Author Archives: SHG

Commerce and Crime

Jon Katz at Underdog picked up a Florida decision in US v. Powers that goes through the many and varied laws named after tragedies to children that give rise to the sex offender registry offenses, and concludes that the federal Adam Walsh Act is unconstitutional as an exercise of federal power that cannot be justified under the commerce clause.

As Jon notes, this is a great decision, following in the footsteps of US v. Lopez relating to guns in school zones.

For those who don’t do federal practice, this is the problem.  The federal government’s authority to create crimes out of whole cloth comes from the commerce clause, based upon the theory that the offense impacts on interstate commerce.  If a law doesn’t “regulate activities that substantially affect interstate commerce,” then the federal government has no business getting involved.

This is a problem for most federal law-makers, who are thus left with fewer opportunities to prove how tough they are on crime and how the federal government matters in the lives of ordinary people by passing laws named after children.  This, of course, refers to the enjoyment of an opportunity to turn every tragedy into some political gain by hastily creating a law to fix a problem that likely doesn’t exist to solve a tragedy that will make the lawmaker more electable.  Does this description make me sound cynical?

The problem with use of the commerce clause is that it is almost entirely rhetorical.  If a lawmaker, or a prosecutor, has any imagination at all, coupled with even a small facility at expressing a point, it takes little effort to create a rationale that turns any and every act performed by humankind into something that affects interstate commerce.

For example, consider “chaos theory.”  That’s the one where a butterfly, flapping its wings in the Sea of China, causes a tornado in Texas.  The theory is perfectly logical, but it also obliterates any ability to separate acts that are local from having a broader impact.  If the flapping of a butterfly’s wings has a global impact, then there is no limit to what would affect interstate commerce.  This argument has been widely accepted and, as a result, federal criminal law has expanded to the point of making federal judges akin to the local magistrate.

Over the course of the past 25 years, the feds have assumed jurisdiction over “crimes” that would never have been considered in federal courts before that.  Part of the problem has been the public’s lack of understanding of the limits of federal authority.  Criminal justice was largely a local matter, to be handled by states under traditional views of federalism. 

But as the lines between state and federal governments blurred, and as people began demanding that “someone do something” about each and every oddball problem that happened, Congress kept reaching out to cover matters that were always considered local before.  Unfortunately, the courts allowed this to happen, adopting an expansive view of the Commerce Clause that would permit any conduct to be criminalized provided a half-way decent argument was made. 

The Lopez decision was a turning point, where the Supreme finally said enough.  But that was 1995, and while it presented a break from the ever-expanding scope of federal authority, few judges have been bold enough to revisit criminal laws to decide whether it has a real impact on interstate commerce or is one of those rhetorical arguments that would have every act subject to the commerce clause because of a butterfly.

The Powers decision, though dealing with an unpleasant and unpopular subject, is an important decision and really quite bold.  It does not absolve sex offenders, or eliminate registry.  It does, however, leave such matters to the state to handle since the law had nothing to do with interstate commerce and the federal government had no authority to get involved. 

We Need an Innocence Commission of One

Grits for Breakfast has been posting about the Innocence Summit held in Austin.  That would be the one where Grits was made to sit in the back of the bus.  When things like this happen, it makes newspaper editorial writers remember that the same system that was wonderful yesterday can fail today.  And so Grits reports that the Dallas Morning News has backed the creation of an Innocence Commission.

It’s needed badly in Texas, which has 33 DNA-established exonerations to date, more than any other state. Seventeen are from Dallas County, more than in any other U.S. county.

News flashes about Dallas cases obscure the fact that local exonerations would not be achieved were it not for the sound practice of storing biological evidence in all criminal cases. No other Texas county has done that; one can only imagine how many wrongly convicted people from the 253 other Texas counties have no shot at DNA exoneration. A special commission could recommend best practices for evidence storage, among a long list of other law enforcement procedures.

