Author Archives: SHG

Spitting Bullets Is Deadly

And once again, the Great Sovereign Nation of Texas competes with the State of Florida for which does the stupidest things.  Today’s issue is spitting.

Via Grits and Berman, this Dallas Morning News story:


Prosecutors convinced a Dallas County jury this week that HIV-positive saliva should be considered a deadly weapon.

Mr. Campbell was convicted of harassment of a public servant. Because of the jury’s deadly weapon finding, he will have to serve half of his sentence before he’s eligible for parole. The police officer, Dan Waller, has not contracted HIV.

For his efforts, Mr. Campbell was sentenced to 35 years in prison.  Now, spitting at a police officer (or spitting at anyone really) is disgusting and wrong.  It should not be tolerated, even though it’s a relatively benign act as harmful conduct goes. A bullet is deadly.  Spit is really disgusting. 

But there are two issues here that are worrisome. The first issue is that Campbell’s spittle was found by a jury to be a deadly weapon.  This harkens to that nexus of science and bias, the fear that lingers long after the reality becomes clear. 


But the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and countless doctors say no one has ever contracted the virus from spit.

And that’s why several AIDS advocacy groups and many individuals contend that the 35-year sentence Willie Campbell received Wednesday for spitting into the mouth and eye of a Dallas police officer was excessive.

This is one of those questions that a judge should never have permitted to go before a jury for this very reason.  It’s what I call a “world is flat” question.  Should the question of fact be put to the jury of whether the world is round or flat?  If the jury decides flat, does it make it so?  Obviously not.  So if no reasonable jury can make a finding contrary to reality, then it’s a question for of law for the judge, not the jury, and should never have been submitted.

The prosecutors position, medical evidence to the contrary notwithstanding, is that there is a minuscule chance that the world “may be” flat.


But Dallas County prosecutor Jenni Morse, who handled Mr. Campbell’s case, said any risk level is sufficient for the deadly weapon finding used during the trial. “No matter how minuscule, there is some risk,” said Ms. Morse. “That means there is the possibility of causing serious bodily injury or death,” the legal definition of a deadly weapon.

What a great argument.  If only that one flowed both ways.  No matter how minuscule the possibility of innocence may be, it there is any you must acquit.  When was the last time a prosecutor offered that bit at summation?  Of course, the prosecution’s burden isn’t theoretical, but beyond a reasonable doubt.  Somehow, this argument doesn’t seem well-suited for the prosecution side.

The trend has been for the imaginative prosecutor to frame his case by taking anything available and turning it into a weapon.  In New York, the shoe worn on the foot of the person who kicked another became the weapon.  Kick barefoot and it’s no big deal.  Kick with a boot on and its a killer.  Is this what was meant by a “weapon”? 

This is just as bad, if not worse, from the slippery slope point of view.  Weapons are instrument that are created for the purpose of causing harm to others.  Weapons are things that, if used in an offensive manner, will facially cause harm to another.  Weapons are not anything and everything for which an argument, no matter how minuscule, can be crafted. 

But this particular cases blows through a more significant and problematic wall.  The medical evidence is that Campbell’s act could not transmit HIV to the officer.  As all expert witness lovers know, the jury is empowered to accept or reject expert opinion.  But here, the jury ignored medical testimony and imposed prejudice to assume medical reality.  This is where evidence disconnects from verdict.  That they can’t do.

The appeal to “common sense” is often used to overcome fact.  People adhere to beliefs grounded in bias, rumor, supposition, that has absolutely no basis in fact.  Prosecutors are taught to use this to overcome their lack of evidence, to play on the jurors’ ignorance. It’s done in almost every case.  It’s a very powerful weapon.

Here, the prosecutor played on the fear of Aids.  Even though it has been 25 years since HIV was discovered, it still scares most people as some unknown deadly plague.  It’s not that we doubt the physicians, but that we don’t trust them enough to accept their prognostications.  We’re not taking any chances. 

I don’t blame cops, corrections officers, court officers, whoever, from wearing latex gloves when handling defendants or convicts.  I see no reason why anybody should take needless chances either.  But that’s a no harm issue, since wearing gloves doesn’t raise issues of harm to the people they are handling. 

