Author Archives: SHG

What Should Law School Be? A Mobblog

Over at Madisonian, a blog where the mere mortals of the practical blawgosphere are rarely invited, the best of academia are hard at work.  They are engaged in a “mobblog”, which is yet another new webword to me, on the subject of the future of legal education.

“Hey, I graduated law school. What do I care?”  That’s right.  There are no clients to be had, nor money to be made, by reading any further.  That leaves maybe three readers for the balance of this post, but I’m interested so I’m going to continue writing anyway.  Don’t say it, Gideon.

My knee-jerk assumption would be that the lawprofs would have a fine go at creating the law school of their dreams.  One that was long on luxurious days of pondering deep thoughts, where the only good use of law students was to take dictation and make pages of well-foot-noted brilliance appear on the computer screen. 

I would have been wrong.  Dead wrong, in fact.  Reading through some of the mobposts (I just made that word up, so feel free to add it to the blog lexicon at will), I was shocked to find some lawprofs and deans flying some fairly radical ideas up the academic flagpole.

There’s Mike Madison  floating the notion that we have too many law schools.  Of course, he immediately undercuts his own question by flipping to the “wrong kind of law schools” because the notion of fewer lawprof jobs is utter blasphemy.

There’s radical law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky coming out for experiential education, the sort of thing that Washington & Lee is trying which those of us not bound by the rigors of scholarly jargon might call “practical education,” but only because we are not licensed to use words like pedagogy.

Alfred Borphy is  big on the idea of making law schools into “mini-universities,” meaning that law schools would stop isolating themselves from the rest of the world and start incorporating other disciplines into their programs.  This is often discussed as the interdisciplinary approach, which used more letter and hence has greater academic panache.  The flip side, of course, is that law schools generally exist within universities already, and why not make universities “mini-law-schools?”  Instead of lawprofs allowing other profs in, they could always take a walk around the campus on their own, like common undergraduate professors. Ewwww.

One of the  most interesting proposals comes from Nate Oman, raising the time-honored concept of “indentured servitude.”  Nate questions whether the cost to law firms of training new lawyers how to be real lawyers should be shifted onto the backs of law students (notably not the law schools, but let’s not quibble) by requiring them to suffer the indignity of some form of practicing lawyer boot camp, like the military, and then repaying the debt by owing a period of employment to their benefactors.

Granted, Nate’s idea as presented presumes that all lawyers come out of law school and then find some law firm somewhere to get a job, where they hone their craft and then move on to higher paying work.  True for some, not for all.  But that doesn’t mean he’s not on to something.

Doctors go through internship and residency after they get their degree.  Law students graduate and, once they pass the bar, can hang out a shingle like they have a clue how to prepare a motion.  Sure, they will eventually learn, and may even get it sufficiently close that they don’t burn their first 27 clients, but is this the best approach.  Lawyer boot camp in the real world of lawyering hardly seems such a crazy idea, though why it doesn’t occur to Nate that the right place to erect the barracks might be the mini-university quad.  This is where a little input from the real world might make an idea fly.

And then, of course, there is the mob that wants law school to be all about luxurious days of pondering deep thoughts. 

It’s quite surprising to find that not everyone in the Ivory Tower is obsessed with reinventing law school in such a way as to eliminate teaching students altogether.  If you have any interest in the future of the profession (either of the two of you still reading this post), go check out  Madisonian and see what the finest minds can come up with.  But whatever you do, don’t post any comments or let them know you’re looking.  If they find out I sent you, I’ll never get a link from the lawprofs again.

Judicial Selection: Does Any Method Work?

From Dirk Olin at Judicial Reports, word leaks out of a conference held yesterday at Fordham Law School of judicial reformers trying to figure out how best to select state court judges.  The conference, entitled “Enhancing Judicial Independence, Accountability, and Selection for the State Court Judiciary: A Program for Reform,: wasn’t your usual group of do-gooders or self-serving sitting judges arguing to protect their seats. 

The room was packed with the brightest of legal luminaries — from Sandra Day O’Connor and Stephen Breyer to the Chief Justice of Ghana. Academic and bar heavyweights were all around. A forum of self-congratulatory blather? Hardly. The real subject was nothing short of saving Western Civilization.

Heavy hitters indeed.  If only Dirk had given a heads-up before this symposium, as this sounds like the sort of thing I would have like to attend.  Note that I did not receive an engraved invitation.

Former Supreme Sandra Day O’Conner opened with a recap of the current judicial atmosphere:


O’Connor was not absolving the bench of the need for accountability, noting that the spread and debasement of judicial elections are at least as responsible for systemic woes as any particular ideology. “We’ve put cash in the courtroom, and it’s just wrong,” she said. “No other nation in the world has it.”

