Author Archives: SHG

Who Bears the Cost of a Strip-Search?

Newsday reports that District Court Judge Dennis Hurley has approved a decade-old class action against Nassau County for illegally strip-searching about 23,000 people between 1996 and 1999 to proceed to the damage portion, liability having been established.  Some geniuses over at the local hoosegow decided that it would be a good idea to strip search everyone, regardless of what they did, why they were there or whether there was any reason to believe that they had contraband concealed in any particular body cavity.


For years, the county conceded that it was wrong to strip-search people who weren’t accused of felonies, and correction officers stopped in 1999, jail officials said.

A winding trail of litigation stretches back for years. In 1995, Ray Shain, a Mineola lawyer, successfully challenged the strip-searching policy after he was arrested and charged with harassing his wife in the midst of a divorce.

This has long been a known problem in Nassau County, where the Circuit, in 1999, prohibited strip-searching anyone charged with a misdemeanor or without particularized basis to believe that a strip-search was proper.  The county sheriff, who ran the jail, operated on the “better safe than sorry” theory and strip-searched everybody.

Put aside, since its already decided, whether strip-searching anyone and everyone arrested, regardless of reason, is a good idea.  It’s not.  It’s offensive and outrageous.  It is a singularly intrusive process for people who are neither legally guilty nor give cause to believe that they pose any threat whatsoever.  For anyone who thinks it’s not big deal because “those people” deserve it, I hope your proctologist is having a really bad day next time you see him.

But the cost of this outrage won’t come out of the sheriff’s pocket.  Sure, it was his brainstorm.  Sure, he’s the one who refused to relent and continued to engage in this conduct for 4 years after the issue was raised as to its existence and impropriety.  But he gets to walk away from it, and it falls to the taxpayer.

When I first learned of this absurd and offensive policy, I was outraged.  I was vehemently against it.  But then, I’m not the sheriff, so who cares what I think.  Well, that point is driven home hard when I have to pay the tab for the sheriff’s decision.  And I don’t like it one bit.

It’s not that I do not think that the class should be compensated.  I do.  Very much so.  But what pains me is that the macho and ignorant in government, the ones so full of the power and brilliance, get to make such horrendously stupid decisions and bear no consequence for it. 

Whether my taxes will be raised or my services reduced to pay the bill for the sheriff’s choices, it will happen and I will pay.  There is no other choice.  But this is the problem with the assumption that belies the belief in law enforcement that they can abuse their power and violate people’s rights.  They can do it, and I have to pay for it.  I don’t want to pay for their choices, which means that I get a say in whether it’s okay for them to choose to break the law.

Next time one of you geniuses decides to mess around with other people’s rights, pay for it yourself.

150 Years Is A Very Long Time

Good Morning America did a segment on a scientist who says he discovered, by accident, a protein that may allow people to live to 150 healthy years of age.  The protein, resveratrol, was found in red wine, though to get enough of it to make a dent would require people to drink 1000 bottles a day.  No word on when human trials to prove this aspect of the theory will get started.

But they have already developed a pill that provides the needed dose of resveratrol and have been conducting experiments with rats, and the experiments have been successful.  The impacted gene in rats is the same in humans, according to the report.

Consider the revolution that this will cause, if the plans to make this pill commercially available to humans in the next few years come to fruition.  On the one hand, people will be able to live long, healthy lives.  On the other, what do we do with them when (a) the money runs out, (b) there are no jobs available for the young, (c) we have a zillion old baby boomers hanging around forever pining politically for the olden days, (d) we get bored.

It certainly gives life in prison a whole new meaning.

Science scares me.  No, not because I don’t know how it’s done, or because I’ve watched “I am Legend” too many times.  I fear that the implications for society are never taken into account, and that these implications can have disastrous social consequences, making life far longer and far more miserable than every before.  Scientists don’t care; this isn’t their thing.  They just make the discoveries.  It’s up to the rest of us to deal with them.

