Author Archives: SHG

John White Sentenced to 2-4 in Cicciaro Killing (Update)

The killing of Daniel Cicciaro Jr., the drunken young man who showed up at the White residence late one night to harm young Aaron White based on a false rumor that Aaron was going to rape a white girl, has ended with the sentence of Aaron’s father, John White, to a term of imprisonment of 2 to 4 years.  He faced a potential sentence of 5 to 15 years for second degree manslaughter.

I’ve posted about this case  here and here.


In a lengthy victim impact statements before the court, Cicciaro’s parents both asked Kahn to impose the maximum 5 to 15 year sentence for manslaughter and gun possession.

“You knew it was murder that night,” said Daniel Cicciaro Sr. “You’re a coward and God knows you’re guilty of killing my son.”

Oddly, Daniel the father saw nothing in the way he raised his son as contributing to the volatile situation resulting in his son’s death.


As soon as Kahn began speaking of the uncharged “moral accessories” to the teen’s death, his parents started shaking their heads — appearing strikingly prescient before the sentence was pronounced.

And when the court session was dismissed, family and friends of the victim stormed out of the courtroom cursing and crying.

This case was horrible for all involved, and all around.  But what is most disturbing is the underlying attitude that resulted in one young man dead and a father going to prison, and no lesson having been learned. 

Update:  See this  WABC footage of Daniel, Sr. after the sentence, screaming “We’ll see what happens when Aaron White gets shot and see how the laws are.”  Judging from the parent, the son never had a chance.  He appears to be sufficiently disturbed to make good on his threat.  It’s hard to find printable language to describe the Cicciaro’s and their ilk. 

Another Simple Solution to Prison Costs

As I write these first few words, I dread the harangue that I foresee coming.  But write I must.

Doug Berman is always on the forefront of finding ways to ease prison overcrowding.  As before, we share that desire.  But that doesn’t mean that anything and everything that serves that end is a good idea.  We been here before too.

And so comes another law from another state that offers a solution :  Just execute them.  My head is spinning.

The Denver Post has an editorial against a law that would “authorize the death penalty for people who sexually assault a child 12 years or younger if DNA evidence links them to the crime.”  If I was ever to endorse the death penalty, it would be for raping a child.  But as much as my feelings toward sexual assault of a child might make me consider taking on the job of pulling the switch, it’s still a bad idea.

What’s interesting about this Colorado law is that it includes a DNA component.  People love DNA because it proves that the guy is guilty, thus removing any potential fear of killing an innocent defendant, a stumbling block to some (but not to enough, unfortunately).  Of course, crime lab DNA scandals, the broad array of collection and analysis errors and the potential of science to figure out one day that the statistical probabilities of positive identification via DNA (as opposed to positive exclusion) leave this scientific certainty slightly less than a sure thing. 

Berman is not happy with this editorial.  In his own words, “it drives him crazy.”  Nobody wants a crazy Berman running loose.

This editorial, in my view, highlights everything wrong with modern death penalty abolitionist arguments:





  • First, despite the usual denials by abolitionists that the death penalty could be an effective deterrent, the editorial uses a fuzzy and highly-suspect reverse-deterrence argument to contend that a capital child rape law could would hurt children. 



  • Then, in an effort to save repeat child rapists from even the possibility of capital punishment, the editorial argues that other offenders (first offenders) should be subject to longer terms of imprisonment. 



  • Throughout we get no real evidence or data, just false assertions and excessive confidence that life sentences (but not the possibility of death penalty) provide “the best way to protect children.”


This stuff drives me crazy and, as I have tried to explain in some prior posts, may promote the worst of all possible criminal justice worlds for children and everyone else.

I read the editorial.  While it may lack a certain depth of discussion that one finds in 47 page law review articles, it covers the bases.  And the basic arguments are all rational and logical.  Unless you don’t agree, in which case you call its arguments “fuzzy and highly-suspect.” 

