Author Archives: SHG

Nowhere Left To Go For Sex Offender

Chuck Kenville’s new blog, Iowa Champion, has a story demonstrating the inherent problems with legislation designed to make registered sex offenders a permanent underclass.  According to this MSNBC story,



Jennifer Lower was convicted of a misdemeanor sex offense in Ohio seven years ago. After moving to Iowa, and then moving her family to a town with no schools or day cares — which she can’t live near under Iowa law — she’s learned that she is still in violation of the law.


From the Cass County Jail, Lower, 29, said she’s frustrated. Lower is a married mother of three. She already moved her family to try to comply with Iowa’s sex-offender residency law that bans sex offenders from living within 2,000 feet of a school or day care. She said she can’t find a home that complies.


It’s not that each individual restriction doesn’t comport with some common sense notion that it’s a reasonable limitation and suited to protect children, but that the totality makes it impossible for a sex offender to find any location that complies with the law


Forced out of Atlantic, Lower and her family moved 5 miles west to Marne, Iowa. There are no schools or day cares in Marne, so Lower said she thought she and her family were safe.

Then Marne passed a new ordinance, making it illegal for sex offenders to live within 2,000 feet of a park or school bus stop. Lowers’ home was a couple blocks from the park and less than a block from a bus stop, so once again, a court ordered Lower to move.

In many areas, it would seem impossible to find a home that is not within 2,000 feet of a school bus stop.  For those who really don’t care about sex offenders, we’re still stuck with a problem.  They have to be somewhere.  We just can’t create a system that makes it impossible for them to find a home that complies with the law.

In this specific instance, Lower refused to move again and was sentenced to 30 days in jail as a result.  The point of the sentence appears ludicrous.  After serving her sentence, she’s still left with no viable options to find a lawful place to reside.  It makes as much sense as the judge ordering her to sprout wings and fly. 

While sex offenders remain the least sympathetic of any discrete group in the criminal justice system, this situation is clearly out of control.  There are far too many offense inappropriately and unnecessarily wrapped up in the sex offender classification, and legislators are busy creating increasing limitations that present an impossible situation. 

It may soon come to the point where we will need an island somewhere to be populated solely with registered sex offenders, that being the only real estate in America that complies with these restrictions.  Unfortunately, I imagine that a majority of Americans wouldn’t really have much of a problem with this idea.

Cop Tases 11 Year Old Learning Disabled Girl

According to this report by WFTV Eyewitness News, Thaliamar Jimenez was shot with a taser at Moss Park Elementary School in Orange County, Florida.  Thaliamar was a learning disabled 11 year old who had a tantrum and, as the officer tried to remove her from the class, hit the officer in the nose.


According to the arrest report, before school Thursday morning, another student told teachers at Moss Park that Thaliamar pushed a boy into the street. When teachers tried to talk to the girl she became combative, started pushing her desk and chair and even spit at the teachers.

“She actually spoke to the student, told her multiple times to come. Even after the student punched her, she still continued to try and make the arrest without having to taze her. And that obviously wasn’t working,” explained Corporal Susan Soto, Orange County Sheriff’s Office.

The school resource officer, Orange County Deputy Donna Hudepohl, tried to take Thaliamar to the principal’s office and that’s when the child started swinging, hitting the officer in the nose.

So Deputy Hudepohl tased Thaliamar.


Many other parents are standing by the woman they call “their deputy.” “She had it coming. She assaulted an officer. You can’t let that go,” said parent Shanna Herrick.

This is a far more complicated issue than would appear from the news report, which is quite disappointing in its lack of information.

The reports states that Thaliamar was a learning disabled student with a behavioral component, which means that she should have had a behavioral intervention plan as part of her individualized education plan (IEP).  In other words, she wasn’t just some “bad girl” who became violent, but a girl who suffered from a disability that gave rise to a loss of control that manifested in this behavior.  This is a common occurrence with LD children, and one that schools should be prepared to handle.

When properly addressed, schools should be aware of the things that trigger uncontrolled outbursts and the ways to diffuse them without doing harm to the student or the student doing harm to others.  While the knee-jerk assumption is that all children have the ability to control their behavior, LD students can be viewed like people with Tourette Syndrome, where they have no ability to control the sounds they emit, often including epithets, and it is no reflection on their being deliberately violent or malevolent.

While the story notes that Thaliamar had prior violent episodes, there was no mention of the school having developed a plan to address her uncontrolled behavior. 

Typically, the parents of other students are intolerant of the needs of learning disabled students, both because they put their children at risk and because they are disruptive and problematic in class.  However, since public schools are wedded to the inclusion model of educating learning disabled students, and since there are few options available to parents of LD students, especially those who lack the ability to pay for the few extraordinarily expensive private schools dedicated to teaching them, even children with behavioral components remain in the classroom.

Still, it’s difficult to imagine that between the teachers, school administrators and police, they were unable to find a way to diffuse Thaliamar’s outburst short of shooting her with a taser.  In light of her learning disability, one would think that the school would have simply waited until she calmed down, diverted her attention or sought to reduce the level of confusion, tension, stimuli until she was able to better process what was happening around her. 

The natural assumption, that Thaliamar had control over her behavior, does not necessarily apply to some LD kids.  When police order them to stop, it produces the opposite affect, increasing tension and the level in stimuli, which the LD student cannot process adequately or quickly.  When the student does not obey, or lashes out because they don’t comprehend what is happening around them, police misapprehend the meaning of their conduct and react.

In the past,  I’ve posted about parents of LD children reaching out to their local police and educating them about their child for the specific purpose of avoiding situations like this.  Some police departments have taken the initiative to  train their officers to identify and address learning disabled children, particularly since the prevalence of autism looms as a significant problem for police. 

It’s impossible to imagine that this situation could not have been handled far better than it was, and the simplistic calculus, girl hit officer so officer tased girl, reflects a disastrously wrong response.  Schools are failing learning disabled students, in the first instance, and police must be trained in how to handle this children to avoid exacerbating the situation and causing needless and pointless harm.

These situations are bound to increase if schools and police don’t get a handle on how to address learning disabled students with behavioral components.  We don’t tase children because they are disabled and don’t understand.  Even if the other parents think it’s just fine.

Yates Named Paterson’s Counsel

Every once in a while, somebody in Albany does something smart.  This time, it was David Paterson, our new governor.   He has named Manhattan Justice James Yates as his counsel.

I am a huge fan of Judge Yates, not because he has always been particularly kind to me (we’ve gone at it a few times), but because he is one of the smartest judges I’ve ever known.  Smart is good.

A little background on Judge Yates:


Mr. Yates graduated from Princeton University in 1967 and received a law degree from Rutgers University in 1973, after which he joined the Legal Aid Society as a staff lawyer. He was senior counsel to the State Assembly’s Codes Committee from 1979 to 1987; legislative counsel to the Assembly speakers Mel Miller and Saul Weprin from 1989 to 1992; and a judge for the State Court of Claims from 1992 to 1998.

Aside from his time in Jersey, which apparently reflects a transitory wrong turn over the GWB, he’s done his time. 

Turning to the more subjective aspect, my experience with Jim Yates is that he possesses a level of integrity about himself, his work and public service that is unbearably rare in New York politics.  This is one of those guys who is in it for the right reasons, and wants to serve rather than “lead”. 

Governor Paterson has made a wise choice.  If Judge Yates needs a hand with anything, I hope he gives me a call.  Albany will gain a great deal by having Jim Yates back.

Como Se Dice, “Slammer?”

From the Wilkes-Barre Times Leader, Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. has ordered three Hispanic defendants to either learn English or do 24 months in prison.

The defendants – Luis Reyes, Ricardo Dominguez, Kelvin Reyes-Rosario and Rafael Guzman-Mateo – all needed translators when they appeared in court to plead guilty to criminal conspiracy to commit robbery. It led to Olszewski leveling the unusual condition.

But in order for them to avoid the 24 months in prison, Olszewski ordered the men to learn to read and write the English language, earn their GED, and, within 30 days of release, get a full-time job while on parole. The defendants, who range in age from 17 to 22, are to return to court in one year with their parole officers to take an English test, according to Olszewski’s order.

At first blush, this imaginative requirement might strike one as a bit jingoistic.  After all, who is a judge to say that his language is better than their language.  But frankly, there’s much to be commended about substituting education for prison when it comes to helping a defendant.


The ruling, the judge said, is supposed to help, not punish.“There’s no way young kids can be hurt by knowing how to read and write the English language,” he said. “It’s a means to helping them get a better education, getting a better job. Period.”

It’s not as if the judge has forbidden them to speak Spanish, or forced them to Anglicize their names.  Indeed, one of the things that criminal defense lawyers have found to be the root of crime is our clients’ inability to find decent employment or lack of the basic educational requirements to gain access to decent jobs.  How can you complain about a judge allowing them the opportunity to better their situation?

Notably, the defendants’ are quite pleased with the option presented by the court. 

But Latino community activists are less thrilled.

But that doesn’t make it right, said Agapito Lopez, a Latino community leader from Hazleton. He said he believes the ruling is a violation of the suspects’ rights.

“I think that it’s contrary to the Constitution,” said Lopez, who stressed he is not an attorney and is speaking from a lay person’s perspective. “I don’t think that is due process. … I think this can be challenged in court.”

Whether this is a violation of anyone’s constitutional rights is a fair question, but that doesn’t make it a bad policy choice. 

Unfortunately, the judge, having taken a leap of faith by engaging in this unusual sentencing trade-off, has done himself little good with his subsequent explanation.


Olszewski said the language condition he imposed on the defendants, who are resident aliens, was not something he had planned. Once he saw all the translators in court for one case, the idea dawned on him.

The decision, he said, could help cut down on extreme costs associated with the paying for translators for each court appearance.

Plus, he said, one of the defendants only went to third grade; the others didn’t finish high school. Learning English will help them get their GED first, and then a job, he said.

“Do you think we are going to supply you with a translator all of your life?” he asked them.

Well, yes, your honor.  That’s exactly what you’re going to do when defendants don’t speak English, even in Pennsylvania.  That’s how this system works. 

Lopez, the community leader responded:


Learning the language could help the suspects, Lopez said. But it would not assure them of getting a job – that theory is merely mythical, he said.

“This is a country in which English is not the official language,” he said. “We cannot force people to learn the language.”

All true, but it can’t hurt and it beats the crap out of spending two years in the slammer, doesn’t it?  The constitutional problem of trading off prison time for learning English, not to mention the fact that the justification for putting the defendants in prison is undermined if they can be safely left out, is clearly a stumbling block to the validity of this creative option.

But I can’t help but think that the defendants will be far better off as a result of this sentence.

(Title courtesy of New York Lawyer.  It was just so much better than anything I could think of.)

Meet The Newest TV Idols, The DEA!

A few days ago, an email came across from PR powerhouse Howard Rubenstein’s shop promoting a new television show. 

On April 2, the new original series “DEA” will premiere on Spike TV, produced by Al Roker Entertainment with unprecedented cooperation with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration and undercover agents. 

“DEA” offers viewers a never-before-seen look at the inner workings of the undercover world of drugs, with exclusive access during each episode as cameras follow a group of Special Agents and Task Force Officers in the DEA Detroit division as they risk their lives in the daily ongoing battle against illegal drugs.

The series follows Special Agents as they work cases ranging from street level dealers to international drug traffickers.

I hope this is something you may be interested in posting on your web site.  Thanks.

Clearly, they missed the point of my blawg. 

Al Roker, the formerly rotund and jolly weatherman, had gastric bypass surgery and turned into an aggressive TV producer.  An ill-wind blew him my way with this effort to cash in on this COPS take off, designed to turn the Drug Enforcement Agency, one of the more violent and dirty arms of government, into the next beloved Angel of public safety. 

Do you doubt that this is a total lovefest?  Watch the preview.  Dontcha just wanna hug ’em?

So I wondered, will it show the DEA agents busting heads?  Will it show them coercing confessions?  What about executing search warrants at the wrong house, and beating some innocent elderly woman “just to be safe?” 

No, this will be another show designed to assure the public that their law enforcement agents would never lie, cheat or steal.  They would never commit perjury to frame anybody.  They would never beat innocent people.  These things never happen.

When I told  Mark Bennett that I had received this email, he asked me if I was really going to “promote” this mutt of a show by blawging about it.  It’s not like I’m going to make this show go away by ignoring it, so yes, here it is.  If you don’t know about the garbage that will influence the public, then you can’t address it.

I wonder if Al would care to do a show about people who were wrongfully convicted and sentenced to death?  We already have enough material for 214 shows.

Judge Cassell Offers The Rationale Behind Victims’ Rights

With all due respect, a phrase used by lawyers to preface any and all insults, former Judge turned lawprof Paul Cassell is running on empty in his quest to elevate the “rights” of victims to the status of a third party in the criminal courtroom.

Via Doug Berman, this is Judge Cassell’s official abstract of his lecture for National Crime Victims Rights Week:


In the last two decades, the criminal justice systems of every state and the federal government have protected the right of crime victims to deliver a victim impact statement at sentencing.  Yet while these reforms have proven popular with the public and politicians, legal academics remain skeptical.  These critics have argued that victim impact statements have no proper role to play at sentencing and that they unduly inject emotion into what should be an objective decision about the appropriate sentence for a defendant.  On this important issue, the critics are wrong and the public is right.  Crime victims have a vital role to play throughout the criminal justice process, particularly at sentencing where judges need a wide range of information to determine the proper sentence for an already-convicted criminal. Moreover, criminal sentencing can never be a completely emotionless process. Even though victim impact statements may be emotional, crime victims provide vital information to judges about the harm caused by a defendant — a critical component of the sentencing decision. By delivering victim impact statements, victims also regain some of the dignity that was taken from them by criminal offenders.  Victim impact statements at sentencing are therefore a proper part of our nation’s approach to criminal justice.

Let’s follow that trail of logic:

Problem:  they unduly inject emotion into what should be an objective decision about the appropriate sentence for a defendant.

Response 1:  the critics are wrong and the public is right. 

Response 2:  Crime victims have a vital role to play throughout the criminal justice process, particularly at sentencing where judges need a wide range of information to determine the proper sentence for an already-convicted criminal.

Response 3:  criminal sentencing can never be a completely emotionless process. Even though victim impact statements may be emotional, crime victims provide vital information to judges about the harm caused by a defendant — a critical component of the sentencing decision.

Response 4:  victims also regain some of the dignity that was taken from them by criminal offenders. 

Conclusion:  Victim impact statements at sentencing are therefore a proper part of our nation’s approach to criminal justice.

Well. okay then.  If someone as smart as Judge Cassell can’t come up with a better argument than that, then it appears that the entirety of the victims’ rights movement has but one real basis:  Because they want to.  Nothing in this statement shows a basis for the inclusion of victim impact in the sentencing decision, but rather a diatribe about why it would be good for victims to be able to have a catharsis.  I don’t disagree that victims have been emotionally hurt, and that a catharsis would be good for them, but that isn’t a reason to include them in the sentencing process.

Contrast a few thoughts, not intended to be exhaustive.  Does the murder of a person without family not count?  Does the sentence rest on one victim’s ability to express anger better than another?  Crimes are against society, not individuals.  This merely fudges the line by an appeal to sympathy.  We can be sympathetic, but that is not a reason to fundamentally alter the nature of criminal prosecution.  The reason certain conduct is criminal is because it causes harm.  This is already covered by the fact of prosecution.

Check out  the comment by  S.cotus to Doug’s post.  He does a great job debunking Judge Cassell’s argument. 


He’s Such a Jerk That He Should Be . . . What?

There’s been a lot of attention to  my post about young attorney Daniel Hynes, who had a particularly bad hair day when he was convicted of theft by extortion in the “Live Free or Die” state.  From  Frank Pasquale to  Walter Olson to  Stephen Bainbridge all the way to the Godfather of Blawgosphere, Glenn Reynolds (who linked to Pasquale because he doesn’t bother with us little people), together with a host of other blogs known and unknown, desired and otherwise.

