Author Archives: SHG

So What Does Tribe Think of Heller?

Harvard constitutional legend Laurence Tribe has finally spoken out on D.C. v. Heller in a Wall Street Journal op-ed.  This had to be hard for him, as he’s clearly conflicted on his support of gun control and his johnny-come-lately belief that the 2d Amendment gives a personal right to keep and bear arms.

So what does a Solomonic lawprof do when faced with such a dilemma?  Split the baby, of course.

But nothing I have discovered or written supports an absolute right to possess the weapons of one’s choice. The lower court’s decision in this case — the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals found the District’s ban on concealable handguns in a densely populated area to be unconstitutional — went overboard. Under any plausible standard of review, a legislature’s choice to limit the citizenry to rifles, shotguns and other weapons less likely to augment urban violence need not, and should not, be viewed as an unconstitutional abridgment of the right of the people to keep or bear arms.

So we have a right to counsel, but no right to select one of our choosing if we can afford one?  We have a right to free speech, but no right to use adjectives?  We have a right to keep and bear arms, but only the weapons approved by the government and only in the places the government allows?

The logic gets strained even further as Larry (the lawprofs call him Larry. Even though I don’t know him, I’m going to call him Larry too to make it look like we’re old friends) goes on.

Worse than that, it would transform a constitutional provision clearly intended and designed to protect the people of the several states from an all-powerful national government into a restriction on the national government’s uniquely powerful role as governor of the nation’s capital, over which Congress, acting through municipal authorities of the District, exercises the same kind of plenary authority that it exercises over Fort Knox.

So the Constitution, the one that applies in the rest of the United States, shouldn’t apply in the same way to Washington, D.C., because of the control the government exerts over a military installation?  Did he pick Fort Knox because it was a base or because of the gold?  Maybe there’s gold hidden under the streets of Washington that needs to be protected?  Or maybe the gold is used metaphorically, referring instead to the lucre in lobbyists pockets.

There is simply no rhyme or reason connected with Larry’s position.  When you’re a legend, are you absolved from the need to express a rationale for your opinions?

But there’s a back story to Larry Tribe’s involvement.  According to David Kopel.

Harvard Law School Professor Larry Tribe was contacted, and asked if he would like to write an amicus brief in support of Heller. Tribe wrote back to Heller’s attorneys that he did not want to do an amicus brief, but he would be interested in exploring his playing a “more central role” in the case.

Even legends have to earn a living.  It looks like Larry wanted the gig as one of Heller’s attorney, ready to argue the individual rights position to the Supremes on behalf of Heller.  Now, he eschews that position (after not getting the gig) and argues in the WSJ for the only unprincipled position available.

No doubt, someone will seize upon the fact that “Larry said so” to support the position that there is a 2d Amendment individual right to keep and bear arms, but the right isn’t “absolute”, as in it is subject to whatever restriction or limitation they think should be imposed.  The problem is that it flies in the face of reason.  If there is a fundamental right, then it has to be treated the same as any other fundamental right.  Otherwise, it is merely a meaningless label, and reduces all “fundamental rights” to meaningless labels subject to government regulation.

Perhaps Larry is just staking out the middle ground, since the reasoned positions have long since been claimed by others and he wouldn’t get any credit with a “me too” position at this stage.  But if Larry Tribe can’t come up with any viable rationale to support the “right but regulatable” position, then it’s likely that we haven’t missed anything and there is just no logical support for this result.

Lawyer’s Labors Result in Indictment

Nurses have long been in short supply, which is why high volume users, like hospitals and nursing homes, have solicited nurses from the Philippines to come to America, the land of opportunity, and care for our sick.  Inducements were offered.  Promises made.  Sometimes, promises didn’t pan out as well as expected.

That was the case with the Filipino nurses recruited by Sentosa Care.  So they hired a lawyer, Felix Q. Vinluan, to represent them in their labor dispute.  Things didn’t turn out too well for the lawyer either.

In her Legal Currents column, published in The Daily Record, Nicole Black of Sui Generis, posts about Vinluan’s misbegotten representation of nurses, where he “advised” them to leave their employment at a nursing home. 

A consequence of their exodus is that certain patients, including some on ventilators, were left behind.  While no harm befell anyone, and the home found replacements quickly enough, Vinluan found himself in a new role.  Rather than labor lawyer, he was now a criminal law “ham sandwich,” meaning that he was indicted for his efforts.


“The grand jury … charges that … Felix Vinluan, with the intent that the defendant nurses engage in conduct constituting the crimes of Endangering the Welfare of a Child … requested and otherwise attempted to cause the nurses to resign immediately from Avalon Gardens.” — PARAGRAPH 18 OF THE GRAND JURY INDICTMENT INP EOPLE V. VINLUAN, I-769A-K-07

What, you may be wondering, was the alleged crime? Surprisingly, it appears Vinluan was indicted for advising the nurses, his clients, of their legal rights under an employment contract purportedly breached by the employer.

