Author Archives: SHG

NY Courts: Nobody Does Too Well

After all the talk about judicial pay raises, Court-o-Rama brings us a post about the bottom of the court system food chain, the court employees.  Before anyone complains about this characterization, the system functions because court officers and clerks exist to do the work that allows judges and lawyers to stroll in and do their job.  Rarely do they receive the appreciation and respect they deserve, and are too often treated like the servants of the system rather than equal cogs in the wheels of justice.  Piss off a court clerk and you will learn how important their role is, as you sit and wait for your case to be called for the next 7 hours.

But if respect is shown in a “material” way, New York court staff just got dissed big time.

Their union just negotiated a 4-year agreement, retroactive to April 2007. The deal increases salaries, improves pay in some areas, enhances longevity bonuses (we don’t quite know what these are, but it sounds like a euphemism for gray hairs — “this light really brings out my longevity bonuses!”), improves payments to the Employee Benefit Fund and Labor-Management programs (?), and increases funding for body armor.

So, they may not be able to afford college for their kids, but at least they’ll be bullet-proof!

The raise amounts to 3% per year (starting in 2007), with 4% in 2010. Basically, this equals a cost of living allowance (or COLA).

If my calculations are right, this means four years will pass during which the staff will essentially tread water.  At least the cost of gasoline isn’t going up, right?

One might wonder what the union has to say about this?  Hard bargaining year in light of the pressures on the system for judicial pay?  Bad economy?  Lousy timing?  Do they apologize to their 6000 union member for having let them down?


“CSEA and the Unified Court System have reached a fair and responsible agreement that recognizes the value and importance of the court employees who make the system work every day,” said CSEA President Danny Donohue. “These were challenging negotiations and I am extremely proud of the focus and commitment of the CSEA bargaining team.”

Extremely proud of what, not having given back salary increases since 1967 or cut staffing by 32%?  With a union negotiation like this, the court staff are lucky they aren’t required to carry the judge into the courtroom on a gilded divan. 

And what is it about bullet-proof vests that cause negotiators to seek constant upgrades?  They’re hot, bulky and uncomfortable, and they cost a lot of money.  Sure, they tend to be an easy “get” since the other side would hate to argue against them and then have someone killed for lack of a vest.  But do the officers really want to latest fashion in vests as opposed to a salary increase?  Maybe they do, but I somehow suspect that last year’s vest would have been just fine in exchange for a little more cash.

While some might be inclined to say that if judges get no raise, and indigent counsel get no increase, and legal fees for criminal defense lawyers remain flat, why should court employees do better.  I don’t.  Each of these things are entirely independent, and I take no pleasure in seeing the staff barely keep apace of the cost of living.

In other words, what a lousy deal.  You guys need a better union.

Laywer Fashionista: Décolletage or Disaster?

Once again, I’m forced to don my chapeau of appropriate attire for the consummate professional in order Ad-dress the horrible advice extended by the Wall Street Journal.  Clearly, they should leave such matters to people like me, on the cutting edge of professional fashion, before they do harm.  I mean, seriously, have you ever seen the way Rupert Murdoch dresses? 

The WSJ has decided to wage war on cleavage.  Not only is this clearly unAmerican, but its blatant sexism belies the Journal’s intention of keeping women in their place,  I prefer to watch their back.  It’s just the kind of guy I am.  No need to thank me.

“There’s no greater crime” for a businesswoman, Ms. Graham adds, with just a smidgen of hyperbole, “than to show cleavage.”

Oh really?  Like it hasn’t done well for Fergie, right? 


Women face mixed messages about what they should wear to evening events. Ubiquitous photos of décolletage-revealing celebrities and models photographed on red carpets and runways do their part to encourage faux pas. The super-short skirt lengths, low necklines and body-hugging silhouettes marketed in stores these days often conjure up the image of a trophy wife rather than an executive. Eveningwear is practically synonymous with sexy.

Perhaps the Journal would prefer that women bind themselves in fine Victorian splendor?

