Author Archives: SHG

Chief Judge Kaye Pulls The Trigger

The problem with making threats is that they mean nothing if you don’t follow through.  After more than a year of threatening, New York’s Chief Judge, Judith Kaye, filed papers yesterday against the Assembly’s Shelly Silver, the Senate’s Joe Bruno and Governor David Patterson.  

The Turk provides some of the history leading up to the filing.  Slater at  the WSJ calls it “going big.”   Niki Black says Judge Kaye has “thrown down the gauntlet.”   Judicial Reports says it’s “breaking the bank.”


The Chief Judge’s counsel, Bernard W. Nussbaum — the former Clinton White House Counsel who is now a Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz partner — held a press conference Thursday after filing the suit.

“By freezing judicial salaries for the last decade, judges have been singled out and held hostage — and that’s unconstitutional,” he said, wearing a dapper fedora on the sun-drenched courthouse steps at 60 Centre Street. The court filing called for immediate action, requesting that the trial “commence on or about May 14, 2008.”

Bernie Nussbaum was an interesting choice as the attorney to represent the judges of New York.  Who’s shoes are big enough, white enough, to service a “client” that important?  Even his decision to wear a fedora on the nicest day of the year, a throwback to a time when judges weren’t forced to beg for crumbs from the political branches, held meaning.

But after so much talk, so many words spilled over the question of how the judges could sue for raise, could even a persona as large as Nussbaum pull it off?


The 30-page suit makes three primary claims: that the New York judiciary is entitled to “adequate compensation,” that State judges were unfairly discriminated against by the State Legislature, and that the judicial branch pay raises are unfairly attached to Legislative pay raises.

The papers aren’t the sort one typically finds in a lawsuit.  They are largely a polemic with a caption at the top.  To anyone even vaguely familiar with the situation, the lengthy rhetoric is neither new nor interesting.  It is another of the  beloved op-ed pieces that our Chief Judge hoped would persuade politicians to do the right thing.

While framed as if it was really a summons and complaint, I don’t believe that is how it’s meant.  This isn’t a complaint of a group that seriously expects to litigate and intends to win.  It’s a complaint designed to make headlines, to enlighten the citizens of the State of New York, to capture the hearts and minds of New Yorkers and engage them to push their legislators to give judges their raises already. 

As PR gimmicks go, it’s a good one.  It will get the front page of papers across the state.  It will elevate the profile of the issue so that New Yorkers become aware of the problem.  And then it will fade from the media’s focus, and the memories of New Yorkers, when the next brutal murder displaces it.  That’s how things go in the press, and even a lawsuit by the Chief Judge is no match for a hot, sexy, brutal crime.

Politicians will ultimately go back to work and the big bang of this lawsuit will have turned into another whimper in Albany.  It’s not that the rhetoric of the complaint isn’t true.  It most assuredly is.  But after the initial impact, assuming it fails to force the powers in Albany to fix the problem overnight, the judges are ultimately left with an actual lawsuit to litigate.


“We are seeking a salary identical to what federal judges across the street are making,” concluded Nussbaum. Federal District Court Judges earn about $165,000, a year, and the State judges are asking for retroactive pay back to January 2005.

Frankly, this strikes me as damning proof that the judges aren’t serious.  Federal judges are similarly ready to take up arms to get a salary increase, and this is the measure that state judges hope to attain?  Still well below the going rate for a first year associate at Biglaw, matching existing federal judicial salaries can’t be anything other than a public relations ploy.  If they were serious, the number should be up around $250,000.  A big jump, for sure, but at least it offers some negotiating room.

After reading all the rhetoric, the complaint finally gets around to a few causes of action.  The first argues discrimination against the judicial branch by the legislative and executive branches, violating the separation of powers.  It’s thrust is one that should start a constitutional crisis, where our tripartite government pulls apart when the checks and balances finally fail. 

