Author Archives: SHG

Texas Plans to Fight Return of Children

The Wall Street Journal reports that Texas is going to appeal the ruling that handed them a stunning defeat for seizing 460 children from the Yearning For Zion ranch.


Texas officials sought Friday to retain custody of more than 460 children seized from a polygamist ranch after an appeals court ruled the children should be returned to their parents, but they also agreed to reunite 12 children with their parents while the case moves on.

The state apparently believes that what it is doing is the right thing.  In the face of widespread criticism, coupled with the stinging rebuke of the Austin appellate court, somebody must feel very strongly about this.

The most significant point in the article is this:


In a case in which everything is big — the number of children, the severity of the child-abuse allegations, the sprawling legal proceedings — a sense emerged among dueling experts that all involved are wielding blunt instruments.

It is a fault with all cases involving large numbers of people and broad-stroke allegations.  When there’s one child involved, the claims are specific.  The state proffers individualized evidence of claimed abuse, and the parents can refute it with equally specific allegations.

Here, it’s one big, vague, non-particularized mess.  What is fundamentally wrong with this approach is that each child, and each parent, has an individual right to be told of the specific allegations against them so that they can contest them.  You can’t contest broad-stroke vagaries.  Absent a specific allegation of wrongdoing, there’s nothing to dispute.

The motivation behind the Texas push harkens to their own past failures.


In the back of the minds of Texas child-welfare officials, said Mr. Choate, a lawyer in San Angelo, Texas, was the federal government’s 1993 raid on a compound in Waco, Texas, where members of a religious sect known as the Branch Davidians lived. Some 82 members of the group, including children, died in a fire following the federal raid.

While this may be a very real fear in the minds of Texas authorities, it’s not even close to a reason to take children from parents here.  Each child is a human being.  So is each parent.  People who are members of peculiar religious cults still get to be treated like actual people, no matter how much “fear” they generate by authorities who don’t want to be blasted later for having missed the chance to save them.

The law works better when used as a scalpel rather than a bludgeon.  Rarely, perhaps never, has it been used in so blunt a fashion as here.  The appellate court was absolutely right to order the return of the children to 38 families, and to blast Texas for is en masse handling of human beings. Rhetoric about “institutional abuse” is fine for media sound bites, but the court properly refused to allow such meaningless claims to rip children from their parents.

I don’t know if one or all of these children is at risk at all.  Perhaps they were.  But children should never be taken away from their parents by such blunt force.  If there’s any merit to the state’s concerns at all, then let them put up or shut up.  In the meantime, the children belong back with their families.  Parents, not the state, should be presumed to be the safe harbor.

Eight Months Later, The Lie Revealed

The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, noted about 8 months ago that a CJA client of his was snagged by a civil lawyer who decided to dabble in criminal defense (I would guess that a rent bill was due).  The client was sitting in jail, and wanted to breath free.  The civil lawyer told the client he could do it, no sweat.

Bennett didn’t mind the fact that his client decided to go with another lawyer.  But was miffed indeed to learn that he went with another lawyer because of a lie.  The new lawyer promised that he would have the guy out in a month.  Eight months later, the defendant sits in the same cell.

This is a message to anyone who is a potential criminal defendant.  Contrary to what you think, that means you.  But for one bad day, you can be the wrongfully maligned perp in the dock too.  Never forget that.

There is no real magic about what criminal defense lawyers can do.  We can work hard and use our experience, skills and imagination to provide you with the best possible chance to get the result you want.

What we cannot do is much clearer:
 
We cannot guarantee a future outcome.  We cannot “buy” your way out of jail.  We cannot manufacture evidence of innocence.  We cannot get prosecutors to cut you loose because we’re old friends.  Same with judges.

If a lawyer tells you he can do any of the above, he’s lying.  If there was one lawyer who had the “answer”, every defendant would hire him and the jails would be empty.  They’re not.  They’re full of people.  Many of the people in the jails had more money than you, are smarter than you and more savvy than you.  And still they’re inside.  That’s because there is no magic bullet in any lawyer’s gun that makes all your problems disappear.