It’s badly needed everywhere.  But while recognition that there is a problem is a first step, there is a much larger point that has yet to make it onto the editorial radar.  The DNA exonerations were critical to making it clear to lawmakers and the public that we are busily convicting innocent people, or somewhat innocent people as the case may be.  But for hard proof of innocence, something that rarely exists in the realm of criminal law, people have denied that this phenomenon really existed, and if it did, that it was so inconsequential as to be unworthy of greater concern.

The DNA cases have proven otherwise to everyone except Justice Scalia, who finds the level of collateral damage acceptable.  Without hard, irrefutable proof that innocent people were being convicted in significant numbers, despite the courts’ use of all the methods to assure the integrity of the process that appellate courts, prosecutors, experts and law professors assure us will guarantee that only the guilty are convicted, society would just ignore the whole problem.  Criminal defense lawyers would argue to the contrary, and everyone else would have a good night’s sleep.

So now we have a baseline to work with.  The people exonerated by DNA were given every protection our system has to offer.  And they were convicted anyway.  Between bad eyewitness IDs and testilying cops, Brady-withholding prosecutors and judges who will always go with the odds and side with the cops on a credibility call, the deck is just as stacked today as it was before. 

While an Innocence Commission is a great idea, and I’m all for anything that will bring greater integrity and transparency to the law enforcement/prosecutorial side of the equation, no one has as yet come up with a way to deal with the fact that the great mass of convictions won’t involve DNA, or smoking gun Brady violations.  People don’t always get convicted with a bang, but often a whimper. 

One punt on a credibility call will spell defeat for an innocent defendant.  One bad ruling on expert testimony blows a defense out of the water.  Identifications are always a source of problems, even if somewhat improved by sequential rather than the bad, a line-up, or, the worst, a show-up. 

We fall back on the way we’ve always done things, even though we know that they just don’t always work.  Why?  Because the system is based on the odds.  The odds are that the cops are more truthful then the defendants, so when in doubt, go with the cops.  The odds are that the ID is more likely accurate than inaccurate, so when in doubt, go with the ID.  People are always shocked to learn that judges don’t have some magic way to tell who is lying and who isn’t. 

And woe is the defendant confronted with the scientific expert.  Judges know nothing about science, and anyone with a few science courses can opine in court as if he’s just discovered the atom.  The breathalyzer is the perfect example.  Nobody has a clue how it works or if it’s accurate, but it’s conclusive proof.  If a little black box says you’re drunk, then you are drunk.  End of story.  You can’t argue with a box, and no judge anywhere will question the notion that the box is absolutely irrefutable evidence.

What I’m trying inartfully to get to is that while our system will be improved by post hoc revisitation, any real desire to stop the conviction of the innocent must start with the trial judge and the application of the “rules” that are now used to play the game as a real tool to vet the bad from the good.  The system is replete with vagaries that will never serve some Commission years later to distinguish good evidence from bad. 

If judges don’t stop playing the odds, siding with the cops and prosecution whenever an issue is in dispute, then innocent people will continue to be convicted.  If judges don’t stop worrying more about the reputations of cops and prosecutors than about the lives of the people before them, still more innocent people will be convicted. 

We have an Innocence Commission of one on every criminal case in America.  If our Innocence Commissioner does his job in the first place, we can make a dent in this horrible problem.  As long as judges continue to play the odds, no Innocence Commission can do enough to save us.

When Twitter is Too Deep

Blogging was supposed to be some shorthand way of expressing ideas that weren’t ready for the bigtime.  In journalism, that would be a step below column.  In law, that would be a giant leap below a law review article.  While a column in a newspaper is nothing at all like a law review article, apparently journalists think columns are the epitome of quick and dirty journalistic thought.  I didn’t realize this under I read this op-ed in Newsday by Joel Stein of the Los Angeles Times.

Joel explains the declining scale of thought as expressed in the fewest possible characters:


The reason I wanted to be a columnist is that you don’t need any complex ideas to be one. So you can imagine how jealous I was when along came bloggers, who have it even easier than I do.

