Author Archives: SHG

Laying Blame For Prisons on the Dems

Lawprof Bill Stuntz has posted a very provocative piece entitled “Who is Responsible for America’s Swollen Prison Population?”  Stuntz uses a somewhat limited statistical analysis to show that while prison population has grown under Republican administrations, it has ballooned under the Democrats.

Stuntz’s conclusion is that, without absolving the Republicans of responsibility, the prisons are overflowing because of the Democrats:


Notice the nature of that political exchange. For Republicans to win votes on crime, all they need do is talk about it: the Willie Horton ad that helped turn the 1988 election is a prime example. No Clinton-style inoculation is needed. For Democrats to win those same votes, they need to take the kind of action that shows their toughness: hence Rector’s execution. Rising imprisonment has been the price Democrats have had to pay in order to win power and enact the policy changes they really want.

Before anyone jumps down Stuntz’s throat because they just don’t like this outcome, give it some thought.  While the Dems have championed some liberal social causes, such as pro-choice and anti-death penalty, when is the last time you heard any Democrat running for office proclaim that personal freedom trumps the “war on crime?”  As Stuntz says, the Democrats have taken up the tough-on-crime banner and run with it.  Nobody is going to Willie Horton them again.

Note that Democrat, in this analysis, is not the same as liberal.  Democrats shed any pretense toward liberal ideology long ago when it comes to crime as the price of getting elected.  My elected official friends tell me that if they don’t get elected, they can’t make a difference.  But if they abandon principle to get elected, they don’t make a difference anyway.  This leaves us with dumb and dumber, er, tough and tougher.

When the Republicans turned the word “liberal: into an epithet during the Reagan candidacy, the Democrats were blind-sided.  They didn’t know how to deal with it, and got slaughtered for their ineptitude in deflecting the Republican assault. 

The Reps followed up with the Willie Horton ad, one of the best political tools every employed, that played into the fears of Americans.  Dukakis’ reaction was put on a tank helmet that made him look like a smurf.  Rather than seize the memory of our Revolutionary forefathers, their struggle for freedom against a despotic monarch who would subjugate the colonists through force, the Dems began chanting their new mantra, “I ain’t no liberal pansy criminal lover.” 

Prove it?  And they did.  Clinton executed a mentally retarded man.  As Stuntz contends, it wasn’t good enough to say you were tough on crime, because the Republicans owned that phrase.  The Democrats had to out-tough the toughest to show their bona fides.  You may not like the implication that the Dems are responsible, or that the Reps not so much, but his statistics comport with impartial observation.  Like it or not, this was the price that the Dems paid for getting elected.

This is why, from a criminal justice perspective, it’s hard to find much to praise about our Democratic candidates.  They do not reflect a party that believes in the Constitution, personal freedom or civil rights when it comes to criminal justice.  While the Republicans don’t either, it just leaves us with no champion.  We’re on the outs again with everybody.

For a couple of decades, I’ve been waiting for someone to stand up and say, “I support the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, even if it means that we don’t execute every alleged criminal for jaywalking.”  I’m still waiting.  Hillary and Barak, it’s not too late, you know.  But then, you guys want to get elected, and nobody gets elected in America without being tough on crime.

H/T Orin at Volokh

The Presumption of a Fraudulent Democracy

The Supreme Court’s decision in  Crawford v. Marion County, which  upheld Indiana’s voter identification law, has been characterized as “unremarkable” or a giant leap toward  the disenfranchisement of hundreds of thousand of citizens.  For many, while it smacks of yet another step toward keeping the poor, the old, the student and the minority away from the polling booth, they can appreciate that it will be a significant weapon against voter fraud.

The New York Times editorial condemning the decision details the history of methods to keep people who don’t fall into the mainstream from voting.



[Florida’s] latest assault on democracy: a law threatening volunteer groups with crippling fines if they make small mistakes in registering voters.


Florida is not the only state trying to stop eligible people from voting. Georgia passed a law in 2005 that made voters pay for their voter ID cards — a modern poll tax. The fee was eventually removed, but the law could still block as many as 300,000 registered voters without the right ID from casting ballots. In 2004, Ohio ordered counties to throw out voter registration forms that were not on thick enough paper.