Of course, that’s not how Suffolk County District Attorney Leonard Lato [the same ADA as in the Marty Tankleff case] framed the issue. Rather, he claimed Vinluan actively participated in “soliciting” a group of nurses to, simultaneously and without advance notice, quit their jobs at a nursing home that housed a number of ventilator- dependent children and adults.

It seems rather ironic that Vinluan, who used the nursing home’s mission as a wedge to give his clients clout in their mass resignation ended up being indicted, certainly showing the District Attorney’s clout to chill lawyers inclined to similarly advise their clients. 

Was this stunt ill-advised?  Of course.  The nurses were contract employees, not at will, and had a professional duty that precluded their using patients as a weapon in a labor dispute.  But was the lawyer’s conduct criminal?  That’s a very different question.

There’s nothing to show that he affirmatively caused the nurses to walk out, as opposed to advising them on his belief that it was lawful for them to do so.  Mind you, the nurses, at the time, believed that the nursing home had already breached its contract to them, thus releasing them from obligation to their employer.

As Niki says this was just a ham sandwich job.  Vinluan committed no crime by advising his clients.  No patient was harmed.  Could they have been?  Possibly, but Vinluan’s representation was due the nurses, not the patients, and he never intended that any harm come to the patients.

But what of advising the nurses that it was lawful to leave their patients alone, without needed care, without incorporating into that advice the limitations of professional responsibility due the patients.  Is it necessary that a patient die before responsibility attaches?  Can the lawyer absolve himself from his advice simply because he viewed his services as part of a contract dispute, closing his eyes to the lives of patients who would be impacted by his advice?

When there are transcending duties that impact on the lives of others, it’s hard to analyze a situation like this by looking only at the attorneys very narrow focus.  Had it not been nurses, with patients dependent on their care, there would be no issue.  But they were nurses.  And the patients needed their care.  The fact that no one (fortunately) was harmed doesn’t change the recklessness of the conduct, if it was reckless at all.

I truly hate to add to the woes of a lawyer trying to best serve his client, even if his fault was myopia, but I think there may be greater validity to this prosecution than just another ham sandwich indictment.  Lawyers dealing with potentially life-threatening clients and situations need to look a little further than the end of their retainer check.  I have no idea whether Vinluan should be indicted and prosecuted, because there are many salient facts that remain unclear.  But I similarly can’t say that his conduct was outside the pale of criminal prosecution.  At least not yet.

Lawfully Forcing a 13 Year Old Girl

This twisted story comes via Windypundit by way of Hit and Run.  Conduct that would not only be viewed as criminal, but would be of such grave moral culpability that it will likely cause its perpetrator to spend many extra years in prison, and have his name put on a national registry to be treated as a hated pariah for the rest of his life, suddenly becomes okey-dokey with one tiny, itty-bitty, change in the fact pattern.  The person doing is a school principal.

Here are the facts, as relayed by the source from an  ACLU brief submitted to the 9th Circuit (which never gets anything wrong, by the way).



Savana Redding, an eighth grade honor roll student at Safford Middle School in Tucson, Arizona, was pulled from class on October 8, 2003 by the school’s vice principal, Kerry Wilson.  Earlier that day, Wilson had discovered [drugs] in the possession of Redding’s classmate….Under questioning and faced with punishment, the classmate claimed that Redding, who had no history of disciplinary problems or substance abuse, had given her the [drugs].


After escorting Redding to his office, Wilson presented Redding with the [drugs] and informed her of her classmate’s accusations. Redding said she had never seen the [drugs] before and agreed to a search of her possessions, wanting to prove she had nothing to hide. Joined by a female school administrative assistant, Wilson searched Redding’s backpack and found nothing. Instructed by Wilson, the administrative assistant then took Redding to the school nurse’s office in order to perform a strip search. 


In the school nurse’s office, Redding was ordered to strip to her underwear. She was then commanded to pull her bra out and to the side, exposing her breasts, and to pull her underwear out at the crotch, exposing her pelvic area. The strip search failed to uncover any [drugs].


“I was embarrassed and scared, but felt I would be in more trouble if I did not do what they asked,” said Redding in a sworn affidavit following the incident.  “The strip search was the most humiliating experience I have ever had.”


But there’s one little detail to make this story even better:

The punchline: The drugs in question were ibuoprofen pills—prescription-strength, 400-milligram pills (equivalent to a couple over-the-counter Advil caplets).

Now some might say that this reflects the unfortunate reality in which school administrators find themselves, trying hard to eliminate drugs from schools and being faced with “zero tolerance” policies that demand action, even though it seems harsh under particular circumstances.

