Author Archives: SHG

Lock ‘Em Up America, Part 2

Liptak is at it. Again, In today’s New York Times, Adam takes another stab at trying to explain our disproportionately high rate of incarceration relative to the rest of the world.

The United States comes in first, too, on a more meaningful list from the prison studies center, the one ranked in order of the incarceration rates. It has 751 people in prison or jail for every 100,000 in population. (If you count only adults, one in 100 Americans is locked up.)

The only other major industrialized nation that even comes close is Russia, with 627 prisoners for every 100,000 people. The others have much lower rates. England’s rate is 151; Germany’s is 88; and Japan’s is 63.

The median among all nations is about 125, roughly a sixth of the American rate.

There is little question that the high incarceration rate here has helped drive down crime, though there is debate about how much.

Unlike his Sidebar Columns, Liptak’s piece is longer this time, so he has the opportunity to provide a more balances and substantive piece.  How does he explain this anomaly?

Efforts to combat illegal drugs play a major role in explaining long prison sentences in the United States as well. In 1980, there were about 40,000 people in American jails and prisons for drug crimes. These days, there are almost 500,000.

Now we’re cooking.  And what conclusions can be drawn from this?


Many American prosecutors, on the other hand, say that locking up people involved in the drug trade is imperative, as it helps thwart demand for illegal drugs and drives down other kinds of crime.

That’s it?  Well, yeah.  That’s it.  Don’t bother thinking there will be any analysis of the obvious, such as why this “imperative” should exist in the U.S. alone and whether it means the rest of the world is over run by drug crazed criminals, for either this explanation is correct, and Americans alone are inexplicably bent toward drug induced rampant crime or the rest of the world is subject to massive crime for its failure to jail everyone in sight.  Which is it Adam?  Silence.

But it’s not just how many we imprison, but for how long.


Still, it is the length of sentences that truly distinguishes American prison policy. Indeed, the mere number of sentences imposed here would not place the United States at the top of the incarceration lists. If lists were compiled based on annual admissions to prison per capita, several European countries would outpace the United States. But American prison stays are much longer, so the total incarceration rate is higher.

And what makes Americans believe that longer is better (incarceration lengths, that is)?


Some scholars have found that English-speaking nations have higher prison rates.

“Although it is not at all clear what it is about Anglo-Saxon culture that makes predominantly English-speaking countries especially punitive, they are,” Mr. Tonry wrote last year in “Crime, Punishment and Politics in Comparative Perspective.”

“It could be related to economies that are more capitalistic and political cultures that are less social democratic than those of most European countries,” Mr. Tonry wrote. “Or it could have something to do with the Protestant religions with strong Calvinist overtones that were long influential.”

The American character — self-reliant, independent, judgmental — also plays a role.

That’s the problem.  If we spoke French, everything would be different.  Actually, the Protestant ethic, “with strong Calvinist overtones,” has much anecdotal appeal.  But it also has one significant flaw.  Why, if this is true, isn’t the United Kingdom right up there with us?  After all, we got it from them.

Having failed to provide any meaningful basis to distinguish America from the rest of the world, Liptak jumps to the apologia.  If you’re a fan of consistency, then give Liptak credit, because he goes back to the well of former federal judge, now Utah Lawprof, Paul Cassell.

“As one might expect, a good case can be made that fewer Americans are now being victimized” thanks to the tougher crime policies, Paul G. Cassell, an authority on sentencing and a former federal judge, wrote in The Stanford Law Review.

From 1981 to 1996, according to Justice Department statistics, the risk of punishment rose in the United States and fell in England. The crime rates predictably moved in the opposite directions, falling in the United States and rising in England.

“These figures,” Mr. Cassell wrote, “should give one pause before too quickly concluding that European sentences are appropriate.”

Simple, but short of evidence as to cause and effect, not to mention degree to relationship.  This would be a really good spot to insert a quote from, say, an American criminal defense lawyer, right?  Not for Liptak, who instead writes:


“The simple truth is that imprisonment works,” wrote Kent Scheidegger and Michael Rushford of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation in The Stanford Law and Policy Review. “Locking up criminals for longer periods reduces the level of crime. The benefits of doing so far offset the costs.”

Well, if Kent and Paul Cassell say so, then why bother with the other side of the story.

In concluding his article, Liptak finally arrives at a bottom line explanation for why America, unlike anywhere else in the world, put more of its own in prison and for longer than anywhere else:


Several specialists here and abroad pointed to a surprising explanation for the high incarceration rate in the United States: democracy.