The fact that some men, pigs all, may take the “wrong message” from evening attire of the professional woman is a comment on the nature of boorish men, not the women.  Certainly there are limits, as good taste would dictate to any person dressing for an evening affair, but to put women in a straight jacket simply because some men can’t get their mind out of the gutter is counterproductive. 


Gail Graham, executive vice president of marketing for Fidelity Investments, watched a respected co-worker alter her colleagues’ impressions of her at a recent business dinner. She “showed up in a dress that was practically backless and showed cleavage,” says Ms. Graham, who later heard male colleagues talking about the woman — days after the event. “It became the story about her. You want the story to be about you and your accomplishments.”

If ever a comment had a catty odor, this is it.  Perhaps Ms. Graham was left to feel a bit dowdy that evening, and the lack of water-cooler discussion of her attire left her feeling more than a bit left out?  So now, the “respected colleague” was considered both highly competent and attractive?  Oh my, who would ever want that to happen?


“If my attorney bills out at $1,000 an hour, I want them to look like a lawyer, not a celebrity,” says Jonathan Fitzgarrald, director of marketing for Greenberg Glusker, a Los Angeles law firm.

Fortunately for Mr. Fitzgarrald, no one at his firm can command that rate, male or female.  But details aside, does he not distinguish between office attire and evening wear?  Would he expect them to wear sensible shoes with that evening gown too?  This is why men lacking the fine fashion sense with which I’ve bee endowed should keep their mouths shut and just stand back and admire.

What strikes me most about this décolletage disaster is how men are excused for their neanderthal impulse while women are castigated for being, well, endowed.


Our brains are hard-wired. The cortex in the back of our brains, Dr. Brizendine says, scans the environment looking for fertile mates. Complicating relations between the sexes, the part of the brain known as the “area for sexual pursuit” is two times larger in men than in women.

Doctor?  I find that hard to believe, unless he missed that day in anatomy class when it was explained that the particular area to which he refers is not in the brain, but somewhat lower.


Exposed skin speaks louder than annual revenue growth, even to a CEO. “What if the men in your office changed for dinner and came bare-chested?” asks Dr. Brizendine.

Then they would be the subject of ridicule because of their exceptionally poor fashion judgment.  It is hardly a nipple to nipple comparison, and would have a decidedly negative impact on other guests’ ability to digest their dinner.


“They’re thinking it’s an empowering thing that they can be sexy and professional,” he says, “but guys don’t see it that way. If she’s dressed sexy, that’s all they see.”

Absolutely untrue.  False.  A lie.  A vicious lie.  And who cares what guys think anyway.  If some man can’t handle a little show of cleavage and a bit of bare back, it exposes him as a neanderthal and potential ascot wearer.  For the record, if nobody has noticed that you’re a woman prior to a formal evening event, then the depth of cleavage isn’t going to matter.  And if they have, then it’s too late. 

So don’t let the claim that some men may see you as a “sex object” rather than the competent professional you are affect your choices.  And stay far away from any man who shows up bare-chested.  He’s a nut.

“The Predominant Class Will Be Lawyers”

New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo announced yesterday that the Pension Scandal, which Turk tells me needs a really good name that doesn’t include a “gate” on the end, will involved “hundreds and hundreds” of attorneys.

According to Law.com,


While his investigators have only exposed the “tip of the iceberg” so far, Cuomo said the problem is not limited to a few school districts on Long Island which were initially exposed for having put attorneys doing work for the districts on the public pension rolls.

Cuomo said the problem is also evident at BOCES school districts, “special” districts like sewer or water districts and towns and villages.

I’m shocked, shocked.  Like this wasn’t part of the message in this op-ed in Newsday.  Like lawyers didn’t have enough credibility problems with the public.  Like they didn’t knew better.


“In many ways, this situation is the public integrity version of death by a thousand cuts,” Cuomo said. “Ten thousand governments. Little scams. Chronic widespread corruption and fraud. And in the end, the taxpayers bleed millions of dollars.”

Cuomo is exactly right, though across New York the petty tyrants will dispute this characterization and curse the ground he walks on. 

