Author Archives: SHG

Once There Was a Bluebook

Ilya Somin at Volokh renews his calls for the death of the Bluebook.  For those who never enjoyed the rigors of law school, the Bluebook is what lawyers call a book entitled “A Uniform System of Citation.”  When I went to law school, it was a little book with a blue cover.  From what I read, it’s gotten larger.  I assume it’s still got a blue cover, though I couldn’t swear to it.

Law students are expected to learn every rule and nuance of the Bluebook.  Law reviews slavishly pour over it, vetting the articles of lawprofs to make sure that they conform to the rules in every respect.  A capital letter here, a period there, makes all the difference.  These are life and death matters for law review editors, and millions of pencil points have been sacrificed to the Bluebook gods.  What a waste of good red  pencils.

But what of the Bluebook to those of us laboring in the trenches?  Here’s the scoop.  We must be able to accurately and adequately communicate our citations to the courts if they are to be able to follow our arguments.  Doing so largely requires us to use relatively standard citation form, which really isn’t a very big deal.  Whether we include a space between “Fed. R. Crim. P.” or not doesn’t tend to create mass confusion.  The judges get the message. 

Once law school fades into distant memory, about 6 hours into our first post-law-school work day, the Bluebook is left in its place of honor on the shelf, never to be looked at again.  Eventually, it is consumed by dust, such that its distinctive blue cover turns a lovely shade of gray.  And there it sits until we die (or worse, retire). 

The Bluebook is probably the biggest non-starter in the law.  Has anybody ever read a Supreme Court decision that included the language:


We might be persuaded that the appellant was correct in his analysis of the caselaw, but because he failed to use a period in his citation form of an obscure law review article, we affirm.

Not me.  In fact, I can’t recall a judge ever mentioning citation form in my papers.  Ever.  This may be because I am a natural Bluebook prodigy, and somehow comply with even the most ridiculously obscure rule without realizing it.  But I don’t think so.  I may be good, but not that good.

No, my sense is that the judges feel pretty much the same as me about the Bluebook.  They don’t care.  As long as the citations can be found, they take no issue.  And you can bet your bottom dollar that they aren’t sweating the Bluebook when the write their opinions.  As if their decision doesn’t count if they mis-cited a case.

So while Ilya, and others like Dan Solove, fight the chains of Bluebook slavery, I’ve got to laugh.  This is what comes of being a lawprof, with that myopia that can come only from dependency on law reviews as proof of existence.  As a right of passage for law students, I find it quaint.  There’s no harm in learning to do things the “right way,” even if nobody really cares.  As a shackle on the bigger ideas of lawprofs, it’s just an arcane yoke that comes with owning specialized territory.

For the rest of us, it’s really pretty funny to hear the lawprofs complain about such nonsense.  Don’t blame the Bluebook (or Yale law review) for being what it is.  If you want to lay blame, how about your fellow lawprofs and deans who have yet to send the memo to the kids on law review that


“Henceforth, Harvard Law Review will no longer use Bluebook citation form. If you can understand the citation, regardless of form, then that’s perfectly acceptable.”

But the truth is, you guys love holding the secret key to getting published in law reviews, and if it was only about good ideas, then anybody could do it. 

Departmental Charges Against Sean Bell Officers

The New York Times reports that 7 police officers involves in the killing of Sean Bell will face departmental charges.  They include the three detectives who were acquitted of criminal charges, as well as the commanding officer at the scene, two forensics officers and another who discharged his weapon.

The three detectives who stood trial in the case — Detectives Gescard F. Isnora, Michael Oliver and Marc Cooper — were charged with “discharging their firearms outside of department guidelines,” said Paul J. Browne, the Police Department’s chief spokesman. Detective Isnora was also charged with taking enforcement action while working as an undercover officer instead of letting officers who were present, and not working undercover, take control.

Lt. Gary Napoli, the ranking officer at the scene, faces internal charges of failing to supervise the operation, Mr. Browne said. Sergeant Hugh McNeil and Detective Robert Knapp, of the Crime Scene Unit, were also charged: the detective with failing to thoroughly process the crime scene and the sergeant with failing to ensure a thorough processing was done.

