While I’m not inclined to discuss what will happen, since whatever is going to come with verdict expected tomorrow will come regardless of what I have to say, a post by Elaine Chiu at Co-Op appears to anticipate the no matter what comes our of Judge Cooperman’s mouth, it’s wrong by her.
Yet, as the prosecutors have made clear, the justification defense does not cover all fifty shots en masse, but rather law enforcement agents have an obligation to stop using deadly force as soon as their reasons for doing so dissipate. In other words, each shot has to be justified. In the heat of the moment though it is rather clear that the police officers did not reassess their need to use deadly force after each shot. Indeed, Officer Oliver who shot 31 times admits that he did not reassess until he ran out of ammunition and only reassessed at that moment because he had no other choice but to do so.
This was an argument, not a thing to be “made clear.” More importantly, it’s an argument that only a lawprof could love. Even an appellate judge would blush before trying to push this one on the panel. And as any cop will tell you, they fire until they’re done firing. If the shoot is righteous, then it’s good to the last drop.
It’s not the Chiu is technically wrong. Indeed, the use of deadly force is permissible only as long as justified. It’s that there is no practical way to tell where the line is in the middle of the gunfight. Is she arguing that each officer should fire one shot, stop, check to see what’s happening at that moment, then decide whether it’s appropriate to fire another shot?
This argument would easily come into play if the officers fired, stopped firing, assessed the situation and then, without justification, decided to start firing again for fun. But in the hail of bullets, no finder of fact, whether judge or jury, is going to convict the cops if they believe the first bullet was justified and there was no break, or “thing” that happened in the midst of firing, that made it absolutely clear to the cops that the need to shoot had ended.
So what really happened here? Perhaps the police officers were justified in their initial shots but what about the later shots? A more complicated story emerges. Instead of only the reasonable use of deadly force, it is possible that panic and shock and reflex also played a part. I blogged on this point last year at PrawfsBlawg. Unfortunately, the doctrine and practice of criminal law rejected more nuanced understandings of defendants and more appropriate defense strategies that combine both justification and excuse.
I’m unfamiliar with a defense strategy called “excuse”. Frankly, I fail to understand what difference it makes, except to those in the academy who need to give names to things that happen regularly and implicitly in criminal proceedings, whether the defense recognized its strategy to be nuanced or not. If they get a not guilty verdict, even for their un-nuanced effort, they will go home happy.
As for the more nuanced understandings between criminal law doctrine and practice, we can barely get a judge to go along with the concept of due process, no less more academic nuances. I can appreciate that lawprofs ponder these things to a degree that makes us poor grunts in the trenches seem utterly ignorant, since they can’t write scathing articles stretching over 25 pages unless they delve deeply, deeply into the underlying nuance.
But what bothers me about Chiu’s analysis is that it criticizes a real case, and the work of real lawyers and a real judge, in anticipation of a verdict that will invariably be wrong because of its intellectually messy framework.
That’s how cases are tried and decided in the trenches. It’s done with a club, not a scalpel. It’s messy and ugly. There is nothing nuanced about trial level courts. There never has been. On appeal, when lawyers and judges have all day to ponder these critically important questions of theory, criticize them all you want. But don’t jump down anyone’s throat about what happens in the trenches because it wasn’t sufficiently nuanced.