Most state court judges and prosecutors in the United States are elected and are therefore sensitive to a public that is, according to opinion polls, generally in favor of tough crime policies.

We do it because the people want it to be done?  But why, Adam?  Why does the public want it this way? 

If it seems that I’m always bashing Liptak, it’s because he disappoints me so often.  Readers here likely know most of the answers to the questions I raise about Liptak’s article, and already understand that decades of tough-on-crime politics and media exploitation of crime stories have created an American paranoia about crime and punishment.  Being fed decades of “common sense” solutions, that more and longer imprisonment must mean lower crimes rates, has created an expectation and acceptance of this “magic bullet” solution. 

But when will our venerable New York Times legal beagle grasp the glaring gaps in his articles?  Why does Liptak refuse to include anyone from the defense side to counter the statistically unproven assertions of Paul Cassell or the bald exclamations of Kent Scheidegger?  No balance.  No depth.  And read by a lot of people who believe that if it’s in the Times, that bastion of liberal ideology, this is the best that can be said.

The entirety of this superficial examination of a uniquely American problem begs one huge question:  Either Americans, and only Americans, are crime-bent at such a pace and degree that we alone in the world require incarceration at rates and lengths that no other nation on earth requires, or the rest of the world is laboring under a crime wave of such significant proportions, which America has avoided by its massive incarceration rates and lengths. 

If neither of these it true, then the entire rationale for imprisonment in America falls apart.  Do you think you can fit this into one of your articles, Adam?

The Right to Defend

Last Friday night, I was cruising through all the various channels on my old black and white TV, from 2 right through channel 13, when I happened upon a show starring the woman who used to be a nurse in one of the hospital shows, ER.  I can’t remember her name, but she played a lawyer named Canterbury.  I had heard about this show, and the reviews were not kind.  While a defense lawyer, she suborned perjury as if it was something we all do.  Or so I heard.

I watched the show, and much to my surprise, her defense against an admitted rape was jury nullification.  She went to trial because the judge would only give the defendant life on a plea.  She opened to the jury that he would have taken the plea but for the life in prison, which was too long.  The judge sustained the objection.  She wasn’t held in criminal contempt.  Nothing. 

Later, she asked a witness against her guy, who also raped the woman, what sentence he received (3 years suspended), and whether the defendant should get life.  Objection overruled.  Closing she argued again.  So it was all pretty silly from a legal perspective, but the mere fact that a TV show was about jury nullification was astounding.  Imagine, all 37 people watching would forever know that jury nullification exists.  And this is all because of the  Texas Tornado’s reviving nullification, I’m sure.

Now  Kip Esquire brings it up in a different context, asking whether nullification applies to “blocked defenses.” 


Question for the nullifiers: At least one state forbids the use of the so-called “gay panic defense.” Should a nullifier be entitled to disregard that prohibition and vote to acquit a gay-basher in defiance of both the law and the jury instructions?

My thoughts immediately went to the words of a Buffalo lawyer, Mark Mahoney, who for as long as I can remember has been pushing the agenda that the right to present a defense is of constitutional magnitude.  By this, he means that it is entirely up to the defendant to pick how he wants to defend against the charges, what evidence he wants to present in support of his defense, and that the state (including the judge) is constitutionally precluded from stopping the defendant.  After all, if there is a 6th Amendment right to counsel for the defense, there has to be a defense.  Moreover, the 9th Amendment precludes government from making laws that impair the defendant’s right to defend any darn way he chooses.

This is where theory and practice diverge.  While a lawyer is free to argue this proposition to the court, try pulling a Canterbury and you’ll find yourself getting slapped silly, first by the prosecutor, then the judge, then, if you persist, the hairy knuckles of a court officer and, maybe just for fun, the male court officers will thereafter join in.  In other words, the rules are designed in such a way as to limit what defenses are available to a defendant.

And what’s the primary defense that’s unavailable?  Why that would be jury nullification.  You can’t even say the “n” word in front of the jury.  How, you ask, could that be, since you’ve read Bennett thoroughly and watched every episode of Canterbury Tales and now realize that this is a fundamental criminal defense? 

Welcome to the world of legal reality.  There’s reality, and then there’s legal reality.  Imagine that a judge decides that the sun rises in the west and sets in the east.  That becomes the legal reality.  It’s what lawyers learn to work with, because we have no choice.  The rule is comply now, appeal later. 

