It was getting more than a little depressing to see that new criminal defense blawgs were coming from Texas on a daily hourly basis, and here in New York, the mother lode of criminal defense (though thankfully nary the execution or polygamist sect), deafening silence.
Until now. I am thrilled to announce that a new blawg has moved into the neighborhood, Judgment Day, just a hop, skip and jump north of the Throgs Neck Bridge, in the Third Department covering 28 upstate counties.
Judgment Day is run by an appellate lawyer who calls himself “Blakely” (because Gideon is so old school), Blakely has already has plenty of great stuff posted. As we all know, appellate lawyers love to write, so I’m looking forward to another heavy hitter in the blawgosphere and hope he keeps up the posting on a daily basis.
Since most of us downstate guys don’t pay a lot of attention to the upstate arms of the Appellate Division, except when they make some serious gaffe, it will be great to have a blawger who’s got his finger on the pulse of the Third (and maybe even Fourth?) Departments so we can hear about the brilliant work they’re doing. After all, this is our very own Unified Court System, and as long as there is no conflicting downstate precedent, those decisions apply to us as well, though we mostly ignore them.
So go check out Blakely at Judgment Day and give him a welcome to the Blawgosphere.
Author Archives: SHG
Open Thread on Newsday Op-Ed
Much to my surprise, an Op-Ed of mine was given a full page in Newsday today. The topic is oversight of “baby government” lawyers, those stand-alone guys who just might be a little too confused or conflicted to provide the sole source of “legal” advice.
My solution to the problem is an inspector general, probably via the Attorney General’s office, to audit and provide support and oversight to these one-man-shows. Whether they are brilliant or incompetent, well-intended or malevolent, no single lawyer is so wonderful, so brilliant, so lacking in conflict, to do the job without competent eyeballs watching.
So if you have anything to say about the piece, this would be a good place to comment.
Consentus Interruptus
Yes, yes, yes . . . NO. Welcome to the new definition of rape, according to the Maryland Supreme Court. Per the Baltimore Sun (courtesy of Bashman),
The state’s highest court ruled yesterday that a man can be charged with rape if he ignores a woman’s calls to stop – even if she had previously consented to sex.
With this expansion of the legal definition of rape, Maryland joins seven other states whose courts have determined that a woman can revoke her consent after intercourse begins.
So much for a bright line test.
The unanimous ruling was grounded in a woman’s autonomy to make decisions about her body, which is certainly something that almost everyone can agree upon. But.
“This goes to the heart of women’s autonomy,” said Lisae C. Jordan, legal director of the Maryland Coalition Against Sexual Assault, which filed a brief in the matter. “It says that, yes, women do have the right to make decisions about something as intimate as sexual intercourse.”
No argument here. A woman absolutely has the right to give or not give consent, and similarly has the right to withdraw consent whenever she decides, for any reason or no reason.
But consider the flip side, creating a rapist out of a man to whom consent has been given to have sex when, in the midst of the act, the woman changes her mind. Or says she changes her mind. Or maybe claims afterward that she said she changed her mind. Or maybe just thought it to herself. Or later got angry because the man didn’t call like he said he would.
The myriad of possible problems with this scenario are endless. Bear in mind, this is not merely about the woman’s right to make decisions for herself, but her ability to convert her erstwhile lover into a lifetime sex offender in the wink of an eye. Talk about sexual leverage.
“This is a dangerous ruling,” he said. “What the court is saying is that every act of sexual intercourse in Maryland is potentially a rape, and if a man doesn’t stop on a dime, he’s going to jail.”
And this is under the best of circumstances. On the other side:
But women’s advocates and lawyers said the high court’s ruling was important because it makes clear that Maryland no longer relies on outdated common law in rape cases.
“Common law is an antiquated system where women had less rights,” said Marie Lilly, an educator at Turnaround Inc., a Baltimore-based nonprofit for victims of sexual assault and domestic violence. “This brings us into the 21st century.”
Maybe I’m just old-fashioned, but this is lunacy. Not because women should have sexual autonomy, but because this turns men into rapist miscreants who, a moment earlier and when they started, did nothing wrong. Aside from what this means for the sex offender registry problems, it imputes a moral culpability where none should exist.
This is over the line.
