Author Archives: SHG

Stay Pending Writ of Prohibition Granted in Filipino Nurses Case (Update)

I wrote about  this strange case back in March, where the Suffolk County District Attorney indicted an attorney, Felix Q. Vinluan, for allegedly advising 10 Filipino nurses to quit their jobs at a nursing home in the middle of a shift, thereby putting the home’s residents at risk.

At the time, the ADA handling the case contended that Vinluan hadn’t merely advised, but actively solicited that they abandon their patients.  It was this claim of active involvement in pushing for abandonment that Leto claimed was the reason for the indictment.

Well, Lato, the seasoned assistant who handled the Marty Tankleff fiasco with an iron fist, just got smacked hard by the Appellate Division, that granted a stay of the criminal proceedings pending the hearing and determination of a Writ of Prohibition, according to Newsday.


The Appellate Division’s temporary stay means the nurses will not face trial as scheduled on April 28 in Suffolk County Supreme Court, attorneys said. The court’s four-judge panel will decide whether the prosecution breaches federal labor law and free speech and anti-slavery amendments to the Constitution.

For those unfamiliar, the issuance of a Writ of Prohibition is only slightly more rare than the appearance of Haley’s Comet.  This never happens. 

The case was scheduled for trial on April 28th, and for now it’s going nowhere other than Monroe Street in Brooklyn.  While not a guarantee that the writ will be granted and the indictment tossed, it is certainly demonstrates that the Second Department is taking the defense’s arguments very seriously, and that they see them as having at least a strong chance of prevailing.

The prosecution of the nurses, aside from their attorney, was one that raises troubling questions of involuntary servitude.  Can it be a crime to walk away from a job, for if it can, and an employee cannot walk away lest he commit a crime, then has he not become a slave to the job?

But the prosecution of Vinluan, the attorney who advised the nurses, is another matter altogether. 

After I posted about this story in March, I received an email from Felix explaining what happened further.  Here’s what Felix Vinluan had to say:


I just read your blog entitled “Lawyer’s Labors Result in Indictment” posted on March 4, 2008.I am the lawyer referred to in your blog. The immigrant nurses were indeed contract employees.But not of Avalon Gardens – the facility where they found themselves designated to work at.They were contract employees of other nursing home facilities that sponsored them through the immigration process and that promised them direct-hire employment.The nurses entered into three-year employment contracts with their respective sponsoring employers.None of these indicted nurses entered into any employment contract with Avalon Gardens.Upon their arrival in New York, their recruiter, who happened to be working for a nursing employment agency called Prompt Nursing Employment Agency, d/b/a Sentosa Services, told them that there were no jobs available with their respective sponsoring employers, but that he could give them employment through Sentosa Services. 

The nurses were made to sign employment application forms with Sentosa Services, and were thereafter directed to work at Avalon Gardens.Their salaries were paid by Sentosa Services, which also issued them their Form W-2s.They were issued badges identifying them as “Agency nurses”.Whenever they had concerns or issues at Avalon Gardens, they were told to communicate their concerns to their agency.Thus, when these nurses came to seek legal consultation, I advised them that their employment contracts had been materially breached by their respective contracting employers, as these employers did not provide them any employment.I likewise advised them that as aggrieved parties to breached contracts, they could deem their contracts as having been voided. Further, considering the totality of their employment arrangements with Sentosa Services, they were actually employed by this nursing agency.And there being no employment contract between any of the nurses and the nursing agency, they were at-will employees, and could terminate their services anytime, in the same way that they could also be terminated by Sentosa Services anytime.


I did not view my legal services as simply part of a contract dispute.For in addition to advising these nurses about their immigration and contractual rights, I also advised them about their responsibilities as nurses, especially about the NYSED regulations on patient abandonment.I advised them that if ever they would resign, they should not resign in the middle of their shifts.It would interest you to know that even before the criminal investigation was begun by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office, the NYSED Office of Professional Discipline already found that the nurses were not liable for patient abandonment and that there were no moral character issues that would prohibit the issuance of their nursing licenses or permits.In fact, the nurses’ collective action in resigning after their concerns were not properly addressed by their agency and the facility they worked at was clearly a protected labor activity under the National Labor Relations Act, as amended.


It is my contention (as well as the nurses’) that the cases (civil cases for alleged breach of contract, pending before the Nassau Supreme Court; the administrative cases, that were already dismissed by the NYSED; and the criminal cases, pending before the Suffolk Supreme Court) filed against the nurses and me are but retaliatory action on the part of the politically-influential owners and lawyers of the Sentosa Enterprise to give notice to other immigrant nurses victimized by their pattern of fraud and misrepresentation in the immigration process that if they complain, they would suffer the same fate as well.More immigrant nurses would have come out to expose the fraud in the immigration process had Sentosa not begun its retaliatory actions.These cases likewise give warning to other lawyers not to represent these nurse-victims, because if they do and advise these nurses that they could resign, as I did, then they would also be made “ham sandwiches”.Newsday, last September 2007, published a two-series investigative report about the political clout of Sentosa’s operators and lawyers.  