The law says that there is no such thing as jury nullification.  Of course, there is, except that there isn’t.  In a courtroom.  On TV, yes.  In a courtroom, no.  It doesn’t exist.  And we know it doesn’t exist because whatever the jury decides is based upon the jury instructions.  That’s another piece of legal fiction as well, and you can’t argue on appeal that the jury convicted your defendant on the wrong legal basis if they were properly charged, because the legal fiction is that they had to convicted for the correct reason because the instructions were correct, and the jury always follows the instructions.  See?

Defendants regularly try to call witnesses on subjects such as false confession or mistaken identification, only to have the judge blow them out of the water by refusing the accept expertise on these issue or holding that the jury is competent to understand the problem without an expert.  Of course, this comes after the prosecution has called an expert on the subject of how your client is guilty as sin because he says so.

Some judges, when the constitutional right to present a defense is argued, will allow a lawyer to push the envelope a little further than she might otherwise.  I’ve used it with some small success at trial.  But big success, such as allowing a “blocked defense” to be openly presented or argued?  Never. 

When Kip asks if nullification works for this purpose, the answer is that it does, just as well as it works any other time.  The problem is that it’s the secret defense, the one you present without saying you’re presenting it.  You argue as far as the judge will let you, then back away before you push the judge far enough to give a curative instruction designed to cut your legs out from under you and make you look like an idiot to the jury.

Should this be the case is an entirely different matter.  If the jury acquits a defendant, the game is over.  No one can look behind the verdict to question why the jury found the defendant not guilty, whether for nullification, a blocked defense, or the way the cop combs his hair. 

When I talk to jurors after a trial to find out why they decided as they did, I frequently learn that their decision made no legal sense at all, and they engaged in some bizarre jury room voodoo that one would have never anticipated.  But if the verdict is not guilty, I thank them profusely and tell them what a fine job they did. 

5th Grade is a Tough Year in New York

What happens when 3000 people show up for a 5th grade graduation ceremony in an auditorium that holds only 489?  In New York, a riot, according to the New York Lawyer.

Brooklyn’s P.S. 92 (for you Texans, “P.S.” stands for public school) decided to hold its graduation at Medger Evers College auditorium.  The idea sounds nice, but it’s just not that big a venue.  While the story doesn’t say how many children were graduating, there must have been a bunch of uncles, aunts, cousins and the like who showed for the big event.  What a happy occasion, and everybody wanted to be there to celebrate.

But when the number of people exceeds the number of seats, by a magnitude of almost 10, there are only two possible outcomes.  One, the guests engage in excessive courtesy, allowing the handful of ticket holders access in a display of grace and understanding befitting the occasion.  Or, mass chaos followed by pushing, fist fights and ultimately the subduing of warfare though the use of mace and beatings.

This was Brooklyn.  Which one do you think happened?

Norma Robinson, who held a ticket for the ceremony, was one of the proud parents who came to Medgar Evers College auditorium for the joyous event.  And ended up maced and beaten by security guards, suffering a torn ligament to her shoulder.  She sued the City for failure to properly supervise the event.  Her case was tossed.

Supreme Court Justice Robert J. Miller dismissed Norma Robinson’s case, holding that a security guard’s actions, not the city’s alleged failure to properly supervise the event, was the proximate cause of her injuries.

“The testimony of plaintiff is clear that she was injured as a result of being maced and hit with a night stick by College employees,” Miller held in Robinson v. City of New York, 1151/04.

“Notwithstanding the City’s actions or inactions in failing to supervise the collecting of tickets, the Court finds that the actions of the security guards was not a foreseeable event caused by the City’s alleged negligence and further finds that any breach by the City of its duty on the day of the graduation was not the proximate cause of the plaintiff’s injuries.”

Curious.  It didn’t strike a Brooklyn judge as foreseeable that security guards would try to quell a riot that happens when a city school fails to take reasonable steps to control the 3000 who showed when there were only 489 seats available?  Frankly, I’m surprised that they didn’t start shooting into the crowd, which I consider eminently foreseeable under these circumstances.  Hey, this is Brooklyn, after all.

And is Robinson left to sue the security guard who maced and beat her with a club?


The identity of the security guard is not known. Robinson, who referred to the guard in her complaint as the “fat one,” names “John Doe” and “Jane Doe” as defendants in her suit.