What I could not imagine – like Aristotle trying to contemplate an atom – was that ideas exist that are too small even for a blog post.

Yet Web writers – like Eskimos with a whale carcass – refuse to throw away these micro-thoughts. They’re publishing them via tumblr.com, which helps you broadcast your passing observations to the world. These are the kinds of thoughts you are about to share when you open your mouth and make a little noise and then decide not to bother.

He’s talking about tumble, which apparently is intended for people too long winded to twitter.


But a tumble isn’t even the smallest known unit of thought on the Web. You can Twitter, which are notes of up to 140 characters written from your computer or cell phone and sent to your friends as a feed or posted as the “update status” on your Facebook page.

This caught my eye in a peculiar way.  Anne Reed at Deliberations is banging the Twitter drum again.  Kevin O’Keefe too, noting that news of the China earthquake broke on twitter.  While I don’t twitter, I may be the only one.  But as trends go, twitter apparently isn’t the end of the road.


But what if you don’t have the energy to type a whole phrase? The quark of self-expression is the “current mood” emoticon on MySpace that says whether you’re angry, depressed, bored or embarrassed. It makes no sense to me that this system does not default to “embarrassed.”

One character, no waiting.  Personally, I don’t give that much thought to my “mood” at any given moment, and it would take me long enough to twitter, maybe even tumble, to figure out which emoticon to use.  So even this quark of the web would be burden to me.

But the trend is the point.  Our thoughts are following our writing, increasingly smaller and inconsequential.  What the government can’t do for us in controlling our ability to conceive full-blown ideas, technology is doing for it. 


It seems like this onslaught of drivel is crowding bigger ideas out of the intellectual marketplace. But this new structure of thought categorization, I believe, actually is a form of mental rigor. Books can now be left to big thoughts instead of drawn-out ideas that are really just brilliant blog posts. And, yes, I’m talking to you, “Life After Humans” guy. I get it: Plants will grow and animals will come. Thanks. I figured that out about a week after I bought a house.

We are now forced to determine if our idea is worth a book or an article or a Twitter – just as poets once chose between an epic, a sonnet, a haiku or that crinkled Xeroxed pamphlet that old guy tries to hand you outside the Coffee Bean. If you can’t figure it out, the market quickly will let you know if your idea should have been a film, TV show or on YouTube.

My posts are often subject to subtle reminders that they are lengthier than most op-eds.  I don’t start out with any length in mind, but just write until I’ve said what I have to say about a subject.  It’s organic.  But I don’t find many things worth posting about that can be done in 140 characters.  And I don’t think there are many ideas worth sharing that don’t require a little more than that.

Will this be the next measure of attention span?  Will any idea requiring more than 140 characters die for lack of interest?  Or will the point be that folks like me, incapable of getting something on paper in less than 1000 words, will be too boring to be worth the bother?  Maybe the lesson of tumble and twitter and the quarky thing is that we need to take the same degree of thought and find a way to express it in 20 words or less. 

I don’t think I can do it.  Nor do I think I want to do it.  The subjects usually addressed here tend to be of sufficient value that they are worth more than 140 characters.  If nothing else, I hope that the commentary on those subjects is worth more than that too.  And whenever thoughts pop into my head that can be expressed in less than 140 characters, I keep them to myself.  They just aren’t worth your time to read them.




Through Windy’s Eyes

It’s got merit.  I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, that Mark Draughn is a smart guy.  No wonder he never became a lawyer.

Mark is the Windypundit of Windypundit fame. For some unclear reason, he finds the law curious and maybe even fascinating, in some morbid way.  So he follows it, and see it through his geeky eyes.  Sometimes he sees things that we, lawyers, don’t see.  He did today.

Here comes another one of my radical ideas for criminal justice reform : Striking judges.

No, I’m not advocating smacking judges around, although I’m sure most criminal court attorneys—on either side of the aisle—can think of a few judges that have it coming.

