Author Archives: SHG

Civil Disobedience Can Start A Revolution

In the little hamlet of Oyster Bay, there is a stately, old town hall with a new slate roof.  Across the parking lot from this edifice reflecting the solidity of government stands a small, dreary brick building.  It houses the office of the Oyster Bay Town Clerk.  This is where the public comes.  Yesterday, the small, dreary brick building was the site of an  act of civil disobedience that bathed it in a glow of importance that made the stately old town hall trivial in comparison. 


About five dozen people stood in a steady rain outside the Oyster Bay clerk’s office yesterday, holding signs and chanting, “Let Dan and Lee Marry,” as an East Hills gay couple applied for a marriage license.

Dan Pinello, 58, and Lee Nissensohn, 50, walked in at 3:30 p.m. and when they walked out nearly two hours later, they each had a ticket for trespassing.

The two men had been prepared to be arrested to make a point about the need for a law in New York that would allow same-sex marriage. But the couple relented and agreed beforehand with town officials to leave once they were ticketed.

“We are law-abiding citizens,” said Pinello, a government professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice. “We pay our taxes. We have no other choice left.”

The two men knew that they would be denied a marriage license.  They knew that they would be given summons, if not arrested, for what they were doing.  So did the town officials, who were fully aware of what was coming and what they could, and could not, do.  The clash was intended, but as Pinello said, they had no other choice left.


While the New York Assembly has passed a bill allowing same-sex marriage, it is tied up in committee in the Senate, where it will stay.

The goal of the couple’s “act of civil disobedience” – as they called it – was to persuade Sen. Carl Marcellino (R-Syosset) to pressure State Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno (R-Brunswick) to take a bill that would allow same-sex marriage to the Senate floor for a vote.

A Marcellino spokeswoman has said the senator supports state law, which says marriage is between a man and a woman. Bruno has said he is against the bill.

The first step to Senate passage would be to get the bill to the floor.  That won’t happen as long as Joe Bruno rules the Senate.  Of course, there’s also the issue of passage even if it made it to the floor, but there’s no point in discussion until it gets out of committee.

Across the northern coasts of the United States, states are attempting to address the issue of gay marriage.  Some deal with it by giving it different names, feeling that by calling a “civil union” or “domestic partnership” they can avoid the religious implications that are the unspoken source of resistance.  After all, who would really care how two consenting adults relate to each other otherwise?  Not your thing?  So what?

This is the current state of the law:


Since 2004, Massachusetts has been the only state to allow same-sex couples to marry.

In 2000, Vermont became the first state to allow same-sex couples to enter into civil unions. Since then, Connecticut (2005), New Jersey (2007) and New Hampshire (2008) have allowed them.

Several states have domestic partnership laws: In Maine (2004) and Washington (2007), same-sex couples have limited rights. In California (2005) and Oregon (2008), partners have nearly all the same rights as married couples.

While our Puritan forefathers are rolling in their graves, changes are coming.  Slowly.  Piecemeal.  Academics discuss the economic implications of marriage, based upon the development of laws relating to property, responsibility and workplace benefits.  Most people don’t think about the “bundle of rights” that come along with the legal union of marriage.  They focus instead on the relatively new ideal that marriage reflects a union of love between two people, and that society denies the meaning of that love when it refuses to recognize a marriage.

It’s highly doubtful that Senators Bruno or Marcellino, both Republicans, will change their views because of yesterday’s act of civil disobedience.  But change is coming, despite their belief.  It’s like a wave that will eventually envelope New York.  Yesterday’s exceptionally well-handled act of civil disobedience may prove to be the pebble that starts the ripples that ultimately spread out and become the tidal wave that overcomes the steadfast resistance to change. 

A revolution may have started in the small, dreary brick building across from the stately, old town hall.  It couldn’t have happened in a more appropriate place.

Cheap Tricks at the Fieger Trial

Two-handed blawger  Norm Pattis has been  detailing the  progress of the Geoffrey Fieger trial.  It has more to do with the fact that his hero, Gerry Spence, who has never lost a criminal trial, is working the room than any particular interest in Fieger or his alleged offense.  Norm watched like a spectator at the cockroach races; hoping to see a fiery crash.