To that, I say baloney.  I don’t care how much grocery clerks love their checklists.  You don’t do this to a 13 year old.  This is akin to the Nuremberg defense.  There must be a point at which any senscient being says to themselves, “this is crazy.” 

To the extent that anyone dismisses the impact of being forced to strip in front of someone, I have no doubt that this is traumatic to someone at that age.  I have a 13 year old son who would sooner punch me in the nose than let me see him naked.  They are very fragile at that age, as puberty takes its toll.  Wouldn’t you think an educator, or all people, would be acutely aware of this?

This is incredibly stupid, and even more-so sick.  Mind you, under any circumstances that didn’t involve the federal courts’ overwhelming deference to public schools authority, somebody would go to prison over this conduct.  How then can it be fine when done by a trusted educator?

Why Definitions Matter: Politics versus Ideology

While I really hate to resurrect old debates, and I really hate to see them come back on some other blawg where a straw man argument is raised that it’s intended to make a point that can’t be made against the real argument, some discussions keep bringing new issues into the mix that themselves are worthy of further discussion.

And so it happens. A little background first for anyone who is so foolish as to not read every post and every comment on Simple Justice.  You may recall that  I questioned Doc Berman’s support for a Kentucky law that sought to promote asset forfeiture. Doug took issue with my position, and then  announced his belief that the blame falls on liberals, who refuse to consider imaginative alternatives to incarceration.  On his own blog, Doug tried to disconnect himself from his own rant by  disavowing the use of “political labels,” not an easy thing to do following a condemnation based entirely on political labels.

Off to the side, Bennett picked up on this anomaly in Doug’s position as well and posted about it.  Doug went over there to  call my post “silly over-reaction,” notwithstanding his feeling compelled to provide an “extended response” to my silly over-reaction.  Does that make his post a “silly extended response?”  I’ll leave syllogisms to others.

But in the comments to Doug’s “extended response,” as well as my “silly over-reaction,” the same thing happened, and this is the point of this post.

Doug’s rant lashed out at liberals and praised conservatives.  Yet, the discussions were about Democrats and Republicans.  This was the point of Bennett’s post, addressing the obvious confusion in definition.  Indeed, over at Doug’s post, no one, including Doug, even made the effort to correct this glaring misdirection.  Here, the confusion was by another blogger for whom I have the utmost respect, but who adamantly refused to see that we were not talking about the same thing.

One of the problems that invariably arises when you engage in discussions like these is that people superimpose their own personal definitions (or project their own idiosyncratic views), making it impossible to talk apples to apples.  Without agreed-upon definitions, we can never be sure that we are talking about the same thing.  And when it becomes obvious that one side is confusing the definitions, as with discussing Democrats but calling them liberals, they tend to insist, strongly, that they aren’t confusing the two because they don’t believe there is any confusion.  To them, the two are the same, and you’re the idiot because you separate the ideology from the politics.

I neither sought, nor anticipated, that my initial challenge to the notion of asset forfeiture (a specific remedy that I believe to be particularly bad) would generate a diatribe against “liberals”.  But after having considered the comments, both by Doug and those who commented on his blog without Doug’s intervention, and Scott Henson here, it dawned on me that it is quite likely that we were never talking about the same thing.  I would have thought that a lawprof would distinguish a term relating to ideology from a political party, but I belief that not to be true now.

If the entire debate was about Democrats versus Republicans, it would have been a very different discussion, at least on my side.  I agree with most of the commenters to Doug’s post that there is little to distinguish between the two.  I would still take issue with the notion that Democrats love incarceration more than Republicans; They both seem to love incarceration, and I don’t see any evidence that one political party loves it more than the other.

So perhaps there was less of a disagreement than would appear, but for the fact that we were arguing apples to oranges.  Or perhaps not.  But whatever the outcome of a Democrats versus Republicans debate, it simply wasn’t the discussion that happened because we were using words divorced from their meaning.  Before we engage in another debate, I’m going to follow  Bennett’s advice and demand that we define our terms up front, so that we don’t waste all those words over nothing.

And finally, I’d like to clean up a few loose ends.  Was my reaction to Doug’s rant an “over-reaction?”  Obviously, I thought it worthy of a post or I wouldn’t have done so.  Others can disagree.  In fact, Doug’s refusal to “agree to disagree” was a large part of my reason for pursuing the issue.  When we debate to the point where neither side is persuaded but there’s nothing new left to say, then reasonable people agree to disagree.  When one side refuses to do so, it becomes problematic.  When it results in a broad-based attack showing underlying animus, it raises entirely different issues.  It seemed to me to compel further discussion.

