Author Archives: SHG

Are Liberals Responsible For Mass Incarceration?

The  Pew report generated a lot of discussion, including lawprof  Doug Berman’s support for a Kentucky law favoring asset forfeiture in an effort to reduce the sky-rocketing cost of imprisonment.  While agreeing with Doug about mass incarceration, I took  strong issue that asset forfeiture was the answer.  In response to my post, Doug and I  debated the issue at some length.

After seeing that we were both married to our respective positions, and recognizing that there was nothing new to be said, I concluded my  final comment by saying that we would just have to agree to disagree.  This usually signals the end of the discussion, but not this time.  Instead, Doug responded, including the following highly provocative challenge:


I am not content to just “agree to disagree (strongly) on this one.” Anyone not seriously thinking about VERY different solutions to mass incarceration, in my mind, is a BIG part of the problem. (And, as you should know, most criminals in prison now don’t have a car or a house or a job to forfeit.) Why are you more sympathetic to people with property who commit crimes than to people without property who commit crimes.

I have long believed that liberals get in the way of SERIOUS game-changing criminal justice reforms more so than conservatives. This discussion confirms this belief. As I suggested at the outset, I think this is ultimately more sad than scary, because it shows that liberals are so brainwashed or beaten by current realities that cannot ever imagine a different world in which sounder criminal laws come to dominate.

The gauntlet has been tossed.  Up to this point, the focus of the discussion on my part was that asset forfeiture, one of the most insidious and abused fictions ever devised by the law, was not the answer to the agreed-upon problem of mass incarceration.  Doug, in essence, viewed the problems with asset forfeiture as being mere tweaks to be corrected once we opened our mind to it as an alternative to incarceration.  Note:  this post is not intended to revisit the issue of whether asset forfeiture is a good or bad thing.  That’s what  this post was about.

But these two paragraphs raise an entirely different issue.  While I am unclear how this is a liberal/conservative issue as framed, that is the way Doug has posed it.  The argument that by rejecting asset forfeiture as a solution means that we are not thinking about “VERY different solutions” is a non-sequitur.  We’ve given enormous thought to different solutions, some obvious and some pretty far out.  My point was that the particular “solution” under discussion, asset forfeiture, was a bad one.  A VERY bad one.

But Doug took this discussion to a much deeper place, where my rejection of asset forfeiture became a condemnation of liberals for their refusal to think outside the box, and therefore responsible for the current state of mass incarceration.  Liberal are “so brainwashed or beaten by current realities” that we are responsible for unsound criminal law.  Conservatives, like Doug, on the other hand are open-minded to new solutions and trying hard to create a world where sound criminal laws dominate.

What I found so jarring by Doug’s position is that we share a concern for the over-incarceration, over-criminalization of American society.  We similarly share a concern about the disparate impact of criminal law on minorities.  There is much we agree on.  Yet, it never occurred to me that beneath these areas of agreement, Doug harbored such a smoldering hatred of liberals.  Indeed, but for a few odd choices, one might well have concluded that Doug was quite the liberal himself.  And everybody is entitled to make some unexpected choices from time to time.

But Doug has come out clearly as a liberal-blaming conservative, and challenges us libs with being small-minded, unimaginative, brainwashed and beaten.  I’m not buying, and I’m frankly shocked by the depth of Doug’s hatred of liberals and the nature and scope of his attack.

Just because we agree on the problem does not mean that we have to accept any potential “solution” that comes along.  By disagreeing with Doug’s acceptance of asset forfeiture as a Utopian ideal, I am not prepared to accept being pigeonholed.  Mass incarceration is a very real problem.  Asset forfeiture is a very bad solution.  We need to solve the problem, and Doug is right that we all need to open our minds to alternatives that fall outside the realm of the usual answers.  By the way, asset forfeiture is by no means a novel idea, having been enjoyed and abused by the feds for decades without any positive impact on the mass incarceration problem.  That Kentucky has just discovered it is, well, a commentary on Kentucky and little else.

But in our zeal to find alternatives, seizing upon solutions that are worse than the problem is not progress.  Legislatures tend to do that a lot, coming up with a brand new idea that ultimately proves to exacerbate the problem rather than fix it.  In New York, we have the Rockefeller Drug Laws, a brilliant solution that has turned into a monumental disaster.  Gov. Nelson Rockefeller was, of course, a compassionate conservative.

Doug has, in effect, accused me of liberal myopia because I do not accept his view that any alternative to mass incarceration is a good one.  Since Doug’s views don’t reflect mainstream conservatism, it would be unfair to make any accusations against conservatives based upon Doug’s comments.  But I have one to levy directly at my accuser:  Professor Douglas Berman, you are just a liberal in sheep’s clothing who is grasping at straws to find a cure to the societal nightmare of over-incarceration.  Stop fighting it and come over to the side of truth and justice.  We will forgive you this one mistake. 