The law of unintended consequences never fails to prove us underwhelming in our ability to consider and address the impact of our actions.  The “common sense” crowd wants nothing to do with the real labor of thinking, and the political crowd cares only about pacifying the masses, leaving the hard issues for someone else to deal with down the road.  While the belief is that someday, somehow, someone will find an answer to our problems that is either too hard to figure out now, or too painful to fix now, and save humanity from itself.  Why bother today when we can leave it for someone else to deal with when things get really, really bad.

But this concept has truly mind-boggling implications, if there’s any merit to it at all.  Consider the second-coming of  Thomas Malthus, or maybe  Soylent Green for the sci-fi fans amongst us.

Even if we are willing to address the social issues that would come from such a monumental change in our lives, there’s one thought that might well defy any potential solution:  Imagine being married for 120 years?  That really puts Paradise by the Dashboard Lights in a different perspective. “Meatloaf again?”



Did I mention how much I love my wife? 

Hero Lawprof Backs Practical Education

The  Washington & Lee Law School experiment into a third year practicum has drawn some heavy  negative reactions from the lawprofs.  This comes as little surprise, as these are people deeply vested in doing things the way they always have.

The criticisms have been a bit, well, facile if you ask me, particularly since I have some serious doubts that many lawprofs have a clue what most lawyers actually do for a living when they get out of law school.  (Hint: not to many will get a chance to argue before the Supreme Court in their first year).

Sam Bagenstos, in a comment to  Leitner’s post on the experiment, offered this critique:


The new Washington & Lee approach, I hate to say, is more closely directed to training students to be the best first-year associates they can be. I’m quite sure that a student who goes through that program will, to coin a phrase, be “ready on day one” for the kinds of tasks that new lawyers do on day one. But I’m far less certain that a student who goes through that program will be a better lawyer over the course of a career. I doubt that law schools have much of a comparative advantage over practitioners in the kind of on-the-job, practical training that is the focus of the new W&L third year.

So many slurs packed into such a short comment.  Who will stand up to this?  Who will challenge it?  As a lawyer, my views don’t count in the world of lawprofs (we’re just the hillbillies of the law).  Anyone?

Yes, a champion has appeared to challenge all the naysayers.  Bruce Boyden over at  Concurring Opinions has taken on his colleagues, an act of some bravery when faced with the academic establishment’s disdain for all things practical.


I believe it is crucial in legal education to go beyond simply asking students to read cases and instead require students to apply those lessons in practical settings. The understanding of an appellate decision that comes from simply reading and discussing a case is a hollow form of understanding. It is understanding without context, and pedagogical studies have shown that context is critical to forming long-term memories. The student cannot begin to incorporate cases or doctrines into their broader context until the practical significance of the holdings or rules is made clear.

But he doesn’t stop there.


Nor is it the case, as these commenters suggest, that such lessons are easily duplicated in the initial years of practice. No practicing lawyer has the time to supervise subordinates closely enough, or impart their wisdom in a direct fashion while working through an issue. Lessons in practice come haphazardly and through trial and error. It is key that the students start learning those lessons as soon as possible, and ideally in a structured environment, with detailed and knowledgeable feedback, and in a setting where mistakes are not catastrophic. If that can happen anywhere, it’s law school, not practice.

Yes!  Law school is a darn good place to learn how to be a lawyer, not just read appellate decisions and “discuss”.

Let me add my own two cents.  It’s true that most lawyers, eventually, will learn about life in the well of a court, what the various papers are, what they mean, how to put the nuts on the bolts.  We all had to do it, though the poor clients we were charged with representing in the beginning got a lot less than they deserved, because we didn’t know any better.

But the discussion of a third year of practical experience by the critics unduly trivializes the practical skills that can, and should be taught.  There’s no need for a class in how to sit on your butt in a library and cite check a memo for a Biglaw senior associate.  There is a real need for learning what lawyers actually do, how they practice, how to argue, when to shut up and when to sit down. 

