Author Archives: SHG

Where’s My Bailout? (Update)

So the fed is going to bailout Bear Sterns.  After all, we can’t let yet another decidedly for-profit biz suffer the consequences of its subprime portfolio.  What’s good for GM is good for America.

A recurring theme has been the government’s role in saving corporate America from its own poor choices.  While Bush  threatens to veto the Surveillance Bill because it doesn’t absolve the telecoms (which is clearly more important than national security), and over-extended quasi-homeowners get to renegotiate their mortgages because they happily cashed out of their homes to prove that consumerism is cool, there are a few of us who will have to hear  Joe Hill’s words ring in our ears:  There’ll be pie in the sky when you die.

Some people don’t make excuses.  Instead, they make rational choices.  We conduct our lives properly so that we live within our means, pay our bills, save our money and don’t find ourselves facing disaster every time it starts to drizzle outside.  We make intelligent choices.  We, apparently, are fools.

It would seem that living within your means is a good idea.  We live without all the bells and whistles that others absolutely need to have.  We don’t concern ourselves with shiny things.  If we can’t afford something, we just keep walking.

When we buy a house, we put money on the table as a downpayment.  We don’t take out a mortgage we can’t afford to pay.  And we don’t lie on our mortgage applications.

When we run our business, we look carefully at our paperwork to make sure that it’s legitimate.  We don’t tolerate, no less encourage, scams to skim a quick buck off the top and pass the garbage portfolio off to the next sucker, tied up in a pretty ribbon to make it look more attractive.  When we make a business mistake, we eat it.

And what’s our reward for making the hard choices necessary to live a life of personal responsibility?  We get to pay the taxes to bail out those who don’t.  We get to pay the taxes to compensate for the shortfalls of those who can’t because they spent their mortgage money on a new Mercedes.  They are driving around in a Mercedes that I am paying for.  You too.  Does that make you happy?


The news from Bear Stearns came after the bank had insisted for days that its finances were in adequate shape. But its chief executive said the bank’s liquidity had “significantly deteriorated” since Thursday. “We took this important step to restore confidence in us in the marketplace,” the executive, Alan Schwartz, said in a statement.

But there was no confidence, and there should be no confidence.  They have a liquidity crisis for a reason.  Actually 1.9 billion reasons.  And it’s not like it hasn’t been coming for a while.  Nobody wanted to look too closely.  Nobody wanted to believe.  And now the  domino theory rears its ugly head.

What incentive is there for individuals or business to play it straight, tell the truth, act responsibly?  So that you can be the last man standing when it comes time to collect to pay the bailout everyone else?

One guy’s having a great time, living large, and deep in debt.  Another guy lives frugally, pays his bills and saves his money.  Which guy wins?  We really need to rethink personal responsibility.

Update:   JPMorgan to buy Bear Sterns for $2 per share.  It was trading at $100/share, down to $50 last Thursday.  Not a bad deal, I supposed.  Wonder if the bailout comes with the territory?  H/T Volokh

The High Price of Hookers For Judges

While the salacious details of Eliot Spitzer’s hookergate remains a favorite topic for discussion around New York, there’s one group that’s not enjoying any of it very much:  New York’s judges.  As reported by the New York Lawyer,


Citing grim economic news in New York and the rest of the nation, soon-to-be-governor David A. Paterson said yesterday it would be “very difficult” to adopt a pay raise for state court judges this year.

Years of negotiations, promises, and table-banging down the tubes.  As Chief Judge Judy Kaye raised, then lowered, then raised, then  lowered her voice, promising her rank and file judges that she was doing what had to be done and they should trust her, one thing is now painfully clear.  No raise this year.  The price of a good prostitute proved higher than the governor thought.  At least he got what he wanted out of it. 

The economy, the annual New York budget crisis, and the upcoming election year all contribute to the problem, but the old gov had this on his list of things to do.  The new gov has new issues, like establishing an administration and relationship with the legislature that the old one burned.  David Patterson has his hands full. 