All Quiet on the West Texas Polygamist Front
Grits For Breakfast, following the lead of Robert Ambrogi at Legal Blog Watch, questions why the rest of the blawgosphere has had so little to say about the West Texas polygamy case, with hundreds of women and children at stake.
Robert Ambrogi at Legal Blog Watch graciously acknowledges Grits’ coverage of Texas’ raid on the Eldorado polygamist compound, but rightly questions why,
as the biggest legal story in recent weeks moves forward, one involving hundreds of lawyers and affecting the lives of many hundreds of women and children, the legal blogosphere seems blind to it all. As one who has come to look forward to blog commentary for insight and perspective, I am disappointed.
It’s a very fair point.
The easy answer is that this entire affair is so fundamentally foreign to my experiences that I really don’t know what to make of it. New York doesn’t get a lot of polygamy cases, and we have very few 1700 acre compounds with religious cults. It’s easy to apply an east coast sensibility to this case, and say they’re all a bunch of religious nuts doing sick things with kids. But is that really true?
This Mormon off-shoot strikes me as bizarre, much as the Waco situation did. But does that mean that a substantial group of people who have sincerely held religious beliefs are wrong and must adhere to the Judeo-Christian ethic that provides the moral parameters of our laws? If we are true believers in religious freedom, they why aren’t these people as entitled to practice their religion without civil interference.
Then there’s the question of the children. Were they sexually abused, or simply married off in accordance with the sect’s beliefs? Young girls may be below the age of consent that the law imposes, but that’s really somewhat arbitrary and fails to address the question of whether this is criminal or just different than the choices made by lawmakers and agreed upon by most people who don’t share their religious beliefs.
As the Texas prosecutors will argue that all children should be removed from their parents, I tend to think that this blanket approach is not merely overkill, but harmful to the majority of the children. Children need parents, and it hardly serves them to put them in foster care if there is no real threat to their safety.
But without having a firm understanding of what this really means, it’s impossible to take a meaningful stand on this case, or to offer any insight that would be worthwhile.
Sorry Grits. Sorry Robert. The reason that this blawg hasn’t had anything to say is that I just don’t have anything to say. Maybe I will once I have a better grasp of the situation, but until then I’m going to do the most helpful thing I can. Remain silent.
Batterer “Forfeits” Right to Confrontation
Can there reach a point where a witness, who refuses to testify against her live-in boyfriend charged with beating her nearly to death, becomes “unavailable” such that the prosecution can use her videotaped grand jury testimony at trial? According to this New York Law Journal article, that is now the case in New York, even when the “victim” testifies that she has no fear of the defendant and chooses not to pursue charges, with the First Department’s decision in People v. Byrd.
Jimmy Byrd was charged with beating his girlfriend, Jill J., and refusing to bring her to the hospital for treatment. She eventually went to the hospital 6 days later, where a doctor found that she would have died had she not received treatment.
While Jill J. gave videotaped testimony from the hospital to the grand jury, she subsequently refused to cooperate against Byrd. The prosecution decided that it was not going to let this happen, and moved to allow her videotaped testimony to come into evidence at Byrd’s trial.
During the hearing, Jill J. contended that she had chosen of her own accord to forgive Mr. Byrd and that he needed treatment in lieu of jail time. But Jill J. acknowledge that Mr. Byrd had violated an order of protection and called her on “many” occasions from prison.
The prosecution, in turn, called witnesses who contradicted Jill J.’s testimony that she did not fear Mr. Byrd. Ann Burgess, an expert on battered-person syndrome, testified that it is common for abuse victims, who are controlled and dependent on their batterers, to retract reports of abuse and later refuse to cooperate.
Justice James Yates held that the prosecution had proven that Jill J. was “unavailable” to testify as a result of the battered woman syndrome and permitted the taped testimony, meaning that the defense would be unable to confront the witness against him.
The Appellate Division, First Department, affirmed the conviction. Relying on the expert testimony of Professor Ann Burgess, the court concluded that the defendant maintained “coercive control” over Jill J. by calling her constantly from jail, and thus caused her to refuse to testify against him, giving rise to her “unavailability”.
Justice Moskowitz wrote: “[W]hen the People can prove by clear and convincing evidence that a defendant has procured the witnesses’s unavailability ‘through violence, threats, or chicanery,’ the defendant forfeits the constitutional right to confrontation as well as the protection that the rules against the admission of hearsay would have afforded him or her.”
