Author Archives: SHG

The New Subjugation

Via  Turley, Elena Reichman may be more sensitive than most to the demands of the minimum wage TSA officials at Palm Beach International Airport.  The path of least resistance would have been to comply, not only because it would have gotten her through the line more quickly but because it was a no-win situation for her.  But the 74 year old grandmother and Holocaust survivor decided not to passively comply, and will now pay the price of freedom in America.  My new favorite phrase, “freedom is not free.”

Elena P. Reichman

While this is not the face of terrorism, it is the face of civil disobedience.  And perhaps the face of America’s newest felon, if the TSA has its way.  Note the downturned lips, the beady eyes, the hair strategically askew.  She’s a bad one, no doubt.

From the Sun-Sentinel story,


Elena Reichman, a Holocaust survivor who lives west of Boca Raton, is charged with felony battery on a law enforcement officer. She was released from jail after posting a $3,000 bond at 5 a.m. Thursday. It was her first arrest, state records show.

Reichman’s daughter, Davira Bareli, said her mother is diabetic and accused security officers and the deputy of acting irrationally with her mother.

Reichman was in the airport to catch a flight to New York for Passover when she set off the metal detector at about 1 p.m. Wednesday, Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office spokesman Paul Miller said.

That’s how it starts.  First, they expect rationality.  Then, they turn violent.


Transportation Security Administration workers told her they would have to do a secondary screening, which includes using a metal detector wand, TSA spokeswoman Sari Koshetz said.

“She didn’t want to take anything out of her pockets,” Koshetz said. “When we asked her again to remove anything she became belligerent.”

When Picerno, a 17-year veteran with the Sheriff’s Office, tried to calm Reichman down, it got worse, Miller said: “She started screaming and grabbed the arms of the deputy and shoved her.”

Reichman was arrested.

No one, not even Turley, will argue that touching, no less shoving, a deputy is appropriate conduct.  But is this arrest-worthy conduct when done by a 74 year old woman?  Is it felonious?  Some of the overly-sensitive folks who truly believe that we are mere supplicants to officialdom will argue that there is right and wrong, and their zero-tolerance mentality will compel them to conclude that she crossed the line and therefore should be executed (metaphorically).  Ah, freedom is not free.  It’s so Orwellian.

There are two comments to Turley’s post that are exceptionally astute.  The first suggests that a person who survived a forced labor camp under the Nazi’s may be somewhat less inclined that our official-lovers to comply with the commands of every uniformed individual who “serves and protects.”  Perhaps this just wasn’t what Elena Reichman thought she would confront more than 60 years after the Nazis’ demise.

The second point, well-made, is about our government’s message to all the fine blue-haired geriatrics that pass through Palm Beach Airport, not to mention the rest of us, that they will tolerate nothing short of total compliance.  While the sheriff’s spokesperson said, “The public needs to realize that anyone can pose a threat,” the only threat Elena Reichman presented was a threat to their authority.  We can’t have people thinking that they can sass the government, no matter how old they are.  We either shut down these malcontents with an iron fist, or there will be anarchy in the streets. 

The second commenter includes a brief tale worth reading as well:


There are muslims in my area who no longer even try to visit Canada. Border officials separate the family and hold the adults for 2-4 hours of questioning every time they go through. That sends quite a message also-one heard loud and clear.

Anyone can be a threat.  Especially people in uniform with the power to turn an old woman’s ill-conceived shove into a night in jail and a felony charge.  Or a Muslim trying to cross a border.  

Freedom isn’t free.  And anyone who wants to champion the view that we, the citizens of the United States of America, would be wise to just start doing whatever we’re told, that our failure to comply rightfully brings the wrath of officialdom down on our heads, should not expect a warm welcome here.

It’s The Economy, Stupid

Less than two decades ago, this phrase swept Bill Clinton into office, while Papa Bush kept checking his wristwatch to make sure he wouldn’t be late for his dinner reservations.  If there’s one thing the American public understands, it’s that they suffer mightily in a bad economy.  The American dream is about prosperity.  Not freedom, equality or justice, but economic prosperity.  Like it or not, that’s the bedrock of the American experiment.