The retired justice led off the proceedings by reminiscing about her early days in Arizona, when she saw placards calling for the impeachment of then-Chief Justice Earl Warren. But recent years, she lamented, have seen far more virulent attacks — judges threatened with violence during the Terry Schiavo life support case in Florida, members of Congress advocating legislated circumscription of judicial authorities, a highly political proposal to slash the terms of sitting judges in Colorado, and, most notoriously, the recently failed “Jail4Judges” campaign in South Dakota to have citizen grand juries sit in judgment on members of the bench and actually imprison some based on individual rulings.

Americans are nothing if not imaginative in finding ways to get what they want.  And what they want, apparently, is a judiciary whose decisions comport with the common man’s common sense view of common wisdom.  Justice O’Conner’s point was that these attack on judicial independence impair the ability of judges to do their job without fear of public denigration or retaliation, often for lack of understanding of the law.

At the same time, independence is under assault internally, by the need for money to mount judicial campaigns and its insidious implications for the integrity of the judiciary.


One particularly tawdry manifestation of the downward electoral spiral that O’Connor recounted involved her recent conversation with “top-notch trial lawyers in Texas.” The group told her that their first action upon hearing of their assignment to a judge was to research their opposing counsels’ campaign donations to the jurist — so they could match them.

“It’s like nothing I’ve seen in my very long life,” she said. “Judicial independence is a bedrock principle, and we’re losing it.”

Justice Breyer then noted that the flip side of the equation, appointment of judges rather than election, offers no panacea either.


Breyer similarly bemoaned the decline of respect for judges within the commonweal, though he stressed that non-elective systems could be just as corrupted. “That might be worse because everyone appoints his cousin.”

He recounted a trip to Russia soon after the ascent of Boris Yeltsin where he heard about “telephone justice” — the practice of officeholders with judicial appointment powers “calling judges and telling them how to vote.” But America has at least the “appearance” of the same problem, he added, “because half the country thinks judges decide cases any way they want.”

The lawprofs then took over with proposals to cure the disease.


[Widener School of Law Professor Michael] Dimino called for a compromise — the imposition of “lengthy, nonrenewable term limits” for state judges, which he said would balance their need for “decisional independence” against fears that they’d devolve into the equivalent of “pollsters.”

Dimino suggested that we do things backwards in New York, where trial level judges should be appointed (rather than elected, as they now are) and Court of Appeals judges should be elected (rather than appointed, as they now are), since the rulings of the latter create the precedent that are “more akin to those of a governing body.”

This proposal was shot down hard by James Sample, Counsel to the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law, who argued that Dimino’s changes were a little too drastic to be a realistic possibility. 


So he called for incremental reforms that would improve both electoral regimes and appointive systems.

Sample pitched public finance for campaigns, arguing that First Amendment concerns should be balanced against due process considerations for litigants who might well fear that they were being denied access to a fair and impartial venue. He also called for much stricter rules promoting recusals, to counter a spreading perception of “pay-to-play” justice.

“The rule of law needs a tourniquet,” he concluded, “and it needs it now.”

While Sample’s proposal is slightly more pragmatic than Dimino’s (though only slightly), it touches on only one of the negative influences on judicial selection, the “cash and carry” judiciary.  While true that putting judges through the electoral process necessarily creates the need to beg for money for campaigns, thus giving rise to the appearance, if not reality, that judges will show their appreciation for campaign contributions in the exercise of their authority, it’s not the only problem.

Sample overlooks the more fundamental problem that electing judges puts enormous control into the hands of a few party leaders, who (by definition) are unmitigated whores.  The political process of becoming a party nominee reflects the worst of all worlds, internal favoritism by paying off political debts or favors with a judicial nomination without regard to merit, or even basic competence.  Licking envelopes for a party boss is not a primary qualification for being a judge.  It is, however, for being a judicial nominee. 

So while the surface mechanics of judicial selection, the stuff we can all see and know about because it happens before our faces, might be changed to give the appearance of a less graft-ridden system, the ugly underbelly goes on unabated and untouched.  Is it better to elect unqualified political hacks to the bench with public or private money?

And the second problem is the nature of popular election of judges itself.  There is not now, nor has there ever been, any method devised that would enable the public to have the slightest clue who would be the best candidate for a judgeship.  Put aside the speech limitations on judicial campaigning, an inherently silly endeavor designed to protect the appearance of integrity at the expense of actual integrity, and ask what Aunt Sadie knows about an individual’s qualifications to be a judge? 

A while back, the  Feerick Commission tried to come up with ways to restore the appearance of integrity to the judicial election process.  The solutions offered were worthless, and even then undercut by the political implications of giving the public any hope of basing their vote on any meaningful criteria. 

I feel badly for the judges and potential judges who have to go through this process.  It’s not their fault that the process sucks, and it’s not like they have an alternative, dignified and meaningful.  Just because they do what is necessary to run for office doesn’t make them unqualified, or bad people.  It just doesn’t do the opposite either.

