Author Archives: SHG

Brady Violations Come Home to Roost

It never ceases to amaze me how things, once on your radar, suddenly appear everywhere you look.  And so it is with prosecutors engaged in what Dallas DA Craig Watkins calls a crime.

First from Eugene Volokh,

Check out the Ninth Circuit’s decision in U.S. v. Chapman for a sharp rebuke of the government, including the affirmance of a district court’s dismissing an indictment with prejudice — thus barring retrial — because of government misconduct.

What misconduct?  Why, the dreaded Brady violation.  From Gideon :


The government egregiously failed to meet its constitutional obligations under Brady and Giglio. It failed to even make inquiry as to conviction records, plea bargains, and other discoverable materials concerning key witnesses until after trial began. It repeatedly misrepresented to the district court that all such documents had been disclosed prior to trial. The government did not admit to the court that it failed to disclose Brady/Giglio material until after many of the key witnesses had testified and been released. Even then, it failed to turn over some 650 documents until the day the district court declared a mistrial and submitted those documents to the court only after the indictment had been dismissed.

So who are these criminals who engaged in a deliberate violation of the Constitution?  Well, one would never know from reading the Chapman decision.  If anyone is listening who doesn’t already know this, this is how it works:  Court almost never name a prosecutor who “commits misconduct” in the decision.  They will excoriate this unnamed prosecutor, but they won’t name him or her.  That is how it works.  Defense lawyers, on the other hand, receive no such love.

Fortunately, we have Mike at Crime & Federalism, who will name names (and probably show naked pictures if he had them) of the criminals in our courts.


According to official court records (here and here), Greg Damm and Kimberly Frayn were the prosecutors who committed “prosecutorial misconduct in its highest form.”

So if you happen to know either Damm und Frayn, give them a little wink today.  They may not be prosecuted.  They may not be subject to discipline.  But at least let them know that you know who they are.  It’s the least we can do.

Detention or Lawsuit? The Angry Professor’s Choice

I would expect this from Yale, but Dartmouth?  Via  Randazza from the Wall Street Journal,


Priya Venkatesan taught English at Dartmouth College. She maintains that some of her students were so unreceptive of “French narrative theory” that it amounted to a hostile working environment. She is also readying lawsuits against her superiors, who she says papered over the harassment, as well as a confessional exposé, which she promises will “name names.”

I don’t have a clue what “French narrative theory” is.  If I had to guess, it’s a new psychosis that afflicts the terminally pretentious and causes them to lose touch with reality.  It seems to me that allowing someone suffering from this disease to be around students is imprudent.  It could be contagious.

So was it mere “unreceptiveness” that brought about this virulent attack?


Ms. Venkatesan lectured in freshman composition, intended to introduce undergraduates to the rigors of expository argument. “My students were very bully-ish, very aggressive, and very disrespectful,” she told Tyler Brace of the Dartmouth Review. “They’d argue with your ideas.” This caused “subversiveness,” a principle English professors usually favor.

If anyone wondered whether the rumors that Dartmouth had gone to the dogs were true, there you have it.  There is a zero tolerance policy firmly in place against arguing with ideas.  We can’t have that.  It’s “subversive”. 
Of course, I thought subversive was a major at Dartmouth.

Sensing that Prof. Venkatesan was deeply engaged in pedantic pedagogy in lieu of prozac, I continued to follow the drama:


After a winter of discontent, the snapping point came while Ms. Venkatesan was lecturing on “ecofeminism,” which holds, in part, that scientific advancements benefit the patriarchy but leave women out. One student took issue, and reasonably so – actually, empirically so. But “these weren’t thoughtful statements,” Ms. Venkatesan protests. “They were irrational.” The class thought otherwise. Following what she calls the student’s “diatribe,” several of his classmates applauded.

Ms. Venkatesan informed her pupils that their behavior was “fascist demagoguery.” Then, after consulting a physician about “intellectual distress,” she canceled classes for a week. Thus the pending litigation.

Now some might ponder the relationship between “ecofeminism” and Mother Nature, but you would only prove yourself to be ignorant.  The point was clear:  Add any prefix to feminism and you get a new field of scholarship, and anyone who disagrees is a misogynist and has no chance of getting a decent law school recommendation.