Biglaw Blawgosphere: Does This Tie Match?

Beck and/or Herrmann at  Drug and Device Law are the exception to the Biglaw types.  They write well and with humility, have a sense of humor, and most of all, blog.  But they have apparently reached a cross-roads in their blogging where they are constrained to wonder why bloggers are under appreciated by their own Biglaw firms.

One or the other (since neither is willing to take ownership of the question) posts:   Why Are Blogs Undervalued?  No, not by you, since you are already reading a blog, but by the management of Biglaw and by the decision-makers of their corporate clients. 

Having crafted the “the most widely read product liability blog on the internet,” they wonder why nobody at work is asking how they did it and how can it be replicated.  They have come up with 4 answers to their question:


First, we’re breathing our own fumes. “Most widely read product liability blog on the internet” is like “world’s tallest midget.” 25,000 pageviews is a drop in the bucket, and there’s essentially no institutional benefit to blogging. If the two of us — Beck and Herrmann, the blogging morons — want to waste our Saturday mornings feeding this beast, we should go ahead and entertain ourselves. But no one should think this has any institutional value.

Second, firm management is too old. Management is basically folks over 50 who start their days sipping a cup of coffee and reading the Journal. Only people under 40 start their days sipping a cup of coffee and checking Above the Law, the Law Blog, Overlawyered, and other blogs. Since firm management has never visited a blog, management can’t believe that anyone else does, either. The power of the blogosphere is simply beyond management’s comprehension.

Third, blogs attract the wrong demographic. The target market for big firms such as ours is the general counsel and C-level management of Fortune 500 companies. With all due respect to our visitors — and we love you guys; really! — you folks are younger and less important. Although a blog can be widely read, it’s widely read by the wrong eyeballs and so not worth the effort.

Or, fourth, blogging is too much work for too little financial reward. It takes many hours of effort each week for the two of us to provide regular, fresh content to this site, and the amount of business generated doesn’t justify the effort. If the two of us get some personal satisfaction from blogging, no one will interfere, but firms do cost-benefit analyses of marketing initiatives, and this one flunks the test. (If that’s the answer, it’s cool with us. We surely aren’t doing this for the financial rewards.) (Come to think of it, why the heck are we doing this?)

As I read these four answers, I could feel the bile welling up in the throats of the Blogs are the new pet rock crowd. As anyone who knows that the blawgosphere exists is aware, it’s a curious place inhabited by people with very different motives. 

Like Beck/Herrmann, I’m a blogging moron.  I can appreciate, though I have no Biglaw masters to please, that there are moments when I wonder why I bother to do this.  There are times when it’s fun.  There are times when it stops being fun.  But since my goal is not to impress clients and gain market share through my blawg, it is not financially motived.  Since my work is not the creation of a commercial blog network, I need not bolster the concept of blogging to encourage others to buy blogs from me. 

But for those whose livelihood depends on the lawyers buying into blogging as a means to get business, a post like this is heresy.  On the one side, marketers are telling lawyers that blogging is the key to success.  On the other side, bloggers are telling lawyers that this is “too much work for too little financial reward.”

As expected, my good friend Kevin from  Real Lawyers Have Blogs was the first to comment.  This is Kevin’s bread and butter, having created the LexBlog group that offers turnkey blogs to lawyers and a network that will make any new LexBlog an overnight success.  There is one condition, a point that Kevin and I has discussed at length: Once he turns over the keys, the newbie blogger has to put in the effort to create some substance of his own to generate organic interest.  Kevin makes the vehicle, the lawyer then has to drive it.  If he crashes it into a wall, there’s nothing Kevin can do to stop him.

In his first comment, Kevin challenges the proposition that blogs are undervalued.  Kevin points out that blogs have come along farther and faster than Biglaw’s adoption of other technology, like email and websites.  In other words, it doesn’t happen overnight and Beck/Herrmann need to give it some more time.  I think Kevin has a point here, especially since the elders rarely buy in to new technologies until it has become so ordinary and commonplace that even they know about it.

But then, a strange thing happens.  Kevin comes back for another bite of the apple and posts this comment :


May be that blogs are being undervalued in your firm because your blog looks so amateurish.

Bloggers may understand Google’s free blogger service and it’s all fun to say we can do this for free.

But what about the lead partners in your firm and huge multinational clients? What do they think when they look at it?

Looks mean a lot. Show up to meet to meet a new corporate client in a suit, shirt, tie, and shoes from Goodwill. Your partners would be less than impressed when you rave about it being fun, the new thing, and free.

Well, that was awfully harsh.  And needlessly personal.  Beyond this being over-the-top as far as self-serving (my blogs look better than your blogs), is that really what blogging is all about, appearance? 