What is it about the death penalty, or its positive side, the elimination of prison over-crowding, that sets people aflame?  It’s not like capital cases are inexpensive to prosecute; they cost a fortune.  It’s not like the fraction of people who might otherwise be put to death is going to make a dent in the prison population.  So why such zeal to kill?

If we look back to the wild west, for you Zane Grey fans out there, remember how they used to hang horse thieves?  A tad harsh to some, but you don’t steal another man’s horse, if you know what I mean.  Did it bring a swift and decisive end to horse thievery?  Unfortunately no. 

The pirates’ mantra was “dead men tell no tales.”  Neither do dead children.  I don’t want any more dead children.  Before someone can denigrate the argument that capital punishment for a sexual assault (whether second or twenty-ninth), guarantee me that no child will die as a result.  The potential that a lifetime in prison will not be adequate retribution for an animal who would harm a child is not enough to make it worthwhile to bring about one child’s death.  Not one.

Certainly, there are many people out there, in fact a majority of Americans, who feel that capital punishment provides justice, for society and the victims.  They don’t make me “crazy”.  I understand their position.  I just disagree with them. 

Junk Science, Jersey Edition

The Breathalyzer has been in use since 1954, according to the Newark Star-Ledger.  But move over, old friend, and meet the new gold standard, Alcotest 7110, so says the New Jersey Supreme Court in a 132 page unanimous opinion.

Challenges by defense lawyers to the accuracy of the computerized Alcotest prompted the Supreme Court in early 2006 to appoint retired Appellate Division Judge Michael Patrick King to study the machine. King held dozens of public hearings and issued two voluminous reports last year, finding the device was “much more reliable” than the Breathalyzer.

Don’t ask me what the two voluminous reports say, or even what the 132 page decision says.  I’m not interested enough to read any of them.

But I do appreciate the Court’s determination that the Alcotest is “much more reliable” than the Breathalyzer.  No doubt, the same is true of the millions of people whose lives were ruined because of the “much less reliable” Breathalyzer, which similarly enjoyed “state of the art” status until somebody figured out it was garbage.

Therein lies the problem with courts making decisions about the reliability of science.  They just aren’t any good at it.  They never have been.  High tech mumbo jumbo confuses the legal mind.  Courts want to have scientific-type tests that they can rely upon so that they don’t have to actually make decisions.  “But the Alcotest says so,” the judge pronounces, “and therefore you are guilty!”


“We are confident, based on this far-reaching and searching inquiry, that the device is sufficiently reliable so that the rights of all defendants have been protected,” Justice Helen Hoens wrote for the unanimous court. “The device, with the safeguards we have required, is sufficiently scientifically reliable that its reports may be admitted in evidence.”

What’s missing from this quote?  The recognition that the same was said of the Breathalyzer in its day.  How did it go from being scientifically reliable to yesterday’s junk science?  The answer, obviously, is that the device didn’t change, but the scientific assumptions didn’t play out the way lawyers decided they should.  That’s because lawyers (and judges) are notoriously bad scientists.


“The Alcotest, utilizing state-of-the-art technology and a host of additional safeguards, will provide strong evidence and sure justice for those who violate New Jersey’s drunken driving laws,” Milgram said. “It will be an invaluable tool for police in their efforts to protect the lives of all motorists who use New Jersey’s roadways.”

So says the prosecution.  It’s like those products that put, “new and improved” on the box, it must be true because it says so. 

The legal system has a long and sordid history of backing the wrong scientific horse.  We pick the one that works best for a clean conviction, and we package it up all nice and pretty in hyperbole to make it seem above reproach.  We can only see that screw-up when the next shiny device comes along, and somebody (as here) opines that it’s “much more reliable” than the last device, which was similarly foolproof when it hit the shelves.  We never seem to learn.

And then there’s always the wild card, the cops.  Maintenance, testing, updating, all the things that are supposed to be done to safeguard the legitimacy of the device, are in the hands of the cops.  We don’t get to watch them do it.  We take their word for it. 