And one last myth that needs to be busted as often as possible:  Private lawyers practice law for a living, which means that they charge clients a fee based upon the amount of work they anticipate doing.  If a lawyer charges you $1000 for a serious criminal case, that means that he’s going to plead you guilty at the next court date.  If a lawyer charges you $10,000 for a case, that means he’s going to plead you guilty right before trial.

How do I know this?  It’s all in the numbers.  Say a middle of the road criminal defense lawyer plans to earn $250 an hour.  Take the total fee and divide by the hourly fee:  $10,000 divided by $250 is 40 hours.  The lawyer plans to spend a total of 40 hours on your case.  That’s one week of his life, spread over the length of the case. 

That one week of his life includes the meetings and time on the telephone.  It includes the legal research and preparation of papers, motions, memoranda.  It covers the time in court, including the time waiting around to have the case called.  It covers visiting the crime scene, speaking with witnesses, reviewing the discovery. 

And it covers hearings and trial?  Where exactly do you see that fitting in? 

The times involved differ for different types of offenses.  A DWI isn’t going to be the same as a murder or drug conspiracy.  And I’m basing this on New York practice, and things may be different elsewhere (though not significantly in my experience around the country). 

So if a lawyer tells you that he can take your case to trial for a fee, just run the numbers.  A better lawyer is going to charge more than $250 an hour, and put in a lot more time at every stage of the proceeding.  If some lawyer tells you can do it on the cheap, then you’re going to get what you pay for.

Like I said, it’s not magic.  Don’t fall for a lie.

Is Voter Education the Answer for Judges?

Anne over at Court-o-Rama indulges in another of the never-ending series of discussions of the “better way” to select judges, an age-old debate that has gone in more circles than a ferris wheel.  But one “point” that she raises has always disturbed me.  One of the “solutions” to the problem of asking the public to blindly vote for judges is


Voter education (indeed, this was the one solution that everyone in the room felt strongly about, though this being a League of Women Voters event, we were preaching to the choir)

Whenever a roomful of people agree on anything, you are almost always assured that the idea is flawed.  Sound ideas need to pass muster under critical analysis.  When nobody disagrees, nobody challenges the notion.  Is it because the idea is so utterly sound, so totally brilliant, that there’s nothing to question?  I don’t think so.

The idea that judicial candidates should provide their resume to the public so that there is something substantive to put out there, as opposed to voting for judges because they look like Judge Wapner, isn’t a bad idea.  It’s just not particularly helpful. 

Let’s assume that one candidate for the bench went to Harvard while the other went to Fordham.  Who wins?  Let’s say one was a criminal defense lawyer and the other was a prosecutor.  Who wins?  What if one worked for Biglaw and the other was a solo.  Who wins?

Educating the voters on the background of judges sounds as if it would provide plenty of meaningful information upon which the public could then vote with some legitimate basis.  The problem is that it doesn’t.  The judicial candidates can’t campaign based on how many defendants they plan to lock up, or how they hate plaintiffs in personal injury cases and plan to keep verdicts low.  They can’t opine at all about how they would rule if elected, as that would be a flagrant violation of ethics. 

So we’re left with information that gives the appearance of being meaningful without offering any true insight at all.  Anne’s group came up with these qualifications for a good judge:


Goodness, according to our members, encompassed knowledge, experience, morals, impartiality, apolitical-ness, and following the law.

Not a single line in a resume (or curriculum vitae for the lawprofs reading) tells us any of these things.  One might assume that the lawyer from Harvard is smarter than the lawyer from Boalt Hall, but experience tells us that might not be at all true.  Should we end up with an entire bench made up of “tier 1” law school grads because of this?  Nobody thinks that’s the way to go, especially if they went to Yale.

Indeed, voter education may have the unintended consequence of preventing the best candidates from getting elected because the public will fall back on such irrelevant bits of hard information for lack of any legitimate basis to select one over another.  We could well find that the public will default to electing prosecutors rather than defense lawyers because they feel that prosecutors are more “moral”.  Do we want to create a paradigm where the public projects undeserved attributes onto candidates because they lack any better method?