Was my post “intriguing”, as Doug characterized it in his “extended response,” or “silly” as he called it on Bennett’s blog?  I’m betting that “intriguing” was a euphemism.  But calling it silly surprised me, since it’s usually considered inappropriate for academics to use name-calling as a substitute for reason and substance.  Sure, I realize that some lawprofs aren’t used to being challenged, but that was pretty disappointing.

At the end of the day, however, I view all of this to have served the purpose of airing out differences, even if the airing may have resulted in more confusion than illumination.  I still have great respect for Doc Berman, Scott Henson, and all who’ve added their 2 cents, whether for or against me. 

Whether or not there will be any further comment, posts or discussions about this has yet to be seen, but I’ve said my piece and I will let this rest.  Others may still want to get in their “last licks.”  For some, getting in the final word is very important.  I cede the floor to anyone else who feels the need to opine, and will let whatever I’ve written up to this point speak for itself.

More Bad 1st Amendment Spam Law

Jon Katz at  Underdog posts about the Virginia anti-spam law that put Jeremy Jaynes in prison for 3 to 9 years on three counts (H/T Jon Katz for correcting me).  In Jeremy Jaynes v. Virginia, the state Supreme Court upheld the conviction in a 4-3 decision that should scare the daylights out of anyone concerned for the Constitution.

The problem, as I’ve personally learned, is that when the case involves spamming, otherwise right-thinking people find it impossible to separate their anger at spam (which I share) with the requirements of the 1st Amendment.  This leads to bad law, bad analysis and ultimately to the undermining of free speech in cases that don’t have anything to do with spamming as we think of it. 

This is how law goes wrong. It’s happening before our eyes, and we just can’t see it because our eyes are clouded by our disdain for the particular conduct in the particular case, rather than the longer view of what bad law means down the road.

Virginia Code, 18.2-152.3:1, contains a few different sections dealing with different evils.  It creates misdemeanors for using or selling computer technology that allows the sender to falsify or forge their email address.  I see no problem with this provision, since it has no connection to content and addresses the use of false identity.  There’s no protected interest in using a false identity, and it’s a bad thing to do.

The law next creates a felony for the following:


The volume of UBE transmitted exceeded 10,000 attempted recipients in any 24-hour period, 100,000 attempted recipients in any 30-day time period, or one million attempted recipients in any one-year time period.


This is the one that’s bad.  I understand UBE to mean unsolicited bulk email.  But nowhere does it limit the law to any particular content.  This is facially unconstitutional.  No, you scream at me, pounding the table to emphasize that my first amendment stops at your computer inbox! 

I agree with you.  To a point.  When the email is about enlarging a part of the male anatomy, or gaining access to certain prescription drugs, or viewing pornographic images of farm animals, or a very private offer from a close personal trustworthy friend in Nigeria, or a host of other commercial solicitations.  We all get them.  Most of us have a spam filter that makes them go away.  Some get through and we delete them.  An annoyance?  Absolutely. 

But consider bulk emailer, Tom Paine, who has some choice words for how his government should function.  Tom wants to spread the word to an unsuspecting public about how he believes he thinks government should work.  It’s important to Tom, because he is a very civic-minded individual and feels that far too many people know too little about their government and are complacent.  He wants to juice them up to become more knowledgeable and involved. 

So [email protected] sends out a bulk email.  Unsolicited.  He gets his hands on a huge list and emails it to everybody.  Now, Tom Paine is a felon in Virginia.  Do we really want Tom to do 9 years?  Do we really want to eliminate free speech unless it suits people’s convenience?  Has annoyance blinded us to why we have a 1st Amendment?

But as Jon points out in his post, the Virginia Supreme Court majority didn’t rule on the 1st Amendment overbreadth argument.  A little local quirk is that

No Virginia standing should be accorded a person to assert an overbreadth challenge when that person’s conduct consists of misleading commercial speech that is entitled to no First Amendment protection on its own merits.

Now that’s curious.  The defendant is precluded from challenging overbreadth when his alleged conduct falls outside the parameters of the overbroad prohibition. 

On the surface, this has some superficial appeal.  After all, why should this guy get the benefit of a law that’s unconstitutional only because of overbreadth when his conduct doesn’t come anywhere near the bad part.  This is particularly true with laws like this, that involves people that do things we love to hate.

The problem is that caselaw is developed through those who do things we love to hate.  Laws are upheld, as here, under their “worst-case scenario” and only later applied inappropriately, usually in a slow progression, inch by inch, until it covers protected speech.  But by then, there’s a body of caselaw upholding and supporting its application. Boom, another constitutional right down the drain.