This, however, is an affirmative use of fear-mongering and ignorance.  It elevates the fears of the “common man” beyond all reason.  It allows the law to embody rank speculation because people who don’t know better are afraid and have been cajoled to give in to their fear.

The second problem with this case is the 35 year sentence. 


Mr. Campbell had served time in prison twice, labeling him a habitual offender and starting his sentence time at 25 years. While in prison awaiting trial for this case, evidence showed, Mr. Campbell bit two inmates and attacked other officers.

I supposed that the length of the sentence is a bow to the needs of the Texas corrections system to come up with some way to help seriously disturbed people rather than warehouse them and then turn them loose again.  If that’s the case, then 35 years may not be enough.  Perhaps 100 years will enable Texas to catch up with modern penal thinking.  Maybe not.

The Danger of Tape Recorders

High profile trials tend to offer insights that more run-of-the-mill trials don’t.  Judges who would ignore defense efforts to get under and behind what law enforcement does in the process of making the case as being irrelevant feel differently when there are journalists watching and listening.  Sunlight really is the best disinfectant.

So a particular exchange between the case agent in the Fieger trial and Gerry Spence offers a glimpse into the manipulations and machinations of the FBI.  Only a glimpse, since Judge Paul Borman wouldn’t let Spence have his way either (just like you and me).  From the Detroit Free Press :


When Fieger lawyer Gerry Spence demanded to know why Rees hadn’t recorded his call with Fieger as Bird had done with Johnson at the FBI’s request, Rees cited an FBI policy which prevents agents from taping conversations.

FBI critics have complained that failing to record interviews enables them to selectively record details of interviews in written reports and prevents the public from seeing the tactics agents use to obtain information.

But U.S. District Judge Paul Borman wouldn’t let Spence explore the issue.

This has long been a problem for me.  It’s remarkable how law enforcement can manage to record what is good for them, but never seems to have a recording of anything else.  Of course, then they are constrained to recount conversations from the witnesses memory, and everything they remember is terribly inculpatory.  Amazing how that happens.

It’s one thing that this crap happens.  It’s another that the defense is denied the ability to show that these purported “policies” are lies.  And they are indeed lies.  They are a deliberate deception.  They know it.  We know it.  The judge knows it.  And still the defense is prevented from proving it.  So much for all that nice talk about prosecutors doing justice and courts being impartial.

What jurors are never told is that there is a handbook for cops and prosecutors that provides them with stock testimony and arguments to weasel their way out of situations where they might get nailed for doing things like this.  The jurors hear the testimony, and it sounds fairly reasonable.  But it’s the same testimony we hear every time, over and over.  The only people in the room who don’t know it’s a scam are the jurors.

Watching police and federal agents try to weasel their way out of corners is one of the most enjoyable things about trying a case.  When you can box them into a lie, it’s a thing of beauty.  Whether the jury gets it is another matter, but we can only hope. 

Once, and only once, was I able to make an FBI agent break into tears, as I was able to use physical evidence to prove he had lied to the jury.  Just as I was about to perform the coup de grace, the judge figured out what was about to happen and stopped me.  It would have broken my heart had the agent not figured it out at the same moment, and begun to tear up.  I’ve had a couple of agents threaten to kill me, but that doesn’t bring anywhere near as much joy as watching one cry.

Even here, a United States District Court judge stopped me from making a monkey out of a government agent.  Why?  Why can’t the defense show the existence of systemic deception and manipulation in order to obtain convictions based upon intentionally produced false appearances and claims? 

Technically, it’s the rules of evidence.  Only evidence relevant to the specific case before the court is admissible.  Testimony about general practices is not.  Testimony in the negative is not.  And since we can’t produce a witness to testify that the particular agent in this particular case made the specific decision not to record a conversation a particular conversation for a specific reason, we have nothing admissible to offer.

But it’s a scam.  And we all know it.  And if you happen to ever sit on a jury, now you know it too. 

Is Same-Sex the New Racism?

“Not long into the oral argument before the California Supreme Court in March over whether gay and lesbian couples have a constitutional right to marry, Chief Justice Ronald M. George showed his hand.


Three times he quoted from the court’s 1948 decision in Perez v. Sharp that struck down a state ban on interracial marriage, a high point in the history of a prestigious and influential court.


“The essence of the right to marry is freedom to join in marriage with the person of one’s choice,” Chief Justice George said, quoting Perez.”