When was the last time any cop testified that, “no, we actually never check the radar with the tuning forks.  In fact, we lost those darn forks two weeks after the radar arrived, and never tested it again.”  Anybody want to best that this is how it really happens?

“But that would be perjury, if they testified that they complied with all the safeguards and requirements,” you say.  Yeah?  So?  Who’s going to arrest the cop?  Who’s going to prove it?  This is a big black hole in the scheme.  But nary a court will notice.  To do so would be to admit that the system really is a sham, and we wouldn’t want that.  It would make us look bad.

A great business idea just occurred to me.  I’ll invent the Smashalyzer 5000, with “new and improved” conviction software.  No matter who blows into it, the green light comes on that says, “You’re smashed!”  I’ll sell a million of them.  They’ll provide “sure justice for those who violate New Jersey’s drunken driving laws,” not to mention anybody else the cops want to nail.  One thing’s for sure, no drunk driver can beat it.

The Heller Oracles Speak (Update)

Now that biggest case in a lifetime (at least for the moment) has been argued, the lawprofs are all over the Heller oral argument like flies on…stuff that flies like to be on.  They’re  predicting a 5-1-3 split.  They’re  predicting a Roberts or Kennedy  majority opinion.  They’re  predicting an individual right, somehow limited to protecting one’s safety inside one’s home with certain arms but not any arms.  They’re  predicting that the Justices had their minds made up before oral argument, and that it didn’t matter one iota.

So why am I feeling so unfulfilled right now?  Because no one wants to talk about the existence or absence of a sound intellectual basis for all these predictions.  I’m not saying they’re wrong about how this will turn out.  For all I know, they’ve nailed the outcome cold. 

But how do you get there from here?  I don’t see anything in the 2d Amendment about an individual right to keep and bear arms, but only in one’s home.  It doesn’t say that it’s only for self-defense.  What words give rise to that belief?  Has the militia reference gone from being the dominant clause to being wholly irrelevant, so that the only example refers to some home-based militia need for arms?

And if it’s a fundamental right (aw heck, a right at all), how do you explain stopping felons from exercising it.  Do we allow unreasonable warrantless searches as long as it’s of a felon?  Are felons not allowed the right to counsel, to confront witnesses, to a jury?  Felons can remain silent, engage in free speech, even practice their religion.  Why should they suddenly be excluded from an individual right under the 2d?  When home invaders shoot a felons, do the bullets harmlessly pass through their bodies?

Hey lawprofs, now that you’ve arrived at your predictions of what the Supreme will do, how do you get there?  What rational basis explains the limitations, conditions, restrictions that you predict?  Where’s that scholarly approach that you guys love so much?

One of the predictions suggests that the Roberts Court will be “modest” in its approach, meaning that it will decide no more than what it absolutely must to resolve the issue of the total gun ban of the District of Columbia.  If so, does this do anything to illuminate how a right for the rest of the nation?  Can we understand a right, its breadth and limitations, without the Court bothering to announce it, or will this just breed total chaos across the nation, awaiting another decision from the Supremes as the circuits conflict and the state supreme courts cross each other?  And what standard are all the other courts to use?  Do they just make it up court by court?

I know, you all want to show that you can guess the outcome of one of the most significant Supreme Court decisions in decades, and I understand that the lawprof who gets it right will probably get tenure, or a pass on teaching crim pro to 1Ls, or a $4 million condo in Manhattan.  But if you can stop playing Jimmy the Greek for a moment, please explain how they get there. 

Having spent a decent amount of time thinking about, writing about, discussing D.C. v. Heller, I’ve tried hard to devise a logical explanation that would allow the Supreme Court to reach the conclusion that so many seem to desire; that there is an individual right, but a right that extends to all the good guys but keeps weapons out of the hands of all the bad guys. 