So at the end of the day, we’re left with the same problem.  And no solutions.  Perhaps this has a little something to do with the bad attitude toward the law?

Selbin Update: The Case Settles (Update)

Hat tip to the Turk, the  New York Times reports that the Selbin lawsuit against neighbor Galila Huff has been resolved.  This case provoked a massive outpouring of anger toward to Selbins generated by John Stossel’s report designed to inflame hatred of lawyers.

Mr. Selbin confirmed the settlement and said Ms. Huff had agreed to take steps to minimize the spread of her smoke. After news of the suit was reported in February, the manufacturer of an air-cleaning system came forward to offer free equipment to Ms. Huff and the Selbins.

“She agreed to use the donated air filters and a smokeless ashtray, which is all we ever asked her to do,” Mr. Selbin said in an e-mail message. “Period.”

Mr. Selbin indicated on Monday that the publicity surrounding the lawsuit had not been pleasant. “I am confident you will find a way to make us look like terrible people all over again for insisting on such an onerous thing,” he said in the e-mail message.

After the lawsuit was filed, a company called Aerus, formerly known as Electrolux, offered to install — at no charge — an air filtration system that, the company said, would remediate the smoke.

Now after all the one-sided sensationalism drummed up by Stossel’s facile report, it appears that the two neighbors managed to work out their differences.  No doubt, some will invent assumptions to yet further the Stossel agenda, since the notion of using the law to resolve differences and ultimately resulting in a mutually agreed upon resolution would be wholly inconsistent with his simplistic vilification.

After all, if the Selbins and Huff worked their problems out, how then can Stossel pursue lawyers as the root of all that’s wrong in America? 

I’m sure he’ll figure something out.

Update:  For those readers who have come to SJ via the ABC.com link to support the hero of the great unwashed, John Stossel, in his war against thre vermin lawyers, please make an effort to have something minimally useful to add.  “Stossel Rules!” is not a useful comment.  Nor is “Lawyers suck!”  Nor are any variations on these themes.

Should Youtube Be Responsible?

Another case of a group of teens hurting another.  A sad and pathetic commentary, of course, but this has a twist that may change the perspective.

According to this report (with AP video),  a gang of six teenage girls lured another teenage girl to a house for the purpose of beating her so that they could record a video, put it on You Tube and become famous.  Unbelievable.

There are a handful of normal motivations that drive crime and violence in this business.  Money and passion are the big two.  Fame is also a known motivator, such as those deluded individuals who murder the famous in the hope that they, by their notorious connection, will rise to be somebody. 

But are these teenage girls whose grand aspiration is You Tube infamy as deluded as, say, a Charles Manson or a Mark David Chapman?  While something is quite obviously very wrong for these teenage girls to want to beat another, the idea that the motivation is mini-stardom is just too hard to swallow.

The father of the young girl who was beaten is, for obvious reasons, most unhappy with You Tube.


“I want stiffer punishments for these shock Web sites that entice kids to make these videos so they can be famous on the Internet,” Lindsay’s father, who declined to give his name, told The Ledger in Lakeland, Fla. “That is the motive, I am sure of it. It’s crazy and it’s terrible and they’re gonna pay.”

Not only won’t there be “stiffer punishments,” but there won’t be any punishment at all.  While the popularity of a You Tube may make it the perfect venue for disturbed children to show the world just how horrible their conduct can be, it remains just a medium rather than a cause. 

That said, perhaps You Tube can do a better job of vetting submissions to eliminate videos such as this as quickly as possible, and thereby remove any hope of these teenagers of obtaining misbegotten fame by airing these videos.  No, not because You Tube is responsible, but because it would be a laboring oar in stopping these shocking and horrific beatings.

And to the parents of these teenage girls, something went very wrong in the raising your children.  If you were unaware before, you’re not now.  Deal with it.

Passing the MPRE: Knowing vs. Having Ethics

Lat announced late afternoon yesterday that the MPRE results are out.  Had he not, I would have never know, despite my deep, abiding concern for legal ethics.  Oh yeah, in case you’re unaware, MPRE stands for the Multi-State Professional Responsibility Exam.  It’s the component of the bar exam that tests legal ethics.

I was in the first class that ever took the MPRE.  We had a required legal ethics course in law school that, if memory serves, went on for one semester.  The course of study consisted of one sentence, repeated over and over.  “When in doubt, screw the lawyer.”  This was the  Lester Brickman school of legal ethics.  The lawprof also said something about lawyers not being a bus, but no one paid any attention to this analogy.

The MPRE is not considered a particularly rigorous examination.  There really isn’t much of a need for it to be, since in theory ethics really shouldn’t require all that much to learn.  But as with all things legal, the devil is in the details. 

