether to write at all, about Memorial Day, I took a look at my post from last year.  It was a brief post, but made its point:

The catch phrase today is that freedom is not free.  But what is this freedom that is worthy fighting, and dying, for?  To show our respect for those who gave their lives for freedom, those of us who remain should be willing to stand up for that freedom and defend it.  We don’t fight for a particular President.  We don’t fight for a political party.  We don’t fight for some transitory policy.  We fight for enduring freedom.  Don’t give up the fight.  Take a moment today to think about it.  Others have given their lives for it.  It’s not much to do.

A year has past, and nothing has changed.   Young people are still dying in Iraq, and we’re still listening to people whose lives are not at risk debate about whether and when they can be brought home.  We’ve paid the price, but are still watching freedom ebb away.

A new factor has come into play this Memorial Day.  The ones who return from Iraq find themselves without jobs or the ability to fill their car with gasoline.  Before worrying about such existential concepts as freedom, people need to know that they can feed their children.  They don’t know whether they can, or for how long.

Everyone will say they honor the dead.  It’s the thing to do.  But speaking nicely of their sacrifice does little to change the fact that young men and women have died for their country.  And dead they remain.  And if we are no better for their sacrifice, then one has to doubt that it was sacrifice worth making.

It’s not their fault that nothing has changed between Memorial Day 2007 and now.  It’s ours.  They already gave of themselves.  If we truly honor their sacrifice, then it must be shown be more than kind words.  So this year, no more cheap talk on the back of dead kids.

Judges Around the World (Update)

Adam Liptak provides a fairly good compare and contrast piece today between how people get robes in the United States versus how judges are selected elsewhere. One might think that Americans elect judges because of some deep-seated theoretical paradigm to achieve a higher and better justice.  Not exactly.


“It’s a remnant of the populist Jacksonian image of public office,” [Herbert M. Kritzer, who was until recently a professor of law and political science at the University of Wisconsin] said. “We’re crazy about elections. The number of different offices we elect is enormous.”

Going back to an anti-elitist time in American history, when faith in the collective judgment of the people was elevated above all else in American politics, the idea of electing judges, together with dog-catcher, became popular.  There was no particular belief that elections were well-suited for identifying and placing people in the position of sitting in judgment, but rather a generic idea that small-d democracy was good, and whatever decision the people made, regardless of their actual ability to make it, was better than any other option.

The off-shoot of this default choice of electing judges has its issues.


“A simple explanation for our results,” wrote the paper’s authors — Stephen J. Choi, G. Mitu Gulati and Eric A. Posner — “is that electoral judgeships attract and reward politically savvy people, while appointed judgeships attract more professionally able people. However, the politically savvy people might give the public what it wants — adequate rather than great opinions, in greater quantity.”

There are many who frankly have no problem with this.  They argue that judges should be responsive to public opinion.  After all, why should our government ignore the will of the people?

The name for this is the tyranny of the majority, where the law changes with the wind and transitory popular notions dictate right and wrong.  For lawyers, this is a nightmare.  We believe that judges must be independent of the will of the people, so that they can make difficult decision without fear of public rebuke.  But that’s what lawyers think, and who cares what lawyers think?

But how do they do it elsewhere?


Contrast that distinctively American method of selecting judges with the path to the bench of Jean-Marc Baissus, a judge on the Tribunal de Grand Instance, a district court, in Toulouse, France. He still recalls the four-day written test he had to pass in 1984 to enter the 27-month training program at the École Nationale de la Magistrature, the elite academy in Bordeaux that trains judges in France.

“It gives you nightmares for years afterwards,” Judge Baissus said of the test, which is open to people who already have a law degree, and the oral examinations that followed it. In some years, as few as 5 percent of the applicants survive. “You come out of this completely shattered,” Judge Baissus said.

In other words, judges are required to have hard qualifications to fill the robes before they can even be considered.  Imagine that.  Qualifications! 


“You have people who actually know what the hell they’re doing,” Professor Lasser said. “They’ve spent years in school taking practical and theoretical courses on how to be a judge. These are professionals.”

“The rest of the world,” he added, “is stunned and amazed at what we do, and vaguely aghast. They think the idea that judges with absolutely no judge-specific educational training are running political campaigns is both insane and characteristically American.”

But this goes to qualifying individuals to serve as judges, not to who those individuals should be in the first place.  The French system is no more immune from cronyism than ours, and arguably ours is more transparent since we know and, to a small extent, have a say in who gets the vote.  Granted, our choices are limited to nominees from political bosses, and we make our decisions almost entirely uninformed, reducing votes to jokes when cast without basis.

While this article offers no solution, though it clearly favors the European approach, consensus is clear that of all the possible ways to pick a judge, popular election is the worst and most seriously flawed. 

Update:  I’ve received some questions about why I didn’t post more about other aspects of the article.  The article also superficially discusses how judges running for election change their behavior and play to the crowd.  This portion of the articles was obvious and therefore unworthy of much comment. 

If you wonder why judges pandering to the public to get their vote gives rise to problems, then you’ve likely been away from the country for a very long time.  Liptak’s treatment of this lacks any insight, and it was therefore not worthy of discussion in the context of the article. 

One good line from the article, that goes to my post about voter information yesterday, is worth repeating:


“You don’t get popular control out of this,” said Steven E. Schier, a professor of political science at Carleton College in Minnesota.  “When you vote with no information, you get the illusion of control.  The overwhelming norm is no to low information.”

But we already knew that, right Anne?