Author Archives: SHG

The Justices on Writing and Advocacy

One of the coolest things I can remember.  Bryan Garner at lawprose.org has put together videotaped interviews with 8 of the 9 Supreme Court Justices (all but Souter) on effective writing, advocacy and a host of related topics. 

There are many hours of interviews, and all are available as a public service here.

I suspect that this will be a foundational set of interviews for many years to come, and applaud both the effort and availability for all to see. 

Thanks to  Orin Kerr.

If It’s Squeaky Clean, Then It’s Not Quite New York

I was one of the few who had doubts that Rudy Giuliani’s march on Times Square was a great thing.  While the porn biz, drug dealing and general seediness left much to be desired, this was Times Square.  This place had history.  Around the world, everybody knew that Times Square was ground zero of porn.  And New York was a rough and tumble place.  It was part of our charm.

Of course, others disagreed.  Now Times Square has Disney and American Girl and Pokemon stores.  But try to find a topless bar.  It’s like being in Anaheim.

Mayor Bloomberg, far wealthier than Rudy, has now eviscerated another New York landmark.  Canal Street.  If you’re not a New Yorker, you may know a song about the place but you have no idea what it really represents.  This short piece from the  New York Times City Room tells the story.


City investigators raided dozens of storefronts on a triangular block in Chinatown this morning in what officials described as a major seizing of counterfeit goods — including fake Rolex, Coach, Prada and Gucci products — with an estimated street value of more than $1 million. Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg and Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly, who announced the raids, also said that the city had obtained a temporary restraining order to shut the storefronts.

In a strongly worded news release, the officials called the block, which is bounded by Canal Street, Walker Street and Centre Street, Counterfeit Triangle.

We love to come up with odd names for our neighborhoods in New York.  No doubt the “counterfeit triangle” will be showing up in condo adds by next Sunday.

So the secret is out.  This is where New Yorkers go to pick up top quality counterfeit designer goods.  Chanel bags for $45.  Rolex watches for $100.  Of course they aren’t real, but they look terrific and you can’t tell the difference without a magnifying glass and really knowing your designer details.  When out-of-towners see every woman on the street, from 90 year olds to 6 year olds, with a Louis Vuitton on their arm, do they think they are all willing to throw away $800 on a bag?  Come on!  Get serious!


As part of the investigation, 42 undercover purchases were made in various storefronts. The investigation uncovered counterfeits of such brands as Coach, Gucci, Dolce & Gabbanna, Dior, Prada, Rolex, Fendi, Burberry, Calvin Klein, Dora the Explorer and Oakley. The building addresses in the “Counterfeit Triangle” that were raided today are 224–230 Canal Street; 232 Canal Street; 234–238 Canal Street; 106 Baxter Street; 112–116 Walker Street; 118 Walker Street; 120-124 Walker Street; and 152-156 Centre Street.

All about a block from the criminal courthouse.  And all those judges carrying designer handbags and wearing expensive watches.  I wonder…

Everybody in New York knows that Canal Street is the place to go for counterfeits.  This was no secret.  It used to be completely out in the open, though it’s gone somewhat underground in recent years, so that you have to ask and pass scrutiny before they will show you the good stuff.  I found out about this when I asked a shopkeeper once if he had any Louis Vuitton bags.  He looked me up and down, and told me to take a hike.  Maybe he thought I was a tourist.  Tourists ask for refunds when they’re unhappy.  They don’t get the idea of buying counterfeit goods. 

I know, I know.  This was all terribly illegal.  It devalues a brand that a designer and manufacturer has worked very hard to establish.   It kills the cache when the poor walk around with the same watch as the rich.  Of course, the people buying on Canal Street were never in the market for the real McCoy.  If they were going to buy the real thing, they would have.  They were on Canal Street because they had no plan to spend more than pocket change.  Rolex did not lose any sales on their account.

From many perspectives, I can’t question the City’s efforts to shut down this illegal activity.  It’s wrong, it hurts legitimate (albeit ridiculously expensive) businesses.  But it was one of those things that made New York City special.  There was character in the seediness of Times Square.  There was character in the seediness of Canal Street.  Pretty soon, there will be no character left.  Then New York City might as well be anywhere else, because you won’t be able to tell the difference.

