Author Archives: SHG

What to do with Chronic Subway Groper

Austin criminal defense lawyer Jamie Spenser sent me an  AP story about guy who just can’t seem to stop rubbing himself up against women in the New York subway.  The subways have long been a notorious locale for women, where men rubbing up against them is a daily occurrence.  Of course, everyone rubs up against someone on the New York subway, because it’s like being in a municipal sardine can most of the time.

But that doesn’t mean that it’s innocent rubbing, and it’s frequently not.  For someone inclined to rub, it’s heaven.  Too crowded to be noticed, too easy to claim it was innocent, men who want to rub have a perfect opportunity to do so.  Most women I know in New York say they have been deliberately “rubbed” in the subway.  It’s not the same as rape, and the women I know don’t seem to get too upset over it, but it’s still disconcerting and unpleasant, occasionally shocking. 

There are also times when a woman rubs against a man, I might add, but rarely do these rubs result in anything other than a humorous story.

But this article was about a fellow named Freddie Johnson, who probably buys the unlimited Metrocard.

Johnson has been arrested a staggering 53 times – the majority for allegedly groping women on subway trains.

In his latest arrest, Johnson was being followed by plainclothes officers who recognized him from police photos. He was charged with persistent sexual abuse, and if convicted this time he could be sent away for life.

Don’t let the “groping” language fool you.  He’s not reaching out with his hand to grab or touch another person.  He’s a rubber.  He gets on the train and he rubs.  He denies that he did any rubbing this time, in an interview with the Daily News.


In a jail interview with the Daily News of New York, Johnson said he never touched that woman. However, prosecutors have he was carrying a messenger bag over the front of his torso, slid it to the back to illegally rub up against the woman, and then moved the bag back to the front to avoid being caught.

Unlike the past, however, this may be a far more serious rub than he’s used to.  Having gotten out of prison on March 25th after a 4 year bit, the authorities have had enough of Freddie.  But what to do?

The Attorney General wanted to civilly commit Freddie, but a judge refused, putting him on strict supervision instead.  And now he’s back in trouble, only a few weeks later.

Obviously, I have no idea whether Freddie committed this offense.  Maybe the cops who were following Freddie, having recognized him from photos, saw groping because they expected to see groping.  After all, Freddie is not likely to be the kind of guy to catch a break from the cops.

There’s always the option of treatment, but that’s an expensive proposition, beds are in short supply and, frankly, Freddie just isn’t that bad a guy to merit that level of concern.


The goal of the state’s Sex Offender Management and Treatment Act that went into effect last April is to protect society by keeping the most dangerous sex offenders off the streets, and provide long-term specialized treatment to see that they don’t repeat their crimes. To qualify, a criminal must have a “mental abnormality,” and be “predisposed” to repeat the offense, prosecutors said.

Currently, 10 percent of sex abuse cases are referred as possibilities for the program, on par with other states that have similar laws, the health department report said. It costs more than $100,000 per person per year to confine them. And there is currently bed space for 181 offenders at three facilities around the state

The District Attorney, lacking any other bright idea, wants to lock Freddie up for life this time.


But Johnson may end up behind bars for good if he’s convicted in the latest incident, because prosecutors say they will push for more serious punishment given his rap sheet. That means he could get up to life in prison.

While it’s unclear how serious a threat this presents, since it’s not quite clear that any judge is going to agree that a non-violent subway rubber felons in prison for the rest of his life, this situation does demonstrate the lack of viable and effective options for minor-league sex offenders. 

Deterrence hasn’t worked.  Rehabilitation is a total failure.  Isolation is too expensive and just over the top.  Then what do we do with Freddie?  If he was a rapist, no one would question throwing the book at him.  But he doesn’t cause physical harm.  He isn’t violent.  He’s just a rubber.  Half the women he rubs probably don’t even know that it happened; it’s just a typical day on the New York subway.

He’s harmless?  No, he is not harmless.  He’s just not particularly harmful.

It’s unhelpful for someone to talk about how Freddie is sick, and can’t control himself.  Maybe, but so what?  Why does Freddie’s “sickness” mean that women on the subway have to be subjected to being rubbed by him over and over. 

We don’t seem to have a place for the Freddies of New York.  I don’t know if there is any good answer to this problem.  Those who feel sorry for Freddie are wrong.  Those who want to put Freddie in prison for life are wrong.  But that leaves us without any real way to deal with Freddie and protect the victims from Freddie.

If Smearing Doesn’t Work, Blame Osama (Updated)

You can’t make this stuff up.  When Senators Arlen Specter and Jeff Sessions  abandoned the Datatreasury amendment in the face of public humiliation, we thought we had heard the end of it.  Nope.  There was still one step (at least) further into the gutter that the banks are willing to go.

This time, no less (expensive) a personage as Asa Hutchinson, former  undersecretary of Homeland Security and now CEO of his very own “consulting” firm, has an Op-Ed in the  Washington Times (not Post, Times) that argues that America must stop DataTreasury to protect itself from Osama Bin Laden. 