I appreciate as much as the next guy that the problem the selecting judges is frustrating, and that every idea intended to help comes with a flip side that presents a negative.  But if nobody mentions the downside to these solutions, they can pass into the mythology of solutions without any challenge.  I’m just trying to prevent that from happening.

Fieger: David or Goliath?

As every regular reader knows, Norm Pattis has been following the trial of Geoffrey Fieger with some intensity.  One of the themes has been that the government is sending a message to Fieger, and those like Fieger, that nobody stands tall enough to mess with the government.

Just so we’re clear, Geoffrey Fieger is neither a pussycat nor a poor, sad individual.  He’s made a ton of money, and comes to this trial with guns a’blazing.  He’s got Gerry Spence on his side, and you can’t get much larger than life than Gerry Spence.  If you have to be a defendant, then you want to be wearing Fieger’s Gucci loafers.

The David and Goliath theme was clear.  But Norm’s old partner in crime, Mike Cernowich, wasn’t buying.

I’ve been following Norm Pattis’ excellent coverage of the Geoffrey Fieger.  Many of the comments to his post express this theme :


Fortunately for [the prosecutor], the government doesn’t need a verdict to win the trial. Just the fact it’s in trial is their victory; the message read loud and clear not f–k with our powerful masters as they gobble up what’s left of our country’s wealth.

I’m about to barf reading about the “David v. Goliath” theme.  Fieger is a very powerful and rich man.  He attempted used his wealth to get around campaign contribution laws.  That’s all the case is about.

Mike may well have a particularly sensitive digestive system, but the imagery is still pretty clear (and rather unattractive, I might add). 


Since when are the wealthy such underdogs?Incidentally, I’m willing to bet that if I took a poll of Fieger supporters, they’d say they agree with campaign contribution limits.They’d should to the heavens that limiting campaign contributions prevents the wealthy from having too big of a voice.

If the GM Corporation were on trial for what Fieger did, would we have this weeping and gnashing of teeth from Spence groupies?  Of course not.  We’d hear how great it is that the powerful are being made to follow the same laws as the powerless.

The Fieger prosecution is not a David v. Goliath story.  It’s a Goliath v. Goliath story.

He’s got a point.  Fieger isn’t exactly the most sympathetic of defendants.  Personally, his swagger can be a bit off-putting, and nobody feels particularly sorry for the defendant who drives home from court in his new Porsche. 

But the fact that Geoffrey Fieger has done pretty well for himself, having amassed a fortune as a trial lawyer, may make him the 800 pound gorilla under many circumstances.  But not when he’s sitting in the defendant’s chair.

When you try criminal cases for a living, a funny thing happens to your brain.  There’s a little compartment in there where you stick the piece of information that the United States government has power that is beyond anything you can imagine.  They have thousands of people with guns and shields who can collect information and evidence about anyone anywhere. 

The strong, wealthy and power collapse on the floor in a paroxysm of fear when a special agent knocks on their door.  Doubt it?  Ask Martha Stewart, Dennis Kozlowski, John Gotti and a thousand others.  The high and mighty to us are nothing more than potential bowls of jello to the government. 

But lawyers refuse to acknowledge this hard, cold, nasty truth.  We can’t or we would be paralyzed.  Instead, we see only the mano a mano fight in the courtroom, the government attorney versus us.  They have all the power, but we won’t be cowed.  We stand up straight and tall, face the entire might of the government, and tell them they have to go through us before they’re going to get to our client. 

All of this, of course, is a shield from a certain truth.  We are puny in the face of the government’s vast power.  We may reject fear, but we can’t deny that the weapons available to the government dwarf those of the defense, no matter how much cash a defendant has on hand or how great a party he used to throw. 

Whether Geoffrey Fieger’s bravado is a sign of boldness in the face of great power or an act to cover the potential impending destruction of his life’s work, I can’t say.  But even Fieger, as wealthy and powerful as he was, is a David as he sits in the courtroom facing the Goliath.