The patchwork quilt of what I call “baby governments” is rife with corruption, but it’s mostly of the petty sort.  A dime here, a dollar there, a harmless little violation of the open meetings law, a blow-off of the freedom of information law.  Selective and vindictive resolution of problems or enforcement of law.  That sort of stuff.  The sort that allows the big fish in tiny little ponds to feel self-important and powerful, all on someone else’s dime.

In fairness to the many lawyers involved, they likely never gave their deeds enough thought to realize that they were wrong.  This was a perk of the job, as far as they understood, and they gratefully accepted the benefit of serving the public for many years when the pension checks rolled in.  If everybody drives 70 in a 55 zone, it isn’t really wrong, is it?

But while Cuomo’s focus is on the lawyers, and you bet your bottom dollar that there will be plenty of folks across New York who will use this as proof positive the lawyers are inherently corrupt, self-serving and untrustworthy vultures who prey on the people for their own benefit, it’s wrong to saddle only the lawyers with the blame.

We don’t elect municipal lawyers.  We elect school board members, commissioners, mayors and trustees.  These are not people pressed into service against their will; They run for office.  When we elect these people, we entrust them with the fulfillment of the duties that come with the post.  It doesn’t pay much, if anything, and it can take a great deal of time, effort and thought to perform these duties.  Or at least perform them well.

In many instances, possibly most, these elected officials are engaged in a huge farce.  We pay for this farce, but that’s only right since we elected these people in the first place.  You get the government you deserve.

While often well-intended (though not always), some elected officials quickly learn that they lack the basic competencies for the job.  Others never learn this, instead believing that they’ve gained sudden brilliance by osmosis, sitting on the chair reserved for the President of the School Board.  It’s an amazing thing to watch, as yesterday’s regular guy becomes today’s paternalistic know-it-all.

But because they lack the competencies, they resort to their “professionals”.  In other words, the putative elected decision-makers defer to the professionals, whether they be District Superintendents, Municipal Lawyers, Engineers, whatever, and then, admirably perform the role of rubber stamp.  Afterward, they pat themselves on the back for a job well done, never once realizing that they’ve done nothing other than turned over the reigns to some unelected official and reduced themselves to a nullity.

Do elected officials get a free pass for being well-intended but ignorant and incompetent?  Are they absolved of sin because they gave away their responsibility to conceal the fact that they can’t actually perform the function for which they were elected?  And we’re not talking here about the lazy, abusive or malevolent.  These are the good ones.

Much as it pains me, I’m constrained to answer yes. To some extent, they are absolved of their sins, since they must rely on the expertise of their retained professionals to provide advice requiring specialized knowledge.  If not, why bother having lawyers at all?

But they are not give a total free pass.  Much of what happens does not require specialized knowledge, though it is often easier to defer to the professionals than do any thinking on their own.  Worse still, there are often clear indications that something is seriously awry that should raise the red flag about the advice they are being given, even to someone who hasn’t got the common sense of a gnat.  Hiding behind advice that doesn’t pass the smell test, or even advice that just emits a slightly pungent odor, is an abdication of responsibility, and it is culpable conduct. 

Passing the blame is a time-honored sport.  But that doesn’t make it right or acceptable.  While Attorney General Cuomo is busy putting an end to the sort of corruption that has permeated baby governments forever, perhaps he can address the root sources of these problems so that the next group of municipal lawyers to fill the empty official seats won’t eventually return us to the same system of failure, incompetence, waste and ultimately corruption. 

Now, does anybody have a really cool name for this scandal that doesn’t include the word “gate” in it?

McCain: All Mom and Apple Pie

Political advertising went from nuclear bombs exploding around little children with flowers to revolving prison doors.  Whether positive or negative, the ads were directed to the issues of the day. 

But what do you sell when one of a candidate’s biggest perceived problems is that he’s really old.  If elected at 72, he would be the oldest person ever elected to the office of President, making William Henry Harrison, old Tippecanoe at 68, an also-ran?  Why, put out an ad showing this guy with his mother!



