Author Archives: SHG

Do NOT Try This At Home

You can bet that the name Harold J. Stewart will be spoken in hushed tones throughout prisons across America.  He is “da man.”  He did what every defendant dreams of doing.  He beat the system, and he did it himself.  Stewart beat a first degree murder case.  Pro se.  No one can remember that having happened before.

According to the Washington Post, via  Jon Katz and Carolyn Elefant, Stewart won an acquittal in Prince George’s County, Maryland, Circuit Court on the retrial of his murder 1 prosecution.  In his first trial, a mistrial was declared after it came to light that one of the jurors didn’t speak English well enough to understand the jury instructions.  Hey Anne, how can it possibly happen that no one, not prosecutor, defense or judge realize that the guy doesn’t speak English?

The family then hired a lawyer, who upon review of the transcript (including his sister who testified that Stewart confessed), advised him to cop a plea.  Stewart refused, and the lawyer withdrew.  Left without counsel, Stewart decided to go it alone.


At the second trial, Stewart’s sister backtracked from her original testimony, explaining that Stewart had asked for help and denying that he ever expressed concern that he’d killed someone.  And Simpson also seized on a discrepancy between a witness’ statement that placed the incident two hours earlier than the time that paramedics arrived at the scene.   Stewart did not call any witnesses.  The jury deliberated only an hour before arriving at the not guilty verdict.

This is the stuff of dreams for defendants, every one of whom thinks after his conviction that he could have beat the case himself.  They are positive of it, obsessing over every minute factual discrepancy and believing, in his deepest heart, that he could have done better. 

But as Jon notes, “[u]unknown is the extent to which Mr. Stewart won his trial because of any effective self-representation or despite mistakes on his part.”  Indeed, there are many questions about how a result like this came about, but there are also some things we know too well.

First, there is a greater likelihood that a person will win the powerball lottery three time than beat a murder 1 charge at trial.  Two, every case is different in small and large ways, though a defendant never lets this detail bother him when he argues that somebody else won their case, why didn’t he.  Three, the inability to be sufficiently detached makes it impossible to appreciate what matters at trial, as defendants obsess about silly things (he said 4 second and it was 6 seconds) and ignore big problems (like the videotaped confession).  And four, most defendants do not realize that they simply aren’t very bright, which helps to explain how they find themselves in this mess to begin with.

Stewart will empower defendants around the country to take charge of their fate.  This is good and bad.  It’s good because defendants should be involved.  It’s their lives, and they turn blindly to a lawyer without giving any scrutiny to the lawyers competence, interest or choices.  Defendants must have a better understanding of what is happening, for it’s their lives at stake.

But it’s bad to the extent that they believe that they know things or can direct the defense beyond the limits of their ability.  Empowerment only works to the extent that it’s rationally justified.  After that, the Dunning-Kruger effect takes over, and it’s all downhill from there.

So congratulations to Mr. Stewart for a job well done, or at least a darn good outcome.  But I caution the 50,000 Stewart wannabes in the wings that they may not be so lucky.  Don’t get crazy, even though it is your life.

Even Meltdowns Have Silver Linings (Update)

Yesterday Bear Sterns, today Lehman Brothers. I guess every cloud does have a silver lining.  No, I’ve got nothing against Lehman, and take no particular pleasure in watching Lehman suffer.  But…

What happens to a 30 year old trader who gets a $5 million bonus?  Does he put it away for a rainy day, thinking that he’s been exceptionally fortunate to receive such largesse?  Nuh uh.  He buys a fine house with a large garage to park his shiny new Ferrari.  Make that Ferraris.  Because he is a market genius, he anticipate that next year the bonus will be $10 million, and he will buy whatever he pleases.  Masters of the Universe are entitled to the simple pleasures man has to offer.

But every once in a while, some force comes along to knock the Masters on their butt.  They don’t know how this could be possible, but it can be poetic when it happens.  It shakes their world, at least a little, to see their holdings decline overnight.  The fear of being like everyone else, of having the Ferraris but not being able to afford the gasoline, permeates the air.  They can’t imagine every being ordinary.

Until the fear and loathing spreads to Wall Street, and hits the boys and girls, the men and women, personally, it’s all just a game played with our money.  When it’s their money, everything changes.  They were sold on the concept that up or down, they still get their commission.  Good economy or bad, they still make their deals.  No one ever told them that their lack of diligence, their excesses of greed, could come back to bite them in their personal derrière. 

Only when the Masters of the Universe come to the realization that they are not immune from the forces of avarice that can undermine life for us common folk do they take it seriously.  They don’t give a hoot about our pocket book, but they care a lot about their own.