And here we thought this was only about saving banks from having to pay billions of dollars.  Now we know it’s part of the war on Osama.  Like I said, you can’t make this stuff up.

Asa’s argument relies entirely on long-discredited allegations and, in an over-abundance of blather, contends that any issues as to the validity of patents are too important to be left to the courts when they involve matters of national security.



One issue that rises above the validity of the patents is the role of the federal government in prompting the private sector to take certain actions. When the government dictates to the private sector, inevitably the latter faces certain costs. This is why government interference in the private sector should be done with extreme caution.


In this case, due caution was given, but the enormous responsibility for the safety and security of American citizens outweighed the specific and narrowly tailored costs to the private sector.


That’s right.  Unless you want Osama to win, our government must seize control of the patents from DataTreasury and hand them over to the banks to use for free.  The cost, shouldered by the taxpayers, is nothing when compared to the safety and security of Americans.

When the banks tried to smear the company on the last go-round, not to mention the wealth of comments left by bank shills in their effort to spin, spin, spin, their smear campaign, I thought we had reached the nadir of PR stupidity.  But the level of desperation has now fallen to an embarrassing new low.

But Asa Hutchinson harping on Osama?  Give me a break.  This is just getting too funny.

Update:  From IPI PolicyBytes, Blogger Tom Giovanetti, who I don’t know but may be a tad more conservative than me, has this to say about Asa’s Op-Ed :


Several commentors want to know “what I think now” after the Hutchinson op/ed. The answer? I now think far less of Hutchinson’s intellect and integrity than I did before reading his op/ed.

You see why he appears more conservative?  I probably couldn’t think less of Asa than I did before.  If anything, I’m beginning to feel sorry for him because this was so pathetic.


I am immediately suspicious of anyone who tries to cloak their issue in national security. In Hutchinson’s article, he spends his first 5 paragraphs raising the turbaned-menace, mentioning Osama bin Laden, al Qaeda, 9/11, the Pentagon, terrorists, etc.  This is an insulting smoke screen. The issue, as everyone knows, is whether or not it is right to specifically obliterate someone’s patent rights after having repeatedly failed to invalidate the patent. Hutchinson insults his readers by trying to sneak his issue through the smokescreen of national defense.

Well, if its a good enough reason for the USA Patriot Act, are you saying it isn’t good enough to protect the financial interest of American banks from a patent holder?  So what’s your bottom line Tom?


Hutchinson’s article is an embarrassment, and should embarrass even those who are on his side of the issue.

After what the banks lost on Sessions, now Asa, not to mention all the little bank shills that run around the internet spreading the word, this has got to be costing the banks a fortune.  It tells you a lot about what the true value of beating DataTreasury must be.

The Boom Days Are Over, According to Hall

I don’t usually read John Wesley Hall’s blog (and he isn’t even on my blogroll, though I’m not on his either).  But Bennett, a good friend of Austin’s Best Criminal Law Blawger, Jamie Spencer,  linked to one of  Hall’s posts and I decided to check it out.  I’m glad I did.

The title of the post is an eye-catcher,



And you think the economy sucks? Ask any criminal defense lawyer


This is counterintuitive for most of the criminal defense bar.  When things get tough, people commit crimes.  After all, jobs grow scarce.  Good jobs non-existent.  People need to keep busy.  People need to feed the kids.  People need to look like their favorite pop music icon on TV.  When in doubt, steal it.

But things haven’t quite worked that way for a while.  I saw this coming for a while.  One of the particular leading indicators was a criminal bar association dinner about 5 years ago, when I scanned the room and realized that I was probably the youngest guy there.  I’m older than I look, by the way.

It came to me that the young guys either were fleeing criminal defense for greener pastures, or weren’t making the money to pay for the overpriced bar association dinners where they gave awards to the same half dozen old time “mandarins” year after year, even though they hadn’t done anything award-worthy in decades.

The old-timers are honored because they are supposed to be a draw for the new kids, who can touch the hands of legends and feel like they are one of the gang.  But where were they?

I was on trial shortly after that, chatting with the judge about how busy things were around the courthouse.  He pointed out the indictment numbers at the end of the year, down about 40% from a few years before.  Not just the numbers were down, but the types of cases had changed as well.  The big drug cases were few and far between.  The crimes were pedestrian, overcharged and decidedly unsexy. 

Poor people doing low-rent crime and getting indicted for cases that would have barely been worth a misdemeanor a few years earlier.  The District Attorney’s office still had the same number of people, and there were more cops on the street than ever before.  They had to do something, so spitting in school zone became endangering the welfare of a minor in the first degree.

The first question people ask when they find out you’re a criminal defense lawyer is whether you’re defending anybody important.  Of course, you respond that everyone you defend is important, but that’s only because you know they asked the wrong question.  They want to know whether you have any cool cases that they read about in the paper.  It’s like being a celebrity, at least for a minute or two.