It is chilling to think that state legislators and election officials would intentionally try to make it harder for Americans to vote, but they always have — with poll taxes, literacy tests and gerrymandering. There was a time when the Supreme Court regularly struck these restrictions down. In 1966, it held Virginia’s $1.50 poll tax unconstitutional. In 1972, it ruled that Tennessee’s one-year residency requirement for voting violated the Constitution.


For most of us, these efforts won’t stop us from going to the polls and casting out vote.  And no one champions the idea of dead people voting, or live people voting multiple times.  So while we may disagree with the burdens placed on voter registration and challenges at the polls, we just can’t get too worked up about it.

But Crawford, a notable change in direction for the Supremes, is different.  Belying the decision is the presumption that everyone who comes to vote is engaging in fraud unless they prove otherwise.  The Court has institutionalized the idea that we are presumed criminals when it comes to voting, and has shifted the burden to us to prove that we are entitled.

The franchise is a bedrock of democracy.  The individuals who are elected to make decisions as to what our government does are put in place because people vote for them.  The Supremes have now held that the Constitution permits states to demand that those same people prove their worthiness to vote by satisfying its rules.  From any constitutional perspective, originalist or living, democracy was never intended to become dependent on proving one’s worth to the very government one was electing.  It’s been turned upside down.

Some will ask, then how do we stop voter fraud?  Aside from whether it’s as grave a problem as the name sounds, noting that the Supreme Court couldn’t find any contemporary proof of the evil it was purportedly curing, that’s the wrong question.  The right question is how do we protect bedrock principles of democracy when others try to tweak minor problems around the edges.  If the tweak conflicts with the free exercise of voting, then it’s not a good tweak.  Go back to the drawing board and find another one, if you can.

It may be that there is no good tweak that will prove capable of putting an end to the potential for voter fraud.  But until the consequence of voter fraud is shown to be of such a magnitude that it would undermine the bedrock principles of democracy, by diluting the legitimate vote of the People with fraudulent votes to the extent that democratic elections have lost their integrity, it’s not in the ballgame.  We don’t let the tail wag the dog (though it seems to happen constantly).

Then we come face to face with the “mainstream” problem.  The fact that “normal” people have picture IDs that they carry around with them all the time anyway, making this issue a tempest in a teapot as far as they are concerned.  I know I do.  In fact, I have a few.  So why should I care, or make a big deal out of this ruling?

Ah, the tyranny of the majority.  If that’s how we live, then everyone must live just like us.  We can’t imagine why anyone would want to live differently.  Isn’t this why the Iraqis will welcome us as heroes and adopt western democracy within weeks of throwing out the old evil dictator? 

Us normal guys don’t seem to mind being presumed criminals because we can readily prove otherwise.  And if anyone needs to be so “radical” that they can’t manage to assimilate, screw ’em.  They are probably all felons, illegals or frauds anyway.  Because we can’t imagine that there are hundreds of thousand of American citizens who don’t live exactly like us.  And if there are, then it’s their own fault for adopting some ridiculous lifestyle that creates their own problems.

But bedrock principles of democracy keep getting in the way.  Each person has an indisputable right to live the way he chooses.  Many can’t adapt so easily to our lifestyle, even though we can’t conceive of how they could not.  There is nothing “common” about common sense, and everyone does what they think best or can within the limits of their circumstances.  We can’t condemn them because we can easily live in the mainstream.  They have as much right to vote as we do.

So even though people in the mainstream may not mind that they are now presumably criminals in the eyes of their own government, anyone who strays from lifestyle orthodoxy just got screwed by the Supreme Court’s decision.  Even you better hope you don’t forget your driver’s license when you show up to vote, because then you’ve become “them”.\

There’s a  new radio program in Connecticut doing a point/counterpoint debate, with our good buddy Norm Pattis playing the role of “Shayna, the ignorant slut.”  The first debate is about the Indiana voter ID decision, with Karen Torre, the local Federalist Society wag.  Listen to the debate, and it’s important that you stick around for the end to hear Torre’s final salvo. 

When pushed to the edge, Torre explains that this voter ID law is no problem because the good people, the honest law-abiding people, the people smart enough to elect our government officials, the ones she wants to vote, all have IDs anyway and the people without IDs aren’t worthy of the vote anyway.

And that, in a nutshell, sums it up.