Lawyers groups, such as the NY State Defenders Association and the National Employment Lawyers Association – NY, have openly come out to support me, and have asked Governor Spitzer to appoint a Special Prosecutor.But what about other bar associations?


May these remarks serve as a challenge to fellow lawyers to take a bold stand and denounce what is clearly an attack against the practice of our noble legal profession.It is my hope that lawyers still believe that ours is a country where the rule of law, and not the rule of men, reigns, and where disputes are won on the merits of the case, and not on who a party knows.


Thank you.


Felix Q. Vinluan


And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why we have courts.  It’s unfortunate that the Suffolk County judges can’t seem to find their way to the right side of any of these cases, though.  And where is the NYSACDL on all this?  Too busy struggling with how to cover their butts in their own mess to stand behind Felix Vinluan for this improper indictment?

UPDATE:  From the New York Lawyer,


But in a statement the lead prosecutor, Leonard Lato, said the stay is not “precedent setting” and such stays are “usually granted.”

Lato failed to respond when asked, “On what planet?”

Tapped to Represent “Orphans” at SCOTUS

I never knew such a thing existed, until now.  Via Doug Berman, from Tony Mauro at Legal Times, here’s the setup:  What happens when cert is granted and a case is headed up to the big bench, but both sides have agreed that the decision appealed is wrong?  In other words, no one wants to defend the circuit?

Answer:  Someone from the Supremes calls up a former law clerk and asks if they would take on the “orphaned” decision. 


On Jan. 7, Jay Jorgensen took an unusual call from his former boss, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Jr.  Alito’s request: Would Jorgensen have time to argue a Supreme Court case in April — a case Jorgensen had never heard of — for free?

In Greenlaw v. United States, it seems the government had decided that it agreed with plaintiff Michael Greenlaw on the main sentencing-related issue in the case.  So the Court needed someone else to argue against lawyers for Greenlaw, a Minneapolis drug dealer.

It had never occurred to me that a case would find its way to Washington and, between the circuit and the merits brief, would leave the decision below without a champion.  Go figure. 

My initial reaction was, if everyone agrees that the decision below was wrong, what becomes of the controversy?  But of course, it doesn’t mean that the sides agree on anything else, and it doesn’t mean that the reason for granting cert no longer requires the inclusion of argument in favor of affirmance lest the Supreme Court find its hands tied, it’s breadth limited, by this agreement between the parties.  SCOTUS isn’t saying it disagrees that the decision below is wrong, but that it wants to keep all its options open.

Apparently, this is the first time this has happened in 5 years, and now it’s happened twice in the same term.  What are the chances?  Well, they may actually be pretty good, given the sentencing decisions issued by the Supremes in the last term.  Great upheaval can do this to a circuit decision, and the lower decision may have been perfectly good law at the time, but things change.

So who does a Supreme Court justice call when he needs a friend?  Former law clerks, apparently.  After all, it’s not exactly a high paying gig.  In this case, former law clerks of Justice Alito (Jay Jorgensen) and Justice Thomas (Catholic University law professor Peter “Bo” Rutledge) have been tapped for the job.  But don’t feel too badly for them.  There is an upside:


Jorgensen, a partner with Sidley Austin, eagerly agreed to the invitation, and on Tuesday he will make his debut before the high court. In doing so, he follows a little-known and rarely available pathway that has launched the Supreme Court appellate careers of several former high court clerks.  Among them: John Roberts Jr., now chief justice, and Maureen Mahoney, who heads the appellate and constitutional practice at Latham & Watkins.

If they ever start a list of lawyers who would make themselves available to represent “orphan” decisions,  I’ll let you know.  But not until I put my own name on the list first.  Having never had the opportunity to argue before the Supremes, I think this is all very cool.

There is one particularly scary aspect to this unusual situation.  What if you represented the “orphaned” decision too well and won, undoing all the gains made?  Nah.

Reader Mailbag No. 3

I swear I get a lot of mail as a result of this blawg, but most of it is relatively boring and unworthy of the, ta da, reader mailbag.  But a couple are fun, and so here it goes.


Greenfield,

Your post was boring.  That’s two minutes of my life I’ll never get back.  Why would you bother to put something so bad up on your blog.  Were you too busy to bother?  Was it too much work to show your readers the respect of writing something worth the time to read?

If you don’t care enough to do a decent job, then don’t bother to publish it.

So you didn’t like a post, eh?  Bummer.  You want your money back?  I agree with you that not everything I write is Pulitzer Prize material.  But then, it’s not like anybody made you read it either, true?

So here’s the deal, if I post something the bores you, immediately stop reading and move on to the next post.  I guarantee that it will be thrilling.  It will make chills go up and down your spine.  And even if it doesn’t, what do you want from me? 