The right is tested by strict scrutiny when it comes to good guys, and no scrutiny when it comes to the bad guys.  The right will permit NRA members to carry any weapon they want, concealed or open, anywhere they want, but will permit government to regulate that right for everyone the government doesn’t like.  The problem is that there is no way to justify this beast of a right.  Except by just coming out with a brand new rule of constitutional construction:  Because we say so.  That’s why I’m feeling so unfulfilled.

Doesn’t this bother any of you lawprofs as well?  After all, how are you going to write law reviews about this new doctrine if there isn’t any doctrine?

Why does it matter?  It’s that old rubric/rationale thing again.  It’s not enough to have a rule, but the rule has to be based upon some cognizable legal rationale.  How do we argue the next case when there’s no rationale behind it?  Without it, we just have a bunch of old folks in Washington making up the rules, and the Supreme aren’t supposed to do that.  That job already belongs to Congress. 

Update:  Carolyn Elefant at  Legal Blog Watch posts “Berman’s post also indirectly responds to Scott Greenfield’s question about how we can justify felon gun possession laws if handgun ownership is a fundamental right.”  In fact, posts like Doug’s were the genesis of this post.  This is not the superficial outcome-oriented question (in fact, it is expressly not about outcome) but about how one can rationally and logically adopt the position that the RKBA is a fundamental individual right without simultaneously adopting the strict scrutiny standard that applies to fundamental rights.

While I realize that the question is more involved than most people want to go, it will prove to be a huge problem going forward when we try to litigate the problems court by court, state by state.  Do we have a rule without a rationale, or do we have a cognizable legal doctrine to guide us as this litigation develops?  This is a much harder question, and one that has yet to be broached, no less answered.

Manslaughter Conviction In Nixzmary Case

The jury  returned a verdict in the trial of Cesar Rodriguez for the death of his 7 year old daughter, Nixzmary Brown:  Not guilty of second degree murder.  Guilty of first degree manslaughter.  According to the New York Times interview of the jurors:

Jurors said afterward that most of them wanted to convict Mr. Rodriguez of second-degree murder but that several holdouts said prosecutors had not proved that Mr. Rodriguez acted with “depraved indifference to human life,” the standard for second-degree murder in this case. So the jury of 10 women and 2 men voted to convict him on the heaviest charge that all could agree on, first-degree manslaughter.

That crime is defined as causing death by recklessly engaging in conduct, with intent to cause physical injury, that creates “a grave risk of serious physical injury.”

This is an interesting verdict in a few respects.  In my opinion, the jury was correct in its not guilty verdict on depraved indifference murder.  But I question why the charge even went to the jury.  Better yet, how it survived an inspect and dismiss motion. 

Daddy Rodriquez beat his baby Nixzmary all the time.  Contrary to the defense assertion, he was not the world’s greatest dad.  This was a pretty twisted fellow who used force on his kids regularly, likely because that was how he learned child-rearing from his own father.  Plus, it’s much easier to just whack a kid than be a loving parent for some people.  I like to call those people “prisoners”, but that’s just me.

However, there should have been no question from the outset that Rodriquez’s  mens rea did not legally reach the threshold of depraved indifference.  He was scum and abusive, but his smacking his daughter was still a rather pedestrian act of a bad parent.  From a difference perspective, a la Justice Scalia, it could be viewed as time honored American tradition, from, the good old days when the phrase “spare the rod and spoil the child” was more popular.  (This is sarcasm, for those of you who are sarcasm challenged.)

And so, the not guilty verdict not only comes as surprise only in respect to the question of whether a jury can hear a trial of a dead child and not be overwhelmed by the need to hang the defendant.  In this regard, the outcome speaks well of this jury.

But the defense in the case is that Cesar wasn’t the one who dealt the death blow to Nixzmary.  He claims it was his wife.  So much for chivalry.  By convicting him of the top manslaughter count, the jury rejected the defense that it wasn’t him.  My guess is that they really didn’t dwell too long on the question of which parent struck the fatal blow.  It could have been either one, and the jury wouldn’t lose any sleep over such details.

