Chuck Kenville’s new blog, Iowa Champion, has a story demonstrating the inherent problems with legislation designed to make registered sex offenders a permanent underclass. According to this MSNBC story,
Jennifer Lower was convicted of a misdemeanor sex offense in Ohio seven years ago. After moving to Iowa, and then moving her family to a town with no schools or day cares — which she can’t live near under Iowa law — she’s learned that she is still in violation of the law.
From the Cass County Jail, Lower, 29, said she’s frustrated. Lower is a married mother of three. She already moved her family to try to comply with Iowa’s sex-offender residency law that bans sex offenders from living within 2,000 feet of a school or day care. She said she can’t find a home that complies.
It’s not that each individual restriction doesn’t comport with some common sense notion that it’s a reasonable limitation and suited to protect children, but that the totality makes it impossible for a sex offender to find any location that complies with the law
Forced out of Atlantic, Lower and her family moved 5 miles west to Marne, Iowa. There are no schools or day cares in Marne, so Lower said she thought she and her family were safe.
Then Marne passed a new ordinance, making it illegal for sex offenders to live within 2,000 feet of a park or school bus stop. Lowers’ home was a couple blocks from the park and less than a block from a bus stop, so once again, a court ordered Lower to move.
In many areas, it would seem impossible to find a home that is not within 2,000 feet of a school bus stop. For those who really don’t care about sex offenders, we’re still stuck with a problem. They have to be somewhere. We just can’t create a system that makes it impossible for them to find a home that complies with the law.
In this specific instance, Lower refused to move again and was sentenced to 30 days in jail as a result. The point of the sentence appears ludicrous. After serving her sentence, she’s still left with no viable options to find a lawful place to reside. It makes as much sense as the judge ordering her to sprout wings and fly.
While sex offenders remain the least sympathetic of any discrete group in the criminal justice system, this situation is clearly out of control. There are far too many offense inappropriately and unnecessarily wrapped up in the sex offender classification, and legislators are busy creating increasing limitations that present an impossible situation.
It may soon come to the point where we will need an island somewhere to be populated solely with registered sex offenders, that being the only real estate in America that complies with these restrictions. Unfortunately, I imagine that a majority of Americans wouldn’t really have much of a problem with this idea.
