Author Archives: SHG

Life and Death in the Blawgosphere

When the  New York Times informed me that bloggers were dying, I was shocked. 


A growing work force of home-office laborers and entrepreneurs, armed with computers and smartphones and wired to the hilt, are toiling under great physical and emotional stress created by the around-the-clock Internet economy that demands a constant stream of news and comment.

Wait a second.  Am I doing this all wrong?  I post when I feel like it.  I post what I feel like.  And that’s that. 

Apparently, there are more blogospheres than I realized, and the other ones can be very bad for your health.  I can imagine people sitting there in their bathrobes typing furiously at their faded keyboard in the middle of the night.  But why would they do that?


“I haven’t died yet,” said Michael Arrington, the founder and co-editor of TechCrunch, a popular technology blog. The site has brought in millions in advertising revenue, but there has been a hefty cost. Mr. Arrington says he has gained 30 pounds in the last three years, developed a severe sleeping disorder and turned his home into an office for him and four employees. “At some point, I’ll have a nervous breakdown and be admitted to the hospital, or something else will happen.”

Millions in advertising revenue?  Well, there’s a motivation, I guess.  Simple Justice has certainly brought me wealth beyond my wildest imagination.  Actually, it hasn’t made me a dime, but after a statement like the one in the Times, I’m reluctant to admit that I am such an utter blogging failure, having failed to capitalize on my blawg at all, not to mention to the tune of millions.


Blogging has been lucrative for some, but those on the lower rungs of the business can earn as little as $10 a post, and in some cases are paid on a sliding bonus scale that rewards success with a demand for even more work.

That puts me somewhere about a mile away from the ladder, since nobody pays me to post at all.  Man, have I blown this gig.


There are growing legions of online chroniclers, reporting on and reflecting about sports, politics, business, celebrities and every other conceivable niche. Some write for fun, but thousands write for Web publishers — as employees or as contractors — or have started their own online media outlets with profit in mind.

In the short time that I’ve been doing Simple Justice, it’s grown by leaps and bounds in terms of readership, comment and visitors.  Because of my ability to crank stuff out fairly quickly, not to mention my lack of paranoid concern that my posts be edited to within an inch of their life, I post a lot.  For a while, my friends in the blawgosphere were busy making fun of me for being a tad prolific.

But this is fun, folks.  When it stops being fun, I stop writing.  Poof, it all goes away the second I decide it does.  The idea of risking my health, even my life, to appease an audience is nuts.  Beyond this blawg, there is a real world.  It’s where I practice law.  It’s where I have a family and hobbies.  It’s where I live. 

I wouldn’t be inclined to work myself to death in any other endeavor, so why would I do so here?  My habit is to sit down, read a bunch of stuff that I have always read anyway, make note of things that interest me and pique my interest, so that I can post about them later.  In the early morning, when I wake up as I always have, I plop myself down in front of a computer and churn out a few posts.  Okay, sometimes more than a few.  Then I get up and go to work.

During the day, I see if there are any comments or emails of consequence, along with the stuff that I receive for real things, like my cases.  Sometimes, if there’s time, I deal with them.  Other times, they just slide into oblivion as real life leaves me no time to pursue them.  Either way, life goes on.  That’s the point.  Life goes on.

From the outside, it’s hard to tell whether a blawg is a large brick edifice of great substance, or a tiny ramshackle cabin in the middle of nowhere.  It can all look the same on the internet.  I’m often amused by the thought of some commenters who probably spend more time trolling the internet in search of post that demand their critical commentary.  It becomes consuming to some.  At Lat’s blog, the commenters fight to post the first comment, even though it often says nothing more than “I’m the first comment. Woo Hoo!” 

Simple Justice, of course, is a major enterprise, with many elves in the back rooms researching, writing, thinking and then thinking some more, about the major issue of the day in the law.  That’s why we are so important in the blawgosphere and why readers flock to us to learn of critical events in the law.  While you may feel sorry for these workaholic elves, slaving away night and day in the cubicles hoping to someday live as good a life as Dilbert, it’s great for me.  I barely break a sweat. 

If only those millions would start rolling in.

Stossel’s Folly: Selbin Responds

The other day, I  posted John Stossel’s disjointed and irrational diatribe printed in the Wall Street Journal.  The focus of his piece, as well as his 20/20 report, was to attack a lawsuit by a New York lawyer named Jonathon Selbin for suing his neighbor for smoking. 

