Author Archives: SHG

A Moron Plays 5000 Questions

Strange stuff happens in the blawgosphere.  Not only are there comments on the blawg, but there are often emails that come along about posts or things people would like me to write about.  Sometimes they are quite thoughtful and helpful.  Other times, they are demanding, as though I have a duty to “check out” someone’s product or argue with anyone who wants to put up a fight.  But none have been as strange as this one.

Two days ago, I received an email from a fellow who called himself Jeff Norman and informed me he was a writer for the Huffington Post.  Was he?  I assume so, but wouldn’t know if it was true.  He asked a bunch of questions about my post on Eliot Spitzer, directed toward how I “know” what Spitzer had done.

Ordinarily, this would be the sort of thing I would ignore.  The easy answer is read my post and, if you disagree, then comment that you disagree. Plenty of people do, and they aren’t shy about telling me that I’m wrong, boring, unimpressive, whatever.  Around my house, this is a parlor game.

But because he was part of the blogosphere (not my neighborhood, mind you, but where big boys play), I decided to respond.  Kind of a blogosphere courtesy thing. What was I thinking?

I was thinking that he was looking for someone to help him to understand the nature of what was happening.  His email included a link to his bio, which said that he was a comedian turned political commentator.  Since he wasn’t a lawyer, perhaps he was looking for a lawyer to provide detail with which he was unfamiliar.

Here I am, trying to be a nice guy.  It was my intention to try to give this fellow Jeff some help.  It was a good intention, but as wel all know, the road to hell is paved with good intentions.  Little did I know that I was already well on my way.

Then the emails kept coming.  More questions.  Questions by the truckload.  Some clear, others vague, some aggressive, some challenging, some simplistic and other sophisticated, but there was email after email, question after question.  This kept up for two days,  A non-stop barage of emails, each with strings of questions.

In my response to his second email, I asked him if he was “taking a survey.”  It seemed reasonable to know why he was asking these questions, since answering them was a drain on my time, a commodity that is either given freely here or sold to my clients in my practice.  Jeff responded:


I’m particularly interested in the opinions of lawyers, but I’m not taking a survey.  I might write something about this for HuffPo, but mostly I’m just sharing my perspective and trying to understand yours.

So I assumed that my original thinking, that this comedian cum pundit lacked the legal background to understand the legal ramifications and implications of what Spitzer was going through.  Sheesh, another guy who wants to be taught the law by email.  But I’d be a nice guy and let it go awhile.

I tried.  I really did try, to help this fellow out.  But he kept coming back with more.  I thought to myself, this can’t go on forever.  I mean the guy’s got to eat, sleep, go to the bathroom, right?  Plus, as thrilling as I am, even I grow weary of me after a while.  But no, they just kept coming.

I tried to wean Jeff off this exchange slowly at first, telling him that answers to his questions could be found in the papers, the complaint, the warrant affidavit, other papers available through Pacer.  I told him that if he wanted to get into that level of factual depth, he had to go to the source material. 

Jeff had no interest in doing the legwork.  Aside from saying he had no Pacer account (though you would think somebody at HuffPo would), he wanted me to cite it all for him.  I should prove it to him.  He wrote me that he thought there was no evidence at all (based upon his failure to look) and since I thought otherwise, I had to prove it to him. 

This was where I decided to get off the bus.  By this point, hours had been spent on this person and it was going in circles.  He didn’t want to look, but wanted to argue with me on the premise that what he doesn’t know must be proven to him.  And I’m thinking, he’s getting a little too nutty for me, as if I owe him some duty to satisfy his curiosity.  No thank you for your time.  No thank you for your effort.  Just more questions and more demands.  So I respond to Jeff’s demands:


I really can’t.  If you want to satisfy your curiosity, you’re going to have to do some leg work.  This is what I do for a living, and I’ve really gone WAAAAY over the edge trying to help you, but it’s gotten out of control and still you want more.  I’m sorry, but this is about as far as I can go.