But that won’t happen here.  Indeed, it’s almost the exact opposite, with checks and balances working exactly as planned.  It’s just that the judges don’t like the choice one tiny bit.  The political branches hold the purse strings for a reason, and have chosen to keep the purse shut tight on our judges.  This financial stranglehold, blatantly political and self-serving in motivation, is politics at its most pungent.  And unfortunately for our judges, it is precisely why the legislature holds the purse and not the judiciary.  Spending the people’s money is a political act, for better or worse. 

The problem for the judiciary is that their claim won’t ripen until they drop the real bomb.  It’s not enough that one branch of government feels really bad about their salaries.  As long as they keep the courthouse doors open, the system works as it should.  In fact, it works pretty well, since the people save money while the judiciary goes on as normal.  The only way the complaint has meaning is if the judiciary of the state packs up its robes and goes back to the farm.  Only upon a failure of a branch of government does the complaint have meaning.

This, of course, will not happen.  The judges, bitter as they are, aren’t prepared to give up their benches.  They worked too hard to get there, and they don’t really have a farm to go home to anyway.  Maybe a few will walk, but not enough to make a dent.  There will be no constitutional crisis today.  When I walk into court this morning, there will be a judge on the bench and she will do her job. Situation normal.

There is, of course, an irony in all of this.  So many causes of action demand a painful choice by a plaintiff, a commitment to their allegations demonstrated by suffering the painful sacrifice they claim has been thrust upon them.  The judiciary is no different.  If they cannot continue, then they have to stop.  Since they won’t close the courthouse doors, and will continue to put their robes on every day and cash their paychecks, they will not force the issue.

A sideshow to this lawsuit is the question of who will hear it.  What judge can sit in judgment of his own salary?  What judge can rule against his own brethren?  While a curiosity, it really won’t prove to be that difficult.  The judges may be angry, as well they should be, but whoever gets the dirty job of holding the bag on this suit knows that it will be subject to scrutiny like no other lawsuit, and will maintain his dignity lest he become the greatest victim of this publicity stunt.  The judge will have no other choice.

This is a terrible embarrassment for all involved.  It shows the legislators as the political manipulators they are, and the judiciary as the weakest of all branches.  It makes New York look very bad all around.  This is the impetus for the lawsuit, to embarrass the state government in the eyes of its citizens. 

Will Albany let their judiciary debase themselves in this lawsuit by turning their back on it?  I hope not.  But given the way legislators think, they may see this as an attempt at extortion by the judges, and respond that they will not be forced to act, even by another branch of government.  But such a view is absolutely wrong.  This is not an act of extortion, but of desperation. 

The legislature has given them no other option but to do something or accept the fact that the judiciary is truly at the mercy of the politicians.  That’s the problem in a nutshell.  Should this prove to be a constitutional crisis, it will be one started at the hand of the legislature for its stranglehold on judicial salaries.  Even if the public relations ploy fails to generate the immediate heat needed to force Albany’s hand, there will still be the issue of legislators holding the judiciary hostage for no better reason than it can.  Hopefully, it won’t come to this.

But doing the right thing for the right reason hasn’t happened yet in Albany.  What are the chances it will happen now?

When Grocery Clerks Run Schools

Start with a kid who’s an honors science geek.  Add in a disposable camera.  Mix it up at school and what do you get?  A kid suspended and charged with a D felony.  Zero tolerance?  How about zero intelligence.

According to this WTNH story, our young geek took the housing off a disposable camera and found that he could get a shock from it.  Since it operates on a battery, it’s hard to imagine it was much of a shock, but any shock can fascinate a science geek.  So he brought it to school, and it suddenly became a “weapon”.  We know that because the cops say so:

Police tell a different tale. They say, it wasn’t an accident. This disposable camera was modified with information found on the Internet. A 14-year-old student then brought it to the Morgan School in Clinton and threatened another student with it.  He was promptly arrested and suspended.  News Channel 8 spoke to his upset father, shortly after.

“One gets a minor shock, equivalent to what a 9-volt battery, touched to your tongue, would do.  Over this, he’s been arrested on a class D felony?” Bret Haughwout, the child’s father said, on April 2nd.

So now this student is out of school for “threatening another student” with . . . what, a camera?  A battery?  “Freeze or I’ll take really bad photo of you!”