In a trial like this, where there is no evidence to distinguish which of two potential actors struck the blow that caused death, there are two possible outcomes.  One, as happened here, is that the jury refuses to absolve a defendant because of this single gap in the evidence, or the other is that no one is convicted despite a dead child.  To expect the latter is to ask too much of our jury system.  Someone must be held responsible, and when you have a dad who evokes no sympathy and has given a jury every reason to despise him, you can usually bet money that he’s going to be convicted.

It’s unlikely that many people will feel sorry for Cesar Rodriguez.  He’s the sort of fellow that most of us would like to see in prison, if not beaten to a pulp in the holding cell for what he did to his daughter on a daily basis.  But whether he should have been convicted of this specific crime is another matter.  Regardless, he stands convicted today, and I wouldn’t bet the farm that he’ll be greeted warmly in the Appellate Division when he argues that the evidence was legally insufficient. 

Why “No Problem” Is A Problem

Dan Hull at  What About Clients? says that law firms have become employee-centric, but still forget about taking care of the client.  He’s got a point.  I don’t know that people do it intentionally.  It’s hard to see how you or your employees fail to provide adequate client service because we tend to get wrapped up in our own self-serving rationale about why we do what we do.  In other words, we excuse ourselves because we understand our own needs and problems.  We are self-blind.

But it’s easy to see such failings in others.  Funny how that works.  So the easiest way to see the little (or big) things that we should or shouldn’t be doing is to note it in others and correct it in ourselves.  This is a prelude to the real purpose of this post, which is to write about something that perpetually annoys me.

We all call other people’s offices.  How often are you put off by the manner of the receptionist, the disdain and air of self-importance that makes you want to reach through the phone and grab him or her by the throat and squeeze.  The job is to answer a phone, and you happen to be a caller.  Why is this such a problem?

Receptionists have long been one of my pet peeves.  Obviously, this is the gateway to your practice, the portal though which every new client comes.  If the receptionist does the job well, the client is happy to enter.  If not, you’ve got a strike against you before you even begin.  I certainly don’t need my receptionist making my life unduly miserable.  I do enough of that myself.

How often is a call taken by someone who gives you the clear impression that he is doing you a monumental favor by answering the phone, or worse yet, taking a message.  No “may I help you,” but “what do you want.”  Instead of saying please, the receptionist seems all to happy to get you off the phone and makes it clear, through intonation and language, that you need to ask “please” if you want to reach someone.

One favorite of mine is when the person you’re calling isn’t there or available.  I ask for “Joe”, and I’m told, “Joe’s not here.”  That’s it.  Dead silence.  Then I have to ask, “And can you take a message for Joe?”  She says, “okay”.  Okay?  Am I interrupting something more important?  Or is my telephone call so inconsequential to your business that nobody there cares if I call or not?

But the worst, most troubling thing that comes across my telephone line is the receptionist who, after “agreeing” to take your message, responds to your thanking him for doing his job, the one he gets paid to do, by saying two particular words:  No problem. 

No problem?  Why should it be a problem at all.  If I’m a client and I don’t call you, you have no business.  Then you can’t pay someone to answer your telephones and they have to go back to Dairy Queen and ask “chocolate or rainbow sprinkles” with attitude. 

The meaning of “no problem” is that, but for their grace, it would be a problem.  I’ve asked for something beyond the pale.  I’m a burden, and they have generously put up with me.  Is my paying the money that pays your salary a problem?

As an attorney, my relationship to my clients is personal.  They have come to retain me, not just any lawyer, but me because of the work I do.  But I have had many a talk with support staff about how the treat clients.  They are not me.  The client didn’t come for them.  The defendant may be my long time client, with whom I’ve shared many experiences, but the support staff is not their dear old friend. 

Their job is not limited to doing what I need of them, but to treat clients with the appreciation due someone whose payments are what makes their salary possible.  Show them sincere appreciation.  Show them courtesy and respect.  As far as you’re concerned, the client earns it.  And never tell a client “no problem.”