Then came the smack. (The first sentence refers to my question as to why anyone would quit comedy to talk about law/politics). 


And now the humor you crave has finally emerged.  Your “analysis” has been exposed as baseless, and instead of admitting it, you claim to be out of time.  Now THAT is funny, because as our email exchange plainly reveals, you’ve been ducking my fair and pertinent question about structuring from the outset, so you should take responsibility for your evasiveness, rather than accuse me of imposing on you excessively.

Holy smokes.  I’ve just spent hours trying to help this guy, and he’s playing a secret game of “gotcha”.  I’m thinking all along that this fellow is, well, fairly dense, not realizing that he wasn’t trying to learn about the applicable law or the significance of aspects like Spitzer’s non-denial.  Nope, he was trying to cross-examine me to prove that I was running on empty.  He could have just asked that in the first place and saved me hours of time that I’ll never get back.  Comedians may have all day to come up with jokes, Jeff, but lawyers sell time.

There was nothing unusual about Jeff’s self-image of brilliance, a pretty common thing amongst questioners who view their right to demand answers as perfectly reasonable and their demands of my time as being a duty I owe to anyone with access to email.  What I couldn’t understand was how little there must be going on in this guy’s life that he would spend this much time pestering me.  I could understand him wanting to learn, even though he couldn’t be bothered to make any effort beyond emailing me, but this guy was like a stalker.  No normal person gives up that much time from his life.

They say that no good deed goes unpunished.  I believe.  So who is the moron who played 5000 questions?  That would be me.  Please don’t expect me to play it again.

Post Script:  When Jeff persisted that I concede that he was right (to what end is unclear, but that’s not the point), I told him that he could read about it here.  He wrote back: “ I can’t wait!  I’m as giddy as a schoolgirl on prom night!”  Rarely do I make anyone that excited.  I bet I haven’t heard the end of Jeff, but too much time has already been spent on this, and so I move on.  No doubt this will “prove” something to Jeff, and I leave it to him (and you) to decide what that something might be.

When The Jester is a Clown

It looks like the  Royal Order of Jesters have some pretty low standards for admission, according to the Buffalo News.


A retired Lockport police captain pleaded guilty Thursday to transporting women over state lines on two occasions to work as prostitutes at gatherings of a fraternal club.

Well, “pleaded guilty” does tell the full story of John Trowbridge, age 60 but still full of mirth and merriment, not to mention a very healthy dose of “take care of numero uno.”  Protestations aside, it appears that the retention of women by the hour is not a new thing to the Jesters.


In court papers filed by the U.S. attorney’s office, Trowbridge admitted that he and other men took the prostitutes to an event in Kentucky in October 2005 and another event in Pennsylvania in the fall of 2006.

Call them “good men” all you want, but I guess it has a lot to do with your definition.

Back to former Police Captain Trowbridge, who enjoyed the brotherhood of fellow Jesters, but only so far.


“He is proactively cooperating in the federal investigation,” said Trow-bridge’s attorney, David C. Douglas. “As a former police officer, he sees cooperating as the proper thing to do in this case.”

This has got to be one of the funniest quotes I’ve ever seen coming from a lawyer.  So are you saying that turning into a snitch is “the proper thing” for a former police captain, but obeying the law was beyond the pale?

This is one of those problems that crop up when a defense attorney starts chatting up the media, but has nothing good to say.


Why would a retired career lawman risk going to jail to cavort with prostitutes?

“I can’t give you an explanation that is rational or logical, any more than our [former] governor could give you an explanation,” Douglas said, referring to Eliot L. Spitzer, who resigned amid a sex scandal last week. “This is a case of individuals making bad decisions.”

Ah, the Spitzer defense.  That’s work very well for him either.

And what do the Jesters have to say about all this?