The absurdity of this scenario is best recognized in juxtaposition with the Billy Wolfe situation, where the school does nothing to stop a kid being physically beaten on a regular basis.  The worst case scenario is that this is a childish prank, “haha, I can shock you with this battery,” which some wannabe educational policy-wonk decided was tantamount to terrorism.  While the article makes no mention of it, this is the sort of stupidity that comes of “zero tolerance” policies, where behaving like an ordinary kid exposes students to criminal prosecution. 

Since I’m deeply concerned for children and their safety, I would be disinclined to turn a blind eye to behavior that presents any real potential for harm.  This one just plain doesn’t.  The only harm here is that a student has been thrown out of school, his record smirched, over foolishness by adults.  Explain to some college that the school sacrificed this geek’s future on the alter of zero tolerance.

On the bright side, our young science geek’s parents went out and got themselves a lawyer to stand up for them against the grocery clerks at the school district.  The lawyer is named Norm Pattis.  Gee, I hope he’s got some guts and isn’t afraid to stomp on the grocery clerks’ necks until they cough up blood.  Don’t worry.  It won’t hurt them any, as it certainly isn’t traveling up to their brain.

FBI: This Is Our Cash Now

This story out of Lima, Ohio, via Overlawyered, is a pretty good example of why forfeiture law isn’t nearly as much fun as some people think. 



Lima Police Department officers originally took the [$402,767] from his house but the FBI stepped in and took it from the Police Department. Ricks has not been charged with a crime and was cleared in a fatal shooting of one of the robbers but still the FBI has refused to return the money, he said.


“They are saying I have to prove I made it,” he said.


The 63-year-old Ricks said he and his wife, Meredith, saved the money during their lifetime in which both worked while living a modest life.


Well, yup, that’s pretty much how forfeiture works.  Once cash finds it’s way into the very official hands of our government, the burden shifts to the citizen to prove it’s legal, since it’s presumptively criminal proceeds.  Why?  Because it’s cash!

Cash, cash, cash.  We’re America.  We don’t have cash.  We use credit cards.  You can’t get into debt with cash, you know.

It’s not like Ricks is totally pure.  Aside from the fact that he shot and killed a robber in his house as his son was being stabbed, he also had some pot in there.

Police originally took the money after finding marijuana inside Ricks’ home, which Ricks said he had to help manage pain. 

“I smoke marijuana. I have arthritis. I have shingles, a hip replacement,” he said.

Ricks, who is retired from Ohio Steel Foundry, said he always had a safe at home and never had a bank account.

Isn’t there a law that says you have to have a bank account? 

On the other hand, maybe Ricks work at Ohio Steel Foundry was a front for his marijuana dealing operation.  Say, did anybody notice if he had a Lincoln Navigator out front with blacked out windows and “light effects?”  Maybe he was wearing a diamond encrusted Rolex while sipping Cristal?  No?

Now you know what the flip side of forfeiture law looks like. 

“The law of forfeiture basically says you have to prove you’re innocent. It’s terrible, terrible law,” he said.  The law is tilted in favor of the FBI in that Ricks need not be charged with a crime and the FBI stands a good chance at keeping the money, Gamso said. 

“The law will presume it is the result of ill-gotten gains,” he said. 

Still Ricks can pursue it and possibly convince a judge he had the money through a lifetime of savings. Asking the FBI usually doesn’t work, he said.

“The FBI, before they would give it up, would want dated receipts,” he said.

I hope he kept the dated receipts.  Actually, I don’t want to be so flip about this travesty.  But having watched forfeiture work its magic, and watched as people applaud when this absurd system shifts the burden to the unpopular defendant, I can’t help but wonder whether they will love it as much when the victim of forfeiture law doesn’t turn out to be the bad guy.  Same law, why should it be any different when it strikes too close to home?

Torch Trumps Constitution in San Francisco

This  morning’s news showed the Olympic torch finally leaving San Francisco.  It also shows the priorities of those charged with protecting the safety of Americans and upholding the Constitution.  Somebody in San Francisco decided that it was a good idea to have a massive police presence to protect the Olympic torch.