When you work for me, you work for them because I work for them.  My job is to help them, so your job is to help them.  Do they annoy you?  Are they irritating?  Do you think you’re better or more important than they are?  Sorry, but without them, you’re out of here.  And so am I.  If I have to serve my clients, you surely do as well.

Be nice to my clients.  That’s our job.  And it starts with the receptionist.

The Constitution, As of 1868

This post by Rick Hills at  PrawfsBlawg is fascinating.  Simple in some respects, and yet almost universally ignored.  The issue is whether we view the meaning of the Bill of Rights as applied to the state based upon what was intended in 1791. when it only applied to the feds, or whether the true “originalist” ideal should be based upon the understanding as of 1868, when the 14th Amendment was passed.

But all of these cases deal with state powers under the 14th Amendment, not federal powers under the Bill of Rights. True, the latter is used as a crude sort of gloss on the former, which is said to “incorporate” the rights through the due process or privileges and immunities clause. But it seems odd to say that a constitutional text enacted in 1868 to protect the freedmen from race riots and Black Codes incorporates not only the bare text of the Bill of Rights but also the obscure legislative history or social understandings associated with the 1791 amendments. Why in the world would anyone think that Bingham, Howards, and the rest of the 39th Congress cared about the fine details of trial practice or militia regulation in the American colonial or Federalist period?

Wow.  All this time we’ve had our eye on the wrong ball. 

Application of the bill of rights to the states comes courtesy of the 14th Amendment, 1868 vintage.  So when this amendment was passed, what then did they understand to be the impact to be?   Did they have the same originalist, textualist, living document arguments that we obsess over today, or was there an entirely different view of what the impact meant.

Lacking the depth of historical understanding needed to even broach the subject, I leave it to others to answer.  But the idea that we are looking to apply the first ten amendments based upon what the framers had in mind in 1791, a time when they were never thought to apply to the states but only to the new-born federal government, brings an entirely different dimension to the discussion.

And what if nobody even considered the idea in 1868, when the 14th Amendment was approved for an entirely different purpose, post-civil war, to address the many freedmen issues that arose in the wake of emancipation? 

How weird would it be if all these discussions were entirely misdirected based upon this one little detail.  This is just an incredibly fascinating wrinkle.

Why A Death Penalty? Cuz They Need Killin’

Doc Berman reports on a Harris Poll on the death penalty.  The big issue, for or against it, is pretty straightforward: “Currently, 63 percent of Americans believe in the death penalty while three in ten (30%) are opposed to it.”  While I believe that the language “believe in” is meant to signify “in favor of” as opposed to “are unsure whether executed defendants are truly dead,” it’s clear that a majority of Americans remain enamored of killing defendants.

So what, you ask?  Well, it gets “curiouser and curiouser,” as Charles Lutwidge Dodgson might say.


One question with regard to the death penalty is whether or not it serves as a deterrent to others. Just over half (52%) of Americans believe that executing people who commit murder does not have much effect on deterring others from committing murder. Two in five (42%) say that executing people does deter others from committing murder. These numbers are almost identical to 2003 as well as 2001, so attitudes on this issue appear to be holding steady. However, this is a difference from 1976. Then, almost six in ten (59%) believed executing people deterred others while one-third (34%) believed that it did not have much effect.

So more than half of all respondents do not believe that the death penalty has a deterrent effect.  Then why are they for it?  Do they just like killing people?  I don’t know about you, but this one shocks me.  If someone believes that putting a killer to death will protect an innocent life, then I can appreciate why they would favor the death penalty.  There’s a rational, even if wrong, basis for their belief. 

But this poll result tells me that they have no rational reason to favor death.  What does this say about people?  They just sleep better knowing that someone will be put to death at midnight?