Alright.  Enough being facetious.  This is a real, honest-to-God Dartmouth professor.  She actually got herself a job teaching young people.  She actually presented sufficient scholarly interest to land a spot at an Ivy League college.  And she is clearly, utterly insane.  As is whoever hired her. 

Somebody needs to give all these profs, deans and other tenure-lovers a really good smack.  Our children’s future depends on it,

Would You Buy A Used Car From A Blogger?

Kevin O’Keefe at  Real Lawyers Have Blogs asks, Does the public trust bloggers?  The reason for the question was “a recent Forrester report posted by Jeremiah Owyang finding the public doesn’t trust bloggers as much as other sources when commenting on products or services.”  Why should they?

Kevin notes that the answer is the product of a poorly framed question, which assumes that all bloggers are the same.  As anyone who spends time in the blogosphere is aware, it’s the wild west in here.  There are blogs that are outright scams, the ones that use robots to steal posts from others without attribution, and there are blogs that appear to be written by 12 year olds with toilet obsessions.  It’s not like we have to pass a test to start a blog.

But when the question is changed to specific blogs or bloggers, the answer changes as well.  It’s all about credibility.  Who has it and why.  There are three primary types of credibility, attributed, ascribed and attained.  A snitch, for example, is endowed with attributed credibility, because a cop somewhere says that the snitch is trustworthy.  The credibility of the cop is attributed to the snitch, even though the judge doesn’t know the snitch from a hole in the wall.

Lawyers have ascribed credibility.  We are license professionals, having passed a bar exam and been given the imprimatur of the state to be competent to represent people.  Our legal opinions, therefore, are theoretically credible by virtue of our education, licensure and status. 

But the best credibility is attained.  It means we’ve earned it through our efforts to be credible, to be worthy of someone’s belief.  After scrutiny of our actions, comments, thoughts and analysis, readers have come to the conclusion that we can be trusted to be accurate and thoughtful.  To borrow from John Houseman, we obtained our credibility the old-fashioned way; We earned it.

I follow a few blogs.  More than a few, actually.  And feel relatively competent to assess their value and credibility.  Some are exceptionally good, both in terms of providing timely information as well as ideas that expand my understanding and appreciation of the world around me.  Since finding my way to the blawgosphere, I know a whole lot more about the law and the world than I did before.  It has been enlightening.

Some blawgs bring little to the table.  Some are written by people whose intellect is, shall we say, limited.  These are people I refer to as “thick”, as in “thick as brick.”  They don’t, in my opinion, have any depth of understanding, and frequently fail to appreciate the issues and considerations in the things they write about.  I tend not to read these blawgs frequently.  Still, they have their following, people who share a similar intellectual depth I assume.

Some blawgs are dangerous.  They may accurate report facts (often only the convenient facts) and then fundamentally misconstrue or manipulate them to serve an agenda.  These pander to the malcontents who look for others who share their angry views and where they can vent about the people they hate.  These blawgs scare me, feeding the insanity that used to hide in dark corners before the internet provided a blawg for every disreputable point of view.  One would never have known just how many crazies are out there until they have a place to congregate.

But what I can’t help but notice is that my description of the blawgosphere is likely the same as everyone else’s, except that we all place different blawgs in different categories.  What I think of as the crazy blawgs are someone else’s credible blawg.  My “thick” blawg is someone else’s thoughtful blawg. 

Simple Justice gets the occasional reader who happens here because of a google search, and finds some old post on a topic that interests him.  But the reader knows nothing about Simple Justice aside from that solitary post.  And the comment the reader leaves behind, often a nasty one that includes a string of unwarranted assumptions, reflects what comes of a lack of credibility.  To this “hit and run” reader, I have no credibility and am therefore a fair target for their vehemence.  People who agree with you have instant credibility.  People who don’t are short, fat and incredibly ugly.

Would I buy a used car from a blogger?  It depends on the car.  But I would, and do, trust plenty of blawgers and if they tell me that car runs like a top, I would believe them.

A Most Extraordinary Raid

The  Wall Street Journal reported last November that Scott Bloch, head of the Office of Special Counsel, was under investigation.  “The head of the federal agency investigating Karl Rove’s White House political operation is facing allegations that he improperly deleted computer files during another probe, using a private computer-help company, Geeks on Call.”  That was extraordinary, given the way this administration has handled itself.  Not surprising that the situation would arise at OSC, but extraordinary that it would come under scrutiny.