In contrast, the streets were lined with people protesting human rights abuses perpetrated by the Chinese, hosts of the games, on the people of Tibet.  Videos showed police clashing with protesters.

I put this on the scale.  On the one side, the Olympic torch, an inanimate object representing the games to be held in Beijing, making its way without incident through San Francisco.  On the other, American’s exercising their constitutional right to protest human rights violations perpetrated by China against Tibet. 

In the middle, a whole lot of cops determined to stop the American protesters and protect the torch.

I think somebody in San Francisco needs a civics lesson, and the police were busily protecting the wrong thing.  Wouldn’t it be nice if our police protected the right of the American’s protesting human rights abuses rather than a torch reflecting a sports event held by the human rights abusers?

If China wanted to avoid worldwide controversy in anticipation of their first hosted Olympic Games, perhaps it would have been better to avoid engaging in abuse in Tibet rather than rely on San Francisco officials to put their torch ahead of Americans exercising their constitutional rights.

San Francisco officials must be confused about who they represent and what their job is.  Next time, have the cops protect the protesters from the torch.

And for those of you who enjoy games, play “Torch Run” and see if you can avoid the protesters and get the torch to Beijing!

H/T PrawfsBlawg

Giving Meaning to Jury Instructions

The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers magazine, The Champion (don’t ask me, I didn’t pick the name), has a  particularly good article written by John May about helping jurors to understand what they don’t, jury instructions.


As Professor Peter Tiersma recently observed, “There has been a substantial amount of research during the past decades documenting that jurors do not understand traditional instructions very well, especially when more difficult concepts come into play.” Fear of reversal on appeal has inhibited judges from drafting clearer instructions. Experimental research indicates that the comprehension rate of jurors on procedural and substantive law questions is less than 50 percent. Part of the problem can be attributed to the fact that “jury instructions often contain much legal jargon; unfamiliar vocabulary; and long, complex sentences.” Not surprisingly, comprehension rates increase with education. The words used to define legal principles can have a dramatic impact upon verdicts. Experiments have demonstrated that different definitions of reasonable doubt can lead to very different outcomes on the same facts.

Nothing surprising, but a clear problem that requires attention.  It’s not that jury instructions tend to be particularly kind to defendants.  Indeed, no one has yet come up with a satisfactory explanation of reasonable doubt, and all attempts to do so have been more convoluted and problematic than the pattern charge. 

As we struggle through our closing argument to tie in the facts with the law as the judge will charge, repeating the charge in such a way as to show how the law should be applied in a particular case and taking ownership of the instructions to give at least the appearance that the law doesn’t command them to convict, criminal defense lawyers have to find a path between objectionable analogies and obtuse, meaningless instructions, to clarify the jury’s duty.

This well-footnoted article contains numerous concrete suggestions for dealing with the problem of educating a jury on the instructions that will subsequently be given by the court in typical legalese.  While some of the examples are a bit of a stretch, and would likely provoke a sustained objection, they still provoke thought on how to deal with the problem.

At one point, for example, the author uses a story about his wife’s “missing” shoes to explain the difference between direct and circumstantial evidence.  It’s a cute story, reflecting how a bunch of perfectly reasonable assumptions can result in a perfectly reasonable, but totally wrong, conclusion. 

While the story works well in the article, I wonder how far into it I would get before the judge interrupted to point out that he will instruct on the law and I would do better addressing something that bore some reasonable relationship to the case that my client was paying me to defend.  Then, having been duly embarrassed in front of the jury and leaving them with half a story that went nowhere, I wondered how the author would suggest I salvage the mess left behind.  The problem with brilliant ideas that are divorced from the courtroom dynamic is that they work so much better when there’s no judge in the room.

As is usually the case in the Champion, the article assumes that the reader is relatively oblivious, restating the obvious a few times to make sure that the least competent criminal defense lawyer gets the point.   But it still offers some good suggestions and is worth a read.

