Author Archives: SHG

Just Paint A Target On His Head Already

After  posting about the impact of reducing anyone convicted of a crime to the status of permanent underclass,  New York Lawyer comes along with this story from Hudson, Kansas upping the ante.

Leroy Schad, 72, was convicted in March 2007 of aggravated indecent solicitation of a child. As part of his sentence, District Judge Ron Svaty ordered Schad to post the signs on his house and on his vehicle during his five years of probation and house arrest.

Hand-painted wooden signs reading “A Sex Offender Lives Here” are posted on all four sides of the his white house in this small central Kansas town of about 150 people. On his vehicle is a large decal with bold yellow lettering reading “Sex Offender In This Car.”

Fans of the Scarlet Letter are no doubt applauding this stroke of brilliance already.


Schad was originally charged with four counts of taking indecent liberties with a 9-year-old girl and an 11-year-old boy on March 24 and 25, 2005. As part of a plea agreement, the charges were dismissed and he pleaded guilty to the lesser count of solicitation.

With no prior convictions, Kansas sentencing guidelines for the offense range from probation to about three years in prison. Schad’s underlying sentence, if he violates probation, is 3 1/2 years.

While I don’t know exactly what “taking indecent liberties” means, I’m sure I wouldn’t like it.  In fact, I’m sure it would repulse me and anger me.  I hope that the kids are okay, and this won’t traumatize them for life, though my guess is that it will.

But as much as I am disgusted with offense such as this, the punishment of being publicly shamed by signs is another matter.


The loneliness and isolation imposed by the house arrest are the toughest to deal with, he said, adding that the signs on his car have sparked threatening gestures from other drivers that sometimes concern him.

You think?  So what was the empirical basis for the imposition of this shaming punishment?  What allowed the court to reject the punishments developed by law and impose conditions of his own making?


“I’m sure there is nothing specifically that says a court may sentence in this manner, but I think that the court has latitude in terms of the conditions it sets,” said Helen Pedigo, executive director of the Kansas Sentencing Commission. “I think the court has the ability to kind of be creative in what they consider restitution to the community.”

Restitution to the community?  I don’t think so.  This is tantamount to psychological torture.  Restitution to the community might well be served by 1000 hours of community service (that’s 25 weeks of full time community service for those of you without a calculator handy).  Not enough?  Give him more, but each judge in his imaginative little fiefdom should not be free to impose his personal vision of retributive justice outside the parameters of the law. 

What’s next, cutting off the hand that offends?

Legislators Caught In Partisanship Grinder

While the details change from place to place, I suspect that the general idea reflects the harsh reality of local legislators everywhere.  In Nassau Count, New York, the government is run by an executive and a county legislature, created in 1996 to replace the unconstitutional Board of Supervisors that disenfranchised anyone who wasn’t tithing the Republican Party.

Nassau County, you see, was the last fully functioning party machine in New York, perhaps the country.  The Republican’s ran this patronage mill with an iron fist.  When they were forced to change the structure of county government, a provision was included for legislators’ salaries, that any raise would not go into effect until after the next election of a new legislature, thus giving the voters the opportunity to vote the salary-raising scoundrels out of office if they weren’t thrilled with their avarice.

In 1996, they set the salary of a legislator at $39,500, the theory being that these were part-time jobs and this was enough.  Of course, the Republican machine couldn’t have cared less, since they all held multiple high-paying county jobs, as did their wives, children, cousins, etc.  It was good old honest graft, in the Plunkitt sense.

Then one day, when the cash flow began to ebb, a funny thing happened.  The machine ground to a halt, and a Democrat named Suozzi took over.  On his coattails road a majority of the legislature and a variety of other offices.  After two elections, the Dems had the county sown up.  The disgraced Republican leader, the one who lost their last machine, was punished by being forced into the position of New York State Republican leader.  In New York, that’s purgatory.

But being a legislator is a lousy job today.  Not only do you have to raise money to run again every couple of years, but it’s a full time endeavor, including nights and weekends.  Begging for a few hundred thou to run for an office that pays $39,500 is ugly.  And you don’t really have any power anyway.

So, according to this Newsday story, the Legislators have had enough of waiting for a decent party invitation to get a good meal.  They want a raise.  But in a county where partisan politics are as bitter as Nassau, nothing gets done without somebody trying to use it to nail someone else to the wall.