Reading Martin Neil Baily’s Op-Ed in the  New York Times this morning, having wondered after the last Democratic debate when I waited futilely for someone to offer something beyond the rhetoric of deep concern,  I smell the disengagement of hope for economic stability from our political  reality. 

Baily is “the director of the business initiative at the Brookings Institution, was a chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President Bill Clinton,” as described in the Times, and is the harbinger of Democratic theory moving forward.  Does this Op-Ed reflect just Baily’s opinion, or the manipulation of public perception on behalf of the Party in anticipation of failure.  Is he creating the plausible deniablity scenario for their inability to deal with the economy, or perhaps their reluctance to anger that group of Americans who refuse to let go of the war in Iraq/Terrorism mindset developed over the past 7 years?

Why would I think this?  Baily’s Op-Ed begins by creating one of the most ridiculous strawman arguments about the relationship of the war to the economy that I’ve ever seen, and I find it impossible to believe that this man, certainly a smart and accomplished man in his own right, would write such a thing. Baily’s thesis is that the economy can’t be blamed on the war in Iraq.

The economic case for linking the two is that war has reduced the global supply of oil and pushed its price over $100 a barrel, draining consumers’ pocketbooks and adding to inflation. Flush with cash, this argument goes, the oil-producing countries have driven down global interest rates and encouraged over-borrowing in the United States. Meanwhile, Washington has borrowed money to pay for the war, adding to the budget deficit and leaving it with few options to stimulate the economy. The Federal Reserve kept interest rates too low, and for too long, as a way of trying to encourage growth.

That’s not the economic case that I am aware of.  Perhaps that’s the argument being had inside the walls of the Brookings Institution, but not at my kitchen table for sure.

Though not an economist, and never an invitee to the Brookings Institution’s water cooler discussions, I try to pay a little attention to the reasons why we are in such a dire economic slump, which reverberates throughout the economy and will touch all of us (except a handful of billion-dollar-bonus-baby hedge fund managers).  My understanding was that the trillion dollars drained and pledged to the war in Iraq, taken from the pockets of working people in America with explicit permission, has left us higher and drier than we would have been had the mission not been accomplished back in 2003.

Some argued that the fortunes spent on Iraq weren’t lost, since the monies were paid to American service people and corporations like Halliburton.  But it was further noted that the “goods and services” that are associated with the costs, the part of expenditures that expands economic benefit, were lost to America and delivered elsewhere.  Thus, while some portion of the cost is returned to our country through payments to Americans, the entire benefit of work product was lost to us. 

Think of it in this way:  Had we spent the same trillion to build roads and bridges, to teach children to read and cypher, we would not only still have the money circulating through our economy, but also the benefit of the money in better transportation and education.  Instead, we get speeches about how we have to “stay the course” and “freedom isn’t free.” 

It was also my understanding that our government’s need to fund this war was the cause of our running up huge deficits, thereby devaluing the dollar to a degree previously unimagined.  This devaluation resulted in the increasing cost of oil in America.  Baily says that “[t]he high price of oil is largely the result of strong demand, notably from China and India, pressing against a limited supply.”  But the price of oil in China and India is half of what it is here.  I must believe that he knows that, and is betting that we don’t.

So why has Baily manufactured this strawman argument to bolster his point that the war in Iraq is not to blame for our economic crisis?  The most likely reason is that the Democratic Party, and its candidates for high office, the front-runner of which is under siege for his decision not to wear an American flag pin on his lapel, has concluded that it cannot and will not bring the war to a swift conclusion, and now needs a means to argue that it’s really not that consequential to our suffering.

Since I’m no economist, and could be all wet in my views, I hope that better minds than mine will scrutinize this trend and, if I am even partially correct, put the screws to our presidential candidates and not let them create a back door to avoid addressing the real problems facing us. 