But it was nothing compared to what happened now.

The  New York Times reports:


WASHINGTON — F.B.I. agents on Tuesday raided and temporarily shut down the offices of a small federal watchdog agency that is charged with protecting the rights of government whistle-blowers but has been accused of retaliating against whistle-blowers in its own ranks.

With the memory of  Phillip Russell still fresh in his mind, Connecticut maven Norm Pattis takes some apparent glee in noting that yesterday was a bad day for Block.  Given that Bloch was supposed to be the protector of government whistleblowers, and the one to investigate misdeed by the administration, it was a bad day for all of us.  We not only find the head of a small watchdog agency in trouble, but we have been denied the function of that agency, had it not become a dirty little fiefdom.

The circularity of this situation, more filled with delicious irony than most, has already been well documented around the blawgosphere.  But one thing that struck me is that the FBI raided Bloch’s home and office. 

I am sometimes accused of being cynical.  It’s a lie, of course, by people who don’t understand me.  Skeptical?  Sure.  Cynical. Never.  Well, maybe sometimes.  But the FBI raided OSC to search and seize evidence!

Criminal defense lawyers don’t often say nice things about the FBI or DOJ.  But yesterday, their actions yesterday shook the very foundations of my skepticism.  It was bold.  It was shocking.  It was the right thing to do.

I applaud one arm of government for not flinching when its duty was to take action against another arm (maybe just a finger?) of government.  I applaud the FBI.  I applaud the Department of Justice. 

When political rot infects a department of government, most of us doubt there is anything to do other than wait for the next election cycle and hope the next one will appoint a someone better, maybe even a little more honest, or perhaps even someone who will actually do the job that is expected of him.  Scott Bloch is accused of being more of the problem than the solution as the guardian of integrity.  He disappointed the American people.  What’s new.

But there is hope for us, as demonstrated by the bold action taken yesterday.  Hope is what this raid was all about.  We can hope that there is someone in Washington, even at the FBI, who can rise above politics.  It brings a smile to this skeptical old face.

Now, what are the chances that the FBI will  raid the CIA and find out what happened to those destroyed torture videos?

If You Thought Judge Judy Was Bad…

No, not Starr Jones.  That would just be too much fun.  But none other than the inchoate defendant herself, former Westchester County District Attorney and perennial “subject of interest” to federal prosecutors, Jeanine Pirro.

According to the  Lower Hudson Valley Journal News (not a major competitor to the New York Times):

“Judge Jeanine Pirro” will premiere on weekday afternoons, beginning Sept. 22 on the CW network. The hourlong program, she said, will provide her a great platform to mete out justice with her own “go for the jugular” style.

And what does Jeanine have to say to those who would, er, doubt her qualifications to “mete out justice?”


“Rest assured, the audience will take something away from this, not just about the law but about real life,” she told The Journal News yesterday. “And my own experience, both professionally as a D.A. and a judge, as well as my personal life experience, are going to add to a very exciting and very real court show.”

Aw, shucks.  I can’t help myself from asking.  So what “personal life experience” are we talking about, Jeanine?”  Would that be when hubby Al copped the federal plea and went to the land of orange jumpsuits?  Would that be the derailment of your senatorial campaign when the feds starting looking up your dress after the Bernie Kerik eavesdropping issue?  Or perhaps the reversal for egregious prosecutorial misconduct in the Anthony DeSimone murder case?  Oops, that would fall under professional experience.  Me bad.

So perhaps I’m unimpressed with Ms. Pirro’s qualifications to be a TV judge.  What do I know?  Let’s turn to the experts, shall we?

Bennett Gershman, a Pace Law professor and one of her harshest critics, was less enthusiastic.  “I think it’s appropriate that she hears small claims cases on an up-and-coming channel,” Gershman said. “Of course, we’re all waiting breathlessly to see how she does in this new adventure of hers.”

Indeed we are.  But I do have one question.  What is the “CW network?”  Do complaining witnesses now have a channel of their very own?

Who Makes the Rules At The ABA?