New Flavors of Spam: Ciallis is Passe; Now It’s Lawyers

Sure, I still get a bunch of trackbacks and pseudo-comments from the folks who want to sell you viagra and lesbian-on-lesbian love videos.  They are ubiquitous, and must apparently interest someone (maybe your he-men, xstripper?) or there wouldn’t be so many websites vying for your attention.

But there has been a new, and disturbing, trend in the blawgosphere.  I have been getting a bunch of spamalicious trackbacks from lawyer websites trying to sneak in their wares.  The biggest violator of my sovereignty has been for a child custody website.  No, I can’t include a link because that would give them what they want, and that isn’t the purpose of this post.  But they have deluged me with spam, which naturally makes me think that these must be some pretty important lawyers.

The next most interesting approach has been from an immigration lawyer in Brooklyn, who is working much harder than the mere trackback spammer.  This spammeister has people posting comments here in barely cognizable English (not to be confused with my own comments in barely cognizable English), and at the end putting a little infomercial about their immigration practice.

At first, I though this was just somebody who had yet to get the basic idea that they don’t get to come to someone else’s blawg to advertise themselves, and I deleted the infomercial part of their comment.  Not that the comment was worth keeping, but it didn’t otherwise break the rule.

In the past, I have deleted comments or portions of comments that link to other blogs, websites or promoted lawyers gratuitously.  This blawg is not available for advertising, whether deliberate or inadvertent.  I keep an eye on things for that purpose, because I do not want to let that sort of think creep in.  If I wanted to advertise, I would put the stuff that pays me into the sidebar like some other blogs do.  Someday, I may end up doing that.  But even so, it will be my call, not the spammers.

So if you want to let lawyers know that HGH and child custody are readily available on the web, go do it somewhere else.  Please.

Out-Sourcing May Have Its Burning Issues

A while back, I raised a few hackles  with my views on taking the subway to Bangalore for cheap legal labor.  Since they couldn’t do arraignments by phone, it seemed that criminal defense lawyers were fairly safe from this new trend that Biglaw was using to increase their per partner profits (ppp) while billing out 1st year associates for 7934 hours a year to corporate America.  And they call plaintiff’s lawyers pigs.

Well,  Jonathon “Spread the Love” Turley has found a new source of agita.  What if Buffy and Jody of Bangalore are, dare I say it, of a “lower caste?”  Then, it appears that your ppp may go up in smoke.  According to numerous press reports,


Police in northern India arrested a man who allegedly threw a girl into a pile of glowing embers after he caught her trespassing, an attack authorities said Wednesday may have been motivated by caste. … [22-year-old Madan] Singh discovered the girl relieving herself Tuesday in a field he owned and demanded she immediately stop what she was doing and leave his property. “When she did not respond, he simply lifted her and threw her in a heap of embers,” local police official Govind Agarwal told the Associated Press.

Now what exactly, Mr. Biglaw guy, do you tell Mr. Corp Counsel when he inquires what’s happening with his document review? 

The world may well have flattened some, but perhaps its premature to think that India is just like New Jersey, except the people there drive better.  They may change their names when they answer the telephone to make themselves sound like your every-day Idahoan, but most people in Idaho don’t have to concern themselves with being burned alive for walking on a path reserved for the Brahmins.

And if human rights are your bag, not to mention any sort of appropriate feelings toward 6 year old girls, would it not be just wee bit disconcerting to think that you are contributing to a country and culture that still has untouchable issues?  Let’s not even talk about China and selling organs from prisoners.

Sure, it’s all a matter of maximizing ppp and getting the drudgery of busywork done as quickly and cheaply as possible.  But hopefully some enterprising journalist, or perhaps even blawger, will take note should some white shoe-iest of white shoes step on some lower caste 6 year old girl.  Just think about it, will ya?

Making Children the Gatekeepers of the Courthouse

The Texas Tornado, ruthless yet empathetic (or emphatic, according to ones preferred recognition of the English language) Houston criminal defense lawyer and president-elect of the Harris County Criminal Lawyers Association, Mark Bennett, has come up with yet another stroke of brilliance.

In anticipation of his assumption of the presidency, Mark has been advised that he needs to be more “diplomatic”.  I fail to see an issue, but apparently folks are very sensitive down there in Harris County, Texas, which puts  more people to death than any other place in the country except the Free and Independent Nation of Texas itself.  I guess they get a little touchy when they are busy executing people all the time.  Probably more so when it turns out that the people are innocent.