My good friend  Susan Cartier Leibel has argued zealously that there’s no good reason why some kid fresh out of law school can’t hang out a shingle and open up shop.  I’ve disagreed with her, because no one comes out of law school knowing how to be a lawyer.  Look at  what happened to Daniel Hynes (okay, he may be a bad example), but lawyers know better than anyone how little law school prepares you to be a lawyer.

The only aspect of this experiment that I suspect will face some very significant problems is whether law schools will have practical lawyers in charge or leave the practicum to lawprofs.  Even though most lawprofs spent a few hours practicing law before joining the faculty, it was usually for some US Attorney, judge or Biglaw shop.  These aren’t exactly the typical things that lawyers do, and the lessons learned really don’t lend themselves to the work-a-day world where most lawyers live. 

And one last thought.  Even if this experiment fails, at least Washington & Lee tried something different with an eye toward producing real lawyers.  It’s a step in the right direction no matter what.

Vermont Supremes Raise Privacy to the Sky

The Vermont Supreme Court held that privacy can include the airspace over one’s property, according to this article to the  Rutland Herald via Bashman.  In State v. Stephen Bryant, the court held that police surveillance from a chopper of marijuana plants growing outside Bryant’s home.


The issue on this appeal from a conviction for cultivation of marijuana is whether the warrantless aerial scrutiny of defendant’s yard, for the purpose of detecting criminal activity by the occupant of the property, violated privacy rights secured by the Vermont Constitution.  We hold that Vermont citizens have a constitutional right to privacy that ascends into the airspace above their homes and property.  The warrantless aerial surveillance in this case violated that constitutionally protected privacy right. 

The court’s decision involved a very detailed parsing of the facts, including Bryant’s “almost paranoid” demands for privacy, as well as the police chopper hovering at an extremely low altitude in order to determine whether the plants were marijuana.  By so doing, the decisions fails to do much to provide a general rule.

The fact that the court extended the defendant’s privacy upward at all, however, is in stark contrast to the federal “open fields” rule, which permits the government to enter upon and search property up until the curtilage (the “area outside the physical confines of a house into which the ‘privacies of life’ may extend“).

The rationale appears to be founded primarily in the “reasonableness” test of the 4th Amendment, as applied to the “plain view” doctrine.  Had fields, planted with marijuana, been observable from an airplane or helicopter flying at a normal altitude for ordinary purposes (as opposed to surveillance in search of marijuana), then the “plain view” doctrine would have prevailed.


“It is of no moment that defendant could not effectively post his sky,” the decision read. “Technology has produced many and varied means of observation and surveillance. But the fact that something can be done does not make the doing of it constitutional.”

This sentence, apart from the rest of the decision, provides an important policy statement as science comes up with more and varied ways of undermining people’s privacy.  While most courts have drawn exceptions around technology, suggesting that since people are aware that technology has lowered the bar on intrusiveness, it’s unreasonable to think that they can maintain privacy, Vermont’s “old school” approach that privacy trumps technological innovation is a refreshing change.  Still, the decision fails to rely on this dicta, and instead resorts to a heavily fact-specific ruling.

Since the police chopper was flying so close to the ground and was there for the purpose of searching for marijuana cultivation, the scope of intrusiveness was unreasonable, and it therefore violated the warrant requirement.  Also relevant was the defendant’s clearly manifested desire to maintain the privacy of his property.  Of course,  this fact, together with the appearance of marijuana growing in the wild in a state part around the defendant’s property, gave rise to the police interest in seeing just what he was up to in the first place, making it a double edged sword.

It’s unclear that this decision will have much applicability to other cases, given its heavy reliance on the specific facts of the case, but it’s always good to hear about a court that remembers that reasonableness remains a component of search and seizure law.