Ken Lammers makes an important point at  CrimLaw about the “rules” for prosecutors that we invariably point to when we want to argue about whether they are doing the right or wrong thing.  Who is it that is coming up with these rules?



I’ve only glanced at these extra ABA “standards”, and do not believe they have been adopted in Virginia. I’m rather suspicious of the ABA’s claim that



“Many jurisdictions have adopted the ABA Standards of Criminal Justice Relating to the Prosecution Function, which in turn are the product of prolonged and careful deliberation by lawyers experienced in both criminal prosecution and defense.“


Really? Who? I’ve known a whole passel of actually practicing prosecutors and defense attorneys and, as best I remember, maybe two three were members of the ABA (generously, perhaps 1/2%). And when I say “member”, I mean someone who pays dues and gets the magazine, not someone who goes to national meetings and spends time composing tomes as to what lawyers should be doing. How could an actual, practicing, in-court prosecutor or defense attorney have time to partake in the production of something like that?


I’m not a member of the ABA.  I have nothing particularly against the ABA, but it just doesn’t have any relevance to my practice.  I’m sure there are plenty of big-time, important lawyers involved, but none that I hang out with.

Bar associations like the ABA and the New York State Bar Association don’t really have much to do with the practice of criminal law in the trenches.  New lawyers tend to join straight out of law school because a lot of these groups offer free membership for the first year, hoping to suck them in a lifers.  They get a certificate to hang on the wall, and potential clients love to see lots of certificates on the wall that attest to the greatness of the law.  I joined back then too.

But when the bill for membership came due, I asked myself what I got in exchange.  The answer was nothing.

As for the people who become active in these associations, I can’t think of anybody who matters in my line of work.  Some of the Biglaw guys, because being a muckety-muck in a bar association is the sort of thing that sells well in Biglaw, but does nothing for lawyers in the trenches. 

When you join these bar association committees, you get to go to a lot of meetings.  There are a lot of lawyers at these meetings.  Lawyers like to talk.  A lot.  And they’re all brilliant.  Ask them, they’ll tell you.  So they talk at each other, and then talk some more.  Pontificating about everything, then using 6 or 7 examples to explain even the most obvious point under the assumption that all the other lawyers in the room are too friggin stupid to understand.  And to hear their own voice and demonstrate their genius to the room.

So the ABA comes up with rules.  Rules for Ken.  Rules for me.  The rules don’t actually mean anything, unless adopted by some entity that matters, or used for their precatory force in an argument to show that there are rules and somebody broke them.  But as Ken rightfully asks, who comes up with these rules?  Beats me.  Obviously, people with a lot of time on their hands and an inclination to stick their nose into areas of practice foreign to their own experience.  Kinda like the ethics lawprofs who love to get quoted in the paper, though they never have to live with their own opinions.

I might consider calling for the ABA to put together a meeting of real criminal defense lawyers and real prosecutors, those of us who actually spend our days sitting on benches waiting for our cases to be called, to come up with a set of real rules for what we are expected to do every day.  Like “don’t withhold Brady,” for example.  Ken likes “do justice.”  Me too, though we might differ on what exactly that means.

But I won’t make that call.  Because if the ABA called such a meeting, no one would show up.  Because we’re busy in the trenches doing our job.  Leaving it to some elves in a back room somewhere to come up with a bunch of rules about what we’re supposed to do.

From Cablevision, With Love

Whenever I get a letter from a “service provider” that begins with the words, “in order to serve you better,” I shudder.  What will this one cost me?

For those of us who enjoy a relationship with the cash machine that Chuck Dolan gave his son James, letters like this come every couple of years.  They are never good.  The letter I received today was no exception.

A few years ago, Jim Dolan cut a deal for cable boxes, and next thing you know, channels that we had gotten for years without cable boxes were suddenly going to go black unless we ordered IO, interactive optimum as Cablevision has humbly named it. 

Now many people really don’t have a problem with a cable box, or an extra clicker or two.  Since we’re not one of those families whose lives revolve around the TV set, we really don’t care for another box or clicker.  Heck, I can’t figure out how to use the old clicker, and need my kid to turn the DVD on for me.  In any event, no more boxes or clickers are welcome at my house.  I downgraded my service and told them, “no thanks” to their one free year box offer.