I guess the “fat one” doesn’t narrow it down as much as John and Jane Doe. 

Hard Times for Hard Drives At The Border

From Orin Kerr at Volokh, the 9th Circuit has ruled in United States v. Arnold that computer hard drives are subject to search at the border just like anything else.  Reversing the decision by District Judge Dean Pregerson, the unanimous decision by Judge Diarmuid O’Scannlain “reasons that the greater storage capacity of computers does not make computer searches at the international border sufficiently different from other searches involving physical items.”


Arnold has failed to distinguish how the search of his laptop and its electronic contents is logically any different from the suspicionless border searches of travelers’ luggage that the Supreme Court and we have allowed.

With respect to these searches, the Supreme Court has refused to draw distinctions between containers of information and contraband with respect to their quality or nature for purposes of determining the appropriate level of Fourth Amendment protection.

Arnold’s argument that a computer hard drive is more akin to a home was rejected by the court.


Here, beyond the simple fact that one cannot live in a laptop, Carney militates against the proposition that a laptop is a home. First, as Arnold himself admits, a laptop goes with the person, and, therefore is “readily mobile.” Carney, 471 U.S. at 391. Second, one’s “expectation of privacy [at the border] . . . is significantly less than that relating to one’s home or office.” Id.

Oh boy.  And so we return to that old, yet lovable tenet of appellate review, remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale.  Bear in mind the  Boucher case on our side of the country has yet to be reviewed.

Yes, of course a person can’t live in a laptop.  You don’t have to go to law school for that one.  But the fact that a home isn’t “readily mobile” isn’t the only reason why homes are given the greatest degree of constitutional protection.  At best, the “readily mobile” element has been the excuse of first resort for denying protection to automobiles, not the rationale for protecting the sanctity of an individual’s personal privacy within their home.

While I can’t say that this would have been the approach I would have taken had I argued the case, the analogy is not as easily dismissed when one considers the expectation of privacy in the content of a hard drive relative to the expectation of privacy one expects within their home.  Or the nature of what exists, even if only digitally, inside the guts of a computer when compared to what’s kept within the drawer of a night table.

I have  posted with some  regularity about the pathetic fact that courts are ill-equipped to deal with technological advancements.  Reliance on precedent, good for stability in the law, is bad then new things happen that don’t fit the paradigm.  The need to shove a square peg into a round hole seems to stymie the ability of courts to comprehend why old precedent doesn’t neatly apply.  This is already a problem, and it’s going to get much worse as new technologies butt heads with old law.

My approach to this problem, the issue of what is subject to search at the border, is to revisit the rationale for allowing a search at the border in the first place.  When there was nothing that could be searched that would reveal anything particularly private about the person, allowing a full blown search without any cause at all didn’t seem all that unfair. 

The government’s interest in preventing smuggling, the introduction of foreign diseases and plagues, and collection of taxes all presented fairly strong reasons to search, while the individual’s need to protect his privacy was relatively weak.  After all, what did the individual have on him that was so private?

But a hard drive is different.  It potentially contains voluminous personal information, or perhaps significant corporate information, that can be extraordinarily private.  From medical information, to legal, to trade secrets, to naked photos of one’s spouse.  Whether you think it should isn’t the point.  It can, and does, should the laptops owner choose to put such things on it.  Should border guards be able to look at naked photos of a person’s spouse? 

On the flip side, the content of a hard drive implicates none of the government’s reasons for searching at the border.  Well, there is one reason.  They might find evidence of a crime, such as downloaded porn.  But then, generalized law enforcement was never a primary rationale for border searches, just a fortuitous offshoot.

The easy reaction from those who are supplicants to governmental authority is to exclaim, if you don’t want the border agents oogling your wife’s naked pictures, don’t put them on your hard drive.  True.  And what else should we not do in our lives that we are entitled to do, that is legal to do, that we want to do, because the government might reach into our personal lives and enjoy a good ogle?

Judge Pregerson got it when he concluded that computers are like diaries, holding our personal secrets.  The circuit didn’t by calling it a container like any other.  Maybe you can’t blame the circuits judges, since computers are just those things that the secretaries type into after they finish dictating.  I don’t know how many federal judges have their own Facebook page, but I bet it isn’t many.  Perhaps the world is flying past these decision-makers at such a rapid pace that my expectation that they keep up, at least a little bit, is unreasonable.