Instead, Norm posts that the government’s case has fallen into the toilet, begrudgingly admitting that it looks like Spence is going to score big.


It appears that Spence and company have the Government on the run in Detroit. After two days of evidence, the defense’s story is well set. Fieger and company had nothing to hide. The lawyers working for Fieger were eager to contribute to John Edwards’ 2004 presidential campaign because Edwards was a fellow trial lawyer doing the people’s work. The firm hid nothing from anyone, even when some 80 federal agents pounced on each and every contributer, going so far as to travel to a college campus to roust a student. In sum, Fieger and his partner, Vernon Johnson, innocently reimbursed folks eager to participate in supporting a fellow lawyer for the common man.

I can picture Norm’s hands trembling as he was compelled to write those words.  How conflicted he must have felt.  But it’s not coming down quite the way that Norm anticipated.


The Government made a key strategic blunder in this case. Twice, they have called as witnesses lawyers who made contributions to Edwards’ campaign while working for Fieger. Both lawyers received gifts from the Government that are rarely given, to wit: immunity from prosecution. This permits the witnesses to say anything they like on the stand without fear of a prosecution for something other than perjury.

As Norm correctly details, the government almost never gives immunity to its witnesses.  Not that it isn’t sought, but you would think that they have to trade off a pay grade for each witness who gets a free pass.  And what did our government get in exchange for this enormous gift?


Today Paul Brochay, a lawyer in Fieger’s firm, testified under a grant immunity. He testified that he agreed to cooperate with the Government only after he learned that federal agents had appeared at his daughter’s apartment at Michigan State University. It was part of an 80 agent sweep, he said, the night of Nov. 30, 2005, a bizarre kristallnacht during which the feds banged on the door of everyone who contributed to the Edwards campaign and was associated with Fieger.

Testimony this good does not come by accident. Brochay, like a witness last week who asserted on cross-examination that he felt no pressure to make a contribution, was a trap waiting to spring. The Government helped set it.

Ouch.  No, ouch isn’t strong enough.  Brochay reached down the prosecutor’s throat and ripped his heart out.  There is no feeling of helplessness quite like your witness testifying that you are totally wrong and the other side is totally right, and that you were a deceitful, cruel animal in the process.

Of course, this was a set-up.  It’s an old lawyer trick that can only be played when a witness gets immunity and sucks the government into believing that he’s their boy.  Once on the stand, he can say anything he pleases, and there is nothing, absolutely nothing, the government can do to stop the words from flowing out of his mouth.  It’s a con game against the government.  Not because the witness’ testimony isn’t true, but because he’s conned the government into putting him on the stand so that he can promptly emasculate its case.

This game doesn’t happen very often.  It requires that all the stars align, and few prosecutors would allow that to happen.  It happened here.  I bet it has more to do with Fieger than Spence, since Fieger is sneakier and would have no reluctance to resorting to cheap tricks.  This would be beneath Spence, who relies instead on the power of his psychodramatic storytelling. 

Of course, there is nothing to stop the government from indicting its erstwhile witnesses for perjury after this trial is over.  The immunity goes to the underlying crime, not lying on the witness stand.  But then, who says they are lying?  Just because their testimony doesn’t agree with what the government wants them to say doesn’t prove perjury (except in the minds of United States Attorneys and District Court Judges). 

Fieger’s lawyers are no doubt prepared to take that risk.  If they have to take a perjury bullet for the boss, they will.  That’s loyalty.  And I bet their families won’t go hungry if they have to some time.  You see, the trick may be cheap, but it’s incredibly effective.  Geoffrey Fieger seems to be a very bottom line guy who appreciates effectiveness, no matter how its accomplished.

Practical Blawgosphere: Lawyers In 3D

War has broken out in the practical blawgosphere.  Naturally, I have to get involved.  The Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, has taken issue with  Shawn Matlock (formerly Young Shawn, but has since earned his wings) of the Fort Worth Matlocks.  The dispute is whether it’s better to have an empathetic criminal defense lawyer or a ruthless one.

Young Shawn Matlock, Fort Worth “Republican” criminal defense lawyer attorney, responds to my position that empathy makes us better lawyers and in doing so asks the following:


But what about ruthless? Ruthless to get exactly what you want. Ruthless to not settle for less. Ruthless to take no prisoners, no matter what the cost to others. Ruthless to the point that everything is just collateral damage.