When a law is bad, the solution is to fix it, not look for excuses to ignore its problems.  That’s how we end up with good laws, laws that adhere to the Constitution and court decisions that fulfill the judges’ oath to protect and defend the Constitution.  The Jaynes decision is a case study in how unconstitutional law is upheld.  Thanks to Jon for his efforts at rooting out this case and reminding us that unpopular cases are where it is most important for courts to demonstrate intellectual integrity.

And by the way, a sentence of 3-9 for spamming is ridiculous.  Just my opinion.

It Pays To Have A Good Lawyer in Buffalo

Kathleen Casey, my Buffalo hinterlands correspondent, has caught a live one up there in the hinterlands Buffalo.  What exactly happens when a privately-owned company contracting with the United States military gets caught screwing around?  Not much.  At least when you have the right lawyers.

From the  Buffalo News comes this story about the sweet deal for National Air Cargo in federal court.

A no-jail plea deal for an alleged multimillion- dollar crime was one of several significant breaks the U.S. Justice Department gave to Alf. There were others:

• The government decided to focus its probe on one small portion of Alf’s business, military shipments within the continental United States. The biggest part of Alf’s business — arranging military shipments to Iraq and Afghanistan — was not scrutinized.

• No individuals were charged, and the company was allowed to plead guilty as an entity.

• Prosecutors agreed that, if the documents the company has given them reveal any “smoking gun” evidence of crimes in the company’s Iraq or Afghanistan operations, they will not prosecute. The company would get a free pass.

• Although the government claims the company made more than $13.8 million based on a series of false statements during a three-year period, the company was allowed to plead guilty to one false statement that a military shipment arrived on time when, in fact, it was late. The false statement cost the government $400 on one shipment to a military base in March 2001.

• The Justice Department agreed not to take any official position on whether National Air Cargo should maintain its profitable status as a defense contractor.  Keeping its access to military contracts means the world to National Air Cargo.

The owner of the company, Christopher J. Alf, didn’t bother to show up in court for the plea.  Instead, he sent his general counsel over, with a check to the government of $20 million. 

So how is it possible that Alf bought his way out of this for chump change (yes, chump change, since he’s pulled down $400 million from his government contracts)?  Here’s the secret.  Shhhhh!  Keep this to yourself. National Cargo and top company officials were represented by


Buffalo’s top attorneys — including [Paul] Cambria, Rodney O. Personius, Terrence M. Connors, Joel L. Daniels and Daniel J. Henry Jr.

Who, you ask?  What about Mr. Skadden and Mr. Arps?  Where are the Biglaw guys with “resources” that important white collar defendants absolutely must have?  Who are these guys?

Let me tell you who.  These are real lawyers.  These are lawyers who can and do strike fear in the hearts of United States Attorneys, because they don’t rush over to the federal building to have tea with the prosecutors.  They don’t come from huge, multi-national, resource-laden, household-word named firms.  They are just your everyday, run-of-the-mill, killer criminal defense lawyers.  I know some of these guys.  They are good.


A team of top defense lawyers can affect a prosecutor’s decision on how aggressively to pursue a case, according to some legal experts, including Amey and Peter J. Henning, a former federal prosecutor.

“A prosecutor should always look at the quality of the lawyers on the other side. You look at the risks and costs of going to trial,” said Henning, who now teaches about white collar crime at the Wayne State University Law School in Detroit.

While Henning’s quote relates to the Williams & Connelly connection,  the gist of his point is dead accurate.  It’s not about who impresses the client, but who impresses the prosecutor, when it comes time to figure out whether you’re going to jail with Martha or depositing government payment checks like Alf.

How many times will I have to post about this.  No matter how self-important or pompous you are, no matter how much you think your being “white collar” makes everything different, when it is a criminal prosecution, you need a real criminal defense lawyer.   They have a special wing in federal prisons for idiots.

I bet Christopher Alf feels awfully good about things today. 

As for the rest of the story, and for those who recognize the irony of this plea in the same courtroom where petty drug dealers get 10 year mandatory minimums and are disgusted by the fact that corporate contractors can buy their way out thievery and deceit with petty cash, this is a case study in a flawed system and the relative benefits of having money to spend.  It’s a good story to read to the kids at bedtime.

What 2d Lt. Wales Now Knows

It’s easy to be fascinated by Royalty when they represent figureheads one ocean away.  Lots of pomp.  Cool swords and uniforms.  The secret thoughts about how nice it would be to have people jump at your command.  As if…

It was a curiosity how the boys of Charles, grandson’s of Elizabeth, Queen of England and plenty of other places as well, could be trained for the military.  Do you scream at a potential future king in boot camp?  What do you call him?  How many push-ups must he do for having a royal hair out of place? 

Some of my questions were answered this week when  Drudge outed Prince Harry as 2d Leftenant [ph] Harry Wales, Afghanistan.  I understand why he did so; I think it was misguided.