How one reacts to this bit of news reveals much about one’s level of cynicism.  Does it pale in comparison to the criminal prosecution?  Of course, but then the three shooters have already been through a criminal prosecution and emerged from the other side as not guilty.  The New York Police Department can’t change that, nor can they be expected to.  It’s unhelpful to demand unreasonable and unavailable remedies not that the botched prosecution is over.

The news struck me as particularly surprising in certain ways.  First, it would have been fairly easy, and fairly credible, for the NYPD to take the position that the three detective had been tried and acquitted, and having been subject to the most severe scrutiny, no further action would be taken.  The “double jeopardy” sensibility (though not in the legal sense) would kick in, and many people wouldn’t expect the detectives to go through serial charges at every level. 

For lawyers, we need to remind ourselves how offensive we find it when non-police defendants are put through multiple prosecutions, state, federal, administrative.  We can’t rearrange our logic because we don’t like these defendants very much.  Either we are process oriented or outcome oriented.  We can’t switch back and forth whenever it suits our agenda.

But what really impresses me about these departmental charges is that they did not stop at the three detectives.  Most significantly, they are going after Lt Napoli, the commander on the ground.  This is a huge step forward for the NYPD.  Remember Abner Louima, where a precinct full of cops were given a pass on their failure to do their duty?  If Napoli was left off the list, no one would have noticed.  That he was subject to scrutiny demonstrates an huge epiphany for the cops, realizing that not only affirmative wrongs, but errors of omission, neglect, maybe even a tinge of conspiracy, are wrongs as well.

The same is true of the forensics guys.  Their failures were manifest, but screw-ups by forensics have almost been universally excused and forgiven.  Up to now.  Why should they not be expected to do their job properly and sufficiently?  Why should they be forgiven their failures, particularly when their failures serve to cover-up potential police crimes? 

Norm Pattis, beating me to the punch on this news, concludes that this will at best result in a Pyrrhic victory.


As for the police department proceedings? The officers will almost certainly be disciplined, and they should be. Departmental policies and procedures are an important means of keeping a department under control. When cops take matters into their own hands and create their own rules, they may not violate the Constitution, but they certainly foster something like anarchy in the police department.

For Bell’s supporters police department discipline will be at best a Pyrrhic victory. That is all they should expect.

I’m not really clear what Norm means by “Pyrrhic” in this instance, as I see no cost to Bell supporters.  Unsatisfying?  Inadequate?  Even if the departmental charges result in the most severe penalty available, discharge from the police force and loss of pension, it is hardly the equivalent of a criminal conviction. so it will never meet the demands of those who believe that Sean Bell was murdered. 

Still, the NYPD is not responsible for the botched prosecution.  This doesn’t diminish the fact that they are doing what they can to address the nightmare of Sean Bell’s death within the parameters of their administrative powers.  It isn’t a substitute, but it’s the best they can do.

The question remains whether the NYPD, having gone as far as taking the broad view of wrongdoing in this tragedy, will now pursue it with vigor and integrity.  Charging is one thing.  Now they have to prove that they can pursue their own cops with the same degree of effort and effectiveness that they would use against anyone else.  This has yet to be seen. 

But as first steps go, I’m impressed.  I’m not prepared to go as far as saying that maybe they’ve learned something from all this, but it’s better than they have ever done before.  And that’s something.

Payback For Camera Boy’s Father

Connecticut Yankees are known for being gracious.  Apparently, that doesn’t apply to their cops.  Not long ago, the Clinton School District went a little bonkers about a science nerd who brought a “deadly” instamatic camera to school.  United States District Judge Kravitz mused whether the rubber band in his hand was equally deadly under the school district’s argument.  The school relented.

End of story?  Not in Connecticut.  According to the Hartford Courant, it’s now payback time:


The father of the 14-year-old honors student arrested and suspended last month for allegedly using a dismantled camera to shock another student in school is now facing criminal charges of his own after police say they found an illegal weapon in the family home.

Police charged Bret Haughwout, 43, on Tuesday with possession of an assault weapon, risk of injury to a minor and possession of illegal fireworks. The charges stemmed from a police search of Haughwout’s Egypt Lane home last month.

Some silly questions come to mind.  Why would the police have a reason to search the Haughwout house?  No mention of a warrant, though presumably they had one.  But possession of a killer camera doesn’t generally give rise to believe that the house will contain a secret cache of other deadly weapons.  Rubber band perhaps?

Perhaps there’s a different reason for the search?


