Author Archives: SHG

The Worst Time to be a Criminal Defense Lawyer?

Susan Cartier Leibel asks whether this is the worst time to be a lawyer.  One of the responses she received as “not if you work for Biglaw.”  I take it that the response meant that Biglaw, with salaries about to hit $190,000 plus bonus for first year associates, life isn’t that bad.

On the other hand,  Lat posted about how 10 partners were canned at Jenner & Block.  Now, I understand that “partners” at Biglaw aren’t always “partners” as the rest of the world thinks, but these weren’t first year associates.  These were people who thought they had a secure home for the long run who suddenly found out that their services weren’t needed anymore.  What do you tell the guy at the Mercedes dealership?

Susan’s view was that solos never get a pink slip, so Biglaw can’t pull the rug out from under you.  True enough.  She also rails against the entrenched attitude of new lawyers that if you don’t get a Biglaw position, you’re a failure.  This, obviously, depends on how you define failure.  Or how you define lawyer, for that matter, since many would argue that despite the big salary, associates at Biglaw are not exactly lawyers.

For the criminal defense lawyer, this argument is largely irrelevant.  Other than Joel Cohen at Strook, I can’t think of any other real criminal defense lawyers who work in Biglaw. (Hey Joel, I should get a beer for the plug, if you know what I mean.)  There are probably a few others, but I just can’t think of them at the moment.

Unfortunately, that’s not the end of our story.  I’ve lived through a few recessions in my time.  For the most part, criminal defense lawyers were immune from these market forces because crime was immune.  If anything, crime increases when the economy tanks.  People seek “alternate” sources of income.  Some of these sources are not legitimate, if you catch my drift.

This time, however, thing are going to be different.  In the past, there was money on the street in crime even when the legitimate economy dropped like a stone.  Narcotics were largely responsible for this situation, with defendants flush with drug money, still inclined to defend and propping up the criminal defense bar while others were going hungry. 

Times have changed.  The streets of New York are relatively quiet and poor.  We no longer have the groups of enterprising drug dealers who put together lucrative businesses like mini-IBMs, organized and profitable with a vision toward the future.  Sure, there are still drugs on the street, but the sellers lack the organization (and too often the intelligence) of the old timers, and tend to spend every dime they make on some piece of shiny crap.  When time comes to defend themselves, their pockets are empty.  Or at least not full enough to do better than the bottom rung of criminal defense lawyers.

The shift in criminal defense has been coming for a few years in New York.  I’ve written about this before.  But now it’s exacerbated by the economic downturn.  Commuting into New York City has just skyrocketed.  Office rents remains high.  The variable costs of services continue to climb.  The only thing that isn’t going up is the fees paid to lawyers or the number of clients ready, willing and able to retain the services of a criminal defense lawyer. 

When potential clients sheepishly look you in the eye and tell you, “I can’t afford that much,” what do you do?  We’re not in the business of telling clients to go away.  But we have rent to pay, and when the fee that clients are willing to pay won’t cover the rent, there’s a problem. 

“But it’s better to keep revenue coming in than not, isn’t it?”  Yes and no.  If fees are too low, then you have to increase volume to make up the shortfall.  If you increase volume, you decrease quality of representation.  It takes time to do this job right.  Time is the one commodity that doesn’t change.  Stuff more people into the available time and something has to give.  You can make money by taking on more cases at lower fees, but you can’t deliver the same level of representation. 

So is this the worst time to be a criminal defense lawyer?  If its only about money, then maybe not.  Take on all comers for whatever they can afford to pay, and you can still earn a pretty decent living in this business.  If it’s about being delivering the best possible representation, then this isn’t a great time to be a criminal defense lawyer.  Or perhaps a lawyer at all.

Enilightened Self-Interest: It’s Showtime!

I’m  not a fan  of  cameras in the courtroom.  Never had been.  I fought (successfully) cameras when Court TV wanted to televise one of my trials.  Sure, it could have opened up a whole new career for me as TV game show host, but I passed.  It’s that thing about my client coming first that kept clouding my eyes.

But Doc Berman reports that a bill just made it through the Senate Judiciary Committee called the  Sunshine in the Courtroom Act that would allow TV coverage of all federal courts.  Doug is all for it.


Readers will not be surprised to learn that I think it is especially important to see what happens in district courts at sentencings.  Indeed, I think all law professors should lobby hard in favor of this Act in order to have a terrific corpus of teaching materials in the form of courtroom video.  I might even be able to develop a sentencing-only version of YouTube.


