Author Archives: SHG

Anticipating the Sean Bell Verdict

While I’m not inclined to discuss what will happen, since whatever is going to come with verdict expected tomorrow will come regardless of what I have to say, a post by Elaine Chiu at Co-Op appears to anticipate the no matter what comes our of Judge Cooperman’s mouth, it’s wrong by her.


Yet, as the prosecutors have made clear, the justification defense does not cover all fifty shots en masse, but rather law enforcement agents have an obligation to stop using deadly force as soon as their reasons for doing so dissipate. In other words, each shot has to be justified. In the heat of the moment though it is rather clear that the police officers did not reassess their need to use deadly force after each shot. Indeed, Officer Oliver who shot 31 times admits that he did not reassess until he ran out of ammunition and only reassessed at that moment because he had no other choice but to do so.

This was an argument, not a thing to be “made clear.”  More importantly, it’s an argument that only a lawprof could love.   Even an appellate judge would blush before trying to push this one on the panel.  And as any cop will tell you, they fire until they’re done firing.  If the shoot is righteous, then it’s good to the last drop.

It’s not the Chiu is technically wrong.  Indeed, the use of deadly force is permissible only as long as justified.  It’s that there is no practical way to tell where the line is in the middle of the gunfight.  Is she arguing that each officer should fire one shot, stop, check to see what’s happening at that moment, then decide whether it’s appropriate to fire another shot? 

This argument would easily come into play if the officers fired, stopped firing, assessed the situation and then, without justification, decided to start firing again for fun.  But in the hail of bullets, no finder of fact, whether judge or jury, is going to convict the cops if they believe the first bullet was justified and there was no break, or “thing” that happened in the midst of firing, that made it absolutely clear to the cops that the need to shoot had ended.


So what really happened here? Perhaps the police officers were justified in their initial shots but what about the later shots? A more complicated story emerges. Instead of only the reasonable use of deadly force, it is possible that panic and shock and reflex also played a part. I blogged on this point last year at PrawfsBlawg. Unfortunately, the doctrine and practice of criminal law rejected more nuanced understandings of defendants and more appropriate defense strategies that combine both justification and excuse.

I’m unfamiliar with a defense strategy called “excuse”.  Frankly, I fail to understand what difference it makes, except to those in the academy who need to give names to things that happen regularly and implicitly in criminal proceedings, whether the defense recognized its strategy to be nuanced or not.  If they get a not guilty verdict, even for their un-nuanced effort, they will go home happy.

As for the more nuanced understandings between criminal law doctrine and practice, we can barely get a judge to go along with the concept of due process, no less more academic nuances.  I can appreciate that lawprofs ponder these things to a degree that makes us poor grunts in the trenches seem utterly ignorant, since they can’t write scathing articles stretching over 25 pages unless they delve deeply, deeply into the underlying nuance. 

But what bothers me about Chiu’s analysis is that it criticizes a real case, and the work of real lawyers and a real judge, in anticipation of a verdict that will invariably be wrong because of its intellectually messy framework. 

That’s how cases are tried and decided in the trenches.  It’s done with a club, not a scalpel.  It’s messy and ugly.  There is nothing nuanced about trial level courts.  There never has been.  On appeal, when lawyers and judges have all day to ponder these critically important questions of theory, criticize them all you want.  But don’t jump down anyone’s throat about what happens in the trenches because it wasn’t sufficiently nuanced.

The Scoundrel Among Us

This story, via the  New York Lawyer and the Monterey County Herald, is the sort that makes my blood boil.  On the blawgs, we talk about the efforts of criminal defense lawyers in the face of adversity, as if we were all fighting for truth and justice for our clients.  Then comes a story about the other side of the criminal defense bar, the ones who grab the cash and leave the defendant to dangle in the wind.

RANCHO CUCAMONGA, Calif.—The State Bar has charged a San Bernardino County criminal defense lawyer with taking thousands of dollars from clients, then abandoning them. William Gebbie surrendered his law license after filing of the 28-count complaint, which accused him of allowing a client to sit in jail for months even though he had evidence to clear the man.

The Rancho Cucamonga-based attorney, who practiced for 38 years in San Bernardino, Riverside and Los Angeles counties, declined comment on Tuesday.

The State Bar says Gebbie improperly withdrew from cases, failed to return unearned fees and collected “unconscionable” fees, among other things.

