Personally, I think gay marriage is a tempest in the teapot. Let two people do whatever they want with each other. It’s none of my business, and it’s none of yours either. Does it freak you out? Who cares. It’s their life, not yours. And that’s that.
But since the California Supremes held that their gay marriage ban violates the state Constitution, it seems like a good time to bring up another issue that people haven’t really spent enough time considering. New York, like most states, does not permit same-sex marriage. Nor does it recognize marriages from Canada or civil unions from Vermont. Yup, we are one progressive state.
As a result, however, a body of law is developing around issues of property and child custody in order to circumvent legislative inertia. Don’t mistake this as a diatribe against activist judges. Rather, this ad hoc law-making, extending the reach of domestic relations law on a case by case basis, is in the process of creating a Frankenstein monster.
The problem is that decisions, well-intended and well-reasoned, that try to expand the reach of traditional domestic relations concepts to cover the situations that typically arise, but now within same-sex relationships, are not being vetted against the potential impact on the future of the law for everyone, gay or not. While it may produce an admirable result today, it has the potential to produce nightmarish results in the future. But because of the constraints placed on courts by the State’s refusal to permit or recognize gay marriage, judges are trying their best to address the issues but feel like their hands are tied.
Nothing against judges, but when they engage in expansive revision of clear, long-held legal concepts, they are really venturing into an area where the courts don’t belong. Judges are not very good at reflecting the will of the people when they advance a political agenda, and no judge should decide without considering how that decision will affect the future state of the law.
Right now, the law of the State of New York is in such flux, such disarray, that it’s impossible for same-sex couples to know how to behave, how to relate to one another, how to deal with the issues that typically arise in relationships. The law may say one thing today, but no one has a clue what the law will be tomorrow. It makes it rather hard to guide yourself accordingly, when there is no accepted law to follow.
All of this arises because of the State’s refusal to allow same-sex marriage. If gays could marry in New York, we could go back the same old law that has served us well for the past 100 years. You want to prove that you have a relationship that the law should recognize and that will give you the rights of a married couple? Then get married. If you don’t get married, then you will not be treated as if you were married.
Now, equitable estoppel is in vogue. The concept has merit under the circumstances, but it lacks any bright line test to tell people where to stop if they want to stay out of trouble. It would force gay couples into defensive postures just to make sure that they don’t say or do something which, under next week’s version of the law, will come back to change the nature of every choice they made. This is no way to live.
Everyone needs law they can rely on to guide them. Gays and straights need to know where the line is, so they can willingly decide to cross it. If the lines gets moved every week, we all suffer. And when the State finally gets it’s collective head out of its collective butt and allows same-sex marriage, we will be stuck holding the bag on a lot of court decisions designed to circumvent the problem, but which will leave us with massive confusion as to whether we guide ourselves by the front door law or the back.
We all know that we’re going to end up with gay marriage across America eventually. Even the religious zealots will eventually toss in the towel when the learn that their favorite TV high priest likes to go down low after a hot and sweaty sermon. So let’s do it sooner rather than later, before we end up with a domestic relations jurisprudence that will cause misery amongst families and children for decades to come. Do it for the children.
Author Archives: SHG
Crossed I’s, Dotted T’s, Enough
My blawging inspiration, What About Clients?, posts often about legal writing. Both Holden and Dan are in favor of writing well, though Holden appears to be the more bloodthirsty of the two. But I get their drift, and agree wholeheartedly. Communicating through written expression is an absolute necessity in the lawyer’s arsenal of skills.
But there comes a time when enough is enough.
I represent a number of lawyers in various matters. Shameless self-aggrandizing point: There’s a reason why other lawyers select me to be their lawyer. Lawyers are not easy clients. Aside from trying to get them on the phone when you need something, or their insistence that they “get it” when they don’t, they want to read everything you write in their case.
Now, criminal law is not considered particularly paper intensive, as compared to other practice areas where people think they are doing litigation when all they are doing is papering each other to death. But I take my motions and memoranda of law quite seriously, and put in a great deal of effort to make my arguments fly soar. It’s not just a matter of professional pride, but since I do appellate as well as trial practice, I recognize the importance of establishing sound legal arguments to avoid claims of waiver or lack of preservation later.