So opens Liptak’s piece on the California Supreme Court’s decision striking down the ban on same-sex marriage.  For many younger people today, it’s impossible to conceive of a time when a black man kissing a white woman would cause outrage in America.  But it wasn’t that long ago.  And it indeed caused outrage. 

Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner might seem shamelessly quaint now, but it was cutting edge in its time.  In the 1960s, a song by Janis Ian, Society’s Child, reminded us that we were far from ready to accept racial lines being crossed.  It was a painful, shameful song.  Are we passed it today? 

But is it really the same as same-sex marriage?  Opponents say no.


Opponents of same-sex marriage say they are uncomfortable with the analogy to interracial marriage bans. “It’s well suited to a sound-bite culture,” said Monte Stewart, president of the Marriage Law Foundation, which supports traditional marriage.

“Sure, it works at the surface level,” Mr. Stewart continued. “But it is actually defeated by the deeper reality of marriage itself. Marriage in its deep logic has nothing to do with race and everything to do with the union of a man and a woman. To apply Perez in the genderless marriage context is actually to betray it.”

When one relies on such fuzzy concepts as “deeper reality,” it’s hard to understand the point except on a visceral level.  Either you believe that it’s a man-woman thing or not, because the inability to explain it in rational terms belies an absence of logic. 

If one perceives marriage as being the proper legal qualifier for procreation in the scheme of good policy, then the male-female thing makes some sense.  Obviously, same-sex couples have procreation issues, putting scientific advancement aside for the moment.  To encourage continuation of the species, society provides benefits to couples who join together for the purpose of having children and providing them with a stable environment in which to grow and develop.  It’s not entirely crazy.

Marriage is a word loosely thrown about these days, but to lawyers encompasses a bundle of unique rights of great consequence.  It entitles one spouse to a portion of another’s estate, no matter what they say.  It impacts property rights.  It gives power to see someone in the hospital and make decisions.  It allows people to claim a education on their tax returns.  Love aside, there are rights involved.  These rights are given by the government to encourage marriage, to encourage having children and to allow the married folk to raise and protect those children in the manner the government thinks best.

The problem is that same-sex marriage doesn’t diminish the importance of marriage, as an institution for men and women.  Allowing gays to marry doesn’t mean straights can’t.  Once we get past the Puritanical idea that gays are “diseased” or just unbearably “gross”, we can recognize that they aren’t going to join into the traditional marriage dance with someone of the opposite sex if we just stop making it too easy to be gay, and thereby save the world from converting little boys and girls to their “disgusting” lifestyle.  It’s not happening.  That’s just not the way it works.

So gay marriages will not produce natural offspring.  So what?  It’s not like they are using up a limited resource that denies it to anyone else.  Much has changed about society’s vision of the perfect marriage over the past 50 years.  Ozzie and Harriet is off the air.  Al and Pat replaced them.  It may not be better, but we can’t go back.  Divorce is prevalent (which significantly undermines the procreation argument).  Should we force married couples to stay together and live in misery?  Hey, if male-female couples can get married and find out they are miserable, shouldn’t same-sex couples be able to make the same mistakes?

The comparison of same-sex marriage to cross-racial marriage is an attempt to find reason to contrast with those who reject the notion of moral equivalencies.  Morality is not rational, it’s what someone feels.  Opponents of same-sex marriage believe it is immoral.  They don’t want their children seeing men kissing men because it offends their heterosexual and religious sensibilities.  Frankly, it’s not my thing either.  But there’s nothing more rational to it than that. 

So bite the bullet and turn your head away if it bothers you.  In time, it will be nothing.  We’ve overcome prejudice before, and we will overcome this.  It won’t happen quickly, but it will happen eventually.  Yes, it is nothing like race, and it is exactly like race.  We’re still working on overcoming racial prejudice.  We have room to work on homosexual prejudice too. 

And for those of you who may have forgotten (or never heard) Janis Ian’s song, written and performed when she was a mere 17 years old, this is really worth a few minutes of your life.

Contraction and Expansion of the Media Universe

The Dolan family, owners of the cash machine known as Cablevision, will soon be the owners of a controlling interest of the primary newspaper of Long Island, Newsday.  From a business perspective, it’s a great combination, allowing the Dolan’s to leverage their ownership of the 2 primary sources of news and information on Long Island.