So where does this leave judges.  Nowhere.  They just got pushed to the back burner again.


Two lawsuits filed by various judges and supported by some judicial organizations have been filed to force the Legislature and the governor to grant a raise. In addition, Chief Judge Kaye has retained former White House Counsel Bernard W. Nussbaum to prepare a suit she has threatened for nearly a year if the other branches of government do not act.

These were acts of desperation.  The suits by the lower court judges were for real.  They just had enough of the spin out of Albany and decided to do what lawyers do.  But Judge Kaye’s threats?  Posturing.  No one in Albany is shaking in their boots.

After all the angst and anger that judges have been through awaiting the promised breakthrough, it looks like they are back to square one.  Justice  Emily Jane Goodman wrote almost a year ago that without a raise, she anticipates personal bankruptcy.  What will she do now?

Small Courtesy: Just Let Them Know

Warning:  This isn’t a law-related post, so if you’re only in the market for something law-related, read something else.

One of the rules around my house is that my kids must recognize their responsibility toward others through community service.  We do it because we must, an obligation of being a member of society.  There’s no glory attached, and we try to do things anonymously to assure that they learn pure motives.  But this has irked me for a while, and now that a year has gone by, it’s time to let it out.

My son, in anticipation of his bar mitzvah, had to come up with a significant project to demonstrate his membership in the larger society of adults.  He decided to start a food and clothing drive for a local national guard unit, stationed in Iraq, to provide them with the things that would make their time more overseas more livable.  While we were never in favor of the war, we still support the men and women who serve.

The drive was done in the name of his school (so as to minimize any personal aggrandizement), and was enormously successful.  We had dozens of large boxes of candy, writing paper and utensils, socks, all the things that our local VFW told us they need and want.  On top of that, the students wrote cards to the soldiers to let them know how they were appreciated.  Inside each box was a note letting them know that this was from the school.

Everything was shipped off to Iraq to the attention of the commander of the unit, who, we were told, would distribute it amongst his troops.  This happened one year ago.  Enough time has passed.

To this day, no one knows if they boxes ever got there.  There was no response, no reaction, no nothing.  The children and families from school asked in the months following the drive about it, and my son told them that he didn’t know if these soldiers were happy to receive the boxes, enjoyed the contents, appreciated the thought.  He couldn’t tell them because he never heard a word.

We spoke with the local VFW commander to find out if he heard anything.  He told us that he hadn’t heard a word either.  He told us that he didn’t know if the boxes every made it to the intended recipients or fell off the face of the earth.

It’s not that we anticipated a letter back from Iraq thanking the students for thinking of them, for gathering things to make their life more pleasant, to show appreciation.  After all, this was about the students showing their appreciate for the troops, not the other way around.

But would it have been too much trouble to let a bunch of school kids know that the boxes arrived and that their efforts weren’t wasted?

The End of the Line

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, posts (on his newly reformatted blawg) about a difficult time with an otherwise good client.

After waiting 40 minutes for him to turn up and then trying to get him to come to the point for half an hour and then finding half an hour later that the first point wasn’t really the point and then finding out another half hour later that the second point wasn’t really the point either, all the while trying to get a straight answer from him, I stood up, unceremoniously announcing that our meeting was over.

Packed into these few words are some important lessons for newer criminal defense lawyers.  More than important, they are critical.

When someone comes to you, it’s not because you’re good-looking, dance well or know a lot of funny jokes.  It is because they need a lawyer, a professional who is capable of helping them with their case.  They want you to serve them as a professional, though they often have great difficulty in expressing this desire.  It is up to the lawyer to guide them and control them so that they get to the place where you can be the lawyer.

Initially, when the client shows up 40 minutes late for an appointment, you already have a problem.  It demonstrates a lack of respect for your time, and therefore for you.  This needs to be addressed immediately.  Your time is critical to your success as a lawyer.  You can spend it working on your clients’ cases, or you can sit around waiting for people to show up whenever they please.  But the time lost can never be recaptured, and one client suffers while another wastes your time.  It’s unacceptable, and clients need to know that.