The Harris poll goes further.  In light of the lack of belief in a deterrence, consider this:


There is one issue almost all Americans agree on – 95 percent of U.S. adults say that sometimes innocent people are convicted of murder while only 5 percent believe that this never occurs. This is a number that has held steady since 1999. Among those who believe innocent people are sometimes convicted of murder, when asked how many they believe are innocent, the average is 12 out of 100 or 12 percent. In looking at this by race and ethnicity, African Americans believe more innocent people are convicted than both Whites and Hispanics (25% versus 9% and 12% respectively). Democrats also believe more innocent people are convicted than Republicans (15% versus 6%).

Thus, Americans believe that, on average, 12 out of 100 people convicted of murder and given the death penalty are innocent.  And they are fine with that.  What belies this approval, the belief that neither you nor anyone you know will ever fall into that 12% gap of innocent but dead men walking?  This is acceptable collateral damage?

Again, bear in mind that the acceptability of 12 innocent people “taking one for the team” might at least have some tenuous rational basis, but that’s not what makes this number acceptable.  These same people do not believe that there is a deterrence, so the 12 innocents dying are just a matter of bad luck?  

Isn’t it nice to know that America’s view of the death penalty is so well-conceived.

Cavity Epidemic in Albany

No, nothing to do with Spitzer’s peccadilloes, but a similar affliction is spreading like a cancer amongst the Albany Police Department.  As reported by the Albany Times-Union, a series of allegations of bizarre conduct have emerged accusing Albany cops of engaging in outrageous and unjustified cavity searches.  


[A] 22-year-old Troy woman who said she was unlawfully strip-searched by members of the Albany Police Department and then forced to undergo a pelvic cavity search at Albany Medical Center Hospital on Jan. 28…The January incident allegedly unfolded when a vehicle in which Crystal Royal, 22, was traveling was stopped by police on Interstate 787. It’s not clear whether she was the driver or if others were in the car.

Royal’s driver’s license was current and her vehicle was properly registered and inspected, according to the claim filed by her attorney Terence L. Kindlon of Albany. He said she was not stopped for any traffic infraction. She was made to stand on the roadway for an extended period of time while her car, body and purse were searched.

Royal was then transported to an Albany police station, where she was “involuntarily subjected to an unlawful body cavity and strip search” that included having her squat naked in front of a female officer.

And then:

That legal filing comes a little more than a week after police leaders defended their internal investigation into a complaint by a Ravena woman who said she was subjected to a cavity search on a public street during a traffic stop on Dec. 22.

In the Dec. 28 incident, no drugs or contraband were found on the Ravena woman, Lisa Shutter, and she was not ticketed or arrested after her body, car and purse were searched by officers who did not have a search warrant.

And then:

In another case with similar allegations, an Albany man has filed a federal lawsuit against the Albany County Sheriff’s Department in connection with his arrest at the Albany bus terminal two years ago. The man, Tunde Clement, was charged with a misdemeanor for resisting arrest but then was forced to undergo a strip-search at sheriff’s headquarters. He was then transported to Albany Med and was forcibly sedated as he underwent an anoscopy, X-rays and other examinations in a search for drugs. No drugs were found.

The problem here is not whether it is lawful for cops to engage in cavity searches, whether on the street (think about this) or elsewhere, or whether there’s a good reason to drug a defendant, engage in forcible intrusive medical procedures.  It’s all illegal.  It’s immoral.  It’s plain old wrong.

No, the problem here is much more basic.  There are a bunch of people running around Albany in uniform, with guns and shields, committing crimes against people and collecting public paychecks for their efforts.  Who stops them?  How would you like to be Lisa Shutter explaining why the cops performed a cavity search of you on the street.  How would you like to be the doctor drugging Tunde Clement and performing an anoscopy because the cops told you to do it.  This is mere inches away from Abner Louima.

Things sound like they’ve gone way off the deep end in the Albany Police Department.  It’s good to know that Terry Kindlon is on the case, but where are our public officials to put a stop to this horrific abuse by their cops?  This is really sick stuff.