Anyway, Mark has initiated a new award, Asshat of the Day Award, hereinafter referred to as the “ADA”.  Mark has a way with naming things.  I’m really jealous of him, because he’s just so much better at it than anyone else I know.  After all, he’s the guy who came up with the “practical blawgosphere,” and has confirmed his place in history by that alone.

The inaugural ADA goes to a particular group, rather than an individual, as is befitting an award that has such sweeping breadth.


Today’s Asshat of the Day Award (henceforth “ADA”) is shared by every 25-28 year old lawyer who thinks that a law degree and a job with a District Attorney’s Office somehow qualifies her to make decisions that affect other people’s freedom, their livelihood, and their futures.

Now that’s diplomatic.  Unless you happen to be one of those 25-28 year olds who is confident that you exercise the power to help lives, or destroy lives, according to your strongly held belief that you do so with justice, mercy, and for the good of mankind (or womankind, so as not to be undiplomatic).

This inaugural ADA meshes well with an exchange here yesterday with a prosecutor named Mark.  I can’t tell you a lot about Mark, because he wasn’t giving up much that would enable me to know where he was coming from.  I don’t know if he fits into the ADA parameters,  He could have been a lifer in the prosecutor’s office, or a kid with one month under his belt.  He could be well-regarded, or deeply hated, by the judges and defense bar. 

Mark took issue with  a post that included some verbiage:


I can’t count the number of times some kid prosecutor confuses himself with being Odie to some cop’s Garfield, lapping up whatever story the cop feeds him as if it’s gospel.

It was the “odie” part that got to him.  Mark wanted to let me know that he’s no Odie.  Of course, no one said he was, but that wasn’t about to stop Mark from making his point.

Two things of significance came out of the exchange.  Mark, notwithstanding his anonymity, wrote


I can’t speak for every prosecutor’s/DA’s/USA’s office in America, but in my office for every two police reports we charge, we deny charges on one. Stop and think about that ratio for a moment. This simple fact, in my mind, is a compelling response to your Odie crack.

And this means what?  First, he can’t speak for “every” prosecutor’s office?  Actually, he can’t speak for any prosecutor’s office except his own, reducing the significance of his assertion to essentially a nullity.  So there’s one office that tosses one third of all charges brought to it by the cops?  Woo hoo.

But more significantly, does this ratio, assuming it to be true, change anything?  Obviously, Mark puts enormous stock in the fact that his office rejects one third of the cases brought to them by the cops.  This demonstrates, in his mind, that young prosecutors are not Odies.  If they were, they would happily lap up whatever the Garfield cops bring in the door, with question or concern.

Things like this make me feel old and tired.  Aside from Mark’s misapprehension that I called every kid prosecutor an Odie, it reveals the arrogance of youth and self-righteousness.  The flip side of being an Odie is society’s placement into the hands of a twenty-something prosecutor, with his great breadth of life experience, understanding of people and philosophical appreciation of the consequences of his choices, the lives of men, women and children.  Little kids playing God with other people’s lives. 

Young people often have a confidence that time wears down.  They feel an assurance that their decisions are right and that they have a deep enough understanding of the world to exercise their power appropriately.  Not all young people, but many of them.  Maybe Mark falls into the class.  Maybe not.  Since I don’t know anything about him, I couldn’t possibly say.  But when you’ve lived through a bunch more aches and pains, you realize the life has far more shades of gray than you thought.  I used to be a twenty-something.  I was much smarter then.  I know much less now.

But after trying to cajole Mark into giving up some info so that I could assess the basis of his claims and arguments, to little avail, he finally wrote something that gave me a ton of insight into his experience and world view:


By the way, I’m sure you have no problem beating up on Odie the prosecutor each and every time he puts an obviously lying cop on the stand. Wait, you mean sometimes the judge thinks the cop is telling the truth? Maybe you should write a post about naive judges.

Here’s my problem.  I knew that “naive judge” when he was Odie the prosecutor.  I knew her when she was the defense lawyer who wants to prove she can be just as tough as the other judges.  I knew him when he couldn’t figure out who was lying or telling the truth, and decided it was easier to go with the odds.  I knew her when she got her butt handed to her by the appellate court for being too pro-defendant.  I knew her when the state senator whispered in her ear that she would never get any higher in the judicial hierarchy unless she stopped making waves.  I knew him when he got tired of trying so hard to do the right thing and decided to just try to make it through the day without losing his cool.