But the high profile cases, while making us far sexier than we deserve to be, aren’t the cases that keep practices thriving.  It’s the bread and butter cases that pay the bills.  The high profile ones are actually a huge drain on a practice, but that’s a post for another day. 

The bread and butter cases generally require the confluence of two things:  Clients who are interested in obtaining the best possible defense, and clients who have the wherewithal to retain private counsel.  Both of these factors have changed markedly over the years. 

The years of snitching have altered the vision of many defendants as to the worth of fighting the charges.  The chances of winning seemed dim, and it was so much easier to just rat out your best friend.  This also made the relative value of using scare resources for legal fees decidedly less worthwhile.  Why pay for the cow when you can just accuse it of a crime?

There has also been a shift away from good quality criminals.  These were the guys who engaged in crime in a relatively peaceful and orderly fashion.  Their purpose was to make money, not waves.  They saved their gains and considered lawyers a cost of doing business.  They never whined about an arrest, but realized it was an inherent risk and dealt with it.  But as business became more difficult, and risks increased, retirement began to look like a terrific option.  Many of the business people, the ones who survived the rat wars, decided to pack it up.

In contrast, the new people who filled the void lacked their business acumen, and watched Tony Montana too many times.  They spent their cash on bling and fun, and when they were taken down a month or two later, had nothing to show for it.  These fellows did not have good client potential.

Today, there are still plenty of cases going through the system, but not enough paying clients to go around.  Some of us get enough to keep us busy, though it’s nowhere near the days when we had to turn people away because we just couldn’t carry another case. 

Others are suffering, and suffering badly.  Some of these are good lawyers, if not great lawyers.  But for whatever reason, their phones aren’t ringing and they sit alone in their fancy office without much to do.  This can’t go on.  The fancy office costs fancy money.  If it’s not coming in, it can’t go out.  Something has to give.  They aren’t interested in going to back to the bad old days of handling indigent defendants for whatever the government chooses to pay.  They aren’t willing to demean themselves by doing thousand dollar felonies, like the kids who are just starting out and will take any case that comes in the door.  But they are stuck.

There will be a major fleshing out of the criminal defense business over the coming year or two, not by choice but by necessity.  Where everyone will go remains a mystery, and whether the strong, meaning the skilled, will survive is a mystery too.  Some of the strongest are doing surprisingly poorly these days, because clients don’t have a clue whether their lawyer is a great one or a mutt.  They hire who they like, and who will take whatever money they have in their pocket.  Neither is a good indicator of legal talent.

My greatest fear is that this market for criminal defense talent will eviscerate the ranks of the better lawyers, leaving only a couple top names and a glut of bottom feeders living off the government dole.  If you think it’s hard to get justice now, just wait until that happens. 

Immigration Law, The Ugliest Duckling

Liptak, whose got his bags packed, sitting by the door awaiting assumption of Linda Greenhouse’s apartment lease, does his  Sidebar today about immigration law.  This isn’t the immigration law done by corporate lawyer-types to bring in executives and specialists from foreign lands to fill highly technical or top management positions in major corporations.  This is the immigration law of people fleeing poverty and persecution with nothing in their pockets and taking terrible risks to give their children a chance at a decent life.

The highlight of the column isn’t the complaining by the judges of the Second Circuit of the quality of the briefs submitted by immigration lawyers, though there’s certainly plenty of that.  It’s the interview of Frank R. Liu, immigration lawyer.  His candid assessment of his work, and the nature of the work of immigration lawyers, should shame the circuit judges for their disdain.

In April 2006, a three-judge panel of the court warned Mr. Liu that his carelessly written and factually unreliable appellate brief, apparently copied in large part from earlier ones, could subject him to discipline.

You might think that would have gotten Mr. Liu’s attention. But he was chastised five more times in 2007, by panels including eight more judges. In May and again in September, Mr. Liu was referred to the court’s disciplinary committee for his “seriously deficient” work.

Frank Liu certainly sounds like an awfully bad lawyer, doesn’t he?  He’s clearly invoked the wrath of the 2d Circuit, and they haven’t held back on letting him know. 

But Frank Liu isn’t about to duck and cover.  He’s asked, and he answers.


“I think the judge has a point, actually,” he said. “Some attorneys, including myself, do not spend enough time. We’re not trained properly in terms of federal appeals. I ventured into an area I found later was very demanding. I was probably not qualified to do the job.”

“Personally, I feel very ashamed, of course, in being mentioned,” he said.

It is easy to feel superior to lawyers like Mr. Liu and his colleagues, but they are symptoms of a systemic problem rather than its cause. 

Mr. Liu said he typically charged a flat fee of about $2,500 for an appeal, a fortune to clients and a pittance by the standards of large firms, which routinely charge $100,000 and more for an appeal.

“A new immigrant makes like $10 or $8 or $7 an hour, and big firms charge like $250 an hour,” Mr. Liu said, underestimating what big-firm partners charge by a factor of three if not four.