A national spokesman for the Jesters, Alex Rogers, said the club is dedicated to spreading “mirth and merriment” but does not condone hiring prostitutes for club events.  According to Douglas, the Jesters events Trowbridge attended in Kentucky and Pennsylvania “included mostly legitimate activities, including golf.”

Well, you know men.  They just want to get them little balls in the hole.  I can’t believe I just wrote that. Forgive me.

Given that the Masons and Shriners to great work, I second  Kathleen’s motion that they take charge of their offspring and clean it up.  If they decide to ignore it, then whatever flying crap that hits them is well-deserved.

Great Stuff Elsewhere

Some days, there’s just too much good stuff out there for one blawg to handle.  And since it’s already been handled so well elsewhere, the best I can do is make sure that you know its out there and point anyone who hasn’t already seen it to the following great stories/posts.

Crime & Federalism :  Mike has this outrageous post via  cnet about how the FBI has come up with a whole new way to snare the unsuspecting for kiddie porn, fake hyperlinks!  Unbelievable, not to mention deeply flawed.  Also, Mark Draughn at  Windypundit and  Orin Kerr have posted about this as well.  Yes, it’s mind-boggling and worth a post, but how many posts can there be that say the same thing?

Underdog :  Jon Katz breaks my heart with this post about how Joe Ligotti, the guy from Boston, turns out to be an actor, not the xenophobic but hysterically funny lowlife that he plays on the internet.  Does this mean the kid from Brooklyn is a fake too?  Is nothing sacred?  If you can’t trust the wackos, who can you trust?

Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer :  Jamie’s got a heart-breaking story (really, this time, not like the Joe Ligotti one) about how 10 year old Jayci Yaeger, dying of cancer, is denied the opportunity to see her father, who has 1 year left on his drug sentence, by the unilateral fiat of a camp warden.  This, apparently, is not sufficiently “extraordinary” to give the kid a chance to be with her dad before she dies.  Doug Berman  also posts about it, though oddly without any commentary.

And then there’s  Turley (whose blawg is named, naturally, Turley):  Jonathon posts about how a 72 year old, beaten and “kneed” when cops apparently executed a warrant at the wrong address and, after realizing it, just proceeded for the fun of it in front of his 2 year old granddaughter, had his jury verdict cut to limit the award to his medical bills.  Apparently, pain and suffering are just part of our duty as citizens.

I can say for sure, but I bet I’ll be adding some more stuff before the end of the day. 

Little “Girls Gone Wild,” Again

Joe Francis can’t catch a break.  After finally getting his jail cell all fixed up just the way he liked it, he cuts a deal with Spitzer’s purported very close friend “Kirsten” for $1 million, only to find that he doesn’t need to spend a dime because he already had her on tape, nekkid.  Woo hoo!  Cha-ching!

“Girls Gone Wild” founder Joe Francis originally reached out to Dupre, offering $1 million for her to appear in a non-nude spread for his company’s new magazine and a chance to join the “Girls Gone Wild” tour bus. But on Tuesday “Girls Gone Wild” employees found archived footage of Dupre filmed in 2003, and Francis retracted the offer.

But as told by the New York Lawyer, that dark cloud over Joe’s head just keeps raining on him.  After all those accusations of underage girls appearing in the GGW videos that gave Joe so much tsuris, it’s now back to bite him in the butt again.

In an e-mail to one of Francis’ publicists — forwarded by Buchwald to the AP — the attorney said he was “informed by Ashley that the video was in fact taken when she was underage (that is 17).”

Buchwald added in the e-mail that Francis was aware of Dupre’s age during the filming.

Francis said he bought Dupre a Greyhound bus ticket back home to North Carolina in 2003. Dupre returned home after she spent a week on the “Girls Gone Wild” bus in Miami and filmed seven full-length tapes, which included nudity, after signing legal papers, the company said.

“It was because she was underage that he sent her home on a Greyhound bus back to North Carolina. It would be outrageous at the very least to play the video of an underage female on the Internet,” Buchwald said in the e-mail.