As I write, I send off my work to my clients for their review. Some clients just feel the weight, and that’s enough for them. But my lawyer clients are very different. They will pore over a document, parsing every verb and adjective into the middle of the night. For some reason, they tend to leave nouns alone.
If I don’t get a half dozen phone calls about a particular set of papers, I find a dozen emails in my box every morning asking the crucial question, “Shouldn’t this verb be in the past pluperfect tense?” “Get scrod,” I mumble to myself. Or the message left on voice mail at 3:32 A.M. asking what the proper bluebook form is for an Idaho citation. Yeah, that’s the one that will win or lose the case.
I appreciate other people reading my work. They will find the occasional missing letter, or inadvertent comma. They will question an awkwardly phrased sentence that seemed perfectly normal to me at the time. Since communication is about reception, not just conception, it is critically important that the message I think I’m sending is the same message that is received by the reader. What I think doesn’t matter nearly as much as what the reader thinks. I’m down with that, and I really like to have someone edit my work.
But there comes a point when all the i’s are dotted, all the t’s are crossed, and staring harder at the page of characters brings diminishing returns. Arguments can be tweaked to the point where their purpose is lost, their meaning is muddled in a morass of unduly-detailed edits. Clients frequently are obsessed with the most trivial details, which loom far larger than life when they read about them over and over and over.
They suddenly take on earth-shattering significance, when the reality is that they are at best peripherally important and at worst totally irrelevant. Litigants are particularly bad at discerning irrelevant detail. They think everything that happened in their life is of monumental importance.
It’s up to the lawyer to allow clients their chance to speak their mind, have their input and feel as if they are empowered to have a say in their case. But it is also the lawyer’s job to know when to put a stop to it. Sure, it’s their life and if they want to screw up the papers, why stop them. It’s unpleasant. It can piss off the client. It’s not as empathetic as some touchy-feely proponents think it should be. But like a good parent, a good lawyer knows that the end-game, prevailing, takes precedence. Sometimes, you have to say no.
Besides, if you don’t put your foot down, they’ll drive you nuts.
Megan Meier Suicide Brings Lori Drew Indictment
The news broke late yesterday in one of the saddest affairs stemming from the internet, the Megan Meier suicide brought about by Lori Drew, the mother of one of Megan’s classmates, who pretended to be a teenage girl who befriended, and then turned abusive, using Myspace. The idea of an adult driving a 13 year old to suicide is heart breaking.
Situations like this are precisely the types of cases that give birth to bad law. We are so angry, so disgusted by Lori Drew’s conduct that we turn a blind eye to the mechanics of prosecuting her because we really want to see her punished for what she did. Anger overcomes reason, a very dangerous proposition.
Orin at Volokh has already dissected the indictment against Lori Drew, arising under 18 U.S.C. 1030, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA). Dan Solove at Co-Op has already dissected Orin’s analysis. Between the two of them, they’ve got the professorial approach covered.
Orin succinctly lays out the government’s theory:
To understand this case, you need to understand the government’s theory. The indictment is not charging Drew with harassment. Nor are they charging her with homicide. Rather, the government’s theory in this case is that Drew criminally trespassed onto MySpace’s server by using MySpace in a way that violated MySpace’s Terms of Service (TOS).
Here’s the idea. The TOS required Drew to provide accurate registration information, not to harass or harm other people, and not to promote conduct that was abusive. She didn’t comply with these terms, the theory goes, so she was criminally trespassing onto MySpace’s computer when she was logging into her account. The indictment turns this into a federal felony conspiracy charge by arguing that she did this in concert with others to obtain information and to further tortious conduct — intentional infliction of emotional distress — violating the felony provisions of 18 U.S.C. 1030(a)(2).
In essence, the government is using the CFAA to turn a breach of the Myspace Terms of Service (you know, that little box you have to click what says “I agree” that neither you nor anyone else has ever read) into the foundation for a crime.