But at the end of the day, these decisions fail to recognize what technology means in our world.  To the precedent-lovers, I say you’re out of touch.  We need to recognize that old school jurisprudence does not apply well to new technologies, and the law needs to start adapting before we become a disreputable anachronism.

Skewering For Sport

Over at Concurring Opinions, Frank Pasquale has a great post entitled, “The Culture of Cynicism Eats Its Own.”  As I raised in the smaller context of the public’s attitude toward lawyers, Frank addresses in the broader context of American politics:


Americans, so we have been told endlessly by the media, hate politicians. . . and their natural henchmen, lawyers. The press fearlessly confronts official misdeeds, subtly educating the populace about the rottenness of its elected leaders. And once wasteful lawsuits are finally cleared out of the courts, captains of industry will be free to exercise the innovative genius that can make the country great again.

Where exactly does the media think we’re heading?  I doubt they think about it at all.  They just see a soft spot that can be easily attacked, and blood lust takes over.  Frank provides a number of examples, such as:


Having “exposed” Barack Obama’s unforgivable hauteur, the media exhibited its own in the process. For example, here’s Frank Rich on tribune of the people Lou Dobbs:


However out of touch Mr. Obama is with “ordinary Americans,” many Americans, ordinary and not, have concluded that the talking heads blathering about blue-collar men, religion, guns and those incomprehensible “YouTube young people” are even more condescending and out of touch. When a Washington doyenne like Mary Matalin, freighted with jewelry, starts railing about elitists on “Meet the Press,” as she did last Sunday, it’s pure farce. It’s typical of the syndrome that the man who plays a raging populist on CNN, Lou Dobbs, dismissed Mr. Obama last week by saying “we don’t need another Ivy League-educated knucklehead.” Mr. Dobbs must know whereof he speaks, since he’s Harvard ’67.


Since when did being smart turn into a deficit, a failing to be ridiculed?  What makes people in trailer parks think that the people best qualified to run the monster mechanism of federal government should live in the trailer next door?

It’s not that I don’t believe there is much to question, challenge or even dislike about the crop of candidates for the presidency.  Just not the fact that they are well-educated and have, as a result of the successes they’ve enjoyed over time, come to live a better lifestyle than most of us.  Would we really be better off to have people who have proven to be failures and ignorant running the show?

The cheerleaders of this new attack, corporate America, operates under the belief that if they get the “ordinary” people to hate their enemies (who would they be, lawyer elitists?), a new age will dawn for profit and pleasure.  Divide and conquer is an old strategy, but it’s time tested and proven to work.  The media, without much thought as to the end result of its class-warfare tactics, are opening the door to this new era of greed by undermining the “elitists” who would oppose it.

Where’s it all leading to? Here’s one clue from Floyd Norris, discussing Steven Fraser’s book on the story of Wall Street:












“By the time of the American Revolution there was already a robust plebeian resentment of the aristocrat as parasite, a privileged nonproducer living off the hard labor of those he lorded over,” Fraser writes. It has not helped that the financial lords have not always been subtle about their superiority, as when Jay Gould, the robber baron who ran railroads in the late 19th century, boasted he could hire one half of the working class to kill the other half.



It is one thing to be seen as venal but brilliant, and another to be seen as both greedy and stupid. That is the risk Wall Street now faces.


It’s not to suggest that the media should suddenly color their commentary to support a particular end goal, thus eliminating any pretense at objectivity.  Rather, feeding the anti-elitism frenzy and thereby fostering the elevation of ignorance that appeals to the lowest common denominator is neither worthy commentary nor helpful.  They are playing a game to enrage the masses just because they can.

Frank predicts that it will come back to bite them in the butt.  And it should, but that won’t help much either, by reducing the fourth estate to just another group to be hated by the mass of people who are angry, frustrated and looking for someone to blame.  What would help is getting off the kick of lowering the value of discussion by skewering people for sport and start elevating the discussion by evaluating what these people, elitist or not, have to offer.

I don’t care if a politician swears like a sailor, wears women’s undergarments or drinks fuzzy navels.  If he has a way to fix what’s going on in our country, he’s got my vote.  I’m not looking for a new best friend, just a person who can serve in an office that will make a huge impact on my life and my world.  So media-types, focus on the issues and stop screwing with people over the irrelevant.

The Undisputed King of Quantity

April 21: 19 Posts
April 20: 29 Posts
April 19: 24 Posts
April 18: 1 Post (with 24 subposts)

Is this Bashman?  No.  Is this some group blog on steroids? No. 