Love Letters to Men of Honor

It didn’t take long for the feds to send letters to the reputed Gambino defendants, according to Newsday.  Prosecutors mailed out plea offers to 60 of 62 defendants, with a level of alacrity that is rarely seen in any federal prosecution, no less one of the alleged Mafia.

According to the story, the offers ranged from 4 months to 20 years. 

Lawyers with the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Brooklyn said the plea offers were given to 60 defendants, including most of the high ranked crime family members hit in the 80-count racketeering indictment. Only reputed Gambino soldier Charles Carneglia, 61, and fugitive captain Nicholas Corozzo,67, who face murder charges, weren’t given offers, officials said.

That’s to be expected.  By taking out the little fish, the government gains leverage in getting the big fish.  It’s really just a variation on an old joke:  Once they’ve determined who is a whore, they are just dickering over price.   The next step will be the tantalizing prospect of cooperation, and a better offer, if only the defendants will give up the big guys. 

Why the speed?  Because the defendants have yet to retain counsel of their choosing.  The feds want to get in there and entice as many defendants as possible to stay with their CJA lawyers, engage in negotiation, hold out the 5K1.1 carrot, before they lawyer up for real.  It’s not that the CJA lawyers are competent, perhaps even spectacular lawyers, but that they are not married to the ways of the defendants.

What ways?  The ways of Men of Honor.  Indulge my rhetorical statements here, since I speak of no one in particular and know nothing about any of the specific individuals involved in this indictment.  But there is some history in these alleged organized crime cases that cannot be ignored.

In the old days, the men involved in organized crime believed in certain things, one of which was that they would never turn on their friends.  They would take the heat.  Do the time.  Come out eventually and know that their families were provided for.  They would hold up their end of the deal.  Their associates, their bosses, would hold up theirs.  Quite symbiotic, and one on which you could count.

That changed over time, as do so many of the old ways.  Valachi.  Gravano, D’Arco, Sessa, Scarpa.  Embarrassments all, but a wave of the future.  While this made for some fine movie insights, it was the end of honor.  To the romantic, the end of honor made them ordinary criminals, unworthy of further interest.

Are all the men of honor really gone?


But attorney Joseph Corozzo of Manhattan, who is representing his father, reputed Gambino consiglieri Joseph Corozzo, 66, said he didn’t even open the government’s offer.

“I threw it in the garbage,” attorney Corozzo said, adding that he was angered that his father was accused of drug dealing in the indictment. “If they want to drop the drug charges, then I will talk to them,” said Corozzo.

Another throwback to the old days was that organized crime would have nothing to do with drugs.  It was dirty crime, dishonorable crime.  Of course, one would have thought that ship sailed a long time ago, but apparently it remains docked at the Corozzo’s.  Why son Joseph would suggest that, but for the drug charge, he would be willing to talk about a plea (and thereby suggest guilt without any apparent benefit to his father) I can’t imagine.  But then, sometimes quotes are taken out of context.  And sometimes, the wrong thing comes out of someone’s mouth.

So will the government’s ploy work?  Will the weak links in the chain pull apart under the pressure of a plea offer.  Will the speed of the offers, before the details can be arranged that would put a different sort of lawyer in place to advise his or her client differently?  Will the current lawyers, certainly not foolish by any stretch, recognize this effort by the government to seize a tactical advantage while the opportunity is available because of their view that new counsel will be far less amendable to plea offers, and perhaps even cooperation, then they are?

And will the defendants in this case chose to follow in the footsteps of Sammy the Bull, or will they chose to be men of honor?  We’ll find out soon when the number of people present at the next court appearance are counted.  There is very little space left in the courtroom with a 62 defendant case.  If there is more breathing room next time, we will see whether there are still any men of honor left.

The Panamanian President, John McCain

For American history buffs, read  Jonathon Turley’s post about the potential issues facing John McCain should he win his campaign for the presidency.  What problems, you ask?  Why, the problem posed by  Article II, Section 1 of the United States Constitution:


No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any Person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States.

So what does this have to do with McCain?  It seems that John McCain was born in Panama, not in the United States.  Well, you say, then that’s that.  Not quite.


McCain was born in 1936 in the Panama Canal Zone while his father was stationed there as a naval officer. In 1787, however, the framers insisted that any president be natural born — that is, born within the United States.