It also means that Jim Dolan gets to cherry pick the information provided to Long Islanders, via News12 (the only Long Island television station, exclusively available on Cablevision) and Newsday.  Should one man, regardless of how one feels about the Dolan’s, have his hands wrapped around the sphincter of information, loosening and squeezing as he will?

Plan B was Rupert Murdoch, the other bidder for the affections of Sam Zell, former owner of Newsday.  Murdoch, who just happens to live a stone’s throw over the bay from Dolan, is the owner of the New York Post and the Wall Street Journal.  And Fox Television, too. 

It might be a bit sensationalistic to ask you to think back to George Orwell’s 1984 at this moment, but it’s message that the control of information is the control of thinking.  From a more practical perspective, whatever appears on the front page of a newspaper is the news.  Things that show up on page 79 are not as important.  We know that because the newspapers tell us that.

The lessons learned from the great media empire of Magnate William Randolph Hearst are not forgotten; it’s just that newspapers aren’t exactly the best financial bet these days, and they can’t force someone neutral to buy them.  They can only take the offers made.  Nor can we blame the Dolans or Rupert for seeking to leverage their empires by accumulating new toys.  As I said, it creates great synergies.

But for the people, it’s a potential nightmare.  Too much control in too few hands means that our information is suspect.  At a time when there is so much political and economic turmoil, coupled with a paucity of hard information to begin with, this is a recipe for democratic disaster.  For democracy to work, the public needs to know what is really happening.  Yes, most don’t bother and won’t learn anyway, but we can’t force people to think no matter what we do.

New York is the largest media market in the world,  We have more outlets than anywhere else.  And yet, we are watching as they align into camps, as the media universe contracts.  On Long Island, the Dolans will be the indisputable single source of news.  Makes me shudder.  But we can’t force Newsday to become an independent.  Each daily paper would cost too much anyway. 

So is the sky falling on the residents of Long Island?  Nah.  You see, at the same time that the old media contracts, new media expands to fill the void.  Nature abhors a vacuum, and will never allow this information vacuum to exist. 

While the blogosphere remains the hysterical, ignorant, unreliable stepchild of old-style journalism, it provides an alternate source for anyone interested in looking for a different take.  Much like our favorite seditionist, Thomas Payne, there are those who challenge, question, editorialize and persuade others to recognize issues and considerations that the newspapers and television never will.  They’re huge.  We’re tiny.  It allows the bloggers to say what they want, say it quickly and put it out there for the world to see.  If the world wants to see it.

Is the blogosphere really the media?  Not quite.  I depend on the kindness of strangers for information.  But we can look at a wealth of sources to arrive at a reasonably valid viewpoint.  Whether anyone else should accept or adopt our perspective is entirely up to them.  Blogs don’t promote themselves as “fair and balanced.”  We are what we are, warts and all. 

But when you hear that something has happened in the world today, you can wait for the 6 o’clock news, or tomorrow’s paper.  Or you can check the blogosphere at that very second. 

If you want to hear some views on the significance of a slice of news, you can hold your breath and hope that the Times will have an editorial about it eventually, or you can check out a few thousand blogs that will explain what they think it means and express an opinion about it.

The media universe is expanding, because the blogosphere exists.  No matter where you live on Long Island, you don’t have to take Jim Dolan’s word for it as to what really matters.  I have no idea how heavily Jim’s thumb will press on the jugular of the managing editor of Newsday, or whether the Dolan’s will want to be as “fair and balanced” as Rupert.  Maybe they will be good stewards of the First Amendment.  It could happen.

But George Orwell never imagined that there would be an underground called the blogosphere to nip at the heels of big media.  For every word they try to remove from the lexicon, we can create two.  For every memory they try to alter, we will have it cached.  While few of us will ever compete with the big boys of the media, we will still be here offering an alternative view. 

Let the Dolans buy Newsday.  If they mess with the news, the blogosphere will be there to pick up the slack.

Cops Gone Wild No. 49

An excellent report last night on ABC’s 20/20 about police out of control, and other police refusing to do anything about it because of the Blue Wall of Silence.

The report showed numerous videos of cops, off and on duty, becoming violent and beating people for pleasure.  It’s a really bizarre report, and calls into question at least a portion of the people to whom we give guns and shields.  It makes one wonder how poorly they screen for people who psychologically unfit to be cops.  Or perhaps who would be our clients but for the shield.