You might think that I’m about to tell you why I think Doug is wrong on this, but I’m not.  In fact, I think this is the first substantive argument I’ve heard as to why proceedings should be visually recorded. 

No, not for the purposes of being on TV, or because “sunshine is the best disinfectant,” or because the public should be able to see what really happens to educate them on legal matters.  Those rationalizations don’t hold up to scrutiny, and are all subterfuges for lawyers who want to be TV stars and TV producers who want free content to broadcast so they can sell commercial time.

It’s not the generic act of videotaping proceedings that creates the problem, unless the cameras are overly intrusive or the proceedings turn into football games with TV timeouts.  It’s the collateral influence that has an unnecessary potential to deny a defendant of a fair trial, willing witnesses and a judge willing to make legally correct but socially unpopular decisions.

But then comes my next question:  Is it similarly okay if the recordings are made exclusively for teaching/educational purposes, and not for television fodder?  If so, I think we’re on to something here.

Doug presents a legitimate interest in what transpires in the courtroom.  Being able to use real life as a teaching tool would be a huge advantage to students.  And I can’t blame the lawprofs for lobbying for a means to make their teaching better.  In fact, I applaud the fact that teaching enters into their thoughts at all, given how much they think of themselves as scholars and how little as teachers.  This is enlightened self-interest, one of the great motivators.

Granted, teaching students to be lawyers must be subsidiary to assuring due process.  If not, it’s the tail wagging the dog, since the only purpose of teaching law students is to prepare them to be lawyers, the folks who serve to try the cases that will be recorded for the benefit of law students.  Impair the trials and there will be no need for law students.  But I don’t see that happening as a result of recording proceedings for educational purposes.  It’s an entirely different dynamic in the courtroom, and one that won’t present a significant threat of problems.

Clearly, this compromise won’t satisfy the TV producers, the home-bound trial fan or the show-boat lawyers who will sacrifice their clients for their moment in the sun.  But that’s life.

Have Neo-Cons Put Judges At Risk?

USA Today   contains an article that threats against federal judges and prosecutors are poised to increase for the 5th year in a row.  Even though no one who reads this blawg is a federal judge or prosecutor (right?), this is horrible news.  Not because of any personal risk to criminal defense lawyers, but because threats against anyone involved in the criminal justice system are inherently bad.  We are all part o the same system, like it or not.

But why is this happening?  Sentences haven’t suddenly gotten harsher.  Judges haven’t suddenly gotten meaner.  What gives rise to the open expression of anger or hostility toward judges?

This may well be the natural by-product of years of attacking judges as “activists” and yanking them down off the bench and into the gutter.  By pulling off their robes, judges have been portrayed as failed people, snake-oil salesman like their politician buddies, unworthy of the respect that had long been shown the judiciary. 

The judiciary has survived on one thing, and one thing alone:  respect.  They command no army to keep away the swarming masses of outraged citizens.  While we may agree or disagree with outcome, they have remained safe in the face of controversy because they are judges, a very small class that exists apart from all others in government and the world at large.  As long as we treat the office with respect, the human beings in robes derived the protection afforded the judiciary.

That disappeared when radio personalities who have an affinity for OxyContin started smearing them personally.  As they become the subject of ridicule and name-calling for decisions that displeased the pundits, the protection offered by their office was gradually worn away.  They were now mere people.  And bad, evil people to boot.  Just ask Rush and his ilk.  These were people who were destroying America and American values.  These were people who America would be better off without.

The ball started rolling downhill from there.  And the result was that the idea of harming a federal judge, or a federal prosecutor, became far less far-fetched, and then ultimately quite reasonable to those with very sick minds.  I remember as I would listen to these neo-con talking heads in the car, marveling at how they twist factual penumbras to suit their ends, that their denigration of judges would have dire results.  I think these results are shown in these threats against judges and prosecutors.

Is this what the neo-cons hoped to achieve by demeaning members of the judiciary for their evil decisions and “activist” proclivities?  Are they proud of themselves?

5 Myths; Truth or Fiction?

An email came in this morning from Andrew Bluestone of  New York Attorney Malpractice Blog about an “interesting” blog post of the “Five Myths About Defending Accused Drunk Drivers.”  It was just posted on a DUI/DWI lawyer’s pseudo-blog (I say that because it was facially self-promotional and not substantive, even though he called it a blog).

It was interesting indeed, so I tracked it back to its source, which I believe to be a California lawyer, William Head, though he notes that it was reprinted from Trial (March, 1993), the magazine of ATLA.  Yes, an odd place for this piece to be published, unless you consider that it’s a great marketing tool for its author who seeks referral from personal injury lawyers.

The lead lines of the 5 myths are:



  • Myth Number 1: Most people accused of this crime are guilty.

  • Myth Number 2: Drunk driving is a minor offense.

  • Myth Number 3: Any attorney can defend an accused drunk driver.

  • Myth Number 4: These cases can’t be won.

  • Myth Number 5: Drunk-driving cases are just like any other criminal case.

The obvious purpose of this essay was to promote the use of specialists in DWI over generalists or even criminal defense lawyers who did not specialize in drunk driving cases.  It further sought to argue that it was worthwhile to hire a specialist rather than just give up or give in.


While my initial inclination toward promotional posts tends to be negative, there is a lot here that is worthy of recognition, though it extends beyond its limited purview of drunk driving defense.  Even “Myths 3 and 5,” while discussed specifically as to drunk driving, can be extended to a variety of other types of criminal cases.

We may quibble with some of the language and assertions.  There are a few lines in there that I don’t agree with, and find either misleading or just too facile and self-serving to accept, but on the whole, this is a very good piece.

  One critical myth, worthy of everyone’s attention, is Myth 4, that these cases can’t be won.  This has become a general sense about all criminal cases, and is often the cause of defendants deciding that retaining counsel is a waste of money and that a plea of guilty or cooperation is their only hope.  This belief has become pervasive, and is possibly the most damaging belief to the Constitution. 

By the wholesale refusal to fight, and to challenge wrongful arrests or constitutional violations, we provide an incentive to government and law enforcement to ignore the Constitution and to further curtail our freedom.  But we can’t defend people who have decided that there is no way to win and no reason to retain counsel.  We are here.  We are ready.  Now it’s up to defendants to decide whether to fight or lay down and die.

For criminal defense lawyers, you may want to take a closer read of the 5 Myths and adopt them to your practice. 

Doninger: Student Speech Gets a Second Chance

Last September, I  posted about the pathetic decision in the Avery Doninger case, where a United States District Judge in Connecticut who held that “douchebag”, posted about school officials by a student on her website, was sufficiently “vulgar” that it warranted the student being denied the right to run for student government office.

Judge Mark Kravitz, sitting high on the bench in fine black robes, then executed the duties of his office in exemplary fashion.


The court blithely deferred to the school administration, holding that who was he, a federal judge, to pass on the question of the propriety of punishment imposed upon an American by a government official.  Didn’t anyone ever give him the judge handbook?  If not a federal judge, then who?

The decision is here.  Yes, the irony of a punishment for the exercise of speech being the inability to seek election to a position in government (you know, working from within the system as opposed to, say, anarchy) has not gone unnoticed.

The case was argued before the Second Circuit this week.  According to the Hartford Courant, Avery’s lawyer, Jon L. Schoenhorn, argued


that the Internet should not give schools more cause to regulate off-campus speech. “It’s just a bigger soapbox,” he said

At the polar extreme, the School District’s lawyer, Thomas R. Gerarde, countered:


the Internet has fundamentally changed students’ ability to communicate, allowing them to reach hundreds of people at a time. If a student leader makes offensive comments about the school on the Internet, the school should have the right to act.

 “We shouldn’t be required to just swallow it,” he said.

While I don’t appreciate the “swallow it” image, I find more offensive the notion that schools, teaching all about the greater glory of American history year after year, have an overarching lesson plan that teaches students that if they are critical of petty governmental tyrants, they will get beaten to a pulp.  Which one is the real America?

Is the problem so simple that schools are administered by frightened grocery clerks, incapable of reasoning their way through disagreements with students?  When their final answer is, “because I said so,” they demand that the law either prohibit students from smart-mouthing back or allow them to punish, without oversight or constraint, the student for her insolence?

The Circuit panel offered some interesting words from the bench:


Gerarde said speech off campus can affect the school. But Judge Sonia Sotomayor challenged his argument, noting that “Pedagogical rights can’t supersede the rights of students off campus to have First Amendment rights.”

“If students are free to say offensive things about administrators on their home computers, chaos will rule,” Judge Loretta Preska told Schoenhorn.

Chaos?  That nasty offshoot of the free flow of ideas that will confuse and baffle young minds?  That seems a bit strong. 

But the district’s lawyer nailed down his position with this statement:


Gerarde posed another situation: What if a class president drove a mile off campus and e-mailed vulgar comments about the principal to hundreds of students? Should the student be able to say he’s off campus and the school can’t do anything about it? “That’s wrong,” Gerarde said.

Sticks and stones, baby.  The bottom line is that the school can’t imagine a world where they aren’t in ultimate control of their students, their words, bodies and thoughts.  It would be just horrible, if you’re a grocery clerk.


Nino Scalia: Pinup Babe

Hey, I didn’t say so.  Scalia did.  In this Kansas City Star, Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia (the second most senior Justice, by the way) reiterates his “living Constitution is crap” argument.



The Constitution is not a living organism,” Scalia said. “It’s a legal document that says some things and doesn’t say others.”


He drew applause when he acknowledged to the crowd that he was a social conservative but then took pains to describe how his method of constitutional interpretation can sometimes lead him to decisions opposite from his political convictions.


“I ought to be the pinup of the criminal defense bar because I’ve written opinions to defend the rights of the accused,” Scalia said.


I agree.  I’m just waiting for the poster of him in a swimsuit.

I continually find it ironic that Scalia, as much as his speeches and views tend to make him appear helplessly dogmatic in his approach, does somehow manage to pen decisions like Crawford that are both earth-shattering from a legal perspective and definitively helpful from the defense point of view.

But his basic argument, that the Constitution is just a “piece of paper” and not a living document, remains misguided in my opinion.  When written, our founding fathers knew and understood that times would change, innovations would happen and this piece of paper they’ve approved would have to apply to changes that could not possibly be imagined in 1789.  I refuse to accept that they were so foolish and parochial as to believe that they had covered everything to the letter at the time, and that nothing new under the sun would happen that would require our Constitution to provide a “spirit”, a principled approach, to guide courts in the future.

There are flaws, however, in how my living Constitution approach has born out.  It provides a bit too much flexibility to those inclined to use rhetorical tricks and bad logic to undermine the principles embodied in the words.  It’s happened too often over the centuries that exceptions upon exceptions have swallowed the rule of law whole. 

Among the issues where this smacks me in the fact, foremost is the 4th Amendment.  As I argue to courts “the Rule,” that no unreasonable searches and seizures “technicality”, I realize that the mindset is so frozen by pigeonholing cases into exceptions, like the automobile exception, that it’s nearly impossible to get the court to consider why one is a rule and the other an exception, and why the exception exists at all. 

Even with Crawford, prohibiting admission of hearsay “testimonial” statements under the 3,256 hearsay exceptions developed to ensure that no damning hearsay statement go unadmitted, every judge below SCOTUS has been busily thinking how they can get around the decision and get back to business as usual.

I hate it as much as the next criminal defense lawyer that Justice Scalia has become the babe of our bar.  But sadly, he’s right.  He has become the most reliable proponent of hard adherence to basic rules that were designed to protect the rights of defendants.

But then, he’s still got that Jack Bauer,  torture hangup that makes him a hard man to love. 

When He Says “Jump”, You Ask “How High?”

The Appellate Division, First Department, dealt with another Empire State Building jumper case.  Why?  Because they don’t have any Empire State Buildings anywhere else.

In People v. Corliss, the panel upheld the dismissal of first degree reckless endangerment, but reversed the dismissal of the second degree offense.  The decision itself was relatively uneventful, and not worth more discussion than can be found in the NYLJ article.

But these are the sorts of cases that just don’t happen everywhere.  It’s not that there aren’t tall enough buildings around the world.  There are plenty, and many taller than the Empire State Building.  The World Trader Center had its problems with stuff like this as well, whether wannabe-spideys climbing up or jumping down.  But it’s not there anymore.

The genius in this case was Jeb Corliss.


Mr. Corliss, a 31-year-old professional BASE (building, antenna, span, earth) jumper and former host of Discovery Channel’s “Stunt Junkies,” wore a prosthetic fat suit and mask to evade recognition as he
entered the observation deck on the landmark’s 86th floor.

After displaying a jump suit and parachute underneath the disguise, Mr. Corliss climbed a security Mr. Corliss, a 31-year-old professional BASE (building, antenna, span, earth) jumper and former host of Discovery Channel’s “Stunt Junkies,” wore a prosthetic fat suit and mask to evade recognition as he entered the observation deck on the landmark’s 86th floor.


 
Jeb Corliss:  “Don’t you trust me?”

After displaying a jump suit and parachute underneath the disguise, Mr. Corliss climbed a security fence and donned a helmet equipped with a camera to record the leap.

But before he could jump, security guards intervened and handcuffed Mr. Corliss to the fence. The guards subsequently cut Mr. Corliss free from his parachute, after he explained that his arms could be ripped from his body if the parachute inadvertently opened while he was bound to the fence.

I didn’t even know there was such a thing as a “professional BASE jumper.”  What is the test one takes to join this profession?  What is the professional code of conduct?  Who pays them to do it?

There must be something about jumping off the Empire State Building in Midtown Manhattan that makes unstable people positively insane.  The potential for harm to others is manifest, yet they don’t care.  They adamantly argue that they know how to do it, that it will be safe, that there is no risk to anyone else.  What a load of crap.  Afterward, do they say, “oops, Sorry.” 

Some readers will no doubt think that I am just terminably uncool because I don’t think that this fellows 30 seconds of thrill is worth the potential harm to innocent folks walking around below.  Of course, those people probably think “Jackass, The Movie” should have won an Oscar.

For those of you who are wondering, “Say, where can we get those really cool sunglasses?”  I assume they are readily available if you select the right package of Cracker Jacks.

In Tough Times, Should Government Have a Free Hand?

A new book by Eric Posner and Adrian Vermeule (both of whom are charter members of the Jack Bauer Fan Club), called Terror in the Balance, offers a disturbing argument:  When confronted with a threat to national security, the government should have the power to simply suspend civil liberties.  The corollary is that lawyers, because we tend to get in the way of such things, should be muzzled, shut down and perhaps locked away if we become too much of a nuisance.

According to a post by Tommy Crocker at PrawfsBlawg, the point of the book is to


‘to restrain other lawyers and their philosophical allies from shackling the government’s response to emergencies with intrusive judicial review and amorphous worries about the second-order effects of sensible first-order policies. We hope merely to clear the ground for government to react to emergencies . . . . [I]n any case nothing in the lawyer’s expertise supplies the necessary tools for improving on the government’s choices.”

In non-lawprof lingo, shut us up since we’re do nothing to help.  Tommy doesn’t think too highly of this proposition:


Although we might expect that important topics, such as whether we want executive officials to have unfettered license to engage in torture, would require widespread public discussion, Posner and Vermeule rely on their notion of expertise instead. Moreover, although we might think that the biggest threats come either from outside (terrorists), or from institutional failures (tyranny), we learn from them that in fact the biggest threat comes from ourselves (or “civil libertarians” as “we” are called – that is, non-experts in national security policy who are concerned about constitutional principles).

See, I told you we were a nuisance.

Frankly, the notion of Terror in the Balance that arguing about rights at a time of real threat may well be offensive, but isn’t quite crazy.  There may well be times when immediate action is necessary to serve a greater good (hat tip to Justice Scalia, sorta).  The problem, however, is painfully clear to me, and has been proven over and over.

What constitutes a “real threat” and who’s to decide is a pragmatic problem that can’t be divorced from the theoretical.  Was invading Iraq necessary because of a real threat?  Congress agreed it was.  It was wrong.  Oops.  Can we trust our President to make the decision of when to suspend our rights?  I’m more than a little reluctant to do so.  Maybe the next president?  I’m not prepared to agree to that either, and even if the next one was cool, what about the one after that?

I get the idea of a real threat, Justice Scalia’s nuclear bomb over Los Angeles scenario, wherever he got that nutty idea from.  I don’t disagree with the idea that if the choice is a court order or the annihilation of half of mankind, I’m in favor of survival as much as the next guy.

I just don’t trust our government to do it.  Perhaps others place a higher value on their security than on their liberty.  Perhaps the sky is falling every time they tell us the sky is falling.  And no, I don’t see the civil libertarian as the primary threat to the continued existence of the United States or mankind, and I consider it pure fear-mongering to contend that we would all be safer and better off if we just got rid of all those civil-libertarian lawyers who keep gumming up the important work of government.

When Plea Bargains Go South

An interesting article in the  New York Law Journal about two judges, two case, where deals were made, but things went awry.  What makes this curious is that the two judges involved, Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Albert Tomei and Nassau County County Court Judge John Kase went in opposite directions, showing the pitfalls of plea deals that go wrong.

First, the common.  Plea deals were negotiated and both judges approved of the deals, including the sentence to be imposed.  While this is not the practice in other parts of New York, and other parts of the country, this is the way pleas are typically handled in New York City and the neighboring ‘burbs.  Absolutely normal stuff.

In Judge Tomei’s case, the Kings County District Attorney caught heat for the deal it cut on an 18 to 54 year sentence for an ex-dentist.  The victims, after getting wind of the deal, were outraged and the DA collapsed under the pressure.  By the way, if 18 to 54 sounds pretty heavy, note that the ex-dentist was convicted for illegally harvesting and selling body parts from more than 1000 corpses.  It’s not like he stole a gold filling.

In the case before Judge Kase, the court reneged on a 1 to 3 year deal for an ex-lawyer who stole $376,000 from clients.  After hearing the victim impact statement, the judge couldn’t go through with it.

In the Brooklyn case, Judge Tomei enforced the deal, refusing to let the District Attorney change its mind and holding them to the “contract” that was made and performed. 

The Nassau case had the opposite outcome, as the court always retains the authority, should information come into his possession that changes his view of the propriety of the deal, to withdraw his approval, let the defendant withdraw his plea, and start over as if the deal never happened.

From a practical perspective, both present some problems.  First, everyone, but most particularly the defendant, relies upon the deal.  The defendant pleads guilty.  The defendant allocutes, admitting his legal and factual guilt.  The defendant makes whatever arrangements are necessary to comply with his end of the agreement.  The plea may require the defendant to give away confidential information, or take other actions, that inure to his detriment.  To then have the rug pulled out from under him is a problem.

To allow the District Attorney to walk away from a deal because he changed his mind, regardless of the how or why, is wrong.  Whatever it is that impacts the district attorney afterward could have been determined in advance.  In this instance, the fault for not getting feedback from victims before negotiating a deal rests entirely on the District Attorney’s shoulders.  There is no reason to shift the burden onto the defendant.

But the same it true for the court.  The judge could have withheld his approval of the plea until he considered all factors, but instead he moved forward.  Contracts are formed in two ways, affirmative consideration and detrimental reliance.  The defendant most certainly relied to his detriment, and he can never be truly restored to the status quo ante.

But the countervailing legal consideration is that the judge owes a larger duty to the community to do justice, even if that means burning the defendant’s deal when it would appear to the judge that his approval was ill-advised.  It’s a tough call, and I have to assume that Judge Kase did not make the decision to reneg lightly.  But the resultant harm to the defendant happens nonetheless.

Be warned when you cut a deal that may seem too good to be true.  While the DA may not have the ability to stop the plea bargaining train, the judge always does.  To the defendant, it doesn’t matter who puts on the brakes.

Geragos Finally Wins One!

Remember when  Mark Geragos represented Michael Jackson?  That was before he found good lawyers and won his case.  He came up such great  media lines as “He’s not a freak.”  We haven’t heard much from Geragos since then, which is itself a blessing.  But he’s back!

During the brief period of his representation of the non-freak Jackson, you may recall that Geragos and an associate were videotaped while flying in a private plane by the owner.  An interesting way to find new revenue streams for jet owners, perhaps?  Well, not the best choice.

From  the AP,


According to court papers obtained Monday, Superior Court Judge Soussan G. Bruguera ordered XtraJet owner Jeffrey Borer and his company to pay Geragos at least $10 million and possibly up to $18 million in compensatory and punitive damages. Geragos’ colleague Pat Harris was awarded between $1.25 million and $2.25 million in damages.

Not bad, considering that it was Jackson’s confidences that suffered.  According to the story, Geragos “was pleased.”  I bet he was.  It’s the first money he’s due, that I can recall, where someone else didn’t have to go to jail afterward.


“This is an important day for lawyers who generally represent celebrities and high profile people,” he said.

Heck, it’s an important day for Geragos too. 

Why am I so harsh on poor Mark?  Because there’s this bone in my head that starts to throb when lawyers mistake themselves for celebrities.  We don’t sing.  We don’t dance.  Sometimes, we can’t even tell a decent joke.  We’re just lawyers, hired to practice our profession on behalf of someone else, who may or may not be talented. 

Geragos has long sought the spotlight, most notably by his pontifications on the Larry King show.  He’s never shown himself to be much of a lawyer, and has demonstrated some remarkable failings (just as Winona Ryder).  There are some great lawyers on the left coast, most of whom represent celebrities from time to time, but unlike Geragos do so with dignity and without the overdose of self-promotion.  Even now, he just can’t help himself.  He has to pump his profile.

But he’s getting at least $10 million for the violation of his privacy.  Not a bad pay day.