Some blogs show that a great deal of effort was put into appearance, with cool, unique templates and all sorts of bells and whistles.  Others, like Simple Justice, are pretty much amateurish in appearance.  I lack both the skill to make it more “professional” looking, and frankly wouldn’t care enough to do so if I had the skill.  My time is spent writing the posts, because that’s why I do this, and not to develop a blog that is more visually appealing. 

But more to the point, who is the arbiter of whether a blog is visually appealing or “amateurish”?  At Drug and Device Law, they clearly haven’t put much effort into their header, as it’s as basic as could be.  So what? 

My uniform has been a suit and tie for more than 25 years.  Still, I ask the same question every morning before I leave the house:  Does this tie match?  As much as I am renown for being a snappy dresser, it’s never quite clear to me whether I’ve made a good choice in ties or a poor one. 

Of course, my tie bears no relationship to the arguments I will make in court, or the research and writing I will put into my papers.  It’s not substantive.  There’s some argument that a particularly bad choice is distracting, but even those lawyers who wear a particularly ugly tie are able to get beyond it.  I do not accept the premise that any defendant has ever gone to jail because his lawyer wore an ugly tie.

Some of my friends (particularly Gideon) in the blawgosphere have tried to push me to improve the appearance of my blawg.  I don’t disagree with them, but can’t muster the energy to care enough to act.  I believe that substance trumps appearance, and I believe that  Drug and Device Law offers substance.  If that’s not a good enough reason to stop by and read, then the blawgosphere is a failure.  No matter how attractive the tie, it will never be more vital than it’s wearer.

YarmulkeGate: Jews and Texas Justice

There are a lot of people in Texas.  Aside from Kinky Friedman, very few it seems are Jewish.  “He ain’t from around here,” rings out whenever a yarmulke-wearing Jew shows up in town.  The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, tells the story about Harris County District Attorney candidate, current Judge and ersatz former litigator, Pat Lykos.


The Juish (as Kelly Siegler might say) witness whom DA candidate Pat Lykos ordered to remove his yarmulke writes in to AHCL’s blog.

The link is to a lengthy comment by a fellow named Gil Fried, who relates that he is a professor from New Haven, Connecticut.  He tells about the choice he was given by Judge Pat Lykos.


I can testify under oath that she forced me to remove my Yalmukah before testifying in her court (either testify without it or be held in contempt and would not be able to testify). In my opinion she was very mean about it and tried to imply that I was wearing it for show (she cited a case from New England involving a former priest who became a lawyer and wanted to practice in court wearing his collar) even when I indicated that I wear my head covering every day.

In New York, we have a lot of Jews.  Some are more orthodox than others, and always keep their head covered.  Some are ultra orthodox, and have an even more distinct appearance.  It’s not for show.  It doesn’t symbolize their membership in the clergy.  It’s considered fairly normal, and nobody around here would blink about it.

Is there a difference between wearing a yarmulke and dressing as Priest?  It seems obvious to me, unless the sight of a Jew wearing a yarmulke is so unusual as to symbolize something strange and foreign, bolstering from God the veracity of this witness.

I would have thought that they would learned something from Kinky.

The General Deterrence Presumption

Grits posted about how a Texas law making the theft of copper wire a felony, regardless of the value of the wire stolen, didn’t solve the problem.  Having never defended a copper wire case, this doesn’t have any personal impact on me.  But his point, that creating harsher sentences under the assumption that hard time will deter the crime, often misses the mark.

There is a certain beauty to sentencing law.  By increasing the severity of the offense (say, misdemeanor to felony, low-grade felony to higher-grade felony) and the resultant punishment, our government can prove that it is dealing with crime.  It makes for good headlines.  It’s easily digestible.  It conforms to the public’s common sense notions about how to stop crime. 

The only problem is that it doesn’t necessarily work.  The operative presumption is that by increasing penalty for a crime, it will decrease the commission of the crime.  Why?  Because the idea of general deterrence tells us so.  People will not commit a crime in order to avoid the penalty for the crime.  Like I said, simple and straightforward.

The problem is that this concept may have no applicability to non-financial crimes, where there is a cost-benefit analysis to be done by the potential perp in advance of the crime.  In my experience, not all potential criminals complete a business plan before making their decision to commit a crime.

Another problem is that the significance of the penalty is relative to the likelihood of getting caught.  If potential criminals don’t believe that they are going to get nabbed for the crime, then the penalty doesn’t affect the equation, or at least not as much.

But this presumes that potential criminals think about the penalty at all before engaging in criminal conduct.  Based upon my highly scientific study (in other words, my personal experience), it’s all according to what type of crime is involved, how intelligent the person is and their inclination to think at all.

Offenses driven by passion or mindlessness are immune from any general deterrence.  It just doesn’t enter into the equation. 

Offenders who are particularly dumb don’t think about much of anything.  This cuts a far broader swathe than people who ponder the issues of penalty and criminality realize.  Since they don’t hang out with criminals enough (other than lobbyists), they engage in rank speculation about the subject with little if any connection to reality. 