One point made in the story is that the pervasiveness of video may be the first crack in the blue wall.  Conduct that cops used to deny, and whose denials were believed and the complainers discredited, is now provable when caught on video.  Suddenly, cops gone wild becomes cops caught on video.  Hey, Joe Francis, this could be a whole new division for you.

The story also points out that most cops are ashamed of these conduct of those who engage in this violence, but can’t bring themselves to do anything about it because of cop culture.  I understand exactly what they are saying, and I don’t care.  It is disgraceful for a cop to conceal the misconduct of another cop, and the fact that he’s gutless to confront the cop culture just means he’s gutless.  It is not a good reason.

Check out the story.

Getting Away With Murder

Via Doug Berman, this story of how Baltimore federal prosecutors are trying to bootstrap a first offender drug conviction into a murder sentence.  The Baltimore Sun article about Gary “Fat Boy” Williams Jr., explains:



Federal prosecutors are mounting what is essentially a trial within a trial in hopes of winning a stiffer sentence. Federal sentencing law allows a judge to consider alleged crimes that have been refuted at trial or which a defendant has never been charged with, a provision that critics say flouts the constitutional protections of the trial-by-jury system.


Williams’ lawyer, Christine Needleman, said, “It’s supposed to be a sentencing for my client’s first [federal] drug conviction. … Instead, they’re trying to tack on a murder that can’t be proven to send him to prison for life without parole, without any of the procedures.”


Rod J. Rosenstein, the U.S. attorney for Maryland, said Williams is accused of ordering the killing of a 35-year-old Harford County woman in February 2006 to obstruct the drug investigation, making it “relevant conduct” to the drug dealing. Prosecutors must prove his involvement by only a “preponderance of evidence.” In a criminal trial, a defendant must be proven guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt,” a higher threshold.


The use of uncharged crimes as relevant conduct is neither new nor shocking.  At least not to lawyers.  It is, and remains, one of the most offensive abuses in federal sentencing.  Turley is quoted in the Sun article as saying, “It’s a practice that is obviously ripe for abuse.”  I disagree.  It is not ripe.  It is facially abusive.

The more usual scenario is that a defendant is tried for one crime, and then the government tries to throw in all the allegations it can muster as to additional similar crimes in order to smear the defendant for sentencing purposes. 

Why didn’t it just indict and try him for the additional crimes?  Because they don’t have the evidence, and when raised only at sentencing, the standard of proof is different.  Rather than “beyond a reasonable doubt,” the standard is only preponderance of the evidence.  The government hopes that the defendant will not fight the relevant conduct enhancement and open the door to a Fatico hearing where they can smear him further.  It allows the government to throw as much as they have against the wall and see what sticks.

But this case is special.  Here, the defendant is charged with drug dealing, but the relevant conduct crime is murder.  The nature of the offense upon which the government wants the defendant sentenced dwarfs the offense for which he was tried.  It’s a scenario that smacks one in the face with a harsh dose of how wrong it is to sentence a defendant for “relevant conduct.”

It may be the “Fat Boy” (an alias that no doubt endears the defendant to whoever named him that) is a bad dude, who has done very evil things.  So get the evidence and put him on trial for it.  There is no aspect of federal criminal law that is so offensive to every notion of justice as this, and there are few cases where it is more apparent than this.  Simply put, a person should not be sentenced for murder unless he’s been convicted of murder.  Is there really any doubt?

Randazza To Wed; Feminists Aghast

Marc John Randazza, adjunct lawprof, first amendment lawyer and head satyr, will be heading to the alter today.  Not, as most would expect, to repent for his many sins, but to marry.  A woman.

Local Porn Lawyer Weds

While little is known about the woman who would accept Randazza’s hand, other than the fact that Randazza seduced her with his awkward, geeky charm coupled with outright deception about the size of his personal domain, it has been noted that she is quite intelligent, attractive and charming.  No, we can’t figure it out either.

The standing explanation for this “opposites attract,”  May-December romance appears to be centered on the fact that the couple will be able to save a small fortune by sharing brassieres.

By the time the happy couple read this post, it’s likely that they will be wed, have engaged in serious argument and Mrs. Randazza will be asking the perpetual bride question, “what was I thinking?”  It will, of course, be too late. 