Seeking to prevent raises from being used against incumbents, Minority Leader Peter Schmitt (R-Massapequa), in the past has demanded that all 10 Democrats vote for a pay hike before his nine Republicans will support it.

Unlike the Republicans, however, trying to keep the Democrats in line is like herding cats.  The problem now is that pesky reform condition in the county charter that prevents a pay raise from taking effect until after the next election.  This makes the pay raise a political football, and ties these folks in knots of fear about how their vote will be used against them. 


Former Presiding Officer Judy Jacobs (D-Woodbury), who supports a pay raise, said changing the charter simply gives lawmakers the mechanism for increasing their salaries sometime in the future; it doesn’t actually raise their salaries.

Legis. David Denenberg (D-Merrick) said he hadn’t seen the proposal and was hesitant to comment on it. “I’m not really sure how they’re trying to do it,” said Denenberg, who has opposed past pay hike proposals. “I would be against a back-door increase.”

Notice how carefully they frame their positions, ensuring plausible deniability (at the risk of abject silliness)?  But then comes ambition to screw up the plan.


But Legis. David Mejias (D-Farmingdale), another past opponent of pay hikes who is widely predicted to challenge State Sen. Kemp Hannon (R-Garden City) this fall, said he won’t vote for a charter change.

“It’s inappropriate for a politician to change the rules to give themselves a raise at a time when people can’t afford to pay their property taxes or health care costs.” Mejias said.

David Mejias has great ambition.  His plan isn’t to get a pay raise as legislator, but to get a new job with better pay (not to mention member money) in the State Senate. 

Nassau County has some of the highest property taxes in the nation, but not because of the county portion.  The absurdly high school taxes (consider this, the Oyster Bay School District rakes in $28,000 per student in taxes!) can make billionaires cry.  But that doesn’t mean that a climber like Mejias won’t capitalize on capital to prove his tax-busting bona fides.  Of course, tripling the salaries of 19 legislators to pay them for their full-time job won’t make a dent in the budget, though the message is always bad when times are tough.

Frankly, the message might be better if they did their job, got paid for it, and sent a message that they aren’t living in a political and economic fairyland.  But that’s not politics today, not even on this little local level with these little local politicos. 

Just Don’t Annoy the Stewardess

from the  Legal Satyricon of Marc Randazzoa, via Nobody’s Business, comes this marketing video of the EMD bracelet, a different concept in airline security.  Marc notes that “This is not a parody,” and I didn’t take it as such.

Oddly, and no doubt to the chagrin of many, I can see the merit in the concept.  But  can we ever trust in-flight personnel with the ability to zap us at will? 

It’s bad enough that police, trained (theoretically) to handle emergency situations, to use restraint, to use weapons and to distinguish when force is appropriate (really theoretically), love the taser too much.  So do we put an equivalent weapon in the hands of flight attendants who just might be annoyed when you ask for that extra pillow or complain about the person in the next seat spilling over into yours?

Does it ever seem like there are plenty of good answers to problems, if only they didn’t involve people? 



Plus, if you get some slimy, sweaty one, it would be really gross.

Beware The Permanent Underclass

A question was posed by W.W. Woodward in  a comment to this post, questioning the impact of the upcoming Heller decision on the rights of “felons”, that merits further discussion.

When does a felon become an ex-felon? Is even a low grade nonviolent felony conviction a life sentence? And, if it is, should it be? Do individuals who, at some time in their lives, have been convicted of a felony not have the right to defend themselves, their homes, and their families?

This question is coming from someone who has been a part of the criminal justice system as a police officer, county sheriff, and correctional officer since 1971.

Mr. Woodward is old enough to remember when we used to say that a person who completed his sentence had “paid his debt to society.”  How quaint that sounds today, like some line by Atticus Finch to Scout.  When is tha last time (other than here) that you heard someone use this archaic phrase?

The problems with reintegration of former prisoners into society have been discussed, but that’s only one facet of the problem.  Whenever a story about a crime is reported, the alleged perp is always described by his or her prior record.  We applaud the loss of a wide variety of common rights and privileges to ex-cons.  We do everything in our power to make certain that it is difficult, if not impossible, for “felons” to never find a good job, a decent home, a new life as a law-abiding citizen.  Once a felon, always a felon.