The pain of our economy is very real, and strikes me as significantly worse than any I’ve seen in my lifetime.  I doubt someone will “discover” the internet again to provide the magic bullet that will lift us out unexpectedly.  There are more problems coming down the pike that no one is talking about, such as the aging of the baby boomers (think excess housing, health care, tax loss and social security).  There a lot of problems here, more than many people have yet to realize.

Are they now pulling the war in Iraq out of the mix? 

Another Way For Lawyers to Embarrass Themselves

Every few hours an email comes in touting some new scheme to suck in desperate attorneys.  This time involves some website called the Attorney Forum, which announces “As of March 30th, 2008 we have launched our
newly updated legal forum which is soon to become the internet [sic] largest destination for legal help and advice in North America.”

Soon to become?  Yeah, I’ll hold my breath.  This is the fifth email I’ve gotten from this fellow named Brian Williams, who, besides being punctuation challenged, appears to have issues with hyperbole as well when he calls his scheme “the largest online legal discussion forum online.”  Largest?  Is he referring to personal girth?

The point of the email is to offer me the opportunity to put a banner ad for his business on this blawg so I can become a “link partner” and, in return, they will add Simple Justice to their “directory”.  It’s almost as exciting as Steve Martin when the new phone book arrived.

But let’s cut to the chase:  This trend toward free legal advice forums is not merely dangerous and embarrassing, but offers huge ethical exposure.  I wrote this when Avvo started down this path, and I’ll say it again with this new crapola website.  It is impossible to give sound legal advice to half-baked, half-informed questions from the public, whether for free or otherwise.  It is unethical for an attorney to suggest that he can, and to engage in this sort of scam for self-promotion.

I don’t care how much rhetoric these for-profit websites spout in support of the wonderful, consumer-friendly, beneficent service they provide; It’s a scam.  It’s wrong and, beyond the most simplistic inquiry or the response of “speak to a lawyer,” there is no possibility that lawyers responding to these public questions are doing any good. 

So why are lawyers prostituting themselves in these forums?  For business.  It’s sold to lawyers as a marketing concept, to show the public how wonderful and giving they are by answering their questions for free, and establishing their “expertise”.  Have so many lawyers become that desperate for business that they will put aside both dignity and ethics in the name of self-promotion?  Apparently so.

Where are the bar associations and disciplinary committees?  Maybe they haven’t figured out that this is happening yet, considering that they barely recognize the existence of the internet.  Perhaps they are afraid of bad PR by challenging the rhetoric about providing this wonderful service to the public of giving bad “legal advice” upon which individuals rely to their detriment.  I don’t have a clue, but it pains me to think of the pompous declarations of attorney ethics while allowing this scam to continue unabated.

The reactions of these scammers is to resort to their hyperbolic statements of the good their doing for the public by providing access to the law.  Giving bad advice does the public no good.  My guess is that the people who seek advice this way are far less concerned with the quality and exactitude of the responses than the fact that it’s free. 

If lawyers want to help the public by offering free legal advice to those who are unable to afford counsel, that’s a wonderful thing.  Sit down, talk, gather all the necessary information to form an opinion and advise away.  Establish an attorney/client relationship and take responsibility for your legal advice.  If you’re wrong, bear the consequences. 

What’s wrong with lawyer that we are willing to demean ourselves and our profession by taking part in these schemes?  Will some lawyers do anything for a buck?  Unfortunately, we all know the answer to that question.

And Brian Williams, please stop sending me emails.  I really don’t want to be your partner, even though you are no doubt destined to be the biggest, best, most heavily trafficked lawyer website anywhere.  I’ll pass.

Things That Should Always Happen

The other day, I did a post about “never events,” things that should never happen.  There some great additions in the comments, though I was disappointed that some prominent members of the practical blawgosphere, Bennett, Gideon, Spencer, Grits, Pattis, Katz, Tarrell,  Skelly were not heard from.   Matlock seems to have gone the way of Malum.  While this isn’t the stuff of the business bloggers like Kevin, Carolyn,  Dan or Susan, they would have been welcome.  And then there’s the lawprofs, and it may be a little too low brow for guys like Solove and Hoffman, Kerr and Volokh,  Randazza and Chen, but I bet that there are some things that they could contribute as well.