The most serious accusation involved Gebbie’s handling of a case against Donald Stephens, whose wife paid the lawyer a $10,000 advance to handle a felony sex case. Stephens sat in jail even though Gebbie had evidence clearing him.

I’m sure some truly imaginative person out there can come up with a handful of excuses to explain away this conduct.  It doesn’t matter.  If he couldn’t perform, then it was his obligation to hand off the case, and the money, to someone who could. 

I’m going to jump to a conclusion here, that Gebbie (a 38 year vet!) wasn’t giving back that $10 grand no matter what, and that was the root of the problem.  Whatever stood between Gebbie and doing his job is irrelevant.  He had the client’s cash and he wasn’t letting go.  The client’s wife was $10,000 in the hole, and likely incapable of affording a new attorney without a refund.  And Gebbie wasn’t giving anything back.  Not a dime.

This is the sort of conduct that brings lawyers, in general, and the criminal defense bar, in particular, into disrepute, and deservedly so.  So Gebbie was disbarred?  Not good enough.  He absolutely should have been disbarred, as he had no right to continue to enjoy the privilege of practicing law. 

But what he did, taking the money and leaving the defendant languishing in jail goes far beyond mere disbarment.  He was responsible for larceny and false imprisonment.  The fact that the defendant was innocent is certainly significant, but even if the defendant was guilty as sin it wouldn’t make a difference.  The duty of the criminal defense lawyer is to defend.  His failure to either serve his client or get off the case and return the fee is an outrage.  He’s an old man?  He had problems?  Too bad.  If he can’t hack it, get out of the business, but don’t ever think that this is excusable conduct by a criminal defense lawyer.

Ashcroft: Mean or Just Stupid?

One has to wonder what compelled John Ashcroft, the Senator who Missourians preferred less than a dead man, to go to Knox College, described as a liberal arts college with the emphasis on liberal.  Perhaps the $15,000 had something to do with it?

From the Daily Kos comes this incredible account of Ashcroft’s speech and subsequent Q&A with the students.  You really need to read the whole piece, which takes you from the pre-Ashcroft campus atmosphere, through introduction and speech, to the question and answer period that followed.  But this will give you an idea of the tone:


ME: First off, Mr. Ashcroft, I’d like to apologize for the rudeness of some of my fellow students.  It was uncalled for–we can disagree civilly, we don’t need that. (round of applause from the audience, and Ashcroft smiles)  I have here in my hand two documents.  One of them, you know, is the text of the United Nations Convention against Torture, which, point of interest, says nothing about “lasting physical damage”…

ASHCROFT: (interrupting) Do you have the Senate reservations to it?

ME: No, I don’t.  Do you happen to know what they are?

ASHCROFT: (angrily) I don’t have them memorized, no.  I don’t have time to go around memorizing random legal facts.  I just don’t want these people in the audience to go away saying, “He was wrong, she had the proof right in her hand!”  Because that’s not true.  It’s a lie.  If you don’t have the reservations, you don’t have anything.  Now, if you want to bring them another time, we can talk, but…

ME: Actually, Mr. Ashcroft, my question was about this other document. (laughter and applause)  This other document is a section from the judgment of the Tokyo War Tribunal.  After WWII, the Tokyo Tribunal was basically the Nuremberg Trials for Japan.  Many Japanese leaders were put on trial for war crimes and crimes against humanity, including torture.  And among the tortures listed was the “water treatment,” which we nowadays call waterboarding…

ASHCROFT: (interrupting) This is a speech, not a question.  I don’t mind, but it’s not a question.

ME: It will be, sir, just give me a moment.  The judgment describes this water treatment, and I quote, “the victim was bound or otherwise secured in a prone position; and water was forced through his mouth and nostrils into his lungs and stomach.”  One man, Yukio Asano, was sentenced to fifteen years hard labor by the allies for waterboarding American troops to obtain information.  Since Yukio Asano was trying to get information to help defend his country–exactly what you, Mr. Ashcroft, say is acceptible for Americans to do–do you believe that his sentence was unjust? (boisterous applause and shouts of “Good question!”)

ASHCROFT: (angrily) Now, listen here.  You’re comparing apples and oranges, apples and oranges.  We don’t do anything like what you described.