This has got to stop, for the cost it imposes on society is huge and dangerous.  In our zeal to punish, and then punish some more, we are creating a permanent underclass of people who may never be able to rise above the felon status.

We are constantly inventing new crimes, and elevating old ones from misdemeanors to felonies, in the perpetual “war on crime.”  Our “war on drugs” has done monumental damage to many ordinary people, many poor people, who are caught up in cultural mistakes.  No, not all of them, but many.  We paint them all with the same brush, however, so that the mule who needs to feed her children is treated like the drug kingpin.  The dopey suburban kid who dabbles to have a good time takes the road to perdition instead of Harvard.  And that’s it, their future potential is nil.

Without the hope of having a future with the ability to achieve a modicum of success toward the American dream, we leave this ever-increasing group of human beings without hope.  We put a never-ending series of stumbling blocks in their, way, refusing to allow them to move forward.  They have no vested interest in society because society offers them nothing for their future.  You want to stop recidivism?  Give them a decent job, a decent education, a real future.  Give them a reason to be a contributing member of society.  Shut them out and what do they have left?

Then turn to one of the most dangerous of all notions to find widespread acceptance in America, Jessica’s Law.  At present, 42 states have passed some version of a law to require the registration of sex offenders, and limit where they can live, work and breath.  To answer Mr. Woodward’s question, anyone who is subject to Jessica’s Law is given a life sentence.  They will forever be a pariah.  They can never leave it behind them.  Even when the laws allow for removal from the registry after a long period of time, their lives will be molded by the miserable circumstances and stigma of being a registered sex offender forever.

As regular readers know, I’m no defender of people who sexually attack children.  But the simplistic discussion of sex offenders and their registration too often stops with the worst of the worst, ignoring the ridiculously overbroad inclusion of people who are hardly sex offenders as we think of them.  Of the 18 year old convicted of statutory rape of his 16 year old girlfriend, who he later marries.  He may receive probation, but little did he realize that this meant the lose of any future at a decent job.

Just as opening our asylums a generation ago created an unanticipated underclass of mentally ill homeless, we’ve now driven sex offenders into the streets as no one will house them and no one will accept them living near them.  I can understand the NIMBY fears, but I also understand that this exacerbates a bad situation.  For those designated “sex offender” who don’t deserve it, we have ruined their lives.  For those who fall within the intended group, we are no safer with them roaming the street than living in a home and holding down a job.  To the extent that we hope to stop recidivism, we eliminate the deterrent affect by precluding them from becoming vested in a law-abiding society.  What have we accomplished?

This is all about manufactured fear of crime.  Yes, specific instances can be horrible, but crime has been  dropping significantly while the heated rhetoric goes on unabated.  If we continue down this path, creating a permanent underclass with no vested interest in law-abiding society, we will create crime for us and misery for them.  With nowhere else to turn, what should we expect?

Is Felony Mediation The Cure?

From Court-O-Rama, finally a good sentencing idea out of Kentucky (who’da thunk?).  From a story on KYPost (no connection to the Jelly), Anne Skove posts about the use of mediation as a tool to keep people out of prison through the use of judges as mediators in felony prosecutions.

Senior judges trained in mediation techniques are mediating felony cases. Case types include burglary, drug trafficking, theft, assault, fleeing and evading law enforcement, and manufacturing meth. Both sides agree to participate; participation is voluntary.

Charges may be dismissed, guilty pleas may ensue. Defendants might pay restitution or participate in drug court. The judge in each case may accept or reject the agreement reached by the defendant and prosecutor. Any way you slice it, it means fewer cases in court and fewer defendants in jail.

Mediation, a tool that has long been used successfully in civil cases, doesn’t seem to lend itself to the resolution of criminal matters easily, yet was lauded as being hugely successful:

“The defendants loved it. People actually listened to them. They said that people would listen to them in court too, but it would be a jury that might sentence them to 50 years,” he said. “The Commonwealth loved it too. We very seldom leave court with people who are happy, but we did. It was phenomenal.”

While I haven’t always  been kind to Kentucky, particularly given some of the  bone-headed things they come up with there, this idea strikes me as remarkably good and timely.  Perhaps not appropriate for certain types of crimes, there are still a broad swathe of cases that would find their way onto the felony dockets and, to a very large extent, wind up filling more and more prison cells, this offers a real alternative to incarceration.