The ramifications of this theory are mind-boggling. Contemplate what it means as you cruise around the internet, visiting websites about which you know little to nothing where you click the little box, and consider that your failure to be scrupulously honest in every way would subject you to prosecution. This is pretext raised to its extreme.
Sure, it’s not likely that our fine government agents will be breaking down your door because you gave a false name when entering Madame Zuwongas’ House of Omniscience dot com. But if it just so happens that they want to get you anyway, now they have a weapon available to go after every human being who’s ever typed the letter “w” three times in a row. Violating a website’s “TOS” is carte blanche to an imaginative prosecutor. We are all felons if this flies.
Another aspect of this indictment that shocks the normal conscience is that the computer that the government claims was accessed “without authorization” was located in California, while Drew and Megan Meier sat at their computers in Missouri. Want to guess where Drew was indicted?
This is a potential nightmare. Despite no hard contact with a state a thousand miles away, a defendant can be dragged essentially anywhere to face prosecution. Away from family, witnesses, and (most importantly) an attorney. If the idea of the Central District of California isn’t bad enough, consider the potential for Bangalore in our flat world. They might not have the same interest in due process that we have here either.
Some responses to Orin’s analysis urged that the federal judge who lands this case will grant a motion to dismiss. The problem is that there is no such animal in federal practice. Once a federal grand jury indicts a ham sandwich (H/T Sol Wachler), it’s supposed to be a done deal until the jury says “not guilty” or the government attorney drops to his knees.
While the view of this indictment is universally negative, despite the similarly universal disgust toward Lori Drew’s conduct, it’s going to take a District Court judge with brass balls intestinal fortitude and an expansive view of his inherent powers to toss this indictment.
As bad as the outcome of Lori Drew’s bizarre conduct toward Megan Meier is, this approach is absolutely horrific. It opens doors that will most assuredly wreak havoc with fundamental principles of criminal law in the future and will create such broad exposure to abuse that it needs to be slammed shut immediately. For everyone’s sake, let’s hope that this one ends quickly.
New Blood in the Blawgosphere
They come. They go. More come.
West Virginia is one of those places that guys like me from New York seem to forget exists. I don’t even get the name, since there’s no East Virginia. Nonetheless, we now have that little corner of the blawgosphere covered by John Bryan at his blawg, West Virginia Criminal Defense Law Blog.
John’s blawg notes that he practices “personal injury and criminal defense.” which means that he’s trying to cover his bases and not chase away any of those really good Pi cases while he’s having fun messing with the government. The blawg has plenty of self-promotion stuff on its sidebar, but his posts are beginning to have a little bite to them.
Hopefully, John will find his voice and start developing more original content and loosen his tie a bit. He riffed off one of my posts (that’s how I found him) and he even called me “Mr. Greenfield.” I felt honored. Usually, when people call me “Mr.”, it’s dripping with sarcasm. Good luck John, and don’t be afraid to let loose a little. Nobody around here has a clue what’s happening in West Virginia, and we’d like to hear about all the sexy stuff your little state has to offer.
Yesterday, I (as well as a bunch of others around the blawgosphere) got an email about a new New York criminal defense blawg. It was a pretty weird email, coming from the “Senior Paralegal and Editor” of the blawg. That is soooo New York. The lawyer, Charles Ross, was either too busy or too important to bother sending out emails to little guys like me, so he had his para do it for him. Apparently my time reading his para’s email was of no consequence, but his time is another matter.
The blawg is called “Exposed, a criminal defense attorney answers the question: what’s my exposure?” I’m not sure if anybody asked. You’re probably wondering whether this is another self-promotional blawg, and of course it is. But it’s got some beautiful pictures of New York interspersed with some pedestrian copy. While it links to newspaper articles, I couldn’t find a single story link to another blog, which suggests that he’s there to promote his own practice and he’s not giving anybody else a nod.
Another peculiarity, for a new wannabe blawg, in the email was this sentence:
We have included you in our very selective blogroll and would be pleased if you were to decide to reciprocate.