Then there’s the story.  There’s a reason why they come to you, even if they are embarrassed at first to tell you.  Even if clients are inclined to tell you the real reason up front, they will preface and spin it in such a way as to guarantee that you here the story their way, meaning with every excuse and argument in their favor they can muster. 

This story is useless to you as the lawyer, but given enough free rein they will take all day convincing you what a great guy they are and how innocent they are.  At the end of the story, you are incapable of rendering useful advice because you still know nothing about the problem, only the excuses for the problem.

Clients often need some catharsis, and I generally give them a few minutes to vent.  Then my efforts are spent focusing them in on the important elements of the problem: “What do the cops say you did?”  Not why you want to explain to me that you didn’t do anything and they can’t prove it anyway.

Many lawyers avoid taking a client to task for wasting time with nonsense as a matter of marketing and public relations.  This is understandable; They pay the fees and it’s generally not in a lawyer’s self-interest to be intolerant of the person paying them.  But they pay legal fees to receive professional services, not a baby-sitter, hand-holder or therapist.  Sure, there’s components of each of these in our work, but we must maintain professional detachment if we are to serve our clients.  The client cannot be left to dictate the means by which we perform our job.  We are the lawyers.  That’s why they come to us.

When we try to appease the client by allowing them to go on ad naseum, we do them a disservice.  We also do ourselves a disservice.  An hour of Mark’s life was wasted for nothing, and he ultimately blew his stack.  No one benefited from this experience.  Mark, being a nice guy, felt badly for losing his cool, but this happens.  What went very wrong was the loss of control of the meeting.  Mark is a very tolerant guy, which no doubt makes him very likable to clients.  To some extent, this is a wonderful attribute.  But only to some extent. 

What cannot be forgotten is that a person came to a lawyer for help, and left without it.  A lawyer gave his time to a person to help, and provided none.  At the end, there were two unhappy people and nothing was accomplished.

Mark is a highly experienced lawyer, and no doubt smelled that the story was wrong after 5 minutes.  He tolerated the client’s talking at length in the hope that at any moment, he would finally get to the point and Mark could provide the help and counsel for which the client came.  It’s always a tough call as to when to shut down a client, seize control of the conversation and direct it toward a more useful subject.  But that’s what the job of being a lawyer demands.  Sometimes it requires us to stop being the nice guy and start being the professional.

Don’t be afraid to be a lawyer.  It’s why clients come to us in the first place.

But It’s the Cops

Gideon at  A Public Defender has put together a number of posts about a website called Rate My Cop, which has so outraged police officers that they have proven, yet again, how even the mighty cower when the cops come a’calling.

The concept isn’t novel of tricky.  Indeed, it’s pretty much the cop version of websites that exist for judges, sex offenders, lawyers, and a host of others.  As explained by Reason Hit and Run :


The premise is simple: [Gino] Sesto wrote to police departments across the country, and obtained a list of the names and badge numbers of their officers. He then posted the names online in a format broken down by state and city, and encouraged users to rate their experiences with individual officers. All of the information he posted was already open to the public. He didn’t post the identities of any undercover officers.


But this time it’s cops.  And that changes everything.


Law enforcement agencies freaked out, saying that making public information available on this website threatened their safety. The site does not post home addresses or information about undercover officers, so that claim seems hollow.

First, they scared Godaddy into pulling the site. Then Rackspace.  These big, tough internet companies shaked and quivered when the cops called and said, “we know who you are.”  They don’t shake when you or I call.  But we’re not cops, now are we?  Isn’t this a bit of a commentary about how much Americans fear the police. 

Even the good, law-abiding folk, the ones who claim that the cops are there friends, aren’t about to take a risk and withstand their ire.  Let’s face the truth:  Americans are scared to death of the cops, and will do anything to avoid angering them and making themselves a target.  In their hearts, people fear the police.  Great!