Congratulations on winning the ADA.  It will be an award you will come to appreciate.  Not now, but some day.

Blawg Stuff: How To Keep Up With Alltop (Updated)

Anne Reed takes a day off from explaining why juries don’t think lawyers are nearly as brilliant as lawyers think lawyers are, and provides  a helping hand to lawyers who would like to keep up with “Alll” the “Top” news and info but just can’t seem to find the time.

Many of you are already much more sophisticated about all this Web 2.0 stuff than I am, or will ever be.  I just started using an RSS feed about a month ago, because things with initials combined with the word “feed” tend to scare me.  When I learned that RSS stood for “really simple” something, I realized that I desperately needed something “really simple,” so this was something for me. 

Here’s the problem:  For working lawyers, browsing the web, not the mention the blawgosphere, takes time.  Not just the time to read whatever somebody writes, but the loading of web pages, the navigating, the time that your computer sits there staring back at you doing nothing. 

For a fellow like me, who makes an effort to keep atop the news and commentary in the blawgosphere while trying to earn a respectable living as a criminal defense lawyer, time is a problem.  There are a lot of posts by people I respect and admire, or hate and loathe as the case may be, every day.  Does anybody have enough time to read all these posts? 

And then new blawgs appear out of the blue, and we want to give them a shake and not ignore them because they aren’t “established”.  I can’t speak for anybody else, but I remember how hard it was to “break into” the blawgosphere, when other blawgs wouldn’t link to me or put me into their blogroll because I was just the new kid on the block.  The big boys were a bunch of snotty jerks, looking down their nose at me if they were looking at all.  They wouldn’t give me the time of day. 

But every now and then, something new comes along that has the potential to make some serious changes in the way the blawgosphere exists to the outside world.  And Anne has announced one of them.  I would have announced it, except I didn’t know anything about it until I found out from Anne.  I try very hard to be firmly positioned as a second stringer in Web 2.0 news.


The law page at Alltop.com, a brand new directory from marketing guru Guy Kawasaki.  I wish I’d had this when I first started.  It’s a “single-page aggregation,” with “the latest five stories from thirty or more sites on a single page.”  (Even Alltop finds this hard to explain:  “You can think of an Alltop site as a ‘dashboard,’ ‘table of contents,’ or even a ‘digital magazine rack’ of the Internet.”)  The sites and the order they’re in keep shifting, and if you want to go beyond law, there are dozens of other pages and new ones coming all the time.

Alltop.com?  Nope, never heard of it.  So I checked it out.  It’s pretty darned cool.  One page, a bunch of blawgs, a bunch of post titles.  I even found my blawg there.  Way down the page, mind you, but there.

Conceptually, this is a great way to keep an eye on what’s going on in blawgosphere.  It saves a bunch of clicks, page loads, etc., and allows the busy lawyer to check out the blawgosphere quickly and effectively.  There are some drawbacks, since titles often fail to provide much of a clue as to what the post is about or whether it’s a substantive post of just a link to someone or something else.  For example, most of my post titles tend to be more a matter of my sense of humor than particularly informative as to the content of the post, so this isn’t going to help someone like me unless I start playing it a little straighter with the titles.

It also is going to give an odd impression to the person who doesn’t know much about the blawgosphere, since there doesn’t seem to be any particular rhyme or reason to why blawgs are listed in any particular order.  Anne says the order keeps shifting, and I saw that as I renewed the page.  But let’s face some blawgospheric reality: There are some blawgs that carry more and fresher content than others, and there are big boys and the rest of us.  This page makes no distinction for the looker who doesn’t know what he’s looking at.

On the other hand, this presentation creates a democratization of the blawgosphere, where past performance is no indicator of future performance.  The newest blawg on the block can get as much play as the most well established.  This may give everyone a fair shot at new eyeballs to the blawgosphere, and then it will be up to the individual blawgs to hold onto them.  Nothing wrong with that.

But anything that saves me time and allows me to navigate the blawgosphere more effectively is good by me.  What would I do without Anne Reed?

Update:  And the Turk gets hosed again.  While Alltop covers all the important blawgs, it seems that no personal injury blawgs made the cut.  A commentary or an accident?  You decide.  But I see a pattern developing.