I felt so honored to be in their “very selective blogroll.” My blogroll, on the other hand, isn’t all that selective. I just include blawgs I read. Exposed has yet to make the cut. Reading warmed over news without any hint of actual thought isn’t my cup of tea. There’s a pomposity about some New Yorkers that’s just too much to take.
One last thing that sticks out. Charles Ross has a really nice firm logo on his blog, with the trademarked phrase “Trusted Criminal Defense.” While it’s not clear what that means, I wonder how he’s going to explain it to the disciplinary committee.
If you think I’m being a little tough on this one, forgive me. He’s clearly put a lot of money into his website and blog in order to promote himself amongst a very big criminal defense community in New York, and that’s understandable. It’s a tough market. But sending out that email via the paralegal, and with such ridiculously pretentious content was more laughable than anything else.
So I offer (the email asked) some thoughts. Chuck, if you want to crack into the blawgosphere, don’t insult others by sending your para to do it. Ever. Second, if you want anyone to read, then write something yourself and have something to actually say. And finally, we’re not interested in your self-promotion.
Show the blawgosphere that you’ve got the right stuff and you won’t have to lay the promotion on so thick. Say something and maybe people will read it, but don’t announce yourself by insulting others with this nonsense. It’s not impressive.
Fieger Takes: Gerry Spence, Abusive Agents and the Norm in Detroit
The trial of Geoffrey Fieger is coming to a head in MoTown. This is the one where Gerry Spence, the lawyer who has never lost a criminal case, stands under the spotlight as the last hope of the regular man against the vast might of the government. Mind you, Fieger’s not exactly the poster boy for the “regular man.”
Regardless of whether you’re a big Spence fan or not, he is most assuredly a living legend amongst criminal defense lawyers. Enough so that my pal Norman, who has followed this trial and posted about it on a daily basis, decided to pick his tired old butt off the seat and hop a plane to Detroit to see the legend in action. For a guy who says he’s not a fan of Mr. Spence, this strikes me as a rather significant commitment.
I’ve followed Norm’s blow by blow of the trial, and even tossed my 2 cents in on occasion. I don’t really have a horse in the race, but I do find it troubling when any lawyer promotes himself as heavily as Gerry Spence. Tzniut , modesty in all things, the Talmud tells us. Spence is not a modest fellow.
In contrast to Norm’s reporting of the trial, Turley posts about it today as well. Reading Turley’s take, one would think the trial is going swimmingly for the government. Reading Norm, one might think otherwise.
I don’t think Turley reads Norm’s blawg. I don’t know if Turley reads anyone’s blawg. He’s certainly not big on links to others if he gets ideas from anyone else. I believe he may read my blawg, but I don’t think he’d ever admit it. I believe this because I choose to live in a fantasy world where everyone reads my blawg. I have absolutely no proof to the contrary.
Turley writes:
The trial of controversial lawyer Geoffrey Fieger for illegal campaign contributions to John Edwards 2004 campaign is in full swing with the testimony of his paralegal and trainer. Despite his all-star defense team, Fieger’s defense seems pretty lame: he admits that he reimbursed employees for contributions but did not realize that it was illegal.
Spence is lame. You heard it here second. But as we all know, trials aren’t like baseball games, where they score by the inning. It’s a winner take all proposition, and it’s not over till the fringed lawyer sings. Turley lists the witnesses from Fieger’s firm who testified against him, and makes it sound like the government scored, witness after witness. Maybe so. His post certainly suggests that Fieger is going down, down, down.
Turley also brings up an interesting aside from the midst of the trial.
One of the interesting aspects of Sandner’s testimony was her refusal to testify under immunity if FBI agent Jeffrey Rees was present. Sandner testified that Rees was so abusive and rough that in his interrogation that she refused to be in the same room with him. I have seen many of such complaints against agents who get away with such treatment of witnesses. Notably, the Justice Department is silent on the sworn testimony. She is obviously quite credible since she is cooperating. Yet, once again, these allegations of abuse seemed to be ignored by the Justice Department — even after being vented in open court.