It’s generated an interesting reaction on the parts of non-lawyers, ranging from the anticipated rant against all lawyers to the specific angst toward this particular rascal.  But what’s curious is how many people were so adamant that this hellion needed to be punished, but could only express in the vaguest of terms what an appropriate penalty would be and why that particular penalty, as opposed to some other penalty, was appropriate.

Why does this matter?  Because it’s way to easy to rant about what a bad guy he is, and how wrong his conduct is, without offering what should be done about it and a rational basis for the punishment.  This is what lawyers have to deal with, and it’s not good enough to vent without considering what to do abut the problem.

To all those folks who want to let loose, try the next step. 

1.  Should Mr. Hynes be held accountable civilly (monetary damages), administratively (suspension or disbarment) or criminally?
2.  What should the precise penalty/punishment be?
3.  Why that penalty/punishment as opposed to any other?

36 Years In Solitary Ends

Via Turk, the  AP reports that Herman Wallace and Albert Woodfox were released from solitary confinement, where they had been since 1972, after their convictions in the death of a guard. 

The murder of a prison guard is one of the most troubling crimes to address.  As the individual is already imprisoned, it presents an impossible task.  How does one protect prison guards from violence when the imposition of the sanction of imprisonment, other than the death penalty, is by definition inconsequential.  The answer in this case was solitary confinement.

But 36 years of solitary confinement is still quite shocking.  These men were part of the “Angola Three,” former Black Panthers.  The death was a media sensation at the time, though I personally have no memory of it.  However, it’s now being argued that the panic at the time not only pushed prison officials to act precipitously, but to wrongly convict Wallace and Woodfox for the crime.  It’s not just the Wallace and Woodfox, or their lawyer saying so:

U.S. Rep. John Conyers, a Michigan Democrat and chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, visited the men recently and said he has learned of evidence proving they were wrongly convicted. 

Nick Trenticosta, Wallace’s lawyer, said he believes media scrutiny and the political attention caused  Angola prison officials to “panic and move the two men into new quarters.”  

“We will redouble our efforts to gain justice and therefore freedom for Wallace and Woodfox. Changing their cells is not enough,” Trenticosta said.

While the report fails to provide any clue as to why Conyers thinks the men may have been wrongly convicted, it raises three very distinct problems.  First, is 36 years in solitary confinement, standing alone, cruel and inhuman punishment.  Second, what if they spent 36 years in solitary confinement for a crime they didn’t commit?  And third, given that there will be many who believe that solitary confinement is a “gift” for any convict who kills a prison guard, and that the right punishment should be death, what about the possibility now, 36 years later, that they were wrongly convicted?

Sorry doesn’t cut it after a wrongful execution. 

Oprah’s Big Give Considered

If one considers game shows as a reflection of society, there is something seriously wrong with us in light of Fox’s “The Moment of Truth,” where contestants answer embarrassing and occasionally disgusting questions to win cash.  Are our lives that empty that we need to get off on the personal shame of others?  Are people that desperate for money that they are willing to tell all on TV?  Why yes, apparently.

In contrast to this abomination is Oprah Winfrey’s entry into the contest, the Big Give.  The concept is a take-off on giving forward, where one good deed is used to encourage generosity in others, who will then continue to give forward.  The game requires a group of people to give away substantial sums of money in worthy and imaginative ways in accordance with varying rules.  Each week, someone is eliminated by a panel of judges who determine who was the least worthy.

There’s nothing about this show that comports with any idea I’ve ever had about charity.  It’s totally self-aggrandizing and the rules often reduce the utility of the monies given to a silly race rather than meaningful help to those in need.  But it is a game show, and what’s a game show without rules?  And if it’s going to take up air time, there has to be some benefit attached for someone.  That it lacks the attributes of sound, charitable giving may be unfortunate, but then it wouldn’t have the tension necessary to make anyone want to watch it. 