How Not To Announce You’ve Arrived

I’ve certainly not been reluctant to take young prosecutors to task for being, well, young prosecutors.  But that doesn’t mean that I give young “defense lawyers” a free pass.  If anything, I’m tougher on criminal defense lawyers who fail to do the right thing, as my expectations of them are higher.  And so, when Skelly at  Arbitrary & Capricious posted about a new blawg, I had to take a look. 

My disappointment was palpable.  This new blawg is called The Public Pretender. Not only because this new erstwhile blogger didn’t bother to notice that he had taken the name of another blawg, just awfully poor form if nothing else.  Had it been that alone, some of us might have exerted a little pressure on the newbie to join the conversation more politely, rather than as a bull in the blawgosphere.  No, that turned out to be relatively minor.

The much larger problem was this:


As of last Friday, I am now a self-employed attorney and counselor at law. Actually, what I really am now is a Criminal Defense Lawyer. That’s the great thing about the law – I can be any kind of lawyer I want to be (well, almost), just by saying so. Friday I decided I’m a Criminal Defense Lawyer.

That’s right.  Almost.  Deciding on Friday that you are a “criminal defense lawyer” does not make you one.  It doesn’t make you anything. 

Our newbie CDL and Blawger, introduces himself in this way:


My name is David Harriman. I am a lawyer in Ohio. I will not name the city for reasons relating to client confidentiality and the possibility that doing so might get me disbarred.

A quick search reveals no lawyer named David Harriman in Ohio. whether criminal defense or otherwise.  Maybe he’s too new to locate, or maybe this is a made-up name for blawgospheric purposes.  But David gives us some background information on himself.


Friday was the day the partners in the firm where I have worked since I passed the bar last November called me into the conference room and rather unceremoniously handed me my walking papers.

*  *  *

Yet, like everyone else who latches onto the public dole when things get tough, bright and early Monday morning I bellied up to Rodney Grooms, the court administrator responsible for handing out these cases, and meekly asked if my name could be added to his list, and if it could be added like pronto?

*  *  *

Having never been in trouble myself and having taken no criminal law classes in law school (the thought of criminal law appalled me), I thought it best to ask for some help before arriving this morning. The best advice I got from the six or seven lawyers I asked was to just stand up and tell the judge why they should get a low bond and then say Not Guilty. Pick your best reason and go with it. The rest just told me to do what everyone else was doing. Which meant, I think, that they had no clue what to do either.

And so, David is now a criminal defense lawyer.

If this story is true, it reflects possibly the worst, most pathetic introduction to the blawgosphere and the practice of criminal defense law that I’ve ever seen.  But I have my doubts.

There’s a tinge of cynicism to this post that suggests that David is not quite as unbearably unqualified and foolish as he makes himself out to be. Indeed, his vivid description of the conversations with defendants in the pens sounds too familiar to be remembered by any kid lawyer who has just decided to become a criminal defense lawyer over the weekend.  There’s no newbie lawyer attitude about how zealous he is, and how unfair the defendants are.  No, this sounds like someone who has been around the block a few times having a little fun with the rest of us.

It’s quite possible that this is a brilliant parody of how some goofball lawyer gets his sweaty little hands around the throats of indigent defendants despite his screaming lack of qualifications, with some effective side-commentary on the state of affairs of indigent defenders, including their pay, treatment by defendants and the absence of personal pride and responsibility by the courthouse regulars.

If this is the case, then I applaud this blawger’s brilliant satire, more than sufficiently close to convincing to make a very sharp point about the state of affairs of indigent defense, the varying characteristics of those who wake up on Monday morning to find themselves “criminal defense lawyers” and the attitude of some criminal defendants.

But if this is for real, there are some people in Ohio who are in serious trouble.

Do Cops Save Lives, Ruin Lives, or Run?

A  letter to the Editor in the New York Times on the Sean Bell verdict has generated some interesting commentary over at PrawfsBlawg. The salient portion stated:

If this situation is to change, we must compel police officers to hold our interests and our lives above their own. They must accept the threat of harm as part of their jobs and their oaths. And they must demonstrate restraint even at the expense of their lives. Our society is served only when they take bullets for us, not we for them.