ME: I’m sorry, I was under the impression that we still use the method of putting a cloth over someone’s face and pouring water down their throat…

ASHCROFT: (interrupting, red-faced, shouting) Pouring!  Pouring! Did you hear what she said?  “Putting a cloth over someone’s face and pouring water on them.”  That’s not what you said before!  Read that again, what you said before!

ME: Sir, other reports of the time say…

ASHCROFT: (shouting) Read what you said before! (cries of “Answer her fucking question!” from the audience)  Read it!

ME: (firmly) Mr. Ashcroft, please answer the question.

ASHCROFT: (shouting) Read it back!

ME: “The victim was bound or otherwise secured in a prone position; and water was forced through his mouth and nostrils into his lungs and stomach.”

ASHCROFT: (shouting) You hear that?  You hear it?  “Forced!”  If you can’t tell the difference between forcing and pouring…does this college have an anatomy class?  If you can’t tell the difference between forcing and pouring…

ME: (firmly and loudly) Mr. Ashcroft, do you believe that Yukio Asano’s sentence was unjust?  Answer the question. (pause)

ASHCROFT: (more restrained) It’s not a fair question; there’s no comparison.  Next question! (loud chorus of boos from the audience)

This is destined to be a classic.  Even Keith Oberman picked it up, naming Ashcroft a “Worse” Person in the World.

Cop Busted By Fed-Up Attorney

Has it ever bothered you to watch a cop speed down the road for no particular reason, or blow through a red light when he feels like it.  What about parking illegally just because he can?

It bothered Seattle attorney Eric Bryant.  According to the Seattle Times, via Orin at Volokh, Bryant did something about it.

Eric Bryant said he was sitting at the restaurant March 7 when Officer Chad Stensgaard parked his patrol car next to a no-parking sign and walked inside to wait for his food, the Portland Mercury reported Thursday.

Bryant told the weekly paper that when he asked Stensgaard about his car, the officer asked Bryant, “If someone broke into your house, would you rather have the police be able to park in front of your house or have to park three blocks away and walk there?”

Bryant filed a complaint as a private citizen alleging several violations, including illegal parking and illegal operation of an emergency vehicle.

Stensgaard was issued a summons to appear in traffic court in May. The fines could total $540.

Talk about taking your life into your own hands.  It’s like painting a target on your forehead.  But Bryant apparently had enough of police officers using their office to skirt the very rules that the rest of us are required to obey.

“Citizens should be concerned that he used his status as an officer of the law as justification for breaking the law,” Bryant said.

The police, naturally, see it differently.

Cathe Kent, a spokeswoman for the Portland Police Bureau, said Stensgaard would fight the complaint in court, “as he rightfully should.”

In fairness, there are some good reasons why police engage in what appears to be unlawful conduct.  If Stensgaard has gotten an emergency call while waiting for his food, requiring his immediate response, and needed to respond immediately, it makes sense that his car was right in front of the restaurant.

Similarly, police often respond to lower grade calls at a high rate of speed, and going through traffic lights, under circumstances that don’t require full lights and sirens since they aren’t in pursuit.  The problem is that these aren’t always the case, and almost every driver is aware of cops who do it just because they can.

I’ve known a number of people who enjoy driving around in RMPs with the lights on to get a quick cup of coffee, or just have a little fun at the public’s expense.  I’ve known a number of cops who mistake their shield for a Mastercard, doing the same in their private cars with the expectation that their brothers in blue will show a little professional courtesy.  For them, it’s a perk of the job, and as one commenter at Volokh wrote, if you could, you would do it too. 

Most people are under the mistaken belief that vehicle and traffic laws don’t apply to police and emergency vehicles.  That’s incorrect.  While they are exempt when required by the performance of their duty, the rest of the time they are expected to follow the law just like the rest of us.  If it’s dangerous for us, it’s dangerous for them as well.  There’s only one huge difference:  Who’s going to stop them?  Apparently, Eric Bryant will.

Orin Kerr asks whether this is an example of a lawyer at his best or worst.  Even the overwrought, over competitive readers of Volokh tended to approve of Bryant’s move, and similarly tended to disapprove of the cop mentality that breaking “little” laws was a fringe benefit. 

Should cops be able to ignore the laws that apply to the rest of us?  Is this an acceptable perk of the job?  And if so, where does it stop?  The next time you see a cop speeding down the road, blowing through a traffic light, will you assume he’s on an “aided” call, or that the donuts just came out of the oven?