I’m not talking about judges who are strikingly attractive, either, although the attorneys would probably appreciate that too.

Assignment of judges to cases is supposed to be largely a random process.  It isn’t always, for a variety of reasons, but that’s another issue.  The point is that you end up with the judge you end up with, having no say in the matter.  This could spell the different between dismissal or acquittal and life in prison.  Yes, it matters that much.  Lawyers aren’t fungible; neither are judges.

If Windy’s idea were to be put into play, one could expect that the judges on either extreme would be the ones struck, and the judge least objectionable would be selected.  This works out particularly well for the defense side, since we don’t have too many judges on our side at all, no less what one might consider extreme.  In other words, there’s very little downside for the defense.

But it would serve another purpose as well.  Extreme justices would find themselves without business, and this tidbit would become the legend of the courthouse.  It would be a way to tell judges that their impartiality is in doubt, and that they aren’t the people we want to try a case before.  It would apply to their judge-stats, which would be the subject of new stories and election advertisements. 

While elected judges, who just happen to be the ones that nobody wants to work with, will remain elected, this process would likely give rise to a cottage industry within good government groups, court watchers and the media to note who has nothing to do all day long in the courthouse.  It will not just work against any re-election campaign, but also serve to shame them into a serious change of attitude.  There’s nothing like a good public shaming to bring a person around to reality.

There are still some kinks to work out, but that’s just a matter of the details.  As for the basic, radical concept, I think Windy’s got a winner here.

Randazza thinks so too, but I won’t let that influence me at all.

Testilying Without Fear

Sure, criminal defense lawyers may post about cops lying on the witness stand, but we’re criminal defense lawyers.  What would you expect?

But it’s grabbed the attention of the New York Times.  Again.  And that counts for something.  Unfortunately, the story lurking behind the story is the one that is most disturbing.  No one who has a clue is surprised to find that cops exaggerate, fill in the blanks, tailor their testimony, whatever you prefer to call it.  This is just what they do in the name of “justice” (their brand, not mine) to put the bad guy away.

So what’s the ugly part.  Just read:

But the judge, John E. Sprizzo of United States District Court in Manhattan, concluded that the police had simply reached into the pack without cause, found the gun, then “tailored” testimony to justify the illegal search. “You can’t have open season on searches,” said Judge Sprizzo, who refused to allow the gun as evidence, prompting prosecutors to drop the case last May.

Yet for all his disapproval of what the police had done, the judge said he hated to make negative rulings about officers’ credibility. “I don’t like to jeopardize their career and all the rest of it,” he said.  (Emphasis added)

Let me spell this out for you:  a federal judge, and a tough one at that, finds that the cop lied on the witness stand.  What’s his primary concern?  Not to hurt the cop. 

One might think he would see his duty as making sure that a lying cop was drummed off the force.  Maybe make sure that no other person was ever mislead into believing that this was a cop who wouldn’t lie.  Perhaps even referring the matter to the United States Attorney for prosecution for perjury.  Remember, the judge just found that the cop lied!

Nope. None of the above.  Make sure he doesn’t hurt the cops career.  That is his concern.  That’s the duty of a federal judge, to protect lying cops from the consequences of their commission of a crime. 

You may recall the 9th Circuit decision in Chapman, about how two AUSAs deceived the district court.  No, didn’t just deceive, but engaged in “prosecutorial misconduct in its highest form.”  Remember how the Circuit condemned them by name?  Of course not, because the Circuit neglected to mention who these miscreants were.  I suspect they didn’t want to jeopardize their careers.

The Times story goes further:


But a closer look at those prosecutions reveals something that has not been trumpeted: more than 20 cases in which judges found police officers’ testimony to be unreliable, inconsistent, twisting the truth, or just plain false. The judges’ language was often withering: “patently incredible,” “riddled with exaggerations,” “unworthy of belief.”