A few days after that deal was struck, Christian’s mother, Carolyn Vangemert, filed a suit in federal court accusing Clinton police Officer Kyle Strunjo, who is stationed at the Morgan School, of false arrest. Vangemert is seeking unspecified punitive and compensatory damages.

Do I detect the smell of payback in the air?  I believe I do. 

This should be quite the interesting case, and the family lawyer, Norman Pattis, will no doubt have plenty to add when he does his best Gerry Spence impression.  I can’t wait to see what happens with this one.

Hull to Gen Y Lawyers: Get It or Get Out

When Dan Hull says the clients come first, he means it.  Over at What About Paris Clients?, Dan posts about receiving one of those emails telling lawyers how to make love to their Gen Y lawyers.

From a marketing e-mail I received today:

Are you frustrated by young workers who feel entitled to success, need constant praise, want everything to be ‘their way’? Are you struggling to attract and retain a generation of workers whose commitment seems more temporary than permanent?

This is Generation Y, a workforce of as many as 70 million, and the first wave is just now taking their place in an increasingly multigenerational workplace.

In this 1-day seminar, we’ll show you how to motivate and manage Generation Y. You’ll learn what makes them tick, how to retain them, and make them productive and energized.

This is one of those generational issues, I guess.  You see, we were raised with the idea that the guy paying your salary told you what to do, not the other way around.  There was no demand to be coddled.  The door swung both ways, and if you didn’t like how things were going when you walked in, you were always welcome to walk out again.  But if you wanted the job and the paycheck, you did what you were told.

Somehow, this group of children got the wrong memo.  They are under the impression that the reason we have law firms is to make them happy.  They may lack the skills, experience and drive, but that doesn’t mean they don’t get a BMW on day 1, or a pat on the back every time they find their way back from the bathroom successfully.

So what does Dan have to say about this?

It’s your problem, Gen-X and Gen-Y. Not ours. Work, figure it out, ask questions, and we’ll help you–but it’s your job to adjust to “us” and the often hard adventure of learning to solve problems for your employer and its clients.

Hull is Baaaaaaad!  Enough with this notion that it’s our job to make them happy.  If 70 million of them want to sit home and play Wii all day long, great.  Eventually, they will get hungry.  Then they will have to earn a living.  Not just receive a paycheck, but earn it.

I know how this happened.  I watch MTV.  I’ve seen “My Super Sweet 16” and “Bridezillas“.  Did you really think the rest of us would coddle you like your nutty parents?  Get real.  Here’s the secret message:  You aren’t special.

Dan Hull is my hero. I’m joining the Hull Revolution.

New Poll: No Raise For Judges

While those of us inside the business take it as an article of faith that judges should get a salary increase every decade or so, it turns out that a poll conducted by Siena College Research Institute shows that the public opposes a pay increase for judges.  According to the New York Lawyer and the NYLJ,

Fifty-five percent of those surveyed said they opposed raising the current $136,700-a-year salaries of Supreme Court justices while 39 percent said they would support a pay increase. Six percent said they did not know or had no opinion.

I’m always suspicious of polls like this, because the subject matter tends not to be known or understood by most people.  Why would they care how much judges earn?  Why would they care more about judicial salaries than how much they pay in taxes?  They don’t, and there’s no reason why they should.

Like a commenter here on one of my numerous judicial salary posts said, if they don’t like the pay, get a real job.  That’s the retort I would expect from most people.  Heck, I’m half inclined to say that too.

But the reaction to the poll is highly dependent on the question asked.  To many people, the bottom salary paid a New York judge still sounds pretty darned good: $136,700.  To people struggling to pay taxes and put gas in the car, whose jobs are at risk if they still have a job, it’s hard to whine about a six figure income on the public dole.  Judges just don’t “feel” underpaid to most people.  And they aren’t exactly the most sympathetic of figures, particularly when they don’t put a lot of effort into being nice to people who come before them.

What was most telling about the poll was the reaction to another question, whether legislators should get a raise.


Forty-nine percent of those surveyed opposed raising state legislator’s salaries and 45 percent said they were in favor.

Almost a dead heat, given the margin of error.  Given how ridiculously dysfunctional the New York Legislature has been forever, this response makes it clear that people aren’t reacting to what officials deserve, but to gross numbers.  They probably don’t even realize that Legislators are part-timers.  It’s just that the number, compared to judges, seems like a bargain.