Now, I assume that Young Shawn intends this at least in part as rhetorical puffery for the paying customers. First, “ruthless” doesn’t guarantee you “exactly what you want”; “ruthless” doesn’t mean “not settling for less”, it means “not having compassion” (maybe Shawn here means “relentless”?).

Even Austin criminal defense lawyer and uber-blawger Jamie Spenser, usually the voice of reason in these internecine Texas horse versus cattle disputes, jumps into the fray asking whether a client should hire a jerk as a lawyer.  There’s nothing like asking a loaded question, right?

Before leaping off the cliff, there’s one predicate detail that must be clarified.  Are lawyers in Texas all one-dimensional?  Why does this argument, built largely on a framework of rhetorical disagreement as to the definition of empathetic, ruthless or jerky, assume that a good lawyer has only one bullet in his six-shooter? 

Bennett’s point, that a criminal defense lawyer who lacks empathy toward others, particularly his client, cannot  function at his best is most definitely true.  While we need not “agree” with out clients’ conduct, we need to appreciate that they are human beings, with inherent failings, who are deserving of our help. 

On the other hand, that does not mean that we must be “enablers” of unlawful conduct, irresponsibility or stupidity.  No, it is not okay to murder people.  It’s not okay to miss court because you had a rough night.  Like a wayward child, we have to feel compassion toward others while recognizing our role in helping clients to become better people than when they first walked in our door.

But that doesn’t mean that we only work in one gear.  There are times when speaking quietly to the prosecutor will be the best tact for accomplishing the goals that will best serve the client.  There are times when getting a little louder is necessary.  There are times when we need to scream at them. 

Bennett rips Matlock for his choice of the word “ruthless”, equating the ruthless lawyer with the sociopath.  That’s a bit extreme, and likely far different than what Matlock intended.  Jamie takes issue with lawyers who promote themselves as “aggressive”, arguing that “competitive” is a better choice.  I don’t see much point in arguing over semantics when the issue is substance.

Matlock’s description of the “ruthless” lawyer is quite harsh:


But what about ruthless? Ruthless to get exactly what you want. Ruthless to not settle for less. Ruthless to take no prisoners, no matter what the cost to others. Ruthless to the point that everything is just collateral damage.

This sounds like the guy who suborns perjury, conceals evidence, lies on his taxes and cheats on his wife.  To ask the question using this definition of ruthless is to invite strong disapproval.  But to the client who wants so desperately to win, the idea of a lawyer with a “take no prisoners” persona probably sounds pretty good.  The gist is that the lawyer will do everything necessary to represent his client.  Many clients want that lawyer.

But why must clients settle for the one dimensional lawyer?  Why can’t the lawyer be empathetic toward his clients, yet aggressive in his representation?  Why can’t the lawyer have a bullet in each chamber of his six-shooter to cover the full panoply of situations, ready to be cooperative when appropriate, ruthless when necessary and everything in between in response to the needs of the case and situation?

I like the word aggressive.  It doesn’t mean acting like a jerk to me, though it can reflect hostile behavior.  But it can also mean vigorous, proactive and bold.  I also like the words “tenacious” and “resolute” in the performance of our duty.  

Descriptions I do not like are “passive”, “foolish” or “complacent”.  These are not words that would ever be used to describe Mark, Shawn or Jamie.  While there may be some differences in how “forgiving” Shawn Matlock may feel toward his clients as compared to Mark Bennett, I have never known a client who would willingly pass up a win for some warm and fuzzy time with his lawyer. 

Yes, most clients want hand-holding from their attorney, as they traverse the cold, scary landscape of a criminal prosecution.  They’re scared and need reassurance, though this too presents some quandaries since what they really want is a guarantee that everything is going to turn out alright.  We can’t give them this guarantee up front, unless we’re prepared to lie through our teeth.  Some lawyers do just that.  Anything for a buck.

But ultimately, clients want their lawyer to be whatever kind of lawyer it takes to obtain the best possible results.  As far as I’m concerned, that means we have to be empathetic, aggressive, competitive, ruthless lawyers.  As needed.