Cops Trained to Testify: Fair Game To A Point

Dallas criminal defense lawyer Robert Guest, at the blawg previously known as  I Was The State, has a great post about Texas police being taught to testify in DWI cases from the “NHTSA Standardized Field Sobriety Student Testing Manual.”  Before anything else, it should be born in mind that this is produced by the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration. 

While it is certainly appropriate, if not obligatory, for the NHTSA to be involved in providing guidance and proper practices for police to conduct sobriety checks (imagine what they would come up with if left to their own devices), one has to wonder whether government has any business instructing police how to testify on the witness stand in order to deflect or avoid problematic cross-examination.  Defendants, especially the innocent ones, are American citizens and taxpayers too.  Doesn’t the government have any interest in not convicting the innocent? 

In any event, Robert post some details:


The manual includes, inter alia, training on how an officer should testify in court. DWI officers are professional witnesses, trained and paid to speak in court. Some of the manual’s tips are pretty mundane; read the police report beforehand, listen carefully, take your time, speak clearly. Not too exiting.


Training Officers To Be Ignorant
Good propaganda demands blind adherence to principle. In our case officers are taught to never question “the studies” or the breath test machine.


Here is how the manual instructs officers to answer questions about the breath test machine, the Intoxilyzer 5000.


From the manual


You are not required to know, and in fact know nothing, about the Intoxilyzer 5000, or your jurisdiction breath test instrument, its internal workings or anything other than how to operate it and take a breath sample from a defendant…. Never testify to its internal workings, or the defense attorney will discredit you and make you out to be a “thinks-he-knows-it-all who really knows nothing

For criminal defense lawyers, the fact that cops are trained to testify is routine.  For reasons unknown, it always seems to come as a surprise to others. 

We prepare our witnesses for testimony, as do prosecutors.  The difference for cops is that they are not merely prepared in advance of the particular case, but trained to be professional witnesses. 

In New York (and I assume elsewhere), police take a course in the Academy on testifying.  They are taught how to present themselves to a jury to appear credible.  They are taught how to avoid answering questions that might prove difficult later on.  They are experts at giving vague and meaningless answers on cross-examination, after having provided precise detail on direct. 

This is every bit as much of their job as turning on the sirens when they see a black man driving a new BMW person who may be breaking the law.  Frankly, if police weren’t trained to give testimony, I would think that law enforcement was a bunch of dopes.  Knowing that cops testify at trial, one would have to be a blithering idiot not to teach them to do so effectively.

Still, this seems like it’s just not “fair” in that the jury, carefully watching the witness’ demeanor, listening to his tone of voice, assessing his degree of responsiveness, falls for witness specifically trained to appear truthful and accurate when he could be lying through his teeth.  Life is unfair.  Trials are unfair.  Some witnesses are born good liars, others require training. 

But Robert’s post draws a clear distinction between the good and the bad.  It is not enough that police are trained to be the most convincing witnesses they can be, but that the manual, put out by our friends and paid for by our dime, tells them what to say and what not to say.  When that conflicts with the truth, that’s subornation of perjury.  When they follow the instructions, that’s perjury.  That’s a problem.

On cross-examination, many criminal defense lawyers will question a cop about their time in the Police Academy, and some of the classes they took, including the class teaching them how to testify.  We get it out in front of the jury to make clear that this isn’t some guy off the street offering evidence, but a trained professional. 

But it’s often necessary to take it a few steps further.  When the cop-witness, on direct, remembers everything in excruciating detail, how does he then not remember much of anything on cross?  (As an aside, why doesn’t the prosecutor jump up and announce that his witness’ testimony is false because they just talked about the specific details that very morning in preparing for his testimony?)  There’s deception by omission as well as affirmative deception.  That’s why they swear to tell the “whole truth.”

And that’s why Robert’s post about the manual is so important.  It’s not just the NHTSA manual, but for the fact that these are written instructions, produced by a government agency, to deceive.  They are taught to “not know” things that they do know, and to know things they don’t.  Robert wants you to know this when it comes to DWI in Texas.  I want you to know this when it comes to other testimony as well.