There’s no suggestion that Joe (or his peeps) knew that she was underage at the time.  Indeed, there plenty of reason to believe that this woman, like many others, say that they are of age when they may not be entirely truthful, thus misleading Joe and his posse into filming young ladies in compromising positions.

But to have the rug pulled out from under him yet again has got to hurt.

Now I’m not terribly sympathetic to Joe Francis because of the effort by his publicist a while back to engage me in  his scheme to  garner support for getting Joe out of jail.  But my issue wasn’t so much with Joe as with his publicist.  Still, I’m no fan of the stuff Joe produces in general, and I’m specifically disturbed by the fact that there are so many problems underage women going “wild” at his urging.  No, I’m not suggesting censorship, but I’m also not prepared to exert much effort to help this dubious commercial enterprise.

“It’s kind of like finding a winning lottery ticket in the cushions of your couch,” Francis told the AP — before he saw the e-mail from Dupre’s attorney.

Bummer. 

NY Judges and Lawyers Square Off Over Pay

As the debacle of judicial pay raises in New York grows, the finger-pointing and back-biting does as well.  No, not between the judges and politicians (that’s been going on since the beginning), but between judges and lawyers.  The  New York Law Journal has put together a series of letters, back and forth, between judges and lawyers and bar associations.

While this series of letters is largely officious, and lacks the grit that appears in  Judicial Reports where the discussion has been far deeper, angrier and, frankly, more honest, the fact that it’s come out in the open in a paper where platitudes and courtesy reigns supreme is telling.

The question of whether the judges deserve a raise has long been answered:  Of course they do.  The problem now is that the judges, unable to break the stalemate in the Legislature on their own, having lost faith in their judicial leadership to be capable of accomplishing the task and seeing no viable means of taking action on their own, have turned to lawyers and bar associations and accused them of not having done enough for judges.

This is a huge paradigm shift.  While judges may be lawyers, and enjoy those bar association functions when there’s food and drink for everyone, there has long been a professional distance between the two.  Once they put on the robe, the brotherhood is forgotten and they are judges.  They treat lawyers like, well, mere lawyers.  Some treat us quite poorly.  Some use their power in the courtroom, and over our clients, to make it clear who’s the boss.  Now they want us to be their buddies.  Interesting.

This was the gist of  my commentary at Judicial Reports a while back, where I challenged the judiciary to change their attitude toward the bar in general before they expected lawyers to make their pay raises our problem.  Nothing happened, as far as I can tell, though I hardly expected it would.

So now we’re at the next crossroad.  Bar associations, mired in their amorphous dedication to “justice”, have come out in support of judicial pay raises, but have done little to help aside from press releases.  I don’t know what more the judges’ expected them to do, but whatever it was they haven’t satisfied the judges.

It’s reached the point where judges sound more like the Wobblies, ready to take to the streets in frustration.  They tried it the right way, the nice way, to no avail.  Pay Raise Central in Albany keeps telling them there will be pie in the sky when they die, but the judges have no interest in waiting (or dying).  And they have run out of options.

Our new governor, David Paterson,  has announced that with all the problems he has in Albany, budgetary and otherwise, it’s not going to happen this year.  Now if only judges can do without eating for a year, they may be okay.  Yes, that’s an exaggeration, but not much of one.  Let’s face it, life has become far more expensive recently and their effective earnings decrease daily. 

The situation has grown dire.  While I had argued before that it was demeaning to suggest that good lawyers only become judges for the loot, there is a harsh reality that good lawyers will not go through the rigors of seeking the bench, and good judges won’t continue to suffer, and make their families suffer, when the salary won’t cover a reasonable nut.  It has really grown that bad.  It may reach the point that the only people who want to be a judge badly enough to live with the pay are the ones we least want on the bench.  And they are going to be there a long time, making life and law miserable for all.

The judges have suffered enough, and they have made their point.  It’s time for the polite lawyers who run the bar associations to take off the gloves and start making a ruckus.  Judges must receive a substantial increase in pay now, or we’ll all be suffering the consequences for a generation.