When juxtaposed with the alternatives available, this show is perhaps the best thing television has ever done to promote positive social values.  It certainly gives rise to an appreciation of the need to help others, a theme that has been shoved aside in our consumerist, self-absorbed society.  If it causes anyone to feel that helping others reflects a way of life that is more meaningful than getting their hands on that new BMW, then it has made a significant contribution.

While I hope that the producers put some greater thought into some of the rules, such as the silliness of each contestant being asked to give away $100,000 in 24 hours with no more than $500 per individual or $10,000 at any one place, an absurd task at best, at least a portion of those funds found their way into the hands of worthy causes and needy people.  This isn’t a bad thing.

To those who feel that Oprah Winfrey has a history of buying her way into the hearts of America, consider the alternative.  Would you rather have Oprah hooked up to a polygraph and have to answer questions about her sex life?  The Big Give is a big step forward.  If the lie detector show reflects a disease, then Oprah’s effort is the first step toward a cure.

Legal Gibberish Blows The Plea

Even though it may involve hours of a lawyer’s time to make it through a court appearance, the actual face time before a judge is often a minute or two, the rest just waiting for the judge to show up, finish her coffee, make lunch reservations, etc.  But then, as the defendant approaches the table to have his moment of justice, everybody starts talking a secret code that makes absolutely no sense to anyone not in the club.

Welcome to life in the well of a New York State court.  For 20 of my 25 years there, I’ve prepared my clients for what’s going to happen each day in advance, knowing full well that they wouldn’t have a clue what was going on in real time.  Afterward, I would explain again exactly what just happened.  For all they knew, the entire proceeding was conducted in Latin, because they rarely had the slightest idea about one of the most important things in their lives.  Nice system.

But last week, the Appellate Division, First Department, decided to do something about it.  In  People v. Achaibar, via  Judicial Reports, the court reversed a plea because the defendant had no clue what was happening.


According to the transcript, Zweibel and the attorneys agreed that Achaibar’s grand larceny case would be treated as an “open D.” But there was no discussion about the meaning of that term, nor was there any indication that Achaibar was informed about the scope of possible sentencing he faced if he pleaded guilty.

It’s about time, though this is only the tip of the iceberg.  Throughout the process, from the arraignment to the not guilty verdict (or dismissal, or even the conviction), all the participants talk gibberish as far as defendants know.  We refer to section numbers rather than normal English words describing an offense.  We allude to case names that offer no hint as to the nature of the subject to the uninitiated.  Acronyms abound, so much so that even lawyers who aren’t hallway regulars in a particular court often have no clue what they refer to, but are afraid of looking foolish so never bother to ask.  Worse yet, they change from county to county, so familiarity in one place may mean nothing in another. (In Manhattan, it’s an ACD; In Nassau, it’s an ACOD.  What’s the difference?  One letter.)

Sure, it allows us to breeze through our minute in front of the judge like old pros, but what of our clients who are trying their best to understand if we just won something or lost something?  Sadly, the defendants are forgotten in this process.  Ask a defendant what happened at his last court appearance and he’ll give you this wide-eyed stare and just shrug.  This is what the courts characterize as “knowing, voluntary and intelligent” because it makes perfect sense to the lawyers.

As an aside, I noted above that my game plan changed after my first five years or so as a lawyer.  Then, I was so enamored of being on the “inside” and being able to use all the numbers and letters that cool lawyers and judges use that it didn’t occur to me that the most important person in the room had no idea what I was doing.  This became painfully evident to me one day when a judge, trying to ram a plea down my client’s throat, demanded an answer in ten seconds.  I asked my client what he wanted to do, and he started to cry.  His life was on the line, and here I was asking him to make a decision that would forever impact his and his families life and he was totally lost. 

It dawned on me then that, despite my belief that I was providing sound representation, I was failing miserably because the person to whom my duty was owed had been almost entirely ignored in the process.  This was a system created for and by lawyers, and nobody seemed to remember that there were real, living, breathing people involved.  I mended my immature ways, and I’m gratified to see that the Appellate Division is finally doing the same.  It’s a start.