While the degree of harm done to Jill J. makes this case quite an extreme example of “battered woman syndrome,” this decision takes a huge leap in stretching the concept of unavailability to a very dangerous place. Essentially, the case was tried backward, with the assumption that the crime had been committed, that Jill J. was a battered woman before any crime had been found, and giving monumental credence to the generic conclusions of the expert as to a particular individual’s motives and psychological state.
While the facts of this case are particularly egregious, this is the type of decision that will filter down to garden-variety spousal assaults, where the use of battered woman syndrome is not truly involved but used to overcome the recalcitrant witness and convict people without confrontation, cross-examination and in defiance of a witness who refuses to pursue the case.
Once the prosecution is no longer required to use living witnesses to testify as to facts, and need only trot out an expert to “explain” the crime based upon assumed facts, one has to wonder how it would be possible to defend.
The problem is that battered woman syndrome has been a double edge sword, with the defense using it to justify conduct by woman against abusive husbands and boyfriends in other cases. This time, it’s come back to bite the defense in the butt. It’s hard, on the one hand, to depend on this “scientific” testimony in defense of an indictment, and yet dispute it when used to conclude that a witness has been rendered psychologically unavailable as a result of it.
It’s unlikely that anyone will cry for Jimmy Byrd, but should this new “forfeiture” doctrine find its way into every domestic abuse case when a spouse or girlfriend chooses not to testify, it may do enormous harm to the concept of a trial and fundamentally alter the dynamic of how these cases are prosecuted and tried. This has the potential to be a very dangerous decision.
Avvo To Bloggers: Promote Us, Baby!
Just when you think it’s safe to read your email, a missive comes from Mark Britton, Avvo CEO, to all Bloggers:
Pardon the mass email, but things have been nuts. I would be grateful if you would spread the word.
Spread the word? As in, be your shill? And for free? Did I miss something?
Now I like Mark. I mean, we’re not as tight as I am with Paul, but we’re cool. If he sent me a private email, I’d keep it to myself. I’m no Avvo rat, you know. But this was sent, as far as I know, to the entire blawgosphere, so it’s not like I’m giving up any secrets here.
Since when did I become part of the Avvo Advertising Network? Did I ever do anything to suggest that SJ was available to “spread” the Avvo word? Rip it on occasion, sure. Comment on it when appropriate. But never to “spread” the word. I never signed up for this.
Confidential to Mark: Blawgs, at least this one, isn’t here to provide you with free advertising or promote your latest new “thing”. I didn’t think too much of the last two new “things” you did, if you will recall, and chances aren’t great that I will think much of the next new thing either.
Now, about this “about me” thing. Is Avvo the new facebook for lawyers? Apparently, that’s the idea. Post anything you want. Include pics and videos. “I like poodles and daffodils.” Mark says this is what lawyers are asking him for. Not this lawyer, mind you, but apparently someone must think this is where it’s at.
I suppose that there are probably lawyers who want to attach their promotional stuff to their Avvo page. Not surprising, given the lengths to which lawyers go to advertise these days. Is this providing the meaningful information to consumers that Avvo claimed was its reason for being in the beginning? Not quite, since self-puffery isn’t really consumer-helpful, but then no one has to look/read/watch any of it if they don’t want to, so it’s probably not particularly harmful either.
But I wonder how long before young lawyers start posting the stuff about themselves that has found its way into those embarrassing facebook pages, or making claims of greatness that are just outright lies or serious ethical violations. Will Avvo police the “about me” pages for content accuracy? How could they? It would be nearly impossible to know whether posted information was true or false.
And so it slides down, down, down. I thought Avvo was really doing well, challenging beleaguered Martindale-Hubbell, whose legal hegemony has fallen into the antique bin. But these new ideas keep reminding that every business model has the ability to grasp defeat from the jaws of victory.
Was this what you had in mind when you sent me the email and asked me to spread the word, Mark?
The Baze Underbelly
Finally, the Baze v. Rees decision is in. If you want get the shorthand version of the 100 page, 7-2 plurality decision, SCOTUSBlog has it covered. There are probably another dozen blawgs that are busily commenting on the Supremes ruling that lethal injection is constitutional.