Maybe judges could take a page from the teachers or cops unions about how to promote themselves to the public to increase support for their salary increase, but that would be really demeaning.  On the other hand, if they think that there will be a popular uprising against the Legislature in support of increasing judicial salaries, it looks like they are out of luck.

Leave it to the public and they would probably cut the salaries of everyone getting a public paycheck.  The public is suffering, so why should people who live off them be doing better than they are?  While this poll doesn’t have much applicability to the problems faced by New York judges, it’s a reminder to the judiciary, and to Albany, that their salary issues aren’t nearly as important to the public as our own problems. 

The Latest Flavor, Vito Fossella

It’s been a bad couple of weeks for New York Republican Congressman Vito Fossella.  First, he gets busted for drunk driving.  Then it turns out he’s got some kid with an Air Force Colonel.  Now he’s under investigation for travel expenses with his second family. 

I’ve been hankering to write this post, but more stuff keeps coming out about poor Vito.  Of course, now he has announced that he won’t be running for re-election.  But he’s staying in the job until the end of his term.  For now. 

This post really isn’t about Fossella.  He’s just the flavor of the week.  It’s about the people who run for elected office.  It’s about the people who make the laws that put other people in jail.  It’s about the people who make the decisions to spend the money for which we are taxed.  It’s about all of them.  And it’s about us, because we never seem to learn.

There is no doubt some are dedicated public servants.  But there are many, maybe even most, who are dedicated to their own little power trip.  These are the ones who are above the law.  These are the ones who listen to no one.  These are the ones who became taller, smarter and better looking the second they were first elected.  They live in a fantasy world of their own glory and importance to compensate for . . . something.

Some say that Vito was charging headlong into self-destruction, as if childhood neurotic self-esteem issues drove him to tragedy.  I doubt it.  He was living large.  He was a young, up-and-comer in the Republican Party.  But talking family values is different than living them.  He must love family values; He even had 2 families.  I guess New Yorkers have polygamy issues closer to home than I thought.

It’s hard to take people seriously these days when they can spout one bit of pap and live another.  Norm just posted  about Fieger, the megalomaniac, who took the stand in his own defense.  This was the defense’s greatest fear and the prosecution’s greatest wish.  And the idea that Fieger would “win” over the jury with his overwhelming important presence was likely impossible to suppress, even for Gerry Spence. So Norm noted:

Political scientist Harold Lasswell wrote a book in the 1930s called Psychopathology and Politics. He applied Freud’s theories of personality development to the study of political leaders, asking, in effect, why would anyone want to be a politician. Mind you, this was before mass communication made walking sound bytes out of people.

Lasswell’s answer was that politician had extraordinary psychological needs, in effect saying that normal people wouldn’t seek office. I suspect the same is true of trial lawyers. Good ones are driven by deep needs to the stage of trial. Nothing else would lead a person to forgo sleep, ease and often peace of mind.

You see, we are reinventing the wheel when we try to understand why the Vito Fossella’s of the world behave as they do.  Or the Eliot Spitzers.  There are way too many names to list, and they aren’t from any particular side of the aisle.  But they crave the attention, the admiration, the adoration that comes with the job.  They become the pop stars they could never be otherwise.

How many others in Congress knew about Vito’s double life?  How many knew that Larry Craig had a wide stance?  Anybody remember Wilbur Mills?  Like I said, it’s a long list.  But even those who keep themselves under control probably know a lot of ugly stuff about the ones who don’t.  And they aren’t talking either.  Maybe their too busy coming up with new crimes for us?  Maybe they have to give an interview with an American flag pin on their lapel about why we need to stay the course. 

What I learn from Vito’s mess is that there are just too many like him.  Scratch a pompous politician and you find another Vito Fossella.  We treat them like they are “important” people, but they behave like everyone else.  They
are likely not the sort of people you would want to have over your house for dinner.  We not only give them an awful lot of power, but an awful lot of deference.  Are elected officials supposed to be treated like rock stars, or are they supposed to be public servants.  If the latter, why do we keep fawning over them, filling their desperate egos with the belief that they really are brilliant and wonderful?