So when today’s letter came, a chill swept through me.  The letter informed me that half the cable channels I now get will require a cable box if I ever want to see them alive again.  But the Big News! is that they were going to give me a cable box for free!* (*for one year).   Now I enjoy some of these cable channels.  TLC in particular.  TruTV is also doomed to be lost, but it’s not like they’ve had anything good there for years.

So I called the nice Cablevision people to ask about their letter.  A very personable young woman took my call, after the obligatory 15 minute cooling off period.  I asked her how much they would reduce my monthly cable bill if they were taking away all these channels.  Sheepishly, she explained that there would be no reduction.  But surely you aren’t planning on taking away half my channels and charging me the same thing, I asked? 

This nice person gave me the script, about how Cablevision would be giving me a cable box for free!* (*for one year).   I explained that as much as I appreciated Jim Dolan’s generosity, I did not want a cable box.  She seemed to understand, though I suspect she was just being kind as only old people and lunatics would refuse a cable box.  Regardless, there was no alternative.  Take the free box* (*for one year) or lose the channels and pay the same. 

Does Cablevision have the right to pull the plug on certain channels at will, resulting in a de facto rate increase?  I would hope that there is some regulator somewhere who oversees these things, given their monopolistic franchise.  If seems to me that it should require some sort of regulatory approval, and if so, I can’t help but wonder how and why such approval was received.  Are people not paying enough for cable in minds of regulators?  Is Cablevision’s cash machine not churning out enough greenbacks?

Granted, receiving cable TV doesn’t rise to the level of a right.  It’s a business, and businesses are allowed to make money, even if its by taking advantage of its customers by unilaterally changing the rules at will and leaving customers with the choice of pay or don’t play.  Hey, who needs TV anyway?

Since cable regulation isn’t my bailiwick, I have no idea whether anybody actually oversees this sort of thing, or whether they even know that Cablevision is pulling off this shrewd move.  I also don’t know whether it would even occur to anybody that there are people out here like me, who just don’t want more boxes or clickers shoved down their throat.  I think most people like more and more technology, and actually call up to say, “Yippee! Send me my box, baby!”

But I don’t want it and Cablevision, as is its way, is just being a pig again.  Maybe they can, and maybe I’ll have no option but to live without half the cable channels I received for the same monthly fee.  But I don’t like it.  And next time I see Jim Dolan at a party, I plan to give him a piece of my mind.

Starting a Movement

For anyone who still thinks of Arlo Guthrie’s classic  Alice’s Restaurant, aside from the annual Thanksgiving airing, the idea of a grassroots movement brings a smile to one’s face.  This morning, there’s an editorial in the  Dallas Morning News praising District Attorney Craig Watkins for his bold stand on criminalizing deliberate prosecutorial withholding of Brady material.

While the editorial is somewhat more circumspect than suits my taste, the fact that Watkins’ announcement is getting play (outside of those of us in the blawgosphere who care about such things) is heart-warming.  And so I went to the New York Times to see what they had to say about it.

Nothing.  No words of praise.  No words at all.

What about the Wall Street Journal law blog?  Silence.  The New York Post?  Forget it.  Newsday?  Never happened.  New York has a lot of dailies, which means they have a lot of space to fill.  Yet not a single newspaper in New York City thought this was worthy of notice.

When this story first broke, delusions of a groundswell of recognition swirled in my head.  Finally, I thought to myself, people will realize that this is not only happening, but that this is a severe problem with horrific consequences.  People will rise up in arms, demand that prosecutors fulfill their duty with honesty and integrity and push for serious consequences when the prosecutor becomes the criminal.  It was a heady experience.

I was wrong.  Not only did the citizenry not rise up, pitchforks in one hand and torches in the other.  The legitimate journalists of New York collectively yawned.  The editors swilled that last sip of cold coffee (mocha frappucino vente) and decided that another story about the Democratic primary was needed.  Who in New York cares what some District Attorney in Dallas has to see.  For crying out loud, it’s some foreign country.

So if they power of the media will not be brought to bare, then it is left to us.  This is big.  Huge.  And it is every bit as relevant in New York as in Dallas.  That the New York Times didn’t think it “fit to print” is shameful, but does not detract from the significance of the news, just the relevance of the Times.