No one goes on trial against the federal government on equal footing.  Not even close.  While Fieger is far better off than most defendants, and is certainly a Goliath in his own right under most circumstances, he is just an ordinary David as Judge Borman stares down at him from the bench.

I’m not saying that anybody has to feel sorry for Fieger, or believe that whatever game he was playing with donations to John Edward’s campaign was either legitimate or just a silly mistake.  But I have to disagree with Mike that there is any man, woman or corporation that enters a courtroom on equal footing with the government.  In America, we are all Davids to the government Goliath, and we always will be.

When White Powder Law Meets White Collar

A reader sent over a link to this law.com post about the 11th Circuit appeal of the government’s pre-trial asset seizure from Kerri K***** in anticipation of forfeiture. 

For years, the criminal defense bar has been arguing wholesale seizures of assets are unconstitutional because they strip defendants of their Sixth Amendment right to choose the counsel of their choice.

“The K*****’s simply want to use their own money to retain counsel of choice to defend them at trial,” said one of their attorneys, Howard Srebnick of Black Srebnick Kornspan & Stumpf in Miami. “The government is interfering by freezing their assets, including the equity in the home they purchased more than a decade ago, without giving the K*****’s an opportunity pre-trial to confront witnesses and present evidence to establish they have committed no crime.”

There’s really nothing particularly new about the concept, as it’s been used since the late 1980s to prevent accused drug dealers of hiring counsel to defend themselves.  Almost the entirety of federal forfeiture law, one of the most notorious and offensive of weapons in the government’s arsenal, was developed to fight the “white powder” criminal defense bar, lawyers who represented drug dealers.

The basic idea is this: Criminals are not entitled to use the proceeds of their crimes to hire lawyers to defend themselves.  Criminal proceeds are forfeited to the sovereign from the outset, not merely after the money is determined to be criminal proceeds, and the government is thus entitled to freeze the assets to prevent them from being wasted and used, thereby protecting them so that the sovereign can get its hands on them.

The practical impact is that it creates a Catch-22.  Seize assets first, deny a defendant the ability to retain counsel to defend, win the case, which therefore proves that the initial seizure was justified.

And one little detail that can’t go unmentioned: The standard for forfeiture was “probable cause,” the lowest possible standard at law.  If the government wanted to seize assets, there was little to stand in its way.

When the targets of the government’s love was limited to drug dealers, there were few objections.  The same arguments were made, due process, equal protection, right to counsel, all the big constitutional issues.  The circuits laughed at us.  Sure defendants had a right to counsel, but counsel of choice was not absolute.  They had no right to retain counsel with dirty money. 

The problem now is that our slippery slope arguments have proven accurate.  Federal forfeiture law was developed on the backs of the least sympathetic defendants, drug dealers, but all that horrible law is now being used to strip white collar defendants in the exact same way.  Then, the public had no problem with the law.  Now, it’s an outrage.  Funny how that happens.

Kerri K***** wasn’t engaged in any notorious activity.  She was part of a company that sold used medical equipment:


For six years, Kerri K***** worked at a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, selling the company’s latest surgical innovations to hospitals. But she and about two dozen other salespeople of J&J’s Ethicon Endosurgery got into trouble with federal authorities by selling inventory that hospitals no longer wanted on the gray market, an indictment charged.

Valid prescription medical devices, such as sutures, allegedly were bought by F&S Medical of Delray Beach, Fla., which turned around and dealt the products to other medical facilities.

The government apparently claims this was stolen equipment being sold on the gray market.  The K*****’s and their co-defendants say this was “excessed” equipment which was given away by the manufacturer as hospitals bought the newest and latest equipment.  They had to get rid of it, and there was a ton of it as the company, Ethicon, kept developing newer stuff.   They took the old and sold it to doctors and hospitals in third world countries.


The K*****’s set aside about $1 million to pay attorneys by taking out a second home mortgage and cashing certificates of deposit. But prosecutors claimed the money was ill-gotten gains. They charged Kerri K***** stored the medical equipment in the family’s garage. Her husband was indicted after she refused a plea deal. Prosecutors said he knew about the conspiracy and managed the illegal profits.