Lasswell teaches us that this is nothing new.  The ego-needs that drive people toward these positions suggest that anyone who runs for office is likely the sort of person we don’t want there.  But no normal person would seek election, leaving us stuck with a government full of Vito Fossellas.  Is the only difference between Vito and the rest of Congress that he got caught? 

How do we accept and justify the suffering done in the name of government when it seems that it’s all a big joke, with Representatives and Senators having a grand time doing whatever suits their fancy while the rest of us suffer their decisions.  There are just too many scandals.   

Vito, you got nailed for being one of the gang.  Bummer.  If you had one less drink that night, you would have been shoo-in for re-election, and likely been eyed for bigger and better things. If you had kept your nose just a little cleaner, no one would have known.  You would have looked just like everyone else in Congress.

Maybe we need to start remembering this for ourselves.  These aren’t rock stars.  Just people with enough psychological problems that they would run for office.  They need to be watched closely. 

Cop Solicitations, The Veiled Threat

The Consumerist had a post that struck a nerve and reminded me of one of the most insidious scams around.


I recently have been victimized by telemarketers identifying themselves as parties involved with the Richmond police department. On two separate occasions, the requests for donations far exceeded any norm that i have ever experienced. It’s appalling to think that these are individuals representing police officers that I respect and support in every way I possibly can.

Most people have come to realize that those phone calls where solicitors claim to be from your local police union  are nothing more than paid telemarketers whose only connection to the cops is three priors.  They come on very strong, pushing any button they can to scare the crap out of the unwary.   The cops get 3 cents out of every dollar raised, if anything at all.  It is a scam of the worst order.

The problem is that this is such a psychologically effective scam that it sucks huge numbers of people into it out of fear.  There is an implicit threat that if you refuse to give money, the cops will know.  You, John Smith of 12 Maple Lane, have turned your back on your police.  And they, Mr. Smith, will remember you.  We know who you are.  We know that you refused to help.  We will remember.

Is there anyone out there who, should the need for police protection arise, wants the responding officer to say, “Oh yeah, I remember John Smith, the guy who refused to donate to the widows and orphans fund, who turned his back on cops, who hates us.”  I know that I wouldn’t want that running through the officer’s head as my life was endangered.

Worse yet, some smaller departments actually run this internally, sending out letters or making phone calls to residents within their small jurisdictions directly soliciting donations.  If people are worried about being singled out by a telemarketer’s call, the threat is 1000 times worse when you get a letter from a real cop in your real little town who actually knows who you are.  How do you say no to this?

So why do they do this?  Why do police unions allow this scam to happen under their name? 

I’ve asked the question of a number of cop friends.  They all respond with that sheepish look of embarrassment.  They know darn well what they are trying to pull off.  They know that this ploy is intended to play off people’s fears that they won’t run too fast to save them if they don’t pony up some cash.  That’s the point.  They want the cash.  It’s all about getting money.

Not a single cop ever suggested that they would ever, ever fail to do their job because someone refused to donate.  Indeed, they go to great pains to insist that donations have zero to do with anything.  In other words, it’s a totally empty threat, that the failure to contribute “might” result in a little slower response should you ever need a cop.  I absolutely believe this to be true.  No cop is going to let someone dangle because they didn’t donate to the union.

But I despise the scam.  It abuses their position, and extorts “donations” by way of implicit threat, or explicit in the case of some of the worst telemarketers.  I refuse to donate.  When the telemarketers call, I say a few choice words, then hang up.  When the real cops ask, I remind them that I pay a fortune in taxes and if they can’t make it on that, they need to find new jobs.  I will not be threatened into donating money to anything.  I contribute out of choice, not fear.

I hope you do the same.

4 Cops Fired. Big deal.

When the video emerged of Philadelphia cops beating suspects, it presented an opportunity.  Here was the list of options:

A.  Nothing will happen, and police brass will announce that the officers were defending themselves.
B.  Nothing will happen, and police brass will announce that the officers were beating acting according to department guidelines.
C.  Nothing will happen, and police brass will explain that the beaten men were suspected in a drug-related triple homicide and therefore deserved a good beating.
D.  Something will happen.

Shockingly, the answer turns out to be “D”, something happened.  According to the New York Times :



Four police officers who were caught on video beating three suspects in a drug-related triple shooting will be fired, Police Commissioner Charles H. Ramsey said Monday.


Three other officers have been suspended, Commissioner Ramsey said at a news conference, and one officer has been demoted.