In her 90s, John McCain’s mother is a feisty, sharp old gal, immediately endearing.  I just love old-timers who still have some fight left in them, and she is as charming as they come.

This is one of the great ads.  Not only does it show John McCain to be the sort of politician who loves his mother, enough to spend his campaign dollars on advertisement featuring her, but it shows two other things:  First, that he comes from good stock, the sort that lives a long time and keeps their wits about them well past the age when most consider not drooling to be a good day. 

Second, the juxtaposition of McCain with his mother makes him look like a kid.  That’s not an easy thing to do when you’re McCain’s age, but he’s managed to accomplish it and do it well.  This add takes 20 years off McCain’s perceived age.  It’s brilliant.

Of course, the ad is a play to perceptions more than reality.  As POTUS, the pressures on McCain will be unlike anything his mother has endured in her very long life.  It’s one thing to sit around the club and sip scotch, as opposed to being the leader of the free world (do we still say that?) and commander in chief.  President is a little more rigorous.  As President Bush continually says, “It’s hard work.”

Still, to the extent that a single image can have a widespread impact on public perception, this is a home run.  McCain may have taken his age out of play with this single advertisement.  And he loves him Mother as well.  No American can help but like a guy who loves his Mom.

Rockefeller Drug Laws Turn 35

Thirty-five years ago, New York engaged in an experiment that, at the time, seemed as if it held promise to stop the scourge of drugs that swept New York.  Gov. Nelson Rockefeller, who was a forward thinker, accepted the notion that by putting into place Draconian penalties for the sale and possession of drugs, and removing discretion from the hands of judges so that the criminals would know with certainty that they were going down hard, he could stem the tide.

As noted in this Newsday editorial, we are now 35 years into this experiment.  While we all knew that it was a failure decades ago, it remains the core of New York penal law.


Thirty-five years ago today, Gov. Nelson Rockefeller signed the drug laws that bear his name, setting the state on a course of costly and ineffective mandatory prison time for non-violent drug offenders. Since then, the war on drugs has waxed and waned, the crack epidemic has come and gone, crime has soared and subsided, and through it all Rockefeller’s laws have endured. It’s time for a change.

Newsday is wrong.  It’s way past time for a change.  The theory behind the Rocky Laws was proven flawed long ago, as people continued to use and sell drugs despite the shockingly harsh penalties.  There have been some recent legislative tweaks of late, but the basic application remains. 

Sell 2 ounces of a narcotic drug and receive a sentence of 15 to 25 years in prison.  Possess 4 ounces and get the same.  How many people out there realize how little 2 ounces really is?  Or 4 ounces?  Could you tell if you held in your hand?  Yet these weights are sufficient to result in the same sentence as murder. 

While the changes have given rise to some escape valves in the law, and changes in the sentencing scheme of late, it’s nothing more than a palliative.  The guys in Albany can pat themselves on the back for having “reformed” the law when they’ve done remarkably little to fix a problem.  Criminal defense lawyers know it.  Judges know it.  Corrections officials know it.  Prosecutors?  I have no idea what they know, but I think they might know it too.


The cost – $430 million all in – would be worth bearing if incarceration were the best way to protect the public and turn drug abusers around. It isn’t. Treatment is more effective and costs less – $17,000 to $21,000 per person, per year, for residential programs, and $2,700 to $4,500 for outpatient care, according to the Correctional Association of New York.

Eliminating mandatory sentences wouldn’t mean eliminating prison time for all drug offenders. Judges would be able to sentence people based on their individual crimes and circumstances. Costly prison cells could be reserved for serious drug offenders, rather than their girlfriends or gofers.

Now that we are in  a recession hard times, cost of incarceration has begun to overtake the zeal to incarcerate.  Of course, the “cost” is not merely the amount the taxpayers contribute to the warehousing of people for long, long periods of time, but the opportunity costs of that money to society, the cost to families of the incarcerated and the cost to society of these people when released from decades in prison. 