The outrage usually stopped there. With few exceptions, judges did not ask prosecutors to determine whether the officers had broken the law, and prosecutors did not notify police authorities about the judges’ findings. The Police Department said it did not monitor the rulings and was aware of only one of them; after it learned about the cases recently from a reporter, a spokesman said the department would decide whether further review was needed.

The public thinks that wrongdoing flows downhill; that somebody somewhere does something about it.  Sorry, no.   If you broke the law, that’s a different story.  If you lie on the witness stand, that’s a crime.  If a defendant testifies and loses, that’s obstruction of justice.  But if it’s a cop, circle the wagons lest his career be harmed.

Tell it to all the people that cop’s put away before.  Tell it to all the judges who defaulted into finding the cop credible, because he’s a cop, or the juries who bought into the prosecutor’s argument that “there’s no reason why the cop would lie…”  There’s a very good reason; that’s just what they do.  It’s their job.  The courts are a big joke, and they say the magic words that put the bad guys in jail.  No big deal, just another day’s work.

What do the police have to say about all this?


Paul J. Browne, the Police Department’s chief spokesman, said that only one of the critical rulings had been reported to the police, by a federal prosecutor in Brooklyn who said he had no doubts about the officer’s truthfulness. The police took no action.

More broadly, Mr. Browne said an officer’s failure to convince a judge that his suspicions were justified “doesn’t necessarily mean the officer did something wrong.”

And what happens when the judge finds it so egregious that he actually names names and acts upon it?


Two officers had arrested a man and confiscated a gun in a Bronx apartment in 2002. But Judge Martin, then on the Manhattan federal court, was troubled that one officer had given the district attorney’s office an account of how she gained entry to the apartment, then largely contradicted it on the stand.

“This has to be one of the most blatant cases of perjury I’ve seen,” Judge Martin, a former United States attorney, said in his courtroom in September 2003. He said he doubted the officer, Kim Carillo, had “any use for the truth.”

“She will tell it, I think, whatever way it suits her to tell it,” he added.

The judge told the prosecutor to ask his superiors to review Officer Carillo’s testimony. They later replied that they had found no perjury, he said, and that the officer was not at fault.

Testilying is an intractable and pervasive problem. This is why.  If there were ramifications for getting caught lying, such as jeopardizing a cop’s career (or more importantly, his pension), they would stop.  No perp is worth losing a pension.  But cops testily with impunity, and everyone in the system, except the criminal defense lawyer, is there to protect that cop from the consequences of committing the crime of perjury. 

Welcome to the real world of criminal law.

A New District Attorney for Manhattan?

Robert Morgenthau has been the District Attorney of New York County, known to the rest of the world as Manhattan, forever.  He is now 89 years old.  When the name John McCain is raised in his presence, he sneers and calls him “kid”.  He’s an old man by anyone’s calculations.

Morgenthau was elected DA in 1974, following the death of legendary District Attorney Frank Hogan.  He had previously served as United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York from 1962 to 1969, during the Kennedy and Johnson administrations.  He was ultimately forced out by Nixon. 

Morgenthau came from a time when the wealthy and whitebread of New York Society filled important public offices as a matter of noblesse oblige.  They came from families that had already established their wealth and social standing, and had little left to prove.  Instead, service became their way of proving their worth.  This, if nothing else, shows what an anachronism Bob Morgenthau is today.

In 2005, the unthinkable happened.  An upstart challenged Robert Morgenthau in the Democratic primary for District Attorney.  The very idea that anyone would confront the last man standing from the days of old New York was not merely unthinkable, but an affront.  Morgenthau, despite his age, held the loyalty of every person who served under him.  Well, every person except one:  Leslie Crocker Snyder.

Leslie Crocker Snyder served as a prosecutor under Morgenthau.  She fought her way into a man’s world by being the first woman to try a felony, and later a homicide, in the office.  Morgenthau required her to get her husband’s approval before allowing her to do so.  She then became the chief of the first sex crimes bureau in the nation, and has a hand in authoring New York’s rape shield law,

Leslie went on to become a judge, first in criminal and then as an acting Supreme and later Court of Claims.  Leslie actively sought the biggest and most gruesome cases, and had no problem making sure that her feelings about the defendants were well known and widely reported.  Because of her outspoken ways, she was profiled on CBS News Magazine, 60 Minutes.  Full disclosure:  I was on it with her, but did not have flattering things to say about her as a judge. 