Movie Review Review: Stop Loss

Ken Lammers, my favorite star of CLTV, posts about a new movie called “Stop Loss.”  Not only haven’t I seen the movie, but frankly I’ve never even heard of it until I read Ken’s rant.  This isn’t surprising, since I generally stick to movies with subtitles, like most New Yorkers.

Ken notes that Stop Loss arrived in theaters DOA, making about $1.6 million on its opening day, which isn’t enough to cover the bill for the crew’s iced green tea.  The official explanation for this huge failure is


Paramount wasn’t expecting much because no Iraq war-themed movie has yet to perform at the box office. ‘It’s not looking good,’ a studio source told me before the weekend. ‘No one wants to see Iraq war movies. No matter what we put out there in terms of great cast or trailers, people were completely turned off. It’s a function of the marketplace not being ready to address this conflict in a dramatic way because the war itself is something that’s unresolved yet. It’s a shame because it’s a good movie that’s just ahead of its time.'”

Oh baby, Ken is not buying into that spin.

AAAAAaaaarrrrgggggg!!!!! You’ve got to be kidding me!

It’s not a “function of the marketplace not being ready to address this conflict.” It’s a function of the fact that you idiots made a movie about a man who is deserting.

For context, Ken has been named “Most Erudite Lawyer in Virginia,” so when he says “AAAAAaaaarrrrgggggg”, he ain’t just whistling Dixie.



Ken’s problem with this movie is fairly straightforward. 

To those of you from Hollywood trying to push these movies: You have no credibility. Every single movie you make comes across from an anti-war point of view.

What about all the good, uplifting stories about people getting killed and maimed?  How come there’s never anything about that?   Don’t they get Fox News out there on the left coast?

Ken explains why it is that Hollywood won’t make Iraq war movies that bring joy to families “who live in the Tweens (the flyover lands between NYC and Cali.)”  Like me (just east of that hotbed of knee-jerk liberalism and land of a thousand Starbucks, Manhattan).

I just wish that Hollywood would stop making the anti-war, anti-U.S. movies. I know they won’t; I’ve heard the Jon Stewart manifesto,


The films that were made about the Iraq war, did not do as well. But I’m telling you, if we stay the course, and keep these movies in the theaters, we can turn this around. I don’t care if it takes 100 years. Withdrawing the Iraq movies would only embolden the audience. We cannot let the audience win.

and I believe that Hollywood will continue to make movies of this sort to live out their Vietnam era mindset and to tell us ignorant sots out in the hinterlands what we should think.


Naturally, I have enormous respect for Ken’s judgment on stuff like this.  After all, he is a TV star and know about the”behind the scenes” stuff that regular guys like me can only learn about when guys like Ken let the cat out of the bag.  I’m hearing you Ken.  I’m getting the message.  You don’t have to spell it out for me, brother, because I’m hearing ya.

But I do have one question.  I apologize in advance for it, because I know it’s just my dumb, naive, outsider ignorance showing, but I’ve got to ask.

Don’t we, like, have to win or accomplish something before we make a movie that’s pro-war?

They Want Grades Too?

This could only be an issue in the Ivory Tower.  Paul Secunda* at  Concurring Opinions posts about a new rule at Florida State University where professors who fail to get students’ grades in on time are “fined” or docked pay, according to how one chooses to characterize it, $10 per student.

And these are supposedly smart people. 


Many professors hate grading, and like most human beings, they often put off what they don’t like. So at many colleges, the end of a term results in some proportion of the faculty turning their grades in late, much to the dismay of the registrars whose job it is to process the grades and make them available to students. The outcome can be more than just annoying to the registrars; late grades can delay diplomas, disrupt the awarding of financial aid, or get students into academic trouble . . . .

So professors hate to grade.  They aren’t all that thrilled about teaching either.  And  they don’t like working on Mondays or Fridays, or before 10 or after 2.  Don’t even suggest that they teach when the latte machine is broken.