But as Gid notes, cops only have an issue when it’s some outsider shining the light on them.  There’s no issue with Cops Writing Cops, the website where cops rip each other’s head off for not showing their brother cop “professional courtesy” (read, allowing other cops to break the law as a perk of the job).

For all the freedom that purportedly exists on the internet, it seems that we’ve finally hit the wall.  And the wall is Blue.

Feige Hits the Small Screen

David Feige of  Indefensible has a deal with Steven Bochco, the man who brought us NYPD Blue.  As  revealed by Skelly,


After pouring his heart and soul into a 2006 book about his experiences as a public defender in the Bronx, David Feige knew exactly who he wanted to shepherd the project to the small screen… Feige, a professor at Seton Hall University’s School of Law, wrote (Steven) Bochco an impassioned letter enumerating the reasons he wanted to work with him. It convinced Bochco, and the result is “Raising The Bar,” scheduled for 10 episodes on TNT this fall.

Now I don’t know how David turned the corner from honest lawyer to lawprof, but I know from his former boss, Dan Arshack, that he was doing real indigent defense in the Bronx (the mother load of indigent defense) in the trenches.  With attitude, Dan says.

How cool is this?  Best of luck, David, and keep it real.  Now if we can just get it to network…

Avvo Sues Jersey to Share The Wealth

While  Avvo is fast becoming the mainstream source for lawyer info, its expansion nationwide has hit a stumbling block in my neighbor across the river.  New Jersey, it seems, won’t give up its lawyers.  At least not for free. 

Avvo Inc. petitioned the state Supreme Court on Wednesday to release names and basic information about a lawyers licensed in New Jersey, citing state law and New Jersey’s “strong tradition of public access to government records.”

The Seattle-based company’s requests over the past several months have been rebuffed by the clerk of the Supreme Court, Stephen W. Townsend.

Townsend maintains that the state Open Public Records Act does not apply to the judiciary, and that its records are governed by Supreme Court rules, according to correspondence provided by Avvo.

According to the clerk, New Jersey’s reason for refusing to give up its lawyers is simple: “Generally speaking, bar admission records are confidential,” Townsend wrote Avvo on Dec. 20.

While it’s hard to imagine why the identities of individuals given a monopoly on the practice of law would be subject to confidentiality concerns (as in, is this person really a lawyer, or is that just a pick-up line?), Clerk Townsend’s position seems highly principled, doesn’t it?  Well, maybe not.

According to  Carolyn Elefant at law.com,


Consider this: In 2006, the New Jersey state bar launched a fee-based, online lawyer directory at its Web site.  The directory would allow consumers looking for lawyers to click on a live link directly to the firm’s Web site.  The bar recognized that the fee-based listings would generate revenues for the state bar.  As New Jersey Bar spokesperson Barbara Straczynski explained in this article on Law.com, “if just 100 members sign up for links to their own sites, that’s $10,000 right there.”

Well that puts a different smell on it, something to which lawyers from Jersey are no doubt inured.

Before this starts up the love/hate relationship with Avvo, or the nagging questions over some of Avvo’s  newer initiatives with challenge the edges of ethics and malpractice, New Jersey’s refusal to disclose the identities of its lawyers because it will interfere with the state’s own ability to cash in is an affront to the public. 

If Jersey refused because it had issues with Avvo’s ratings, like the issues it has with Super Lawyers, then it would be a fair question and a responsible position.  But if the only problem is has is cash (hey, it’s not cheap to clean up toxic waste sites, you know), then it’s just plain disingenuous.

Why is it always New Jersey?

The Washington & Lee Experiment

Ken Lammers of  CrimLaw broke the news.  His alma mater, Washington & Lee Law School, is going radical, and he wishes they had done so many years ago when he was cutting his teeth.  This is a big break in chain of law school tradition, worthy of the attention of the  Wall Street Journal blog’s attention.  What’s the shocking news?