More to the point, the concept of sure and harsh incarceration defies the legitimate purposes of sentencing, and reduces the integrity of criminal justice to a nullity.  There is no rational basis to contend that a mule carrying a kilo of coke to make $500 to feed her children requires a 15 year sentence as a deterrent.  Want a deterrent?  Educate her so she can get a job and feed her kids.  Or better yet, educate her so that she doesn’t have kids when she’s a 17 year old child herself.

Despite 35 years of proof that the underlying idea behind the Rockefeller Drug Laws is a failure, there is no groundswell of support for scrapping them in Albany.  To do so would make legislators look weak on crime, and we still haven’t gotten past the political benefit of appearing tough.  The contrary position, being smart on crime, is too difficult a sell, unless a concerted effort is made by politicians to change the political atmosphere. 

So 35 years later, we’re still grasping the same failed concept, politics over reason.  That’s a pretty pathetic birthday present from Albany to the people of the State of New York.

A Blawger Sits in the Balcony Because He’s Not Real

Scott Henson, who’s Grits for Breakfast is one of the predominant blawgs in the area of criminal law and Texas law and politics, took a hit for all of us.  Scott goes much farther than most of us in the blawgosphere in developing news stories, breaking scandals and revealing the ugly underbelly of the law. He is, by any definition, a journalist.

Yesterday, Scott went to a “summit” in Austin on wrongful convictions.  The summit was held in the Senate Chamber, which means of course that the Senators were out playing golf, but that’s not the point.  It was a meeting of officials and opinion leaders in Texas on a subject about which Scott has dutifully and thoroughly reported.  He could easily have been asked to be on the podium, as he is an opinion leader on the topic.

But when he arrived to take a seat on the Senate floor, as he reports in this post, he was told that he wasn’t worthy of a seat reserved for a journalist.


I was a bit annoyed when I was told bloggers couldn’t go onto the Senate floor because we’re not real journalists, so I didn’t get to take the photos I’d hope to get. (That crap really needs to change next session – in all modesty, this blog reports circles around some of the reporters who had credentials to get on the floor.) But even from my perch in the gallery, the discussion was awfully interesting.

Not only does Grits report circles around some of the “real” reporters, it has a readership that dwarfs most small-town papers.  Yet the fact that he types articles that never kill trees renders him less important than the kid from the Podunk Gazette, readership 278. 

No, all blawgers are not journalists.  In fact, few should qualify, as few do the legwork that a journalist does or report with the depth or consistency of a print journalist.  But Scott does.  Without a doubt, Scott Henson is as much, if not more, of a journalist than most of the fine reporters with press passes, even from the big dailies, as his posts report the news and provide a depth of understanding and analysis that a person who reported yesterday about the soap-box derby in Travis County would never possess.

Would it be difficult for the guardians of legitimate journalism at the gate of newsworthiness to tell a Scott Henson from some crazy internet blogger?  Maybe, but who said that respect under the first amendment had to be easy. 

If I want to know what happened at this wrongful conviction summit in Austin yesterday, Grits for Breakfast would be the first place I would turn.  When they deny Scott Henson’s right to sit on the floor where the real journalists sit, they deny my first amendment right to know as well.  Scott Henson is as real a journalist as they get.  Let him on the floor, and give him a seat up front.

Another Proud Moment in Law Enforcement History

Philly was never a great place to mess with the cops.  It used to have a Mayor named Rizzo who was quite proud of the fact that his cops could stop any black man anywhere anytime for anything or nothing.  Ah, the heady days when the cops could keep all those bad guys in line with a few blows from their nightstick.

But Frank Rizzo was such a long time ago.  It’s not like that could happen today.  Right?



It is such a shame that there’s no audio to go with the video.  So, to add to the experience, I offer the following dialogue:

Cop:  Hey Joe, nobody has stomped on his thigh yet.
Cop:  Got it.
Cop:  isn’t anybody gonna hit him with the night stick?
Cop:  Fine, do I have to do everything myself.
Cop:  Petey, did you get a head kick in there?
Cop:  No, Sam, I was waiting my turn.
Cop:  Well, go for it.  It’s not like we have all night you know.
Cop:  Harry, you already beat him twice.  Give somebody else a turn.
Cop:  I did not.  I only beat him once. 