So if the legitimate elite northeastern limousine liberal media wants nothing to do with this, then I will take it to the streets.  Are you with me?  Just keep pounding away across the blawgosphere.  And start singing, “you can get anything you want…”

New York’s Finest Back to its Old Tricks

According to Newsday, it didn’t take long for New York City cops to forget that they aren’t supposed to engage in racial profiling. 


The NYPD is on course to stop and frisk a record number of people this year — more than 580,000 — after a year in which the accusations of racial profiling led to a noticeable drop in the practice.

The City Council released the latest numbers yesterday for the first quarter of 2008. According to the statistics, 145,098 people were stopped in the first three months of this year, compared with 109,855 for the last quarter of 2007.

This is a 32% increase in stop and frisks.  In 2001, police were required to fill out “stop and frisk” reports so that the numbers could be tracked.  Whether or not most street cops actually do is another matter, since no one would have a clue whether they complied with the record-keeping requirements or not.  But at least some do, and the result is quite astounding.


The controversy hit a peak last February when the council revealed that NYPD officers in 2006 stopped more than 508,000 people on the street and questioned them.

Not just questioned.  Stopped people, questioned them and then placed their hands on people’s bodies and frisked them.  It’s bad enough that people walking along a street in Manhattan are subject to the order of a cop to stop, but to then that’s only where the indignity begins.  And who are the subject of this police attention?


In statistics released yesterday, blacks comprised 54 percent of those stopped in 2007 and 51 percent for the first quarter of this year. For Hispanics, the numbers were 31 percent last year and 32 percent so far this year.

I know, you’re shocked to learn that 84% of all people stopped and frisked are black or Hispanic.

Before the naive leap to defend the practice, there are a few things to know about it.  Of this huge number of people stopped, the vast majority have done absolutely nothing to warrant police attention, aside from wearing clothing that suggests to cops that they may be up to something, hanging out on the street with friends, and of course have skin of a different color.

This happens in “high crime areas,” but of course they happen to live in high crime areas, defined by the police as an area that is primarily inhabited by people of color.

They “mouth off” to police, meaning that when cops order them to “come here,” they have the audacity to ask “why?” 

According to the New York Times :


To police officials, the practice of stopping civilians on the streets, to question and search them — sometimes looking for illegal guns — is just one of many crime-suppression tactics. The increased number shows that the department is standing by its strategy as a worthy practice, people in and outside of city government said.

“Stop-and-questioning or stop-and-frisks of individuals in connection with suspected criminal activity is an essential law enforcement tool,” said Assistant Chief Michael Collins, a police spokesman. “The number of stops conducted by police officers is driven by the situations they encounter on patrol.”

The Times puts the number of arrests stemming from 145,098 stop and frisks at 8,711.That means that 137387 people, each of whom has a constitutional right to be left alone, were wrongly subjected to a stop and frisk.  This doesn’t strike me as a particularly effective tool, given that it nets such a small percentage of criminal defendants while interfering with rights of so many.

This is another example of “small damage,” for which our boys in blue suffer no consequences.  The 94% of people stopped who are not arrested have little recourse.  Should they sue the police?  For many, getting stopped and frisked is a daily occurrence.  They become so inured to being subject to police fiat that it’s almost a ritual.  It’s not supposed to be this way in America.  But that’s life in some neighborhoods.

People wrongfully stopped could complain to the Civilian Complaint Review Board, but everyone in New York knows that to be a waste of time.  It is perhaps the most worst waste of promise to ever come out of an effort for reform.  The likelihood of discipline is minute, because police need only articulate some palpable rationale for the stop to get away with it.  The old “furtive movement” or shifting wasteband excuses always win the day for cops.

Consider the impact of these numbers on yesterday’s post,  Paul Cassell: Blacks Deserve To Be In Prison.  Aside form the other reasons, obvious to anyone capable of thought, such as poverty, lack of educational opportunity, peer and cultural influence, historic and current racism, the fact that police give grossly disproportionate focus on black and Hispanics, and act upon it without fear that they will be accountable for baseless unconstitutional stops, has a huge impact on the disproportionate arrest and prosecution rates of minorities.

This report shows two things very clearly.  We still lack the ability to prevent NYC cops from stopping people at will and violating their right to be free from police interference.  And there are a lot of black and Hispanic New Yorkers who suffer because of it.  Not a good thing.

The Unexplained 9 Months

The Second Circuit decided a challenge to the “Justice for All Act” of 2004, 18 U.S.C. § 3771 (2004), in US v. Eberhard.  The defendant entered into a plea agreement that called him to be sentenced under level 30, criminal history I, at 97 to 121 months, with neither side to suggest otherwise. 

The PSR came back with a bit of a surprise, adding 4 points for supervisor, making the defendant a level 34, with guidelines of 151 to 188 months.  Somehow, the PSR then recommended a sentence of 96 months.  The defense apparently thought it best not to dispute the PSR, and the 4 point adjustment was left hanging.

The Judge, Robert Sweet. issued a written sentencing opinion in advance of sentencing, adopting the PSR and stating that, subject to modification at sentence, the sentence would be 151 months.

Then came the sentence.  Then came the victims.


At that sentencing hearing, Judge Sweet heard from several victims, who urged a draconian sentence.

After hearing from victims, the government, and Eberhard, Judge Sweet calculated a Guidelines range of 151 to 188 months, and expressed an inclination to sentence at the bottom of that range, in order to allow Eberhard an opportunity to make restitution once his prison term had ended. Judge Sweet then imposed a sentence of 160 months — nine months longer than foreshadowed in the written sentencing opinion.

The primary argument raised before the Circuit was that compliance with the Justice For All Act (don’t you just love the name!) violated the ex post facto clause.  The Circuit blew this argument away, holding that judges had the authority, if not the mandate, to allow victims to speak toward sentence since 1994.

The Court then goes on to state that regardless, this law wouldn’t implicate ex post facto in any event.


The Clause prohibits Congress from passing laws that (1) “make[] an action, done before the passing of the law, and which was innocent when done, criminal; and punish[] such action,” (2)  “aggravate[] a crime,” making it “greater” than when committed, (3) increase the punishment beyond that prescribed when the action was done, or (4) “alter[] the legal rules of evidence, [to] receive[] less, or different, testimony, than the law required at the time of the commission of the offense, in order to convict the offender.” Calder v. Bull, 3 U.S. (3 Dall.) 386, 390 (1798); see also Carmell v. Texas, 529 U.S. 513, 530 (2000).  A law requiring that  victims be reasonably heard (if they request) after the defendant has already been convicted does not implicate the Ex Post Facto clause.

I can’t help but feel that somebody’s law clerk dropped the ball and forgot to put in the bit of writing that is supposed to create a logical nexus between the last sentence and the stuff that precedes it.

Missing from the decision, however, is any explanation of how the defendant ended up, after a plea agreement, a PSR recommendation, a sentencing opinion and nothing else transpiring in the interim other than the “vindictive victim statements” getting the extra 9 months.  Indeed, Judge Sweet at the actual, physical, real life sentence, announces that he was giving the defendant the bottom of the 151 months.

So where did the extra 9 months come from?

The Circuit expressly refused to adopt the defense’s position that the 9 months was a result of the judge trying to appease the victims.  Let’s assume, for a moment, that the Circuit was just covering an upward sentence because it has an affinity for sentences higher than they could otherwise be.  Did the extra 9 months, tacked onto the guidelines sentence of 151, change anything for the victims?   Well, it does prolong the time before restitution by that period, which seems contrary to the victims’ interests, but not long enough to make it significant.

Then why?

This goes back to my argument that this newly created “right” for victims to have their say as to sentence, after a contract has been made between government and defendant, expectations and understandings firmed up, is fundamentally wrong in the criminal justice system.  Did Judge Sweet, after making it about as clear as humanly possible where he was coming out on Eberhard’s sentence, feel constrained to give the victims some bone, some recognition of their suffering, beyond what was already on the table?

The prosecutor should take the victims’ concerns into consideration in fashioning the plea offer, but once there is a deal on the table, a deal accepted, a deal to which the defendant is committed, it is no longer “fair” to give the victims a chance to use the negotiated deal as the baseline and then demand more. 

If there was no harm, no victim, no wrong, then it wouldn’t be a crime.  How many fingers get to poke the judge for another 9 months after the sentence has been all but uttered?

H/T Doug Berman