Shocking Turnaround, Yates Declines Albany Post

I  reported a few weeks ago that Jim Yates, Manhattan Supreme Court Justice, had been named by Governor David Paterson as his Counsel.  Yesterday, in a shocking turnaround, Yates declined the position.

According to the New York Times, Jim Yates said that he realized that being a judge was his “true calling,”


“I very much would have enjoyed the opportunity to serve the governor and his administration, but serving as a judge is a position that I love, and that I find too hard to leave,” Mr. Yates said.

From a political and “career advancement” point of view, this is a very surprising position.  Jim Yates has been on the short list for a Court of Appeals appointment many times, but never got the nod under the Pataki administration.  His return to Albany in the powerful position of Governor’s Counsel would have given him the inside track for the next opening on the Court, and certainly the governor’s ear on matters of criminal justice reform, long a subject of interest for Yates.

Reaction by Joe Lentol, Brooklyn Assemblyman, sums it up pretty well:


“This is going to be one of the biggest losses for the administration that I can think of,” said Assemblyman Joseph R. Lentol, a Brooklyn Democrat. “Jim Yates is one of the smartest people I’ve ever known. For him not to be in the governor’s office will not be good for the state — he’s that good.”

Until a new counsel is name, David M. Nocenti, counsel under Spitzer, will remain as interim.  According to New York Magazine, state senator Eric Schneiderman and Robert Morgenthau protégé Dan Castleman are now the leading candidates. 

I have to agree strongly with Joe Lentol.  Losing Jim Yates in Albany will be a major loss for the state.  He’s that good.  But I wonder what really happened.  Nobody loves being a judge that much, and there’s far more that could be accomplished by a few years in Albany than in one courtroom in Manhattan.  I doubt we’ll ever know the real reason, and hope that at least Jim Yates makes it back to Albany to the Court of Appeals on the next round.

H/T Turk

Why Is It So Difficult to Execute Someone?

A great op-ed in the  New York Times by Gilbert King detailing the sordid history of failed and botched executions following each of humankind’s new and improved methods.

King’s detailed stories are significant because they reflect the backstory to the decisions relied upon in some of the plurality opinions in Base v. Rees.


In its ruling last week, the court once more ignored the consequences of its rulings for men like Wallace Wilkerson, William Kemmler and Willie Francis. The justices cited and applied Wilkerson’s and Kemmler’s cases as if their executions went off without a hitch.

Supreme Court decisions will do that, you know.  As will some other courts as well.  The trick is to sanitize all the facts that don’t conform with, or support, the conclusion and pretend that they never happened.  If you leave the bad facts out of the decision, you end up with a little piece of stare decisis prepackaged for use the next time someone complains.  Then they can say, “but we have precedent, and we certainly can’t go against precedent.  That would be wrong.”

But I can’t help but continue to ask, has our knowledge of medicine and anatomy lagged so far behind everything else scientific that no one has as yet come up with a painless, immediate and definitive way to execute someone? 

We’ve got drugs for irritable bowel syndrome.  We’ve got drugs for restless leg syndrome.  We’ve got drugs for erectile dysfunction (whatever that is).  Are you telling me that we don’t have a drug that can guarantee to kill a person?

What about a massive overdose of heroin?  Not only will he die, but he’ll be euphoric in the process.  What about a bullet to the back of the head while he’s sleeping, point blank range?  Ugly but effective.  Make federal buildings taller and toss him off the roof.  If there’s 50 ways to leave your lover, how many are there to put someone to death?

And yet here we are, with the latest word from the Supremes still ringing in our ears, that lethal injection is the best we can do, or at least good enough to pass constitutional muster.


And 60 years after two drunken executioners disregarded the tortured screams of a teenage boy named Willie Francis, the Supreme Court continues to do so.

They really need to write more factually accurate decisions.

New York, The Law School State

I’ve long taken the position that one of the primary problems with lawyer over-reaching, ethical issues and just plain diminishing revenues is that fact that we have too many lawyers.  And if we have too many in general, you can bet that New York, the lawyer haven of the world, has too many in particular.

So what’s New York going to do about it?  What else, build more law schools!