I write what I write.  Some subjects come out of the blue, and aren’t for everybody.  It’s possible that the only person interested is me.  That can happen.  But that’s why I write (and why SJ is here so you can come and complain), so you’re just going to have to suffer and bear with me.  By the way, if you think I have bad days, go read Bennett (Only kidding, Mark).


Greenfield,

You say that you want people to post their comments, but then you tell them they’re stupid when they do.  You’re a hypocrite and a lying sack of sh*t lawyer.  Hey, that’s redundant, isn’t it?

Well, you got me on that one.  No, not the childish vulgar potty humor (I’ve heard better), but that I say I want comments and then delete the stupid ones.  Here’s the problem:  When you write a comment that goes:

Lawyers are vultures.  They lie, cheat and steal.  They should all die.

It isn’t really helpful.  It says one thing, you hate lawyers, without any reason.  What’s to discuss, no lawyers aren’t vultures (and how could you insult vultures that way)?

It also doesn’t help to be the 7th person to say, I have a bad experiene because

I lost my case when my lawyer blew it, just because I drove my car into that person.  I was late and had to put my make-up on.  It wasn’t my fault!  So all lawyers are lying, cheating liar cheaters!

Does the fact that you were wrong in the first place extrapolate into all lawyers being evil?  Or perhaps it says that you, individually, have issues?  I think the latter, but this isn’t psychotherapy, so I really can’t help you here.  I hope that explains why I do it, and yes, comments should be limited to ones that are thoughtful, civil and reasoned.  You’re welcome to vent, but just not here.



Dear Lawyerpreneur and Friend,


 


     I want to share an unsolicited fax I received.  It read in part:


 


     “I was at a point in my practice when I was looking for a marketing guru to help me get to the next level of my law practice.  Nader Anise is that guy.  I found his ideas both innovative and practical.  Even though he is in great demand, he made himself accessible, answering my questions when I needed to communicate with him… I would highly recommend Nader to any attorney looking to take his practice to the next level.”  Peter Gemborys, Esq., Wilminton, NC


 


     Why am I sharing this with you?  Because the issue of “getting to the next level” is one of the most asked about topics in my business. 


 


     Well, guess what?  I have the answer and it may surprise you.


 


     EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY, I am going to do something that will excite many lawyers, intrigue quite a few… and… shock a handful (those who know me best).


 


     But, particularly, it will thrill those lawyers who are looking to get to the next level in their law practice.


 


An Exciting New Development…


 


     I am opening up two (and ONLY two) new slots in my super-successful coaching program, The Elite Earners.


 


     Believe me, being a part of Elite Earners is life-changing… and career changing.  It is sort of my “secret society” of lawyer superstars.  I am very protective of the lawyers in this group and shield the identity of each member at all costs.  I also keep the discussions, coaching calls and brainstorm sessions strictly confidential.  The less I talk about the program the better.  Although I have several big-name celebrity lawyers as members, you’d never know it.  They like it that way and frankly so do I.  Much less hassle.


 


     So, anyway, after continued pressure from many of my Lawyerpreneur subscribers, I have decided to add two additional slots for the Elite Earners Coaching Program.  Because I’ve cut down on my speaking engagements, I think I can swing another coaching client.


 


     Obviously, I want these slots to go to the most ambitious, motivated, goal-oriented, hard working lawyers out there.  The slots will be filled on a first-come, first-served basis… HOWEVER, I must personally approve your application first before you’re accepted.  Your success is as much an ego and pride thing to me as it is to you.  I want to make sure whomever I accept into the program is dead-serious about making big money in their practice.


 


     DETAILS:  WHAT IS THE COACHING PLAN ALL ABOUT?  Once a month (for exactly one hour), you and I will meet on the phone and conduct a coaching call.  I’ll listen to your ideas, your questions, your frustrations… and… your greatest challenges.  I’ll give you BETTER ideas, answers to your questions, specific strategies, resources, contacts, plans, and pretty much help you become wealthy as a lawyer.  That’s really the objective of this coaching program.  That’s why I call it, “Elite Earners.”  You will be part of a group of elite lawyers… and… you will be one of the top legal earners in the country.


 


     Frankly, there are certain strategies and secret marketing “formulas” that are reserved only for my Elite Earners.  I certainly don’t make all my secrets available publicly.  But my Elite Earners get it all – uncensored, unabridged and without holding anything back.


 


     One idea from me can result in tens of thousands – hundreds of thousands – of additional revenue per year.  It’s not unusual for that to happen.  In fact, it’s a frequent occurrence.


 


     Samuel Bearman, an attorney in Pensacola, Florida, credits me with helping him achieve extraordinary marketing success.  One time he and I spoke on the phone for only 12 minutes.  The result?  Over $437,000 in additional revenue.  Just from a 12 minute conversation.