I can recall taking the MPRE with my law school chums.  At one point, I remember going to the restroom and finding a friend in their.  He was one of the smartest guys in my class.  He was smoking a little weed to kill time before he got to the test.  I asked him what he thought, and he responded, “good stuff.” [edited version of his comment].  We weren’t talking about the same thing.

Using the full gamut of my education in legal ethics, I completed the test promptly and did what all good law students do after completing any portion of a bar exam.  I got a beer.  Some of my classmates discussed the nuances of a particular fact pattern present by the test.  They struggled and argued to find a way that the lawyer’s conduct would be acceptable, testing the outer edges of ethics to see how close they could tread.  I drank my beer.

When I was finally asked what I thought, I told them that it was unethical and the lawyer was screwed.  This started the ruckus all over again.  Even then, I seemed to have an ability to provoke discussion.  I sat silently, nursing my beer as they explained to me, using numerous examples and analogies, why they were right and I was wrong.  If they had 8 by 10 glossies with circles and arrows, they would have used them too.

When they finally fell silent, having spent their last ounce of energy arguing their case, I just shook my head.  Nope, the lawyer is screwed.  Finally, one exasperated friend asked, “why?”  I answered, “because on the MPRE, the lawyer is always screwed.”

When I received my score for the test, I was shocked that it was ridiculously high.  I remember wondering whether I had received the highest score in the state, it was that good.

It was also that meaningless.  Sure, you can’t adhere to the various ethical proscriptions that apply to lawyers if you don’t know what they are.  It serves a purpose to learn the Code of Professional Responsibility.  But knowing ethics, and having ethics, are two entirely separate things.  The former takes study.  The latter takes integrity.  There is no class to teach integrity.

Skimming the comments over at Above the Law, it appears that most of the Biglaw wannabes received a passing score on the MPRE.  Whether they have ethics, and will engage in the practice of law with integrity, is another question.

The Perks of Office

Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer Jamie Spencer (see how I worked that in for you?) found this article from the  Orange County Register about cars registered to employees of 1800 state and local governmental agencies get a free pass from traffic violations.  The reason, according to  Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer Jamie Spencer (did it again), is:

An Orange County Register investigation has found that the program, designed 30 years ago to protect police from criminals, has been expanded to cover hundreds of thousands of public employees – from police dispatchers to museum guards – who face little threat from the public. Their spouses and children can get the plates, too…

While the article primarily addresses the loss of revenue, while the bills mount for those motorists who made the mistake of not having a civil servant in the family, there is an institutional problem at stake here that should not go unnoticed.

Arguably, the original rationale for concealing the identity of certain motorists (i.e., cops) make sense.  If personal information, such as home address and family members, of police officers was readily available, it would subject them to huge potential personal risk for doing their jobs.  While this would theoretically allow them to ignore inconvenient laws on their own time, we would hope that they, as law enforcement officers, would make the affirmative choice to comply with the laws.  In any event, the risk of harm to police is reasonably viewed as more important than collecting the occasional traffic fine.

Thus, the rubric is born, reasonably connect to its rationale.  So far, no problem.

But then others in the service of the People saw the benefit, and said, “me too!”  Without researching the details, let’s assume that next it was judges (“angry defendant’s could come after us”) and court personnel (“us too, us too!”).  Then the people at the Department of Motor Vehicles (“everybody hates us”) until it reached the local water district repair person. 

In due course, the argument becomes, “hey, they get it.  I want it too!”  It shifts from being an appropriate means of protecting against a rational threat to a basic perk of the job.  The local water district repair person asks, “why should they get it and not me?”  The answer is that it ultimately becomes a bargaining chip, without a particular associated cost (making it the kind of chip that government negotiators love).  Even though there’s a loss of traffic violation fine revenue, that comes out of somebody else’s budget line, and no governmental unit cares a whit about anybody else’s budget line.

The problem, obviously, is that the rubric is now disconnected from the rationale.  The reason behind the rule has since been forgotten, and the rule is then applied to people in way that cannot be justified.  It’s gone beyond its logical extreme.

But there’s another issue at stake, and this goes to the nature of government.  There are two views of government service that are decidedly different.  One is the view that people who work for government are public servants.  The other is that they are employees or “leaders”, according to where they are on the food chain.  While the words “public servant” are still used from time to time when helpful, the concept is largely a fiction. 

Public servants, in theory, hold their positions in government in order to serve the people, to fulfill the mission of government.  When is the last time you felt that government was deeply concerned with fulfilling its mission toward you?  For most of us, government has become the monolith on the other side of the table from the People.  We need it to do some things, and we fight it to keep it under some degree of control.