Norm mentioned this as well, but didn’t go into this troubling aspect as Turley does. Norm’s take is that the jury will come to hate the agents and believe that witnesses are testifying for the government out of fear that the agents will harm their children.
Agents, of course, believe that they are entitled to do anything in the name of “justice”. There is no limit to the depth of their depravity to get the bad guy. It’s a curious moral dilemma, but lawyers working for the Department of Justice don’t seem to notice this problem.
It’s very cool that Norm was able to hop a plane to go see Spence cross the case agent today. I can’t wait to read what happens. If I didn’t have to slave away on my own cases, I would have taken the seat next to Norm. I love a road trip.
Picking Juries, Federal Style
The other day, Houston Criminal Defense Lawyer Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, posted about voir dire in a federal case. It was a short post. That was all he needed:
A judge’s voir dire is calculated to get jurors to promise to follow the law while a lawyer’s voir dire is calculated to find those who might have difficulty following the law.
A judge’s voir dire is calculated to get jurors to agree with the judge while a lawyer’s voir dire is calculated to find those who disagree.
A judge’s voir dire is calculated to qualify more jurors while a lawyer’s voir dire is calculated to find those who are not qualified.
That pretty well sums it up. For state court practitioners who don’t visit the really nice wood-paneled federal courtrooms too often, all the efforts put into voir dire go straight out the window. In state court, voir dire can take days. In federal court, you’re almost guaranteed a jury before lunch.
This makes it all the more ironic that the Supreme Court considered the issue of magistrate-conducted voir dire in Gonzalez v. U.S.. as Jon Katz (Randazza’s muse) posts at Underdog. There, the Supreme affirmed a conviction where the lawyer agreed to have a United States Magistrate Judge conduct voir dire, thus saving the District Judge’s time for more important things like approving a speedy trial waiver. The problem was that the defendant never waived Judge-conducted voir dire and agreed to let the magistrate do it instead.
Once justice dissented in Gonzalez. No, not Scalia (he concurred). As Jon put it,
This case is worth reading both for the majority opinion and for Justice Thomas’s dissent, in which he insists that defendants — not their lawyers — personally have the opportunity to say aye or nay on the record about having a magistrate judge conduct jury selection. As much as I did not want Justice Thomas to join the Supreme Court and still feel the same way, I thank him for his dissent in Gonzalez .
I can appreciate Jon’s gratitude to Justice Thomas, even if it’s only this once. The idea that defendants (you remember them, the people who actually do the time after the lawyers go to the bar for happy hour) actually have a hand in their own fate matters. It’s a slippery slope when courts and defense lawyers forget that these are real people at stake here.
In this particular instance, however, the issue is far more form over substance. First, as noted by the Texas Tornado, federal voir dire is a show put on to pretend that we have something to say about who gets on the jury and make us feel like lawyers.
Second, ask a defendant whether he would prefer judge-run or magistrate run jury selection. These are the full panoply of potential responses:
a) Blank stare
b) “What do you think?”
c) “What’s the difference?”
d) “What should I do?”
e) Silence while gazing at the window
The plain truth is that this, like most other decisions at trial, is of little interest to defendants. They want to win, and they want their lawyer to win it for them. They expect their lawyer to be their lawyer, make lawyerly decisions and handle such matters. And who can blame them?
I agree with Jon, and Justice Thomas, that decisions that are given to “the defendant” should remain with the defendant as a matter of principle. I agree that it is vital that defendants remain part of the game, not merely an observer to a trial as their life is decided by a group of people who presume to be able to distinguish truth from fiction.
But the reality is that the decision will always be made by the lawyer on matters such as this, because that’s why people have lawyers and why the Constitution guarantees them the right to be represented by counsel. The words of assent should be uttered from the mouth of a defendant, after a full and accurate explanation by the judge of the rights at stake. But the decision comes from the lawyer, and most lawyers realize that in federal voir dire, it doesn’t matter anyway.
Hitting the Internet Wall
A couple of years ago, I was asked to give a CLE on the use of technology in trial preparation. At the time, I had just finished a trial where the complaining witness had a website, which I found and used to emasculate his perjurious testimony. It was a great cross-examination, if I do say so myself.