Well, that’s certainly something for the City of Brotherly Love.  The fact that this horrific beating wasn’t swept under the rug, justified or excused reflects a significant advancement in the attitude and tolerance of the Philadelphia police department.  Of course, one has to wonder whether it would have been the same had their not been a video of the beating, but let us not indulge in rank speculation.

What else did Ramsey have to say?


Commissioner Ramsey said he did not know why the officers acted as they did but he added that emotions were running high because Sgt. Stephen Liczbinski had been killed two days earlier in a robbery in the Port Richmond area of the city.

Some of the officers used “indiscriminate force” that went beyond what is justified to make an arrest, he said. The officers kicked one man in the head and hit another in the head with an object while they lay on the ground.

“There are a group of officers whose actions were outside of department policy,” Commissioner Ramsey said. “We have to be better than some of what we showed on the fifth of May.”

All true, but having overcome the first hurdle, admitting that cops don’t get to beat suspects because of “high emotions,” a second hurdle remains.  Firing, suspending, demoting are all punishments reflecting the right direction, but if you or I were to do what these officers did, would it end there?  Hardly.


D. Scott Perrine, a lawyer for one of the men, Pete Hopkins, 19, said the disciplinary action “falls far short” of the appropriate response, which he said should be criminal charges of aggravated assault for the officers involved.

“The only reason these people are not in handcuffs is because they are police officers,” Mr. Perrine said. “They behaved like a pack of wild animals.”

Therein lies a significant difference, and problem.  How many of our defendants have argued with their lawyer that if they don’t have a video, it never happened?  We hear this all the time, and we tell them that it doesn’t work that way.

But here, there was a videotape.  It showed cops behaving like animals.  Had this beating been perpetrated by anyone other than our men in blue, you can bet the farm that they would be arraigned the next day and held on ridiculously high bail.  But not here.


The 67-second video, which has been broadcast repeatedly on local and national television, is now being examined by District Attorney Lynne Abraham, who will decide whether to file criminal charges against the officers. The F.B.I. is also reviewing the tape, Commissioner Ramsey said.

What exactly are they waiting for?  They are waiting for people to move on to the next atrocity so that they forget about this one.  Having done something, the officials are hoping that the combination of short attention span and the never-ending stream of police scandals will direct attention elsewhere, so that they can claim they dealt with the problem and be the heroes of the great unwashed.


Mayor Michael Nutter said at the news conference that he was satisfied by the department’s response to the beating, pointing out that 16 of the 18 officers at the scene had been fired, disciplined or subject to retraining.  “Today’s announcement represents, I believe, what is required in this matter: swift, direct action,” Mr. Nutter said.

It strikes me as unlikely that he would be satisfied if this was cop on the ground being beaten by a gang of hoodlums, and the upshot was that 4 lost their jobs. 

So Philadelphia has clearly made some headway from the days of Rizzo and the Move firebombing.  But it still has a long way to go.  Like most places, including New York.

Child Porn Anyone?

The Supremes reversed in U.S. v. Williams, holding that the Protect Act (Prosecutorial Remedies and Other Tools to end the Exploitation of Children Today) passes constitutional muster.  Congress kept trying, and SCOTUS has repaid its efforts by giving its stamp of approval.  See kids, effort counts.

What’s less clear is what exactly the Protect Act protects against.  And that’s been the problem all along.  Eugene Volokh is a 1st Amendment guy, so my first thought is to turn to his analysis.

So this will make clear that solicitation, offer, and attempt to commit a wide range of crimes — including the distribution or receipt of child pornography — is indeed criminally punishable. And, contrary to Justice Souter’s dissent (joined by Justice Ginsburg), I don’t see how this will materially change the protection offered to distribution of nonobscene pictures that don’t actually depict real children, but instead show computer- or hand-drawn children, or adults that look like children: A distributor or recipient may avoid liability under the statute by simply offering or asking for “pictures of adults who look underage” or “computer-generated pictures that look like children.”

Well, that makes everything clear.  Well, not really.  Let see if we can cut to the chase.  According to the New York Times,


“Offers to provide or requests to obtain child pornography are categorically excluded from the First Amendment,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the 7-to-2 majority.

Got it.  The problem is that criminalizing the speech of making offer/requests for kiddie porn, but then not requiring that there actually be kiddie porn or that the porn under discussion actually involves children, disconnects the speech from the underlying bad act (child pornography). 