Man getting beaten on ground:  Ahhhh,  Arrggghhh.  Ahhh.

Cop;  Did he say something, Joe?
Cop:  Yeah, he called you a wimp.
Cop:  Oh yeah? 
Cop:  Harry, that’s your fourth kick to the head.
Cop:  Bull, prove it.  You got a video?

Well, Harry, in fact we do.

If You Don’t Already Agree, Get Lost!

 I realize that this may seem a little disingenuous, since I’m not the most tolerant blawger when it comes to people who refuse to put much thought into criminal justice issues, but I’m a piker compared to this.

When I posted about Lawprof Deanna Sacks’ article proposing to create a cause of action for sexual fraudulent inducement, I wondered whether my position was really some male misogynistic perspective or whether women, somewhat less radical than Sacks, thought the same thing.  Mind you, I don’t see anything anti-feminist about objecting to insanely stupid ideas, but then, agreeing with myself is a form of mental masturbation.  Meaning, I could be wrong.

Of course, I wasn’t the only one who thought this was just plain nuts.  Marc Randazza, lawprof and 1st Amendment maven, thought so too.  For his efforts, he was bobbitized in effigy, having broken the sacred oath of orthodoxy to which all non-Libertarian lawprofs are sworn.  Marc’s problem is that he has a sense of humor, which is treason to radicals.  He is thus dismissed as having a bad attitude.  This may be true, but he’s still a funny guy.

In contrast, consider the Presiding Justice of the Court of Radical Feminism, Ann Bartow.  A lawprof by day, angry blawger otherwise.  Worse yet, we share the same undergrad alma mater, Cornell ILR (I graduated before she arrived, so don’t blame me).  Most of the angry people there wanted to grow up to be wobblies. 

In the comments to Deanna Sacks’ post at Feminist Law Profs, there were some thoughtful reactions that disagreed with the proposition.  Not thoughtful like mine or Randazza’s, but thoughtful in the way that they actually felt compelled to explain why, from a feminist perspective, they disagreed.

This is how Bartow responded :


“OneSidedDialogue” posted the identical words in the comments section of Above The Law. Moreover, OSD shares an e-mail address with someone who has left fairly abusive MRA type comments here in the past that did not make it through moderation. With those caveats, I decided to let this comment post, but note that given that the author has not even read the described article, it seems very calculated to derail discussion of Sacks’ actual analysis.

Shades of Priya Venkatesan.  This prompted another commenter, “first time caller.” to take issue:


The comment [to which Bartow responded], while unusually lengthy for such a short post, seems to address the issues/arguments alluded to, if not fleshed out, in the post (sex as contract, lies as fraudulent inducement, STD as tortious harm, etc.) and some potential problems that pop to mind when the post is considered. Is this not allowed? If we must read the underlying article before commenting on the post promoting the article, why isn’t the article linked to in some fashion? And if no comment is worthy if based only on the partial understanding provided by the post, why no similar lambasting of AshleyJax’s uninformed agreement?

The comment seems to raise some obvious potential shortcomings to an intentional sexual tort regime. I certainly hope that reading Prof. Sacks’ full article lays to rest these potential bogeymen, but I – like the commenter – apparently can’t read it until the Fall. Thus, we are left commenting on a short post. Or not. Are we holding off on all discussion until Fordham puts it out? If so, why the post?

BTW – what is an “MRA type comment”? I’m not up on the lingo.

She was doing so well until that last line.  The admission that she’s “not up on the lingo” was proof of heresy.  Clearly, this “abusive” commenter didn’t know the secret handshake.  And so, the judgment of Presiding Justice Bartow:


“first time caller” – this is a blog by and for feminist law professors. Prof. Sacks put up a post that enabled her colleagues to see what she was working on. She doesn’t owe you anything, nor do I. Marc Randazza decided to use her short post as a way to leverage himself as much visibility as possible, in a superficial and distortive way. That he couldn’t wait until the article was actually available to start trashing it is an issue you can take up with him.