That made me competent to talk about the subject back then. In retrospect, the idea of an old codger like me (meaning anyone over 30) talking about technology is laughable. Today, if you haven’t tried any of the tech ideas that appeared online in the past 30 minutes, you’re out of date. I am, regretfully, out of date.
Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer Jamie Spencer is busily keeping codgers like abreast of new developments, which has the terrible side-affect of preventing him from finishing many of his blawg posts. One of the things he’s found is this website,
Felonspy.com – You need to know who your neighbors are. Especially if they’re dangerous criminals
Unbelievable! Put in an address and this website will tell you all the felons in the neighborhood. What an incredible thing this is. Not. It turns out that it’s just a scam. My “felons” turned out to be the exact same as Jamie’s “felons”, and I happen to know that nobody by the name of “Vincent May” lives in the same house as Abby Rockefeller.
Compare this to Gideon’s discussion of Microsoft’s Virtual Earth. Gid, a self-proclaimed techno geek (not something that one would openly admit in my day) talks about how useful it is to be able to sit at one’s desk and “see” a crime scene in order to understand police reports, road layouts and such. I’ve often used Google Earth for the same purpose.
These are not only real tools, but incredibly useful ones to be capable of accomplishing things that would take us half a day, and usually require us to go back a couple more times, in the old days. In fact, I find that I get a more useful view from these photos, since they can provide a broader image of an area than one can see in person, than visiting the scene itself.
The point is that there is incredibly good and useful stuff available now that codgers like me never dreamed of, and complete crap that might serve to trap the unwary, and if relied upon, make one appear quite properly a fool. It’s understandable that every twenty-something, or younger, wants to create the new, greatest website phenom. A handful have become billionaires this way, and a lot more have become relatively rich. As the philosopher Tevye said, it’s no crime to be rich.
But we have become inundated with techno miracles. Even the really good stuff, like the competing “Earths”, leave us in a quandary. Why two competing versions? Which is better and why? And most importantly, how do we find the time to figure it out?
From the great mass of unwashed lawyers side, there are too many miracles appearing to keep track. I try my darndest to follow, and I can’t. And in the mix of lawyers over 30, I’m considered quite techno-savvy. I even have a blawg! I must know something, right?
While many lawyers come here to read Simple Justice (and I thank each and every one of you), the vast majority have never read a blawg in the life. As I stumble across new blawgs daily, I’ve come to the realization that my RSS feeder is already overloaded with far more than I can read. It’s not that new blawgs are unworthy, but that it takes time that I just don’t have.
I’ve hit the wall. The internet may be limitless, but the real world is not.
There’s a folder on my browser with all the new-fangled legal websites that provide information, caselaw, searches, investigative tools, you name it. It’s got so much stuff in it that I can’t find anything when I need it. I look at the names of the websites and I can’t remember what they do or why I put them into the folder.
Many call themselves by strange names, non-words that constitute “hard trademark” fodder like google and yahoo!. That used to be cute. Now it’s just unhelpful. Give me a name like “Find 2nd Circuit Decisions” so I’ll have some clue when I look at it in the future what it does.
But the problem is exacerbated by the daily hourly minute second nano-second growth of new websites with ever-greater, newer, more novel ideas. And then toss the scam websites in to really gum up the works. We’re way overloaded. Who can blame that great mass of lawyers who, unlike me and Gid and Jamie, aren’t totally techno-savvy, for concluding that there is no way they are going to jump into the middle of the internet now and figure out what’s good and bad. It’s overwhelming. It makes my head spin. It gives me a headache. No, that’s the red wine. Sorry.
This gives me an idea. Someone should create a website and call it something like “Legal Source.” It should scour the internet for every tool, blawg, database, whatever, that could possibly serve the needs of lawyers, and then categorize them so that if you need something, you can find it. It should distinguish the real from the scam, and then rate them on utility, accuracy, reliability, cost.