The Court’s plurality adopted as a standard for assessing the validity of an execution method whether it poses a “substantial risk of serious harm.” It rejected the death row inmate’s proposal that the standard be “unnecessary risk.”
And that pretty much sums up the big picture.
Now for the little picture. Justice Scalia and that other justice have a concurring opinion. Who woulda guessed?
From the official SCOTUS syllabus:
JUSTICE THOMAS, joined by JUSTICE SCALIA, concluded that the plurality’s formulation of the governing standard finds no support in the original understanding of the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause or in this Court’s previous method-of-execution cases; casts constitutional doubt on long-accepted methods of execution; and injects the Court into matters it has no institutional capacity to resolve. The historical practices leading to the Clause’s inclusion in the Bill of Rights, the views of early commentators on the Constitution, and this Court’s cases, see, e.g., Wilkerson v. Utah, 99 U. S. 130, 135–136, all demonstrate that an execution method violates the Eighth Amendment only if it is deliberately designed to inflict pain. Judged under that standard, this is an easy case: Because it is undisputed that Kentucky adopted its lethal injection protocol in an effort to make capital punishment more humane, not to add elements of terror, pain, or disgrace to the death penalty, petitioners’ challenge must fail.
We are a kind and merciful people, you see. The point of the 8th Amendment cruel and inhuman clause is to prohibit any method of execution deliberately designed to inflict pain. It should kill, but not deliberately hurt.
For example, drawing and quartering? Out. Hanging. In. Iron Maiden? Out. Firing Squad? In. Embowling alive? Out. Embowling dead? The jury is out. Gibbeting? I didn’t know what this was until today. But it appears this too depends on whether it’s alive gibbeting or dead gibbeting. Well, that will have to await a further decision.
It’s all about intent. So as Edgar Allen Poe suggests, kill them with kindness. And that’s all you need to know about executing people in America.
This Apple Fell Far From The Tree
Judicial Reports posts about the reversal by the Appellate Division, First Department, of a decision by Justice Gregory Caro to deny suppression in People v. Gomez. There was no question that the defendant was properly arrested for driving erratically with a suspended license. But the inevitable search that followed became a source of some contention.
Justice Caro, a career Manhattan prosecutor before putting on a robe at Mayor Rudy Giuliani’s pleasure, is a familiar name to many of us. His father, John Caro, was a Justice on the Appellate Division, First Department. He was one of the finest that ever sat on that bench. John Caro started his career as a police officer, moving on to the law and later the bench.
Back in the good old days, when judges still considered the rights of defendants as being worthy of some consideration, John Caro held some sway. His experience as a cop on the street made him painfully aware of the games that were played, the lies that were told, the motivation to fudge the truth and the details to put the bad guy away, even when the evidence might come up a bit short.
Cops couldn’t fool Justice John Caro as easily as some others, because he understood what they were doing. It was wonderful to have John Caro on your panel. You knew there was one person sitting there who knew what really happened, and who wouldn’t just dismiss your argument and go with the odds.
Apparently, the son isn’t the father. Not that he’s a bad judge, as I’ve never had any personal experience before him and can’t claim to know what makes him tick. But he doesn’t have the experience that his father had on the street, and given the disinclination of appellate courts to reverse, the outcome in this case suggests that he blew it big time.
In the Gomez case, the Appellate Division held that the prosecutions argument that a search of the car post arrest was an inventory search, one of the plethora of exceptions that make the 4th amendment spin in circles. But at the suppression hearing, the prosecution neglected to put on any evidence that the procedures for an inventory search occurred. And then, there’s the telltale sign that no inventory was made. But why let details like tailored testimony stand in the way of a search when it comes up with evidence of drugs.
The reversal, however, was not without its dissent.
In a 4,300-word dissent, Justice James McGuire castigated the majority for cooking up objections to the search procedure that Gomez failed to raise himself. “The specific grounds upon which the majority relies are glaringly absent from counsel’s argument,” McGuire asserted. “By not raising these arguments at the hearing, defendant deprived the People of an opportunity to meet them with evidence.”
This is quite an interesting effort at salvaging the conviction. While the burden of proof at a suppression hearing falls on the defendant’s shoulders, the burden of production belongs to the prosecution. If they fail to produce, is it the duty of the defense to point it out to them so that they can try to find some way to fix the failure? Why would the defense want to babysit the prosecution to aid in them in getting your client?