If you don’t know what an MRA is, try here: http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com/purpose/ That blog is probably a better place for you than this one.

What is unbelievably cool about Bartow’s response is how she managed to denigrate Randazza in the process even though he had absolutely nothing to do with anything.  That’s a real gift.

There is no doubt in my mind that I don’t get it.  Perhaps that makes me anti-feminist, at least in the mind of a certain individual whose name shall go unmentioned.  If so, mea culpa.  You see, I just not prepared to let myself be bobbitized, and if that’s what it takes to please a radical, then it makes me the bad guy.

Some years ago, I did a TV show about a federal court decision that implicated feminism.  Patricia Ireland, then President of the National Organization of Women, was also a guest on the show, as was some guy, whose name I can’t recall, who was President of the National Association of Men.  I was the “legal analyst.”  The NAM guy kept winking at me, as in, “hey bud, we’re in this together, right?”  He was a doofus, a bull in the china shop of reason.

Patricia Ireland, on the other hand, was gracious, funny and reasonable.  She was cautious in what she said because she understood that acceptance of women as equals could not come at the expense of acceptance of men as equals.  There was no doubt about where she stood and what she thought, and if her reasoning wasn’t apparent, she was happy to clear it up.  I really enjoyed being on the show with Patricia, and we found ourselves in agreement on just about everything.  She was a very impressive person.

Even if guys like me and Randazza are seen as the enemy of radical feminism today, I think that Patricia Ireland would have viewed us as being pretty darned understanding of feminism and, frankly, acceptable examples of the male of the species.  If they can’t even accept a modest and thoughtful challenge from other women without ripping their lungs out and banishing them to some remedial feminism website, then I’m feeling pretty comfortable with where I am.

Uma, Meet Emily

Only in Manhattan can this happen.  The trial of Jack Jordon, the Uma Thurman stalker, caught the attention of many in New York, largely because it was about Uma Thurman.  They say it was one of her best performances.  But what are the chances that a reporter for the Wall Street Journal would happen to be one of the jurors?

Manhattan juries may be a little different from those found in other places.  The jury included “two lawyers, a former editor for the TV show “Wife Swap” and a rock-show caterer.”  I bet Anne Reed could make some hay with that group.  And one reporter named Emily Steel.

The WSJ Law Blog reports that Emily Steel, as it happened, sat on the Jordon jury and, fortuitously, wrote the blow by blow for the front page of the Wall Street Journal.  Steel explains the gist of the jury’s deliberations:


Getting there took us about seven hours of deliberation, spread over two days, starting Monday afternoon. Our debate centered on a surprisingly complex question: Where is the line between obsession and menace?

She then takes readers through the process.  While it lacks depth (it is the WSJ after all), it’s always fascinating to take a peek into the jury room to understand how a bunch of people arrive at a verdict affecting the life of a fellow human being.

One exchange in the jury room is most enlightening:
But I had a question. The charge was for the period from May 1, 2005, until Aug. 17, 2007, but Mr. Jordan’s obsession wasn’t pushed over the edge until August last year. Could we say he was guilty of the stalking charge, if he wasn’t stalking her for that entire period?

One of the lawyers on the jury said that his behavior wasn’t to be interpreted in a vacuum. Each of his actions during that period — from the praying-girl card Mr. Jordan delivered at the movie set to the notes he pushed through her door — was to be interpreted as one criminal act.

If that was the case, then I could say he was guilty.

That’s the problem with putting lawyers on the jury.  They are still lawyers.  So much for getting legal instructions from the judge, with the attorneys capable of objecting and preserving.

The end of Steel’s account is also revealing, not for any insight into jury deliberations but for what we would otherwise learn about them from the media.


As I left the building with a few fellow jurors, we rode in an elevator with reporters grilling us for quotes. Their first question: What did it feel like to be a juror in the trial of Ms. Thurman’s stalker?

What did it feel like?  Now there’s a useful question.