Leslie lost the Democratic primary in 2005 to Robert Morgenthau by 41% to 59%.  Morgy, up to that point, had not prepared for a smooth transition by naming an heir apparent to his office, and Leslie, not getting any younger, decided that she had to buck the party and try if she was ever going to achieve her goal of becoming the first woman District Attorney of New York County.

Today, I received this bit of news:



LESLIE CROCKER SNYDER FOR MANHATTAN D.A.



PLEASE SAVE THE DATE FOR A COCKTAIL RECEPTION SUPPORTING


LESLIE CROCKER SNYDER


New York State Supreme Court Judge (ret.)


DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATE FOR MANHATTAN DISTRICT ATTORNEY


JUNE 23, 2008 ♦ 6:00.8:00 P.M.


NEW YORK ATHLETIC CLUB


180 CENTRAL PARK SOUTH
NEW YORK CITY



*** Invitation to follow shortly ***



Host Committee (Raise/Contribute):


$25,000 (Chair) ♦ $10,000 (Vice Chair) ♦ $5,000 (Host)
Tickets:
$500 (Friend) ♦ $1,000 (Sponsor) ♦ $2,500 (Patron)




Individuals may contribute up to $31,392 for the Primary Election and up to an additional $ 45,832 for the General Election, provided that s/he does not contribute in excess of $150,000 in a calendar year to all candidates for public office in New York State. During 2008, a corporation may contribute up to $5,000, in the aggregate, to candidates seeking election to non-federal office in New York. A partnership may also contribute, and the contribution will be attributed to its partners for the purpose of an individual.s campaign and annual limit. Campaign contributions must be from the individual or entity.s own funds and are not tax-deductible.


It looks like the primary season has started, and I most assuredly will have much more to say on the subject as we go along.  But the first question I have to ask myself is whether I want to plunk $25K down to be a host committee chair. 

OT: Futzing With Blawgs

Ken Lammers just CSS’d.  Gideon changed to some type that moves and has fixed his asides, which I guess prevents them from having baby asides.  Bennett has done all sorts of changes to his blawg, so many I can’t count.  Spencer tells me I ought to do this or that from time to time.  Windy too.

My blawg may not be the most visually appealing or technologically cutting edge.  But I have no plans to fix anything.  It’s not that it “ain’t broke,” but I already have my hands full. 

The way I have this figured, anyone who comes here does so to read something, or watch the occasional new video on my sidebar.  If they come back, they do so because they want to read more.  No one comes back because they find my blawg so incredibly cool that they want to show it to their friends.

I get complaints about my blawg.  Most of the time, it’s a problem with my program, which the company changes every once in a while and invariably wreaks havoc before they straighten out all the bugs.  They don’t test anything first, so they wait until I email them before figuring out whether their changes cause other problems.  They refuse to pay me for this service, but they fully expect me to let them know ASAP so they can fix the bugs.

There’s a lot I don’t know how to do with computers.  It’s not that I’m terrible for someone of my generation.  I’m not.  But keeping pace with change isn’t always on my front burner.  I try, but there are just too many letters and they explanations of what they mean lack a certain clarity to me.  Also, I don’t see the point.

I just type away and hope something worth reading comes out of my fingers.  I hope that it interests anyone reading.  Some have already told me that I’m boring and ignorant.  Others are more encouraging.  Still, there’s not much more that I can do than write about things that interest me and try to say something that is worth the few minutes a reader loses from their life by stopping here.