According to this Newsday story, the budget just passed by the Legislature, the one that didn’t have enough money to give raised to judges, has $50 million in there to develop three new law schools.


The state budget passed by the Legislature earlier this month includes more than $50 million for developing law schools in the Rochester and Binghamton areas and on Long Island. The Rochester school would be affiliated with St. John Fisher College, a private school in suburban Pittsford, while the SUNY system’s Binghamton and Stony Brook universities would get their own law schools.

What’s a branch of SUNY (State University of New York) without a law school, right?  Second string. Worthless.  A loser school. 

So why do we need 3 more law schools in New York?


“I have no idea why the state would consider three more law schools,” said Thomas Guernsey, dean of Albany Law School. “There’s no evidence in the job market that we need more than those 15 schools.”

The bar association reports that about 7,700 people passed the New York bar exam in July 2007. With several thousand people passing the exam each year, there’s no shortage of lawyers, Guernsey said.

So there’s no shortage of lawyers (duh), and the law deans don’t think we need them.  Then why?

A state lawmaker who pushed for the St. John Fisher funding in the state budget says a law school, if located in downtown Rochester, would give the city a much-needed economic boost.

“This is really about improving regionalism and improving Rochester’s academic landscape and career opportunities,” said state Senator Joseph Robach, a Republican from suburban Greece.

(For those of you who didn’t realize the suburban Greece is a part of New York, it’s just a hop, skip and jump away from suburban Rome.)

Well, like I always say, if it’s good for downtown Rochester…

“But This Other Guy…” and Other Fine Questions

Brother Norm Pattis, of the Connecticut Pattis’, writes about the phone call.  You know the phone call.  It’s the one where the defendant’s mother, wife or baby mama calls to ask you why you can’t get her man the deal that this other guy got.


A client’s mother called. How could I justify the fact that the state was offering her son such a heavy sentence? He had not hurt anyone? Indeed, the state wanted more time from her son that for the murderer she read about in the newspaper. That guy killed someone, and all he got was three years. How can the state want her son to serve more time than a murderer?

Anyone who hasn’t gotten the call hasn’t practiced criminal defense law for more than a week.  Somewhere out there in the ether, there’s a lawyer getting his clients deals that are just miraculous.  Three years for murder?  Now that’s a deal.  Why can’t you get those deals? 

Of course, rarely does the caller get the facts right.  In fact, they are almost always about a hundred miles away from reality.  Often, the story comes from a chat on a street corner with some other person who heard from her neighbor about her cousin’s nephew who knew a guy, etc., etc.  You get the picture.

As Norm points out, it’s a tough call to address.  After the 500 time you hear this, it loses its charm.  One gets tired of deconstructing a story which may or may not have any factual basis at all, and then explaining the intricacies of the criminal justice system.  Such as evidence, as in they give better plea offers to people against whom the evidence is decidedly thin versus your son’s case, where they have him on videotape from 27 different angles.

But neither mama nor baby mama want to hear any of this.  If you’re not getting a deal like 3 years for murder, then it’s your fault, not the defendant’s, nor the prosecutor’s, nor the cop’s, nor the judge’s, nor the videotapes. 

These stories create expectations that real lawyers can’t meet.  Because they are born of emotion, they cannot be adequately address through rational explanation.  The fact is that clients and their families argue with their own lawyers as if we are the stumbling blocks to a successful defense.  We inexplicably are stopping them from getting a sweet deal.  If they just convince us to get them the deal, then we’ll get it for them.

Norm, in a transitory fit of kindness, chose not to slam the phone down on its cradle.  Instead, he chose to meet with the client and as many family members as the client chose to let into the room.  He planned to point out that the defendant’s mother was right, but that the defendant’s case reflected a misguided policy toward people who solicit 14 year olds on the internet, which is deemed worse than murder these days.

Like Norm, I too am sympathetic to the concerns of family.  I too agree that sentencing policy is often unduly harsh, and that prosecutors frequently beat up on those they can because of good evidence to compensate for their feelings of inadequacy when someone gets away just because they have no evidence of guilt.  There is little fair about how this system works.

But I prefer to take this a step further.  Without context, defendants learn nothing from this experience and it is my hope that when my representation is over, my clients will be better off than when they first came to me.  Many defendants, contrary to popular belief, lack a firm grasp of how the criminal justice system works. 