“Writing the Brief,” Excerpts From Scalia’s New Book

At the  ABA Journal (via Bashman), there are some pretty extensive excepts from Justice Antonin Scalia’s and Bryan Garner’s new book, Writing the Brief.

It’s really quite good, and definitely worth a read.  Just a quick quote that I really enjoyed:

Whatever else you do when confronted by a hostile and unreasonable judge, don’t reply in kind. Don’t become hostile yourself; don’t display anger, annoyance or impatience. Keep telling yourself that you owe it to your client—because you do.

Even so, lawyers are entitled to take great delight in the wonderful comeuppances to judicial boorishness that some of their more rash predecessors have devised. Our favorite was also a favorite of Justice Robert H. Jackson. A noted barrister, F.E. Smith, had argued at some length in an English court when the judge leaned over the bench and said: “I have read your case, Mr. Smith, and I am no wiser than I was when I started.”

To which the barrister replied: “Possibly not, My Lord, but far better informed.” Smith, who later became a famous judge as the Earl of Birkenhead, could reportedly carry off such snappy rejoinders with impunity.

Go read the entire excerpt.  You may even want to buy the book!

OT: “Blow” Is Only A Figure of Speech

So this isn’t a criminal law matter, but it’s just too darn funny to pass up.   Eric Turkewitz (of the Park Avenue Turkewitzes) posts about the birth of a fish story.



On a blog called ER Stories, an anonymous individual who calls himself an emergency room doctor in the northeast sets forth this set of facts, but without a single link or method of authentication:

A woman comes into the ER with a claim of a fish bone stuck in her throat, and has an x-ray. The radiologist says its an osteophyte, a small bit of bone. So she gets scoped two days later and, lo and behold, a fish bone comes out, not an osteophyte.

Now the good part, our anonymous doctor continues the story with the good stuff:



A few weeks later, all three doctors get the dreaded “, esq” singed letter – they are being sued for missing the bone. Now, here is the ridiculous part. Her suffering? Severe pain? Infections? Scarring? Worse? No, SHE SUED BECAUSE SHE COULD NO LONGER PERFORM ORAL SEX! Yes, that is right.


And why shouldn’t she, though it would seem that the consortium claim would have been worth more.  One might think physicians are entirely unfamiliar with “benefits” of oral sex. 

But the problem, as this story made the grand rounds of the doctor blogs as part of their proof of the evils of medical malpractice, is that there was nothing to show that this ever happened.


[T]he original story has no case name, no documents or docket number, nor even a state where this allegedly happened.

The original author responded to the challenge of the unsourced material in the comments of Kevin’s blog, in order to “authenticate” the story, with this whopper:


Actually I posted this story. I heard it first hand from a physician (who works with me) who was a partner with the doctor that was sued. He knew the details as they unfolded. Unless he was lying through his teeth to me, it is how it happened.

This was a much better story without the explanation.  Nonetheless, it is painfully clear to me that physicians are either particularly gullible or have no appreciation of the importance of human sexuality.  In either case, this just goes to show that criminal defense lawyers don’t get all the good cases.  Or all the fish stories.

The NACDL Comes to Town

The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers will be holding its  50th Anniversary Gala Celebration this week, May 1-4, in New York City.


NACDL is proud to host its 2008 Spring Meeting and 50th Anniversary Gala in New York City—the world’s most exciting city! As the “city that never sleeps,” New York is an adrenaline-charged haven of unending excitement that holds immense romantic appeal for its visitors. There are a million different New York moments that are just waiting to be had, and what better a time and place to pursue them than with your friends and colleagues at NACDL’s 2008 Spring Meeting and 50th Anniversary Gala?

Chock full of metaphors, there’s still plenty of room for anybody to come and hob nob with the nabobs.  How do I know they’re nabobs?  Because, they’re putting on a CLE entitled “Warriors for the Defense: Trial Techniques from the Masters” 

The Masters!  Wow.  How much better can it get.  No kidding, there are some great lawyers in the group.  Some are masters of their own domain.  CLEs are nothing without a little hyperbole.

But there’s one thing that’s bothering me about this affair.  I’ve never quite understood what the NACDL had to do with the “local” affiliates, and there’s a bunch of them.  It doesn’t do much of anything for the affiliates, other than lend the “cache” of its name.