But since we do this for love, I’m giving it a go in the opposite direction.  Things that should always happen.  Always events.

All prosecutors should have to spend a week in prison.

All judges should have to earn a living with real clients.

All criminal defense lawyers should have to meet with the victims of the crime.

All lawyers should have to do pro bono for the poor.

All cops should be required to snitch on dirty cops or get the same sentence.

All people who believe that convicting innocent people is an acceptable necessity of an imperfect system should nominate one member of their family to go to prison “just to be safe.”

All doctors should have to hear the sound of a latex glove being snapped on behind their back.

All public officials should be required to pass an 8th grade civics examination before taking office.

Again, I invite everyone’s contributions, and hope to hear from those of you who (like me) seem to have something to say about almost everything.

Schools Have Rules, No. 17 – Gale Ladehoff

Hot on the heals of the mindless love of rules in the face of reason in the Austin school district comes  this little gem via  Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado.


When Gale Ladehoff, principal of the Clear Horizons Early College High School in the Clear Creek Independent School District (and Official Woman), assigned a student to Saturday school because of excessive absences, she may not have known that the absences were due to a medical condition. She may not have known that this unwarranted discipline would cause the family logistical difficulties.

But rules are rules.  This subject of the all-mighty principal, Houston family lawyer Ron of Ron’s Insanity, decided not to suffer in silence, but to tell the tale of his meeting with the principal.


[Principal Gale Ladehoff] says that “rules” must be enforced. I, in my usual tactful and discerning manner, tell her that this is simply asinine. She obviously has no appreciation of my attitude. While there was no real attempt by her to dialog, things really break down when I tell her that i don’t give a damn about her rules.

She tells me the meeting is over. I’m standing there dumbfounded. “You’re stopping the meeting because I disagree with you?” I ask. Apparently once a tyrant declares that the meeting is over, you suddenly become persona non grata and become subject to forced removal. Her associate asks, “should I call security?” My sarcastic response to her was, “oh yes, call security, because I’m obviously a threat.”

We are all necessarily involved with petty bureaucrats from time to time, and we all enjoy similar experiences.  Bennett links to my “Official Woman” post whenever he comes up with one of these stories, because of its commonality and its sober tactic of dealing with them by feigning devotion and understanding that they live and die by their checklists.  But when your child is the victim of the Official Woman’s wrath, it may be too hard to bite your tongue and pretend to grovel at her feet.

We really have a serious problem in this country, with women like Gale Ladehoff, grocery clerks of great self-importance with just enough power over a very small but critical aspect of our lives to cause harm.  The problem is that the Gale Ladehoffs not only don’t comprehend how or why their actions are pathologically dangerous, but reflexively become more deeply entrenched as their power is challenged.  They are incapable of admitting error, because by definition their decision is right in the most absolute sense.

But there is another aspect to this phenomenon, one that is equally insidious.  These dangerous and ignorant Official Women are enabled by those who believe that they are truly entitled to flex their muscle, and that everyone else is obliged to bow to them.  This includes their superiors, usually Official Women in their own right, but also others who have come to not merely accept the rule of petty tyrants, but in a variation on the Stockholm Syndrome, support their authority no matter how offensive or wrong they may be.

Take, for example, this  comment to Bennett’s post:


Just one other thing, though: in the future, Ron should watch his tone and manner. If I had been the principal and had – for whatever reason – closed the meeting and he failed to leave, especially after expressing anger like that (however justified his feelings were [IMHO] in that case), I would have called the police too.

Once Ron insisted on staying where he was – rightly or wrongly – no longer welcome, he was trespassing. Not only was he breaking the law in one way, but his tone and manner could give reasonable people the impression that he might soon break it in other ways too.

Aside from the fact that the commenter has recast the story to make Ron the criminal, it demonstrates a bizarre obsequiousness that suggests that anyone challenging the Official Woman gets what he deserves.  If the Official Woman gives commands, and her subjects must obey.  If they fail to obey, then they are wrong and deserve what they get.