We have a process that works and we have mediators available,” said Paisley, who worked with Judge Wehr to coordinate the mediations in Clay and Boyd counties. “Now it’s just a matter of identifying the next areas to use this program, which likely will be jurisdictions with heavy caseloads and an overcrowded jail nearby. Overcrowded jails pass on significant costs to the counties and this is one tool to help reduce those costs.”

At a time when government, and to some lesser extent people, are recognizing the extreme cost of decades of lock-em-up politics and the lack of substantive benefit to sating the bloodlust for ever-increasingly long sentences, taking chances with new concepts that offer the potential to have a positive impact all around is critical.  Frankly, I think this idea sounds brilliant.

Kentucky deserves enormous credit for this new application of mediation.  I wonder if  Ken Lammers knows about this?

“Neither Force Nor Will, But Merely Judgment”

George Will, the last living dinosaur of thoughtful conservatism, invoked Alexander Hamilton’s description of the judiciary in Federalist 78 in his Washington Post column. 


We have Alexander Hamilton‘s assurances, from Federalist 78, that the judiciary is “the least dangerous” branch of government. Having “neither force nor will, but merely judgment,” it “has no influence over either the sword or the purse; no direction either of the strength or of the wealth of the society; and can take no active resolution whatever.”

Will proceeds to argue that Hamilton was wrong, as evidenced by the impact that the federal judiciary has on essentially every social controversy faced by our society today, and calls Hamilton’s description “anachronistic”. 
His purpose is to echo Chief Justice Roberts’ State of Judiciary speech calling for an increase in judicial salaries, a ball that was dropped somewhere in the capital rotunda between the House and Senate where it never found its way out of committee.

But the fact that society turns to the federal judiciary to do its dirty work doesn’t make the Supremes more powerful than Hamilton imagined.  And the fact that federal judges are paid almost as much as a first year associate at Biglaw proves just the opposite.

The judiciary is, in the sense that Will discussed, society’s whipping boy when it comes to social issues.  Congress can pass laws that are flagrantly unconstitutional but immensely popular as they appeal to the “common sense” notions of the masses or the somewhat secret bias of the voters, knowing that there is a federal judiciary behind it to make the hard calls.  The courts make the unpopular decisions so that politicians can claim the glory without having to play the school marm, saying, “No, you can’t do that.”  The courts are the government’s janitors, cleaning up the mess that politicians leave behind.

The fact that the Chief Judge of the United States Supreme Court can’t manage to wangle a decent pay raise for his people proves Hamilton’s point.  The judiciary have no power to affect affirmative change, not even for themselves.  Just as the Chief Judge of New York has been embarrassingly ineffective, so to is Chief Judge Roberts.  For all the power attributed to the courts, their inability to impact their own livelihood is manifest.  The courts are entirely dependent on gifts from politicians.

George Will repeats the reasoning behind the need for substantial increase in judicial pay, but he need not have bothered.  No one questions it.  No one argues that judges are overpaid.  No one doubts that judicial pay is embarrassingly low.  That’s not the problem at all.  The problem is that the judiciary is powerless to do anything about it, and the politicians gain nothing by increasing their pay. 

“It’s the right thing to do,” is the rallying cry.  But this only matters to people who care about doing the right thing.  Sure, plenty espouse that their motives are good and pure, but either not enough people join them, there are too many “right things” on the table to capture enough attention or they don’t mean what they say.  For the most part, the judiciary does care about doing the right thing, and argues to the government in the way that would be meaningful if argued to a judge.  Clearly, this hasn’t worked. 

One would hope that the “more dangerous” branches of government would not rub the judiciary’s nose in its impotence.  For those platitude loving stump speechifiers, this would seem to require no thought at all.  But it is clearly too unimportant, or too lacking in political benefit, to be worth their time.  It’s not the cost factor in a down economy, nor the fear of popular uprising that drives politicians away from increasing salaries.  If anything, the voters don’t care enough one way or the other.  This just isn’t an issue that “resonates” with voters.  It’s housekeeping.

Whether the lack of a decent salary is stripping the judiciary of qualified and competent judges is a separate issue, in my mind.  But the indisputable fact that the other branches of government can control or ignore the judiciary through the power of the purse reveals a glaring gap in a tripartite concept of government.  It proves Hamilton prescient.  The judicial branch of government is indeed the least dangerous.  In fact, it poses no threat at all. 