So why, I wondered, when the NACDL came to town did it put the touch on the local affiliates to pony up the cash to pay for its cocktail party?  When it asked the NYSACDL for money, I wondered what was in it for us.  After all, we have just lost a bundle to mismanagement, raised the members dues to pay for it and proven that enough member of the Board were incapable of the responsibility of caring for other people’s money.  So why kick in for this?

As it turns out, it wasn’t just the NYSACDL that put out.  So too did the New York Criminal Bar Association, the Jersey and Connecticut groups, and even Nassau County Criminal Bar Association. I’m sure these groups are all very impressed with being allowed the opportunity to bask in the reflected glory of the NACDL, “Liberty’s Last Champion.”  I can’t help but wonder how the  New York Council of Defense Lawyers and New York State Defenders Association manage to survive without being an NACDL affiliate.

The answer finally came to me today.  It seems that the members of the association, the ones whose money was gifted to pay for the NACDL cocktail party, are given the great opportunity to pay $50 to go to the cocktail party their money paid for.  On the other hand, the Board of Directors, the ones who approved the gift of the members money, get to go for free.  It’s all become very clear to me. 

I realize that I may be nitpicking these days, but it has all gotten terribly tedious to watch one small group of people happily squander the money entrusted to them by other people without their knowledge.  On the other hand, I truly don’t know that the people whose money is being spent on parties to which they’re not invited really care.  And if they don’t, then what difference does it make that their money is being spent and they derive no benefit from it whatsoever.  You get what you deserve.

A Prosecutor’s Eyes Wide Shut

While I keep an eye on some prosecutor blogs, you can’t watch everything in the blawgosphere anymore since there are just too many these days.  I’m not complaining, just stating my reality.  So when this post came along over the weekend from Western Justice, I had no idea until  Ken Lammers and  Gideon did their thing.

The post opens with a quote from the most dubious of sources:

“The defendant wants to hide the truth because he’s generally guilty. The defense attorney’s job is to make sure the jury does not arrive at that truth.”

Alan Dershowitz

It’s not the first  incredibly stupid thing that Dershowitz has had to say.  The source is a 1982 article in U.S. News & World Reports, according to Wikiquote.  While the context is unclear, it’s sufficiently stupid to stand as a representative expression of Dershowitz’s latent self-loathing.

With this intro, WJ launches into a “theory” that defense attorneys are “lie promoters.”


Now, most defense attorneys will not ask their clients for a full, detailed version of what actually happened. But let’s say their client comes in, and tells them everything that happened–down to the very last detail, and those details are essentially–I’m guilty, I did it, and everything in the police reports is true.

Under that limited scenario, when a defense attorney goes into court, questions the jury during voir dire, presents an opening statement, cross examines witnesses, and maybe even calls a few witnesses himself, and then argues in closing not just that the District Attorney did not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, but that there are several other reasonable alternatives as to what might have happened, are defense attorneys lie promoters?

Let’s start at the top.  Who says most defense attorneys don’t ask their clients for a “full, detailed version of what actually happened?”  I’m unaware of Western Justice having any experience as a defense attorney, or having taken a survey.  Interesting that the theory beings on an unfounded assumption.

Then, the theory proceeds under the silly hyperbolic argument that everything the cops say happened is “exactly” what happened, “down to the very last detail.”  This has never happened in my 25 years of lawyering, but frankly is immaterial.  The very last detail is the “color” of the situation, not the crux of the crime.  If the cops get the critical facts right and establish the elements of the offense, then we have a guilty defendant.

But this is where we separate the men from the boys.  Western Justice, after giving examples worthy of the finest misdemeanor assistant, asks:


Is he not promoting the lie by arguing it to the jury, and submitting it as the actual truth, when he knows full well how incredulous that “truth” is?

This is the cocktail party question, the one that typically follows “how can you defend those criminals?”  It comes somewhere after the spinach dip and your third vodka.  This is the question that makes lawyers (not necessarily law professors like Dershowitz who like to play all side against the middle just in case a TV show needs a comment) wince.

Criminal defense lawyers don’t argue what the “truth” is, unless they want to end up like  this guy (note that he became a defense lawyer after 32 years as a prosecutor).  We argue that the prosecution has not proven guilt.  Whether you want to frame it as putting the prosecution to its proof doesn’t matter.  Our job is to make the government work for its convictions.