Puhleeaase.  This is a problem?  Imagine a world where people are offered money to perform a function and then, gasp, are actually expected to do it.  Even when they don’t feel like it! 

As I recall, sometimes students are required to turn thing in to their professors.  They are supposed to do so on time.  Sometimes, they’re told that they will drop a grade if they are late.  Apparently, this might be an empty threat since they won’t be getting a grade regardless. 

I can certainly understand why professors hate to grade.  It’s often subjective, and anything subjective requires an extra degree of effort.  How annoying that must be.  I can picture professors, sitting in their offices looking at a pile of papers, taunting them to “grade me, grade me.”  It’s enough to make their head ache.  I understand.

Grow up.  Aside from the fact that you had no interest in actually teaching when you took on the job of teacher, and thought this would be all about sitting in the faculty lounge with a snifter of brandy discussing brilliant theoretical issues like who had the predominant property right in Lord of the Rings, you still cash the paycheck. 

In all fairness, I suspect that most professors will agree with the comment by Hillel Y. Levin (from Stanford, no less).


But good lord, this is part of the job! Teaching IS the job, and part of teaching is grading. Moreover, a good part of law school is teaching professionalism; how can we expect professionalism of our students if we don’t display it ourselves?

It’s the fact that this is even a discussion that amazes me.  And all these years, I’ve been showing up in court on Friday just because some judge decided it was good for him and my clients, for some inexplicable reason, expected me to be there.  What was I thinking?

* Paul notes that his post was about whether the penalty aspect violated the FLSA, and asserts he does not grade late or drink lattes.  Starbucks has failed to confirm or deny.

When Worlds Collide: Law As Savior of Science

Rarely has the  New York Times had a more provocative title for an article than “Asking a Judge to Save the World, and Maybe a Whole Lot More.”  The article describes a suit brought in Hawaii by two men who contend that other scientists have created a machine near Geneva, Switzerland, that can destroy the world.  Totally.

The world’s physicists have spent 14 years and $8 billion building the Large Hadron Collider, in which the colliding protons will recreate energies and conditions last seen a trillionth of a second after the Big Bang. Researchers will sift the debris from these primordial recreations for clues to the nature of mass and new forces and symmetries of nature.

But Walter L. Wagner and Luis Sancho contend that scientists at the European Center for Nuclear Research, or CERN, have played down the chances that the collider could produce, among other horrors, a tiny black hole, which, they say, could eat the Earth. Or it could spit out something called a “strangelet” that would convert our planet to a shrunken dense dead lump of something called “strange matter.” Their suit also says CERN has failed to provide an environmental impact statement as required under the National Environmental Policy Act.

The Large Hadron Collider certainly doesn’t have a name that suggests doomsday, but real science tends not to be so melodramatic.  On the other hand, the name doesn’t suggest that it’s the best use one could find for $8 billion either, though in the scheme of military warplanes, it’s really not that much money.

Are Wagner and Sancho a pair of nuts who run around screaming “the sky is falling?”  Perhaps.  They previously attacked the Brookhaven National Laboratory to stop it from operating the “Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider.”  It’s been running since 2000, and we’re all still here.

But these scientists are on the cutting edge of theory, far beyond the knowledge and understanding of ordinary folks. 


The new worries are about black holes, which, according to some variants of string theory, could appear at the collider. That possibility, though a long shot, has been widely ballyhooed in many papers and popular articles in the last few years, but would they be dangerous?

According to a paper by the cosmologist Stephen Hawking in 1974, they would rapidly evaporate in a poof of radiation and elementary particles, and thus pose no threat. No one, though, has seen a black hole evaporate.

As a result, Mr. Wagner and Mr. Sancho contend in their complaint, black holes could really be stable, and a micro black hole created by the collider could grow, eventually swallowing the Earth.