Dirty Words Aren’t As Bad As Censorship

The  New York Times has an editorial today about the FCC’s policy to free the world of “fleeting expletives” going before the Supreme Court, and urging the Court to shut down the FCC idyllic vision of the airwaves.

While some (like my potty-mouthed Satyr-wannabe friend Randazza) 1st Amendment proponents wrap themselves in expletives, for the shock value if not to inure others to the idea that they are just words, not bullets or knives or other things that cause physically pierce your heart, I tend to avoid them.  Not because I’m some Puritan throwback, but because I find them to be jarring and send folks off-course from whatever it is I’m trying to say.  I also think we do best to communicate with more specific language.  But that’s me.

I have no problem with cursing otherwise, and I’ve taught my children (Randazzo would be so proud of me) that curses are just words like any other that people use to express themselves, but that if you can accomplish the same expression with words that are more socially acceptable, it will serve them better and avoid needless controversy.  My kids have never felt a great need to curse.

It bothers me that there is so much cursing on television.  Much of it seems pointless, unnecessary to the dialogue and inserted for shock value.  It’s gratuitous stuff during the family hour, and I would prefer if it wasn’t there.  I wish that the folks who produced these shows would try to avoid it unless it serves some particular purpose,  I wish they would show some restraint and maturity; just because they can doesn’t mean the should.

But there are times when expletives are consequential, a necessary and natural part of the story.  That historical shows and figures are censored to eliminate reality is shocking.  The fear that moves such as the FCCs $550 million penalty for Janet Jackson’s wardrobe malfunction (I blinked and missed it) has caused producers to rewrite history to sanitize it to avoid the ire of the FCC.   

There are also times when they just happen, because real people saying unscripted things sometimes curse. 


The commission suddenly changed course in a case involving the 2003 Golden Globes Awards show, which included the singer Bono’s uttering a single expletive as he accepted an award. Reversing its long-held precedents, the F.C.C. decided that Bono’s lighthearted slip made the broadcast indecent.

I don’t necessarily like it when it happens, but it does not bring my world crashing down.  I don’t become outraged.  I don’t write my Congressman.  I don’t call the FCC.  It’s a word, for God’s sake.  Just a word.

Didn’t we get past all this a long time ago?  Hadn’t we reached a point where we were going to move beyond Leave it to Beaver?  Sure we all know that those shows didn’t display life as we (or anyone else) knew it, and that it created a fictional world that would offend no one, anywhere, ever.  We were ready for a world a little more real.  We were tough.  We could take it, without our heads blowing off.

When some comments made by Cher and Nicole Richie on a Billboard Music Awards show (I have no clue what was said, as I somehow missed the broadcast) were just too much for important decision-makers at the FCC, they went into action, announcing their new rule that “fleeting expletives” would not be met with summary execution, or a fine, or both. 


Broadcasters challenged the commission’s new rules, and last June the New York-based United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit struck them down. Federal agencies like the F.C.C., which interpret Congressional laws, have to make reasoned decisions, and the court ruled that the fleeting expletive policy was not properly reasoned. It carefully dissected the F.C.C.’s analysis, which it rightly found to be “divorced from reality.” The court also noted that the commission’s rules most likely violated the First Amendment.

When the Second Circuit says these guys are “divorced from reality,” they should have realized that they were way out of line.  

What pushed the FCC to try to turn back the clock 50 years?  Perhaps it was the reaction to the occasional excess, or as will invariably happen, the fleeting expletive.  Did Hollywood push the envelope needlessly at times.  I think it did, but the solution is in what we watch and what we want from entertainment.  Not some man in a black suit pushing the censor button to protect out delicate ears.


The stakes in this case are much higher than whether awards shows can air a few bad words. The F.C.C. has used its new policy to turn itself into a roving censorship board. Among other outrageous decisions, it hit KCSM, a small public-television station in San Mateo, Calif., with a $15,000 fine for broadcasting “The Blues,” a PBS documentary about the musical form that, given the subject matter, understandably contains fleeting expletives.

Not only do I hope that the Supremes do as the Times urges, but can we put this to rest once and for all.  Both Ozzie and Harriet are gone.  It’s time for big daddy at the FCC to give up telling us what’s indecent.  We really need to move beyond this.  Does everyone realize this except the FCC?  Is there some special place where they hire people for the FCC to come up with stuff like this?  Perhaps Pleasantville?