NYT Bullying Story: Less Than Perfect

The  New York Times article about the bullying of Billy Wolfe was designed to evoke a reaction in its readers, and it certainly did in me.  But it was a news story, not an editorial.  As Walter Olson at  Overlawyered now points out, it was only partially news, the part designed to evoke the reaction.  Dan Barry, the writer of the article, was a little less than thorough.

The Times corrected that error.  No, not the New York Times, but the Northwest Arkansas Times.  In an article entitled, “Who’s the bully? : Police, school records raise questions about claims made by Fayetteville High student,” the clarity of the New York piece was suddenly muddled by the other side of the facts. 

This raises two distinct questions, and both will be taken in turn.  First, what is the New York Times thinking?  To have its knees cut off by its Northwest Arkansas namesake is humiliating, but to be shown up as deceptive fundamentally undermines its credibility.  Without credibility, the Times is just a dog-trainer’s best friend and a tree’s worst nightmare. 

The story of Billy Wolfe was a strong one.  It could have withstood the truth.  But it is far more difficult to withstand be shown as a half-truth.  Regardless, what business does any journalist have telling only those parts of the story that suit his agenda? 

It’s possible that it was just lazy writing, a story that came to the Times prepackaged and a reporter who chose not to do the legwork necessary to find out whether there was anything else that needed to be in there.  Having had some experience with the Times in my work, this wouldn’t shock me either.  I was once told by a Times reporter that the reason she didn’t include a number of readily available facts was that I didn’t reach out to her and tell her in advance.  It was my responsibility to do her job for her, and I was supposed to divine that she was writing a piece so that I could make her life easier.  Right.

Some Times reporters are different than those working for other papers.  They are far more important.  They don’t have to engage in the rigors of newsgathering, because they are stars.  After all, they work for the New York Times, not the New York Post.  Despite this, we still believe that the Times does its job reporting the news.  The alternative (that the Post does a better job) is unthinkable.

The failure of the New York Times to present a full and accurate account of the Billy Wolfe story is disgraceful and unacceptable.  And, for the reasons below, foolish and pointless.  If you’re going to put an article on the front page with a big picture, don’t blow it.  The Times did.  They should be ashamed.

And now the second question.  With the revelations of the Northwest Arkansas Times in hand, does everything change?  Not at all. 

While the NYT story painted Billy Wolfe as pure as the driven snow, we now find that he was instead a teenager, with flaws and issues of his own. 

Dylan Gray smiles as he sits on the couch on a cool spring night and tells a story of a boy at school who likes to call him names, like stupid or retarded. The couch is a nice change from the wheelchair to which his muscular dystrophy normally confines him.

This same boy sneaks up behind Gray and screams in his ear, which is sensitive to noise because of his medical condition. As Gray relates the experience, this next-door neighbor once pounded him in the back of the head several times with a medium-sized rubber ball despite Gray’s protest.

I find this conduct particularly offensive, and hope others do as well.  What I do not find, unfortunately, is that it’s particularly abnormal.  As kids struggle with self-esteem issues, they seem to find someone to denigrate to build themselves up.  Name-calling is commonplace in middle and high schools.  Nor can I presume that a young man with muscular dystrophy ever did anything to Billy Wolfe to explain this conduct.  There is no good explanation, and this is not acceptable conduct. 

So we now know that Billy Wolfe can be as much of a jerk as a typical teenager.  What else?


Allegations against Wolfe at one point were so serious that police investigated a report a year ago that Wolfe threatened to bring a gun to school.

This is where the NATimes gets too fuzzy for comfort.  Confirming (with the typical “I didn’t mean to”) that Billy Wolfe was the recipient of beatings, they toss this line in without any foundation to distinguish whether this is supposed to demonstrate an act of affirmative aggression or a reaction of a kid who feels helpless to stop the constant string of beatings he’s received and is threatening to lose it and pull a Columbine. 

When I read the NYT article, it occurred to me that this is the precursor to a child who ends up so psychologically damaged that he gets a gun and blows other kids away.  My sense is that the NATimes is pulling a NYTimes through its failure to place this in context; This was Billy’s reaction, not initiation, of aggression. 