 


     But that’s chump change compared to a settlement he reached thanks to some targeted marketing strategies I armed him with.  He sent me an email gushing how my advice…


 


     “… resulted in a settlement of $100,000,000 (one hundred million dollars) and I am now representing clients in another case that we believe may involve many millions of dollars.”  Samuel Bearman, Esq., Pensacola, FL



 


     It might sound hard to believe, but it’s true.  If you’d like to “read up” on me, take a look at the interview I did with Helena Bachmann.  It’s at:  www.NaderAnise.com/Bachmann.  But make sure you come to this page after you read the interview.


 


     In addition to the monthly coaching call, you will have access to me via fax and email on an unlimited basis (of course within reason).  I give my Elite Earners high priority when it comes to answering their questions.  Plus, you’ll receive insider invitations to programs that no one else gets.


 


     BUT I MUST WARN YOU:  If you miss your monthly coaching call due to something that is NOT an emergency, you will have lost your coaching call slot for that month.  These slots are extremely hard to come by.


 


     I’m not about to sell you on the benefits of having me as your marketing coaching.  Either you see it or you don’t.  But let me say this… my normal 1-hour consulting fee alone is $3,000.  If all you do is just speak with me for only half an hour a month for year, the fee is $18,000.  Add the unlimited fax and email coaching… and you’re at $25,000 per year. 


 


     But my Elite Earners members get a much better deal.


 


     Now who SHOULDN’T apply for the slot?  Listen.  I don’t mean to sound like a jerk.  But I have to be completely up front with you.


 


     From experience I usually KNOW who succeeds in this program and who doesn’t.  Even worse, I hate when people waste my time – even if they’re paying me big sums of money.  My ultimate goal is for you to be successful.  Once that happens, we both make a lot of money.


 


     So, here are the types of lawyers who shouldn’t apply. 


 


     DO NOT APPLY IF: 


 


1.  DO NOT APPLY IF paying the coaching fee will make you broke or close to it.


 


2.  DO NOT APPLY IF you’re not 100% committed to building a cash-cow of a law practice and becoming wealthy in the very near future.


 


3. DO NOT APPLY IF you’re difficult to work with or are unwilling or unable to take direction from me.


 


4.  DO NOT APPLY IF all you want is a sounding-board for your ideas… and WON’T eagerly implement the ideas I give you.


 


5.  DO NOT APPLY IF you have to ask every lawyer you know… every listserv member you have… your husband, your wife, your kids, your dog, if you should do this.  Seriously.  The most successful lawyers are the independent, quick decision makers.


 


6.  DO NOT APPLY IF you have NEVER ordered any of my products or attended any of my seminars.


 


7.  DO NOT APPLY IF you think you know more about marketing than me.  Believe me, we won’t get very far.


 


8.  DO NOT APPLY IF you are a law firm with more than two decision-makers regarding marketing.  I don’t believe in decision making “by committee.”  One or two decision makers – max.


 


9.  DO NOT APPLY IF you expect ME to do all the marketing and work for you.  This is a COACHING program.  That means you do the marketing work and I coach you.  I give you advice and ideas; warn you of potential pitfalls; and encourage you when needed.  I also give you access to many of my contacts.  I DO NOT do the marketing work for you.


 


10.  DO NOT APPLY IF you lack the burning, unquenchable desire to outearn, outperform and outlawyer every single attorney you know.  You MUST have that killer instinct.


 


     FEE:  For the year it’s $9,600.  If you’re getting chest palpations, this program is not for you.  But if you realize that $9,600 is a drop in the bucket compared to what I can do for you – AND you have the money – keep reading…


 


     To make sure you’re fully committed for the year, this fee must be pre-paid.  If you’re accepted, the only concession I’ll make is I’ll accept $4,800 now (by credit card or check) and another $4,800 in six months.  I’ll do this ONLY if I’m fully convinced that we’re on the same page and you’re on board with this 100%.


 


     But remember, I am only opening up two slots.  No more.  I’ll bet the ranch I’ll get many more than two applicants with a credit card in hand (did you know there are approximately 700,000 solos and small law firms in the U.S.?), so jump on this ON THE DOUBLE, if you want to be an Elite Earner.


 


     Attorney John Lauro (FL and NY licensed), one of the few Superstar lawyers who is willing to talk says this:


 


 


     “Last year, I took a bold step and asked Nader to become a mentor and a coach as part of the Elite Earners Program.  It cost a lot of money, but so does everything of true value – including each and every one of us.  It was worth every cent.  If truth be told, given what I have received, I would have paid more… Since teaming up with Nader, my income has grown more than any other time in my life; but just as important, I have increased the visibility of my firm, enhanced my professional relationships, and developed a better quality practice.   Nader has taught me how building a practice can be one of the most rewarding aspects of being a lawyer.”  John Lauro, Esq., FL and NY (Represented NBA referee, Tim Donaghy)



 


     HERE’S WHAT TO DO NOW:  I am going to respond to applications on a first come, first served basis.  So, that means… if you’re interested in applying, do so IMMEDIATELY.  (By the way, only apply if you can actually pay the fee.  Please don’t ask for any discounts or any other payment plans.)