But Mr. Liu said he was not hiding behind the economics of his practice. “There is simply no excuse,” he said. “Even if you don’t charge a lot of money, you have to do your job.”

While our judges, state and federal, decry their poverty, what of the lawyers who toil on behalf of the immigrants? 

Here’s the lowdown:  Immigration is a volume practice in one of the most bizarre pseudo-courts around.  Immigration judges are angry people with big chips on their shoulder, listening to the same complaints, and scams, and whining hour after hour, day after day.  And most of it is in some strange tongue that grates on their nerves.  The Circuit has been hugely critical of the wholesale lack of due process in Immigration Court, where they are just too sick and tired of all these people to care much about it.  If the Circuit judges don’t like it, let them come and sit there for a month and see how they feel.

A lawyer can make a decent living doing immigration work, provided he has the volume necessary to keep those ten dollar bills flowing.  You see, he can’t charge much because they don’t have much.  They are mostly hourly workers, as Frank Liu says, and they have little or no savings.  They often pay weekly, bringing in what’s left after they buy formula and pampers for the kids, and hope it will be enough to make the lawyer happy.  They don’t actually see the lawyer much, but talk to the secretary.  The lawyer is in court, handling the names on his calendar, and can’t be in the office to chat with his clients if he’s going to actually do any work. 

So how much time does he have to spend on each case?  Not much.  But for many immigration lawyers, that isn’t really a big deal.  You hear the same sad stories over and over.  It all blends after a while, the tales of persecution in the old country.  The stories of marriage to an American, who has previously been married to a handful of other new immigrants.  The unfortunate guilty plea that makes a person with a wife and 5 children deportable, even though he’s lived here for 34 years. 

This is an ugly practice.  For most lawyers, it bears absolutely no resemblance to anything we would call the law.  Some immigration lawyers have a system figured out:  Collect as much of the cash as the client can muster, put in the pro forma papers and argument, and if you lose, the client gets deported anyway so there’s nothing to sweat about.  This is decidedly low rent law, and like making knock-off dresses for some box store, they can’t tell the difference anyway.

And then there’s a lawyer like Frank Liu.  The Circuit is all over him because his briefs fall so far below the level they expect from lawyers.

There is, Judge Robert A. Katzmann wrote for a panel of Second Circuit judges in February, a “disturbing pattern of ineffectiveness” at the lower levels of the immigration bar, one that rears its head in the appeals courts with “alarming frequency.”

Two briefs Mr. Liu submitted to the Second Circuit in October 2006 support his self-assessment. They included, for starters, 27 paragraphs that were essentially the same in each brief. Mr. Liu did add a half-dozen paragraphs to each brief to take account of the distinct facts in the two cases, but he made no effort to explain where the lower court judges had gone astray in ruling against his clients.

Yeah, that Liu must be a real stinker, right?  Or perhaps there’s a different problem than the one perceived by the judges of the 2d Circuit, so quick to criticize.  At least a lawyer like Liu pursues appeals to the Circuit on behalf of his clients, though he will never be able to afford the luxury of spending a fraction of the time on a brief that Biglaw firms do when representing major American corporations. 

How many of our Circuit judges enjoyed the lifestyle of a low rent immigration lawyer before they received a presidential appointment?  You see, guys like Frank Liu would never make it onto the radar of a senator, no less a president, and hence are notably underrepresented in the Circuit Courts of Appeal.  They don’t have the slightest clue what the world is like for Frank Liu, or his clients.  The mere fact that Liu tries, within the limits of his skill and time, to help his clients is worthy of their appreciation.

I do not, and am not, excusing bad lawyering in immigration or any practice area.  It is most disturbing, however, that federal judges, the same one rightfully complaining about their lousy pay, have neither tolerance nor understanding that a lawyer like Liu and his brethren in the immigration bar are trying, albeit poorly, to handle the ugliest duckling in the legal pond.  If you don’t like judicial pay, try immigration law pay.  How nice to have wood paneled chambers when these guys work in the legal gutter.  They are trying.  Give them a break.

And Adam, imagine how much better your column would have been if you took the subway over to 26 Federal Plaza and actually saw what life was like in Immigration Court.  No, you probably would have taken a taxi.

Are Prosecutors Worthy of Total Immunity?

The Supreme Court has  granted cert in a Los Angeles case, Van de Kamp v. Goldstein, where Tom Goldstein spend 24 years in prison for a murder conviction based upon a jailhouse snitch.  The snitch, it turns out, was a pro and had a history that should have been disclosed under Giglio, and would have provided the fodder for the defense to rip the rat’s credibility. 

But the management at the District Attorney’s office, well, they just didn’t have any system in place to track snitches, and somehow nobody knew anything about anything.  So Goldstein, an innocent man, spends 24 years in jail because of crappy record keeping.

When he gets out, Goldstein sues.  And wins. 

According to this Los Angeles Times article,


Prosecutors, like judges, must be free to do their jobs without fear of being sued later, the high court said in 1976.