Chris Cuomo announced on GMA that the reason Harry was in Afghanistan is that he’s “expendable”.  Prince William is the heir to the thrown.  Prince Harry is the spare.  It’s not bad to be the spare, though I doubt anyone really thought of Harry as expendable.  More likely that William could not be put in harm’s way, while Harry had to fulfill the role of showing the world that the Royals would not ask their subject to do that which they would not.

There is much to admire in this idea that those who are charged with the responsibility of leadership, even if only by example, should be required to suffer the indignity, the discomfort, the pain of those who will live with the product of their choices.  If Prince Harry was treated as a real soldier, and there’s no reason to think otherwise, then he will know what it means to be in combat.  What a critical lesson for anyone who could ever be in a position to send another person into the line of fire.

Americans are so much better than everyone else.  We keep saying that, over and over, in the hope that the mantra becomes truth.  How many of our “leaders”, and I use that term very loosely (very, very loosely), have put their children in the line of fire.  How many have been in the line of fire themselves?

Line of fire is used metaphorically.  It’s not about being in the military.  It’s about experiencing life the way the rest of us do.  It’s about the petty annoyances that we all suffer.  It’s about trying to figure out what we are supposed to do to make our children’s lives better than our own.

In college, there is a field of study called “political science.”  Some take poly sci to become profs or researchers.  Most do so because they want to become politicians.  We know these students.  They were the ones who ran for class president in high school.  I have an image of a kid wearing an Argyle vest.  It wasn’t fashionable then either.

This course of study leads to a career path of politician.  It often passes through law school on the way.  Remember  Paul Caron’s post about the Kaplan study. The  flip side of the money issue was that “42% (52% of men, 34% of women)” want to go to law school to prepare them for a political career.  The ability to know and understand the law is very important for people who are asked to write and vote on whether something should be a law or not.  It’s a pretty good skill to have.

But there should be no such thing as a “political career” where young people decide that they want to grow up to be part of the cadre of decision-makers who control the lives of others.  What hubris to think that they have the capacity to lead, or serve.  What have they done in their lives to give them the breadth of understanding necessary to fulfill this role?  Absolutely nothing.

Harry put on a uniform and saw what life was like for a soldier in the field.  This was an experience that will impact on his understanding of life.  He didn’t get to choose his role in life by picking courses from a catalog.  He was born to it.  But at least he learned something.  Can our politicians say that?

A Blogger Comes of Age Under Fire

Since he first opened the doors to his blawg, The Matlock Blog, I kidded its sole proprietor, Shawn Matlock.  He was invariably referred to as “Young Shawn” or simply “YS”.  On my sidebar, his blog was listed in my criminal law blogroll at “Young Shawn Matlock, Republican.”  When you hold the cursor over the link, it says “A Blog for Non-Believers.”  It will happen no more. 

Shawn came under fire recently.  I’m not exactly sure why, as he hasn’t explained in his posts and he hasn’t told me what happened privately.  I didn’t ask.  If he wanted me to know, he would have said something.  He’s allowed to deal with problems in any way he choses.

Shawn is a young private criminal defense lawyer in Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas.  He’s a proud Republican, and sees no conflict between his political views and the performance of his job.  He proudly wears a bow tie, though the photo on his blog shows him more conservatively dressed. 

When he started his blog, I believe he intended to play it straight, discussing court decisions of interest and items of legal news.  He was soon perverted by the corrupting influence of folks like Bennett,  Jamie Spencer and Gideon.  I may have had a hand in it too.

Shawn’s blog quickly evolved into a blawg, posting about his experiences with a heavy dose of commentary.  He was bold in his language and comments, saying whatever was on his mind in a straightforward manner.  There was little doubt about what he meant after reading one of Shawn’s posts.  He was not subtle.  There were no subtext messages.  He used words that others avoid, and he continued to do so despite being questioned for their use.  These were his words, and they reflected how he chose to express his thoughts.

Lest one connect his politics to his occasional use of a politically incorrect term, Shawn’s Republicanism was a cover for having a heart and mind in the right place.  Rather, Shawn used language for clarity of thought and nothing more.  He had no intention of offending anyone, and likely believed that those of us who read his posts (I was designated his number 3 fan, a position that I lobbied for since I didn’t want to come in at number 4) all understood this to be true.  We weren’t offended.  True, it’s almost impossible to offend us, but we wouldn’t have been regardless.

But, as an example of the power of the blawgosphere, interest in Shawn’s blawg grew beyond the 4 original fans to others.  They didn’t have the opportunity to get to know the author, and read only the top one or two posts.  Someone got angry with Shawn.  Maybe it was more than one; maybe someone told all of his friends to read the offending post and lash out at Shawn.  I don’t know the details.  But Shawn made it clear that something he wrote offended someone.