Instead of each lawyer googling to try to find out if there’s something out there to use to locate “Joe Blow” and figure out if he a lying skel, we could just go to Legal Source and see everything that’s available and which would be best to use. This website could update it’s sources every quarter second to make sure it’s up-to-date, particularly since whoever runs this website has nothing else to do and no actual life. He or she would live to serve lawyers. Oh, what a wonderful cyberworld it would be.
This isn’t a bad idea at all. It probably already exists and I just don’t know about it yet. I haven’t got the time to look. I told you I hit the wall.
Twitter Version: 2 many websites; need new one 2 aggregate. Sleepy.
Judges, Don’t Make Us Spank You
From the New York Lawyer, an article about a statement released by the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct directed at the state’s 1300 underpaid judges telling them . . . what?
In warning the judges of the potential ethical repercussion of recusals, the judicial conduct commission noted that it was acting in the wake of “recent published reports that at least some judges are encouraging or engaging in acts of recusal” out of a purported “frustration over the compensation issue.”
Did the Commission actually “warn” the judges? Let’s take a look. This is what the statement says:
It would benefit neither the judiciary nor their justifiable interest in a fair compensation package for the Commission to be constrained to consider complaints against judges alleged to have violated these or other sections of the Rules in connection with the salary issue. The Commission urges all parties with a role to play in this matter to do so responsibly, professionally and with the utmost sensitivity to promoting public confidence in the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary, the courts and the administration of justice.
What in the world does that mean, “constrained to consider?” It sounds to me as if the Commission’s message is exactly the opposite of what it appears to be, that they are giving a big wink to the judges by providing them with the roadmap around any potential rule issues and announcing that they have no plans to find themselves “constrained” to consider much of anything.
I support the judges standing up for themselves, and have come out publicly to that effect. Others disagree with me, and that’s fine but, as far as I’m concerned, unhelpful. The judges have played nicely with the Legislature for a decade, and have been turned into beggars. It does beg one thing, the question of when enough is enough.
The arguments have all been made. Everyone agrees on the right and wrong of it. A million words have been spilled in the battle for a salary increase. They died in vain.
This is war. And it was declared by the Legislature and Executive when they offered kind words but no cash. The judges now have two choices: Sit back, very erect in their silky black robes on their high bench in their big leather chair, knowing that you’re the only person in the room whose pay has not increased in 13 years and that you are utterly powerless, impotent, to do anything about it. Or “exercise” individual conscience and act on it.
To those who claim it’s about dignity, I say there is nothing dignified about being proven that your impotent. Viagra won’t help this dysfunction. To those who claim that recusals or slow-downs will hurt the judiciary in the “eyes of its supporters,” I ask how? How can the judiciary be hurt any more than it already is? Will they start reducing judicial salaries? Take away their robe dry-cleaning allowance? Make them empty their own judicial wastebaskets?
A judge can put a defendant in prison forever. A judge is a member of a branch of government, charged with a primary function, for better or worse, in our scheme of checks and balances. And for all the high-sounding praise, a judge is a pawn in the game of politics. Unless the judge says enough is enough.
It’s not like they haven’t tried. They’ve been patient. They’ve been dignified. They’ve relied on the system that is the basis of harsh reprimands to litigants of all ilks. And they’ve been screwed for it. As I wrote over at Judicial Reports, “they didn’t start the fight, but it’s up to them to end it.”
Let’s see what the Commission plans to do about it. No pain, no gain.
When Prosecutors Go Hollywood
Liptak came up with something interesting yesterday. He should get a bonus. His New York Times piece tells about a California Supreme Court decision which, though cautioning prosecutors to “try their case in court,” reversed a lower appellate court’s recusal of the prosecutor on a death penalty case.
Before going any further, it is critical to note the name of the defendant first: Jesse James Hollywood. I kid you not. This kid was destined for trouble. What was his mother thinking?
So here’s what happened:
The case asserting a cinematic conflict of interest involved Jesse James Hollywood, who faces the death penalty for his role in the 2000 kidnapping and murder of a 15-year-old boy. While Mr. Hollywood was a fugitive in Brazil in 2003, Ronald Zonen, a deputy district attorney in Santa Barbara, gave information and documents about him to Nick Cassavetes, a director and screenwriter.