 


     JUST SEND ME AN EMAIL (just click reply to the above email address) and respond to the following information:


Get lost, you flake.

Who’s Seeking Justice Anyway?

I stumbled on a new blog today after checking out  Houston Criminal Defense Lawyer Mark Bennett’s post, Lanyard Nation.  By the way, the lanyard post is worth reading just to see what the Texas Tornado could piece together on a dare.

This blawg is called Seeking Justice, by Tom McKenna.  It’s apparently been around for a while, but it’s new to me.  What I can’t figure out is who Tom McKenna is or what the philosophy behind this blawg is.  There are conservative and liberal aspects, with a heavy dose of libertarian thrown in as well. 

But if you can forgive me, I did think that  this post was (for the most part) very funny and too true.


School 1967 vs. School 2007

Scenario: Jack goes quail hunting before school, pulls into school parking lot with shotgun in gun rack.

1967 – Vice principal comes over, looks at Jack’s shotgun, goes to his car and gets his own shotgun to show Jack.

2007 – School goes into lockdown, the FBI is called, Jack is hauled off to jail and never sees his truck or gun again. Counselors are called in to assist traumatized students and teachers.

Scenario: Billy breaks a window in his neighbor’s car and his Dad gives him a whipping with his belt.

1967 – Billy is more careful next time, grows up normal, goes to college, and becomes a successful businessman.

2007 – Billy’s dad is arrested for child abuse. Billy is removed to foster care and joins a gang. State psychologist tells Billy’s sister that she remembers being abused herself and their dad goes to prison. Billy’s mom has an affair with the psychologist.

Scenario: Johnny and Mark get into a fistfight after school.

1967 – Crowd gathers. Mark wins. Johnny and Mark shake hands and end up buddies.

2007 – Police are called, SWAT team arrives and arrests Johnny and Mark. They are charged with assault and both are expelled even though Johnny started it.

There’s plenty more over there.  Yes, yes, I know that some of the changes are appropriate and not all politically correct “improvements” are inherently silly.  But our loss of perspective on ordinary human conduct versus the beloved trend toward our magic bullet solutions of zero tolerance, 3-strikes, etc., makes these painfully humorous observations meaningful.

So Tom McKenna, how about a link to an “about you” page so us newcomers to your blawg can learn a little bit more.  And for the rest of you, scroll down to the bottom of the page and check out the nuns.  It’s worth the trip.

Senator Sessions Gets Religion

The  bank-owned shills are silent.  Alabama Senator Jeff Sessions has made a sudden about-face on the patent overhaul bill and turned against the DataTreasury amendment, the very one he authored, or at least signed his name to after the bank lawyers handed it over to him on a silver platter.

According to the Washington Post,


Sessions announced his decision in a letter last week to Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick J. Leahy (D-Vt.). In the letter, he noted that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office said his amendment to a larger bill could affect more patented check technologies than originally thought and might undercut U.S. patent-protection efforts with trading partners.

“I wanted you to be aware of these developments,” Sessions wrote to Leahy.

That’s awfully thoughtful of him.  After all, the amendment was designed to screw just one specific company, as made clear by the banks’ concerted attacks to smear the Claudio Ballard for having the audacity to invent something that they really, really need.  Maybe the collateral damage would hurt another of Sessions’ close and dear friends?  Or maybe he thought no one would notice how he slipped in this piece of garbage amendment and, when people did notice, when people realize what he was trying to pull under cover of darkness, and he realized that he was caught red-handed, he suddenly found religion?  It happens in prison all the time.

But there’s one last question left unanswered:  Does Sessions have to give the money back?  After all, he tried really hard.

Also, at Patently-O, noted that Arlen Specter has pulled his support, and that the DataTreasury amendment has been pulled from the bill.

Clinton on Crime: Me Too!

I take no position between Hillary Clinton and Barak Obama, so please don’t read this as favoring one candidate over another.  It is, however, intended as a slam on the Democratic Party, lest anyone think otherwise.  It is not an endorsement of any other political party, mind you, but then at least the Republicans know what they stand for, regardless of whether it’s good or bad.

Via Volokh, we have Hillary’s stand on crime from the New York Times :

“Violent crime is on the rise again in America,” Clinton said. “There were 392 murders in Philadelphia last year, that’s an average of more than one a day, every single day.” [Ed.Note: Appreciate the math help, Hillary. That could have slipped right past most people.]

Clinton said the cost of her crime agenda was around $4 billion per year in new investments, which would be funded from savings from reducing corporate subsidies.

The plan foresees reinvigorating a 1990s police recruiting program known as “COPS” and would invest $1 billion a year to “close the revolving door” of prison inmates reverting to crime on release and going back behind bars.

She pledged reforming probation and drug policies so that non-violent drug offenders would be given a chance to get treatment and avoid jail if they stay clean.

Revolving door?  Now where have I heard that before?  Hey, Mike Dukakis, does that sound at all familiar to you?