Is it time for massive failure on Wall Street, banks collapsing under the weight of the same greed that gave birth to the subprime crisis, watching their portfolios implode because there is nothing beneath the surface of faked appraisals and scam applications?  Perhaps it is, and if so, perhaps it’s time. 

Whether it’s Lehman or Goldman Sachs doesn’t matter to me.  They all need a little lesson in humility, to recognize that there are real people on the other end of those account numbers who will bear the brunt of their bone-headed decisions while they believed they could do no wrong.

Anybody in the market for a slightly used Ferrari cheap? 

Update:  Not new (unless you haven’t seen it already), but an explanation of how the subprime crisis happened.  Thanks to  Volokh and Reasonable Doubts.

Rothgery Oral Argument: It’s Easy to be PC

Orin Kerr, who must have a permanent “get in free” card from the Supreme Court considering how he jumped the long line outside for today’s oral argument in D.C v. Heller, reports on yesterday’s argument in Rothgery v. Gillespie County.

Orin saw it this way:


My overall sense of the argument was that the Justices seemed less concerned with the traditional Sixth Amendment inquiry into whether the criminal case against the defendant had truly begun than the somewhat different question of the state’s power to detain suspects pre-trial — and the role of counsel in determining when that power should be exercised. In Gerstein v. Pugh, 420 U.S. 103 (1975), the Court had been pretty unconcerned about the defendant who might be stuck in prison unable to make bail before charges were formally brought. According to the Court, the question of “whether there is probable cause for detaining the arrested person pending further proceedings” was a simple matter that “can be determined reliably without an adversary hearing.”

This scares me.  In fact, it scares the daylights out of me for two reasons.  First, the initial probable cause determination is not a simple matter, not at all.  I can’t count how many times I’ve seen allegations that don’t amount to a crime proffered as the basis for arrest and used to hold a person for bail or jail. 

If the judge took a critical view of these complaint, essentially stepped into the defense lawyers shoes and challenged an empty allegation each and every time, then the Court’s “simple thing” might be true.  But that’s not how it goes down.  Judges don’t play the adversary to the cops.  At least most of them don’t, and if the judge isn’t going to parse the allegations for content to make certain that the allegations amount to a crime, then the proceeding is a rubber-stamp sham.

Moreover, some allegations are facially false.  Who is going to tell the judge that the cops are full of it, and show the court from inconsistencies in the allegations, or omissions in the events, that they nailed some poor guy to put him in the can a few days before the truth shows up to let him out?

This happens.  All the time.  For every serious case, there are a thousand minor garbage cases, where the cops allege that a defendant assaulted them by striking their fist with the defendant’s face.  You would hope judges would toss these cases immediately, but the fact is  they don’t.  Show a little disrespect and buy yourself a few days in the pen, courtesy of a judge who skips right over any real review of probable cause unless some defense lawyer forces the issue.  Even then, it’s a struggle, but at least there’s someone to fight the vapid, false or facially garbage complaint. 

Judges tend to be the weakest link in this process.  If there’s no lawyer for the defendant, who will try to make the judge do his job? 

Secondarily, I think every Supreme needs to spend a night in the holding cell, or perhaps on the Rock (Rikers Island).  I can’t comprehend how they can be so cavalier about an innocent person sitting in a jail cell for a few days or weeks.  No big deal?  Are they nuts?  It’s a huge deal.  It is a monumental deal.  If a person has committed no crime, then 5 minutes in a cell is a big deal.  Let our Justices enjoy an American cheese sandwich on white bread while fending off the smiling faces sharing the holding pen.  How dare they trivialize a few days in jail.  This is outrageous.

My hope would be that they didn’t appear too concerned about these matters because the wrongfulness was so clear and flagrant as to be unworthy of question, and they were moving on to the issue of holding uncharged defendants.  But my hopes have been dashed too many times.


The Court today seemed to look at the issue very differently. The Justices didn’t want to overturn Gerstein, but they seemed very worried about the possibility that people could be detained pending trial but then not charged, and that they might be stuck in the interim even though no formal charges had been filed, without a lawyer to challenge the detention.

A fair concern, but when does it start?  Do the cops get to put the defendant in the cell for the first night for free?  The first week?  Month?  Every minute in a cell for an innocent person is wrong.  Why ignore the initiation and only grow concerned that it could go on at length?  Am I missing something here?

Any innocent person who has been through the system can tell you about the pleasure of being an overnight guest of the State.  I’m sure the cells in Gillespie County aren’t mini-Club Meds.  I’m equally sure that I enjoy the ability to go home every night to my family, and I fully expect to be able to do so since I’ve committed no crime.  Doesn’t Chief Justice Roberts feel the same?  Why would he not appreciate the fact that others share this expectation? 

No, I’m not at all happy with the nature of the Court’s concerns.  You can bet your bottom dollar that the probable cause determination is no “simple matter,” and that the days or weeks in jail following a rubber stamp matter.  They matter a lot.  Enough for our Supreme Court to appreciate what it means to a person and take it very seriously.  I hope they do.

Here’s  the link to the transcript of the argument, courtesy of Howard Bashman.

Will Convictions Be A Blank Slate?

An email came in today from some gal named Jennifer announcing that Slate.com was creating a new “law blog” called Convictions. Interesting, no?  This new blog is supposed to be “commenting on legal issues ranging from Supreme Court arguments to political scandals and more.”  That’s what Jennifer said.

So why did they call it Convictions?  Beats me.  But the better question is what it brings to the table that isn’t there already.  Here’s the writers:


Slate writers like Jurisprudence columnists Dahlia Lithwick and Emily Bazelon, “Convictions” editor Phillip Carter of McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP,  along with top litigators and law professors across the country…

Like?


  • David Barron, Harvard Law professor and former attorney-advisor in the Clinton Administration
  • Rosa Brooks, Georgetown Law professor and Los Angeles Times columnist
  • Jack Balkin, Yale Law professor and noted constitutional scholar
  • Diane Amann, Professor at University of California at Berkeley School of Law
  • Doug Kmiec, Pepperdine University Law professor and former Assistant Attorney General in the George H.W. Bush Administration
  • Walter Dellinger, former acting Solicitor General of the United States and Duke Law professor
  • Judge Nancy Gertner, federal district judge in Boston, Massachusetts
  • Eric Posner, University of Chicago Law professor
  • Richard Ford, Stanford Law professor
  • Kenji Yoshino, Yale Law professor

  • Nancy Gertner would be pretty cool except she’s a sitting District Court judge up in Massachusetts, which means that there’s not a lot she cay say.  But where are all these “top litigators?”  All I see is another bunch of lawprofs, and let’s face facts, the blogosphere is seriously top heavy with lawprofs already.  So much so that it’s getting increasingly difficult for them to find anything to write about.  And former solicitor general Dellinger?  Because we’re all arguing before SCOTUS next week anyway?

    I also note that my buddy Orin Kerr at  Volokh says he’s writing for this Slate thing too.  But Orin, you post at Volokh.  Is there a reason why you’re posting at Convictions instead?  Has Gene been mean to you?  Did you guys have a fight or something?  Why, Orin, why?

    Seriously, what is clear about Slate’s new blog is that there isn’t a single real “in-the–trenches” practitioner in the bunch.  It’s a bunch of lawprofs and dilettantes, another high-and-mighty group cobbled together to give the final word on all things legal, but for the fact that not one of them faces life in the trenches.  What is it about the lawprofs that make these media types get all hard excited?

    There are already a few posts up at Convictions, and I started to read them and got bored.  They just don’t say anything.  They try to be cute, but go nowhere and illuminate nothing.  I gather Slate saw raw meat in the blawgosphere and wanted to get its piece, but my guess is that Convictions will be linked all over the place (because we know how the boys love to link to the big names) and will bring absolutely nothing to the blawgosphere that wasn’t here already.

    Sorry.  I know that many people enjoy the lawprofs.  I have nothing against them per se.  It’s just that you can only watch the same movie 50 or 100 times before it’s a bore.  This ivory tower adoration is out of control.  I want to read Bennett and Pattis and Spencer and even Matlock.  At least they actual do what they post about. 

    Doug Berman apparently learned of Convictions today too, though he’s feeling a little left out because they didn’t invite him to be part of the group.  “Still,’ Doug writes, “this blog is clearly to be a must-read because of its participants.”  Exactly.  Not because of its substance, but because of its “must-read participants.”  Ah, to bask in the glory of importance. 

    Sigh.  What a waste.

    By the way, they may call it a blog, but there’s no place to comment.  They do have a reader discussion forum called “The Fray,” where you have to register and get a password.  And, need I say it, there are advertisements.

    The Contingent Greening of America

    For those of you who follow Simple Justice regularly, you know that I’m a fan of the environment.  I even have a Prius.  So when I saw that if everyone in American went with paperless bank statements, it would save 18.5 million trees, it caught my interest.

    Not because I want everyone to go paperless, but because I realized how problematic such pleas will be.  I say this because of my recent experience with Citibank.  You know Citibank, with those wonderful commercials about how money isn’t everything.  Yes, that’s the attitude I want from a bank too.  But I digress.

    One day, a letter came from Citibank informing me that a computer file in the hands of one of their vendors was compromised.  Who or what, they wouldn’t say.  Privacy, I was told.  Not my privacy, of course.  As a result, they had to change my account “for my own protection.”  The ramifications of a change of account are huge, and it would be an enormous burden on me.  What was Citibank planning to do about that?  Nothing.  “We’re sorry for the inconvenience, but it’s for your own protection.”  I had no choice, I was told, and so they made the change despite my demand that they do nothing.  I love arguing with customer service reps.

    The next day, I went online to check my account, as I had a question about whether a check had been paid.  Poof!  It was gone.  Disappeared. Like it never happened.  So I called back the CSR, “Suzy” from Bangalore, who informed me that this is what happened when they terminate an account because it was compromised.

    “But what about my past statements?” I inquired without notable accent.  “Oh, we must remove and eliminate everything about the account,” Suzy patiently explained to this stupid American.  “So how do I see my statements?”  Again, Suzy repeated, “we are very sorry for the inconvenience.”  This, loosely translated, means “get lost.”

    The sad truth is that my statements are gone, and they aren’t coming back no matter what.  Had I saved a tree, it would be at the expense of having no bank statements.  Try to tell the IRS that it’s Citibank’s policy.  I’m sure they will be very interested.

    And what if I were to close my accounts and switch banks.  What are the chances I could always go back and access them?  I wouldn’t bank on it (get it?).

    The notion of a paperless world sounds wonderful.  I love trees.  Always have.  But I also love being able to retrieve my bank statements, accounts and all the other great stuff that allows me to know who’s stealing what from me at any given time.  And sometimes you need these things years later.  Will they be there for me online?  Not likely.  I can’t imagine Citibank saving any bandwidth for me if I’m not a current customer.  In fact, I can more easily imagine Citibank accidentally deleting all my statements and having some Dairy Queen reject tell me, “I’m sorry for the inconvenience.”  I don’t believe that Citibank is truly committed to saving trees.

    So the greening of American by the elimination of paper statements would result in a huge savings of resources, plus would earn banks some significant change by not having to print and mail all that stuff to me (though I’m sure the unsolicited garbage will come anyway).  But the ready availability of statements of account in the future will remain contingent on banks’ policies to preserve and permit access to accounts, today and years from today, whether you are still their customer or not.  Absent the security of knowing that they will be available to you when you need them, this is just an environmentalists dream that could turn into a banking customers’ nightmare.

    Of course, I could just believe all those commercials about how banks really love me.  But love is fickle, like bank policies and explanations from Suzy in Bangalore.

    Some Nagging Questions on the Economy

    As the speed with which our economy falls continues to increase, a few nagging questions persist.

    1.  Do all of those patriotic Americans who absolutely believed that a war for freedom in Iraq was worth whatever it costs still think it’s worth it when they consider  the cost (this would be the money that the government takes from, or will take from, us and our children)?

    2.  If you save your income and put it into some financial instrument so that your investment will grow and be there for you some day in the future, can you rely upon the expertise of financial institutions to assure your future?

    3.  Do our elected officials recognize that pontificating about what’s wrong after the fact does not help?

    Amigos, I have been posting about the economy for some time, warning that bad things are coming and those who can’t seem to connect the dots are bringing us to a precipice that will do great harm to many.  These aren’t my most popular posts.  Indeed, many spend far more effort “explaining” economics that appreciating that this isn’t theory but reality. 

    Take a broad view of what’s happening around you.  We have spent half a trillion dollars on the war in Iraq for a goal that is at best rhetorical.  Ah, how some love their jingoistic ideals and the accompanying rhetoric.  It makes them feel so . . . American.

    But then, these same people like to have jobs.  They want to make good money, “because they work hard.” 

    Wall Streeters are smarter about money than us ordinary folk.  Except at Bear Sterns.  But then, the people who worked their made a boatload of money in commissions, salary and bonuses.  That’s because Wall Street’s vision extends about 6 hours into the future.  They care only about the half point they can pull off the table in the next 5 minutes.  Our world revolves around theirs.  we need them, because without them we have no place to park our money until we grow old and die.

    But whether they make us money, lose our money or collapse, they take a piece of every transaction and put it into their pockets.  The piece turns out to be pretty large.  They want to make good money, “because they work hard.”

    In the meantime, our government has a duty to all Americans to keep the wheels of hope alive for our future.  See how bright, shiny words can be added to any sentence to make it seem uplifting even when there is absolutely nothing of substance or reason involved?  It’s a miracle. 