As a friend of mine, a criminal defense lawyer who ended up elected to the Legislature told me, they don’t get it at all.  They legislate in some fantasy land and then wonder why it never seems to work the way they thought it would.  Their solution?  Do the same thing all over again, but make it even harsher.  It may not work, but they will be heroes for doing so.

For reasons that I have never quite understood, ordinary people maintain a belief that criminals approach their work the same way that professors do.  They study up, become fully familiar with the law, the punishments, the legal bars and police tactics.  They “know” stuff.

Well, I’m here to tell you, they don’t.  They don’t know stuff.  They are dumb.  They hear nonsense talk on the street from other dopes and believe it, spreading misunderstand through the community like syphilis.  They show up on my doorstep in a shocking state of dumbness.  Their primary source of information tends to be old ladies sitting on crates on street corners who answer all questions.

While tweaking penalties may serve to help the politicians, and provide a perpetual source of discussion for people like me, the presumption that it serves a general deterrence purpose is, for the most part, mental masturbation.  The people we seek to deter don’t pay attention, don’t get it and don’t care. 

School Massacres: It’s Not Just The Weapons

The New York Times has  an editorial blasting our politicians for their failure to address the “Gun Crazy” culture that it blames for the killings at Northern Illinois, Virginia Tech and Columbine High School. 

Our political leaders are not helpless. They could match public shock with prompt, concerted and effective action to make mass shootings a less frequent fact of American life. But neither party’s leaders have shown any sign of stepping up their responsibilities. The latest campus carnage barely caused a ripple in presidential politics, where conventional wisdom dictates against actively advocating more stringent gun control laws.

The “solutions” set forth in the editorial are clear:  Eliminate the “gun show” loophole, perform background checks, ban automatic weapons, etc.  These are nothing new, though they have been the bane of the RKBA supporters.  Awaiting the DC v. Heller decision, they are not likely to be nearly as worried about the Times’ view today as they were in the past.

But nowhere in the editorial is there any discussion of what is driving these individual to commit this horrific killings.  There is a disease afflicting some youth in our society, and we are ignoring it.  Instead, the Times wants to treat the overt symptoms and leave the disease unchecked.  I have argued that we should address one element of the  motivations for these high profile shows by  never revealing the identities of the killers.  That’s gone over like a lead balloon.

But the recurrence of these mass killings by otherwise ordinary kids has yet to be scrutinized by social scientists, politicians or newspaper editors.  In the post-mortem, everyone can see the unhappiness and purported mental instability the drove these people to randomly kill others.  How wonderful that we can attribute negative qualities and psychological pathologies to killers after the fact.  It may make us feel better to believe that these were sick kids, but it does nothing to help us identify the problem, or the people, before they shoot up another school.

Schools have adopted zero tolerance policies, ousting kindergartners for drawing pictures of weapons (not to mention hugging each other, because a hugger could grow up to be pathologically empathetic someday).   While this has given rise to bizarre and laughable results, except for the poor families caught up in its stupidity, it has done nothing to deal with the problem.

How many educators and social scientists have watched VH1 lately?  The shows that glorify million dollar parties for children, and suggest that the failure to have one brands a youth a total failure, are common fodder.  Could this have any impact on the depression felt by youth? 

What about the economy, where college students who have struggled for years to achieve the promise that their parents and society made, only to find that it’s empty and that they are unlikely to reach their goals of financial success.  Could this weigh heavily on their minds?

What about our consumerist society, where the desperate need for bling has reached into our high schools and colleges, and left those without to be ridiculed and marginalized.

And what about our cultural glorification of pain, with shows ranging from “Jackass” to “America’s Funniest Home Videos” have us laughing uproariously at the hurt suffered by others.  This diminishes their view that seeing pain inflicted, and therefore inflicting pain, is really such a terrible thing.

It’s not that I dispute the fact that a gun in the hands of these killers facilitated their acts.  But the gun did not cause them to kill.  By focusing their pressure on the weapon, rather than the reason, for these killings, we move no closer to recognizing and curing the disease.  Am I the only person who is concerned about this?  It seems so.

A Healthier Tension In Academia

In a Times Op-Ed, Stanley Fish argues that Bruce Benson’s appointment as President of the University of Colorado is, well, stupid.  Benson has an impressive personal resume, “oilman, Republican activist, failed candidate for governor, co-chairman of Mitt Romney’s (now ended) campaign, successful fund raiser, donor to the university, former chairman of the Metropolitan State College Denver Board and chair of a blue-ribbon panel on higher education.”  But nowhere in that resume is there anything suggesting a background to prepare him to be a University President.