Welcome to the new CrimLaw, source for all criminal defense news, no matter how odd or peculiar.

 

And I bow to his efforts, the Prince of Prolific, Ken Lammers.

Crime must be slow in Virginia.

Earth Day Still Matters

The first Earth Day, the brain child of Gaylord Nelson of Wisconsin, was celebrated in 1970.  It’s purpose was to focus attention of what we were doing to our planet.  We were thoughtless about it back then.  It had yet to dawn on us that with our daily damage to the earth, it couldn’t sustain us forever.  Earth Day first opened our eyes to the possibility that we have an obligation to care for our planet.

Green has suddenly become the “in” word, with corporations promoting their “greeness”.  We have a public service announcement where Nancy Pelosi and New Gingrich sit side by side, in film noir style, to inform that they both agree that we need to deal with our climate. 

As oil prices increase, we recognize conservation as a fiscal necessity.  But more importantly, our water, our air, our land, have all become accepted parts of our culture.  No longer are conservationists and environmentalists ridiculed as “tree huggers” and oddballs. 

But the fact that th big picture is coming into focus, a mere 38 years after the first Earth Day, isn’t enough.  Too many neglect to do the little things that they can in their daily lives to be part of the solution.  It’s not that they aren’t concerned, and don’t support, the cause.  It’s that they can’t be bothered to recycle themselves, or find a garbage can rather than throw their trash out their car window.

Despite the cost of gasoline, many still love their SUVs with 12 miles to the gallon.  “But I need a bigger car for the kids,” they say.  The kids need air to breath too.  They still don’t connect that beautiful green lawn with the poison leaching into drinking water and the oceans.   

While it wouldn’t hurt for everyone to decide to take a giant step forward, but it’s inexcusable that so many still don’t do the minimum to help.  Recycle.  Plant a tree.  Don’t litter.  And when the Hummer comes off lease, get a hybrid.  They’re pretty good and get you to the same place just as fast.  Be part of the solution.

Where to Draw The DNA Line

An interesting article in the  Washington Post highlights the inherent conflict in DNA as a most personal possession of human beings and a exceptionally good identifier in criminal prosecution.  I know for a fact that Jim Watson wouldn’t care one way of the other when he discovered DNA, but he must be awfully proud to be the source of such debate. 

The conflict comes from the fact that the DNA of millions of people who have never committed a crime is just sitting around waiting for someone to put it into a databank somewhere to be pulled out as needed.  And it’s not just to show provide information the individual “donor”, but the donor’s family, ancestors, and maybe even mailman for all I know.  The point is that your kid’s DNA can lead the cops straight to you, as his daughter’s did the BTK killer.

Now that DNA is going to be collected from arrestees, not just the convicted, a whole new world of potentially innocent people will be brought into the DNA pool.  No, not just the arrestees, but their families and children who are not yet a twinkle in their eye.  Are you seeing the scope of this situation?

But then, there’s the flip side:


As things stand in some states, lab analysts who discover a potential suspect in this way may not be permitted to share that information with investigators. Such a policy, said William Fitzpatrick, a New York state district attorney, “is insanity. It’s disgraceful. If I’ve got something of scientific value that I can’t share because of imaginary privacy concerns, it’s crazy. That’s how we solve crimes.”

As much as I hate to say it, Fitzpatrick is right.  We expect cops to identify criminals who commit egregious crimes, such as rape and murder, and we have a tool readily available for them to use, but like some prissy school marm, deny them access.  It’s got an element of insanity in there.

But the problem with the scope of these DNA databanks is that they are scarfing up every bit of DNA they can find.  This includes the DNA of victims, anyone else who may have been at a crime scene at any other time, the cleaning lady, whoever.  The potential sources for DNA databanks is only limited by the number of people on earth.  And that, amigos, includes you.


The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that authorities may not conduct searches for general law enforcement purposes without suspicion about individuals. Although convicted criminals have a diminished expectation of privacy, searching a database for unknown relatives might violate that principle, said Jeffrey Rosen, a George Washington University law professor.

“The idea of holding people responsible for who they are rather than what they’ve done could challenge deep American principles of privacy and equality,” he said. “Although the legal issues aren’t clear, the moral ones are vexing.”