This rule of “absolute immunity” applies whenever a prosecutor “acts within the scope of his prosecutorial duties,” the justices said then.

But it is not clear whether this immunity rule protects supervising prosecutors against suits over alleged management failures.

So the issue is framed.  But there remains an underlying assumption that troubles me about the limited scope of this case, and it’s exacerbated by the discussion that  Gideon started yesterday about the refusal of state attorney grievance procedures when applied to misconduct by prosecutors.

Why must prosecutors, “like judges,” be free to do their jobs without fear of being sued later? 

Prosecutors are not at all “like judges” to begin with.  They serve an important function in the criminal justice system, right?  So do defense lawyers, but nobody is saying we’re “like judges.”  We’re not immune from suit.  What could be so horrible about prosecutors living “in fear” of suit if they perform their important function so badly that innocent people go to prison.  Do we expect prosecutors to screw up?  Are we fine with incompetent prosecutors?  Are we fine with prosecutors who deliberately skirt, even break, the law when they do their job?

There is nothing conceptually wrong with our expecting that prosecutors perform their function competently and lawfully.  Certainly, no one would argue that prosecutors have a right to be either incompetent or malevolent.  So where’s the problem?  Well, mistakes happen, prosecutors respond.  Nobody is perfect, they say.  To err is human.

Yeah.  That’s what we say about the defendants too.  Why is that argument more persuasive when it’s your butt on the line?  I guess the value of mercy and understanding all depends on who’s paying.

The argument in opposition is precisely what one would expect.


In their appeal to the Supreme Court, lawyers for Van de Kamp and Los Angeles County said the 9th Circuit’s decision, if allowed to stand, would “open the floodgates” to suits against top prosecutors. They said plaintiffs could always allege that a managerial lapse led to a faulty prosecution.

There are a lot of potential floodgates in this country.  People are always screaming about them.  They must be very, very afraid of drowning.  Do you wonder what they are hiding that makes them so afraid?

The fact is that an opening like this, a tiny crack in prosecutorial immunity, has no floodgate potential at all.  The number of cases where a defendant is convicted, then subsequently reversed based upon some prosecutorial failure of any sort, is minuscule.  Reversals of convictions happen rarely, and within that extremely rare universe exists such a tiny subset of reversals due to prosecutorial misconduct or failure that it would not even make a ripple.

It’s the accountability that frightens them.  It’s the very idea that they would be held responsible for their failures, whether deliberate or not.  And why shouldn’t they be?  It would do a world of good for the integrity of the system if prosecutors were afraid, very afraid, of being held accountable for their mistakes in fulfilling their very important function of putting human being in jail.  They should be afraid of being wrong.  They should be scared to death of convicting innocent people because they screwed up.

Indeed, as per the discussion at Gideon’s blawg, the reality is that attorney discipline rarely is applied to prosecutors, even after courts hold that they have committed misconduct.  Traditionally, the expectations of ethical conduct by prosecutors are so low, and the willingness to turn a blind eye to their ethical lapses is so high, that they have no reasonable fear of being held accountable in any forum for their failings, whether deliberate or incompetent.  Essentially, they are given carte blanche to be bad.

This is not to say that many, if not most, prosecutors try their best to perform their function ethically and competently.  Indeed, this is why there are so few instances where a lack of immunity would present a problem.  Most prosecutors do a very good job, whether we agree with them or not.  The Nifong cases are a monumental rarity, which is why it’s received so much attention. 

So what do prosecutors really have to fear?  That they will be held to the standard we expect of them.  I fail to see anything wrong with that.

Things That Should Never Happen

Inspired by a post at Kevin, M.D., about “never events,” things that should never happen in medicine.  What things should never happen in law?

Think of this as a legal Rorschach test.

Innocent people should never be convicted.

Police, except when serving undercover, should never lie.

Public officials should never break the law.

Poor people should never be denied access to a lawyer.

Children below the age of 14 should never be treated as adults.

Mentally-challenged people should never be taken advantage of.

Judges should never find police witnesses credible by default.

Pretext stops should never be constitutional.

Government should never spend more on prisons than education.

Lawyers who cannot try a case should never represent criminal defendants.

Please let me know what other “never events” should be on the list. 

Op-Eds Must Still Be Grounded In Reality

Georgetown 3L Joseph Sant has quite a feather in his cap, having an  Op-Ed published in the New York Times.  It’s not easy to do under any circumstances, and particularly when the author is still a student.  It’s well-written piece.

If only that were enough. 

Sant writes of the suffering of the Legal Aid Society.  I can think of a long list of grievances that the LAS could properly advance, from their lack of funding to their being overworked and wrongly treated like the dregs of the legal profession.  Unfortunately, these are not the grievances advanced by Sant. 

The Times piece is all about the Legal Aid Society’s representation of “poor homeowners caught in the subprime-mortgage meltdown.”  Huh?  In some places, the LAS provides civil representation to those qualified with regard to foreclosure.  There’s nothing wrong with that, despite the fact that the LAS generally is stretched too thin to provide criminal defense to the indigent.  If they can provide aid, that’s good.