Even after being stripped of the money, the K*****s didn’t qualify for a federal public defender. U.S. Magistrate Judge James M. Hopkins in West Palm Beach concluded the couple could liquidate their 401(k) retirement accounts and their children’s tax-deferred college funds — at a cost of a $200,000 tax penalty — to pay for a cut-rate lawyer.The defense asked for an unusual probable cause hearing to test the prosecutor’s case, but prosecutors opposed the move. The hearing would be like a mini-trial, giving the defense an early glimpse of evidence and strategy.

It sounds entirely different when the accused are selling surplus used medical equipment than kilos of cocaine.  The problem is that they are stuck with the same forfeiture law.

While it may first hit you that win, lose or draw, the government has ruined these defendants financially just by bringing charges.  A million here, a million there, pretty soon defendants find that their entire life’s work and savings are wiped out.  Explain that to the kids when they want to go to college.

But when the same defendants not only lose everything they’ve worked for their entire lives, but lose it to the government in an asset seizure and are left without the ability to defend themselves, the scenario emits a very unpleasant odor.  It’s one thing to lose to the government after a fair fight, but another when the government gets to tie your hands behind your back first and then challenges a defendant to “put up yer dukes.” 

The arguments being made now are the same as were made way back when the defendants were unpopular.  The old adage that “the law abhors a forfeiture” went out the window, and asset seizures became de rigor.  Will the 11th Circuit be able and willing to find that “conceptual ledge” to stop the law from sliding down that slippery slope when it comes to white collar defendants? 

All the K*****s are asking for is a pre-trial hearing where the government would be required to produce evidence that their assets, mostly gained before their involvement in the alleged crimes (and seized as “substitute” assets, meaning that lawful assets take the place of illegal assets that the government claims were gain but can’t be found or don’t exist), are subject to seizure.  The government refuses, because it would give the defendants a “sneak peek” at their evidence, as if revealing the government’s purported truth would be prejudicial.

This seems like a great case to test the waters where white powder meets white collar.  But the state of the law is terrible for the defendants.  If crime is crime, then why should white collar defendants be subject to different law than any other criminal defendant?  And that’s why we need to fear the slippery slope.

* Note that the name has been altered to protect the innocent.

Slip Sliding Away

Logic, logical fallacies and fallacious logical fallacies, are the meat and potatoes of lawyers.  Without them, we would have little to say beyond, “does not!”  Believe me, that won’t get you very far.

One of the favorite arguments is the trusty “slippery slope.”  The slippery slope argument is that one “action will initiate a chain of events culminating in an undesirable event later.”  The problem with the slippery slope is that it fails to establish or quantify the relevant contingencies. 

Paternalistic pedagogues like to argue about things like this, the relative merits of rhetoric and logic.  Over at PrawfsBlawg, Rick Hills offers a screed against the slippery slope:


So why do patently unconvincing slippery slope arguments grow like black mold in a leaky attic every time a court makes a decision about sexuality? I think that we’ve used slippery slope arguments so carelessly that we are losing our intellectual capacity to draw fine-grained conceptual distinctions. Once one starts invoking the essential similarity of one thing to another, one can’t stop: The temptation to assert foolishly that logical consistency requires elision of any distinction not crudely cut with a meat cleaver becomes an addictive habit. (E.g., “You think animals have rights? Why don’t you let them vote?” “You think invading Iraq was a good idea? Why not China?” And so forth).

Vivid imagery aside (“like black mold?”), the slippery slope argument has been around forever and has yet to undermine our “intellectual capacity” any more than American Idol or the Gong Show (which, I hear, is making a comeback).  It can’t be that “patently unconvincing” or we would have given it up long ago.

Eugene Volokh, explains:


It’s true that arguments that it will be logically impossible to distinguish a future case from this case are usually very weak. Very few distinctions are logically impossible.