In reading Stossel’s attempt at persuasion of the logic-challenged, clearly effective to some of our commenters who failed to recognize the absence of connection between one anecdote of a neighbor lawsuit to Stossel’s conclusion that class actions were the bane of America, I assumed that Stossel had at least gotten his facts right.  I reacted, like most, that Selbin was a jerk for suing his neighbor, but that this had zero logical connection to Stossel’s irrational conclusion.  Oops.  Never assume.

Today, I received a statement from Jonathon and Jenny Selbin, which they had previously provided Stossel and 20/20, which they immediately ignored.   After reading the Selbin’s statement, maybe he’s not such a danger to society after all.  As for Stossel, his ability to adhere to facts may be almost as challenged as his logical reasoning.

The bottom line if that after reading the details of the Selbin lawsuit, you may still think that the Selbin’s are a little too touchy and making a mountain out of a molehill.  But they aren’t the lawyers run amok that Stossel claimed, nor evil people for trying to live comfortably in their own home. 

Courts exist to resolve disputes that people can’t resolve on their own.  That’s the whole point, John Stossel, and the Selbins were forced to go to court by their neighbor’s refusal to get along, not because they are evil, money-grubbing lawyers.  Next time you want to scam the public and feed into the paranoia and ignorance, find a better target.


Statement of Jonathan and Jenny Selbin Regarding Smoking Lawsuit


We declined 20/20’s offer to appear on camera, just as we have every other such offer, because we are private people who did not seek and do not want publicity. Indeed, we regret that this matter had to come to litigation and generated any publicity at all.

For over a year we reached out to our neighbor Galila Huff and asked her to simply take reasonable steps to reduce the second-hand smoke coming from her apartment into our common hallway. She refused every step of the way. When that did not work, the Condominium Board passed a resolution requiring residents to keep second-hand smoke out of common areas. Ms. Huff ignored that too. As a last resort, we filed our lawsuit based upon well-established New York law that treats second-hand smoke in private residences as a nuisance.

We filed our lawsuit for one reason and one reason only: because second-hand smoke is toxic, especially to young children. That is not just our view, it is the official position of New York City, New York State, the Surgeon General of the United States, and just about the entire scientific and health communities. This is not a situation involving the sorts of things every New Yorker knows they must live with in the tight quarters we share, like food smells and noise. This is about toxins in our home being breathed every day by our 4-year old child. We filed our case as parents trying to do the best we can to protect our son from the needless exposure to toxins. Surely if we put chemicals toxic to Ms. Huff or her dog in the common hallway on a daily basis, she would be justified in asking us to stop (and, ultimately, suing us if we refused to stop).This is no different.

We do not want money. We do not want publicity. We simply want Ms. Huff to take reasonable steps to keep her smoke in her own apartment. We also do not want to try to tell Ms. Huff to stop smoking (in her home or anywhere else), nor is it our business what she does in the privacy of her home. It is only because her smoke comes into our common, shared hallway that it has become our business.

We believed this case was settled shortly after it was filed when the Aerus Company graciously donated two of their high-end air purifiers to Ms. Huff and one to us. We told Ms. Huff that we would quickly dismiss our lawsuit if she would simply agree to use these air purifiers and to put a fan in her window blowing out. Unfortunately, Ms. Huff has told us through her lawyer that rather than put a fan in her window, she instead intends to “contest this matter both in court and the media.” We regret that is her position.

We stand behind the basis for our lawsuit, but also stand ready to work with Ms. Huff to resolve this issue along the lines we have already made clear so that everyone can return to their normal private lives.

Comments From the Jesters Raise a Question

Recent  posts about the Royal Order Jesters have brought out an unusual array of comments.  Some were thoughtful.  Some were not.  Some were downright embarrassing.

One commenter raised a  red flag that has bothered me since.  The Hon. Bro. Keith A. Meyer (that, I believe, is his Mason handle, and I respect his choice of presenting himself that way) wrote:


I did not however join to drink and swear and party and go on sex tours and become a whoremonger and an adulterer, and if i know a brother that is so doing then i will personally bring him up on mansonic charges. Which we as masons know is far worse then what any court can do to us.

This notion raised a specter that had not previously occurred to me.  The Mason’s have their own, internal way of dealing with misconduct.  I don’t know what that is, and I don’t know what constitutes misconduct to a Mason.  But then he adds that it is “far worse then [sic] what any court can do” made me think.

The issue arose from a retired upstate New York judge who was a member of the Jesters, an offshoot of the Masons, who happened to be a “whoremongerer” on the side.  I wondered, was his allegiance as a judge to the Constitution and the laws of the State of New York, or to the Masons?