Ben Brafman Worked a Miracle

The  word spread like wildfire yesterday that the giant of the securities class-action, Mel Weiss, was copping a plea.  Few lawyers will ever be as hated, or have as much impact, in the sphere of business as Mel.  He was nothing if not controversial.

Mel was accused of sharing fees with the named plaintiffs in class actions that made corporate America shudder.  Like his partner,  Bill Lerach before him, Mel admits that he did so.  Aside from issues as to the merit of the prosecution itself, which is water under the bridge at this point, if there was any human being who was going to be nailed to the cross for being one of the most hated men to corporate America for having done his job too well, it was Melvyn Weiss.

In stepped Ben Brafman, a New York City criminal defense lawyer.  What Ben did for Mel Weiss was nothing short of spectacular.  Read Ben’s post-plea agreement statement.  This was an astounding deal, one that Mel would have been insane to pass up.  Ben earned his (I’m sure not inconsequential) fee on this case.

If ever there was a case where one would suppose the government intended to “send a message,” Mel Weiss’ would be it.  They had the case lined up perfectly, with his partners having pled before him and the set up arranged perfectly.  The potential need for the government to cut a deal was slim, bordering on non-existence.  They could have taken as hard a line as they wanted, and there was nothing Mel could have done about.  Yet somehow Ben not only cut a deal, but cut a spectacular one.

What was this spectacular deal? 


The Plea Agreement provides that Mr. Weiss may receive a sentence of from 18-33 months imprisonment, with the Court having the discretion to substitute a period of home confinement and/or community confinement for up to half of any prison sentence, should the Court conclude that a prison sentence is appropriate.  Mr. Weiss has also agreed to pay a total of $10 million dollars in fines and forfeiture penalties.

The message on time is clear enough, so Mel can spend some time gazing out his rear window at Oyster Bay and contemplate the error of his ways.  The $10 million may seem like a lot to some, but that was likely a trade-off of the legal fee he would have spent had he gone to trial.  Well, some of it anyway.  Mel can afford it, and no one need fear that he’ll be suffering any substantial change in lifestyle.

If you are on Ben’s A-list of clients, such as Puffy Daddy and Mel Weiss, you will have one extraordinary lawyer representing you.  While not averse to the limelight, unusual for an orthodox Jew for whom modesty should be a rule of life, Ben has the goods to back it up.  His work can be exemplary.  I’m jealous of him because he gets cases that I want.  But when Ben pulls off a coup like this, I can’t help but admire his extraordinary skill.

Once a regular lawyer, Ben has soared into the stratosphere of top criminal defense lawyers in New York and around the country.  What’s unusual is that many of the well-known names are more a matter of brilliant self-promotion than brilliant lawyering.  Ben is just the opposite, having made his bones through skill and not merely because he has a pretty face or hung at Regines or Reos, kissing up to the powerful. 

Mind you, Ben’s time is spent on his A-list clients, which is what happens when you have A-list clients banging down your door, and there’s only so much brilliance to go around.  So the pseudo-important may be disappointed to find that they aren’t Ben-worthy. 

But let there be no doubt that Ben Brafman is all he’s cracked up to be.  Well done.

The Blogging Assasin

Hyperbole is nothing new to the blogosphere, but  Real Lawyers Have Blogs raises the problem of bloggers and commenters use of the blogosphere as a weapon against others, while hiding under the veil of anonymity.