While I am no advocate for anything that involves harm to children (as regular readers here know and passersby should know, so that’s why I repeating myself here), I am concerned about the criminalizing of speech about crimes.  Even if I were inclined to turn a blind eye to this decision because of its kiddie porn component, Eugene’s analysis points out the larger problem.  I know, he didn’t mean to, but he still did.

Eugene argues that the holding is rather unremarkable and really does little to change the nature of 1st Amendment protections.


The Court read “advertis[ing], promot[ing], present[ing], distribut[ing], or solicit[ing]” as essentially involving solicitation or offer of a specific transaction in a particular item. That the item might not actually be obscenity or child pornography doesn’t matter because the general criminal law is that an attempt to commit a crime is punishable even if the attempt is factually impossible. Trying to buy illegal drugs, for instance, by soliciting someone to sell them to you is generally a criminal attempt even if the solicited seller was only going to deliver fake drugs rather than real ones. So the bottom line is that the prohibited conduct constitutes criminally punishable solicitation, offer, or attempt to get or give constitutionally unprotected material.

His example at the end of the paragraph is what grabs me.  Trying to buy illegal drugs is not a substantive state crime.  It is the possession or sale of drugs that is the crime.  If a fellow walks down Amsterdam Avenue asking if anybody knows where he can score some heroin, he has done nothing criminal.  It won’t help his sainthood application, but he’s not going to the can for it. 

Similarly, if a fellow stands on St. Nick asking passersby if they want some cheap blow, and then hands them a glassine of baby powder, he too has committed no substantive state crime, though he may have to run hard and fast to get away from some very disappointed purchasers.  There has to be real drugs involved, and there has to be an actual transfer involved, for the deal to be criminal. 

Before anyone raises conspiracy to commit the crime, allow me to point out that this is the very problem.  Federal conspiracy charges are imaginary crimes.  Offer to sell 5 kilos of coke that don’t exist and could never be consummated and you end up convicted for a fallacy.  This is one of those really bad things in the law, and part of the reason why conspiracy is called the “darling of the prosecution.” 

By taking bad law and bootstrapping it into new bad law, we don’t end up with good law.  Further, the Protect Act, further proof that acronym laws are inherently suspect, is not a conspiracy crime, but a substantive crime.  It is a crime to offer child pornography, even if the porn doesn’t exist or isn’t really kiddie porn.

Please understand, I maintain my view that anyone engaged in anything to do with kiddie porn is scum.  For those who enjoy it, you make me wretch.  But I can still separate my disgust from my ability to consider the ramifications of criminalizing the solicitation/request speech.

What is interesting is that this is an invention of law created of necessity caused by the pervasiveness of porn on the internet.  Before the internet, there were no doubt still the same number of people around who were interested in something as despicable as kiddie porn, but there was no similar outlet to offer or seek it.  The internet has empowered people who would otherwise have hidden their sickest urges a way to seek their kicks.  It’s allowed seemingly upstanding citizens to show that they’re really filthy cretins.  It has empowered a subculture that had nowhere to turn before. 

And so, one person’s opportunity has presented society with a horrible problem to address.  I can’t blame Congress for trying to deal with it, nor the Court for reaching a bit too far to find a way to allow it.   Naive me, I’m still blown away by the fact that the problem with kiddie porn is as pervasive as it is.  I cannot fathom it, and I am shocked and truly disgusted by it. 

But breaking down walls to allow the criminalization of speech when there is no underlying substantive crime is not the right solution. 


The law applies to “any person who knowingly advertises, promotes, presents, distributes, or solicits” the prohibited material, raising concerns about whether mainstream movies or innocent photographs of babies in the bath might invite prosecution.

Justice Scalia dismissed these concerns as “fanciful hypotheticals,” saying that such situations would either not give rise to prosecutions or, if they did, would be protected by the courts.

I have to part ways with Nino here.  If constitutionality of a law is dependent on the sound discretion of prosecutors not to be overzealous or abusive, or the oversight of district court judges to somehow stop indictments should the AUSAs get out of control, we’re in deep trouble.  History has proven that neither of these stopgaps work very well, and since when does constitutionality hinge on the government being trustworthy?