But the galling aspect of this “theory” is the implicit assumption that it is the defendant who is inclined to play with the “truth”.  I can’t count the number of times some kid prosecutor confuses himself with being Odie to some cop’s Garfield, lapping up whatever story the cop feeds him as if it’s gospel.  What makes prosecutors believe, truly believe, that they aren’t getting fed a slab of beef surrounded by a garnish of utter fabrication?  This “my cop would never lie” attitude is the mark of naiveté.  Cops treat kid prosecutors like the village idiot, too stupid to recognize tailored testimony if their life depended on it.

So is it more fulfilling to claim ownership of the “truth” when it’s the product of child-like self-righteousness?  One side has an ethical duty to do justice.  The other had a duty to defend a person.  That’s the way the system is supposed to work, and to think that there’s one side that owns the truth is just silly.

The Charming Nino Scalia

Any criminal defense lawyer who missed Antonin Scalia on 60 Minutes last night is nuts.  Rarely does one get to see a fellow charm the pants off of Leslie Stahl to begin with, and a Supreme Court Justice at that.  How could you pass up this opportunity?

Orin has already linked the interview for us:


“60 Minutes” Interviews Justice Scalia: Part 1 is here, and Part 2 is here. I thought Part 2 was particularly engaging and worth watching.

No doubt there will plenty of descriptions and commentaries around today about it.  Indeed, plenty of blawgers were busily typing away about it last night so that this morning it was already all over the blawgosphere.  But that’s not going to stop me from having my say as well.

There was something about Justice Scalia’s attitude in the face of criticism of his originalist philosophy that reminded me of Rumsfeld and Karl Rove.  If he was unpleasant, I would call is smugness or arrogance.  But he wasn’t unpleasant.  He was incredibly normal and occasionally charming and funny. 

There was a protective coating that surrounded Justice Scalia that gave him the internal assurance that he is right and anyone who disagrees with him is wrong.  It’s not a matter of discussion.  He is not to be persuaded otherwise.  He is the persuader.  It is his job to convince others that they are wrong.  He need only listen to the extent necessary to point out the error of others.  He will not be moved.  He is right. 

Scalia admitted openly that he is a “law and order” guy.  That’s quite an admission for a Supreme.  He argues that despite his being a law and order guy, his job is to decide what the Constitution says, and that it has no impact on his decisions.  This is the sort of self-serving reasoning that immunizes overt bias, just because he says so.  It seemed beneath his intellect to assert that he is openly biased but is so wonderfully capable that he always rises above it.

Of course, Justice Scalia has authored from of the most shockingly important defense decisions since the Warren Court, based upon his originalist philosophy,  Crawford for example.  But then his reaction to Stahl’s suggestion that Bush v. Gore was a political decision was, well, silly.  His response was “it wasn’t” and “get over it.”  Well, that’s convincing.

Most revealing was Scalia’s argument that torture isn’t prohibited by the 8th Amendment because “it isn’t punishment.”  Torture, for the purpose of obtaining information, is not punishment, the specific word used in the Constitution, thus meaning that the Constitution does not speak to torture at all and therefore doesn’t prohibit it.  To say his understanding of the word “punishment” is a tad narrow is to insult the literal understanding of third graders.  They know punishment.  And it’s torture.

He claims to abhor torture (what that means), but consistent with his statements of philosophy throughout the interview, that doesn’t mean that the Constitution addresses it and that everything we hate is somehow prohibited by the Constitution.  That, Scalia says, is why we have laws.

I can’t help but wonder if our founding fathers would have done things a little differently had they anticipated the judicial philosophical of Justice Scalia.  While no originalist can tell us what every person involved in the creation, revision, execution and ratification of the Constitution had inside their heads as they did so, I can imagine the argument that might have happened in 1887 1787.


But Madison, we need to include something that says that the Constitution should be interpreted in light of future changes in society, from technology to society’s vision of justice, or somebody may think that we have somehow anticipated everything that will ever happen from today until the end of time, and covered it based upon what we know now.

You have got to be kidding, Jefferson.  Who could possibly be that stupid?

Justice Scalia says he gets tired of repeating himself.  I understand.  I feel the same way.