I admire the other guys who know far more about the mechanics of all this, and who make a concentrated effort to keep apace of technology and improve the function and appearance of their blawgs.  In fact, I’m a little jealous, as I’m sure they know things I don’t, and I hate being the last one to know.  Gideon has tried very hard to help me change things, but I just can’t seem to pull it off.  He’s been a real pal, and I’m unworthy of his help.

So I have no present plans to make my type move, change the background color or put in the “fix”.  I do, however, plan to keep typing as long as I have something to say.  I hope that’s a good enough reason to check out Simple Justice from time to time.

Mom, Revisited

So it’s Mother’s Day.  I’m one of the lucky ones.  I still have a mother, alive and kicking.  Many of my contemporaries do not.  My mother has slowed down a bit, but is still in good health and with as many of her faculties intact as one could reasonably expect.  She’s no longer with me, having moved to God’s waiting room.  I speak to her once a week, which is more than I did growing up.

I call her Alta Caca.  She doesn’t find me amusing.  But then, it really isn’t a joke.  Other than complaining about things she can’t control, she’s relatively happy.  Even at her age, she’s trying to fight.  Other people are old.  Not her.  I get a kick out of it, though I tell her that it’s okay to enjoy herself at her age.  She doesn’t care. 

My children have a mother too.  She works very hard, far harder than I do.  I realize it.  Plus, she supervises me.  Everything I do requires her detailed supervision, or I would likely get it wrong.  This must take a lot out of her.  I’ve told her that she really doesn’t have to oversee everything I do, but she disagrees. 

Mother’s Day, like Father’s Day, like Arbor Day, doesn’t make a lot of sense to me.  We live our lives everyday.  If I don’t appreciate you on Tuesday, why should I give you a card and make you breakfast in bed on Sunday?  And if I do appreciate you the rest of the year, does this day change anything? 

But I’m an oddball on these things.  I’m told I lack sentimentality (amongst other things).  Most people must like Mother’s Day a lot, because I see in mentioned in advertisements everywhere.  Retailers wouldn’t mention it if it didn’t mean anything to people. 

I’m not one to give gifts on Mother’s Day.  Or Birthdays. Or a lot of other days either.  Whenever I see anything I think my wife would enjoy, I get it and give it to her right away.  I wasn’t reared with the idea that giving gifts for their own sake was a worthwhile.  Why give somebody something they neither want nor need because Hallmark makes you feel guilty?  And why withhold a gift just because the calendar doesn’t have a red number on the date? 

I was taught this by my Mother, the Alta Caca.  She told me not to bother getting chatchkes.  It was a waste of money, and she knew that I loved her anyway.  Mind you, nothing with the words “Louis Vuitton” on it qualified as a chatchke, but that was certainly way beyond my reach and grasp as a kid.

My wife was raised differently.  Special days always called for a special gift.  She knows now that the “special gifts” weren’t really special, or particularly desired for that matter, but the important thing was to have a gift.  Now she tells me that she needs nothing when I ask.  I know she’s lying to me.  She drops hints.  I never get them, so I have no clue what she wants.  She refuses to just tell me.  So I still don’t know. 

I’ve explained to her that I would be thrilled to get her anything her heart desires.  She doesn’t care.  What matters is that I figure out exactly what she truly wants on my own and get it for her.  If she has to tell me, then it doesn’t count.  It has to be a surprise.  It’s a test.  I’ve failed miserably, year after year.  I’ll fail again this year.

My mother, the Alta Caca, is no longer of the view that it’s silly to buy gifts for special days as a matter of sentimentality.  Now she wants them.  I’ve explained this to my father, who doesn’t seem terribly concerned.  He’s settled into old age more gracefully than my mother, and has learned to wield it like a club.  He conveniently forgets such things when necessary, and nobody doubts him.  He’s a funny guy.  I’ve learned much from him.

I wish all mothers Happy Mother’s Day.  I hope you have someone to show you their appreciation for all you do, and who is better at it than I am.  But even though I may not be good about showing it, I appreciate my mother and the mother of my children.  Especially the latter, without whom I could not survive.  I would buy her a really good gift, if only I could think of something.  I have to go now and make pancakes.