What if we found that judges who are Masons are torn in their responsibility?  Would a judge/Mason cut a fellow Mason a break?  Would he decide that Mason justice, rather than criminal justice, was the appropriate way to deal with his lodge brother?

There is a secrecy, and a zeal, that came through some of the reactions to this Jester revelation that leads me to think that a fear that judges who are also Masons might not be so crazy. 

Is this just a silly reaction to a few overzealous Masons who take their club a little too seriously, or is there a real concern that some judges may feel a stronger allegiance to their brotherhood than to their responsibility to the law?  I’m beginning to wonder in earnest.

How hard would it be for a defendant to give a judge the secret Mason wink, or work the word “hallibut” into his not-guilty plea?   Are Masonic judges conflicted?  Is there really a secret Masonic star-chamber that does worse things than our courts?

The Masons are a secret society, and reportedly have had such distinguished members as George Washington and Teddy Roosevelt.  To have a bunch of judges in there would hardly seem a stretch.  So I can’t help but wonder, do we need to question judges on whether they are Masons, and where their loyalty stands?

Don’t Twitter Me

My knowledge of cutting-edge technology is somewhat limited.  Generally, I have to ask  Bennett or  Gideon in order to find out what some of the new stuff is or does.  They try to tell me, but I usually don’t quite get it. 

I never had a myspace page, though I strongly urge any witness who I will cross-examine to get one immediately and puts lots of good stuff on it.  I joined Facebook because I kept getting invitations, but I have no idea why and have never bothered to look at my page.  I never had a beeper, and won’t get a blackberry.  The concept of being accessible 24/7 disturbs me.  I’m always there when my clients need me, but I’m not at their beck and call.

And now there’s Twitter.  It’s a horrible name, but it probably plays better with younger folks (the type of people who rarely use the word “folks”).  I heard of Twitter, but didn’t have the slightest clue what it was.  Kevin O’Keefe has cleared this up for me.  I feel so on top of technology today.

Kevin has posted a video at  Real Lawyers Have Blogs that explained Twitter.  The video explains it in plain English, apparently anticipating that eventually people like me would want to know what it was and that we were just too dumb to figure it out on our own.  That’s true, of course.

So for any other dinosaurs, this is Twitter in plain English:

Why?  Why would anybody want to do this?

We already have far more information available about us than anybody really wants to know (except if I have to cross-examine you, in which case you should just keep on putting more stuff on Facebook). 

Do you really want to know what book I’m reading, in real time?  What about my thoughts on the Giant’s chances of making it to the playoffs?  Or how many cups of coffee I drink every morning.  As I said to Kevin, we already have too much information.  This is just way too much.

Seriously, who has the time for this?  Who cares?  If you want to know what’s going on in the life of the people you care about, speak to them.  Can’t you see the kid with the crackberry flipping back and forth between Facebook and twitter and blogs and email, all while you’re sitting there trying to have a conversation.  He’s living online and ignoring the real person in front of him.  This is progress?

I’m already appalled by the image I have of people furiously posting comments on this blawg, trying to “win” arguments and prove their brilliance, as if this cyberworld was real.  Some comments seem the digital equivalent of trying to reach through the computer and strangle someone.  It’s ridiculous.  Use your heads, people.  This is a conversation, but snarling and cursing isn’t going to beat up your nemesis.  It’s only a friggin’ computer, for God’s sake.

I have a plan for a new concept.  It’s called “Chat”.  It involves one person physically meeting another person and then saying words, whereupon the other person says words in response.  They go back and forth, back and forth.  They learn things about the other person and tell things about themselves.  Sometimes, they drink a beverage or eat food while they do this.  Afterward, they shake hands, give a hug or maybe even a peck on the cheek, and go their separate ways. 

Or maybe the chat won’t go so well and one person will smack the other across the kisser.  But at least it will be real.  I better patent this quick, before someone steals it.

Sean Bell: 50 Wasted Bullets

The Sean Bell killing trial is winding down, as the defense is mopping up.  According to  Newsday’s interviews with a number of defense lawyers hanging around the courthouse, it’s looking grim for the prosecution.

This is one of those conflicted cases for criminal defense lawyers, where it’ hard to know who to root for.  Three police officers are on trial for pumping 50 bullets into Bell and his friends as they left his bachelor party on the day before his wedding. 

For the public and lawyers in other practice areas, the 50 bullets has always been the key factor.  It’s been played up in the media because of its sensationalistic ring.  It is, of course, a red herring.  The issue has always been whether the police officers were justified in firing the first bullet, not the last.  Police are trained to keep firing until the job is done, and if they were righteous when they first pulled the trigger, then it was a righteous shoot no matter how many bullets followed.