Clearly, there is an immediate reaction that it would patently wrong and unfair to disallow a McCain presidency because he was born while his father was serving his nation in the military on a foreign assignment.  Certainly this would offend the sensibilities of anyone, regardless of whether you are McCain supporter or otherwise.  It’s just wrong.

But this isn’t about fairness.  This is a straightforward issue of constitutional requirements.  The language is clear.  The intent of the framers is clear.  The originalist interpretation of the Constitution leaves little doubt as to what the outcome should be.  Flagrantly wrong in terms of fairness, but clear in terms of a Constitution that does not change to accommodate circumstances not anticipated by its authors.

Nor is this the first time that Article II, Section 1, has been at issue.  Turley provides recent examples of the problem:


The last time that we faced this question in a serious candidate was Barry Goldwater, who was technically born while Arizona was a territory in 1909. Other such questions were raised by Mitt Romney’s father who ran in 1968 despite his birth in Mexico and former Sen. Lowell P. Weicker Jr., who was born in Paris.

The Barry Goldwater situation is particularly interesting, as it is unlikely that our founding fathers thought about a person born in a territory that would be given statehood in the interim who would thereafter run for President.  As for Lowell Weicker, the issue is lessened by the fact that Paris is considered a part of Connecticut by local standards.

Turley also provides an interesting insight into the reason for this clause.  It seems that the ongoing dispute between Alexander Hamilton and just about everyone else, based upon Hamilton’s strenuous support for a federal government with nearly unlimited powers (he put the elastic in the “elastic clause”) gave rise to great fear that he would anoint himself king given half a chance.


It is clear that the Framers consider natural born to refer to a birth on U.S. soil. Indeed, Alexander Hamilton was viewed as ineligible due to his birth in the West Indies. It has often been suggested that the provision was written in part to block Hamilton by his detractors — though this may be apocryphal. It seems more likely that people like Jay were concerned with a preference among some to have a King, including some foreign princes who might rule the nation.

So basically, this clause was included to make sure that Hamilton could never be President, much to Arnold Schwarzenegger’s consternation.

The surest answer to this problem would be for the courts to hold that a United States military base on foreign soil is still America, like an Embassy.  But this is where the law of unintended consequences comes into play.


The zone was a foreign military base like Guantanamo Cuba. Ironically, the Bush Administration has been arguing for years (with Senate support) that U.S. laws and jurisdiction do not extend to Cuba in the cases of the detainees. If such bases are now treated as U.S. soil, it is unclear how that would affect this long-standing claim that it is not for purposes of civil liberties.

Either it is or it isn’t.  It can’t be American soil for one purpose and not for another.  For those who might be inclined to argue this point, this is because we can’t redefine everything to produce a desired result unless we remove any pretense of legitimacy from our legal system.  This may be fine with you (and may be fine with the courts, for all I know), but it will produce an inherent integrity issue.

American history really is quite fascinating, no?

Money For Nothing

Gideon  posted a rant about defendants belief that money buys “justice”, justice being defined as a better plea offer.  This went down the path of attacking the private criminal defense bar as being unable to get a better offer than the public defender, and therefore being a waste of money.  While the smell of the post was that Gid had a particular situation in mind, it crossed a lot of bridges.

I’m disturbed by Gid’s post.  I’ve taken to task private criminal defense lawyers who market themselves by disparaging public defenders.  It’s no better for a public defender to do the same to the private bar.  It’s also untrue in many circumstances.  The problem is that it is indeed true under some circumstances, a problem that needs to be conceded and remedied.

Let’s start at the beginning:  Criminal defendants do not pay for outcome.  They pay for service.  They pay for the work, the time, the effort, the experience that a lawyer puts into his case.  No lawyer, nor any amount of money, guarantees a result.  Anyone who tells you otherwise is a liar.

That said, the better the lawyer, the more time and effort he can put into your case, and the availability of money to pay for the plethora of support services available, will substantially increase the likelihood of a favorable result.  Anyone who tells you otherwise is a liar.

Gideon fails to distinguish between the quality and quantity law practice.  His words ring true for many in the private criminal defense bar.  They deceive people into becoming clients by making false promises that they can do better.  For some people, it falls under the belief that money buys better “justice”.  For others, it’s because law is a big game, and they are buying influence, connections, insider-type stuff that fits their vision that this is all a big game and it’s not what you know but who you know that keeps you out of jail.