Shawn felt badly that he had offended someone.  It resulted in his post, Mea Culpa.

The bottom line is this: Some of my posts have offended some people that read this blog. It has been pointed out to me that some posts, whether in tone or content, have been inconsiderate and demeaning to those involved. Although I take care not to name names, for those involved it is clear about whom or what I am writing. I apologize for this.

The gut reaction when someone out there tells you that they are offended by a blawg post is to tell them to get lost.  Shawn resisted this response. 


I never took the time to consider the feelings of those involved. I have simply written what I was thinking at the time, without consideration to anyone else. This blog is more than a daily journal, it is a posting for all to see. I have not taken the requisite care with such an endeavor.

The rebuke gave Shawn pause to consider a different dimension to his writings.  It never dawned on him before that his words had the power to hurt others.  This is a problem that afflicts many of us who blawg.  We put strong words into our posts and push the “publish” button.  Sometimes, we look at what we’ve written and wish there was an “unpublish” button too.  We can edit out later.  We can even delete the posts.  But the nature of the blawgosphere is that once something has been put out there, it never really goes away.

I added a comment to Shawn’s apologia that it takes a big man to say he’s sorry.  It was a sign of maturity, and I respect that.  But an apology alone left questions unanswered.  It’s good to admit an error, but is it good to relinquish control of your own thoughts and beliefs?

Shawn back up his Mea Culpa post with another post that closed the open loop.  In …however, read the fine print,” Shawn got back on the horse.


But what about the content? Well, like I said, this is just my own ranting or rambling. It’s my voice in the digital age. Some of what I write is what I actually think, some might be opinions of others, some might just be me wondering out loud. Sometimes there is an inside joke going on.

Dealing with what is written on this blog is sort of like the radio. If you don’t like the song, turn it off. If you don’t like what I’ve written about, or how I’ve written about it, or whatever, then don’t read this blog. I don’t get paid for doing this. It’s just something I do in my limited spare time. I like to write, so I write. Plain and simple.

This is where Shawn comes of age in the blawgosphere.  While a blawger needs to be somewhat circumspect to avoid needlessly offending people, only because we remain part of the human race and survive with the same norms as anyone else, we cannot give up our voice in order to please others.  You can never please everyone.  More importantly, if that’s your purpose, then you have nothing to say.


If you put your own thoughts out there, you will eventually piss someone off. It’s true. “It’s much easier to say nothing.”

There’s the money line in Shawn’s post.  The realization that any idea has the potential to piss someone off, but the only option to expression is to say nothing.  Unless you want to hide in a hole in silence, you risk angering someone.  Once you accept that risk, you are ready to move forward.


If you want to read this blog, but don’t like the way I’ve covered something, then tell me. Leave a comment. Tell me I’m a moron. It wouldn’t be the first time. In fact, it wouldn’t be the first time today. You can even comment anonymously if you like. I try to respond to all comments, and I generally don’t delete comments for being vulgar, so bring it.

Finally, if you think I am a moron, but leaving a comment won’t be enough, then here’s an idea. Write your own blog. You can write all day long that I’m a raving lunatic jackass if you like.

Shawn shoots from the hip here, but with the best of intentions.  I suspect as interest in his blawg grows, he will come to realize that vulgarity breeds vulgarity, and the level of discourse will devolve into uselessness.  Civil discourse is harder to accomplish, but far more useful and interesting.  You see the inkling of realization of this in Shawn’s secondary suggesting, write your own blog.

The Matlock Blog is Shawn’s blawg.  It is his, completely and entirely.  No one else, not you nor me, has any right to go there and express any opinion, about Shawn, his posts or the weather.  At least not on the Matlock Blog (a name that could stand for some creative review, I might add).  I can say whatever I want about it here, because this is my blawg.  But I can’t there, because it’s his.  Unless he allows me to do so.

So Shawn correctly maps out the options.  If you don’t like what he says, click on the X.  If you feel compelled to write a dissertation on the depths of his ignorance, start your own blog, perhaps the “I Hate Matlock Blog” is still available.  Perhaps not.  And if Shawn allows you to post a comment, appreciate the fact that you do so because he has chosen to make that opportunity available to you.  Behave yourself as you would entering someone else’s home as a guest.

In these two posts, Shawn Matlock has come of age.  He will no longer be referred to here as Young Shawn.  I will change the name of his blawg in my sidebar blogroll.  He may still be subject to occasional ridicule, but only for his content.  And fashion sense.  And political affiliation.  Welcome back to the blawgosphere, Shawn.

Avvo: Dinner is Served

When  Avvo first came on the scene, I had my doubts.  Like most lawyers, I thought the idea that a lawyer would be wrapped up in a single number was ridiculously simplistic and misleading.  Who needed consumers of legal services to be further mislead?  Lawyer advertising did enough to mislead people without Avvo.  We needed no help.