I’ve enjoyed the company of many an Official Woman.  There are a lot of them.  They can be found anywhere there’s a little bit of power to be flexed.  Some are petty annoyances.  Some are dangerous.  Some can do real harm to children, like Gale Ladehoff, and make families quite miserable.  While Ron’s approach was doomed, having no chance of moving the Official Woman away from her checklist of rules, it was a strategic error only.  I can’t fault Ron for becoming irate under such Kafkaesque circumstances.

But I think we need to create a new category for the enablers of Official Women.  Without them, the Official Woman would be just another petty tyrant.  As Mr. Bennett says, notwithstanding the echo of John Wilkes Booth, sic semper tyrannis.

Schools Have Rules, No.16

Without rules, assistant principals would just be ordinary men with sexuality issues.

One might think that people, even school officials, in Austin, Texas would have some feeling for the men and women “in harm’s way” over in Iraq.  But you can’t count on Texans anymore.  And this isn’t Dallas, it’s Austin, for God’s sake.

From this AOL report,


Master Sgt. Morris Hill is serving his country in Iraq, a long way away from his beloved sons back in Texas. Luckily, these days, we have the means for people on opposite sides of the planet to talk to each other in real time, almost without regard to where they actually are. We have cell phones.

Unfortunately, the only time Hill could call his son Brandon was during the school day — a time when students are generally forbidden from using their cell phones. It would seem, however, that this situation would count as extraordinary circumstances and an exception could be made, but administrators disagree. Brandon was suspended for taking the call.

The good news is that he wasn’t tased, which may well have happened if Brandon lived in Vancouver.  But then, he father wouldn’t have been Iraq, either.

It would be slightly more understandable if this telephone call came as a surprise, a “shock” if you will.  But Master Sgt. Hill is not the sort of fella to leave things to chance, and made arrangements.


The odd part is that the father had apparently made an arrangement in advance with the assistant principal to allow his sons to receive calls from him. “He had spoken with Mr. Fletcher,” said Pat Hill, the boys’ mother. “He thought there was an agreement understood that if he called either Joshua or Brandon at school, that everything was fine.”

Fletcher, eh?  Wasn’t she the nurse in One flew over the cuckoo’s nest?

So now that all the stupid posturing is over, the brain trust at the school naturally rescinded the suspension, let Brandon back in school and apologized publicly for having a calligyian cortex, right?  Not in Texas, amigos.


Mrs. Hill is trying to get the suspension removed from her son’s record, but the school says the matter is closed.

And what does the school superintendent have to say about this?


In a written statement to KXAN Austin News, Kathy Blake, the secretary to the Copperas Cove district superintendent, said: “In an emergency situation there are procedures in place to address those individual situations. This is true for all of the students in our district. The incident in question occurred almost two weeks ago and has been resolved.”

This is priceless.  Not merely because the school’s statement to the media comes from the secretary, but it was a written statement, meaning that they can’t even use the excuse that the Super wasn’t available at the moment the call came in.  They had all the time in the world and actually chose to have the secretary respond.

What, was the school district’s grocery clerk on vacation?  

Hey criminal defense blawger Jamie Spencer, is this how you guys run your schools down there, keeping kids from talking to their Dads who are in Iraq and could become a statistic at any moment?  Know any good lawyers down there?  I’m pretty sure this is too much of a stretch for Norm to handle.



Genius Stewardesses Save Flight From Religious Fanatic

As reported in Newsday, quick thinking stewardesses, whose reflexes were honed by their experience avoiding Elvis look-alikes in cowboy bars around the country, quickly acted to save a planeful of  passengers from the potential wrath of the Lord at JFK Airport yesterday.


The Orthodox Jewish man, who wore a full beard, a black hat and a long black coat, stood near the lavatories and began saying his prayers while the United Airlines jet was being boarded at John F. Kennedy International Airport on Wednesday night, fellow passenger Ori Brafman said.

“He doesn’t respond to them, but his friends explain that once you start praying you can’t stop,” said Brafman, who was seated three rows away.

What?  You thought it was some Muslim extremist?  And what did this animal do when he finished his prayers and could then attack these fine stewardesses?