This is a scam on the public, perpetrated by lawyers who want your money.  It is the product of too many lawyers, not enough money, and the transition of law from a profession to a business.  Sadly, this is only one of many such scams designed to gain business and separate client from cash.  It prays on clients’ cynical beliefs.  Clients too often want to be lied to.  They want answers they know to be false, because they want to believe they can buy their way out of their problems.  These lawyers are only too happy to fill the demand.

There have been numerous times in my career when I have lost a client to another lawyer because I refuse to lie to them.  It angers me to lose clients this way, though not enough to join the ranks of liars.  I’ve often said that I could be rich, if only I was willing to be dishonest.  I’m not.  Perhaps that makes me a business fool, since other lawyers have taken very substantial sums of money from clients to whom I refused to lie.  There are many business people I know who believe that my refusal to “play the game” is naive.  They believe that life is a scam, and getting the business at any cost is the way to win the game of life.

Perhaps I’m wrong, but I have made the decision to maintain my integrity at the expense of business.  My clients appreciate my position most of the time, though they tell me sometimes that they would prefer that I tell them what they want to hear even when it isn’t the truth.  But there’s no “honesty switch” on my back that can be turned on and off whenever the client would like. 

Gideon relates statements from clients that make him laugh:


Which is why I chuckle when defendants say things like “why did I pay that guy so much? I could have gotten the same result with a public defender” or “man, he didn’t do nothin’. The offer stayed the same”.

I hear these statements as well.  I’ve heard them for 25 years, but they don’t make me chuckle.  These types of statements reflect one of two things:  Either the lawyer misrepresented what he can produce for the client and then failed to do so, or the lawyer did everything he could but was unable to accomplish the outcome the defendant sought. 

The first lawyer is the one that angers Gideon, and rightfully so.  This is the lawyer who denigrates the public defender and makes promises he cannot keep.  This is the lawyer who lies.

The second lawyer is the one that has represented the defendant skillfully, honestly and with zeal, but was still unable to achieve the desired outcome.  This happens.  Even if the lawyer’s skill and effort raise the likelihood of prevailing to 99%, that means 1% will not prevail.  But the lawyer has not done “nothin”.  He did everything he could, but that does not guarantee the desired result.

Consider Martha Stewart.  Consider Dennis Kozlowski.  Millions of dollars were spent on their defense, to no avail.  I’ve joked that I could have lost their case for half the fee, but the fact is that they used their money, power, influence to prevail.  Still, they lost.  Even John Gotti was finally convicted.  If they couldn’t find the “trick”, the guarantee, what makes others think that they can?

I suspect that Gideon’s objective was to address the class of criminal defense lawyer that uses deception to get cases, that puts down the public defender to get money, that guarantees that they can get them a better plea offer in exchange for cash.  If so, then I agree with Gid wholeheartedly. 

Not only are do they anger Gideon, but they anger me as well.  I work awfully hard for my clients, and earn my fees.  And still I will lose clients because of my refusal to tell them what they want to hear when someone else is only too happy to do so.  It has become a dirty business.

William F. Buckley, 1925-2008

William F. Buckley, Jr.  died last night.  America has lost one of its greatest and most unique minds and personalities.

Bill Buckley was a true conservative.  He hardly reflected the neo-con mindless jingoism that prevails today, glorifying simplistic answers to difficult questions by contending that if it’s the “American Way,” it must be right. 

While some may wonder how I can admire William F. Buckley, it has to do with respect rather than agreement.  His politics were a world away from mine, yet he brought such wit and intelligence to his views that it was impossible not to admire the man.  Nor was I alone in my admiration.


His friends included such liberals as John Kenneth Galbraith and Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., who despised Buckley’s “wrathful conservatism,” but came to admire him for his “wit, his passion for the harpsichord, his human decency, even for his compulsion to epater the liberals.”

I have two Bill Buckley stories to tell.  Bill Buckley was the honoree the year before I graduated law school.  For reasons unknown, I was asked to take care of him while he was in the Green Room awaiting his time to go on stage.  There was a piano in the room, and after having a drink, he sat down.  He played and sang a bawdy song.  No, it was filthy.  But very funny.

I watched in awe.  I knew quite well who William F. Buckley was.  I knew about his politics.  But I had never met anyone with his patrician manner, his vocabulary or such a twinkle in his eye.  And then he played piano and sang dirty songs.  And he did so well.  It was extraordinary.