Obviously he has a strong interest in education, but his highest degree is a B.A., and he has never been a member of a faculty or engaged in research or published papers in a learned journal. In short, he is in no way an academic, and yet he is about to become the president of an academic institution, and not any old institution, but a state university ranked 11th among public universities and 34th among universities overall.

Yet Benson was the only candidate to emerge from the search.  Despite a 40-4 vote against him by the faculty, he got the job.

The argument in Benson’s favor is that the skills he brings to the job from his prior experience will serve him well in this position; “academic credentials are not that necessary because management skills, like those Benson is presumed to have, are transferable from activity to activity. Someone who can manage an oil company will be able to manage the enterprise of a university.”

My first question is what is the job of a University President.  If it’s fundraising, promoting and elevating the image of the school and herding cats, then there doesn’t seem to be any need for an academic background to perform the job well.  Indeed, one may well question whether a President too involved or sensitive to academic concerns might divide his loyalty between the hard reality of management and the soft and fuzzy concerns of scholarship.

But my experience with successful managers is that they, and their supporters, often overstate the applicability of their management skills under a flawed assumption.  If Joe is a successful manager at X, he must therefore be competent at managing Y, with Y being an entirely different industry.  It may be that Joe is a brilliant manager, and that his competencies do extent to Y.  But it may also be that Joe was lucky at successfully managing X, and that he lacks the assumptive managerial competencies.

This would suggest that it’s a very individual decision, when considering whether a person without academic background has the skills to be a University President.  Of course, we don’t really like individualized decisions, and much prefer broad generic rules that we can apply across the board.

What makes this issue interesting is that the faculty, scholars all (just ask them), beloved of empirical studies and defiant in their academic independence, fall back to intuitive arguments (just like the rest of us poor schnooks) when it comes to their own problems.  In dismissing the rationale for hiring Benson, Fish responds:


The reasoning, however, is specious. It is no doubt true that an experienced executive will quickly learn the ropes of an industry new to him. The product may be different, but the tasks will be basically the same: assess market share, learn the routes of distribution, fine-tune the relationship between inventory and demand, increase efficiency perhaps by downsizing the workforce.

But in the academy there is no product except knowledge, and that may take decades to develop, if it develops at all. The concept of market share is inapposite; efficiency is not a goal; and there is no inventory to put on the shelves. Instead the norms are endless deliberations, explorations that may go nowhere, problems that only five people in the world even understand, lifetime employment that is not taken away even when nothing is achieved, expensively labor-intensive practices and no bottom line. What is an outsider to make of that?

Maybe an outsider will be capable of understanding the investment in knowledge, or the product of education.  But to call the reasoning “specious” jumps the gun.  It just isn’t all the hard to comprehend the internal self-image of academia, where decades of deep thought will ultimately produce brilliance, or maybe not.  But University is where the opportunity for such thought must happen, or it will happen nowhere.

On the other hand, maybe the Academy has other purposes to serve as well, and the elevation of scholarship to the exclusion of education presents an issue that the faculty can’t see.  We all have a tendency to be blind to things we would rather not see.

Whether Bruce Benson is the right guy for the job is an individual question.  I haven’t a clue.  But the notion of bringing in a President who might challenge the faculty to do their job better, more effectively and even recognize that it’s not all about them, might create a healthier tension in academia.  Vigorous discussion, and even dispute (something that doesn’t happen often in the collegial halls of the University) almost invariably result in better decisions than consensus for its own sake.  Why not try it?

On the other hand, if the faculty believes that bringing in a fellow who can’t spell University to run one will mean the death of scholarship, then where’s the proof?  The same “common sense” answers that scholars rightly ridicule don’t become stronger when they come out of their mouths.

The trend in academia toward insular scholarship, and away from education, is a problem.  The cost of an education is too high for many consumers, and parents and students suffer to achieve a degree.  At the same time, they are treated as the flotsam of the academic process, a necessary evil to finance more important work.  Scholars feel dirty wasting their time teaching, when they could be thinking and writing, proving their worth in the greater academic community.  Their disconnect of scholarship and education is a product of their self-indulgence, supported by their “management” that understands and agrees that teaching is the “toilet cleaning” of higher ed.  Something that has to be done, but nobody wants to do it.

Maybe a Bruce Benson can remind the scholars that the University doesn’t exist solely for their pleasure.  Maybe a Bruce Benson can be an advocate for the forgotten and neglected students.  Maybe an outsider will see that the mission has gone off course, and return it to a path that serves all the interested parties in the University.  That wouldn’t be such a bad thing, even though the faculty will hate it.

Defending Cellphones to the Death

Robert Guest, who Was The State, has  taken up arms against a proposal to ban the use of cellphones will driving near schools in Dallas.  And he is steaming.  He writes, “Her column fails to recognize that this law is a waste of criminal justice resources and an affront to privacy, liberty, and freedom.”