But moreover, this points to the ongoing problem with appellate obsession with preservation, which has come to trump the Constitution in the review of convictions.
Justice John Caro, in his days on the Appellate Division bench, would have known better than to believe that a basic evidentiary search could be salvaged by calling it an inventory search. He would never have bought into the fictions that cops use to skirt the law, because he knew how the game was played. It’s unfortunate that his son, sitting on a different bench but with the authority to make similar decisions about the “fibs” told by police witnesses to get over the hump of the law, didn’t learn the lessons from his father that others did.
Man, I miss Justice John Caro. He knew.
We’re Martians to Civil Litigators
Via Dan Hull at What About Clients?, Chicago’s Stewart Weltman tries to explain criminal defense lawyers from his civil litigator perspective in a post entitled, “Criminal Trial Lawyers are From Mars, Civil Trial Lawyers are From Venus (A Lesson in Why They Sometimes Must Treat Cross Examination Differently).”
How do you not read a post with a title like that? So I did. And it was pretty long. And when I got to the middle, I realized that Weltman was right about one thing, we’re from a different planet than they are.
Weltman’s view of a criminal defense lawyer’s cross-examination came from an article about how
one of Chicago’s top criminal defense lawyers, over the course of his still on-going six day cross-examination of one of the government’s star witnesses in the Rezko political corruption trial, was wowing some of his colleagues with his cross-examination prowess.
I thought to myself, this is going to be about how criminal defense lawyers, skilled in the art of cross-examination, can surgically destroy a witness, bit by bit, inch by inch. My unrealistically optimistic expectation was that Weltman would level spectacular praise on the criminal defense lawyer for his brilliance on cross, something that no civil litigator could ever hope to accomplish given his limited trial experience and lack of artfulness. Oh, I was soon to have my hopes dashed. Not dashed, crushed.
But what struck me most in this article was not the descriptions of cross-examination prowess displayed by him. I would assume nothing less from an attorney of his caliber. Rather, what struck me was that the cross-examination had lasted six days and was still going.
No doubt criminal defense lawyers have to function in a different universe [or at least a different planet] and maybe that is the salient point for us civil trial lawyers to derive from this article. Clearly, if this were a civil case, it would have been settled long ago.
Oh, the love I thought I was feeling was ebbing from my body. Don’t play with those criminal defense lawyer kids, Johnny. They’re not like us. I could hear it coming.
This witness also wore a wire – recording very damaging conversations against the defendant. But this criminal defense lawyer has no choice. His client refused to agree to a plea, so he must plow on doing the best he can with what he has.
So under the any port in the storm theory, he has to hammer as long as he can on the witness’ drug use and faulty memory because this may be the only high point in the trial for his client’s case – hoping that this will be the jury’s last impression of the witness and that he can thereafter convince the jury that he ripped apart the core of the government’s case.
Boom. The assumption falls like a ton of bricks on the criminal defense lawyer’s head. The prosecution can’t be wrong. The criminal can’t be right. The defense can’t win. This is just a desperate effort to find something, anything, to fight the charge. There’s a certain tone of failed heroism to Weltman’s view, knowing that he can never prevail, this top-notch criminal defense lawyer just fights the good fight, knowing that in the end he will fail and justice will prevail.
And then comes the coup de grace for our tragic hero:
So while the article reveled in this lawyer’s undoubted cross-examination prowess, the back story was really about what a great criminal lawyer does in desperate straits. Using his courtroom prowess to essentially filibuster the government’s case because, quite frankly, the deck he has been dealt with – the overwhelming evidence against his client – requires that he do something – anything.
So this is how a civil litigator thinks criminal defense happens. And you wonder why defendants doubt the worth of a strong defense? If other lawyers don’t get it, what are the chances that non-lawyers will perceive the myriad of issues, problems and strategies that are available to the criminal defense lawyer. If other lawyers view criminal prosecution as a lost cause, why should non-lawyers think otherwise?
Civil litigators, who believe that they are court insiders and know how the system works, because they try a case once every five years or so, are part of the wink and nod crowd when it comes to criminal law. In their hearts, they think that anybody arrested is likely guilty, and that our efforts are all to find some trick, some gimmick, to fool the jury and get them off. They smile at us knowingly, that we represent the devil and play the game on the dark side to make a buck. Just like they do.