While the Northwest Arkansas Times paints a different picture of Billy Wolfe, as a teenager with his own issues and who can be annoying, offensive and aggressive in his own right, it pales in comparison to the beatings he received at the hands of others.  The scope of harm received by Billy Wolfe is still far greater, and far less typical of teen aged boys, then the scope of harm done.  Also, there is no analysis of cause and effect, which would be critical to a reasoned challenge to the claim of those who beat Billy that he deserved it.

But my  original post on the Billy Wolfe article was less directed at the other kids who did the beating, than the school officials who ignored the problems.  This new article doesn’t change anything about my critique of these “educators”.  If anything, it exacerbates the problem.  So if there was more bullying, beatings, harm done to children in your school, under your care, than originally thought, your failure to protect the children is even worse. 

Whether it’s protecting Billy, or protecting others from Billy, the duty of school officials, teachers, administrators, to keep children safe from harm in schools is manifest.  Nothing presented in the New York Times, or the Northwest Arkansas Times, informs me that children are safe at Fayetteville High School.  The new set of facts, assuming them to be true, makes the failure of the school to fulfill its obligation manifest.  It is still a criminal failure to protect.

Don’t Mess With The Donald

I don’t know David Scharf of Morrison Cohen (and whatever happened to poor Singer?), but he’s messing with the wrong guy.  We’re talking Donald Trump, the man who was on the balls of his heels, bankrupt and losing money hand over fist in Atlantic City.  Next thing you know, he’s a TV star and teenagers think bad hair is cool.  And you pick a fight with a guy like this?

Scharf was Trump’s go-to lawyer, and represented Trump in a suit against contractors who over-charged for earth moving work at his Trump National Trump Golf Trump Course in Briar-Trump-Cliff Manor.  But according to The Donald, Scharf thought he was the firm’s ATM, and Trump was displeased.

donald“I have dealt with a lot of lawyers and paid a lot of legal fees,” Donald Trump told the NYLJ recently. “I have a Ph.D. in legal fees. I know when fees are fair and when they are not.”

And when the Donald says they’re not, he ain’t paying.  So instead, he suing for legal malpractice, and Morrison Cohen is counterclaiming for $470,000 in unpaid legal fees.  According to Anthony Lin of the New York Law Journal, Trump had already paid them $1 million.

But Scharf did win the case for Trump, although Donald says it wasn’t because of the lawyers.  “We won the case because I’m a great witness,” he said.  No one ever suggested Trump didn’t hold himself in high esteem.

Trump was awarded “around $2 million in damages for breach of the earth-moving contract, but only around $40,000 for the infrastructure contract. The judge also awarded Trump around $1.3 million in attorney fees.”

Now let me do the math.  Judge awards $1.3 mil in legal fees.  Trump paid $1 mil.  Morrison Cohen says $470K still due.  That means that the firm is $170k over the award.  Oh, please Donald.  That’s a decent lunch for you and a date.  It’s less than what you get from one hair gel commercial. 

For those of you who are not fortunate enough to be a New Yorker, and are unaware of how tacky Trump Tower looks in real life, you have probably seen him on his glorious alter to himself, The Apprentice.  Does the Donald look like the kind of guy who gets pushed around by some legal beagle?  Does he sit their quietly and let the hired help waste his time?  I think not.

Yet he claims that “Ninety percent of the conversations I had with David Scharf were about legal fees, not the case.”  I’m having a very hard time buying that one.  I just can’t see the Donald quivering in his big leather chair letting Scharf run on ad naseum about the unpaid bills, beating Trump up day after day. 

On the other hand, if Trump can make America belief he’s one of the most important men in the nation, anything is possible.