But slippery slope arguments endure partly because they are often cast, much more plausibly, as arguments that if X is done, it will become more likely that Y will be done — not that X and Y can’t be treated differently, but that they won’t be treated differently. These arguments aren’t about logical consequences, but about psychological consequences (plus some other consequences). And as such they can’t be rebutted simply by pointing out that a distinction could be drawn.

So, there may be a tendency to be a tad hyperbolic in the presentation of the slippery slope argument, perhaps being a little more absolute in the view that bad things will most assuredly follow, but that doesn’t mean that opening the door doesn’t make it more likely.


The other reason that slippery slope arguments endure is that slippery slopes do often seem visible. I say “seem” because it’s often impossible to tell for sure whether X increased the likelihood of Y, or whether Y would have happened in any event. But sometimes there’s good reason to think that slippage has happened, often despite the express insistence of backers of X that of course X won’t help lead to Y.

Eugene provides examples where promoters of a position assert that there’s no slippery slope in sight, and yet time proves them wrong.  The law tends to move in small steps rather than giant leaps.  Each step taken in a particular directions makes the next step that much easier to take.  Given enough time, the law often finds its way to a particular outcome that was raised, and dismissed, when the first step was taken.  By the end of the journey, the final step seems quite reasonable because of the baby steps taken to get there.

Slippery slope arguments also have a great deal of superficial appeal.  Lawprofs may be inclined to argue about the “conceptual ledge” where the slope stops being slippery, but people of more common intellect (which includes lawyers, judges and jurors) don’t stress over such details.  Given the 12 seconds involved in most decision making, superficial appeal is a fine way to go.

There are a bunch of issues floating around lately that are subject to slippery slope arguments.  Will a constitutional right to same-sex marriage inexorably lead to a constitutional right to polygamy?  Will a constitutional right for individuals to bear arms lead inexorably to a constitutional right of felons to own guns?  The obvious answer is no, not “inexorably”.  But it does make it more likely, and present some difficult logical obstacles for a court on the next case, when the envelope gets pushed a little farther.

So while the lawprofs both recognize, and ridicule, the logical fallacy of the slippery slope, the fact remains that while there is no guarantee that threats of dire consequences will ultimately come to pass, they sometimes do. It’s mistake to dismiss the slippery slope argument too quickly. 

If I happen to see a camel’s nose peeking under my tent, I plan to give it a decent smack on the snout.  Unless I happen to be standing on the south side of the camel, in which case I’ll be pushing that rump as hard as I can.  It would be a lot easier if the camel happened to be standing on a slippery slope.

Donninger Update: Better Timely Than Never

On Saturday Night Live, a running joke on the Weekend Update was that Generalissimo Francisco Franco was still dead.  The joke started in 1975.  It’s still as potent for me today as it was then.  And he’s still dead.

Among the many things that capture the essence of the joke are our beloved courts.  Ask Avery Doninger, the Burlington, Connecticut high school student who was denied her run for school secretary because she called administration officials a bad name on a website when they canceled her “Jamfest”. 

Her suit in federal court resulted in a non-responsive response, with the Judge punting.  Who was he to question school officials, he asked?  The judge, Avery answered.  So when the judge deferred, Avery appealed.

But in the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, Generalissimo Francisco Franco is still dead.  We now have come to the end of another school year.  As Andy Thibault at Cool Justice Report informs, Avery is still waiting. 

Justice delayed is justice denied.  It’s a fine platitude, one of the better ones if you ask me.  It’s particularly appropriate when dealing with a high school kid.  High school may seem like it last forever when you’re a teeny bopper, but the rest of us know it flies by very quickly.  We also know that once gone, it’s gone.  For Avery, it’s pretty much gone.  You see, Avery is now a senior in high school.  Unlike Franco, she won’t be a senior next year.

Now, the focus shifts a bit.  A question on the mind of the Doningers is just how much the Lewis S. Mills High School’s intransigence and dislike of minor vulgarities cost the taxpayers.  They foiled the district lawyer’s bills on August 1, 2007.  They received redacted copies.  For those who are unfamiliar with “redacted”, it means that they blacked out all the good stuff so the reader can’t see it.  It’s a lawyer word for hiding the parts you really want to see.