Few examples make this clearer than the perk given the employees, and their families, of 1800 governmental agencies.  It’s a perk of the job, and the job just happens to be working for a governmental agency.  You can’t blame them for wanting the benefit.  Who wouldn’t?  But there’s no connection between serving the public and beating red lights at will.

Lawyers: Can’t Live With Them

But won’t live without them.  There have been a  few  posts  lately that have (inexplicably) brought out a wild crowd of readers and commenters.  A few post mortum thoughts seem appropriate.

First, it’s important to recognize that this is not a representative sampling of the lay view of lawyers.  These are people who have sought out the subject to read further about it, then gone the extra step of leaving a comment.  Most people, lacking either a strong interest in the subject or a need to express themselves on it, particularly to say “me too,” won’t bother.  Others, who might disagree with the majority, won’t comment for fear of being subject to ridicule.  It was that type of crowd.

But that said, these comments offer an insight to what a not unsubstantial number of people think and feel about the law and those who practice it.  These are the same people who sit on juries and proclaim that they can be fair and impartial.  They absolutely believe that they are fair and impartial; that they happen to hate the law and lawyers is, in their eyes, a fair  and well-deserved statement.

In the course of reading comments yesterday, I sent an email around to some of my civil law blawging buddies, asking why they don’t jump in and correct some of the misperceptions and misunderstandings.  One of the things that the comments revealed with the lack of distinction between various types of lawyers and practice areas; Not all lawyers sue people.  Some defend them.  Some criminally, other civilly.  In the public eye, and according to a few of the conspiracy theorists, we’re all in this together.

It made me wonder how this impacts on the agenda of the tort reformers.  Walter Olsen at  Overlawyered posted about a jury run amok in a civil suit against Ford, where the jury found liability against a party that no one suggested was liable.  While there are plenty of legitimate grievances against the law and lawyers, much of the criticism requires a certain degree of comprehension to appreciate what is wrong and why. 

Having whipped up the mob, have the Overlawyered guys lost control of their sympathizers?  It seems that their directed attack on those things that they challenge in the law has morphed into some vague but pervasive hatred.  Some of the comments reflect a belief that the law itself, for nonspecified reasons, has become the monster.  Others suggest that the entire legal profession is comprised of evil, malevolent people. 

How do the reformers stop the mob from burning down their houses when they come for the lawyers?  They have thrown Pandora’s box wide open.  But did they really mean to suggest that all laws and lawyers are evil?

But there’s good news in this as well, by my calculations.  I few years back, I was involved in a small consortium of lawyers who sought to put together a business designed to create an alternative dispute resolution mechanism, premised on many of the reforms that people believe they now want.  It was fast, inexpensive and effective.  One of the key components was that lawyers were not required.  In fact, they would be highly discouraged, since lawyers only seem to gum up otherwise good ideas.

The idea was put through the rigors of a number of focus groups.  We learned things that shocked us. 

One thing we learned was that this anger toward the law and lawyers is, indeed, pervasive.  People believe that the law is a big game, and the one with the most money wins.  People believe that neither the law nor lawyers have any integrity, and our job is comprised of playing the game (read lie and cheat) better than the other lawyer.  So far, not too shocking.

We also learned that people believed that “everyone” really knows who is right and wrong before hand, and the entirety of lawsuits is a sham played out at the behest of, and for the benefit of, the legal profession.   Of course, when pushed on hypothetical scenarios, the same people who believed that right and wrong are absolutes ended up on opposite sides of the issue, but even when confronted with that reality, simply shut down and rationalized that they were right and the other guy was crazy.  People refused to accept that (1) they could be wrong, or (2) reasonable people can differ.  Anne Reed, take note.

So far, it seemed that our concept should be received with open arms, perhaps even joy and adoration.  But then came the shock.  Despite all of these beliefs, the participants in these focus groups were almost uniformly in agreement about one thing:  If they were going to go to have a “trial” of their dispute, they wanted a lawyer.  Even though this system was designed so that litigants would not need a lawyer, they didn’t care.  They wanted a lawyer.

At the end of the day, even the lawyer haters want counsel.  Indeed, it makes a great deal of sense.  For all the angst and anger, the belief that lawyers are the scum of the earth, they STILL wanted a lawyer on their side if they headed into battle.  Why?  Because the fear of having to prevail on their own, being put to the test of their persuasive skills in real life, left them quivering bowls of jello. 

People, once put to the test, exposed their underlying fears.  They asked, “but what if the other guy can talk better than me?”  “But what if I get nervous?”  “What if I forget to say something important?”  “How do I know what I’m supposed to say?”  “How am I supposed to know the law?”

All good questions.  But they fly in the face of the complaints about lawyers and the law.  It’s easy to rail against lawyers and the law when you have nothing on the line.  The comments are cathartic, allowing people who have been fed the belief that miserable things happen to good people because of bad lawyers, but the catharsis stops the second it’s their turn on the docket.  Then, they want the best, meanest, toughest lawyer around.  They don’t want to lose (especially since they are, in their own minds, invariably right), and they don’t trust themselves, their skills, their minds, to win the day.