Joseph Hosteny, an attorney at Niro Scavone whose scathing piece “The Cowardice of Anonymous Bloggers” appeared in Intellectual Property Today already addressed the question when it published in late February (back when Frenkel’s identity was still a mystery). By calling anonymity a “repugnant disguise” and essentially comparing Troll Tracker’s actions to those of an amoral paparazzi photographer, Hosteny makes clear his position on the issue:


Anonymous postings are poisoning the online well, making any real debate over our patent system in the Internet arena difficult to nearly impossible. We litigators have been told, over and over, that we are not civil enough to each other. Unlike some politicians, many of us have heard — and heeded — the message. But these anonymous bloggers, and those who post anonymous comments to these blogs, can say whatever they want. As [Chicago Tribune public editor Timothy] McNulty said in his article, “Anonymity emboldens the cowardly and the liars.” But recently, the situation has become worse. We are now seeing death threats.

Very strong words indeed.  In some instances, things appear to have gotten out of control, generating opinions like this as well as  the silliness of Kentucky’s Tim Couch.  Death threats reflect sick minds.  There are always a few people with sick minds floating around, despite natural selection.  I don’t know that anyone will ever find a way to make these people disappear.

I’ve made no bones about the fact that I am, generally, not  a fan of  anonymous  blogging or commenting.  My reasoning is two-fold.  First, anonymity emboldens people to write things that they would never say to a person’s face, giving rise to the problem that Hosteny opines about as well as a general lack of civil discourse.  Second, it’s difficult to understand and appreciate a lot of what’s written without context, provided by having some knowledge of who’s saying what. 

I’ve been challenged as attacking the messenger instead of the message, but I respond that the meaning or significance of the message (i.e., I think the death penalty is the best thing since sliced bread) is relative to the messenger.  Whether a statement comes from a law student, a non-lawyer, a prosecutor, a judge, a lawprof, matters in interpreting or appreciating the statement.  The blogosphere is an imperfect form of communication, and engaging in a meaningful discussion sometimes demands more information than a particular poster provides.

That said, let’s not go off the deep end either.  The vast majority of anonymous comments and blogs do not reflect malevolence.  Yes, it may “embolden cowards and liars.”  It may also just protect ordinary people who prefer not to have their name all over the internet to be searched later and have their posts thrown in their face. 

There have been trolls since someone figured out that people can post stuff on the internet.  They annoy, they disrupt, they attack.  But there are far, far more people who want to contribute in a positive fashion.  Sure, we may not always like what they have to say, but mere disagreement is part of the game when you express opinions.  I try to deal with it, and sometimes I do so poorly.  But I try my best.  Hopefully it is good enough.

If my memory serves, there was a time on the internet when the right-thinking people would spot a troll, a drive-by idiot, a liar or coward, and shut him down.  People stood up for honesty and integrity online, and we promised to police ourselves and thus keep the friendly finger of the government off the delete button.

I don’t see this happening much anymore.  People see things they know to be wrong, and just skip to the next post or comment.  They don’t want to get involved, invoking the memory of Phil Ochs.  If we do a better job of self-policing, clean up the attacks on our own, perhaps we can eliminate much of the problem.  I doubt we will ever stop people from being dangerous, as some will always find new and offensive ways of behaving.  But we can deal with a lot of it, and make this experience better and more useful for the rest of us.

One last thought on the subject: Volume of words doesn’t win arguments.  Nor does getting the final word.  If that were so, I would win every point, mostly because I can control whatever happens here.  Disagreements are not life or death.  There’s no need to stay up late at night responding to everything for fear that you might “lose”.  This is a discussion, and the merit of your point will prevail if it is worthier than the other persons, not because you’ve written the same thing ten times or because you can’t distinguish between reason and emotion. 

But most importantly, it’s just a discussion.  You can stop any time you want.  I often let comments that I think are just silly float by because it’s not a discussion I want to continue.  Did I lose?  Not as far as I’m concerned.  And I guarantee you that it won’t keep me up at night.

Convicted For What? Nixzmary Aftermath

I  posted yesterday about the conviction of Cesar Rodriguez for first degree manslaughter in the death of his 7 year old daughter, Nixzmary Brown.  While I abhor the father’s treatment of his daughter, the mechanism of prosecution of even despised defendants remains a concern.  Having stumbled upon this post at Crime & Consequences, comment is now required.