This was the first time in my life that I had met a renaissance man.  Bill Buckley was a renaissance man.

Many years later, I learned that one of my friends was producing his television show, Firing Line.  I went to watch the show being taped, and my friend put me in the Green Room with his guest, John Kenneth Galbraith.  Unlike Buckley, Galbraith reflected my views toward economics and politics, but he had the ability to create the ideas that someone like me could only agree with.

I stood there was Buckley and Galbraith greeted each other, like prize fighters who had the utmost respect for the other’s skills, but also a certain camaraderie that came from knowing that they were of a different order than the rest of us.  The show that day was spectacular.  The banter between them was lyrical.  Just to be able to listen to two men, geniuses both in their own right, spar with a level of wit that I never imagined possible was one of the high points of my life.


Buckley so loved a good argument — especially when he won — that he compiled a book of bickering in “Cancel Your Own Goddam Subscription,” published in 2007 and featuring correspondence with the famous (Nixon, Reagan) and the merely annoyed.

“Mr. Buckley,” one non-fan wrote in 1967, “you are the mouthpiece of that evil rabble that depends on fraud, perjury, dirty tricks, anything at all that suits their purposes. I would trust a snake before I would trust you or anybody you support.”

Responded Buckley: “What would you do if I supported the snake?”

I am deeply saddened to hear of his passing.  I am deeply saddened that we have no more Bill Buckley’s.

With the DEA’s Permission

It’s not that the Drug Enforcement Administration is always looking for a silver bullet.  It’s that they just don’t care about collateral damage.

The  Wall Street Journal, via Volokh, has an important piece about the DEAs newest and brightest idea for dealing with prescription drug abuse.  While the illegal abuse of such narcotics as OxyContin, Rush Limbaugh’sdrug of choice, on the government’s radar since the overdose death of Heath Ledger, it should come as no surprise that our law enforcement heroes want to rush in and save the day, albeit a day late. 

While it is their intention to investigate, a word that strikes fear in the hearts of any potential target, those doctors who prescribe medications “inappropriately,” whatever that means, it’s not enough to sate the hunger to win the war on whatever war we’re waging today. 

Rather, the DEA has chosen to pursue an affirmative attack on prescription medications, and it just happens that the only people standing between it and victory are physicians.  And patients.


For one thing, they prompt some law-abiding doctors to think twice before writing legitimate scripts. A 2001 study of California doctors found that 40% of primary-care physicians said fear of investigation affected how they treated chronic pain. A recent survey of physicians by the Center for Addiction and Substance Abuse found that one-third worry “a great deal” or “somewhat” about review of their own prescribing of controlled drugs by law enforcement agencies; and 44% report that this actually influences which medications they prescribe.

The expansion of DEA regulatory authority could slow development of improved medicines, by chasing away companies that fear added uncertainty about whether new products will get approved. This includes new generations of narcotics more resistant to abuse. It would actually be better for the public if the FDA made these abuse-resistant painkillers immediately eligible for priority review, which can shave time and cost off the development process.

How do you feel about having your local DEA agent sitting in the examination room, giving the thumbs up or down to the doctor’s prescription?  I’m not too keen on the idea.

While much of the efforts of the criminal defense bar is directed toward the overkill of punishment for drugs that has put so many people in prison while accomplishing so little, it’s largely addressed street drugs, from crack to marijuana.  Now they’re getting into the choices made by doctors and patients, with the express intention of chilling the choices a physician will make in prescribing medications.  Better that patients are not properly treated than prescription drugs fall into the wrong hands.

The issue is not whether it’s okay to have prescription drugs abused.  The issue is how the government decides to deal with it.  Since the DEA has never been good at, nor to my knowledge considered, a surgical approach to problems, they plan to come in with a big club and beat docs over the heads for doing their jobs.  Are there some docs who deserve to be investigated?  I’m sure there are, though I can’t say that I know any personally.  But I’ve represented numerous physicians, and would be more than happy to defend a few more, as the DEA will no doubt plow into physicians with the same mindset that they have with street dealers.

But interfering with, and causing physicians to withhold, needed medication from patients for fear of the DEA breaking down their door has the potential to cause a lot of harm to our health care.  And we have enough problems with health care already.  We shouldn’t need the DEA’s permission to receive treatment.