This comports to a degree with my own anecdotal experience with people who have negative feelings about lawyers and the law.  My clients may attribute positives to me, because I am THEIR lawyer, but the lawyer for the other side is still evil.  Largely, this is just a self-serving attitude.  Since they are right, and I am helping them, I’m not a bad guy.  But the rest of the profession remains evil.  There is still the issue of why THEY should have to pay, since they didn’t do anything wrong, but accept that as a necessary evil since they can’t get legal representation any other way.

I would expect that personal injury lawyers, for example, face the same situation, even when their clients are “tort reform” believers.  When they are hurt, their cause is just because they are absolutely certain that someone else is at fault, and hence can separate their “philosophical” belief from their personal circumstances, the latter being specifically good for them and hence inherently just. 

But this does little to calm the wave (tsunami, tidal or ripple) of antagonism by those who are not personally involved in litigation, and view the legal system as society’s plague. 

It’s ironic that individual cases, played large by the media, have such an influence on people’
s perceptions.  If they weren’t anomalies, they wouldn’t get any air time at all.  Yet these become the norm in people’s minds, and hence the measure of the law.  Worse yet, they are almost always used in a way that is self-serving by the media, to prove a point of how bad, crazy or wrong the law is.  But if it were presented otherwise, it would make for a lousy story and do nothing to support the proponent’s agenda.  Truth can be incredibly boring.

So there you have it.  Make of it what you will.

Rules, Misconceptions and Conspiracy Theories

Reading Gideon’s  Monday Morning Jumpstart (which I love because Gid picks up a bunch of interesting stuff that I often miss on my own) this morning, it occurred to me that there are some great posts around that suffer from a basic misunderstanding in the blawgosphere. 

Many, myself included, like to talk about the blawgosphere as a conversation.  To some extent, it is, but it’s an imperfect one.  It’s limited by the inherent restrictions of written expression, omitting tone and nuance.  The lack of give and take results in people writing lengthy tomes, raising numerous points of varying degrees of relevance, and making it too unwieldy to cover everything.

But the most significant limitation is the inability to know who we are talking to.  We each carry baggage, our education, our experience, our location, our prejudice.  This is one of the reasons I harp on the problem with anonymity in the blawgosphere.  Our ability to understand what others are saying depends to some extent on knowing who we’re having a conversation with. 

We project our own understanding onto others when we have nothing else to go by.  It makes for disagreements when none really exist.  It produces confusion rather than illumination.  We end up fighting with shadows to no avail.

One such post from Gideon this morning comes from the Rocky Mountain News, entitled “Debunking the top 10 myths of jury trials.”  I thought this was a very good piece.  Perfect?  No.  Comprehensive?  Not quite.  Deep?  Hardly.  But very good for its audience. 

Obviously, this was not directed at trial lawyers.  Why would trial lawyers need some consultant to debunk trial myths?  This article was clearly intended to provide some basic information to the general public to dispel some similarly basic yet pervasive misunderstandings about criminal trials.  And for that purpose, it was great.

So then comes the lawyers and the lawyer-haters, the cops and the cop-haters, to argue about it.  The argument veered off into jury nullification (apparently a very hot issue lately, with a hat tip to the Texas Tornado).  Interesting though the discussion might be, it was tangential (at best) to the article and hijacked it from its obvious purpose.  Hey, that’s the blawgosphere, right?

I read another  post by Grits about Rothgerry and a book by Richard Leo, “Police Interrogations and American Justice.”  Scott’s view of Leo’s message took it in a different direction than I had thought about before, with an emphasis on when a defendant should be entitled to counsel rather than how police interrogation tactics tend to produce false confessions.  It was an interesting approach.

I became aware of Leo’s book when Anne Reed  wrote about it a while back.  It was not particularly impressive, as far as I was concerned, stating an obvious problem at length and offering no real solution.  In this field, we have long been aware of the problems with police interrogations.  We really don’t need scholarly validation of the obvious. 

But the Grits post, by taking it in a different direction, presented a different issue, since police interrogate two distinct types of people:  Targets and Witnesses.   At first, I thought that I should point out this distinction, since Grit’s was absolutely correct in his assessment about targets, but it didn’t apply to non-targets, who were interviewed for the sole purpose of gathering evidence against the target.  But what would this have done to Scott’s point in writing the post?  Nothing positive, and the post was worthwhile, if not exactly perfect.  And perhaps it would have misdirected an important point by pushing a tangential point.

The blawgosphere is primarily inhabited by lawyers, but we also have another group that seems to flit in and out according to their personal issues.  No matter what gets posted, there’s no pleasing them.  These are the conspiracy theorists, the ones who believe that all lawyers are evil and bent on total domination.