Gruesome pictures bring jury to tears as they see the room where 7-year-old Nixzmary Brown was bound to a chair, starved and forced to urinate in a litter box. Reported by The New York Times yesterday, Cesar Rodriguez was convicted of manslaughter for killing his stepdaughter. The jury wanted to convict him for murder but felt the prosecution “didn’t really give [them] enough.”

The saying that a picture is worth a thousand words is never more true than at trial.  The impact of seeing something horrible strikes at the core of our being, and evokes a human response to right the wrong we see.  Prosecutors know this.  Judges know this.  Criminal defense lawyers know this too.

Cesar Rodriguez was on trial for the killing of his daughter.  The fact of poor 7 year old Nixzmary’s death is horrible, something that should invoke a visceral reaction of abject anger in any person. 

But this snippet from C&C is entirely different.  And it’s exactly what’s wrong with this prosecutorial ploy, an appeal to sympathy, a plea to the jury to hang the defendant, not for the commission of the crime charged but for his general blame-worthiness as a father and human being.  This is very wrong.

Rodriguez was a terrible, abusive parent.  One might well question his worthiness as a human being, given the nature of his treatment of his daughter.  But that’s not why he’s on trial.  The pictures described by C&C have everything to do with Rodriguez’s lack of humanity toward his daughter, but nothing to do with the question of whether he murdered her.  He is on trial for a discrete act, not for being a bad parent or human being.

Note that there is relevance to other offenses, such as endangering the welfare of a child, a minor offense in the scheme of a murder trial, but no mention is made of this in the C&C post, and the implication is that Rodriquez’s guilt can be inferred from his generally bad treatment of his child. 

The fact that this C&C post ignores any evidence of criminal conduct (or lack thereof) and prefers to characterize Rodriguez’s conviction in terms of his horrific but irrelevant general treatment of Nixzmary serves as a warning to all.  This is a smear.  Sure, it’s designed to get the bad guy, but it’s still nothing more than a smear.

There are some, perhaps many, who believe that the end justified the means.  I do not.  This snippet was very wrong, and speaks quite poorly of a prosecutorial mindset that will use any appeal to sympathy and prejudice to reach its goal.  Beware.

An Easter Invitation – BAT08

David Giacalone at  f/k/a has posted an alert for the blawgosphere about BAT08 – Blog Against Theocracy 2008 – taking place this upcoming Easter weekend, March 21 – 23, 2008.  As explained,


The theme [of the blogswarm], like always, is the Separation of Church and State — we are for it. But the variations on the theme are many…This is not a bashing of religion – peeps can believe what they choose, however they choose — but it is a reminder that the Government should keep out of religion, and Religion should keep out of the government.

I’ve just learned what a  blogswarm is, “the analogy is to that of a swarm of locusts (bloggers) descending on a wheat field (story or news item). The effect of the blogswarm is to catapult a story or news item to the forefront of the national discussion for that day or week.”  If nothing else, it creates a larger discussion of the issues, and it strikes me that Easter is a perfect opportunity to discuss the separation of Church and State. 


(Photo gratuitously taken from David Giacalone, but post-hoc permission granted on the basis that nobody buys anything from me because of it, so everybody has to promise not to or I’m in deep trouble with David.)

As so many of us will engage in both the festivities of the day, as well as the solemn meaning of the resurrection, we do so without regard to any government permitting us, encouraging us or joining us, in doing so.  Religion exists inside individuals.  We need no government to approve of our beliefs this Easter.

This is always a controversial subject, and tends to bring out some very strong opinions.  I’ll refrain from discussing it now since the point of this exercise is to put it all on the table at the same time. 

I urge anyone and everyone interested in the subject to join in this blogswarm.  It is critical to recognize that this has nothing to do with bashing religion, any religion, but is about government’s role relative to all religions. 

So join the blogswarm this week end and Blog Against Theocracy.  Where tall boots, just for safety.