Logical Fallacies and Non-Lawyer Commentary

Over the past couple of days, there has been an unexplained surge of interest in  an old post about the 1st Amendment.  My guess is that it was linked to some non-lawyer listserve or blog of very angry people, some of whom decided to drop by Simple Justice and give me a piece of their mind. 

Generally speaking, I’m cool with that, provided they don’t violate  the one rule of this blawg.  Some did.  Some went even further.  These are the risks one faces when you decide to blawg.

But other issues are raised by this deluge of interest and angst that merit discussion.  One of the commenters, Robert Reese, politely but insistently kept pounding the table by repeating the phrase, “your 1st Amendment right stops at my doorstep.”  After a few comments to this effect, to which I attempted to explain (obviously ineffectively) how the law applied, it finally dawned on me that the foundational problem was that Robert had no familiarity with the law and was flying on emotion masquerading as reason.

At that point, I copied in a blurb from the caselaw.  He then recognized the distinction between the law and his dissatisfaction with the policy behind it.  More on this below.

Another commenter, Christine Baker, similarly lacked any familiarity with the law, and had neglected to read the comments between Robert and I, and demanded answers to questions designed to prove that she was right and I was wrong.  Christine’s comments showed an inability to grasp logical connections, which caused her to offer this insight :


I know I’m an idiot, like all people who aren’t lawyers.

Apparently, her post hoc position managed to get in a dig against all lawyers as well as me.  But it fails to address the problem, whether she would be a lawyer or non-lawyer.  Arguments still require a logical connection, and visceral opposition doesn’t make an irrational argument stronger.  Christine ultimately resorted to her original argument, which may make perfect sense to her but provides no logical connection to her point.

And then there is my personal favorite comment, from Sam Hassan.


Why do you have a security code for me to post a comment here. You are stripping the sapmmers of their first amendment rights.

PS I don’t really believe that, but I just wanted to show how silly your argument is.

It doesn’t get any better than Sam.

There were numerous other comments left that never saw the light of day because the posters refused to give real emails.  I could have manually allowed them, but most had the fatal combination of being ignorant and offensive.  As a manifestation of anger, I can understand why they felt compelled to make offensive comments.  As a practical matter, they just won’t appear on this blawg.  So, I hope it was cathartic for these posters, but it contributed nothing to the discussion.

And why did I bother with any of this?  Lawyers have an ethical responsibility to help educate the public on the law.  While their arguments may have been poor and irrational, their feelings about the impropriety of the subject and confusion about the law warranted some attention.  So I tried to help, recognizing that convincing someone whose beliefs are grounded in emotion by responding with logical argument is almost always doomed to failure. 

And now, a public service to my anger-ridden readers.  There is a good argument in the midst of all your anger, but you’ve been blind to it because of your efforts to ground your argument in law, something with which you are ill-equipped to argue.

Receiving an unsolicited fax of any sort is annoying.  It is a burden on your machine, telephone line, paper, toner and psyche.  While some may shrug it off, some rightfully have gotten fed up with it and have taken the offensive.  In other words, your feelings on the general subject are valid and no one disputes your right to feel as you do.  But it is emotional, not legal.  And there’s nothing wrong with that.

Legally, there are limits on what the law can prohibit.  Note the word “prohibit”, as this is what makes all the difference in the subject at hand.  No one, and no law, says you have to invite unsolicited emails, or telephone calls.  No one, and no law, suggests that you must embrace the exercise of free speech by anyone else.  You have every right to hate it and hang up the phone, tell the faxer that you want it stopped, or take whatever action you might have lawfully available to you to control the use of your telephone or fax machine.

The 1st Amendment issue in the TCPA is a different issue.  The TCPA prohibits only commercial solicitations.  We know that because it says so.  Constitutionally, that’s all it can prohibit, no matter whether non-commercial unsolicited faxes are just as annoying and bothersome as any commercial solicitation.  It is the law.  It may not be to your liking, and you can argue about the 1st Amendment stopping at whatever part of your house or business you like, but your feelings about the law don’t change what the law is.

Consider, if you will, that under existing federal law, charities are still permitted to call numbers on the Do Not Call registry.  This includes such dubious solicitations as the various pretend police charities, where 97% of the funds collected go to the business handling the solicitations, and 3% go to any actual police benefit.  This annoys me to no end, and likely annoys you as well.  And we are both entitled to be annoyed by it, but that doesn’t alter the fact that they have a right to solicit in this fashion, no matter how much we wish they wouldn’t.

