Author Archives: SHG

Paul Cassell: Blacks Deserve To Be In Prison

Former federal judge, now Utah lawprof and victims’ rights activist, Paul Cassell, never ceases to shock and amaze me.  But this time, it’s far more shock than amaze.

Posting at the Volokh Conspiracy, Judge Cassell states with approval . . . well, best to let him speak for himself this time:

Heather MacDonald has this great article in the City Journal, persuasively debunking the myth that high black incarceration rates result from racial discrimination. She reviews the available empirical evidence, which finds no evidence of systemic racism. Instead, the studies show that a disproportionate number of African-Americans are in prison because they have committed a disproportionate number of serious crimes.

As I read the article, I couldn’t help but think that it was actually written by Ann Coulter and Heather MacDonald just changed the name at the top.  It is an astounding piece of rhetoric, published in the City Journal, the mouthpiece of the Manhattan Institute, and one of Rudy Giuliani’s favs.

So just a little more from the article to whet your appetite:


This popular “social ecological” analysis of incarceration, as Fagan and other criminologists call it, treats prison like an outbreak of infectious disease that takes over certain communities, felling people on a seemingly random basis. “As the risks of going to jail or prison grow over time for persons living in those areas, their prospects for marriage or earning a living and family-sustaining wage diminish as the incarceration rates around them rise,” Fagan says. This analysis elides the role of individual will. Fagan and others assume that once one lives in a high-incarceration—that is, high-crime—area, one can do little to avoid prison. But even in the most frayed urban communities, plenty of people choose to avoid the “Life.” Far from facing diminished marriage prospects, an upstanding, reliable young man in the inner city would be regarded as a valuable catch.

If I understand this correctly, it not only argues that blacks are responsible for their incarceration rate, but the same argument would make them responsible for their lack of success in the workplace, lack of educational prospects and ultimately what us “apologists” view as the products of racial prejudice, both existing and historic.

It isn’t terribly surprising that people think this way.  Statistical analyses like these are often used in a vacuum, excluding a full view of the situation to focus on specifics that support one’s thesis.  But what makes this so shocking it that a former United States District Court Judge, a current professor at Utah Law School, has found this of such value, so persuasive and so close to his own views on the subject that he decided to promote and present this to the world as the position he supports.

Anybody want to pretend you’re on the Senate judiciary committee and ask Paul Cassell a question or two?

Real Harm That Happens in School

Not too long ago, I  posted about a Connecticut science geek kid who was expelled from school for bringing a disposable camera in and another kid getting shocked by the batter.  His lawyer, some guy named Norm, convinced District Court Judge Kravitz, who has  some history of blind deference to school officials, that this was a joke.  The judge mused whether the rubber band he held would be a weapon in the eyes of school officials, and tossed the case.

And yet, serious problems not only go under the radar of school officials, but generate a backlash that makes one wonder whether our children would be safer in school or in Oz.  The prison, not the munchkinland.

From the Buffalo News, via our hinterlands correspondent Kathleen, comes this story of “hazing”.  What exactly happened is unclear, as the story enjoys the vagaries of the phrase “sexually abused” when it speak of what three members of Wilson High School’s boys varsity baseball team did to at least two members of the junior varsity team. 

The police didn’t “haze” Abner Louima. 

So the school officials held a meeting, after the “incident” broke when police arrested the varsity ball players.  This is what happened :



They came to the public information session hosted by school and police officials about the April 17 incident on a bus, where three varsity boys baseball players allegedly sexually abused at least two junior varsity players. Armed with passion, many of the audience members took to the microphone and targeted television and print media for what they saw as turning their small town into a circus.


They also stepped up to the plate to defend varsity coach Thomas J. Baia and junior varsity coach William M. Atlas, who have been charged with endangering the welfare of a child and stand accused of turning a blind eye toward activity on the bus.  Some former players, fellow teachers and parents of former and current players spoke highly of their experiences playing for Baia and Atlas.


An expert on hazing, Susan Lipkin, a psychologist from Port Washington, LI, offered this advice:


“Parents should understand that stopping hazing now does two things: it protects all the children coming up from being … hazed in the future and prevents students from behaving that way when they go on to college, the military or the workplace,” Lipkin told The Buffalo News. “And kids need to know that you don’t have to be hazed to be part of a team. It does not build team spirit or bonding.”