But Sant’s view is that the LAS should be at the forefront of a political campaign to win cash and prizes for the subprimers.  That’s another matter altogether, and the sort of argument that will make people push to withdraw support for funding the Legal Aid Society for being where they don’t belong.

But [Legal Aid] lawyers are hamstrung by federal regulations that limit homeowners’ access to speedy, low-cost legal relief.

No, No, No.  There are no regulations that limit homeowners’ access to anything.  There are regulation that limit the LAS, which receives governmental funding, from engaging in political activities.  Homeowners are free to go hire a lawyer, whether by fee or contingency, any time they want.  A good time might have been before they signed their names 37 times on the mortgage papers.

One restriction prohibits legal aid lawyers, unlike their corporate counterparts, from collecting attorney fees on behalf of vindicated clients. Fee awards are an incentive for both parties to negotiate quickly because legal costs increase as litigation drags on. Recalcitrant lenders can stall as long as they like, knowing it will cost them nothing.


First, let me say that it doesn’t quite play out that way, but this would reflect the difference between a law student’s theoretical view of the world versus real life.  Since the vast majority of civil cases settle, no attorneys fees are awarded regardless of their availability.  And it is always in the defendants’ interest to drag things out.  But more importantly, what exactly do you mean by “vindicated clients?”  Are they plaintiffs or defendants, and if defendants, in what action.  Foreclosure?  As in they committed to paying 6 times their monthly earnings, and should now be relieved of that responsibility?  And keep the house?  Where do I sign up?


Another counterproductive regulation prevents legal aid lawyers from lobbying lawmakers with solutions to repair our mortgage markets. Policy deliberation is an echo chamber, dominated by financial players, excluding legal aid experts, who criticized short-sighted deregulation.

Well, that’s neither quite true nor quite right.  There are associations representing the perspectives of indigent defenders that engage in lobbying efforts.  But they aren’t lobbying on behalf of the poor homeowners?  Maybe that’s because the definition of victim in this situation is hardly as clear as you think.  And what “solutions” do LAS lawyers know that no one else has thought about?  Maybe they should just whisper it to some other “unrestricted” lawyers, who can then wrap Congress around their pinky and fix this whole mess.  If they have an answer, don’t keep it a secret.  Hey, just stick it in the comments below and I’ll personally forward it to Congress.  I’m sure they will appreciate it, and I’ll give the LAS credit for the idea.


Finally, federal law forbids legal aid lawyers to undertake class action litigation, preventing them from attacking systemic abuses in the real estate industry. Class actions offer the best chance for taking on foreclosure fraud, identifying illegal fees, recovering stolen equity and sending powerful signals to would-be predators. Instead, legal aid lawyers must prosecute cases one at a time.

While I seem to recall Michele Maxian, formerly of the New York Legal Aid Society, doing some “special projects” involving class actions, let’s assume that Sant’s correct.  When it comes to his poor homeowners, what class actions is Sant talking about?  Downtrodden Homeowners who agree to take mortgages they can’t afford versus Evil Subprime Lenders who give mortgages to people with no assets and no income?  Don’t they teach students at Georgetown that when claims are dependent on the individual facts of each case, they really aren’t class action material?  And if he wants speedy justice, class actions certainly aren’t the way to go.

I don’t for a moment doubt that Sant’s heart is in the right place, and his arguments are all well-intended.  But promotion of well-intended but misguided positions tends to invite rebuke that just makes things worse.  I strongly support the work of the Legal Aid Society, and I don’t want to see it become the butt of public ridicule over squandering its very limited resources on a blanket vision that homeowners are victims, an argument with which many (myself included) have some very real issues.


Most homeowners facing foreclosure did not seek out perilous mortgages with irrationally high interest rates, nor were they able to bargain with lenders on an equal footing. Subprime lenders aggressively went after the financially unsophisticated like the elderly, their fixed incomes strained by the increasing cost of living, and those in low-income and minority neighborhoods.

If the federal government had not weakened and silenced legal aid, borrowers would have been far better protected against the abuses of our unregulated subprime mortgage industry. Now that many of these families risk losing their homes, we should get rid of misguided regulations on the lawyers who can best help them.

These rates aren’t exactly irrational.  These subprime lenders provided a means for people without savings to purchase a home, something they could never had done otherwise.  They assumed significantly higher risk, and needed significantly higher returns to cover the losses when a significantly higher proportion of borrowers defaulted.  Had these evil lenders not been so evil, these poor homeowners would not have been homeowners. 

Had the real estate market itself not bottomed out, then crashed, these same poor homeowners might have been able to refinance based upon the undeserved equity in their homes, obtained better rates and lived happily ever after inside their very own home.  Don’t you see that this opportunity would have never existed without subprime mortgages?  They just don’t give homes to people with no money because they have a nice smile.