More Neighbors in the Practical Blawgosphere

A few new folks have joined the practical blawgosphere lately, and the good news is that they’re not all from Texas. 

First, Anne Skove at Court-O-Rama, “the least dangerous blog,” has an incredible gift for understatement.  She light, she’s funny and yet she makes her point.  While she may call her blog “the least dangerous,” my bet is you don’t want to be on the receiving end of her skewer.  Anne has already made the blogroll, because she really is terrific.

Next is Grey-At-Law, a “later in life” law school grad who’s awaiting word from the Michigan bar.  His interest is primarily criminal law, and he’s well on the way in his blog. Even though he’s yet to receive his ticket, he’s got some interesting stuff posted and hopefully Grey will put his nose to the grindstone and start churning out regular content.

And finally, we have Charles Kenville’s Iowa Champion.  This blawg is brand new, but Chuck has hit the ground running and looks like he’s in it for the long haul.  I look forward to Chuck’s hitting his stride, expressing his views and making Iowa safe for the Constitution.

For anyone reading, thinking, “Hey, I could do a blog too.” come on and give it a go.  There’s still plenty of room in the neighborhood. 

Settlement Demands Have Their Risks

Daniel Hynes was a newly minted lawyer, only one month in, when he apparently came up with a bright idea, according to this report in the New York Lawyer.

Fifteen months ago, Daniel Hynes of Manchester told a Concord hair salon to pay him $1,000 or face a lawsuit because its different prices for men and women were discriminatory. In one court document, he said the unequal prices at Claudia Lambert’s salon caused him mental anguish. That’s even though the salon charged women more than men.

Well, how is a young lawyer supposed to make a living when he’s got no clients and needs a haircut?

Unfortunately, a jury was unimpressed by Hynes’ career move, and convicted him of misdemeanor theft by extortion. 

Hynes, apparently relying on his vast legal experience, disagreed with the jury.


“The conviction goes against the First Amendment,” he said. “People have a right to petition the courts.”

It’s unclear which 1st Amendment rights he’s talking about, since sending out demand letters is a little different than petitioning a court for redress.  

But he does have a point about lawyers sending out letters to people or businesses who, they believe, are doing something actionable and trying to settle.

Where do we draw the line?  People often feel the “lawyer letter,” that demand that you pay money “or else” or stop doing something “or else,” is extortionate.  After all, the express threat is “pay me or pay to go to court and then pay me.”  There’s certainly something extortionate there.

The question deepens when it’s no longer a matter of threatening to take someone to court if they don’t settle a claim, but when it reaches the point of becoming a crime.  Does it turn on the lawyer’s good faith?  Does it turn on whether the claim has a reasonable basis in law? 

Bear in mind that there are claims brought to lawyers that ultimately turn out to be frivolous or baseless, but lawyers pursue them because they seem colorable at the time.  There’s a huge difference between the claim being shot out of the water for being frivolous and the lawyer being convicted of a crime for pursuing it.

Mr. Hynes was a busy fellow.


Assistant Attorney General Elizabeth Baker said Hynes sent letters to at least 19 salons in the state. The one to Claudia’s said haircut prices should be based on the time required or the length of the customer’s hair, not gender.

My guess is that 19 letters is probably over the line.  But a conviction for extortion?  That’s a bit much too.

Addendum:  For anyone inclined to comment, please  read this first and leave your comments.

No Role for Religion. None. (Update)

Hours have been spent trying to play a part in the  blogswarm for Blog Against Theocracy, 2008, but I remain unable to write something that expresses my thoughts adequately.  Other bloggers have had no problem, and  some have even produced multiple posts.  I have been paralyzed, and can’t seem to come up with a single post that I want to publish.

So I leave it at this.  Religion has no place in government whatsoever.  Believe as you will and exercise your religion to whatever extent fulfills you.  Just keep it out of government.  God doesn’t need it.  Government doesn’t need it.  No one needs it.  Religion is personal.  Keep it that way.

If you disagree, there’s nothing I can say that will change your mind.  But it’s my government too.

Update:  Does anyone believe  that this is what makes God happy?  If it would, would he be worthy of your devotion?



H/T Turley