In a second post, coming quickly on the heels of his first, Robert goes  the 1st Amendment route to attack the proposed ban.  While I generally find myself in agreement with the positions taken by Robert, he must be one huge cellphone user because he’s gone blind on this one.

First, there is no longer  any question that cellphone use while driving is as bad as, if not worse, than drunk driving.  It is not merely benign conduct, but conduct that has the potential to kill.  Worse yet, it lacks the moral stigma of drunk driving, so that ordinary law-abiding people wouldn’t think twice about chatting away on the cellphone while behind the wheel.  It doesn’t make you a bad person.

For some, the point can be quickly driven home on a policy basis by noting that there is no conversation that someone needs to have so desperately that is worth the life of my child.  Until recently, society survived without cellphones.  We were not on the verge of crumbling for lack of an opportunity to chat with a friend, or even a client.  Are cellphones convenient?  Absolutely.  Are they worth taking a life?  No.

But this effort to wrap this up in a 1st Amendment right is misplaced.  The restriction is not about the frequency or content of cellphone communications.  This is a limitation on driving a vehicle while engaging in unsafe conduct.  Driving a car is a privilege, not a right.  Being able to communicate is a right, but not while enjoying the privilege of driving. 

You need to talk to someone immediately?  So pull over and talk all you want.  Talk till your blue in the face.  Just don’t do it while driving a car.  No one is taking away your right to talk.  They are taking away your privilege of driving while you talk on the cellphone. 

Anecdotally, I’ve had about 100 near misses driving around people with a cellphone glued to their ear.  And this is New York, where it has been unlawful to do so for a while already.  It’s another law observed primarily in the breach, with a substantial number of otherwise nice people breaking the law without a second thought. 

Now I’m a very defensive driver, primarily because I don’t trust other people with the ability to kill me.  And I’ve managed to escape unscathed from my close calls with cellphone drivers.  Others have not.  Whether it’s one or a million doesn’t strike me as terribly relevant, since the trade off is non-existent.  There is simply nothing anyone has to say on a cellphone that is worth someone else’s life.  Not even one life.

Usually, when the cellphone driver has the near-miss, they give you “the wave.”  That’s the sign that they are sorry to have come so close to killing you, as if that would mean a lot to your children at your funeral.  But even as they wave, the cellphone remains glued to their ear.  The risk remains.  Their focus is on their critically important phone call.  Their focus is not on the road.

I am all for liberty and freedom.  There are issues worth fighting for, and even dying for.  But the “right” to chat at any moment doesn’t even come close to making the list.  There is no 1st Amendment right at stake in laws prohibiting the use of cellphones while driving, since cars have breaks as well as accelerators.  And there is no trade-off between the life of a human being and the convenience of using a cellphone whenever you darn well please.  If there is any problem with the proposed Dallas ban, it doesn’t go nearly far enough.

Cheap At Half the Price

The word is out that toe-tapping Senator Larry Craig, our  favorite restroom aficionado, has  spent about $213,000 in legal fees to overturn his guilty plea for bathroom hijinks.  This is just about the median cost for a misdemeanor defense.  In my wildest dreams.

It must be awfully good to be a Senator from Idaho.  Granted, it’s Idaho, and some people will do anything to get off the potato farm, but still.  This is a lot of money to fight a conviction following a plea of guilty.  I have to assume that somebody told Larry that this isn’t going to be easy, and the chances were slim that he was going to beat the rap.

Is this a fight for principal?  It doesn’t have that smell, since the gist of Larry’s argument is that the underlying law is unconstitutional.  Whether or not it is, I have no idea.  I just haven’t spent the time to research and think about it since I’m not getting any piece of that big chunk of change. 

The problem is that a win doesn’t remove the taint of Larry Craig’s conduct, just the criminality of it.  While it may no longer be a violation of law should the law be held unconstitutional, he’s still going to find himself awfully lonely in the Senate bathroom, when the others keep their distance.

Nor is this going to alter the denial that he’s not gay, which would have done wonders for his reputation and made him a sympathetic figure as the victim of homophobic laws.  So either he’s a liar about his sexual preference, or seriously unstable.  This isn’t going away just because the law is bad.

But back to the legal fee.  The prosecution, according to the story, has spent about $28,500 to fend off the challenges of Team Craig.  To some, this might seem like a pretty expensive proposition for some misdemeanor bathroom toe-tapping, but to a Senator, this is lunch money.  These guys spend more than a billion dollars on a plane.  The light bulbs in the cockpit cost more than this. 

So what has Team Craig done to run up a bill over $200K?  So far, a motion to withdraw a guilty plea and an appeal.  Not to mention a bit of crisis management, I’m sure.  While this may make public defenders cringe, I can see it.  While definitely on the high side, if not very high side, it’s not totally outside the ballpark given the circumstances.

But it’s not money well spent.  My suggestion (other than Larry Craig giving me a call for some friendly advice), you would have done better to use the money as a downpayment on a potato farm.