So this “black hole” thing isn’t totally off the wall.  While Stephen Hawking is brilliant, are we prepared to stake the continued existence of the world on his say-so?  One mistake in the calculations, and zap.

Where does one go to challenge those on the cutting edge of science when you fear they’ve crossed the line?  Honolulu.  Putting aside the jurisdictional issue, and any other questions as to why Honolulu other than to get a decent tan while fighting for the continued existence of the world, Wagner and Sancho have gone to court to get an injunction against the Large Hadron Collider.  They will ask a judge to rule

There are a few things that courts do well.  Okay, “well” may be subject to dispute, but things that courts are better equipped to handle.  The cutting edge of science is not one of them.  We can barely deal with science when it addresses  what happens inside those black boxes that tell cops about blood alcohol content.  It’s all mumbo jumbo to lawyers, so we hand it over to some theoretically neutral science-type person who tells us if it’s any good or not.  We don’t really have a clue how any of this stuff works.  We’re just lawyers, for crying out loud.

The idea that theoretical physicists will argue the merits of whether the Large Hadron Collider is safe or will destroy the earth to a judge strikes me as ludicrous.  There is no judge on earth competent to understand the argument, no less decide it.  An hour of mumbo jumbo and the judge will be thinking of the back nine, dreaming of that perfect pitch for an eagle, while words like “quark” and “strangelet” sail over his head. 

No doubt the court will fall back on comfortable legal concepts like “burden of proof” to decide to deny the injunction.  How does one meet the standard of proof that this thing will destroy the earth?  It’s not like we have precedent. 

I’m hopeful that the plaintiffs are wrong about this.  Norm Pattis, on the other hand, thinks it might be pretty cool if the end of everything happens in a trillionth of a second as we are all sucked into a black hole.  But Norm tends to be a little more existential than me.  Though, he may have a point when compared to the variety of other ways we can self-destruct.  At least it won’t hurt.

So if the judge in Honolulu rules in favor of CERN and allows the Large Hadron Collider to do its voodoo, and he’s wrong, can the plaintiff’s recover damages?  Lawyers can be so silly at times.  Poof!

Full Disclosure:  As a wayward youth, I was employed as the “warm body” at the Tandem Van de Graaff Accelerator at Rutgers University.  From midnight until 8 am, I babysat this nuclear collider-type thing, keeping awake by playing with the controls, letting frozen hydrogen spill onto the floor and watching the freezing smoke fill the room and hitting tennis balls against the nuclear pile (it was the only free wall in the place).

Law required that someone be present to monitor the nuclear pile at all times.  So they hired a high school kid to do the graveyard shift, since no one else was stupid enough to stay up all night and watch it.  This happened in the days before we had any appreciation of the potential damage a kid like me could do to society.  Nothing melted down or exploded.  I wore a radiation badge just to make sure, which I was told would protect me in case of nuclear accident.  Think about it.

Had something gone awry, I doubt greatly I would have been much help.  But I would have felt really bad about it.

Special Supplement!  For anyone who doubts that lawyers have no business whatsoever making scientific determinations,  here’s a cartoon that makes theoretical physicists laugh out loud.  Enjoy!

Large Hadron Collider

But You Knew The Bill Would Come (Update)

Newsday offers another tale of the “unfortunate” homeowner caught in the subprime mortgage crisis.  But I can’t, for the life of me, comprehend what this person could have been thinking when she got herself embroiled in this mess.


A year ago, Smith-Correa said, she and her husband were able to move into their $235,000 three-bedroom Cape-style home with less than $3,000 down. The couple had to take on two mortgages, one with an interest rate of 13.1 percent, and another at 8.5 percent, that was slated to go up to 8.8 percent, Smith-Correa said. The mortgages the couple signed for then quickly became too expensive, she said.

Smith-Correa said her husband, who works in construction, has had difficulty finding employment, and she’s a stay-at-home mother with five children, ages 4 to 11. “The builders aren’t building, and people can’t afford to have things done on houses, anyway,” she said.