There must be some rule in the presidential candidate playbook that requires them to announce a plan to put 100,000 more cops on the street.  Crime works.  Fear works.  People afraid of crime vote.  Forget whether putting the cash into education or healthcare would work better, they have to prove that they are tough on crime.  Or else.

The economy did very well under Bill Clinton.  But most of his judicial appointments would have made Ronald Reagan blush.  There’s no talk of personal freedom or civil rights or due process.  That would be loser talk.  That would be, dare I say it, liberal. 

Clinton adds the obligatory drug treatment proviso, because that’s in vogue.  But even her way of suggesting it smacks of too little, too late, too full of crap.  Whenever the words “non-violent drug offenders” is used, it smacks of being that little group of addicts who fall into the category of “harmless, good people who made a little mistake” that somehow manages to include a total of about 12 people.  Real defendants in the real world never seem to fit into the classification of criminals that the public loves and wants to help.  They live dirty, unpleasant lives that just don’t seem to evoke middle-class sympathy.

While there are other issues that may satisfactorily distinguish one party from another, it’s not criminal justice.  We lose in the ‘tough-on-crime” game no matter who gets the nod, and candidates of all flavors will trip all over each other to prove that they can protect us from the evil criminals. 

Wake me up when we get a candidate that stands for due process and wants to spend more on education than cops.

Lessons From Sean Bell: Conflicted Prosecution

When  I posted about the Sean Bell case, it appeared pretty clear that the prosecutor had not done a very good job of proving the case.  For those of you not in New York, this is the case where 3 undercover cops shot and killed Bell on the eve of his wedding, proving that there are indeed 50 ways to leave your lover.

So I had a chat with a former Queens assistant about the case.  I was told that the ADA, Charlie Tesagrossa, was one of their best (faint praise, but the best one can do), and that this trial was not reflective of his work.  This has been apparent, though has largely gone unnoticed.  The question posed was why the Queens District Attorney did not seek a special prosecutor to try this case.

This trial is a prime example of why police officers, as criminal defendants, fare far differently than anyone else.  There is an internal conflict that inherently exists, even though nobody wants to talk about it.  I want to talk about it.

Anybody who has ever seen the introduction to Law & Order (classic version) knows that the police and district attorney are two arms of the same corpse.  But on TV, they like each other.  They respect each other.  They work well together. 

Real life isn’t always the same as TV.  Cops don’t really like ADAs.  In fact, there is frequently an overwhelming desire for some 20 year cop to smack the crap out of some 2 year snot-nosed kid ADA who talks down to the cop, cooling his heels in ECAB, waiting to sign the complaint.  Some ADAs think cops are uneducated morons, all brawn and no brains, who bully their way through life hiding behind their shield. 

And cops know better.  They know that these little boys and girls, who are about 12 minutes out of their mommies’ guts, think that their 3 years in law school makes them special.  Cops know what happens on the street, and these kids “don’t know squat.”  Leave it up to them and they’d ruin a wet dream.

So this inherent tension has existed for as long as I’ve been around, and no doubt far longer.  It’s a good thing, in general, as it helps to keep both sides relatively honest.  Sure, there are the cop-lovers in the DA’s office, the ones who believe every dropsy claim because their beloved cops would never lie, but there are also the ones who try to keep the cops honest because they don’t care for a cop patting them on the head and telling them to just shut up and file the complaint.

But this tension has totally screwed up this trial.  It’s bad.  Instead of putting the best prosecution forward, the Queens DA has chosen to lay all its cards on the table, warts and all.  The reason is obvious.  The cops, upon whom the DA is forced to rely, are 110% behind the defendants in this case.  The cops are angry about this case.  They are angry with the DA for pursuing it. They are angry with the DA for turning on them.  They are angry with the DA for not having the guts to toss this case in the garbage, where the cops believe it belongs.

And so, the prosecutor has straddled the fence.  He has to try the case, but can’t go to war with the cops.  To go after the three defendants as he would with any other defendants would have been to declare war on the police.  This was not an option.  Treat these defendant-cops like defendant-mutts and no ADA would be safe from a parking ticket ever again.  More importantly, it would cause a rift in that side of the system that would be very hard to heal.  Cops are vindictive and have a long memory.  There would have been payback.

The Queens District Attorney should never have handled this prosecution, as it suffers from a clear conflict and that conflict has negatively impacted on the fulfillment of its duty to the People of the State of New York.

To the extent that people doubt that police are held accountable for their conduct the same way other people are, the Sean Bell case is a flagrant example that this is the case.  These cops have not been treated like everyone else.  They have no been subjected to the same level of prosecutorial intensity, purpose and effort.  They have been given the trial that every defendant wants, but only cops receive.

Regardless of the outcome of this trial, it has made one thing clear.  Cops are treated differently.  Now we know for sure.

Note to Ken Lammers :  Yes, we do have special prosecutors in New York.  But the Queens District Attorney, Richard Brown, chose not to use one but to prosecute this case in house.  Brown is regarded as police afficionado.