When the man finally stopped praying, he explained that he couldn’t interrupt his religious ritual and wasn’t trying to be rude.

What a shame that they don’t carry tasers, because if there was ever a time when they were needed on an airplane, this was it.

So now that this dangerous religious fanatic was finished praying, what does a highly trained stewardess do to assure the safety of all the passengers and get them to their destination as quickly as possible?


But the attendants summoned a guard to remove him, said Brafman, a writer who had been visiting New York to talk to publishers.

That will show that black-coated animal. Hah!  Anybody want to argue why flight attendants shouldn’t be armed?

No Free Rides in Vancouver, eh?

Via  Turley, who apparently has a keen eye on the doings of our neighbors to the north, comes this story from the  Globe and Mail about how kinder, gentler Canadians deal with fare-beaters.  Zap.



VANCOUVER — The country’s only armed transit police have been tasering passengers who try to avoid paying fares.


According to documents provided in response to a Freedom of Information request, police patrolling public transit in the Metro Vancouver area have used tasers 10 times in the past 18 months, including five occasions when victims had been accosted for riding free.


Before all you crazy libs get all up in arms about this, it’s not like they tase the deadbeats straight away. 


“After several warnings to the subject to stop resisting arrest and the subject failing to comply with the officers’ commands, the taser was deployed and the subject was taken into control,” said the report provided by TransLink, the region’s transit authority.

See?  They failed to comply with the officers’ commands.  You don’t want to be tased?  Then don’t fail to comply.  It’s not brain surgery, you know.

But naturally, the hearts that bleed maple syrup are all bent out of shape.


On the face of it, the use of tasers by transit police here is far outside guidelines that say they should be used only if someone is suicidal, violent or about to injure himself or someone else, Mr. Dosanjh said.

“Their current use is absolutely inappropriate,” he said, adding that the latest revelations, coming after a storm of recent controversy over taser use by regular police forces across the country, have brought him close to calling for a moratorium on the powerful stun guns.

Guidelines?  We don’t need no stinkin’ guidelines.  Here’s the guidelines, you lily-livered deadbeat lovers:  Do as your told or suffer the consequences.  Since when do perps get to decide whether they feel like listening to a command by a cop?  If they say “jump”, you say “how high?”

And what does the Big Guy in charge of the transit police in Vancouver have to say, sitting atop his horse looking like Dudley Doright?


Yesterday, the head of the RCMP admitted the police force did not do a good job making information public about taser use, and vowed that changes will be made.

“Frankly we did not handle this matter very well,” Commissioner William Elliott told the Canadian Club of Ottawa. “We should not have needed two kicks at the can. We must learn from that and do better.”

Terrific.  Even the main mountie turns out to be an apologist for teaching these mutts a decent etiquette lesson.  Canada.  Feh.

Judicial Foot Stamping, And Still No Love

Justice Stanley Sklar announced that the judges, in protest over the denial of pay raises, will cancel Law Day.  According to the  New York Law Journal newsbrief,


To express their dismay over stalled efforts to win a pay raise, Manhattan’s 55 Supreme Court justices have canceled the Law Day ceremony they customarily host on May 1. In a statement yesterday, Justice Stanley L. Sklar, president of the Board of Justices of New York County, said “the judges cannot go forward with developing their own ceremonies this year when the judges have been denied justice.” Having gone more than nine years without a raise, Justice Sklar wrote, “it is clear” that judges working in New York City have the lowest salaries of “any judges in the United States” when adjusted for the cost of living. “Many of us have borrowed from our pension plans to pay for college tuition or other expenses,” he added. In February, Chief Judge Judith S. Kaye likewise decided not to give her annual State of the Judiciary address until the governor and the Legislature ended the “judiciary’s intolerable grief” by enacting a raise for the state’s 1,300 judges.

So this begs the question, who cares?  I know, it’s the symbolism, but does anyone else get the feeling that some in Albany are shrugging their shoulders, while others are just chuckling at this?