It’s not an expensive house, but they put only $3000 down, which suggests that these were not people awash in savings to begin with.  But the monthly nut, $2,400, was a known quantity.  What were they thinking?  While the husband may have made a decent living doing construction when times were good, it’s still not going to be sufficient to pay the mortgage (plus the taxes on Long Island) and feed 5 kids.  It’s not even in the ballpark.

What I cannot grasp is how someone undertakes a commitment to pay a monthly sum that they simply cannot afford?  I would sincerely appreciate someone explaining to me how such thinking works, because I cannot feel sympathy for someone who entered into a mortgage knowing that they would never be capable of living up to their part of the bargain.

Update:   Orin says “The Bush administration is finalizing details of a plan to rescue thousands of homeowners at risk of foreclosure by helping them refinance into more affordable mortgages backed by public funds.”  To those of us who conducted ourselves in a financially responsible fashion, looks like the jokes on us!  Thanks, Comrade Bush.

Practical Blawgosphere: Maintaining Civility

The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, has hosted a number of terrific discussions recently on jury nullification (if you haven’t been by his blawg over the past week, it’s must read stuff).  In the course of heated debate, one commenter called another a “nazi”. 

This is where Mark drew the line, declaring Defending People a “No-Nazi Zone.”  The practical blawgosphere being what it is, this too naturally started a debate.  Commenters were upset with Mark’s assertion of his authority as the owner of the blawg to start, stop, limit, edit, delete, amend, modify anything that shows up at Defending People. 

There a slew of curious things that happen in the practical blawgosphere.  While comments to the lawprofs’ blogs tend to be sedate, thoughtful and sometimes pretentious, the practical blawgosphere draws a very different crowd.  Some of the readers/commenters offer some great insight and information.  Others challenge and question.  Many comments tend to be simplistic, but reflect a non-lawyers’ perspective and add to our understanding of how others perceive the situation.  These are exactly what we hope for when we post and have comments.

But then there’s a dark side to all of this that readers don’t know anything about.  There are a lot of nuts out there, and the more people who read a blawg, the more bizarre the comments become.

There is a wide variety of things that come across the comments section, ranging from people who want to use a blawg for promotion, whether self-promotional, commercial or inadvertent.  There are the anonymous ten year olds who want to vent their spleen by screaming curses and railing against whatever annoys them at the moment.  There are those who want to argue, without limitation by logic or reason, and just keep insisting and insisting and insisting that whatever they think must be right.  And there are those who want to use someone else’s blawg as their personal soapbox to pontificate on a subject of interest at mind-boggling length.

For those who have a blog, the question of how to deal with these comments is a difficult one.  To a large extent, no one wants to stifle anyone else.  The conversation takes on a life of its own, and it often produces fascinating discussion.

On the other hand, there is a tone of civility, respect and thoughtfulness that we hope to maintain.  Commenters often care little about this, since it’s not their blawg and it’s not their problem.  It’s all too easy for someone to type in words that anger or frustrate others, particularly the person whose blawg it is.  While the commenter can simply disappear, the blawger is left with the mess.  This is particularly true of anonymous commenters, who are emboldened to post particularly nasty or stupid things since nothing gets traced back to them.

There’s a lot of ugliness in the practical blawgosphere, but that doesn’t mean that drive-by trolls or pundits or children get to dirty up a blawg because their fingers can type our inappropriate words.  The word “nazi” is as inflammatory as they come, and its use almost invariably gives rise to an undesirable discussion.

Mark Bennett was right to assert his authority as Blawger to decide that Defending People would be a “No-Nazi Zone,” and I applaud his taking control.  As I stated in a comment to his post, anybody who doesn’t like the house rules should go start their own blog, and post anything they want.  Over there. 