Your argument, therefore, is one of policy, not law.  Perhaps it’s somewhat short-sighted on the policy side, since your concerns are limited to the particular use of a fax machine, but the protections given free speech in one context necessarily carry over to others, because courts are constrained (unlike angry blog commenters) to try to use reason to justify their decisions.  Under other circumstances, I’m sure that many of the same people would be strong supporters of constitutional rights; they just don’t like it in this context.  And it’s your absolute right to dislike it.  No one would say that you are compelled by law to be happy about something that you find annoying.

To the extent that much of the commentary misapprehended the specifics of the particular case of Stern v. Bluestone, particularly the aspect that the report involved was faxed only to lawyers who included their fax numbers in the New York Lawyers Diary as an invitation to other lawyers to send them faxes, it’s of little consequence.  The bigger issue, unsolicited faxes aside from this particular case, is a fine topic for discussion and comment.  To the extent that this helps to explain matters, it was worth the effort.  To the extent that this does nothing to clarify the law, at least I tried.



Law Students: Starting Out Wrong, Ending Up Miserable

In a brief post, Paul Caron at  TaxProf Blog writes:


A Kaplan survey of 1,949 students taking the LSAT lists the reasons they want to go to law school:



  • 73%:  Enable them to have a high income
  • 42% (52% of men, 34% of women):  Prepare them for a political career

That’s it.

Much time has been spent addressing the dissatisfaction of  law students and young lawyers.  I’ve tried.  Others have too. 

When a stat like 73% of students say they want to go to law school for the money, two things become abundantly clear.  There will be massive dissatisfaction when they learn that not everyone will be a candidate to read  Above the Law every day to see how high their bonus will go.  Not a Tier 1 grad?  Not a law review editor?  Then you are going to have a problem.

But even if you climb the big money mountain of Biglaw, get that massive $200k+ paycheck with concierge service, and earn that beloved money that will safely place you in the  middle of the pack of the well-to-do, you will learn a truth that eludes most children.  Wealth is not the end of the road.  You still won’t like the work of being a lawyer.

The old adage is “rich or poor, it’s good to have money.”  Absolutely.  But it’s not enough.  Once you have it, and are able to climb another rung on Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, you are going to find yourself miserable again.  And since you are likely to have a long life ahead of you, that misery will extend for a very long time.

Even the students who don’t achieve the “high income” that they mistakenly believe comes with putting “Esq.” after your name, and who earn enough to be comfortable and relatively happy, have to deal with the fact that they will be expected to do the work of being a lawyer. 

If that’s not for you, and it’s not for everyone, what’s your plan B?  There is a lot of griping about changing the way law is practiced, and much of it has merit.  But it’s not going to change what lawyers actually do.  It may make the balance work better, if it ever happened, but that’s not really the problem.  You must first like doing the work of being a lawyer.

Now Law Schools, it’s your turn to step up.  You send out tons of law porn to seduce students to apply.  Do any of the glossy photos show young lawyers sitting in libraries alone in the middle of the night looking miserable?  Do any show lawyers unable to make the lease payment on that Mercedes convertible?

A very high value is placed on intelligence.  How do you value desire?  How do you value an appreciation of the tasks that lawyers perform in the course of being a lawyer?  Do they come into law school thinking that their days will be spent being Perry Mason, or trying to get a rise out of Justice Thomas?  Do you vet these inchoate lawyers to make sure they have a clue what they’re getting into?

Why care about this?  Because lawyers play an important and necessary role in the continuing viability of society.  And if they are miserable doing so, or are disappointed with their lives, they aren’t going to fulfill that role very well.  They will be bad lawyers.  They will  engage in impropriety to get that extra buck.  They will put self-interest, personal happiness, above their responsibility to clients and the law.

Sure, the law is hardly what it’s cracked up to be anymore.  Lawyers are accused of being greedy and incompetent.  There’s a reason why people feel this way about lawyers.  Wouldn’t it be a good idea to prevent this from continuing.  “An ounce of prevention” sort of thing?  If there was ever any doubt about the reason for young people seeking a career in law, this statistic should be a pretty smack across the kisser.  Did anybody else feel it?