And indeed, the story ultimately found its way into the movies.
The film, “Alpha Dog,” was released last year, and it flattered neither Mr. Hollywood, depicted as a dimwitted nihilist called Johnny Truelove, nor the audience. Manohla Dargis, writing in The New York Times, said the film had “much the same entertainment value you get from watching monkeys fling scat at one another in a zoo.”
From the legal perspective, bear in mind that this prosecutor, Zonen, handed over confidential records he possessed as a deputy district attorney to a Hollywood director. Zonen claimed his intentions were good:
Mr. Zonen, who was not paid for his consulting work, said he had hoped the film would lead to Mr. Hollywood’s apprehension.
As it turned out, Mr. Hollywood (the real one, not the cliché) was caught before the film was released. Because of Zonen’s conduct, his attorney argued that Zonen should be recused for his efforts to poison the jury pool and his misconduct in releasing his file to a movie guy.
On appeal, the Court held that Zonen engaged in conduct that was “highly inappropriate and disturbing” but did not rise to the level requiring his recusal for having denied defendant a fair trial. Probably true, as it’s unlikely that any movie was going to poison the well in this case. The defendant’s name alone was going to assure that he was the subject of attention.
But here again, a prosecutor does wrong, and so what? This deputy should have been canned as soon as his boss found out that he opened his file to a director. This was a crime, according to the California Supreme Court. And that’s okay?
While recusal for having sought to poison the well may have been rejected, why not recusal for demonstrating the lack of ethics for committing a crime in the course of the prosecution? The defendant is entitled to a prosecutor who will perform his duty ethically and properly, not one who happily commits a crime in the process. He must be trusted to perform such functions as providing Brady material and otherwise acting in good faith. If he doesn’t mind committing crimes, then how can the system be assured that he will perform his function ethically otherwise?
And this is how bad movies happen.
Indigent Defense Problem? Study It!
What’s often obvious to people on the inside of the onion gets subsumed in layers of obfuscation to the outsiders. I wouldn’t have thought this true of indigent defense, but apparently I would be wrong.
Newsday has an editorial today about indigent defense. That’s not just a good thing, but a great thing. Issues like this rarely make it onto the radar unless there’s some tragedy or scandal that commands attention. This popped up organically, without any particular screams for change.
Unfortunately, the news is not all good. Indigent defense in New York, aside from the past issues of exceptionally poor pay to the lawyers providing it, and the state having made it an unfunded mandate, suffers from lack of oversight, highly inconsistent quality, wasteful expense and occasional abuse. It’s a barely a system at all, more like the longest running ad hoc show in town.
Recognizing that indigent defense failed to satisfy the true meaning of Gideon, Chief Judge Judy Kaye put together a commission to come up with a better system, a real system. The outcome was announced by Judge Kaye in 2007. The state needed an independent Indigent Defense Commission to operate a statewide system that could provide education, oversight, support and control to the provision of services to the poor. It would save money and drastically improve the quality of representation.
Apparently, Albany has finally taken the idea and ran with it. Sideways. Albany has come up with the brainstorm that they need for form an “independent commission,” not to run and manage the system, but to study the system.
Legislation initiated in the Assembly would create an independent public defender commission to dissect the system’s inadequacies. It would report to the legislature what it would take to ensure an adequate, independent legal defense, what it would cost and how to get there from here. It’s a journey that officials need to take.
While I appreciate Newsday taking any interest in the subject at all, do they not have anyone around that newspaper who actually reads it? Don’t they know that this was already completed, and the results are in?
While the editorial writers of Newsday may have their hearts in the right place, their heads are somewhere else. It’s been studied. It has the support of the court system. It has the support of the bar associations. It’s a no-brainer. We need the commission to run it. What we don’t need is another commission to study it.
The only thing this guarantees is that another few years will pass, and another thousands more indigent defendants will be prosecuted without adequate representation, and millions of dollars will be flushed down the toilet, and we will find ourselves right back at the starting line. Wonderful.