Popular views hold that “these people” know the system inside and out, and play the system for a fool.  Not in my experience.  While some may have a working idea of how some particular aspect of the system works, they rarely have a sufficient understanding to help themselves. Note how defendants regularly make statements to cops that destroy them at trial, and how many end up taking a plea and going to prison.  This isn’t an accident.

So when I get the call, I sit down with my clients just like Norm does.  But rarely do I explain that the system is harsh and unfair.  Instead, I ask them why they think the system exists, what purposes it serves and how they could have done things differently to avoid their current situation. 

Sure, I deconstruct the myth that brought on the call in the first place and explain the particulars of the case that give rise to their specific issue.  But I hope to do more when I have the chance.  Not only do I try to save one person in one case, but I try to help one person to have a better life in the future.  It doesn’t pay any extra, but it’s one of the fringe benefits of being a criminal defense lawyer.

Justice Stevens’ Rights, Unless He’s Wrong

In his concurring opinion in Baze v. Rees, Justice Stevens expressed his belief that capital punishment was unconstitutional.  Mind you, he concurred that lethal injection was fine anyway.  This gave rise to our favorite Utah Lawprof and victims’ rights advocate, Volokh Conspirator Paul Cassell,  ripping the old man a new one for his views:


Purer expression cannot be found of the principle of rule by judicial fiat. In the face of Justice Stevens’ experience, the experience of all others is, it appears, of little consequence.

Harsh words indeed.  But Alice Ristroph at  Concurring Opinions wasn’t about to let this former federal judge off the hook that easily, noting that Judge Cassell was guilty of the same crime:


When I read Stevens’s concurrence last week, the last paragraph reminded me of one of then-Judge Cassell’s opinions. In 2004, as a federal judge in the district of Utah, Cassell authored a widely noted opinion in United States v. Angelos (345 F. Supp. 2d 1227). Weldon Angelos was a first-time offender convicted of selling marijuana. The government applied a federal firearms statute with severe mandatory minimums, thus ensuring what was almost certainly an effective life sentence for Angelos. Judge Cassell wrote, “[t]he court believes that to sentence Mr. Angelos to prison for the rest of his life is unjust, cruel, and even irrational.” But out of deference to Congress and to existing constitutional precedents, Judge Cassell “reluctantly” applied the unjust, cruel, and irrational mandatory minimum and sentenced Angelos to 55 years and a day.

Ouch.  That’s the problem with writing opinions when you’re a federal judge.  They keep all these books around forever, and later on people can still find them.

In an effort to remove the petard from whence it was hoisted, Paul Cassell responds:


Perhaps I could have been clearer in my earlier post, but I have no problem with any judge expressing their point of view of constitutional or other issues. I did that a few times myself as a judge, as Ristroph points out. My problem with Justice Stevens’ views that the death penalty is (now) unconstitutional (and I think Orin’s as well) is that Stevens is simply wrong on the merits. Judges certainly have a right to speak on legal issues … but they should be right on those issues.

Talk about going from the frying pan into the fire.  So it’s not wrong for Justice Stevens to express his opinion.  It’s that his opinion that the death penalty violates the 8th Amendment prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment is simply wrong.  So says Paul Cassell.

Thanks for clearing that up.

What’s The Reasonable Cost for Trial?

Since criminal defense lawyers go to trial far more frequently than civil lawyers who call themselves litigators (“I’m an expert at depositions”), what’s a reasonable price for a trial?  Well, try this one on for size.

Per the WSJ Blog, a fee request from Biglaw firm Allen & Overy.


One case. Two associates. 15 months. 4,540 billable hours.

Legal fee?  $10.32 Million.  The trial lasted 5 days.  I would tell you how much per trial day that is, but my pencil point keeps breaking every time I try to do the math.

According to the judge, this was a garden-variety patent case, in which approximately 9 man/years was spent over 15 months, culminating in the 5 day trial. 

Let me be frank about this.  I think this is an eminently reasonable fee, and I want a fee just like this one.  I will give you the best 5 day trial you’ve ever seen.  In fact, we’ll round it off to $10 million even, and you can take the rest and buy Starbucks coffee for a few of your favorite assistants.

But what do the Wall Street Journal’s readers think of this fee?  They think it’s reasonable too. 

Confidential to criminal defense lawyers:  What are we doing wrong?