Two lawyers can barely agree on where to have lunch.  The idea that they could agree on world hegemony is ludicrous.  But there’s no arguing with these folks, who wear aluminum foil around their heads to protect them from the bar association shooting gamma rays at them.  Even though they tend to write silly things, express opinion devoid of fact, and demand their “right” to be vulgar and angry, they still keep coming.  How do we write for these people?  How do we stop them from dragging the conversation into the gutter?

These conspiracy theorists add nothing to the conversation.  Indeed, they are conversation killers to everyone but other conspiracy theorists and themselves.  They do so love to post and post and post about their generic hatred of lawyers.  But that’s the nature of the blawgosphere, where anyone who happens upon a post can chime in, no matter how much or little they know or have to add.  About the best we can do is cut them off, delete the worst or silliest, and even that tends not to slow them down.  They are on a mission.  Possibly from Mars.

The legitimate media looks at the blogosphere as the realm of kooks and misbegotten self-appointed pundits.  They may have a point.  I would like to think we can do better.  I plan to try.  Do me a favor and before somebody jumps in to argue, ask yourself if it adds to the conversation or is just offered to be contrary and ornery.

Understanding Judge Weinstein

Judge Jack Weinstein is a legend in the Eastern District of New York.  Uncowed by the powers above him, he has long bowed to no one and stood his ground on what he believes to be right and wrong.  Someday, books will be written about him, as he is one of the few who was unafraid to use his authority to do justice.

In his magnum opus, a  236 page decision (plus a 50 page addendum) in US v. Polizzi, Judge Weinstein held that he failed the defendant by not informing the jury that a conviction would subject him to a mandatory minimum sentence.  But he had much more to say than just that.

Judge Weinstein considered the role of the jury in our criminal justice system as the buffer between government and individual.  He came out on the side of the jury.  As quoted by Orin over at Volokh,


Perhaps the issue is as well summed up as it need be by quoting briefly from Professor Roscoe Pound and Judge Learned Hand. Pound referred to jury nullification as “the great corrective of law in its actual administration.” Roscoe Pound, Law in Books and Law in Action, 44 Am. L. Rev. 12, 18 (1910). And Learned Hand declared that nullification supplies the necessary “slack into the enforcement of law.” United States ex rel McCann v. Adams, 126 F.2d 774, 776 (2d Cir. 1942). It allows the jury to temper the law’s rigor “by the mollifying influence of current ethical conventions.” Id.; see, e.g., Andrew J. Parmenter, Nullifying the Jury: “The Judicial Oligarchy” Declares War on Jury Nullification, 46 Washburn L. J. 379, 426 (2007) (providing other supporting citations); Appendix A, infra.

In Harry Kalven, Jr. and Hans Zeisel’s comprehensive and still valid study, The American Jury (1966), the authors concluded that in the relatively rare cases where the jury reaches a “different conclusion from the judge on the same evidence, it does so not because it is a sloppy or inaccurate finder of the facts, but because it gives recognition to values which fall outside the official rules.” Id. at 495. “It . . . will move where the equities are. And where the equities are at any given time will depend on both the state of the law and the climate of public opinion.” Id. See also, e.g., Valerie P. Hans, Judges, Juries, and Scientific Evidence, 16 J.L. & Pol’y 19, 23 (2007) (“[M]any disagreements [between judges and juries] are explained by the fact that compared to judges, juries appear to require a stronger case by the prosecution to convict the defendant; or by the fact that juries infuse community notions of justice into their verdicts.” (citing, inter alia, Kalven and Zeisel, supra)). Above all, the experience of trial judges is that the jury is among our most conservative institutions. When in doubt we should trust its judgment, as did those who adopted the Sixth Amendment.

Notably, this comes on the heels of Bennett’s  fascinating  discussion of jury nullification (making me wonder if Jack Weinstein reads Bennett regularly) as well as Gideon’s  discussion of what else the jury should be told to flesh out the full force of public influence.

In his consideration of Judge Weinstein’s decision, Orin, with his lawprof hat firmly in place, finds it wanting:

  The most obvious difficulty with Judge Weinstein’s decision is that the perceived spirit of the Supreme Court’s latest decisions doesn’t trump otherwise binding precedents simply because older precedents may be in some conceptual tension with new cases. See, e.g., Rodriguez de Quijas v. Shearson/Am. Express, Inc., 490 U.S. 477, 484 (1989). And even if they did, I don’t see the inconsistency between the new Sixth Amendment decisions and the traditional rules on what the jury is told about sentences.

Of course, this was not a decision to be read with a pointy hat on one’s head.  That’s the hat one wears when blindly affirming precedent, never to be changed once carved in stone. 