Challenging a Cop’s Simple Truth

The New York Times editorial, Racial Inequity and Drug Arrests, makes the point that blacks and Hispanics show overwhelming disparities in being arrested and convicted for drug offenses. 

Now, two new reports, by The Sentencing Project and Human Rights Watch, have turned a critical spotlight on law enforcement’s overwhelming focus on drug use in low-income urban areas. These reports show large disparities in the rate at which blacks and whites are arrested and imprisoned for drug offenses, despite roughly equal rates of illegal drug use.

The key part of the quote is that this happens “despite roughly equal rates of illegal drug use.”  If true, this shoots a huge hole in the theory that the reason there are disproportionate blacks and Hispanics in prison is because they commit more crimes (or are more inclined to commit crimes, as has been argued by Paul Cassell as well as certain commenters here).

While it’s unclear how these reports reach the conclusion that the rate of illegal drug use is about the same for people of all races and colors, the back end argument provides carries indisputable weight, that law enforcement attention is “overwhelmingly focus[ed] on drug use in low-income urban areas.”

The cop answer is the Willie Sutton answer: because that’s where the drugs are. 

While this is no doubt true (it’s hard to argue with 1000 dime bags of heroin), it misses the point.  Going after blacks and Hispanics in poor urban neighborhoods is like shooting fish in a barrel.  There is no one to complain about running roughshod over constitutional rights in the process, and even if someone was to complain, there’s no one who would care. 

Use of facile “exceptions” to reason and argument, seen in such phrases as “high crime area” and “for the officers’ safety” seem to trump all other points.  Then there’s always “furtive gestures,” which is the Mastercard to ignore the 4th Amendment.  It used to be the dropsy cases in New York that made all other search problems disappear, but it was so overplayed that even the courts caught on.

Put any community under a microscope and it looks ugly.  You will find that even upstanding people in neighborhoods with nice homes and expensive cars do things that they would really rather keep to themselves.  But it’s hard to peek inside the windows of these sprawling ranches and split levels without getting caught.  And the homeowners are more likely to know somebody in power, and to be given the benefit of the doubt.  They can do as they please in the privacy of their rumpus rooms, while poor people need to do it out on the street where they are easy targets.  They have no rumpus rooms.

For a while, New York City police would cordon off an entire city block in uptown Manhattan.  Anyone within the block, or trying to get in or out of the block, would be subject to search.  It was an outrageous strategy, lacking any particularity to deprive huge numbers of blacks and Hispanics their right to be left alone.  But there is no such right in poor neighborhoods.

I argued many of these cases.  The judges didn’t care.  They weren’t listening.  They knew, and they weren’t going to do anything about it.  I was unable to persuade them to be as outraged as I was.  But this never happened on Sutton Place.  No New York matron was ever stopped and frisked because she walked from the front door of her brownstone to the waiting limousine.

Then there are the “affidavit buildings.”  These are the Bronx tenements where the owner has signed an affidavit permitting the cops to question and search anyone entering their building.  Somebody enters to visit a tenant, and is accosted by police in the lobby, who ask them where they are going and, if they don’t answer fast enough or perhaps just for sport, toss them against the wall for a frisk. 

You may wonder how an owner’s affidavit terminates a visitor’s constitutional rights.  Initially, so did many judges, but after a while, the wonderment stopped and the practice became routinely accepted.  When entering a building on Park Avenue in the upper 50s, no one is ever tossed against a wall for a routine frisk. 

I don’t know whether people on Sutton Place or Park Avenue engage in illicit drug use at an equivalent pace as people on St. Nicholas Avenue.  I know some do, but I haven’t taken a valid survey.  Unlike others, I will not use my anecdotal knowledge as proof of the pervasiveness of the problem. 

But I will conclude that police treat people much nicer on certain streets in New York than on others.  Are some people more deserving of being treated pleasantly and respectfully than others?  Clearly so, and that’s the cop’s simple truth.