For those who missed the interview, enjoy.


What Do 100 Blacks Know?

There is a group in New York called 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care.  This is one of the boldest initiatives by anyone in law enforcement that I’m aware of, because these are people who have broken away from that great blue wall that we all know about.  It takes enormous guts to challenge the status quo when you depend upon others for back up.  They’ve taken the risk.

Yesterday, Norman Siegel, former head of the New York Civil Liberties Union, stood in front of 1 Police Plaza and called on Governor David Paterson to make reforms in the aftermath of the Sean Bell killing.  From Newsday,


Earlier in the day, Siegel called on Gov. David A. Paterson to help bring about the reforms Siegel says are needed in the system that prosecutes officers. He spoke at a news conference outside 1 Police Plaza in Manhattan, flanked by Sen. Eric Adams (D-Brooklyn) and members of the group 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care

Chief among those changes, they said, is a permanent special prosecutor to handle any fatal shooting or allegations of corruption by a police officer.

Sen. Adams is a former police captain.  He is black.  He is “working on legislation that would give the state attorney general responsibility for crime scenes after any police shooting, not the department involved.”

What is curious is that the two of the police officers who first at Sean Bell were black as well.  To some, this would indicate that race wasn’t a factor.  But 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care know better, and that’s why they, essentially alone amongst police, stand up against their brothers. 

Police officers will say that race had nothing to do with what happened to Sean Bell.  And they will believe what they say.  They will tell you that it wasn’t white against black, it was cops against criminals.  This goes back to the absolute belief that no one understands what a cop does except another cop.  This belief is so firmly ingrained in the NYPD culture that it is beyond discussion. 

But somehow, some way, 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care were able to see beyond this internal culture of us against them.  They came to realize that what happens between law enforcement and the African American community is different.  They have rejected the mentality that all black civilians are presumably perps, against whom one must be on guard and vigilant. 

These “accidental” shootings don’t seem to happen too frequently on Park Avenue.  The official explanation is that people on Park Avenue don’t tend to commit crimes too frequently, and hence don’t draw police scrutiny or fire.  It may be true.  After all, there’s not much reason for investment bankers to commit street crimes when they can do so in the privacy of their paneled office. 

But this argument conceals the troubling belief that permeates law enforcement, the belief that blacks are criminals.  This is what 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care are trying to fight.  To change.  They are trying to keep black men, women and children alive.  They are trying to stop them from being killed by bullets discharged from service weapons. 

And what about the reforms?

Why did it take this long to realize that the county district attorneys offices are ill-equipped to prosecute police officers?  Everyone is smarter after the fact, naturally, but the conflict that manifested itself in ADA Charlie Testagrossa’s handling of the trial has long been apparent.  I wrote about it here.  Whether an standing office of special prosecutor would be enough to change anything is questionable.  It’s a start, but it’s not enough.

The special prosecutor still relies on the police to investigate and manage the forensics.  If the police investigate the police, the opportunity for mischief still exists.  Unless a special prosecutor will come with a special police department to do the legwork, he will still rely on the cooperation and integrity of local cops to do the job. 

But even if we assume that the special prosecutor will not be influenced by conflicted reliance on law enforcement, and cops will do their job even when it’s against other cops, there is a problem that has yet to be confronted:  The law is designed to prosecute civilians who break the law.  The law is not designed to prosecute police officers who shoot and kill people.

The defense in the Sean Bell trial was justification, that the officers were justified in the use of deadly force because of a reasonable fear that their lives were threatened.  This defense is nearly impossible for any defendant to use successfully, since the hurdle of a reasonable fear of threat is extremely high.  Except when it comes to cops.  And cops have guns.  And cops are entitled to use those guns when they believe they are threatened. 

Cops are allowed a latitude in protecting and defending themselves that no one would be allowed.  It makes sense, since cops find themselves the object of threatening conduct because of their job and on a regular basis.  If they can’t protect themselves, we could have a lot of dead or injured cops on our hands.  That’s not a good thing either.  Cops must be allowed to protect themselves in order to do their job and go home when their shift is over.

No one else is given this degree of latitude, either in assessing potential threats against them or acting to defend themselves against a perceived threat.  Consider the case of John White.  Claims of justification are scrutinized to death when it’s a civilian who employs it.  Civilians are not supposed to take the law into their own hands.  That’s what cops are supposed to do.