The public has this sense that the disproportionately high number of shots fired somehow changes the scenario.  Fifty bullets just seems like overkill.  It was in an absolute sense (why were that many shots needed?), but it is of little legal significance.  This is a hard sell, however, and should there be no conviction in this case, people will take to the streets because of the “injustice”.  There may well be an injustice done here, but the number of shots fired won’t be it.

The defense took the stunning path of trying this case before a judge rather than jury.  I  questioned it at the time.  The strategy appears designed to get over the 50 bullets hurdle, one that the judge, Arthur Cooperman, would be more likely to overcome than 12 jurors.  For cops, it’s hard to find a jury of one’s peers. 

Justice Cooperman, who  received a reversal (again) from the Appellate Division during the course of this trial for failing to suppress illegally obtained evidence, will decide this case on his own.  It will be one of his final decisions before leaving the bench, and likely the one for which he will be remembered.  It’s hard to know how this will influence his feelings about the case.

But the criminal defense lawyers who have been sitting in the courtroom, watching some strong lawyers like Tony Ricco defend the cops, say that the prosecution has blown the trial.  From the accounts I’ve read in the papers, it’s appeared as if they were trying to blow the case at times.  Not to be cynical, but prosecuting cops has its problems for the District Attorney as well. 

The district attorney lives and dies on the cooperation of the police; they need the cops on their side if they are to do their job.  Police, on the other hand, always circle the wagon, no matter what a cop is accused of doing.  They don’t believe anybody, including the DA, understands them or their job, and that there is never a good reason to put a cop on trial.  The only exception would be Serpico because he was a cop-rat, the only unforgivable offense.

The structure of the prosecution’s case left much to be desired.  The two friends of Sean Bell, Joseph Guzman and Trent Benefield, are both suing the City for their injuries, giving them 50 million reasons to lie.  The prosecution knew this, of course, but did nothing to address it. 

Jean Nelson, the one friend of Bell’s who wasn’t in the car and hence wasn’t shot, was called by the prosecution, but gave the defense critical testimony.


Nelson helped police when he said he saw Isnora on Liverpool Street standing in front of Bell’s Altima with a drawn gun, saying, “Yo, I want to holler at you,” slang for “I want to talk to you.”

Bell then drove straight at Isnora, an undercover cop, who jumped onto the hood to get out of the way before the vehicle slammed into a police van being driven by Oliver, according to Nelson.

Since Nelson has no financial interest at stake and he’s naturally inclined toward the Bell side, this testimony looms huge.  Even though Nelson testified that he saw no shields and heard no one announce that they were police, the justification defense relies on the belief of the cops that Bell was using his car as a weapon against them.  It’s the reasonable belief of the cops that matters for the defense to prevail.

Another prosecution witness, undercover Det. Hispolito Sanchez, also provided testimony that may prove crucial in this regard.  He testified that he heard “someone in Bell’s group remarked, ‘Yo, go get my gun’ during the argument outside the Kalua.”  While this testimony lacked a certain ring of truth about it (particularly since there was no such gun), as if the undercover was offering his blue brothers a wink that no one could dispute, one still has to wonder what the prosecution was thinking when the called Det. Sanchez as a witness.

The lawyers quoted in the article know a little something about criminal trials, and I’m inclined to believe that they’re opinion that the prosecution has blown the case is accurate.


“I clearly feel that the prosecution has not proven a case beyond a reasonable doubt,” said Murray Richman, a top defense attorney from the Bronx who concedes he is not “pro-cop.”

When “Don’t Worry” Murray, who has probably tried more cases than anyone else I know, says they didn’t prove the case, I’d bet money he’s right.  While it won’t help the relationship between the NYPD and the people of Queens, or anyplace else in New York City, and it will have the taint of another thrown prosecution when cops are involved, it looks like Justice Cooperman’s job won’t be that difficult.  And he won’t go out on yet another reversal.

But there will be cries in the streets if these 3 officers are acquitted by the judge.  50 bullets.

The Limousine Liberal Syndrome

Bill and Hillary Clinton have provided  a timid peak at how they’re doing since they left the White House.  Not too badly, if you consider $109 million over eight years to be a decent return on investment.  I know I do. 

The Clintons released their tax returns, save for 2007, yesterday, a Friday, designed no doubt to minimize attention, as noted by Turley.  Jonathon is no doubt correct, as every politician knows the news cycle better than they know their own kid’s name.  While it may be an attempt to hide from Bill’s failure to live up to his own vision of charitable giving, I suspect that their reluctance is much more basis.

It’s hard to sell to the American public that you care about them when you’ve made over $100 million.  The number is just too hard to swallow.  It’s too much.  It begs the question, if they cared to much, why aren’t they giving it back.  Why does Hillary take her Senate paycheck?  Why does Bill take his White House pension?  They don’t need the money. 

One of the epithets that has been used effectively is “limousine liberal.”  That’s the rich fellow who espouses deep, abiding concern for the poor and downtrodden, as he gets into the back seat of his long, black limo to be whisked off to some black tie affair. 

There’s a smell of hypocrisy about it. If they want to give something to the poor, let them start with their own money, the argument goes.  They can afford it.

There’s an element of truth to the complaint.  To enjoy vast wealth, while asking others who have decidedly less, to give, sounds disingenuous.  Some, like Bill Gates, give away enough to fund small cities.  But then, Bill Gates won’t be missing any meals in the near future.

The problem in politics is being caught in the conundrum of holding heartfelt beliefs while holding a healthy bank book.  Despite the apparent odor, there is no rational correlation between financial success and concern for others.  Why must wealthy people be selfish and self-centered to be perceived as honest?

On the other side, why must people who care about others divest themselves of rewards of their personal financial success?  There is no logical argument to support the notion that one must be impoverished in order to truly “feel the pain.”  Empathy has no financial qualifications.

But it is valid to question just how much wealth one requires before acting upon those heartfelt beliefs.  It’s fine to say that a person is entitled to enjoy a comfortable lifestyle while recognizing and appreciating the situation of those less fortunate.  Where to draw the line of “a comfortable lifestyle” is awfully hard to do. 

The problem for the Clintons is that most people would agree that $100 million in the bank is probably over the line.  Even if Chelsea ends up being needier than anticipated, they will still have more than enough money to take good care of her.  Hillary can afford as many pantsuits in pastel colors as any woman could want.  Bill doesn’t look undernourished.  What if they gave $50 million away, and only had $50 or so left in the bank.  Would they suffer?  I doubt it.

Of course, it costs a lot of money to run for the Democratic nomination.  It costs a lot to run for President if you get the nod.  This is not for pikers, and the Clintons, who may have been anticipating a run for a while now, could be saving their pennies to cover the cost of donuts on the campaign trail.  It could happen.

But I have no doubt that Bill and Hillary Clinton understood that the minute they let the public know how they were doing financially, a backlash (that she doesn’t need at the moment) would happen.  Whether she deserves it has yet to be seen, but $109 million is still a whole lot of money.

Come Out For Literacy Nassau

This Monday, April 7th,  Literacy Nassau will be holding its annual fundraising and “(un)Scrabble” challenge.  If you can, come on out and support this group, whose mission is


Through personalized instruction, we open
doors to opportunity and success for adults
in our communities who seek help with
reading, writing or speaking English.

The (un)Scrabble event will include a cocktail party and dinner, silent and live auction.




The evening’s host will be  Brian Kilmeade from Fox & Friends, and I have been honored to serve as auctioneer for the live auction.  Get over there and bid your heads off for a great cause!

And lest anyone wonder why Fox & Friends co-host Kilmeade has so graciously given of his time to host this event, bordering on blashemy in the world of “fair and balanced” politics, check out the video below. 

A Scathing Dissent From Judge Merritt, 6th Circuit

Via Doug Berman, Gilbert Stroud Merritt, Senior Circuit Judge in the Sixth Circuit, has apparently had enough.  Perhaps this is the product of too many years on the bench, watching as people before him are sacrificed on the alter of simplistic, reactionary politics. 

In United States v. Jeross, (6th Cir. Apr. 4, 2008), Judge Merritt issued a dissent that leave little doubt about his feelings toward the United States Sentencing Guidelines and the Circuit’s refusal to stray.  Of particular interest is his note that the Supreme Court’s efforts in Blakely–Booker–Cunningham are simply being ignored in favor of the rote application of the guidelines.



This is another drug case in which our system of criminal law has imprisoned for many years two more lives and torn up two more families by grossly excessive sentences imposed in the “War on Drugs.”  There are many reasons that our federal system of punishment has turned in this direction, not the least of which is the advent during the last 20 years of our irrational set of sentencing guidelines that judges apply by rote on a daily basis.  We are constantly adding new prisoners like these defendants with long periods of incarceration to the more than two million men and women now incarcerated in the hundreds of prisons and jails around the country.


These sentencing guidelines hold that mitigating factors like family ties, mental illness, education, and the likelihood of rehabilitation are simply “not relevant” in the sentencing process.  Judges’ minds are closed down and sentences ratcheted up by applying convoluted conversion formulas like the one just recited in the majority opinion.  The recent Blakely–Booker–Cunningham line of Supreme Court cases has given judges an opportunity to rid the system of some of the worst aspects of guidelinism, but we judges soldier on by applying the old mandatory system as though nothing of significance had happened.  The cost to the taxpayers and in human lives has become enormous and shows no signs of change.


Having argued these points with passion over the years, only to have a few judges express sympathy, but claim their hands were tied, and to have other judges blithely announce that compelling factors in sentencing are simply off the table, and questioning why I would waste their time by even bringing them up, Judge Merritt’s dissent well expresses the frustration of trying to return some semblance of reason to a process that designed to eliminate any degree of individualized consideration.

Doug notes in posting this dissent that he does so to let Judge Merritt, whose dissent he aptly described as tilting at windmills, knows that at least one person is paying attention.  Make that two.

NYSACDL: Compounded Failures and Deep Disappointment

This post has been more than a year in coming.  It has been more than six months since an unusual vote by the past presidents and Board chose to ignore the significance of financial scandal, and only now are the members being told.  I’ve waited a long time for this to go public, but now that the president has finally sent out a letter to the membership, the time has come.

In January, 2007, a review of the financials for the Association revealed stunning irregularities.  They centered on the executive director’s expenses via the Association’s American Express account, which had voluminous unexplained charges ranging from match.com to women’s shoes to a wedding dress.  Also discovered were interest charges amounting to around $14,000 for unpaid AmEx bills in 2005. 

An independent auditor was retained and an audit committee formed.   Both arrived at the same conclusion.  The executive director had to be fired.  She had been charging the Association AmEx card for personal expenses for years.  When confronted, she claimed she had paid back all the money, but she was unable to prove this.  The claim was false. 

The interest charges to the card reflected the executive director’s directions to pay off the minimum balance after the annual dinner in 2004 rather than pay off the full amount, even though the Association had the funds to pay the total.  The president at the time started receiving dunning calls from AmEx. His response was to tell the executive director to get them off his back, and otherwise ignore it.

This was a disaster.  But only the first in a series. 

In September, 2007, the Board held a meeting to determine what to do about the executive director.  A massive campaign was waged prior to the meeting to convince past presidents and certain friendly board members that the executive director didn’t mean it, didn’t really do anything, was a good and dear person, and that fault should be laid at the feet of others, even though the executive director, and no one else, was solely responsible for the use of the Association card for personal expenditures. 

The September Board meeting was quite unusual, in that there was a large turnout of past presidents who otherwise never show.  The Association allows past presidents to vote on the Board, a peculiarity in itself.  By a majority of one, based largely on the past presidents, the Board voted to retain the executive director, despite what had happened.  Over objection, she was required to repay the amounts charged, and a committee was formed for that purpose.  The outstanding balance would have been sufficient to make it a felony. 

This is the first leg of the story.  The second was the dues increase levied against the membership this year, while there was silence on the part of the Board as to what had happened.  Factions on the Board argued about what, and how, to tell the membership of this scandal.  There was a group of Board members who thought that disclosure of this scandal with the members’ money would “harm” the Association, and that the members had no need to know of it.  There was another faction who believed that the members had a right to know, and the Board had a duty to tell them.  There was a third faction who just wanted this ugly mess to go away.

Upon pain of some present who demanded that the membership be told, a committee was formed to prepare a letter in October, 2007.  By January, 2008, the letter was completed, circulated, and summarily rejected by the group that did not want the membership to know the truth.  This letter revealed too much, and made the executive director look too “guilty”.  A second letter was hastily drafted, that fudged the details and gave the impression that everything had been well-handled by the Board.  It was meant to calm the potential storm.

It took from January 16th until April 4th for that letter to be sent out to the membership.  The letter, copied below, is dated March 14, 2008.

I have waited until the letter was sent to the members to write about what happened because it was not my place to make the disclosure, though I have pushed for it (as have others) from the beginning.  Now that the letter has been sent, it’s time to discuss what happened and why, and what is so fundamentally wrong about all of this.

As someone who has dedicated a great deal of time to the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, having served as Amicus Chair, Board Member, Vice President, I find that the entirety of this situation has been a disgrace.  I am shocked by those Board members who chose to forgive and forget when it was members money, not theirs, at stake.  It was not their place to do so.  I am shocked that the Board thought so little of the membership that they would conceal what happened. 

I personally like the executive director.  I always have.  But as a fiduciary, what she did was wholly unacceptable, no matter how much I liked her.  There is no theory, no rationale, no argument that could possibly make her conduct acceptable.  Neither the letter, nor this post, begin to provide the flavor of how bad this was.  It was quite outrageous.  It was clearly very wrong. 

Similarly, the fact that a majority of the voting Board, meaning past presidents who appeared only for the purpose of voting to retain the executive director, decided that it was within their province to forgive someone who used members’ money for her personal shopping, is inexcusable.  They failed as fiduciaries.  They failed the members.  They had no right to forgive someone using the members’ money to buy her daughter’s wedding dress. 

Then, the decision to increase dues while concealing the financial scandal bordered on fraud.  Bear in mind, the nature and scope of this impropriety was known throughout this period, and deliberately withheld from the membership while the members were told of the dues increase. 

But the final nail in the coffin was that it took more than six months since the decision of September, 2007 to forgive this scandal before anything was disclosed to the members.  Those who thought forgiveness was the right thing to do were afraid of how the membership would react if the truth came out.  They had reason to be afraid. 

Those who voted to discharge the executive director held different fears; They were afraid that disclosure of this scandal would cause the Association to implode, and they didn’t want to “harm” the Association.  This paternalistic fear, that the members couldn’t handle the truth so they would handle it for them, treated the members like children.  Good enough to pay the dues, and not good enough to know the truth. 

I have resigned from the Board, in protest of this and other issues that have been percolating for years.  I cannot condone the actions and inactions of the Board, and I have long questioned whether the Association has lost its focus and any true purpose for its existence.  The duty of the Board in this scandal seemed clear to me from the outset, and that portion of the Board had no right to substitute its personal feelings for its responsibility to the members. 

Now that the letter has gone out, after almost daily prodding by those who believed that disclosure to the members was the absolute minimum required of the Association, it’s up to the members to decide whether the Board fulfilled its fiduciary responsibility.  Some may decide that they no longer want to be a member of the Association.  Others may agree with the Board’s action.  Others still may not care.

But the Association exists for the members, not the elite or the Board or to give the executive director a place to go
every weekday.  To deny the members the truth is wholly unacceptable.  It is now up to the members to make what they will of this situation.  I have chosen to end my involvement with the NYSACDL, and I am deeply saddened that I feel there is no other choice under the circumstances.



Text of the Letter:

Many of you may have heard about an important matter that was addressed by the Board this fall regarding the Executive Director, Pat Marcus. This brief description of what took place is intended to advise the membership generally of the events that took place. Please feel free to contact me directly if you would like further information.

In January, 2007 the NYSACDL Board authorized an audit of the books and records of the Association for the years 2005/2006. An Audit Committee of the Board was formed at that time and it was requested to interview, select and, with the Board’s approval, retain auditors for this purpose. Following a search, the Audit Committee reported to the Board, which authorized hiring the firm of Salerno, Gannon and Angelo, PC (SGA).

In May, 2007 SGA gave its report to the Audit Committee. The auditor’s report disclosed the use of the Association’s credit card by the Executive Director for personal expenses, a matter which was of grave concern to the Audit Committee.

As a result of this preliminary report, the Audit Committee recommended the termination of the Executive Director and referred the matter to the Executive Committee. After considering the issues, the Executive Committee called for a special meeting of the full Board of Directors which was held on September 8, 2007 to address the issues in the Auditor’s report. The Board reviewed voluminous records of the Association’s finances for the two preceding years as well as the explanation by the Executive Director. Ms. Marcus explained that she had used the NYSACDL card on numerous occasions and had paid the bill from her own funds. This had occurred for the entire time she had been employed by the NYSACDL.

Having duly heard Ms. Marcus and reviewing the documents and recommendations of the accountants, the Board voted (although notably not unanimously) that Ms. Marcus would remain in her position.

Following the September 8 meeting, a thorough investigation of all the relevant documents was reviewed by a sub-committee of the Board. It was determined that, although thousands of dollars of personal expenses were paid by Ms. Marcus at or near the time of the purchase, approximately $3,100 of personal charges had not, in fact, been paid by Ms. Marcus over the course of years, Ms. Marcus has subsequently reimbursed the Association for such personal expenses.

While the Board agrees that Ms. Marcus’ behavior was imprudent, it took into consideration her many years of faithful service to the Association and what appears to have been a mistake in miscalculating what was owed. She has not been allowed to use the Association’s credit card during the investigation and will not be permitted to use it for personal expenses at any time in the future.

Please be assured that no member money was diverted for non-Association expenses during this period.

More importantly, the Association has undergone a complete revamping of its financial controls and procedures in accordance with the recommendations of the auditors.

In the event there are questions or concerns regarding any issue mentioned here, please feel free to contact me.

Sincerely,

/S/
Lisa Schreibersdorf

Liptak Headed To Washington

As has been widely reported, New York Times Supreme Court correspondent, Linda Greenhouse, has hung up her spurs and taken an “academic” position at Yale Law School, after accepting a very sweet buyout.  Greenhouse had covered the court for 30 years, nabbing some Pulitzers along the way.  She’s now going to be “journalist in residence” at Yale, teaching courses in law and media.

But the question of who would fill her shoes remained a mystery until yesterday, when Lyle Denniston at  SCOTUSBlog disclosed an internal announcement that the new SCOTUS maven will be Adam Liptak.

“We think we have found exactly the right person to succeed Linda. I am pleased to announce that Adam Liptak will be the paper’s Supreme Court reporter. If Adam’s time as national legal correspondent is any measure, he will continue to make coverage of the court one of the paper’s distinguishing features, something we do better than anyone else in the country.

“Since joining the newsroom in 2002, Adam has covered the Valerie Wilson case and the Supreme Court nominations of John Roberts and Samuel Alito. He has roamed the country bringing life to musty legal cases and fights over judicial ethics, and produced major projects on the criminal justice system. He has also written a must-read column, Sidebar, that has been cited on the floor of the Senate, in Federal appeals and district court decisions, in editorials in The Times and The Washington Post, and on the Colbert Report (I kid you not).

“Before joining the newsroom, Adam was one of our lawyers. And before that he was an associate at the New York firm of Cahill Gordon and Reindel. The resume is impressive. But what impressed me most in my discussions with Adam was his remarkable ability to talk about the law with sweep and simplicity. It was striking that these are the precise qualities that make Linda such a great reporter.”

While it’s not exactly shocking the Liptak got the post, since he wrote the Sidebar column that I so dearly love to  skewer on a regular basis, the choice remains curious.

I’ve been fairly critical of Liptak’s columns in the past, not so much because of his bias but because of his superficial approach.   Althouse makes an interesting and revealing comment in this regard:


The resume is impressive. But what impressed me [i.e., Washington bureau chief Dean Baquet] most in my discussions with Adam was his remarkable ability to talk about the law with sweep and simplicity.

Is simplicity really what is needed?  Arguably, it’s a good thing to be able to take a complex subject and present in a simple, comprehensible manner.  But that’s not what Liptak does.  Simplicity isn’t the word I would have chosen.  Simplistic is more precise.

Half the time, I get the impression that Adam Liptak doesn’t quite get it.  While I’ve often commented that he tells half a story, leaving glaring gaps in his presentation of issues where other views or arguments are required to flesh out the ideas, I tend to think that he’s simply unaware that there are better, stronger or countervailing points of view. 

When it comes to the Supreme Court, there is no shortage of complicated issues and arguments that one must recognize to appreciate what’s at stake and what they do.  It’s an onion, with layer upon layer of nuance, scrutinized by observers within an inch of its life.  Certainly in the blawgosphere, we discuss these cases to death, fighting over every word and arguing every angle. 

Some may well believe that the lawprofs, and even some lawyers, take things too far.  We see issues where none exist, and collateral consequences that only a legal mind could imagine.  But its this depth of recognition that allows one to “see” the issues and problems, and then vet the mass of thought for the points worthy of discussion. 

My focus, naturally, has been primarily on Liptak’s work relating to criminal law issues.  More often than not, he’s been disappointing.  He’s never had a feel for criminal law, and some of his articles have defied any semblance of reality.  His  bail bondsman piece was one particularly egregious example of truly bad work.  But his article on felony murder, which demonstrated a fundamental lack of understanding of the subject matter, is the type of piece that makes me think he’s over his head.  At least on criminal law issues.

The New York Times, for better or worse, is a paper of some substantial influence.  People will read what Liptak writes and believe that his words accurately reflect the significance of matters before the Supreme Court.  This is a huge responsibility.  His words will forge attitudes and beliefs.  People will take sides based on what he writes, and believe that they understand based on what he says.  To the extent that freedom of the press is a pillar of effective democracy, Adam Liptak has been placed in a pivotal role.

Is Adam Liptak up to the task?