Rusty Hardin Wrongly Maligned For Roger Clemens

There was certainly a lot of angst and criticism around the blawgosphere over Roger the Rocket’s testimony before Congress.  People who ought to know better were busy claiming he perjured himself (like you know), picking sides in the steroid scandal, and blaming his lawyer, Rusty, for the biggest screw-up since Wachtel Lipton told Martha Stewart, “just go in there and talk to them…”

Now, the  New York Lawyer has an interview of Rusty Hardin with Paul Braverman, where Rusty explains himself:



H: What is a public person to do if he’s falsely accused? Why do lawyers think that the safest strategy is the best strategy? Roger has made clear that he is not interested in the safest strategy. He has made clear that his public reputation, what his family and friends think, is what he holds dear. Who the hell am I to tell him that he’s wrong?

B: You don’t think much of your critics?

H: I expect second-guessing. But these people on TV, they talk about whether I should “allow” a client to testify, whether I should “allow” him to assert his innocence. Their attitude is paternalistic and patronizing. Who the hell is the lawyer to make that decision?

B: It seems like he was asking for trouble.

H: I saw it all coming. I knew there would be a deposition and a congressional hearing. I knew there would be a criminal referral. I fully advised Roger. He made the decision. He’s a grown-up.

B: Even if that decision sends him to jail?

H: I believe strongly that people that can fight, should fight. Roger has the means, the ability, and the heart to fight. I salute him.


You can’t argue with Rusty’s position.  Clemens knew the risks and chose to talk.  There’s a limit to what a lawyer can do.

But this interview does beg one question:  Rusty, what are you doing telling the advice you gave your client out of school to cover your own butt?  Salute Clemens all you want, but keep your privileged communications to yourself.

Tax Assessor, Heal Thyself

In lovely twist of irony, Nassau County Tax Assessor Harvey Levinson has applied for a reduction in his assessment, according to this Newsday article.


Nassau Assessor Harvey Levinson, who vigorously defends the accuracy of the countywide property tax assessment system he oversees, has challenged the assessment on his own Garden City condominium.

In a handwritten grievance signed by him and his wife, Levinson is asking the county’s Assessment Review Commission to reduce the value of his fourth-floor apartment in the exclusive Wyndham West complex.

It’s not that Harvey isn’t entitled to challenge his taxes, an onerous burden for anyone in the county no matter whether you’re getting a pension plus salary like Harvey or just work for a living like those of us who didn’t have the foresight to suck early and hard on the government teet.

The problem is that Harvey is the point man for the proposition that his office’s assessments are right on target, even though he upped the ante this year again while the real estate market fell another 10-20%. 

Of course, the absolute assessments really don’t matter all that much, provided that absurd increases are applied across the board.  If your neighbor’s house increased as much as yours, then everything remains the same as far as your proportionate share of taxes.  Most people don’t get how this works, and are blown away by the absurdity of their individual assessments without recognizing that it’s relative assessment that determines how badly they get hurt.

But the fact that Harvey, in his personal capacity, takes issue with his own office’s work, is the type of thing that opens the door to the real complaints.  The initial assessment, the baseline used to make annual adjustments, has put many people at a perpetual disadvantage relative to their neighbors because it was just so unbearably bad.  No matter how many times Harvey postures for the media, it’s not going to change the fact that the initial reassessment, when the county switched from a 1934 building cost basis to present value basis, stunk. 

The bottom line is that government needs to raise money to pay for all that good stuff it does.  Some of it is the stuff you ask for.  Some of it is the stuff that makes politicos feel very important.  Either way, they spend and somebody has to pay. 

Nobody, as far as I can tell, has devised a taxing scheme that doesn’t leave somebody feeling screwed.  It’s largely a matter of who gets screwed (since somebody has to) and can do the least damage.  Government folks realize that there’s no way to make everybody happy, so they shrug off the complaints as being an unavoidable fact of life.  To a certain extent, that’s true. 

But there has long been recognition that property taxes, as a means of collecting local government revenue, is possibly the worst of all possible worlds, being highly regressive, undermining the social policies favoring home ownership and being essentially impossible to get right.  But it’s here, it’s written in stone and anybody foolish enough to suggest changing it will immediately be subject to grave mental anguish.

Nobody reduced my taxes this year Harv.  Hope you have better luck than I did.