I foresee bald, fat, 45 year old federal agents sitting in front of government issued computers asking every newcoming to a chat room if they want some child porn.  It’s certainly easier work than going out on the street and protecting real people from real crimes.  Some perverse idiot, in a suit and tie with three kids at home, who is ashamed of his secret inclination to see some teenybopper blondie having sex is pushed to indulge his sickest fantasy, and responds.  Ta da, we have our newest federal inmate.  A small part of me says screw the idiot, he got what he deserved.  But a bigger part says we’ve gone over the edge.

And no matter how one feels about child pornography, or those who purport to deal in it, once words are disconnected from the evil that law seeks to stop, the possibilities are endless.

The Judicial Death Penalty

The antics of Niagara Falls Judge Robert Restaino had their moment in the sun before the New York Court of Appeals.  Restaino was the fellow who blew his top when a cellphone rang in his domestic violence courtroom, and held 46 defendants hostage awaiting the guilty party to step forward.  That never happened, of course, but the good judge caught the eye of the Judicial Conduct Commission and bought himself a ticket to the world of the robeless.

Through his attorney, Terry Connors, Restaino appeals his removal to the big court in Albany.  The Niagara Gazette reported on the oral argument.


“Don’t impose the judicial death penalty here,” Terrence Connors said. “(Restaino) has so much more to give.”

Ouch.  That, methinks, is what everybody is afraid of.


“Why it happened holds the key to whether Robert Restaino should be returned to the bench as a Niagara Falls City Court judge,” Connors told the court. “It was a perfect psychological storm and one we should have seen coming.”

Almost immediately, Judith Kaye, the court’s chief justice, interrupted.

“What were these signs (of impending trouble) that were missed?” she asked.

“(Restaino’s) incredible caseload, his unbelievable caseload,” Connors answered.

Now if I were a wag, I might suggest that caseloads are what judges are supposed to be able to handle, not what drives them over the wall. 


Restaino’s lawyer had already argued in a 60-plus page brief filed with the court before the hearing that Restaino’s “eruption (on the bench) was the result of severe psychological stressors at work and at home.”

“We have a lot of workaholic judges,” Justice Robert Smith said. “Are they all at risk (of behavior like Restaino’s)?”

Connors told him studies of the legal profession show many are.

“(Restaino) went completely off the rails,” Smith said. “How can we say to the community, ‘We understand what (the judge) did, but he won’t do it again?’ ”

Granted, Terry had little to work with on this appeal.  The fact is that he may have evoked some sympathy for Restaino’s inability to handle the psychological pressures of the bench, but that’s an argument for keeping him as far away from a position of power as possible, not putting back in the “pressure cooker.” 

But Connors plea for mercy begged a question:


Several of the justices repeatedly pressed Connors over “where to draw the line” on what behavior can be forgiven and what can not.

“Is there some conduct,” Kaye asked, “that is so intolerable (that a judge must be removed from the bench)?”

“Yes,” Connors replied.

“But with this (extreme stress) explanation, then what (conduct) would be (too extreme)?” Kaye pressed.

“There have been judges that threatened people,” Connors replied.

Kaye cut him off. “(Restaino’s conduct) is worse.”

Restaino didn’t threaten.  He actually did it.  To 46 defendants.  Luckily, judges aren’t armed or summary execution might not have been out of the question.  And then there’s the problem with the fact that after a few hours (hours!), Restaino hadn’t come to his senses:


Justice Victoria Graffeo questioned Restaino’s motivation for reversing course and releasing the 46 individuals who were jailed several hours later.

“Didn’t he do this when a reporter called?” Graffeo asked.

Connors insisted that Restaino was already making plans to release the individuals before reporters began asking questions of court officials about what had happened.

Making plans?  Terry Connors had a tough position on his hands.  Exactly what “plans” must one make to stop acting like a psychopath?   The best argument Terry had available was that Restaino was contrite (just like everybody when they find their hand in the cookie jar) and that it was an aberration (questionable, but there were no prior actions against him by the Commission).

But the extent of impropriety here was huge.  Imprisoning 46 defendants for hours because a cellphone rang?  That’s big on the list of really bad offenses by judges. 

So it seems the answer comes down to an old retort that happens when we argue for a lenient plea for a murderer.  Nobody gets their first murder for free.  And so, I predict that Robert Restaino will be selling one slightly soiled robe on eBay.  Any bidders?