The real problem underlying the Sean Bell case is the one understood by 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care.  The problem is that cops, whether white or black or green, perceive African Americans as an inherent threat, as presumed miscreants, and will pull the trigger when they wouldn’t if the person was white.  There is simply a greater reluctance to fire at a white person than a black person.  Until that cultural view toward African Americans changes, we will continue to have cases like Sean Bell.

The solution isn’t to convict cops who shoot and kill black men, but to stop wrongfully shooting and killing black men before it happens.  No special prosecutor will accomplish this.  Our best chance is 100 Blacks in Law Enforcement Who Care working to change the culture from the inside.  These are 100 brave people.

FOR ANYONE STILL READING THIS, here’s a fun little blast from the past.  Read  this 2002 NYT Op-Ed following the exoneration of the 4 police officers who shot and killed Amadou Diallo.  We get older each year.  So does the story.

Actions, Reactions, Over-reactions

Via Walter Olson at Overlawyered, this story from the London Independent, a story that brings pain to my already at-risk chest.  Trees, nearly 40,000 of them, some 100 years old, felled in London because of . . . (gasp) lawyers.  Well, there had to be a reason that Walter took note of the story.

I love trees.  Ask  Bennett and he’ll tell you.  I’ve got about 5 acres of woods on my property.  Lots and lots of trees. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again.  I am a tree-hugger, and proud of it.

So when I saw that London lawyers were cutting down trees, I was aghast and had to read the story for myself. 

Yet there is growing evidence that healthy mature trees are being felled by risk-averse insurers and councils because of the mere suspicion that they may affect neighbouring properties with subsidence, or fall on people.

In the past five years, London councils alone have chopped down almost 40,000 street trees, including some more than 100 years old. Some were aged, diseased or dying, but 40 per cent were removed because of insurance claims; yet a report commissioned by the London Assembly said that only 1 per cent of tree-removals were justified.

Wait a second.  I had the picture of guys in wigs and black robes carrying huge axes and cutting away at any tree in their path.  As it turns out, the story is just a wee bit different.

There are no London barristers in their bespoke suits cutting down trees.  There are London politicians cutting down trees.  Why?  Because it’s easier to butcher trees wholesale than use one’s head and understand problems and solutions.  It’s always easier to blame lawyers for making you do something stupid than taking responsibility for being lazy and taking the easy way out.

Trees are living.  Trees grow.  They age.  They need care.  Trees need to be trimmed from time to time to keep old, dead limbs from falling and hitting people on the noggin.  This isn’t a tough concept, but it’s work to pay attention to the needs of trees and care for them.  Sometimes, especially in city venues, trees need more care than they would in a field were they stand proud and alone.  If they are hungry, they need to be fed.  If they are thirsty, they need a drink.  And if they are inches away from a building (and one should ask who was the genius who planted the tree next to the building or built the building so close to the tree), they need particular attention.

But don’t blame the lawyers.  The lawyers didn’t tell you to kill all the trees.  The lawyers expect that you take care of them so they don’t fall on their clients.  Regardless of the lawyers (and this is the point), the trees need to be loved and cared for. 

The fact that those who make brilliant decisions on behalf of the public have chosen not to take an individualized look at trees to address their needs, but would rather chop them all down wholesale, is not the lawyers’ fault.  There is an action (i.e., dead limb falls on nice person), and a reaction (trim dead limbs) and an over-reaction (cut down all trees on the face of the earth).

If you don’t like the way mass-clearing of trees is happening, and I don’t, then blame the idiots who would rather take the simpleton’s route of getting rid of all the trees and blaming it on lawyers than react properly and appropriately be addressing the particular needs of the trees.  

Too much work to look at each tree individually, you say?  Then you end up with an earth barren of trees.  But then it’s your fault that you don’t want to put in the effort to do it right, not the lawyers.  Walter, you can’t blame the lawyers because over-reacting is easier than reacting. 

If there’s a diseased tree, a dangerous tree, then address it or, in absolutely necessary, cut it down.  There are times this is necessary.  But don’t butcher trees because it’s easier than thinking.  What a horrible waste.