But while we were sleeping, Avvo has come a long way.  Via Real Lawyers Have Blogs comes Joseph Campos’ post at Law.com, legal technology, that the paradigm has shifted away from Martindale-Hubbell, the only game in town since 1868, to client-centric Avvo.

When Avvo first launched, I challenged the concept in a series of posts:



Yeah, Avvo has been the source of a lot of words here at Simple Justice.  Similarly, I questioned whether  M-H was capable of keeping pace with a changing world.  The problem with being too successful for too long is that change presents huge risk, and recognizing new directions can be very dangerous if you pick the wrong path.  It was not surprising that M-H was inclined to go the conservative route, but it could have hedged its bet.  It didn’t, and has now firmly established itself as an antique.  The books still look good on the library shelf, but there’s no reason to ever buy a new, and very expensive, set. 

Campos notes that Avvo embraced, while Martindale-Hubbell rejected, the notion of client reviews.  M-H was always about lawyers rating other lawyers.  Clients could watch from afar, but could never get in the door.  Avvo welcomed clients.  This cause massive initial fear by lawyers, because of the concern that the only clients who would be inclined to make the effort to review would be the dissatisfied ones.  Dissatisfaction is a much stronger motivator than satisfaction.

This fear has yet to be realized.  The has been no mass attacks against lawyers at Avvo, which either reflects Avvo’s promise that they will vet reviews to maintain their integrity or that clients don’t hate lawyers nearly as much as lawyers think.

Avvo has also generated  much anger from those who promote solo practice, because it is viewed as discriminating against younger solo practitioners.  The basis for this is Avvo’s Big Number.  The Big Number gives a value to legal experience, and to the various accomplishments that come with legal experience, such that a more experienced lawyer will have a higher Avvo rating than a new lawyer.  Conversely, a new lawyer will be lower rated by Avvo, which will hurt that new lawyer’s chances with clients who check out Avvo ratings when selecting counsel.

I’ve had numerous discussions with Avvo co-founder and VP, Paul Bloom.  He’s open to learning about problems, and open to doing something to fix them.  He wants Avvo to succeed, and he views his success as contingent upon Avvo’s acceptance by the legal community as a legitimate source of information.  While the basic issue with Big Number is itself immutable, since this is the foundation of Avvo’s rating service, Paul and Avvo CEO Mark Britton (who I don’t believe has ever stopped by to say hello.  Maybe he doesn’t like me?) have made many tweaks to address the issues and problems raised. 

A few comments about some of the newer tweaks on Avvo: 



  • On the Avvo blog, they list the top ten lawyers viewed in the past week.  While I can’t prove it that this is just a scam by the lawyers to up their profiles.  It doesn’t pass the smell test, particularly since I know one of them and know full well how desperately he markets himself.  I don’t judge him for doing so, but it does undermine the integrity of this top ten list. 


  • They have added the Avvo Track Record, where attorneys can list cases and outcomes.  Aside from the problem with claiming false outcomes, and the fact that a successful outcome in one case has no bearing on any other, this new feature is rife with ethical issues.  By the lawyer posting the details of a case, he inherently reveals client confidences.  This would require a whole post in itself, if you don’t understand why this is so.  But it is, and it’s wrong.


  • Lastly, they have a new feature called Lawyer’s Avvo Answers.  These are answers by lawyers to questions asked by potential clients.  This is awful.  Beyond the fact that the questions don’t provide sufficient information to formulate a meaningful answer, it is dangerous, seriously dangerous, to provide generic, sometimes erroneous, answers about complex legal issues.  The lawyers who contribute to this feature get the benefit of self-promotion, but do so at the expense accuracy and credibility.  One such question asked how to get away with a crime.  The lawyer explained how to dance around the law.  Is this the what we should be doing?  This is a bad feature, and any lawyer who participates should be ashamed of himself.

These present issues, which bring some Avvo initiatives into disrepute.  Avvo ought to be careful about skirting the lines of ethics and credibility.  Just because they are playing the game well doesn’t mean that they can’t do something awfully foolish to lose whatever credibility they are gaining.

What Campos’ post says to me is not just that Avvo has arrived, but that M-H has left the building.  The boat sailed and Martindale-Hubbell wasn’t on it.  It’s unlikely that this makes Avvo the top dog in lawyer ratings just yet, since lawyers by definition and nature take a very, very long time to accept change.  But it does indicate that the change has happened and lawyers will eventually figure it out.  There may be other challengers to Avvo and M-H that ultimately displace both of them, but now that the paradigm has changed, it appears that Avvo represents the future as much as M-H is perpetually mired in the past.  Dinner is served.