One has to assume that Judge Weinstein realizes that his decision will not be embraced by the Second Circuit, with a rousing chorus of Kumbaya following oral argument.  Judge Weinstein is a brilliant jurist, but more importantly, a fearless one.  He’s been around long enough to have gotten beyond the desire to climb the ladder of judicial importance, and now seeks only to do whatever he can to make people think.  He knows the harm the law can do, and is trying, in his own way, to change it.

For those who criticize judges for activism, Judge Weinstein is unlikely to be their model of the perfect judge.  For those who are slaves to stare decisis, this decision is going to make their hair stand straight up.  But for those who believe that Congressional micromanaging of the criminal justice system to meet some politically valuable vision of an acceptable tyranny of the majority, who are happy to do as much harm as necessary to those who bring inadequate political clout to the table, and for those who continually seek to find a more fair and just system despite its inherent inadequacies, Judge Jack Weinstein is a hero.

There is little likelihood that smaller minds with narrower visions will find Judge Weinstein’s decision persuasive or legally fulfilling.  But that wasn’t the judge’s point.  At least he got some people thinking, and so he accomplished his goal to some extent.  Hopefully, more people will learn of this decision, a discussion will ensue, and Judge Weinstein’s effort will not have been in vain.

Jester Judge and Creative Sentencing

I know I’ve spent a lot of time  posting about the Royal Order of Jesters, but secret whoremongering (not my word) societies do have a certain fascination.  But Kathleen, my hinterlands correspondent, keeps feeding me great news out of  Buffalo that demands attention.  It’s not my fault.

It appears now that Supreme Court Justice Ronald H. Tills (Ret.), who knows mirth when he sees it, has an unusual reason to select one of the Winnebago women he was bringing to the Jesters’ convention.

A woman who faced drug and prostitution charges in State Supreme Court Justice Ronald H. Tills’ courtroom later accompanied him on an out-of-state trip for a fraternal organization called the Jesters. Investigators are trying to determine whether the woman offered her services as a prostitute at the convention or whether she was just a guest of the judge, who has since retired.

Maybe it happens a lot up there in very cold, very snowy, very lonely Buffalo, that judges and those whom they sentence form deep, long-lasting personal friendships.  It could happen.  I don’t know what the “hot chick” to judge ratio is, but it could be pretty slim pickings if judges aren’t allowed to select from the working girls who come before them.


According to five sources close to the investigation, Tills became personally acquainted with the woman after she served six months of jail time he imposed and while he was still on the bench.

It’s not like Judge Tills didn’t make her do her time first.  Maybe he’s just a believer that she paid her dues to society, and was now entitled to resume her rightful place in the Winnebago.


Authorities and judicial ethics experts said it would be inappropriate for a judge to engage in any sexual relationship with a woman who had previously been sentenced in his courtroom.

Well there’s a shock.  “Authorities and judicial ethics experts” could suck the fun out of anything.  This is why they have no appreciation of serious mirth.  I mean, really, can you imagine a mirthful judicial ethics expert?  And don’t even get me started on “authorities”, with their prune faces all squished up whenever anybody wants to do anything fun at all.


Members of a human trafficking task force are investigating allegations that some of the Buffalo Jesters hired prostitutes — including some who worked in massage parlors — and took them to out-of-state conventions of the Jesters.

Suddenly, it doesn’t sound nearly as mirthful, does it. 


The woman Tills is associated with is described as a West Side resident whom the judge had sentenced after she was arrested on felony charges of selling cocaine, possessing cocaine and offering to commit prostitution with two undercover cops.

The woman took a plea deal, sources said, admitting to a single felony count of attempted sale of cocaine. In February 1998, Tills sentenced her to six months in jail and put her on probation for five years.

In December 2000, the woman was back in Tills’ courtroom, accused of violating her probation. A month later, Tills ordered her to spend 90 days in a drug counseling program, sources said. 

She later got a job as a cleaner in the Erie County Courthouse on Franklin Street, where her duties included cleaning Tills’ courtroom and chambers. According to a worker at the courthouse and five sources familiar with the investigation, the woman frequently visited with Tills in his court chambers.

While others can debate whether prostitution is a victimless crime, or should be legalized, this really isn’t about prostitution anymore.  It’s about a judge who appears to have abused the authority of his office to take advantage of a defendant whose life was placed in his hands, and of whom he took huge advantage. 

Together with this law secretary and the police captain, all on their mirthful way to the Jesters convention, with these women in tow.  Perhaps these women were happy to join them, it being a better gig than the street or massage parlor, and not a whole lot different than joining the judge “in chambers” from time to time.

Sometimes I think I’m as pruny as those “authorities” and “judicial ethics experts.”  But I still have this bone in my head that expects judges to show a modicum of integrity.  Heck, I think everyone should.