Hey Sailor, Wanna Date?

Ah, the number of times I heard a woman of the evening ask this question while walking along East 23rd Street on a balmy spring evening back when I was in law school.  I used to respond, “how about a movie?”  I never got any takers.  But if nothing else, East 23rd around Park Avenue South was always “social”.

Kevin O’Keefe at  Real Lawyers Have Blogs has picked up on a significant bit out of the Q&A of  Canadian blogger Steve Matthews (didn’t he used to have a band?) about  something that they do better than us.


One aspect Canadian law bloggers do very well is the social side of blogging. We actively read and link to each other’s blogs. There are many great conversations, debates, and generally a strong web-community being developed.

It could be the fact that we’re smaller, but I also give a lot of credit to Slaw.ca, our Canadian legal blogging co-op. Simon Fodden has done a great job of expanding both the range of participants and the topics we’re discussing. There’s also a core group of us that work hard at welcoming & acknowledging new Canadian legal blogs. I think that’s important.


Kevin agrees wholeheartedly, and I know Kevin to not only be sincere about this, but the type of guy who puts his money where his keyboard is.

As if Kevin’s point was enough, Dan Hull at What About Clients? jumps on board as well.  If Kevin and Dan say something, I listen. 

Their point is clear:  Why aren’t American blawgers being “social” with their blawgs?  Some guys with great stuff, interesting and provocative, link to no one, acknowledge no sources and exist as little isolated islands (in the stream; no wait, that was Kenny Rogers.  Wrong band). 

A while back, I complained about how there were certain isolated groups of bloggers, who would banter back and forth between themselves but rarely let outsiders into the conversation.  It was like high school cliques, and if you weren’t one of the cool kids, you were nowhere.  This post had a bit of an impact, and some of the older, more established blawgs decided to be a little less insular.  It didn’t hurt too much.

But the phenomenon continues still with others.  One blawg I link to all the time, Jonathon Turley (who calls his blawg Res Ipse Loquitur, but I always refer to as just plain old “Turley”) never links to anybody.  I think he gets stuff from other blawgs (mostly because I know that others post things before him, but he still doesn’t acknowledge their existence.  Not that I plan to stop reading and linking to him, because he’s got great stuff and he’s very provocative, but I can’t help but wonder why?  Is this a political statement?  Is this a lawprof thing where he sees nobility in isolation?  Beat the heck out of me. 

Speaking of the lawprofs, even they have come out of their tower and played in the gutter with the rest of us.  Sure, they were a little defensive in the beginning, but once they figured out that real lawyers don’t bite, they turned out to be okay.  And, though I will deny this is anybody ever tries to use this against me, they really are quite smart.  Well, most of them, anyway.

Which brings me to the practical blawgosphere.  We’re pretty good about welcoming new blawgers, and linking to others.  True, we do a lot of internal link-love, but that’s because we have a lot in common and we tend to find the same stuff interesting.  Plus, it allows us to have conversations that bring all of our blawgs into play. 

Some in the practical blawgosphere are better than others, of course.  I think  Gideon, who has been a bit light on posting lately (probably because he’s carrying 789 cases), is probably the best.   Bennett is very good about this too, though he’s kept busy just dealing with the daily dose of new Texas blawgers.   Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer Jamie is also a trooper in the cause (that’s another one you owe me, Jamie).  But even amongst the blawgers who make real efforts to link to others, to welcome the newbies, our blawgospheric social life could be better.

So why aren’t we as social as we could be in the blawgosphere?

A few things come immediately to mind.  First, some blawgs appear out of nowhere, post like crazy, then disappear into thin air.   Malum in Se did that, and now nobody can find him anywhere.  Many blawgs just don’t post enough to follow, not that they don’t have good posts when they do, but there’s only so much time to read and searching out the very occasional posts is just too much effort.

Another problem is that many blawgs that have potential end up resorting to self-promotion, either because that’s their underlying purpose or because they just don’t have anything else to write about.  There isn’t much to link to when a blawg’s content is all about “me”. 

And of course, there’s always the volume problem, meaning that there are just too many blawgs around to keep track of, and I’ve found some great blawgs that I somehow totally missed before.  The only explanation is that there’s more going on than anyone can follow.  The numbers can be overwhelming.

But there is also one insidious reason that remains in the background.  Blawgers have a certain internal interest getting their own eyeballs, and they don’t want to share those eyeballs with other blawgs.  Some will share easier with close friends, but are a little more reluctant to link to sources they view as competitors.  Some are reluctant to even link to close friends, the competitive spirit overcoming their congeniality.  In light of the volume issue, the concern about eyeballs is understandable, though I bet that the more linking one does, the more eyeballs come your way.  Protectionism has its price.