Breaking News: Law School to Teach Practice of Law

The Washington and Lee School of Law is poised to turn the world of legal education on its head. The deans are announcing a plan to overhaul its 3L curriculum by replacing all academic classes — that’s right, all academic classes — with “experiential” learning.


Imagine, students coming out of law school capable of . . . being a lawyer.  It’s a whole new world.

As the  law school describes its new program:


Students will not study law from books or sit in classrooms engaging in dialogue with a professor at a podium. The demanding intellectual content of the third year will instead be presented in realistic settings that simulate actual client experiences, requiring students to exercise professional judgment, work in teams, solve problems, counsel clients, negotiate solutions, serve as advocates and counselors—the full complement of professional activity that engages practicing lawyers as they apply legal theory and legal doctrines to the real-world issues of serving clients ethically and honorably within the highest traditions of the profession.

This differs from Ken’s memory of law school, which he describes as “cramming 2 years of education into three years.”  But breaks from tradition will naturally be met with skepticism, if not open ridicule.

Carolyn Elefant describes the reactions over at WSJ:

On the other hand, the commenters at WSJ Law Blog don’t like the program at all. A number of commenters don’t like the compulsory nature of the program, arguing that they should have a choice over the courses they take. Others say that law schools should simply dispense with the third year entirely, and let students acquire training on the job rather than in the classroom. Another commenter hopes that other law schools will follow suit, but fears that in the short run, a skills-based program could harm job-seekers’ prospects, particularly if they choose to work out of state. 

Carolyn isn’t a fan of practical training either.

But my greatest problem with skills training is that there’s simply no one-size-fits-all approach and ultimately, students may have to re-learn much of what was taught. What works for lawyers at a large firm in a metropolitan area might not play in Peoria. And once certain habits are entrenched, students may be reluctant to deviate from them in practice, which can stymie change in the profession.

I think Carolyn’s points probably are the most significant in terms of developing a program that meaningful in terms of breadth and scope, and I can see many problems stemming from the fact that law schools lack a bench of practical instructors to fulfill this newfound mission.

But the criticisms, aside from the one that suggests that job prospects may be stymied by anyone doing anything outside the norm (always a truism in the law), are really more a matter of program development, fine-tuning the details, then of the concept itself. 

It’s to be expected that any law school that tries to buck the system is going to get slammed.  Lawyers are, if nothing else, sticklers for tradition, no matter how poorly it serves the profession.  Stare decisis is our mantra, beloved no matter how bad the decision might be.

But if one views the W&L decision to break away as a throwback to the old days, when aspiring lawyers clerked their way into the profession, perhaps the stodgier mandarins will find it more palatable.  Practical training is new to us, but old to the law. 

I sincerely hope that the folks who have chosen this experiment listen to the critics, forge a program that addresses these concerns, because I sincerely believe that this is a ground-breaking positive change for legal education.  If done right.  And if not, then there is little loss since we all know that the third year of law school is a waste of time anyway.  Go Washington & Lee!

Poor Alan Dershowitz; Where Did He Go?

Harvard lawprof Alan Dershowitz used to be a dynamo.  Sure, a wacky one, but always full of bizarre theories and ready to attack.  He barked and he bit, with that wild ‘fro whirling around his frothy mouth.  Vibrant and relevant, Dershowitz made his bones by being on the cutting edge of attacking the establishment. 

But now he’s gone.  He’s been gone for a while.  And yesterday, this piece in the  Jewish Daily Forward (h/t to Gustitus at The Defense Perspective who, much to my surprise, must be a regular reader of the JDF) proved that poor Alan is still gone.  Not gone as in dead, but gone as in “gone mainstream.”

Beyond his sadness for his former Harvard researcher, young Eliot, which is fair enough though hard to imagine how this same young fellow learned at Dershowitz’s knee, his sadness is for the “waste” of it all.