    The government is the only business around that has a never ending supply of customers that will pay whatever price it decides to charge.  And public employees are the only group of workers whose income and job prospects are never affected by economic conditions.

    Each year, they are assured of increases in salary, benefits and job security.  They want to make good money, “because they work hard.”

    It has occurred to me that there isn’t much point to my charging my clients for my services if the funds are going to simply disappear later when another shocking downturn in our economy occurs.

    It has also occurred to me that people who spend their money as soon as they get it on bright, shiny things may not be as foolish as I thought, since they are at least getting some benefit out of it while my “paper losses” mount.  Watching “paper losses” is not nearly as pleasant as driving that Aston Martin I have my eye on.

    It has further occurred to me that I am tired of having other people commit to choices that I disagree with, but have to pay for anyway.  That goes for neo-cons, politicians, public school teachers, Wall Streeters and others.  Waste your own money and leave me out of it.

    And finally, don’t tell me about economic theory unless you can account for why we seem to be so poor at addressing the constant series of failures that plague us.  I don’t have answers.  But neither do you.

    Anyone else have any nagging question?

    SCOTUS Today, When Does Right to Counsel Attach?

    In a peculiar case, Rothgery v. Gillespie County, naturally coming from the Sovereign Nation of Texas, the Supreme Court will hear argument today about when the right to counsel attaches.  The those who practice in jurisdictions of the United States, this case sounds plain screwy, but this is Texas.

    According to petitioner’s brief, This fellow, Walter Rothgery, was arrested in Gillespie County, Texas, for being a felon in possession of a firearm.  He wasn’t a felon, but that’s not the point.  He was arrested and the following morning brought before a magistrate, which apparently is a local judge who makes an initial probable cause determination and sets bail.  Despite Rothgery’s requests for a lawyer, none was assigned.

    The hearing held was called a “magistration”, where the police provide an affidavit to the magistrate saying, in effect, he committed the crime because I say so.  There’s no prosecutor present, and the magistrate then endorses the affidavit to show that he concludes there was probable cause for the arrest, and they all go out for a beer.  Except Rothgery, who does back to the jail cell.  Seriously, it’s that simple in Gillespie County.

    Now a little interesting history on the 6th Amendment right to counsel, per Orin Kerr :


    If I understand the history of the right to counsel, it was originally understood to mean that defense attorneys are permitted if a defendant had hired one, not that the government would provide one for him. The common law practice in the 16th and 17th centuries had banned defense attorneys in criminal cases; defendants were not permitted to use them, as it was feared that the defense attorneys would distract the jury and get in the way. If I recall my history correctly, Parliament had established a right for an attorney to appear and argue on a defendant’s behalf in the late 17th century in treason cases, and that had gradually spread in the 18th century to other criminal cases. The first Congress did not provide a lawyer for defendants beyond capital cases, further suggesting that the Constitutional right to counsel was originally understood to mean only a right to have an attorney appear on a defendant’s behalf if the defendant had hired the attorney on his own.

    This should give you a better appreciation of Gideon v. Wainwright, and how revolutionary it was to provide counsel to the indigent.

    As for Mr. Rothgery, who spent 3 weeks in jail, was later indicted, rearrested, given counsel who later proved that he was not a felon and had the case dismissed, he’s a little miffed about having to go through all that when it could have been avoided had he been given an attorney in the first place.  Hence, the case.

    While I would like to tell you that this case has no consequence for the civilized world, and is only a Texas peccadillo, I don’t believe that’s true.  There are still plenty of little local-yokel “justice courts” around, including New York, where police show up with villains in shackles to have judges, often non-lawyer judges, decide probable cause and whether to hold a person in jail until a real judge can be found.  Just because it isn’t called by a silly name like “magistration” doesn’t make the process appear any closer to real justice.

    In Rothgery, the denial of indigent counsel at the magistration stage was approved because there was no prosecutor either, thus connecting the right to defense counsel to the appearance of a prosecutor.  If they don’t have one, we don’t get one either, in other words. 

    Of course, given the nature of this magistration proceeding, there’s no need to send a prosecutor out on horseback, since the fix is in when the cop submits the affidavit that says,


    “I charge that . . . on or about the 15[th] day of July, 2002, . . . Defendant, Walter A. Rothgery did . . . commit the offense of unlawful possession of a firearm by a felon—3rd degree felony [Penal Code §] 46.04 against the peace and dignity of the state.”

    Seriously, how many prosecutors do you need to come up with this sort of hard-driving accusation?