The Spinning of The Pew Report

The Pew report has been the subject of intense interest around the blawgosphere.  This is the report that tells us that we finally reached a 1 in 100 incarceration rate (and far higher for minorities) and the cost is blowing the doors off of budgets, the latter a subject discussed here just yesterday again. 

There are already a slew of posts relating the content of the report, at A Public Defender, Reasonable Doubts,  ne-percent-of-adults-are-behind-bars-in-America..html”>Underdog and Sentencing Law and Policy, and no reason for me to repeat it here.  Instead, I want to focus on the spin that’s coming out, with no doubt more to come, that will provide the context for the report.

Adam Liptak of the New York Times has already  churned out his column on the report.  In juxtaposition to the report, Liptak brings in Paul Cassell, Utah lawprof, former federal judge and victim’s rights advocate (though Liptak doesn’t mention this last piece).

“We aren’t really getting the return in public safety from this level of incarceration,” said Susan Urahn, the center’s managing director. 

But Paul Cassell, a law professor at the University of Utah and a former federal judge, said the Pew report considered only half of the cost-benefit equation and overlooked the “very tangible benefits: lower crime rates.” 

In the past 20 years, according the Federal Bureau of Investigation, rates of violent crimes fell by 25 percent, to 464 per 100,000 people in 2007 from 612.5 in 1987.

“While we certainly want to be smart about who we put into prisons,” Professor Cassell said, “it would be a mistake to think that we can release any significant number of prisoners without increasing crime rates. One out of every 100 adults is behind bars because one out of every 100 adults has committed a serious criminal offense.”

This is a deeply disturbing article, and comment by Judge Cassell.  It no longer surprises me that Liptak promotes the tough-on-crime perspective, or that he prints lop-sided arguments without any critical thought.  It’s just happened way too often.  So much for expecting the Gray Lady to give a reasoned story.

Judge Cassell’s statement is, first, factually wrong.  The numbers do not reflect a simple truth that 1 out of 100 adults has “committed a serious criminal offense,” and he must know this.  They reflect the over-criminalization of conduct, with new crimes being created every time an election rolls around.  They reflect the magic bullet theories that the public loves so dearly, like mandatory minimums and three-strikes laws.  They reflect the ever-increasing sentences, pushing innocent people to plead guilty or cooperate, to avoid a 30 year bit.

Nowhere does the Liptak story mention any of these influences in counterpoint to Judge Cassell’s facile reaction.  But we’re not done yet.

Cassell states that the cost-benefit equation overlooks the “very tangible benefits: lower crime rates.”  It’s hard to imagine a lawprof engaging in such a flagrant post hoc argument.  That argument supports the claim that breathing causes cancer, since everyone who has cancer was breathing beforehand.  The proof is in the pudding, right? Wrong.

If we incarcerate far more people than need to be, or deserve to be, it will impact crime rates.  By that logic, why not incarcerate everyone and then we can eliminate crime altogether.  It bears no causal connection between the rate of incarceration and crime rates.  Even worse, the crime rates were down before the incarceration rates went up, showing the disconnect between the two.

It is shocking to see someone as respected, though biased, as Judge Cassell posturing for Liptak, and to find Liptak buying into it all the way.  Worse than shocking, it is sad and pathetic that they seek to rationalize and promote this blight on American society. 

But let’s go to the next level, and ask why they presume that Americans, more so than people anywhere else in the world, feel the need to commit crimes.  Are we just bad people?  Are we evil and violent?  Neither Cassell nor Liptak offer any answer. 

I’ve  suggested in the past that our consumerist society is a driving force in criminal conduct, but don’t think anyone is going to touch this since it would offend major corporations and unbalance our economics (as if our economy was doing so well to begin with).  But this doesn’t explain why crime rates might increase, since most of us have a moral compass that prevents us from indulging temptation. 

At the end of his piece, Liptak offers a crumb to the reasonable by noting that Texas, the nation’s incarceration leader, is now trying to provide treatment alternatives for DUI offenders.  They problem is that this is a drop in the bucket and still reflects the institutional refusal to recognize the source and scope of the problem.  It’s like a safety valve to sooth the public that they are now dealing with the budgetary forces, while knowing that it will do nothing to address the problem.  Another feel-good, magic bullet reaction of no real consequence.

We haven’t had a crime problem in the United States in more than a decade, as statistics have shown huge drops in the crime rates over that period.  This was bad for politics, since there’s no better proven vote-getter than being tough on crime and harsh on defendants.  So they just ignored the facts, enjoyed the medias promotion of sensationalist crimes and used this as a platform of fear to demand our attention.  And we happily gave them our votes in exchange, an addiction for anyone running for office.