Over 200 Arrested, But Nothing Accomplished

Yesterday, a peaceful and well-organized protest led by the Rev. Al Sharpton tied up traffic around Manhattan and resulted in over 200 arrests, according to Newsday.  In contrast to spontaneous protests of the past, involving rioting or car-burning, this was a “pray-in”, and was designed to bring New York to a halt for the afternoon rush hour. 

The protesters intended to engage in civil disobedience, and expected to be arrested for it.  It was really quite cooperative, protesters waiting patiently in line for the police to bind their hands and take them away. 

Put aside any ill-will one may have toward Al Sharpton’s integrity (a lot of New Yorkers remember Tawana Brawley, or just see Al as an opportunist) and consider the bigger picture.  There is a point to be made about the treatment of blacks by police in New York City, and the protesters were determined to make that point.

Will anything change?  Nothing changed after Amadou Diallo.  Not after Abner Louima,  Will Sean Bell be the tragedy to make a difference?  No.

Unlike some, I am firmly of the opinion that institutional racism remains firmly entrenched in the New York police department.  Others argue that it’s not racism, but just the fact that blacks are inclined to be criminals.  It is my belief that this view, standing alone, reflects the very problem of intransigent racism.

But while people protest, the question that remains is whether anybody is paying attention to the message.  After a while, it’s just another protest.  People become used to it.  People anticipate a protest after an event, and when the protest happens, they briefly look up from their coffee and remark, “they had another protest yesterday,” and then take another sip.  It’s just another day.

The targets of the protest, the police, the politicians, just shake their heads at the Rev. Al’s antics.  He’s very predictable.  They take comfort in the fact that Judge Cooperman made the right decision when he announced the “not guilty” verdict.  And the judge was right.  But that has little do with the fact that there is a problem, a very real problem. 

The verdict was a comment on a prosecution, but not the attitude that led up to the needless death of a young man who would probably not be dead if he was white.  This detail is dependent on a very subtle appreciation of what happened.  Many people will be incapable of seeing it, and will resort to a knee-jerk assertion that I’m saying that Sean Bell was shot because he was black.  That’s not what I’m saying. 

I’m saying that if the cops were dealing with a young white man, they would have hesitated before pulling the trigger because they would not have had the same degree of fear that they had in a black neighborhood with a young black man behind the wheel.  This is what distinguishes an everyday situation from the killing of a man, the moment that a cop decides to pull the trigger of his service weapon.

Just as there are deniers here, there are deniers in the police department.  They don’t see it.  Not at all.  They reject that there is institutional racism in the cop culture, in the fear and belief that young black men are more likely criminals than not.  They take comfort from the certainty of their belief, because they don’t want to be racist and don’t want to believe that they are. 

Just as firmly as I belief that racism remains pervasive, I believe that police do not believe that they, as a group, are racist.  I truly believe that they don’t want to be, and believe they aren’t.  When protests like this happen, they shake their heads at the foolishness of it, because it’s seen as just another misguided effort by people who want to find racism under every rock, when the truth (their truth) is that these protesters just don’t get it.

And so, the protest falls on deaf ears.  Again.  Civilians just don’t understand what it’s like to be a cop.  They don’t understand the pressure, the split second decisions, they fear that they could be killed at any moment.  It’s all so simple to civilians.  Only another cop understands. 

So to police, there is nothing that the protesters could say or do that would matter, because they could never understand what it’s like to be a cop.  So the protests fall on deaf ears.  Again.

The police have a defense mechanism like no other.  It’s a shell that protects them from all accusations, that allows them to sleep at night, comforted by the belief that they are right.  Bad things happen, and have happened over and over again.  And yet it is never a systemic problem.  There is always some excuse, coupled with their “civilians can’t possibly understand” culture, that shields them from their institutional failures.

It’s not just killing black men.  It’s inherent in their culture.

Nothing changed after the Dirty 30.  Nothing changed after Serpico.  Nothing changed after the Brooklyn narcotics scandal of the past year. 

Nothing ever changes because nothing can penetrate that shield around cops.  Yesterday was a fine example of civil disobedience.  But it will accomplish nothing.