But nobody has the right to go to somebody else’s blog and be offensive, and it’s up to the blawger to determine the house rules.  If you enjoy a blawg, and the community that develops around it, then show a little respect.  If you don’t like the blog, or the rules, then you’re free to leave.  And if you want to find a blawg where you can be as vulgar, rude, offensive as you want, there are plenty of them out there.  Just not at Defending People.  Or here.

Corruption Follows When One Lawyer Is In Charge

A Newsday investigation follows up the  stories about  lawyers being carried as full time employees at several school district by finding that 23 Long Island school districts are doing the exact same thing.


In some cases, a town, village, library, special district or county also reported the attorneys as employees, often as full time, even though records show they did not always work full time. By being reported as employees at these other agencies, while also working in private practice, they were able to enhance the size of their state pensions.

Shockingly, neither Newsday, nor anyone else that I’m aware of, has as yet figured out that this is not a school district problem, but the result of a basic systemic flaw in the operation of these small local governmental units.  If one looks under the bedsheets of almost any local government, you’re going to find the same problem, although the manifestations will change from government to government because the options for abuse and corruption differ.  But the underlying problem is exactly the same.

In each of these small governmental units, there is one lawyer who becomes the official attorney for the unit.  Unlike litigators, whose every decision is challenged in court on a constant basis, these attorneys are left to espouse “The Law” to a group of elected officials who are generally either not lawyers or not lawyers knowledgeable about the relevant law. 

These official attorneys, who may or may not be competent since there is no one qualified to challenge or question them, make pronouncements upon which these local governmental units rely as if it’s the word from above.  If the attorney says it’s legal, then it’s legal.  If she says it’s not, then it’s not.  Life is that simple for these local governmental units.

This opens the door to mischief of all sorts.  First, as all lawyers are aware, the law is rarely so simple that a single lawyer can spout responses that are beyond question.  Indeed, even lawyers who are inclined to agree with one another often disagree on the details and nuances as applied to various situations.  We fight like cats and dogs, because the application of the law is never so clear cut.  Even brilliant judges have their decisions reviewed by appellate courts.  Yet these local attorneys are above reproach, and their word is absolute.

Moreover, this situation leaves local governments highly vulnerable to deception and manipulation.  The attorney exerts an inordinate amount of control over the elected body’s decision-making authority, often dictating policy through dubious pronouncements about what the law requires.  With minimal effort, he can push a governmental unit to make harmful and indeed illegal choices, which may work to his benefit or that of people he chooses to help.  It is a flagrant opportunity for abuse and corruption, and there’s no one to stop him. 

Adding fuel to this fire, local governmental units are rife with corruption already.  Not the backroom payoff type of corruption, but more the “honest graft” type and the “rules don’t apply to us” type.  Petty tyrants who would be challenged by a 3rd grade civics test believe that the laws are something to pretend to follow, and that politics is a game to be played through schemes, lies and self-dealing.  Who’s going to stop them?  The only person positioned to know better is the official lawyer, and his livelihood depends on getting along with the local elected officials.

This is a dangerous and volatile situation, doomed to failure.  But it is not incurable, once the problem is recognized.

I propose that the position of a Statewide Inspector General be created to oversee the functioning of these local governmental units that rely on the counsel of a single lawyer.  The IG can maintain constant oversight and random audits of these units to ascertain whether the attorneys are deceiving, manipulating or otherwise engaging in corrupt practices.  Further, someone needs to protect the taxpayer from mere incompetence, particularly when some elected official has installed his “pal” as the lawyer.

Putting a single lawyer, subject to no oversight whatsoever, in the position of dictating the law to local governmental units is a recipe for corruption.  It’s been shown in Long Island’s school districts, and if anyone scratches the surface in almost any of Long Island’s (or any other locality where this happens) hundreds of villages, sanitation districts, water districts, police districts, library districts, whatever, you will find massive systemic problems. 

It’s time to take a giant step backward, so we can see the forest instead of just staring at the individual tree.  It’s time to fix this problem.