Having explained this to civil litigators more than a few times, I’m tired of telling them that not everybody is guilty, that not every cop is right, that violations of the Constitution are still worth fighting. They laugh, say “whatever”, and wink.
Weltman and I agree about one thing. We’re from Mars and He’s from Venus. Mars was the God of War, a fighter, and that’s what we do. We are not tragic heroes, fighting a futile battle. We try cases to win. If it takes 6 days of cross, then we do six days of cross. If it takes 10 days, then so be it. If you don’t understand why, it’s not our problem.
Just don’t add to the mix of ignorance by trying to “explain” something you know nothing about. Stick to whatever it is you do on Venus and stay away from Mars.
Obama: Elitist But Right?
It was far more important to understand the motivations of middle class frustration than know the price of Belgium endive, but instead of opening a discussion about the frustration of people suffering in the once-thriving manufacturing areas of our country, Obama opened himself to huge criticism. So much for being the man of the people.
But this Op-Ed in Newsday by Dale Maharidge, an associate professor at Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism, argues that while Obama’s words may have stung, and struck an unpopular chord with true believers, that doesn’t mean they weren’t valid.
There’s a 600 or so mile-wide swath of the nation, just west of New York City reaching past Chicago and south to New Orleans, bypassed by the so-called boom of the 1990s. In 2000, at the peak of the alleged good times, I traveled across this region and found working people in suburban houses as desperate as the unwilling hobos of the early 1980s.
Workers have lower real wages in inflation-adjusted dollars while the rich have amassed record wealth. They endure higher tax rates than hedge fund managers. They subsidize bailouts for Wall Street titans.
I saw their anger slowly building over the last 25 years. This was allowed to happen because policy-makers, both Democrat and Republican, ignored the working class.
According Maharidge, these people are indeed angry and frustrated, and lash out at whatever they can to explain why their circumstances are so bad and intractable.
Of course the anger doesn’t always come out in xenophobia, against gays, against immigrants – as Obama says, “antipathy to people who aren’t like them.” But it does for many. This reaction is as old as humanity. It can be a dangerous brew. We know how this anger played out in Weimar Germany – Hitler exploited it for his political gain.
While we may not, as a nation, want to admit this happens because it makes us appear petty and unseemly, are we ignoring a reality in the name of political correctness? The knee-jerk reaction of the media was to castigate Obama, to blindly accept that his analysis was wrong. Why? Sometimes unpleasant words reveal an unpleasant reality, but a reality nonetheless.
By denying that there is any merit to Obama’s observations, we foreclose any discussion about the root causes of anger and frustration, and its misdirect blame toward immigrants, gays, whoever. Blaming someone else, someone reachable, is the common reaction to frustration. It’s not like steelworkers can do anything about hedge fund managers who make billion dollar bonuses. But they can direct their hatred toward the immigrants who they wrongly rationalize are stealing their jobs.
When they do get angry enough to do something, they don’t turn left. The Center for New Community in Chicago counts 37 anti-immigrant or white-power “hate” groups in Pennsylvania. But their membership, the exact number not known, is really very small. Most workers, even if angry, simply endure.
Obama was brave to talk about the anger. But to convince the working class to vote for him, he will have to firmly address their needs – labor laws tilted in their favor, new green-collar jobs, a good health care program, and so on.
What’s unfortunate is that this is yet another discussion that we, as a society, need to have. We need to clear the air, understand what the real problems are, divorced from the simplistic solutions born of misguided anger and frustration, if we are to find real solutions. If politicians are perpetually guided by propounding popular solutions based on what pleases the greatest number of voters, even though they are based on misguided notions of who the voters hate the most today, we will get nowhere.
It’s hard to blame Hillary Clinton for trying to take advantage of Obama’s comments, as she wants to win a primary. On the other hand, she’s a smart woman and knows better. She knows that Obama had an important point, and still bolstered the elitist claim to gain advantage for herself at the expense of an important discussion.
But the media has no excuse for going along with this nonsense, joining (starting?) the feeding frenzy against Obama. While I am not an Obama supporter, the castigation of his ideas means that we will lose yet another important chance to figure out how to fix an economy that has fundamental problems. Another instance where a worthy discussion never happened, and we will all suffer for it.