Randazza, hated by radical feminists everywhere for his scathing support of women who do not toe the line, takes it all with a sense of humor.  According to Randzza, “Since Ann Bartow wouldn’t have me, what choice did I have?”  An inquiry as to whether feminist lawprofs wear brassieres went unanswered.

Congratulations, Mr. and Mrs. Randazza. 

NY School Lawyers Fight Back

It’s often said that the best defense is a good offense.  As if the New York school district lawyers scandal isn’t offensive enough, a gang of four has sued Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and Comptroller Tom DiNapoli for violating the New York State Constitution by depriving of them of their vested property rights in their pension, per Judicial Reports.

In a 52 page complaint, the four lawyers, all pensioners, on behalf of themselves and all lawyers similarly situated, lash out at what they call a “political gambit” by the state.  According to the New York Law Journal :


Mr. Roemer, of Roemer Wallens & Mineaux in Albany, said in an interview that Messrs. Cuomo and DiNapoli are attacking public pension practices that have been routine for generations.

“Both the comptroller and the attorney general are taking the actions they are taking based upon their stated positions that private practice lawyers, i.e., lawyers in private practice who do work for municipalities, can’t be employees of the municipalities, they must be independent contractors,” Mr. Roemer said. “That is simply incorrect. There is no law to support that whatsoever.”

Cuomo’s response:


“The best defense, which is not a defense in my opinion, is, ‘Well, we were doing it for so long and no one said anything,'” Mr. Cuomo said. “That doesn’t cut it as a legal defense.”

Mr. Cuomo said the arrangements were a type of “political patronage” in which local government officials hired attorneys, who also happened to be politically active locally, and made them eligible for pension benefits by classifying them as employees.

“Many levels of government, regulations that were misused, politics – you put those factors together, and that’s the stew that we’re dealing with,” Mr. Cuomo said.

Cuomo’s view misses a critical point.  There is merit to the laches argument.  If it’s been going on forever, everyone knew about it and no one ever suggested that there was a problem, future generations are entitled to rely on the accepted practice.

Of course, Laches is an ugly back door argument, where they get away with it only because they’ve always gotten away with it, not because it’s right.  On the other hand, the lawyers’ argument comes off as another disingenuous, nit-picky, manipulative lawyer-type position, the type that makes people hate lawyers.

In short, the lawyers say that the law does not preclude them from being in private practice while simultaneously being part-time school district employees.  No doubt that’s true, but that does not make them bona fide part-time employees either.  This is a loop-hole argument, and one that will sway no public sympathy.  Of course, it’s unlikely that they’re aiming for sympathy.  They’re looking for their pension checks.

In case you non-New Yorkers are wondering why this is such a big deal, consider that last year, the per capita cost of educating a single student in my district was $28,000.  On Long Island, my district is considered third rate at best.  I’ve often thought they would do better by just leaving the kids home, investing the money and giving it to them when they reach 18.  It would likely produce more income than most will ever earn in their lives.

So can a lawyer be in private practice and a part-time pensionable employee as well?  Of course they can, but that doesn’t answer the question of whether they were.  We all know the answer to that question.  They were never “employees” under any stretch of the definition.

Some smart lawyer found a loophole, told a school board that he would cut his hourly rate if they put him into the pension system, and they would save money because the cost would be spread around the entire state instead of paid out of district taxes.  When no one complained, all the other lawyers followed suit.  And all the lawyers after that.  And they figured they had it made in the shade.  Lawyers with pensions.  Who’da thunk?

I can’t blame the lawyers for thinking that they have a right.  Let enough time go by and any scam begins to look like it’s deserved.  But getting away with a scam for a long time doesn’t change the fact that it’s scam.  It always was,  It still is.  It’s not malum in se, but it’s painfully disingenuous. 

While some will disagree, I don’t see this as criminal conduct.  I see it as bad lawyering, bad policy and a fundamental problem with the way legal advice is rendered to what I call “baby governments.”  And it’s all on our dime. 