    The underlying issue in Rothgery really does have meaning for the rest of us as well.  For upstate New York practitioners, who appear in local courts where the rules seem to come out of the blue, where there is no law that anyone else would recognize as such, where the judges run the local gas station and don’t know nothing about birthin’ no due process, the absence of an attorney for the defendant can prove critical. 

    It may be hard to imagine for us city lawyers that this still goes on, but obviously it does and it will as long as there are placed called “courts” that continue procedures that would make us pull our hair out.  While originalists will remind us that these local courts, with their local peculiarities, were common in the country way back when, so was paying the constable a salary based on the number of drunkards arrested that day. 

    Orin suggest that part of the problem with these types of cases is that the language used varies around the country, causing confusion as to what is required and when it has to be given.  Orin suggests:


    The Supreme Court might get around this by trying to define the Sixth Amendment right by reference to something else the Constitution requires, such as the Gerstein v. Pugh probable cause hearing required after arrests under the Fourth Amendment.

    But isn’t that exactly what happens in a magistration, where the magistrate signs off on the meaningless cop affidavit so that they can hold the defendant until they can take the guy to a real court?  Shifting nomenclature doesn’t change what’s supposed to happen at the proceedings, and obliterate all related rights. 

    It strikes me that the problem is that localities just don’t want to spend the money on providing indigent defense when it’s inconvenient, and are not going to do it until someone puts a gun to their head and forces them to behave like a real court.  Until then, they are going to hold on to their quick, convenient, traditional procedures that have served them (though not the defendant) well up to now.  So it’s now up to the Supremes to decide whether these local courts are going to start behaving like real courts.  And then it will be up to the rest of us, likely court by court, to force them to actually do so.  I bet they aren’t going to change easily.

    An Imperfect But Critical Balance of Power (Update)

    One of the most brilliant innovations of the United States Constitution was checks and balances.  By creating a system that prevented any one of our tripartite branches of government from towering over the others, our founding fathers recognized that the concentration of power was too dangerous to leave unchecked.  While the perpetual balancing act may be imperfect, it remains a stroke of genius.

    But there is one group that was left out of this balancing act, the media.  While a free press is a right established by the 1st Amendment, it’s relegated to a subordinate position to the government.  How so?  The fact that the government “gave” the media the fundamental right of freedom proves that it is subordinate.  Co-equals do not need each other’s permission to exercise their natural authority; they have the power to take it. 

    While it can be easily argued that the media has frequently squandered its inherent power on silly, sensationalist stories that do little to add to the accumulated knowledge and understanding of the public, and hence is unworthy of much of our concern, it still has a purpose in the scheme of a democratic society that cannot be denied and is occasionally fulfilled brilliantly.

    An example was shown in this  Wall Street Journal editorial, supporting District Judge Reggie B. Walton for holding former USA Today reporter Toni Locy in contempt of court for refusing to identify her FBI sources about Dr. Steven Hatfill.


    As many as 12 different officials in the FBI and the Department of Justice leaked inside information to Ms. Locy about their investigation into the anthrax attacks of 2001. They told her, and she reported, that some investigators thought former biodefense researcher Steven Hatfill was behind the attacks. The FBI, they said, could not “risk the embarrassment of losing track of Hatfill, even for a few hours, and then being confronted with more anthrax attacks.” These leaks, and others like them, ruined Dr. Hatfill, against whom, as Judge Walton noted, “there is not a scintilla of evidence.”

    Dr. Hatfill is now in court, seeking justice for his life ruined needlessly at the hands of our government officials.  His cause is just, and even the WSJ wants him to win against the government.


    Now Dr. Hatfill wants justice, which means getting the names of the leakers. Ms. Locy is the only one who knows the names. Dr. Hatfill asked for them; she asked Judge Walton to let her keep the names secret based on her private promises of anonymity. Judge Walton said no and ordered disclosure. Ms. Locy is in trouble not because she reported what she heard, but because she disobeyed a court order to tell us where she heard it. It’s hard to see how we could run a court system any other way.

    So Toni Locy, like Judith Miller before her, will pay the price of refusing to give up her sources.

    And so, an irony must be noted:  The Journal’s head-scratching at how “we could run a court system any other way” neglects to consider the State Secrets Doctrine, which allows the government to protect itself at the expense of running a court system.  Is it reasonable for the courts to shut their doors when the government wants to keep a secret, but not when the reporter does the same?  Absolutely, when the balance of power favors the government, even though both exist (theoretically) to create a balance of power for the benefit of the people.

    But more directly, a court can order a reporter to answer, and jail the reporter upon refusal.  Without the belief that insiders can disclose secrets to reporters and protect their identities, how many lies will go unnoticed or undisclosed?  This is a problem too, your honor. 