Now some people may be happy to have their DNA collected and held in a databank, just as some are happy to allow warrantless searches at will, because “they have nothing to hide.”   But what of your children?  Or your cousin?  Are you prepared to be the source of your kid going to prison, because you have nothing to hide?  And what if you did nothing wrong, but your DNA happened to be at a crime scene for a totally innocent reason.  Not an easy thing to dispute.

This is a very tough issue, because there is much to be said about police being able to locate the person who snatched some kid who will likely turn up dead on a roadside unless found quickly.  The criminal could well be someone that everyone in the community thinks is a good guy, like the baseball coach or the nice guy in the house down the block.  Nobody wants a dead, sexually molested child. 

Where does the line get drawn?

LA Prosecutors Get Split Ends

In Los Angeles, a bad hair day is worse than anywhere else in the country.  So when the LA Timesargues that expecting prosecutors to handles the administrative function of their office at least as well as the basic car rental shop is too much of a burden, and accuses federal judges of “hair splitting,” it’s quite a dig.

The suit by Thomas Goldstein against the LA County District Attorney was previously discussed here.  The Supremes have granted cert, making the editorial argument that precedent provides “absolute immunity” for prosecutors rather dim-witted. 


In 1976, the Supreme Court ruled that prosecutors have absolute immunity to Section 1983 lawsuits. Justice Lewis F. Powell wrote that immunity is rooted in a concern that “harassment by unfounded litigation would cause a deflection of the prosecutor’s energies from his public duties” and tempt a prosecutor to “shade his decisions instead of exercising the independence of justice required by the public trust.” Powell noted that the law provided other checks on errors or misdeeds by prosecutors.

Someone should have whispered in the editorial writer’s ear that the Supremes make the precedent rather than blindly live by it.  Nonetheless, the argument falls decidedly flat. 

“Harassment by unfounded litigation” is bad for everyone, not just prosecutors.  The legal system tries to weed out frivolous lawsuit, and we hope that lawyers refuse to take on “unfounded litigation.”  If they do, there are “other checks” to stop them.  Fewer lawyers would help too.

But Goldstein’s case isn’t “harassment” or “unfounded”.  In fact, it extremely well-founded, not to mention well-deserved.  The suit is not for a bad outcome, but for the absence of basic administrative systems to prevent the denial of constitutionally required information that would have prevented Goldstein’s lawyer from going into trial blind. 

While I have severe reservations that prosecutors deserve “absolute immunity,” rather than some lesser degree of immunity, the point of the Van de Kamp v. Goldstein is that there are functions involved that bear no relation to the prosecutorial function the arguably deserves a degree of protection.  It’s an office, like any office.  It can have procedures, like any office, that enable it to function with reasonable reliability.  The administration of the office, ranging from losing files to maintaining access to information about personnel, is no different than any office anywhere. 

Any business that does not maintain basic administrative procedures will fail.  It’s “customers” will be dissatisfied.  It’s function will be impaired.  This isn’t a novel concept.  If you can rent a car from one place, return it to another, and every office along the way will be able to immediately access all necessary information about the car and you, then there is no reason under the sun why a prosecutor cannot tell if the snitch in one case has been a snitch in others, and what gifts the snitch was given by his adoring fans.

The LA Times sees none of this.  According to the editorial, running an office, any office, is no different than prosecuting criminals.


Given this precedent, how could the 9th Circuit permit a suit against Van de Kamp? The appeals court noted that the absolute immunity covered only decisions by prosecutors that are “intimately associated with the judicial phase of the criminal process.” By contrast, the court said, the district attorney’s alleged failure to disseminate information about informants was an “administrative” action not closely related to what went on in court. That strikes us as hairsplitting. Appalling as Goldstein’s ordeal was, it doesn’t alter the fact that he is suing the county’s chief prosecutor for a miscarriage of justice. Unless the Supreme Court wants to dispense with prosecutorial immunity altogether, it’s difficult to see why he should prevail.

If this newspaper can’t distinguish the administrative function from the prosecutorial function, than one has to wonder how anybody there is able to keep the facts of a story straight.  I bet they have a way to determine whether a particular person has been the subject of a story in the past.  Is that journalism, or basic administration? 

On the other hand, I think the LA Times may be on to something when it suggests that if the Supreme Court doesn’t agree that this is “hairsplitting”, may it should dispense with prosecutorial immunity altogether.  Imagine, prosecutors doing their job right.  Even on a bad hair day, those prosecutors would look awfully handsome to me.