One has to wonder, do the judges think that canceling Law Day is an effective way to protest or garner support for their cause?  If so, they have been away from the trenches for far too long.  Maybe there’s some merit to the idea that no one should be able to sit on the bench for more than 10 years so they don’t lose touch with the real world.

For me, Justice Sklar’s protest came at a really bad time.  As I was talking to a civil associate at my office, a call came in from a civil Supreme judge’s chambers demanding that someone get their butt downtown to be physically present for a submission date on a motion.  But why, I foolishly asked, if the motion was already submitted, would they need a warm body.  There was no oral argument.  In fact, the motion was already decided by a prior decision, and this was a mere formality (the law loves its formalities).  The answer came back clear as a bell:  Because the judge says so.

So someone showed, the case was called and marked submitted, and someone left, having done nothing but given $4 to the charity we call the subway and wasted 2 hours of their life and the firm’s time and client’s money.

The juxtaposition of the judiciary’s foot-stamping, with their total refusal to understand and appreciate the pointless, wasteful and needless burdens they place on lawyers, makes it very hard to feel sorry for them. 

I’ve made this point before, and I’ll make it again.  Judges, if you want lawyers to join with you in your quest for an appropriate increase in judicial salary, then stop treating the bar like dirt.  We work for a living too.  Our clients work for a living too.  It’s not all about you. 

You squander our time like it’s worthless, demanding that we jump at your whim and spend hour upon hour sitting around your courtroom for your convenience, without the slightest concern for the impact on our livelihoods.  And then you cry that we don’t care enough about you?  Give me a break.

Respect is a two way street.  You want it?  Then give it.  You want us to be concerned that you have to dig into your pensions to pay for college tuition?  Do you think that our kids go to college for free?  You work hard?  Are we sitting in your courtroom eating bon bons?

I can appreciate that there are limits to what the judiciary can do to make its point, given that it will never do what is really necessary to create the constitutional crisis that will force the issue.  Whether you should is another story.  But for crying out loud, stop treating the lawyers like serfs, who exist only to “please the court” under pain of their clients’ suffering, and then expect us to care deeply for your plight.

Is this getting through to anyone?

H/T Andrew Lavoott Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog.

The Death Penalty Outside the Box

The Supremes heard oral argument yesterday in Kennedy v. Louisiana, the latest effort to disconnect the constitutionality of the death penalty from the crime of murder.  While the court has already held it unconstitutional to impose the ultimate sanction for crimes committed by juveniles and the mentally retarded, and has rejected the attempt to impose the death penalty for the rape of an adult, Coker v. Georgia, this time may be the charm.

The  WSJ Law Blog, stealing from  Dahlia Lithwick who was present for the argument, provides some of flavor of the questioning:



Fisher argued that if you look at the pair of recent cases that banned capital punishment for mentally retarded offenders (in 2002) and juvenile offenders (in 2005), it’s clear the social consensus is trending away from the death penalty. But Roberts said the clear trend that matters is not the one Fisher points to but rather that “more and more states are passing statutes imposing the death penalty in situations that do not result in death.” The cases declining to allow capital punishment for minors or the mentally retarded, he says, are “qualitatively different” from the distinction here between child rape and murder, because they focus on the “culpability of the offender” as opposed to the nature of the offense.


Scalia, writes Lithwick, almost chortled. “Did you ever hear the expression ‘hoist by your own petard?’” he asked Fisher. “The trend here is clearly in the direction of permitting more and more … capital punishment for this crime!”


Frankly, it just amazes me when the right side of the court, the one that argues about originalism and what Madison would have whispered to Jefferson if they ever whispered to one another, suddenly abandons all pretense of caring about precedent to expound on evolving views of penal decency.

Naturally, Justice Alito joined the chorus:


Justice Samuel Alito quotes a line from Coker opining that “life is over for the victim of the murderer. For the rape victim, life may not be nearly so happy as it was.” He asks, incredulously, is that “something that would be written today?” Ginsburg adds that the attitudes toward rape that animated Coker—that women were the property of their husbands or fathers and were “spoiled” after a rape—have “no parallel with child rape.” There was a lot of race and gender bias under the surface of the Coker case that isn’t immediately present in this one.