They appealed the foil production, and received an order to produce unredated bills.  It seems that the lawyer was hiding the cost associated with each of her screw-ups, requiring her to undo, redo and generally clean up after herself.  But don’t fret, at least she got paid for all of it, no matter that it was expense of her own creation.  It wouldn’t occur to the school board to question why they are paying their lawyer for screwing up, then again for fixing the screw up, then again for finally doing something properly.  After all, it’s not like the money comes out of their pockets, right?  Andy calls this the “welfare system for board of education lawyers.”

As time marched forward, it must have become apparent to the Doningers that the Circuit Court’s decision was increasingly irrelevant.  No matter what the result, Avery’s time in high school was coming to an end.  Her view was toward her future, college, senatorial campaigns, reconstituting SDS perhaps.  She couldn’t be restored to her rightful place in the high school hierarchy no matter what. 

But this won’t be a total waste.  After all, the lawyers for the school district, even if they are forced to turn over unredacted copies of their bills, still get to keep the money.  Generalissimo Francisco Franco is still dead.  Nothing has changed for Avery Doninger or the taxpayers of Burlington school district.

That Shiny New SUV

I think very highly of Mark Draughn.  I’ve said it before and I will no doubt say it again; He is a very smart guy.  But there is one thing he’s done, and has made flagrantly public, that confounds me.  Last February, Mark bought a RAV4.  What was he thinking?

The RAV4 what they’re calling a “crossover” vehicle—part SUV, part something else. Toyota likes to say it can’t be categorized, but I’d call it a fast and nimble car-like SUV. It’s like my old Camry, but jacked up off the ground just a bit.

This vehicle has been around for at least a decade, long before anybody called anything on wheels a “crossover”.  That’s just the latest marketing term to get people to buy things that used to be called SUVs now that SUVs are going have gone out of fashion.

I looked at the RAV4 years ago when it first came out as a car for my wife.  It was more a tin can on wheels than a trustworthy vehicle at the time.  It was then marketed as a small SUV.  I felt like I could crush it with my hands.  There was something that made me feel that it wasn’t ready to go off road.  Or on road, for that matter.  We got a Jeep instead.  My wife hated that Jeep.

But the sorry truth that I was a slave to SUV fashion came at the beginning of the trend.  There was something alluring about having a rough, tough SUV that could handle anything.  I had a strange romantic illusion that I would be touring Africa in an old, beat up Land Rover Defender.  I blew it.  That was out first and only SUV.  As soon as the lease was over, we got a Saab.

Now I realize that Mark is from Chicago, and that it takes a little longer for trends to work their way from the coast to the middle of America, but this SUV craze has been around for at least 20 years now.  It should have made it there a while back, and be gone already.  So why didn’t Mark get the memo?

Last summer, gas was selling at $2.35 a gallon.  People were outraged.  It was big news.  Today, it’s around $4.05 at the moment, and may hit $12 a gallon by mid-afternoon.  It could happen.  We’ve had an inkling that gas was getting more costly for a while, and even “crossovers” need gas.

So I’m constrained to ask again, what was he thinking?


I keep telling myself it wasn’t foolish of my wife and I to buy our first SUV this year because the high prices are only temporary.

Mark says the RAV4 is the most fun to drive vehicle he’s ever owned.  I would urge him to try an Austin Healey.  If not that, I can provide a list of about 5o that might change his view.  Maybe Mark has been a dedicated K-car buyer for years.  That would explain a lot.

Ford Motor Company announced that they are suspending production of pick-ups and SUVs.


Less than a month after reporting a surprising first-quarter profit, Ford said Thursday that it would drastically scale back production and step up cost-cutting efforts in response to a sharp drop in sales of pickups and sport utility vehicles.

Ford is now forecasting that industry demand for cars and light trucks will be 14.7 million to 15.1 million vehicles — the lowest point in more than a decade.

The biggest losers in the market are the big pickups and S.U.V.’s that Ford and its domestic rivals, General Motors and Chrysler, rely on for much of their profits.