The Pew report is shocking, and should be shocking.  If Cassell is right, then we need to figure out what is so deeply wrong with this country that drives so many to crime.  If Cassell is wrong, then we need to put an end to our love of magic-bullet incarceration solutions and reject the illogical arguments that we have adopted to justify putting one percent of our citizenry into prison.   Either way, there is no spin that can change the fact that the Pew report reflects a blight on America.

Thanks for  Susan Cartier Leibel for the heads-up on Liptak’s column.

Some Alternatives to Sentencing Are Just Plain Bad

Doug Berman at  Sentencing Law and Policy threw me for a loop with this post.  Doug is a self-proclaimed fan of alternatives to incarceration.  Me too!  But that doesn’t mean any alternative is a good alternative. 

Doug, on the other hand, thinks this proposed Kentucky statute is a good thing.

The proposed sex offender law would work much like those already on the books for taking the property of convicted drug dealers. “If they use an asset in a crime they run the risk of forfeiting their property,” Kerr said. Under the bill, officials would also be able to take the sex offender’s home, or other property, if that is where the sex crime took place.

The notion being sold is that the cost of imprisoning sex offenders (which may well be even higher in Kentucky if sheep could talk) is too high, so it would be better to punish them by forfeiting their assets than making them a public charge.



Under the bill, property would be seized by law enforcement, held and then sold. The funds would go to police and prosecutors, minus any liens on the property, such as car loans. “This will help prosecutors by giving them additional funds to prosecute the offenders,” said Kerr. Kenton County Commonwealth’s Attorney Rob Sanders, who, according to Simpson, requested the bill, said that under the bill 15 percent of the money that comes from sex offenders’ confiscated property would be earmarked for prosecutors, who could use the funds for expert witnesses, forensic investigations and the like. Law enforcement agencies investigating such crimes would collect about 85 percent of the money brought in from sex offenders’ seized assets.


Incarceration, the false god of security, is being called into question because some politicians are finally beginning to recognize that its cost exceeds its continued marketability to the public.  This isn’t news.  What is news will the newly discovered ways to fix the problem, with asset forfeiture rearing its ugly head.

Why is this bad.  This requires a list, so here goes:

1.  It will not be a substitute for incarceration.  It may start out with that intent, but no one is going to be the fellow who stands up in public and says, let all the sex offenders out of jail to rape your children.  Then we’ll have both punishments available, and both will most assuredly be used, because asset forfeiture brings in money and they still get to imprison the sex offenders.

2.  The funds will be used for prosecution and law enforcement benefit.  History teaches us all too well that when money does toward the cops budget, they suddenly find religion.  This provides police and prosecutors with a strong incentive to overreach, to come up with arguments to capture assets bearing no relationship to any crime.  How so?  For example, the defendant was sitting in his home when he used the computer, therefore his home is an instrumentality of the crime.  And he pays the mortgage for that home from his savings account, so the savings account is the instrumentality. It goes on.

3.  The impact is not limited to the sex offender.  What of the offenders wife and children?  Let’s assume that you couldn’t care less about a sex offender, and have no problem with taking everything he’s ever had from him.  Does his innocent wife and children get thrown out on the street because of what he did?

4.  The assets are seized before conviction.  The assets are used to retain counsel to fight the charge, but if they are seized pre-conviction, in order to preserve them for forfeiture, then the defendant will lose the ability to retain counsel of choice.  This has always been the catch-22 of asset forfeiture, glorifying the post hoc ergo propter hoc school of prosecution.

5.  Sliding down the slope.  Once criminal punishment is disconnected from its legitimate purpose, there is no rational starting or stopping point.  Asset forfeiture, based upon a legal fiction that the res (“thing”) offends the sovereign, only makes sense if it is the proceeds of crime.  But there are no proceeds when it comes to sex offenders.  Therefore, the asset forfeiture would be based upon the “instrumentality” approach, which opens the door to widespread seizure without any legitimate sentencing purpose to be gained.  It is, from the defendant’s standpoint, purely punitive.  From the government’s standpoint, it is pure gravy.

6.  Another situation rife with potential for corruption.  Cops are sitting on a sex offender, and now have the power to seize all his assets, a purely financial impact.  What might they suggest to this miscreant as an alternative to justice?  Does anybody want to bet that it will dawn on a cop at some point (likely very early) and then spread like wildfire that these perps will happily fork over some very big bucks to avoid losing everything?  The opportunity for graft in this idea is huge, and history again teaches that when the opportunity for corruption is present, someone will seize it.  A lot of seizures going on here.

This is just a horrible idea, and one if accepted that is likely to spread across offenses, while the nature and scope of criminal offenses itself continues to expand at an ever-increasing rate.  The power that this will give government to wreak havoc over people will be shocking, and the negative by-products are overwhelming.

I’m with Doc Berman in his quest to find viable alternatives to incarceration, but this just isn’t a good one.  I’m still a little shocked that Doug would consider it, no less support it.