So Coker’s preventing executions for rape was just a matter of race and gender prejudice?  No one could have seen that coming. 

The other side opened with an appeal to emotion, according to Lithwick:


Juliet L. Clark is an assistant district attorney from Louisiana, and she opens with the most graphic description of a sex crime I have heard at the court. It is so awful that Justice Stevens finally stops to ask whether the victim’s injuries were permanent.

And not to have the possibility of expanding the death penalty happen without him, Ted Cruz, outgoing solicitor general of Texas weighed in:


He opens forcefully with the claim that “few evolving standards of decency are more pronounced than the growing understanding in modern society of the unique and irreparable harm caused by violent child rape.” He urges that Coker dealt with adult rape, expressly leaving open the question of child victims. He adds that part of the reason states now want to penalize child rape with execution is that today, “we’re seeing crimes that 20, 30, 40 years ago, people wouldn’t imagine.”

And that’s just amongst Texas politicians.

What is amazing about the entire tone of the argument is how the pro-execution arguments have seized the language of their adversaries, relying on evolving standards and the living Constitution to overrule precedent and allow executions where they have never been permitted before. 

An interesting intramural discussion broke out, that will enlighten as well:


Justice Stephen Breyer observes that he can imagine many such “horrible” circumstances. But, he cautions, “I am not a moralist. I am a judge.” He worries that if the court reverses itself after decades of confining capital punishment to homicide, the court will rapidly find itself in the business of creating some highly complex “moral categorization of crime.”

“Just the way they used to,” grins Scalia.

“Perhaps 200 years ago, that’s true,” retorts Breyer.

There is no question that the issue of crimes against children is one of the volatile and emotional around, and that if any crime will push the Supremes over the edge, the rape of a child is the one to do it.  Breyer’s point, that disconnecting death from death (yes, treason has been the oddball since the beginning, but it’s different from all other crimes and really doesn’t help anyone’s analysis) opens the door to a constant series of constitutional assessments of moral relativism that feeds the tyranny of the majority in a way that courts are never supposed to do.

Why is this different than evolving standards of decency flowing in the other direction?  That’s a good question, and one that is clearly colored by a world view that mercy and compassion are better than vengeance and retribution.  The belief is that we become more enlightened over time, less barbaric, and that the death penalty is our homage to The Code of Hammurabi, a relic of a time when we were far more brutal. 

But even under Hammurabi, it was a death for a death.  This parity isn’t good enough for us, thousands of years later?  Is lex talionis (mirror justice) too easy-going for the death penalty advocates?

Not that I’m in favor of editorializing the reportage of Supreme Court arguments, but Dahlia ends her article with this bit of personal insight:

Me, I am going to pour myself a big old drink and try to count the number of jurists who, after a lifetime on the court, have concluded that the death penalty in America simply cannot be fixed. Then I’ll weigh them against the number who started off opposing capital punishment and became increasingly certain that the system works. Maybe this is yet another trend that doesn’t matter. And Justice Scalia would tell me that the death penalty needn’t be perfect to be constitutional. But it’s probably not an accident that judges who have stood watch over hundreds of executions eventually need to believe that they are evolving toward a system that’s at least better than what came before.

This has long been clear:  As Supreme Court judges “age”, there has been a clear tendency to arrive at the conclusion that for all their efforts, arguments and opinions, they ultimately reach the conclusion that the death penalty is cruel and unusual punishment, and that it is not, cannot and never will be fairly applied.  Moreover, a lifetime of reviewing death penalty cases cannot help be leave one of the view that our criminal justice system, thought “not perfect” as Justice Scalia finds acceptable, is too far from perfect to stomach when it comes to the execution of people.

Maybe all of this really depends on how much “collateral damage” one is willing to accept as part of our imperfect system in order to gain a little, if any, deterrence and rid our society of those people who disgust us.  The answer to this question largely depends on whether you’re the guy pushing the plunger on a syringe of a three-drug cocktail or the family of the guy on the table with a needle in his arm.