Cops take a bullet for us?  That got  Adam Kolber seriously juiced up. prompting  this defense of police officers:


True, police officers do accept increased risks of harm when they take their jobs.  And, of course, their specialized training and ability to assess situations may even affect the way that the law is applied to them in some situations.   But I don’t think it is fair to ask a police officer to value the life of someone else more than his or her own.  A police officer is not obligated to jump into the line of fire to save a civilian.  In any event, it’s hard to know how one would “compel police officers” to act differently under conditions where they believe that their lives are imminently in danger.

It’s not at all clear what Adam expect of cops.  He may be saying that they aren’t required to commit suicide to save a civilian, but that doesn’t tell us what risks they are supposed to assume.  Of course, the notion of risk may be different to a 2002 Stanford Law grad.  I’ve seen a little more.

But then, another lawprof, Rick Hill,  jumped into the fray,  A calmer, more experienced voice?  Not exactly:


But there is perhaps a deeper incoherence in the letter writer’s demand: The difficulty is that police officers can endanger lives through inaction – “restraint” — just as much as through action.

Uh oh.  Rick’s not only in the game, but he’s swinging for the fence.  I didn’t even know that incoherence came in depths.  But Rick’s going for broke by attacking this outrageous letter writer who promotes the radical concept of “restraint”!


Adam is quite correct that it is preposterous to ask cops to take a bullet for civilians: No police force has ever been so saintly – certainly not for the pittance that NYC pays its Finest (starting salary being about 25k). But even if we could somehow induce cops to show a Christ-like inclination to turn the other cheek, should we do so? I would think that such sanctity might very likely cost more civilian lives than it would save.

Well, that begs a questions (aside from the source of his facile assumption). 

How much would we have to pay cops if we expect them to do more than stand around looking cool in their new blue uniform?  How much to take a risk?  How much for a knife?  A gun?  A weapon of mass destruction?

But the secondary point, going a lot further than Adam even considered, is whether we really want cops to show restraint in killing civilians because it “might very likely cost more” lives than it would save.  Sorry.  This being a lawprof and lawprofs being the types of guys to base their ridiculous notions on something, can you spell this out for me a little better Rick?

So if cops stopped shooting and killing innocent people, it would likely mean that more innocent people would die than would be saved?


No, ya moron, that’s not what I’m saying.  I’m saying that if cops are reluctant to pull the trigger when the think it’s necessary, the bad guys will still be alive to go kill civilians.  And they will kill more civilians than the cops will kill by shooting first and asking questions later.

But isn’t it a little different when criminals shoot and kill innocent people than when cop shoot and kill innocent people.  I mean, after all, they are the cops and we did pay for the bullets.  And does the idea that the job of a police officer may someday involve putting him or herself at risk in order to “serve and protect?”  Or are those words incoherent as well?

Or maybe we need to get some new people teaching law school who aren’t dedicated to the proposition that it’s worth a few civilian lives as long as we protect our cops.




No Druggies in College Upheld

Via Bashman, the 8th Circuit has upheld one of the most bizarre and counterproductive laws ever conceived by Congress to make sure that people convicted of a drug crime receive no support in becoming a productive member of society.

From  The School Law Blog, a challenge to the “a federal law that restricts, and in some cases bars, students with drug convictions from participation in federal college aid programs” was rebuffed in Students for Sensible Drug Policy Foundation v. Spellings.  The Circuit rejected the double jeopardy argument, that having completed the sentence imposed, students were then subjected to a secondary penalty of being denied access to college financial aid.

The student group argued that the primary purpose of the law is deterrence of criminal action, so the secondary sanction on those convicted of drug crimes is a form of double jeopardy.  But the court noted that, under the law, a student may restore his or her eligibility for federal student aid by completing a drug-rehabilitation program.

“And the section was enacted as part of the Higher Education Amendments of 1998, which were primarily designed to increase access to college and make it more affordable,” the court said.

Now I’m not necessarily inclined to be dogmatic about how Circuit’s explain their reasoning, but this seems to lack a certain rational flow, even more so than most decisions.

The law, 28 USC 1091(r). is one of those sweet little caveats stuck into the Higher Ed amendments that smacks naughty children across the backside while giving the nice boys and girls a little extra sweetness.  The court’s analysis centered on whether it was a civil or criminal penalty, which is initially based on a determination of whether Congress, by its language, intended it to be a criminal penalty.  By not calling it criminal, it must be civil.