    It would make me very, very happy to see Dr. Hatfill nail those government scoundrels to the wall for having destroyed his life to use him as a weapon in the war of fear.  But with the belief that they could speak under cover of anonymity, Dr. Hatfill would never have known of the scheme to use him to deceive the public.  It’s a circular problem.  It’s a matter of balance.

    Why should the press be subjugated to the courts when it comes to the performance of its duty?  A free press is necessary as a check on the government, its excesses and abuses, if we, the people, are ever to learn the dirty little secrets that people with too much power hold dear. 

    The WSJ editorial poses four questions that reveal far more about its disingenuous support for the government than its critical thinking.  It finally posits this question:


    One wrote that “if a shield law is put in place, irresponsible journalists can print anything and get away with destroying lives. There has to be some sort of checks and balances here.” If these comments reflect public opinion better than the media conglomerates’ lockstep editorializing does, how can a senator justify a shield law?

    In its bizarre twist of logic, it has reversed the argument to suggest that “media conglomerates” will use their “irresponsible journalists” to subvert justice for the people against the will of the American people.  It almost makes one feel sorry for our weak government, unable to fight against the overwhelming power of the pen.

    But there is one line that I agree with, that there has to be some sort of checks and balances here.  The press cannot jail a federal judge.  The press cannot subpoena federal officials to give testimony, or punish a perjurer.  The press has no army or police force to silence anyone who would disclose too much.  And the press has no way to protect itself from a court system that makes the rules that dictate and control the subservient press. 

    When this changes, then we can think about how to crush a free press.  Until then, our fourth branch exists only to the extent the other three allow it, without the necessary checks and balances.

    Update:  My good buddy Norm has written on the subject, and comes out exactly opposite of me. Go figure.  Of course, Norm knows his newspaper reporters.

    Pass The Torch to the Left

    At about age 50, something strange happens.  No matter what our goals were when young, no matter how exciting life appeared when everything was still before us, we reach a point where we grow weary.  We tire out.  The thrill is gone.

    Almost everyone I know hits the wall when it comes to what they do.  The excitement of that first “not guilty” verdict was invigorating back then.  Now, it’s what we expect.  The first big, high-profile case was a thrill.  Now, dodging the media is a burden.  Been there. Done that.

    Everyone needs a challenge, a goal, to push them forward.  We want to scale higher mountains, to overcome new challenges.  But we find that the things that excited us long ago have become pedestrian.  It becomes a grind rather than a thrill.

    Every person of a certain age feels the same thing. Many refuse to admit it, but they are just lying to themselves.  Maybe they think it reveals them as unhappy people, or is counterproductive in their self-marketing scheme, but the truth is that we all grow tired.

    For this reason, I have a proposition.  At age 50, we all pass our jobs, professions, careers, whatever you want to call it, one person to the left.  We start fresh with a totally new set of goals and aspirations.  We do something that we’ve never done before, a fresh start.  We stare at a world full of new potential, the opportunity to succeed or fail at something we’ve never tried before. 

    For you generation Y’s, or Q’s or whatever they call twenty-somethings today, I have a surprise for you.  In your mind, you never really get older than about 30.  Sure, your eyes don’t work as well, and parts of your body hurt in the morning that you never before realized you had, and you can’t remember your kids’ names.  But your brain tells you that you’re still alive and vital.  You try to lift things that will throw your back out for weeks because your brain says you still can.

    There are rites of passage that propel us to move forward.  Remember that first kiss?  It was electric.  You want to feel that charge run through your body again.  No, not by cheating on your wife, but by doing something you’ve never done before.  There are a million challenges out there that I have yet to meet and overcome.  I want to feel the energy as I stare them down, and the exhilaration as I prove that I can still do anything I set my mind to.

    My mind will always have the accumulated knowledge and experience gained over 50 years, and I can now see how this can be applied to so many new and different things that would not have interested me 25 years ago.  So many things are far more fascinating to me today then they were years ago, when my focus was too narrow and my interests muddled.  Back then, education was something to put up with as I pushed forward to whatever I would ultimately be.  Today, it is like food to a starving man.  Why didn’t I learn so much more when it was all there for me to partake? 

    I’m ready to do it all again, just like everyone else my age.  Not a do-over, as I don’t want to be 21 again, foolish, scared and ignorant, too full of my self-potential to appreciate the joys of youth and how little I understood about the world.  No, I want to do it again knowing everything I know now. 