As for me, I enjoy the social aspect of the blawgosphere.  Bantering with lawprofs is fun.  Arguing amongst the practical blawgosphere is informative.  Finding totally new blawgs in totally unrelated practice areas has given me a ton of new things to consider.  This has been much more intriguing than the practice of law ever way (though I’ll deny ever saying this too).  But I could do much better at being social, and I’m going to give it my best.

And by the way, if you’re a blawger and I haven’t linked or mentioned you, let me know.  If you’ve got anything to say, I’ll be happy to go on a date with you.

Free Consultations No More

This is more of a Norm Pattis post, so it may be significantly above my usual banter.  For many years, there was no charge for an initial consultation.  After all, how could a client decide to retain me without a sit down and chat?  It was how this business worked, and who was I to be different.

No more.  I actually feel quite badly about it, but I’m left with no choice.  Over the past few years, there has been a spate of “potential” clients seeking a consultation with me.  They have no intention of retaining me to represent them, as they are a little too price sensitive for that.  No, they come to see me for an entirely different reason.

This isn’t the initial consultation of the old days, but a consultation in the truer sense.  They want me to sit down with them, read the papers, hear their story and then tell them what can be done and how to do it.  The presentation is how I would represent them if I am retained.  But I won’t be retained.  They want a cheap lawyer, but expensive advice.

The economy is in the toilet, and people are tight with their money.  I can’t blame them.  I am too.  But I have only a few things to offer, my skills as a lawyer and my personal integrity.  Both are taken from me when a person pretends to seek counsel but is really looking for a free ride on strategy or options that he can bring to someone else for execution.

Yes, I realize that it’s not going to work out as well for the defendant, since the execution of a honed defense strategy is not a simple matter, and still as dependent on the skill of the lawyer as the development of the strategy itself.  But that’s the defendant’s choice, not mine. 

I’m here to represent people.  It’s what I do.  But I feel no shame in being paid for my services.  I do, on the other hand, prefer to not allow people to take advantage of me, even if I realize what they are doing.  Should I give my legal advice away for free, it is my choice.  It is not something that I will allow to be taken away from me by deception or subterfuge.

And so, to avoid this from continuing, I no longer offer an initial consultation for free.  I would be honored to devise a strategy for you and provide you with the wealth of available options, including an assessment of their viability.  But there will be a fee for this service.  This is what I do as a lawyer.

Bennett will disagree with me (as he has in the past) and tell me that he will offer a free initial consultation to anyone who asks, since that’s how a criminal defense lawyer gets his business.  But then, he may not have a situation like mine.  I think Norm may understand better why I do this. 

Indigent Defense Caps Make Rates a Joke

While legal aid lawyers get a salary, private lawyers who take assignments to defend the indigent are in a totally different boat.  A few years back, they went to war to get the rates increased so plumbers would stop laughing at them.  Eventually, they succeeded in obtaining an increase in the hourly rate that allowed them to almost break even.  It was a grand victory.

Except there is still a dirty little secret lurking behind these indigent defenders, and Carolyn Elefant did her math and figured it out. 


What do large-firm, white-collar criminal defense attorneys and court-appointed criminal lawyers have in common?  They both charge $650. Only for the Biglaw attorneys, that’s $650 an hour, while for court-appointed lawyers in Pennsylvania, it’s $650 for preparation of a felony case (or a whopping $2,000 for homicides).

It’s a cute way of comparing a harsh reality.  While many will complain about the $650 an hour lawyer, there are many more in the other category, trying to work within a $650 cap.  Where are the public screamers calling them vultures now?  They won’t know.  It’s not Stossel-worthy.


While court-appointed lawyers aren’t entitled to the same pay as their large-firm clients (whose clients can afford to pay huge fees), at the same time, $650 for a felony or $2,000 for a homicide is unconscionably low. At a bargain rate of $50/hour, that’s 13 hours for the felony case or 40  hours for the homicide. Kind of hard to squeeze in a trial with caps like that. 

If you’re a criminal defense lawyer, what do you do? Do you press your clients to take a plea? And how many of these cases do you handle at a loss before you stop accepting them at all? 

There’s the conundrum.  Most lawyers will ignore the cap, do their best to represent their client and, in essence, pay out of their own time for the cost of fulfilling the promise of Gideon, a cost that is supposed to be borne by society.  Then there are the others, the “plead ’em and weep” crowd, that will max out the cap and walk away.

Few will show any sympathy for the lawyers who defend the poor.  Even the good-guy lawyers can’t get a tear now and then.  But the numbers, as Carolyn shows, just don’t add up.  So what if they get $100 an hour.  The cap at the back end reduces the hourly rate to a farce.  Or the representation to a farce.  Take your pick.

Anybody at Biglaw want to limit their time to 13 hours preparation for a felony?  They can’t even prep for lunch that fast.  Welcome to the world of criminal defense.  For lawyers and indigent defendants.  Now that you see the numbers, you know what you’re getting.

And if your lawyer does his job regardless of the cap, he’s doing it on his own.  Remember that the next time you’re inclined to make fun of your “worthless” indigent defender.