Is it true that many subprime borrowers didn’t appreciate what they were getting into?  Of course, but then the same holds true for so many things in our society, where people act on matter of great importance in their lives with little thought and less knowledge.  Should the LAS have opened “mortgage closing clinics” to advise poor homeowners not to sign those bad mortgage papers because of their “irrationally high interest rates?”  Would you feel better knowing that you saved your clients from high interest and denied them any chance of home ownership?

I think it’s wonderful that a law student has gotten an op-ed published in the New York Times.  For Joseph Slant, this is a great day.  For the Legal Aid Society, not so great.  What backlash this will cause to impair the LAS’s primary function, the defense of the indigent, has yet to be seen, but the door is wide open for its detractors.  The work of the Legal Aid Society is too important to be sideswiped by a piece like this, and the New York Times should know this and be more responsible about what it publishes.

A Heartfelt Reply to Alberto Gonzalez

Dear Mr. Gonzalez:

Thank you for sending your resume for a position with my firm.  I applaud your many accomplishments, which reflect well upon your work ethic and ability to get along with your superiors.  These are both important to one’s success in the law, as well as many other endeavors.

Your interest in joining the ranks of attorneys representing criminal defendants after many years working for the government is curious.  While it is clear that you have a great depth of experience, and your ethnicity would be appealing to many of the accused who would feel comfortable with someone sharing the same cultural background, there is no indication that you have gained any insight into the world of defending individuals prosecuted by the government.  Without such an epiphany, your dedication to the service of criminal defendants is suspect.

Even if I was to assume that your interest in changing sides was sincere, few of the skills you gained in your career to this point will transfer well to the defense.  We do not tend to write many memos on the subject of authorizing conduct in which our clients might wish to engage.  When such questions are posed by our clients, they often seek a means of engaging in unlawful conduct.  We do not assist them in such things.  It would be illegal, and we would be culpable for our conduct.

The work of a criminal defense lawyer is often unpleasant and frustrating, making it a marked change from the experience that you have enjoyed to this point.  We rarely find that courts assist us or are sympathetic to our goals.  Frequently, we find that our clients are undeservedly vilified by our own government.  But you are likely aware of this already. 

We are also frustrated by the lack of resources available to the defense in our litigation.  As you may know, the government has many special agents, experts, laboratories and the ability to gather information from sources about which we are as yet unaware.  The defense, on the other hand, has few resources at its disposal, and those that are available are often beyond our clients’ means.  This shifts the burden of representation onto the lawyer alone, and will likely be far less satisfying than your experience with the government.  After all, if the government needs more resources, it need only raise the spectacle of fear and then tax at will.

But most significantly, we are facing an economy that imperils the ability of individuals to mount a defense based upon the costs involved.  Between lost jobs, the devalued dollar and rising basic costs, few defendants are able to afford private criminal defense counsel.  This, of course, means that our need for additional staff is limited.

I’m sure that a person with your background, as a former Attorney General of the United States of America, will have little difficulty finding a suitable position.  After all, name recognition alone should serve to make you a very desirable new hire for those law firms who wish to assert greater influence amongst a select group of individuals in our nation’s capital.  You must certainly have some valuable information of interest to very important people, though these are unlikely to be the type of people that would be of interest to my clientèle. 

I wish you the best of luck with your search for a job, but I am sorry to inform you that there is no place for you with my firm.

Sincerely,

/s/

From the Times.

SCOTUS Reporting: Just the Facts?

Dahlia Lithwick at  Slate questions whether it’s time to change the way the Supreme Court press corps reports, causing uproarious laughter to emanate from Rupert Murdoch’s Centre Island manse. Prodded by a comment from Jack Shafer, the question was motivated by the “changing of the guard” at the New York Times.

In the Web era, is the best use of the Times’ column inches the traditional day-after-oral-arguments story and the day-after-decisions dispatches? Is there a more creative way to report on the court? Should Liptak cover the court with more argument and greater point of view, the way he covers the law in his current Sidebar column? Whether dug-in journalists are excellent or mediocre, their departures give publications the opportunity to reinvent themselves.

Oh my.  Well, this is a rather scary proposition, isn’t it?

As previously discussed, Adam Liptak’s elevation to Supreme Court God is a  source of some concern for me.  But the idea that basic reporting of Supreme Court decisions be given the blessing to stray to the editorial strikes me as nuts.

Journalism has long left the realm of a dry recitation of the basic facts.  Whether because of our need to be entertained or our lack of basic ability to draw the facts from an article and formulate an opinion, we are fed a diet of cherry-picked information spun in a way to suggest right and wrong, good and evil, funny and stupid, from the outset.  But the fight has always been to keep straight journalism in line, challenging stories that are editorialized beyond the point of factual recognition.

While it can well be said that reporting already prevents us from questioning the content of the story, we still need to believe that we’ve been given the basics in a relatively trustworthy fashion.  When the New York Times story on the bullying of Billy Wolfe made the  decision to omit an entire side from the story, I was outraged.  After learning the ignored information, it barely made a dent in my thoughts on the subject, but the fact that I, the reader, was denied a full and accurate story was offensive.  Whether it’s the Times or the Post, I don’t care.