* * *

“The common trend over the past five years or more has been basically to turn a boy into a girl by penetration,” Lipkin said of the worst situations. “In other words, they get engaged in homosexual play and then they call the victim gay because he’s been sodomized. Ironically, it’s the perpetrators that are committing the homosexual act.”

Well, that was useless.  Half of Port Washington are psychologists.  They all talk like this, which explains why Long Island is has its own problems:


And members of a Long Island high school football team sodomized three junior varsity players with a broomstick during a preseason training camp in Pennsylvania.

Here’s the deal.  When cops do it, it’s sick.  When little Johnny the football or baseball player does it, it’s still sick.  And when it happens under the auspices of school officials and parents, who are perpetually cautious of science geeks but seem to have a blind spot when it comes to their athletes, we seem to have a problem brewing.


“We’ve come a long ways from a wedgie,” said Wilson Village Trustee James O’Donnell III.

You think?  There are real threats to kids and there are nonsensical concerns that seem to envelope school officials.  Is it hard to appreciate why a child sodomized with a broomstick while teachers/coaches watch and do nothing is different than a disposable camera?  Do we need a psychologist to explain what happened, or tell us after the harm is done that little Johnny is acting out his repressed sexual confusion?

How about this idea for school officials:  Your star athletes don’t get to commit violence on younger children any more than anyone else.  Sodomizing kids with broom sticks is about as bad as it gets, and if it’s happening on your school bus, or at your school’s camp, under the watchful eyes of your teachers/coaches, you have an extremely serious crime on your hands.  Forget the disposable cameras and make sure that no child in your care is ever sodomized again.

Keeping Prosecutors Honest

Timing is everything.  The Supreme Court granted cert in Van de Kamp v. Goldstein, reviewing whether  prosecutors deserve absolute immunity for their administrative failure. I’ve done a  series of  posts about young prosecutors flexing their muscles when many are not yet ready to do so.

Then, everything turned on its side yesterday when Dallas DA Craig Watkins came out of the immunity closet.  Looking at the 45 wrongful convictions in Dallas, Watkins announced in the Dallas Morning News :



Something should be done,” said Craig Watkins, whose jurisdiction leads the nation in the number of DNA exonerations. “If the harm is a great harm, yes, it should be criminalized.”


Mr. Watkins said that he was still pondering what kind of punishment unethical prosecutors deserve but that the worst offenders might deserve prison time. He said he also was considering the launch of a campaign to mandate disbarment for any prosecutor found to have intentionally withheld evidence from the defense.


This is earth-shattering.  Posts about this already about in the blawgosphere.  See Grits, Gideon, Robert Guest and Shawn Matlock. 

Why has this created such a stir?  It does two things, both quite significant.  First, Watkins has broken the rule of silence, the rule that keeps everyone pretending that prosecutors don’t deliberately violate Brady and withhold exculpatory evidence.  Withholding Brady material is tantamount to deliberately convicting innocent people. 

It’s not that this is new to the criminal defense lawyer.  We’ve lived with  the Brady joke for years.  It’s that a big city District Attorney has finally stepped forward and admitted the truth.  Sure, the truth was apparent from the fact that all these people were subsequently exonerated, where there convictions were obtained in part because of the Brady game, but the courts still clung to the idea that the rights of defendants were secure in the hands of prosecutors.  Courts are good a maintaining legal fictions.

Watkins then takes the problem one step farther.  Not only does he let the cat out of the bag, but he publicly announces that prosecutors who violate Brady should be subject to criminal prosecution or lawyer discipline.  Wow!

Consider:  We were arguing a mere weeks ago whether prosecutors are worthy of total immunity, meaning that they could not be subject to civil liability for their failures, whether in the prosecutorial function or the ordinary administrative function.  This would be a radical departure from the historic grant of absolute immunity, the shield surrounding prosecutors that protects them from liability no matter how badly, or intentionally, they harm someone.  Today, we speak of criminal liability.

It would have been easy enough for Watkins to fall back on the “one bad apple” excuse, or the “need to train them better” solution.  These are usually enough to calm the nerves and leave the masses satisfied that their elected officials are fixing the problem.  But Watkins didn’t skirt the problem or the solution.  Clearly, he has no future as a presidential candidate.

Naturally, Watkins epiphany has not been greated warmly by all District Attorneys. 


John Bradley, the district attorney for Williamson County near Austin, said taking criminal steps against prosecutors, even when they intentionally withhold evidence, is a “ridiculous step” and an “overreaction.”