    It doesn’t matter what the next job will be.  Well, it does, but that just confuses the point.  There are so many things that can be done better, smarter, in a way that will help people and accomplish goals that kids can’t even conceive of, no less do.  I see value in a thousand different avenues of endeavor where others see dead ends.  I see how boxes constrain young minds as they are taught by pinched-lipped teaches “the right way” to do things.  I want to risk failure by testing the edge of the world to see if I fall off, but I have no plan to fail. 

    There is a fire in us that still burns to achieve the things that we’ve left undone.  We aren’t ready to get on that sled and be dragged out into the cold, snowy forest just yet.  I want to get into the ring with some kid, who is no doubt stronger than me, and show that I can accomplish with intelligence and experience what he cannot with brute youth.

    If we all passed the torch one person to the left, and started anew, it would have the most significant impact on humankind ever experienced.  I’m ready to climb the next mountain.

    When Secrecy Was King — The FISA Court

    The  New York Times has an editorial today arguing that President Bush’s attack on the House surveillance bill, the one that “threatens the safety of the nation” by not allowing the President to wiretap at will and, more importantly, won’t give telecoms blanket immunity for jumping as high as the administration says, is wrong.

    Hardly shocking, right?  Well, step back and bit and you may think otherwise. 

    Imagine that there was a law passed in Congress that no one knew about that authorized the government to create a secret court, with secret judges, where only prosecutors could go in order to get eavesdropping warrants signed.  There was no defense lawyer told that this was going to happen, and none allowed to argue against it.  There was no one to challenge the affidavit in support of the warrant as a pack of lies, or stale, or lacking in substance, or simply inadequate to justify the extreme remedy of eavesdropping.  The secret court would decide to grant the warrant in secret, and no one would ever know that it was granted.  There was no way to challenge the warrant afterward, no appeal and no knowledge that any of this ever happened. 

    Can you imagine that happening in America?  It’s crazy.  It’s unAmerican.  It sounds like the Spanish Inquisition meets Godzilla.  It’s the process established by the  Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978, 50 U.S.C.  § 1803.

    The sad truth is that few knew it happened at the time.  As word leaked out about this wild secret court that rubber stamped eavesdropping warrants, people couldn’t believe it.  Something like this could never happen in America.  But it could, and it did.

    For every fan of logical fallacies, you know that the  slippery slope argument is one of the most reckless and overused arguments around.  But it isn’t always wrong.  The problem is that you can only prove its validity in retrospect, and prospective use is tantamount to sheer speculation.

    And so we return to today’s New York Times editorial, which pines for the days when we had a mere star chamber to decide invasions into the privacy of Americans.  This would have been unthinkable in 1978.  Eavesdropping was considered so inherently drastic, so fundamentally wrong, that the idea that the Times would encourage the existence of a court for just that purpose was unthinkable.  A secret court would have been a joke, beyond the pale.

    Thirty years later, the New York Times argues for this secret court.  Not because it has a professed love of secret courts, but because the alternative is the wholesale elimination of any oversight at all.  Back then, the idea of trusting federal judges to issue ex parte warrants would have been the stuff of anti-Utopian novels.  This was Huxley and Orwell after a night of eating tainted enchiladas, coming up with a scenario so far-fetched that no one would believe it possible.

    That said, here’s what the New York Times thinks today:

    He accused House leaders of “putting in place a cumbersome court approval process that would make it harder to collect intelligence on foreign terrorists.” Actually, the bill merely ensures that special judges continue to supervise surveillance of American citizens. The “cumbersome process” is really a court that acts swiftly and has refused only a half-dozen of more than 21,000 wiretap requests in its nearly 30 years of existence.

    Sometimes the slippery slope applies, and now, 30 years later, we see that the Church Committees recommendations led to a day when the notion of any judicial oversight of government intrusion into our privacy is considered too much.  They never saw this coming.

    Some will say that I’m just an old man remembering a simpler time when our country wasn’t threatened with terrorism as it is today.  My anachronistic, simplistic views of freedom and privacy are “quaint”, but grossly unrealistic.  Maybe so.

    But I do know a few things.  About 3000 people died in the WTC attack on 9/11.  About 3300 people (the second leading cause of death of children under age 4) die each year by drowning in a pool.  About 4000 American troops have died thus far fighting “terrorism” in Iraq since 9/11.  About 50,000 people die every year in automobile accidents.  The threat of terrorism is overstated in terms of harm to Americans, and we happily ignore the basic facts when jumping to facile conclusions.

    No one would have believed that we would be discussing the wholesale elimination of oversight of eavesdropping warrants 30 years ago, when we took that first step onto the slippery slope.  Look at us now.