Throughout our history, men in high places have engaged in low sexual activities. From Thomas Jefferson to Franklin Roosevelt to John Kennedy to Lyndon Johnson to Bill Clinton, great political figures have behaved like adolescent boys in private, while at the same time brilliantly and effectively leading our nation in public.


Our nation, unique among Western democracies, is obsessed with the private lives of public figures. Whether it be Larry Craig soliciting favors in an airport bathroom or Rush Limbaugh getting illegal pharmaceuticals in a parking lot, this obsessive focus on the private imperfections of public figures threatens to drive many good men — and soon, good women — out of public life for fear that they will brought down by their private peccadilloes…

Eliot Spitzer can be charged with hypocrisy for prosecuting prostitution rings while patronizing prostitutes himself. The voters would have had every right to hold his hypocrisy against him had he run for office after completing his term. They could have considered the recklessness of his conduct in evaluating his ability to perform his public functions. But forcing him to resign constitutes an abuse of the political and criminal processes, an abuse that would only be compounded by using vague criminal statutes to prosecute him for federal crimes for which no one is prosecuted.


How sad to see poor Alan so confused.  It’s a duty, a mitzvah, to clear up this sorry mess. 

Eliot, your one-time protégé, was not forced to resign because of his private peccadilloes.  Indeed, he was not forced to resign at all.  Nor did he have an affair, as many historic figures did.  He chose to resign in the face of his own shame for his actions and in the face of criminal charges that may be levied against him as they have against many, many others.  Crimes, Alan, not sex. 

This young woman was not his date, or even his girlfriend.  She was prostitute, which is why he had to come up with a way to finance his expensive appetite that trampled the law.  He smurfed money to hide his payments to a prostitution ring.  That ring was a gang of people engaged in criminal conduct, and he worked with them to find a means to be a enjoy their criminal enterprise.  You can argue that it should not be a crime, but as long as it is a crime, then law-abiding people generally try not to engage in it.  This goes for Governors as well.

If Eliot Spitzer was caught having “an affair,” it probably would have helped his reputation in New York, where he’s not admired for his humanity.  Indeed, few would believe him capable of having an extra-marital affair, mostly because of the unlikelihood of getting a woman to agree to it.  He isn’t the best looking fellow, and was never well-regarded at small talk.  This could explain why he needed to pay for it. 

But to have Mr. Clean committing crimes is not the same thing as Jefferson and Sally Hemings.  Sex may make the crime more salacious to the public, but it would have been no different had he committed the crime for any other purpose.  Are all the money launderers and smurfers in prison tragic? 

It’s nice how, in your later years, you’ve come to have such empathy for high government officials. But when did firebrand Dershowitz start forgiving people who obtained great power from the responsibility that goes along with it?  When did wild-man Dershowitz excuse hypocrisy in the exercise of police power?  The Alan I remember was never an apologist for the powerful.  He was a defender of the downtrodden.  Where did he go?

So no, professor, Spitzer isn’t paying an unfair price for a sexual peccadillo, or for joining an impressive list of men who loved women too well.  He resigned out of shame of his own creation, and should he be prosecuted, as I believe he will, it will be for the commission of crime and nothing more.  That his conduct was hypocritical presents an irony.  If it was criminal, then he suffers a fate solely of his own making.  There’s nothing vague about it.

Tasered Again: Dudley DoRight Is Gone

Via Turley, another happy taser story.  This time, its our brothers from the North who decide that they need to teach a man, suffering from a Parkinsons-like disease, not screw with them.  See, and you thought this was a particularly American thing, didn’t you?

It’s a funny thing when the Royal Canadian Mounted Police are the culprits.  There’s an image, between the word “mounted” in their name and too many years of watching Dudley Doright save the Nell from Snidely Whiplash (a dig against PI lawyers?), when he left her tied to the railroad tracks.  They seemed purer.  Better. They rode horses.

But then, they have tasers.  And just like us, they sometimes need to teach a fella who’s boss.



Welcome to Canada, ay?

And just so you know it’s not just us, consider this too: