Harvard constitutional legend Laurence Tribe has finally spoken out on D.C. v. Heller in a Wall Street Journal op-ed. This had to be hard for him, as he’s clearly conflicted on his support of gun control and his johnny-come-lately belief that the 2d Amendment gives a personal right to keep and bear arms.
So what does a Solomonic lawprof do when faced with such a dilemma? Split the baby, of course.
But nothing I have discovered or written supports an absolute right to possess the weapons of one’s choice. The lower court’s decision in this case — the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals found the District’s ban on concealable handguns in a densely populated area to be unconstitutional — went overboard. Under any plausible standard of review, a legislature’s choice to limit the citizenry to rifles, shotguns and other weapons less likely to augment urban violence need not, and should not, be viewed as an unconstitutional abridgment of the right of the people to keep or bear arms.
So we have a right to counsel, but no right to select one of our choosing if we can afford one? We have a right to free speech, but no right to use adjectives? We have a right to keep and bear arms, but only the weapons approved by the government and only in the places the government allows?
The logic gets strained even further as Larry (the lawprofs call him Larry. Even though I don’t know him, I’m going to call him Larry too to make it look like we’re old friends) goes on.
Worse than that, it would transform a constitutional provision clearly intended and designed to protect the people of the several states from an all-powerful national government into a restriction on the national government’s uniquely powerful role as governor of the nation’s capital, over which Congress, acting through municipal authorities of the District, exercises the same kind of plenary authority that it exercises over Fort Knox.
So the Constitution, the one that applies in the rest of the United States, shouldn’t apply in the same way to Washington, D.C., because of the control the government exerts over a military installation? Did he pick Fort Knox because it was a base or because of the gold? Maybe there’s gold hidden under the streets of Washington that needs to be protected? Or maybe the gold is used metaphorically, referring instead to the lucre in lobbyists pockets.
There is simply no rhyme or reason connected with Larry’s position. When you’re a legend, are you absolved from the need to express a rationale for your opinions?
But there’s a back story to Larry Tribe’s involvement. According to David Kopel.
Harvard Law School Professor Larry Tribe was contacted, and asked if he would like to write an amicus brief in support of Heller. Tribe wrote back to Heller’s attorneys that he did not want to do an amicus brief, but he would be interested in exploring his playing a “more central role” in the case.
Even legends have to earn a living. It looks like Larry wanted the gig as one of Heller’s attorney, ready to argue the individual rights position to the Supremes on behalf of Heller. Now, he eschews that position (after not getting the gig) and argues in the WSJ for the only unprincipled position available.
No doubt, someone will seize upon the fact that “Larry said so” to support the position that there is a 2d Amendment individual right to keep and bear arms, but the right isn’t “absolute”, as in it is subject to whatever restriction or limitation they think should be imposed. The problem is that it flies in the face of reason. If there is a fundamental right, then it has to be treated the same as any other fundamental right. Otherwise, it is merely a meaningless label, and reduces all “fundamental rights” to meaningless labels subject to government regulation.
Perhaps Larry is just staking out the middle ground, since the reasoned positions have long since been claimed by others and he wouldn’t get any credit with a “me too” position at this stage. But if Larry Tribe can’t come up with any viable rationale to support the “right but regulatable” position, then it’s likely that we haven’t missed anything and there is just no logical support for this result.