Was this what the public wants from their prosecutors?  Is this the way they are supposed to do their job?  And what would Bradley do to deal with the problem?


But he said he supports changing state bar rules to allow grievances to be filed when they are discovered rather than within four years of the alleged misconduct, as currently required. There is no recourse when Brady violations are discovered decades later.

It’s wonderful when District Attorney’s discover mercy and temper their righteous lust for convictions.  It’s unfortunate that it doesn’t apply to anyone other than their own.  This tepid and worthless “fix” shows why changes need to be made, radical changes, to hold prosecutors responsible for the very real harm they can do.  And it shows why it can’t be left to prosecutors to police prosecutors. 

This subject desperately need some sunshine, “the best disinfectant.”  It needed to be brought out publicly as a dirty little secret of the system that can do as much harm to an innocent victim as the slug from a Glock.  Convicting innocent people by withholding evidence is a criminal act, one that is worse than a great many of the crimes that have become the subject of the war du jour.  If we want to talk about conduct that diminishes faith in the system, this should go to the top of the list.

Now that Craig Watkins has opened the door, let’s deal with it.  The first step is for the Supreme to affirm Van de Kamp v. Goldstein.  After that, we can eliminate immunity for intentional violations of law.  Then we can debate whether criminal sanctions are needed, or disbarment is good enough.  We have a lot to talk about.

When Government Causes Small Damage

This post by  Radley Balko at Reason got me thinking.  The post is about another “isolated” incident of cops, acting on an anonymous tip, breaking into someone’s home to search for drugs, hydroponic marijuana in this instance.  My favorite line from the story is, “Then I asked them if a marijuana plant could grow inside my underwear drawer.”

The story itself isn’t a new one, where an ordinary family becomes the focus of a DEA raid.  Nothing is found.  They committed no crime.  The DEA wreaked havoc on their lives, and then it just left.


“What added salt to this injury was after the situation – house is searched, door is broken – they just walked away,” the Llorentes’ lawyer said. “Like, ‘We’re the government. We made a mistake.'”

What troubles me is that Llorentes’ had to get a lawyer and were left by our protectors, our government, with the disruption of their lives and a broken door.  Putting the impact on their personal security aside, what about the door?  Radley’s post already deals with the big picture of the raid, leaving me this tiny gap to talk about the little picture, the collateral damage.

I see government causing wrong, but relatively small, harm all the time.  Usually, the people who have suffered the harm are victims in the truest sense of the word.  They did absolutely nothing to cause or invite the problem.  Yet, in the wake of government’s actions, they are left with a problem.  Should the victim of the government be left holding the bag?

The problem is that the hard costs associated with the damage are frequently not sufficient to warrant a lawsuit against the government.  Indeed, it would cost more for the attorney than to just fix the door, making it a counterproductive option.  Sure, attorneys fees are recoverable, but that’s at the end of the case (meaning that somebody has to be in the interim) and there is still the burden of pursuing litigation, with its attendant time demands.  This is a significant burden.  Should the victim of the government be required to sue?

The answer, unfortunately, is that the victims of government arrogance, incompetence or just plain mistake often have no other choice.  There is a lot of government out there, ranging from the big bad federales to the little local municipalities, and they all seem to suffer the same ability to cause harm to those they exist to protect.  It would be nice to think that they should just do the right thing, but there is some bone in the heads of government officials that seems to make it way too difficult to admit error, no less gross incompetence, that presents them from correcting their mistakes.

So the Llorentes are left to either eat the cost or litigate.  Neither choice is acceptable.  Neither choice reflects how government should be allowed to treat its citizens.. 

What is needed is an alternative mechanism for people to obtain redress against the government for damage caused by clear and indisputable governmental error.  This would be a means for people to pay the cost of repair, restoration and correction of government mis- and malfeasance promptly and without need for an attorney.  It’s bad enough that the courts have viewed government “accidents” such as the one perpetrated on the Llorentes as being inevitable and an unfortunate collateral consequences of our war on (insert whatever war we are fighting today). 

When the DEA, or the cops, break down your door by mistake, and leave without so much as an apology (not that an apology is the answer), and your left standing there wondering how your life just went from quiet and normal to a nightmare at the hands of governmental stupidity, there must be a way to stop our beloved government from adding insult to injury. 

And if the cost of repair came out of the paycheck of the genius responsible for the screw-up in the first place, perhaps our law enforcement officers would be a bit more cautious before breaking down doors.  But then, that might inhibit them from doing their job, and we would certainly never want that to happen.  Would we?

Confronting the Dead Witness

A very touchy issue was the subject of this Los Angeles Times editorial, supporting the California Supreme Court’s affirmance of a murder conviction in People v. Giles and looks for affirmance from SCOTUS.  In this case, Dwayne Giles was convicted of murdering Brenda Avie based upon statements she made to police a few weeks in advance of her death, that Giles had assaulted her and threatened her with a knife.  Oral argument is now over and we await decision.

The statement by Brenda Avie was introduced at Giles’ trial.  The Supreme Court upheld the admission of that testimony, over challenges that it was hearsay and that it denied the defendant the right to confront witnesses.

The editorial begins with the ignominious comparison to the child who killed his parents and begs for the mercy o the court because he’s an orphan.  It’s a poor analogy.


In a case reminiscent of the story of the boy who killed his parents and then asked for mercy because he was an orphan, the U.S. Supreme Court has been asked to overturn a California man’s murder conviction because the victim’s statements about his violent nature were read in court. The case is legally more complex than the apocryphal story about the orphan, but the principle is the same: A defendant shouldn’t benefit from silencing his accuser.

The Giles case raises some very real issues that not so easily ignored, but can easily result in the conviction of an innocent person.  In Giles, the defendant claimed that Avie was the aggressor and that he acted in self-defense.  This adds an additional problem, since we are naturally biased against the notion that women would be violent aggressors against men, even though it is a remarkably common occurrence that flies in the face of “common wisdom.”

Testimony from the grave is some of the most persuasive evidence around.  Our natural tendency to feel sympathy for the dead lends a level of credence that is hard to challenge.  It is wrong to think ill of the dead.  Jurors don’t want to do so.  The evidence, therefore, takes on a degree of credibility far beyond that of almost any other type of testimony.

The problem with this is multifold.  At its lowest level, there is no assurance that the testimony of a police officer as to the statement of deceased is accurate, complete or clear.  Even if we assume that the officer has not embellished the statement for purpose of using it effectively at trial, whatever he says it is cannot be questioned.  There is just no way to effectively challenge the content of the statement, even though it is necessarily filtered through the officer. 

Did the officer understand what he was being told, or did he “translate” the statement of the deceased into his own vision of what she was trying to say?  Did he get all the salient information, or did he fail to ask questions that might change the significance of her complaint?  Did he transcribe it correctly?  Did she write out the statement accurately? 

Often, when complainants are asked to write out statements, their own lack of education or writing skills results in a markedly inaccurate statement of fact.  Word-smithing is a difficult job, and most people aren’t very good at it.  Yet the specific words later become critical, particularly when there is no one to ask, “What did you mean by this?”

Then comes the problem of whether the underlying allegations are truthful, or completely truthful.   Austin criminal defense lawyer Jamie Spencer (he makes me write this) recently posted about a comment left at his blawg:



I called the police on my boyfriend and said he hit me with a gun which never happened. I was mad and I wanted him to go to jail that day.


But now I feel bad for lying and I want to tell the truth but I don’t know what will happen since I lied to the police.


Please help me and tell me what I should do.


It happens.  And it happens with greater frequency in emotionally charged relationships.  How does one distinguish between the angry liar and victim?  There’s no answer to this question when there’s no witness to cross-examine.

It is initially up to the judge to serve as gate-keeper to evidence such as this to determine whether there is sufficient indicia of the truthfulness of the underlying statement.  But there’s no secret method that judges possess to tell which is true and which is false.  They play the same guessing game as anyone else.  This is a huge weak link in the chain of evidence control, and contrary to popular assumptions, judges have no better way to “know” the truth than anyone else.  It’s sheer speculation, with the defendant’s life hinging on the outcome.

The flip side of the problem, as the LA Times editorial argues, is that a defendant should not be allowed to gain an advantage by having murdered the witness against him and thus left no witness to testify against him.  The merit of this position is clear.  To allow the defendant to prevail by an act of murder is to encourage murder and to defeat justice.

But there is sound reasoning on both sides of this equation, and little to distinguish which direction is better or worse as a general rule.  The issue is sometimes resolved in favor of the side that does the most complaining, as in the deceased having told 20 friends what a bad and violent man her boyfriend/spouse/partner was.  This “strength in numbers” approach shifts the weight of evidence in favor of admitting the statement of the deceased into evidence.

This too presents problems, often worse than a mere single statement.  If a person is inclined to verbalize anger toward another, that person may be very likely inclined to do it with frequency or regularity, telling the same story to many people.  But does a lie told often enough become truth?  Clearly not, but it becomes a very convincing lie.

Ultimately, it seem that the admissibility of the statement used to convict Dwayne Giles should turn on a more reasoned approach to evidence and the criminal justice system in general.  Since a defendant is presumed innocent, then it cannot be presumed that the defendant committed murder that prevented a witness from being available to testify against the defendant so that the statement can be used to convict the defendant of murder. 

Similarly, the judge as gatekeeper must require more than bias, speculation or repetition as indicia of truthfulness before allowing a statement to be used when the defendant will be denied the right to confrontation.  There is a cottage industry in the “spousal abuse” field that provides prosecutors with tools to circumvent rules that apply to all other crimes in order to obtain convictions based on bad and unreliable evidence.  This has been extremely dangerous, and yet has been accepted regularly by judges inclined to be adopt the notion that abuse of women is so different, so special, that convicting innocent people is worth the price.  The proponents of this evidentiary abuse take the position that the men are invariably abusers and criminals and the women always victims.  It’s hard to argue when someone holds that mindset, since it falls under “no harm, no foul.”

While it is understandable that the LA Times doesn’t want a murderer to walk, its editorial position was decidedly myopic and failed to account for the significant problems raised by using statements from the grave to convict people.  Perhaps the position was guided by a belief that Giles is guilty, so who cares about the other side.  But will it feel the same when the editorial board believes the defendant was innocent, but convicted on bad evidence?  They need to consider that as well.

Also, take a look at  Niki Black’s disussion of People v. Nieves-Andino, similar to Giles though the New York Court of Appeals punted rather than address the constitutional aspects of the case.

If We Did What Mastercard Does

As the  New York Times editorial notes, the modest changes urged by the Fed will be fought by the Big Banks tooth and nail, and may well never actually see the light of day no matter how tepid they are in addressing abuse of consumers.  It’s good to be a bank.

If anyone else played the bait and switch game like credit card issuers, they would be wearing an orange jumpsuit.  But banks not only get away with it, but they have the juice to put enough fear into the heart of Congress to potentially kill any hope of reform.

Representative Carolyn Maloney, the New York Democrat who has been pushing the important Credit Cardholders’ Bill of Rights in Congress, raised the right fears as the Fed proposal was announced. “These rules may be watered down. They might not be put into effect at all,” she scoffed. “The Federal Reserve is not in the Constitution to correct abuses. We are, and there are abusive, abusive, abusive practices going on now.”

The powerful American Banking Association has already signaled its plans to fight the Fed’s rules as a “regulatory intrusion” into the market and warned that eventually it could be the consumers who lose because of changes. But consumers are already losing as their interest rates on the cards suddenly skyrocket, fees appear mysteriously on their bills and even the billing cycles get shortened to make it harder to pay on time.

What’s most striking about the problem is that it’s purely cash and carry.  Banks have the cash, and that’s how they carry Congress.  There’s no question that this is a shocking abuse.  Forget the villainous subprime mortgage brokers, they are pikers compared to what the credit card banks have done to the American public.  And the banks are untouchable.

My fellow citizens, this is the price of democracy today.  And the banks are paying for it.  Remember Senator Sessions and the DataTreasury amendment?  That was pennies compared to this.  Expect the banks to pull out all the stops to make sure that the American consumer never gets an even break.  Even though these changes are relatively trivial, the banks won’t let a camel’s nosehair under the tent.

The price of democracy?  It’s paid for by the banks.

Kaye to Judges: Don’t Rock The Boat!

While Chief Judge Judy Kaye  cajoles the judges she thinks are under her care and feeding to maintain the dignity of their office, who are busily  eating spam during the luncheon recess, the rank and file judges are quietly beginning to realize that if they don’t stand up for themselves, and perhaps take a hit, the best they can hope for is “pie in the sky when they die.”  Some have no plans on dying anytime soon.

Judge Kaye likes to send memos to the troops.  It helps to keep their morale up, or so she’s been told.  Somebody has been whispering in her ear that any proactive measures taken by judges to payback the legislators will not be taken kindly.  Judge Kaye wants to be kind to legislators.  She’s a kind person.  Legislators, however, are not always kind.  But they do know how to push Judy Kaye’s buttons, apparently.  According to the New York Lawyer, this is an email directed to the wayward judges:


“Our many friends and supporters tell us quite frankly,” Chief Judge Kaye advised in an e-mail, “that we reduce our effectiveness and weaken our cause when we publicly engage in conduct that is perceived as retaliatory, such as denigrating public officials and using recusal as a strategy rather than as a matter of individual conscience.”

Unfortunately for Judge Kaye, and her legislative “judge whisperer,” the troops are not terribly kind either.  When given the “spam option,” their path seem clear.  Quietly, little by little, the judges of the State of New York are coming to recognize that they didn’t create this problem, and that their dear friends in the legislature aren’t going to show them the requisite love. 

While it’s painful to watch the last bastion of the legal profession slide down the slippery slope of maintaining “dignity”, there’s nothing dignified about poverty.  Rather than deal with the problem, the big boys in Albany are using playing their stomachs.


“You just have to be careful that if you protest in ways that diminish the capacity of your neighbors to access the courts, you are contributing to the diminished confidence that exists with the government and the judiciary,” Mr. Paterson said Wednesday at a news conference.

One can’t help but love the high-minded arguments to keep the judicial inmates happily locked within the asylum.  But what has occurred to some of our judges is that platitudes don’t fill empty stomachs.  The judges didn’t create this problem, and 9 years without so much as a nickel raise due to New York politics is long enough to let dignity alone direct their actions.

If the Albany gang wants to maintain confidence in the New York bench, then just give them the raise that is long past due.  They could pay for it out of Bruno and Silver’s member money alone.  Bing, problem solved.  But how much more disingenuous can the politicians be then to blame the judges for doing something about their being the lunchmeat in the Albany political sandwich? 

This aura of dignity argument is a play on the fragile psyche of the judiciary, an appeal to judges to “stay the course” and rise above the fray while they are being treated as a joke by the other branches of government.  I have no doubt that the judiciary wants to do exactly what Judge Kaye says.  They don’t want to screw with the mechanics of the courthouse.  It brings no joy to their heart to be forced to get down off the bench and fight.

Does it “diminish confidence in the judiciary” for judges to start doing something to level the playing field?  I don’t think so.  Not at all.  And while I can understand why Judge Kaye feels compelled to appease the powerful in Albany, it’s time for her to take a stand as well.  Maybe I still remember the old activist years of the 60s too well, but the judges didn’t ask to be treated like dirt by the legislative and executive branches, and they are not to blame for it.  If they don’t stand up for themselves, who will?

Yes, it would make Judge Kaye and the rank and file feel much better about themselves if all the lawyers in the trenches marched on the picket line on their behalf, thus allowing them to preserve their dignity while we did their dirty work.  But this isn’t going to happen.  If the judges won’t stand up for themselves, lawyers won’t sacrifice for them.  If Judge Kaye wants to truly be the leader of the New York State judiciary, then it’s time to take a firm, clear and proactive stance.

The judiciary is a co-equal branch of government, not the slaves of the system.  The legislature takes off half the year.  The executive goes on vacation.  It’s time for the judiciary to establish its rightful place in the Albany hierarchy and stop being the pushy-bottom of government whenever somebody screams “dignity”.  Go get ’em, and let’s hope that their leader understands why.

Geeklawyer, Available For Trials and Birthday Parties

Dan Hull at  What About Clients? scours the world for critical news, even when it involves the lowly criminal trial.  And thank goodness he does, or I might never have seen this post by Geeklawyer, perhaps the funniest ever.  Now I really want to meet  Ruthie too.

Just a tidbit, as it would be wrong to steal the thunder of such a brilliant barrister.

Disappointingly Geeklawyer did not get to hear the sluttily voiced Ruthie provide each and every member of the jury with remote oral sex from across the courtroom. Her leader was at fault: a thoroughly charming old school barrister, he insisted on using her for the jobs for which junior female counsel are conditioned by nature; fetching coffee cooking and ironing shirts. That is to say, a wife: but one to whom one need not give over 50% of one’s assets at the end of the trial/marriage.

It transpired however that the graceful and supple Geeklawyer’s dark presence caused pandemonium to Ruthie’s client. Not pandemonium of the usual heart, pitter patter, variety. No. Apparently Geeklawyer bore an uncanny resemblance to one of the defendants. When Geeklawyer turned up at court and sat at the back of the public area he was unaware of the turbulence he caused.

WAC once paid Simple Justice a huge compliment by saying, “Yeah, Simple Justice–they be bad….”   But I bow to the master, Geeklawyer.  He be baaaaaad.

Stealing Sex, the New Frontier?

As if there aren’t enough problems with sex offender laws, a post over at Feminist Law Professors argues that we need an entirely new avenue of attack, intentional sex torts.  Apparently, women cannot be trusted to engage in the normal tete-a-tete that characterizes the interplay between men and women, and thus need to be shielded from the shifty and deceitful man who might lie to a woman in order to steal “a woman’s personal right to choose who invades her body.” Invades?  Yikes.  According to lawprof Deana Pollard Sacks:

For decades, feminists such as Susan Estrich have argued that rape has many forms, and often occurs in contexts not involving physical force or violence. While women have always known this, most (male) judges in the U.S. publish sentiment in criminal and tort cases reflective of an inappropriate “boys will be boys” mentality.

What does she propose the law protect helpless women against?

In a world filled with dangerous sexual diseases, it is particularly important to protect women’s rights to protect their own bodies, not just against physical violence, but against fraudulent inducement of sexual decisions and all of the dangerous consequences that can result from a lack of truly informed consent to sexual relations.

Fraudulent inducement of sexual decisions?  Well, that cuts both ways, doesn’t it?  What about the woman who’s had a little surgical improvement?  Don’t men deserve a heads-up?  Tossing the “dangerous sexual diseases” phrase at the front is disingenuous, since this isn’t limited to concealment or denial of STDs, another matter entirely.  This is about “twinkle in the eye” type stuff, the sort that follows the all-time lamest pick-up line, “What’s your sign?”

Before someone bites my head off for that crack, let’s cut to the arbiter of all things sexual, Marc Randazza at The Legal Satyricon.

Expanding tort law to cover dishonest sexual encounters is a horrifying proposition. We have to be left to be human — even if that means that some immoral, abhorrent, and even disgusting behavior will leak through the sieve of our legal system. There simply does not need to be a law to cover every bit of sketchy behavior. For as long as we live and love, someone will lie about their feelings to someone else. Hearts will break. Men and women will lie to each other. Men and women will sleep with each other for the wrong reasons. I’m not simply arguing that “boys will be boys.” I am arguing that this is the yin to the yang of love, passion, and ecstasy.

In other words, people will be people, and this call for a new tort cause of action by women against men for fraudulent inducement is a way to interject the law, from the feminist frontier, to save women from the evil, deceitful male who would say anything to fool the helpless female and undermine her rights to choose.  Even the way Sacks presents the problem, “invade her body,” smacks of assault.  She doesn’t make the ritual sound very inviting.

I recently discussed the  Maryland Supreme Court decision allowing a woman to withdraw consent from sex in mid-act, and the potential mischief that can cause.  But this obviously isn’t enough to sate the feminist vision of women’s hegemony, or their ability to attack men should they feel maligned.

The goal used to be about empowering women to take charge of their own lives and bodies.  This included the power to play the sex-game with men on equal footing,  It’s unclear whether there is a feeling that they’ve accomplished this goal and need new dragons to slay, or have given up and decided to move in a different direction.  My sense is the latter, since they have overlaid a maternalistic approach that tells women that they will protect them from their own ignorance and gullibility, apparently because they feel that women are incapable of protecting themselves from lying men by making their own choices.

This goes beyond the silly into the nutsy.  Remember the “wild and crazy guys” from Saturday Night Live?  Are they criminals?  Are they tortfeasors?  Or are they a parody of how hormones affect idiots.  And this isn’t a phenomenon that afflicts only the males of the species.  It is important to note that this is not about a man lying to a woman about his HIV status; that’s a matter of concealing a deadly disease, not about sexual inducement.  And that cuts both ways.  This is about the purported need to save women from facile-tongued men who would undermine their right to exercise their sexual options based on legally-compelled factually-accurate representations. It brings new meaning to Meatloaf’s “Paradise.”

To prove its need, Sacks quotes from the 1975 New York decision in the trial of Marty Evans by Justice Edward Greenfield:

“So bachelors, and other men on the make, fear not. It is still not illegal to feed a girl a line, to continue the attempt [to obtain sex], not to take no for a final answer, at least not the first time. . . . [A] male [will] make promises that will not be kept, . . . indulge in exaggeration and hyperbole, or to assure any trusting female that, as in the ancient fairy tale, the ugly frog is really the handsome prince.Every man is free under the law, to be a gentleman or a cad.” (People v. Evans).

As it happened, my former partner was Marty’s lawyer.  Marty was called “The Snowman” in the newspaper, because he gave women one heck of a “snowjob” to get them in bed, way beyond anything ordinary men would even consider.  This was about as extreme as “fraudulent inducement” was ever going to get, and Justice Greenfield was castigated for his decision in this case (it was a judge trial).

Justice Greenfield decided that there were places where the courts didn’t belong, and this was one of them.  Whether the verdict would have been the same today is doubtful.

To wreak havoc with the natural give and take between men and women by sticking the law into the middle of every conversation, pick-up line, and contact goes beyond the pale.  Being an old married man, none of this effects my life, but I have hope that young people will be able to enjoy the mating game that led to maturity and marriage without being required to have a lawyer oversee and parse each whisper for tortious accuracy.  And I bet most women won’t want Deanna Sacks listening in either.  It just seems so . . . kinky.

Court of Appeals Bucks The Trend

For quite some time, the trend has been to find a crime when someone dies.  It’s quite a compelling argument, and the one invariably used by the “victims” rights advocates when they speak to the loss of a loved one.  But the harsh truth is that sometimes people are killed and it isn’t a crime.  Of course, speaking truth can land a judge on the front page of the New York Post, a place where only Britney Spears feels happy.

Judge Susan Read, writing for a 4-3 majority of the New York Court of Appeals, bucks the trend in People v. Cabrera.  The facts of the case are quite sad, where 17 year old Brett Cabrera, driving his folks’ SUV with some friends, on their way to a lake in Sullivan County, hit a curve too fast and went off the road.  He had four teenage passengers in his car, even though he only had a junior license.  Three of his passengers, not wearing their seatbelts, died.

Brett Cabrera was convicted of 3 counts of criminally negligent homicide.  He spent almost two years in prison and was out on parole when the Court of Appeals issued its decision. According to Newsday :


The Court of Appeals, divided 4-3, dismissed the assault and homicide convictions against Cabrera in Sullivan County Court.

The court majority said there needed to be another “morally blameworthy component” besides speeding to sustain criminal negligence. They said Cabrera, as an inexperienced driver, simply misjudged the risk and his skill on the curve where the SUV went off the road.

The gut reaction to situations such as this is often that if someone is killed, especially a child, then it must be a crime.  Indeed, some of newest laws, the ones usually named after dead children, come into being for this very reason.  There is a certain swell of public outrage when a child dies and there is no one imprison, and this void gets filled by a new law or novel application of an old one, such as the  Heidgen murder conviction for drunk driving.

The outcome, no matter how tragic, does not dictate the occurrence of a crime.  Sometimes people die as a result of simple negligence.  Sometimes, they die and there’s no one to blame, as much as that doesn’t seem possible.

The Court of Appeals decision in Cabrera was clearly a painful one, as demonstrated by the severe split, but an important one.

Even so, the “rule” announced by the Court, that an affirmative act of the defendant was needed to increase the risk into unreasonably dangerous risk presented the test for criminal culpability. 

In short, it takes some additional affirmative act by the defendant to transform “speeding” into “dangerous speeding”; conduct by which the defendant exhibits the kind of “serious[ly] blameworth[y]” carelessness whose “seriousness would be apparent to anyone who shares the community’s general sense of right and wrong.” Thus, in the cases where we have considered the evidence sufficient to establish criminally negligent homicide, the defendant has engaged in some other “risk-creating” behavior in addition to driving faster than the posted speed limit. (citations omitted).

Unfortunately, we are left with an incomprehensible rule, bogged down with wholly subjective characterizations like “seriously blameworthy carelessness.”  Not even the “risk-creating” language helps, as any half-decent prosecutor ought to be able to frame a death into an issue of some rhetorical “risk-creating” conduct.

But the fact that a majority of the court chose to reverse this conviction, albeit after the sentence was completely served, says something.  The Court’s focus on culpability, rather than ultimate harm, is critical to the integrity of criminal law, where punishment is imposed, as opposed to civil law where damages are ascertained.   Culpability should never be determined by the outcome, no matter how painful that may be to understand.

It’s not that the deaths of these 3 teenagers was not a terrible thing.  It just wasn’t criminal.