The same lawyers who are the bulwark of governmental callousness to the taxpayers they are supposed to serve, are awfully facile when it comes to figuring out loopholes to feather their own nests.  It’s a bedrock principle of their version of “public service.”  Their supposed keepers, our baby elected officials, are at best rubber stamps and at worst children playing with guns.  It’s a failed system, not because it’s conceptually wrong but because its execution has never met the expectations of philosophers.  While the lawyers are not alone in this failure, they have abused and enjoyed the benefits of having unfettered influence over a room of idiots. 

And the only thing this complaint points out well is that the State, over the many years in which this scam has been ongoing, has been just as incompetent in protecting the public fisc as has the municipal lawyers.  A pox on all their houses.  But whatever happens, it will still be on our dime because no one will address the root cause of this scandal.

Pain From the Other Side

While it’s critical to recognize the pain caused the defendants by error and abuse of the criminal justice system, let us not forget that defendants aren’t the only ones who are treated with utter indifference.


Note that she has not only sought help from the Florida State Attorney, but from all those media outlets who purport to be “on the side of the little person.”  She was rejected by all, including the glamorous Nancy Grace, pseudo-victim extraordinaire.

Some days, I get the feeling that there’s very little that our government does very well, and perhaps not well enough to justify its existence.  As has been said often enough here and elsewhere, criminal defense lawyers defend the criminal.  We do not defend crime.  And we most assuredly so not defend callousness on the part of government.

H/T He who never has anything nice to say about me.

Fighting the Tyranny of the Reasonable

Every dog has its day.  Today belongs to my favorite mutt purebreed, Norm Pattis, sitting on a hard bench in Detroit so that we don’t have to.

In what may be his most brilliant post yet (which is not an easy level to achieve), Norm writes:

Lawyers and judges share a hermetically sealed world of case law and convention. We take the fact patterns of other lives and impress them into forms known at law. Over the course of years, we acquire a sense of what is reasonable based on what has occurred before. Reasonableness can cripple a lawyer.

Spence needs today to shake loose of Judge Borman’s tethers. The facts and the law work against Fieger in this case. If Deepthroat is right, and this case has larger significance, then Spence must take the case to the only people who really matter in this case, the jury. He can’t do that at sidebar. When the Government objects today, as it will, and the Court calls for a sidebar, Spence should stand his ground and withdraw the question. Let the people hear the case, he should intone.

This comes in response to some missive from someone who calls himself, with either an abundance of imagination or sexual issues, “deepthroat”.


Deepthroat writes with the passion of the converted. He reminds me of a student I saw at TLC, a wealthy man in his own right from the Southwest who has declared himself a latter-day Sam Adams; he literally bought himself a place in the hearts and minds of students and staff alike. He, like Spence, knows the people and their needs. Leave him be to fight the people’s fight. He, like Spence, knows best. In Deepthroat’s view the Fieger trial is a political trial. Fieger may be a fool, but so is everyman; so, for that matter, is the Government. Hence, the fight.

Positioning oneself as THE VOICE OF THE PEOPLE is not an easy thing to do.  I’ve seen lawyers try it.  I’ve seen them embarrass themselves.  People who think that they, and they alone, hold the truth tend to beg other people to give them a hard smack.  It may have worked for Darrow, but brother, you ain’t Darrow.

Will it work for Spence?  He’s a large fellow (and according to Pattis, this is not likely to diminish anytime soon) with a basso voice and an interesting timbre.  He can command a room.  He projects a larger than life image.  And he enjoys opening up to the jury, like Charlton Heston enjoyed spreading the Red Sea.

But the brilliance of Norm’s post is the idea of the tyranny of the reasonable.  It’s the war of ordinariness against the unusual.  The law loves the use of reasonableness as a standard against which conduct is measured.  Who can argue otherwise?  Of course, it’s not without its problems, since nobody agrees exactly on what reasonable is.  We are all right in our definition.  Just ask ourselves.  We know.

But when it comes to criminal law, since when is it our duty to adhere to someone else’s vision of doing what is reasonable or going to prison?   My reasonable may not be yours, or hers, of that other guys.  Which one becomes the standard to decide if mine is a crime?  But these questions aren’t asked in a courtroom.  Instead, judges and prosecutors fall back on phrases like “common sense” to cover the vast breadth of reasonableness in the hope that most people on a jury won’t see reasonable the same way as the defendant.  Or his lawyer.

It’s a great phrase.  It’s a great concept.  Well done there, Norm.  Now everybody, “NORM!”