The court’s inquiry then turns to whether it is so punitive that it is criminal despite Congressional intent.  Clearly, a fine objective standard.  This is one of those great rationales, like Congress enacting a law that holds that all thieves should have their hand cut off if they want federal financial aid, but it’s civil because Congress could have required that the whole arm be cut off, thus making it far more punitive than it is.

Under dubious existing precedent, the 8th Circuit’s decision is probably correct, only because of the lack of sound basis for distinguishing between criminal and civil sanctions.  The problem is that law itself is irrational and counterproductive.  Do we not want people who have been convicted of crimes to turn their lives around, become productive and law-abiding members of society and never return to crime?  Then why enact laws to create new hurdles? 

This goes back to the notion that, once a sentence has been served, people have “paid their dues” to society.  While the problem is pervasive with people convicted of sex offenses, which carries at least an arguable (though creating an untenable permanent underclass) reason, there is absolutely no reason for this ongoing assault on people convicted of drug offenses.  Except, to give them an extra little smack for being bad boys and girls.

At Doug Berman’s Sentencing Law & Policy, a commenter rants that the law is irrational and therefore violates the due process clause.  A second commenter notes that when there’s no rational connection between the law and a non-punitive purpose, the entire classification scheme makes no sense, both raise valid points. 

The 8th Circuit decision shows two things quite clearly:  First, the reluctance of a court to do its job in invalidating unconstitutional laws when they can find any hook, no matter how questionable or unreasonable, to uphold it.  And second, that the days when former convicts are allowed to rejoin society after their punishment has been completed are over.  This is a bad decision upholding a very bad law. 

For people who are of the view that anyone convicted of a crime is unworthy of having a life, this probably won’t present a problem.  For everyone else, this is another group to add to the list of society’s rejects whose future potential is to live under bridges or go back to crime.  This is one incredibly stupid law.

Lawyer Fashionista: Jurors Care Too

As you know, I live on the  cutting edge of lawyer fashion, and therefore share some of my insights with those whose attire is less than (uggh) spiffy in the hope that you too can practice law in sartorial splendor like me.  But many lawyers take for granted that while we are under the fashion microscope whenever we step into the courthouse, we are not alone.

San Diego, according to UPI, is a particularly tough place when it comes to courthouse nattiness for all the players in the system.  Ordinarily, the dress for jurors runs the gamut, from suits and ties to dungarees and Ts.  After all, it’s not like courts are inclined to chase potential jurors away, particularly since they are good Americans who have come to do their duty for democracy.

Except for Timothy “Fuzzy” Timms and Mick Rush.  Fine Americans both, they appears at San Diego Superior Court ready to serve.  And were summarily subject to the commands of the fashion police:


Hells Angels members Timothy “Fuzzy” Timms and Mick Rush said sheriff’s deputies escorted them from the San Diego Superior Court’s Hall of Justice after they reported for jury duty and refused orders from the deputies to remove their leather vests, which bear the club’s “death’s head” insignia, the San Diego Union-Tribune reported Tuesday.

After all, there was nothing on the jury summons that said people wearing “colors” need not attend. 

If they were Masons (or Jesters for that matter), and wore a pin or tie tack with their club’s insignia, they would not only have been given a warm welcome, but would possibly have exchanged secret handshakes with the judge.  Why single out the Hell’s Angels for their fashion attack?

It turns out it was all a big mistake, however, by over-zealous vest-haters at the gate.


A court spokeswoman said the Superior Court and the Sheriff’s Department apologized to the two men, saying the ejection was the result of deputies and court officials “misunderstanding” an April 24 order by Superior Judge Jeffrey Fraser.

“He (the judge) does have a case before him involving Hells Angels members and his order applies only to that case and to his courtroom, not to the entire courthouse,” court spokeswoman Karen Dalton said.

Well, you know how confusing those court orders can be, making it nearly impossible for the fashion police to distinguish between your basic motorcycling juror and defendants on trial.


“She apologized and said they were embarrassed, and she sounded very sincere,” Timms said of jury services manager Terri Brewton. “I told her I did not have any complaint about jury officials, but rather I was embarrassed to be surrounded by six deputies and told I had to leave because of my attire.”

That’s right.  Even Hell’s Angels members have feelings, you know.  After all, it’s not like these guys showed up wearing ascots. 

It leaves me to wonder, of course, whether any apology was offered to those defendants picking juries who were denied two fine citizens, just trying to do their duty, as a result of another courthouse fashion faux pas.