In the blawgosphere, there are often significant disagreements about the merits of Supreme Court news, reflecting our world views, relative worth of law versus order, freedom versus equality, whatever strikes us based upon the nature of the case.  But these discussions will be reduced to flights of fantasy if we do not have some reliable means of learning what happens down there in Washington.  True, we could all go watch the arguments ourselves, but then we would be very hungry since we would be unable to earn a living.

As for the rest of the world, less obsessed with doing in the law than blawgers, they too are entitled to a little straight poop on the Supremes.  Given how confused most non-lawyers are about the law, the current trend in reporting, making it readable for the “ordinary person,” already presents a substantial obstacle to the public understanding what is happening.  Reporters already “interpret” the complexities and “boil them down” to make their stories more comprehensible.  By definition, this means they filter their stories through their own vision, and inherently change them to conform with the reporter’s understanding.  What the Supreme Court does and says can be fairly important to our society.  It’s worth the effort to report it well and honestly.

I don’t trust information filtered through minds and hearts before it gets to me.  I may agree or disagree, but it’s still dubious information.  With the new golden boy in town, I’m even more afraid, since my view of his past work is that his understanding of the issues that most concern me is spotty at best.  As I’ve written here, there have been numerous instances where his depth of understanding didn’t scratch the surface.  Is this the best I can hope for in the future?  Not good enough.

Lithwick’s interest, in taking the expertise of the small group of Supreme Court journalists, and giving them rein to spread their word because they, more than anyone else, know the Supremes is a questionable proposition in the first place.  They may have their fingers firmly on the pulse of 9 people in D.C., but do they have the feel for the legal world everywhere else?  What do they know about how big words in Washington play out on the street, or in the courthouse hallways? 

There’s plenty of room on the editorial pages for opinions of all size and description.  If they want to wear their politics on their sleeve, as if they don’t already, that’s the place to do it.  But keep Supreme Court reporting straight.  At least as straight as we can.  At least try.

H/T Orin at Volokh.

Making America Safe for the Chi-Coms

I  questioned why some genius in San Francisco decided that a torch was more worthy of police protection than American citizens exercising a basic constitutional right.  Now I learn from  Marc Randazza that it was worse than I thought.  Per this Daily News article :

As she ran with the flame, Majora Carter, 41, a South Bronx environmental activist, whipped out a small Tibetan flag to condemn China’s human rights abuses in the Himalayan province.

Carter said a Chinese paramilitary squad escorting the torch pounced and turned her over to cops, who pushed her into the crowd.

“Apparently, I’m not part of the Olympic torch-bearing entourage anymore,” Carter quipped.

Now how come nobody mentioned that there was a Chinese paramilitary squad accompanying the torch?  On American soil? 

And since when do San Francisco police officers take their marching orders from the Chinese?

While some readers who show a strong preference for order over law may argue that my view of what the police should have been doing with regard to the protesters along the secret, ever-changing torch route might have been disrespectful to the “spirit” of the Olympic Games (as if the Chinese abuses in Tibet aren’t), what our cops did to Majora Carter can’t be so easily dismissed.

Majora Carter’s act of defiance cannot possibly be viewed as disruptive to the travel of the torch (that would be the torch that is more important than human beings) since she was the torch bearer.  She carried it.  She ran with it.  She went in the direction she was supposed to go.  She just took out a small Tibetan flag as she did so.  Where’s the harm?

Randazza’s description (with quite vivid imagery) of the Chinese troopers, together with our very own police, abrogating Carter’s political act goes much farther than here.  But adding to the mess comes the reactions of a few other torchbearers:

Fellow torch-bearer Richard Doran, 57, a retired FDNY firefighter, called Carter’s maverick move “disgusting and appalling.”

“I think she dishonored herself and her family, and if she wanted to do that, she should’ve given up her spot to someone else,” said Doran, 57, who carried the torch wearing his Rescue 4 helmet to honor firefighters killed on 9/11.

Retired NYPD cop Jim Dolan, 64, who also carried the flame, agreed, saying, “That was not the time and place to do it. We were there to represent the best of American citizens.”

Unless I’m mistaken, the “best of American citizens” is to blindly support Chinese communist abuse in Tibet.  Since when did New York’s Finest and Bravest become a bunch of commie lovers?

Of course, they really aren’t commie lovers.  They are rule lovers.  They are lovers of Order.  They do what they are told.  There is no higher calling than to maintain order.  And that is perhaps the worst indictment of what happened here.

While we’re busily whipping out rhetoric in other quarters about how young Americans are dying to protect our freedom, situations like this smack us in the face to remind everyone that few even comprehend what freedom means.  It makes their deaths that much more tragic, and our freedom that much more tenuous.  But it sure makes us swell with pride when it said with patriotic music in the background.  I wonder if the Chinese goon squad feels the same way?