If Mark hurries down to his Ford dealer this morning, maybe he can snag the last Explorer on the lot.  If he thinks it’s fun gassing up the ol’ RAV4, he’s going to have a blast pumping gas into an Explorer.  Plus, it could be the last gas-guzzling SUV produced in the United States of America, and fetch him a nice premium from a collector on eBay someday.  If could happen.

How Many Miracles Do We Have Left?

Thomas Friedman’s column in the New York Times, “Imbalances of Power,” is required reading for anyone who cares.  It’s hard to read, because it isn’t a happy column.  No platitudes about how great we are, and how we can use traditional American bluster to push out way out of our problems.

In fact, I have serious doubts that Friedman isn’t too optimistic in believing that the United States economy, if allowed to do its voodoo, will cure our problems.  What problems?

If this huge transfer of wealth to the petro-authoritarians continues, power will follow. According to Congressional testimony Wednesday by the energy expert Gal Luft, with oil at $200 a barrel, OPEC could “potentially buy Bank of America in one month worth of production, Apple computers in a week and General Motors in just three days.”
I suspect that he’s a step behind on this already.  While Americans are busy fighting about silly issues, whether gays should marry or whether the government should kill people, former third world countries have been busily providing us with the stuff that we use everyday.  Our gas money has gone to the Saudis.  Our clothing money has gone to the Chinese.  Our services money has gone to the Indians.  And we’re worried about how to motivate Gen Y to put in a little effort before they are handed the obligatory BMW convertible.

Presidential campaigns are great sources of inspiration, based upon the brighter future, the promise of change, the strength of the American people.  Except these words don’t actually do anything.  They are just words, carefully crafted to make people feel good about the candidates and instill hope that their problem can be solved. 

There is a certain truth to America’s strength, but few are willing to admit it.  Our strength came from our work ethic and ingenuity, creating things, ideas, services that produced wealth from markets around the world.  We tacitly believe that somebody will come up with the “next big thing” that will magically cure our ills and bail our sorry butt out  of this state of affairs.

Bill Clinton was viewed as a hero of the economy.  He’s attributed with saving us from the Bush I crash, creating a surplus and bringing in the days of milk and honey.  But he really had nothing to do with it.  We were saved by the explosion of internet commerce, this new magical economic landscape that offered unimagined promise.  It would have happened regardless of who was president, and it pulled our chestnuts out of the fire.

Up to now, America has enjoyed these fortuitous events as the way to save us from ourselves.  We have come to believe, truly believe, that this will continue.  America will always have some new, unexpected miracle that changes everything.  It’s like some sort of entitlement, some gift from God because we are the best, most worthy nation on earth.  Don’t worry about all the bad things we do.  Something will save us.  It always does.
The failure of Mr. Bush to fully mobilize the most powerful innovation engine in the world — the U.S. economy — to produce a scalable alternative to oil has helped to fuel the rise of a collection of petro-authoritarian states — from Russia to Venezuela to Iran — that are reshaping global politics in their own image.

This is what Friedman talks about when he remains optimistic about encouraging the United States economy to perform its magic yet again.  He believes in miracles.  He believes that our captains of industry, our engineers, our scientists will come up with something, anything, to save the day if only we push them.

What if they don’t?  There is no guarantee that another internet will come along just in the nick of time to save the day.  Maybe we’ve used up our good fortune.  Maybe the ride is over.  You only get so much good luck before your luck runs dry.

Friedman may be right, that we still have some juice in the economy to pull us out of this jam.  Perhaps “Mr. Fusion” is right around the corner, and the rest of the world will come running to us for their needs.  But even so, can we count on another miracle to come along the next time?  And as long as Americans continue to hide our heads in the sand, there will most assuredly be a next time.

Enjoy your fancy foreign car.  But you may not have any gas to drive it.  But it won’t really matter, as you won’t have the strength to drive when there’s no food to eat, or the health to drive it when you can’t afford the medicine to keep you healthy.  Or job to drive to.